Allah SWT created Time & Space. The Indwelling of God in Space is a Christian concept. He has no need to come into His creation.
@Gog3453
9 ай бұрын
@@mikhan5191 creation is not capable of containing Allah because creation is limited
@mikhan5191
9 ай бұрын
@@Gog3453 - agree
@houdaghemari1262
9 ай бұрын
الحمد لله i'm happy i found this channel
@moonmoonStar
9 ай бұрын
alhamdulillah. i pray you'll pass ur exam welll and continue to share knowledge with us. and thank you for the books recommendation. edited : future suggestion topic, maybe you can explain a little bit about Aqidah al-Sanusiyya and if there are any differences from Aqidah Tahawiyyah? or both are just the same but just different ways of explaining our aqidah ? because for laymen muslims it can get confusing. thanks in advance.
@UmarElhashmi
9 ай бұрын
InshaAllah Ameen and Shukran for the suggestion!
@marioluigi9599
9 ай бұрын
@@UmarElhashmi Are you a hadithiyuun? Just wondering
@UmarElhashmi
9 ай бұрын
I’m not sure what that is!
@moonmoonStar
9 ай бұрын
@@UmarElhashmi from a simple google search. Hadithiyoon/ hadithuyuun is a term from a group/movement called "Progressive Islam" that labels we the muslims who are orthodox Islam and adhere to hadiths as source for rulings and authority as hadithiyuun. i'm sure from that name alone, "Progressive Islam". you can take a guess what kind of "Islam" these people want to preach. May Allah protect us from this fitnah.
@marioluigi9599
9 ай бұрын
@@UmarElhashmi It means you follow the word of Uzbek Prophet Bukhari and Iranian Prophet Muslim to associate in partnership with the word of the Lord Almighty your God most exalted .
@fahlito
9 ай бұрын
Maa sha’allah Ustadh! Keep up the good work as you’ve been doing! Simplifying is needed, and refutations are also needed. Keep it coming!
@Mj-in5uj
7 ай бұрын
brother make more vids, ur very good
@malikimadhabdeutsch9332
9 ай бұрын
We should all memorize the first part of Ibn Ashir ❤
@AhmaduIsMyLove
9 ай бұрын
@UmarElhashmi, can we give or receive salaam from non muslims even if good intended
@Karim01101
5 ай бұрын
Assalamu alaykum Umar. I have a question regarding the statement you mentioned of the Aqqadatul Tahawiyyah “All the prophets are sinless” Does this mean they have never committed a sin, or never committed a major sin, or will not have any sins on their scale on the day of judgement? I ask this because I think of the moment Adam Alayhi Salam ate from the fruit and disobeyed Allah, or when Musa Alayhi Salam pushed the person and he ended up dying from it. I understand that none of these actions had the intention of disobeying Allah, and they were not actions that humiliated them or rendered them as less great examples for mankind to follow, but are they considered sins? Barak Allah Fik.
@UmarElhashmi
5 ай бұрын
Wa alaykum alSalaam, please check out episode 4 of my Shia Refutation Series, titled “Are prophets able to commit sins”- here I answer this question in depth. Barakallahu feek
@kaleemthedream9450
9 ай бұрын
Can you do a refutation of divine simplicity please specifically the falasas versions of divine simplicity and also Thomas Aquinas type of divine simplicity
@UmarElhashmi
9 ай бұрын
Yes soon inshaAllah
@markward3981
7 ай бұрын
السلام عليكم ورحمه الله وبركاته I respect Aqeedah Tahawiyyah and this channels efforts but best to begin with the Quran and ahadith....every interpretation of Aqeedah and fiqh has it's strength's and weakness. Another interesting point in the Hadith of Jibril alayhi salaam, no where is Aqeedah mentioned, nor many of these arguments scholars brought after the Sahaba. In the Hadith we find Islam ...Iman ...Ihsan and the hour. Yet each group makes it obligatory for you to believe dozens of points besides those. Just an observation and Allah knows best
@silktops1
9 ай бұрын
As salamu alaikum just to add which was missed to believe in all the Angels , the Unseen ,the Qadar the good and bad that everything is destined by Allah that nothing happens except by His Will . We don't question about Allah's self He created Man in the best of shape form , Prophet Muhammad peace be upon was asked will we see Allah on the Day of Judgment then he pointed to the Moon and said yes we will see Allah as we see the Moon , Allah is light upon light and has a vail covering it is Prophet Muhammad said when he went to the 7th Heaven.
@UmarElhashmi
9 ай бұрын
Wa alaykum assalam The first bit wasn’t missed, it was mentioned in the part where I spoke about the 3rd Chapter of Aqeedah Aside from that, here are some points to clarify with what you mentioned: -We will see Allah on the day of judgement, in a way that we cannot imagine in this world, as He is superior than physical form -The pointing to the moon was to demonstrate the clarity, as in as clear as you see the moon today, you will see Allah that clear. It was not to say Allah is bright like the moon. -Allah is not light. Light is a creation of Allah, and He existed before light existed. The usage of this wording in the Quran was in reference to the Lawaazim of light. -There is no veil that covers Allah. The veil is on our eyesight, we are veiled from seeing Him in this life. As for Allah, He is enteral and superior, there is nothing that encompasses Him, thus no veil can cover Him. Hope this clarifies! Salam
@MohammedAbdul-ot3uv
3 ай бұрын
@@UmarElhashmiBeautiful explanation, man honestly I’m flabbergasted by how people, especially online personalities are so brainwashed by this pseudo salafi Aqeeda, truly people follow the jaahil and ignore the learned scholars, a sign of end of times. I find it funny that even people like Muhammad hijab has made it clear that he does not follow Muhammad ibn abd al wahab but still follows teachings of ibn tahmiyaah when they are both cut from the same cloth, these daee’s are truly confused and lost. I pray that Allah brings more people like you and Maturidi scholars into the mainstream Muslim media so jaahil people including myself can learn more and understand the true Ahlus Sunnah wal Jammah which they have obviously tried to hijack online people like “sheikhs” assim, Al fawzan and daees like Muslim lantern and the likes are really misleading people with their pseudo salafi beliefs.
@emrmmtmhmt7315
9 ай бұрын
Ru in Turkiye rn? And which city?
@UmarElhashmi
9 ай бұрын
Istanbul
@nadzirahfarhah3423
9 ай бұрын
❤
@sarimsakliyogurtlumantikli1212
9 ай бұрын
Assalamu Alaikum brother. Can you criticise the reliability of the argument for the truthfulness of Ash'ari/Maturidi sects below? P1- Any religion that is represented by a dominant majority of people who misunderstood it's core fundamentals of creed is a religion that wasn't able to protect it's integrity. P2- Any religion that wasn't able to protect it's integrity can't be the one true religion of Allah. P3- Islam is the one true religion of Allah C1- Islam could not have been misrepresented by a dominant majority. C2- The dominant schools of Ash'ari/Maturidi could not have misrepresented Islam.
@amano22
9 ай бұрын
why follow tahawi's creed? why not Quran and hadis/sunnah, why we not follow the companion who learn Quran and hadis from prophet? why we not follow the tabien who follow the companion who follow the prophet?
@UmarElhashmi
9 ай бұрын
Who do you think Tahawi followed? Did the prophet ﷺ compile the subject of Aqeedah in one book that we can all agree on? He didn’t Did the Sahabah? They didn’t Did the Tabi’een? They didn’t Who was the one compile the agreed upon Aqeedah of Ahlulsunnah that is taken from the Quran, Sunnah, and Salaf? Imam alTahawi- Allah accepted His work which is why it’s the most well known between all Muslims
@amano22
9 ай бұрын
@@UmarElhashmi 4 imam mazhab from tabien's generation write books, why not learn from them first? why need to learn tahawi's?
@UmarElhashmi
9 ай бұрын
@@amano22 Omce again, what do you think Imam Tahawi based his book on?? It’s THE SAME as the aqeedah of the Prophet ﷺ, the Salaf & 4 Imams. All of them are Ahlulsunnah. Tahawi’s book is structured for the average person. The 4 Imams books are for scholars. They are advanced and in depth covering differences of opinions and arguments for the scholars to know. It’s not for the layperson whose specialty in life is not to delve into the Islamic sciences. Tahawi’s book is simple, bullet points that highlight THE SAME AQEEDAH as the 4 Imams.
@bigboy6103
9 ай бұрын
You are recommending hamza Yusif? Are you kidding me? Haven’t you seen the various videos online where he lies about the meaning of jihad and the other video where he calls Krishna “LORD” and says “Eastern philosophy” saved Islam …. And the other video where he said if “8th century Muslims ” came back to life in Norway they would think it’s under an Islamic state by Omar Ibn Abdulaziz. And the he makes fun of the hudood of cutting the hands by trying to shake without a hand…. you really want me to take this man serious?
@UmarElhashmi
9 ай бұрын
Salam. I recommended Imam alTahawi. His book is in Arabic, so for English speakers, I recommended a translation. I’m so sorry that the best translation of the book happens to be by Shaykh Hamza. If you can show me a better and more clear translation that does not distort any of the text with opinions of modern scholars- we would recommend it regardless of whether we agree with everything the translator says. Now, did I say go listen to Shaykh Hamza’s personal views on some topics? I didn’t, so keep those thoughts to yourself.
@bigboy6103
9 ай бұрын
@@UmarElhashmiyou are asking me to read up on a translation of imam tahawi by shaik Hamza Yousif. Yet he is literally praising Hindu gods and praising secularism - doesn’t that fall under aqeeda akhi?
@UmarElhashmi
9 ай бұрын
@@bigboy6103 Akhi it’s not his writing it’s not his work he didn’t write the Aqeedah book it’s a translation for people who don’t know Arabic he had no part in writing that book The content is Imam Tahawi’s, and the translation is just Arabic to English it’s got to do with a dictionary and grammar nothing to do with aqeedah of shaykh Hamza
@bigboy6103
9 ай бұрын
@@UmarElhashmimy brother, I know it’s not his writing. But my issue stands - how do you expect me to read a book with commentary from a man who has openly done those things? How can you ignore them? do you deny them?
@UmarElhashmi
9 ай бұрын
@@bigboy6103 Brother for the last time. It. Is. Not. His. Writing. Nor. His. Book. If you have a better translation to Imam alTahawi’s work (I repeat, imam alTahawi, yes meaning the work is Imam alTahawi’s no one else’s)- so if you have a better translation, by all means let me know so we can suggest it to others so that all can benefit Or translate to your own version and let someone more knowledgeable than yourself review it Or read the translation that was done by Shaykh Hamza, and keep in your heart to take the good and leave the bad. His translation of that book is good, it’s in line with ahlulsunnah and there’s no points anyone can make against it except that they are a deviant sect to Ahlulsunnah
@BeardedGuy_Tawhid
9 ай бұрын
@Umar Elhashmi assalam alikom wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh. I am careful who I take knowledge from and I do not know of you before today so I have a question for you if you could answer it for me please. Where is Allah?
@BeardedGuy_Tawhid
9 ай бұрын
Nevermind I see from another video you follow Ash'ari madhab.. I will not be subscribing. Salaam.
@UmarElhashmi
9 ай бұрын
Wa alaykum Assalam wa Rahmatullah wa barakaatuh my dear brother in Islam There’s no problem if you have something against me personally and I don’t mind you criticizing something we believe, However I just want to remind you and myself, to keep respectful the nature in which we address certain people based on their madhab in Aqeedah, as a very large number of our greatest scholars of Islamic history, whom the Ummah is reliant upon for every field within Islamic sciences, were Ash’ari or Maturidi in Aqeedah and it’s certainly unfathomable that Allah chose to continue the chain of preservation of this Deen through misguided deviants Please see my video titled: The Ummah is Ash’ari and Maturidi May Allah accept all our sincere intentions and efforts Wa Alaykum Assalam wa Rahmatullah
@BeardedGuy_Tawhid
9 ай бұрын
@@UmarElhashmi Assalam alikom wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh, Nothing against you personally at all brother, I don’t even know you. Nor do I know if you are a deviant or other was, I have no label for you except Muslim. I don’t want you to have bad feelings from our interaction so I will explain my position for you. Not all Ash’ari deny the attributes of Allah that are clearly defined in the Quran/Ayat and Hadith. However some Ash’ari scholars and students of knowledge certainly do along with other severe deficiencies in Aqeeda which is much more important than the acceptable differences between madhab in Fiqh, so that is the reason why I avoid Ash’ari for beneficial knowledge completely as a general rule and that is why I asked you the question.. “Where is Allah?” The answer to this question generally reveals many things about a persons Aqeeda. I didn’t come to your channel for any other reason than to see if you were another reliable source of reminder and knowledge for me. It was your video I seen after my initial comment regarding Salafi madhab/creed that turned me off subscribing. That was why I made my second comment dismissing the need to answer. Since you replied without answering the question though I will answer the question for you. Allah is above all creation upon His throne all aware, encompassing all knowledge and wisdom in a manner that befits His majesty and nothing is higher than Him. And.. The straight path is Tawhid, Quran and Sunnah as understood by the first rightly guided generations. This is Ahl Sunnah. Assalam alikom wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh, May Allah guide us both to what pleases Him and keep us from what angers Him and admit us to Jannah Al Firdous. Ameen
@mikhan5191
9 ай бұрын
@@BeardedGuy_Tawhid- Allah SWT is NOT located in any place. Not in any Space.
@Ibrahim.l20
9 ай бұрын
good@@BeardedGuy_Tawhid
@QuadrantRoyale
9 ай бұрын
Be careful with Sheikh Hamza Yusuf... Listening to him may increase you in open mindedness, mercy, and intellect
Пікірлер: 61