Lesson: don't waste your time on politics, go straight to building alternatives
@olechristianhenne6583
4 жыл бұрын
To bad they focus on trump and problems and complaing
@fs1541
4 жыл бұрын
Olé!
@DeADvElOciRaPtor
4 жыл бұрын
Yes
@TheCarnivoreSoprano
3 жыл бұрын
Period
@WhoIsJohnGaltt
3 жыл бұрын
I’d really like to know who is paying extra for this schooling when their already paying money for the public school with taxes. I mean how can you compete with something you would be forced to pay for twice??
@eli-huyasharal3913
7 жыл бұрын
Won't hear this on the news
@isaacg.1185
7 жыл бұрын
HEY, DO YOU KNOW TRUMP? TRUMP! TRUMP DID THIS! TRUMP SCANDAL! TRUMP BUYS IMMIGRANTS? TRUMP DEPORTS IMMIGRANTS! TRUMP SAYS SOMETHING CONTROVERSIAL!
@darkdudironaji
7 жыл бұрын
Isaac G. What's even worse is, while the liberal media is bashing Trump 24/7, the conservative media is just saying, "Can you believe what the liberal media is saying about Trump!?" Trump has said a lot of stupid shit. GET OFF IT ALREADY! TELL ME WHAT HE'S ACTUALLY DOING AS PRESIDENT. THAT'S ALL I CARE ABOUT! THAT'S ALL THAT IS GOING TO AFFECT MY LIFE!
@jaycampbell6402
5 жыл бұрын
@@darkdudironaji - He is actually preparing America to face the fact that the cold war is over instead of racing around trying to start a new cold war in places like Iraq, Syria and Libya. He is proving to the American public that if we don't trap US forces in the third world, we don't need to be be bribing dictatorships like China by making bad trade deals. Trump is showing Americans how much of their wealth is being siphoned away by the neocons and neoliberals who want to use it to leverage power for themselves on the international stage. Because of that Trump has not murdered anywhere near the amount of people as any of the last four administrations taken alone. That is reason enough for anyone of conscience to support him and is the reason the neocon/neoliberal media lapdogs hate him.
@Tethloach1
5 жыл бұрын
@@jaycampbell6402 The media helped improve his image in the last 5-10 years. they make him look so good that there is no point in criticizing him at all. I have had zero criticisms of him since he has been president.
@Malouco
5 жыл бұрын
Eli-hu Ya these people write a thread about trump off topic complaining about how all media talks about is trump. Lmao. I'm sure u nor I give a fuck about him as a person or a president.
@ShaAllahShabazzMBA
6 жыл бұрын
"If the teacher has a Master's degree but they aren't a good teacher, then we don't consider the master's degree to be very valuable." So simple that it goes over the heads of most "educated" people.
@Irishcrossing
6 жыл бұрын
"educated people": I am so glad that my entire career life is based around a piece of paper that dictates what I already knew in high school. All that money wasted on this piece of paper, rather than my own skills. Also "educated people": What do you mean the public schooling system is flawed? How else can you acknowledge a persons worth other than their degree in education? Jeez how stupid can you be?
@nopedefinitelynotnahthatsnotme
6 жыл бұрын
So true. Although i went to a private school the teaches with their "masters" sometimes were garbage. And someone with a couple years of college and some smarts could easily out-teach many of these dummies with degrees.
@imreborbas9029
5 жыл бұрын
True, but I can sympathize a bit. When you're employing millions of people, it's hard to go case-by-case. And going by papers is better than choosing completely at random. This is one of the biggest problems of centralization. There is a reason entities that grow too large tend to become slow and unresponsive and usually collapse.
@gorkyd7912
5 жыл бұрын
The size of the company is not the problem. The ability to train employees and adapt is the problem. Telling everyone to choose teachers who have masters degrees is tying up the success of schools to the value of a masters degree, which is determined by the quality of some university somewhere that is probably a scam (most universities are scams). So it can't be quickly adapted if, say, the worth of a degree drops by 50% in 10 years. But that doesn't mean your CEO has to hand-pick every teacher, they just need to codify a more reliable way of determining if a teacher will be successful. If the success of your business depends entirely on the success of teachers (like when you're competing directly and must out-perform "free" public schools every single year) then you can afford to spend a little extra on perfecting your testing / screening and get the right people instead of just falling back on sketchy certifications.
@harrymills2770
5 жыл бұрын
@@gorkyd7912 : A teaching certificate doesn't mean a whole lot, other than that the person took a lot of education courses that are NOT related to the disciplines they mean to teach. As a former college student, I saw the wash-outs who decided to get a teaching certificate because they weren't fit to compete in any major area of study. A master's only says you have some competence in the content area. A teaching certificate only says that you took a bare minimum of regular courses and a bunch of "education" courses. Neither says you're any good as a teacher. Only observing you in the classroom and seeing how students respond really tells you, and that's easy enough to do, unless it's a public school and administrators (and teachers) don't want to visit classrooms. In a private setup, if you suck, you're OUT. In a private setup, parents have real skin in the game, and if you suck, they're pullin' their kids out and spending that money somewhere else. There's no penalty for failure in the public schools. The worse you suck, the more money you get. And year after year, the number of staff and administration per actual working faculty member goes up and up, without end. And there are actually LESS staff supporting the actual faculty. The staff and administration do everything BUT anything related to the actual teaching and learning. And every time you TRY to implement something meaningful and really quality-control-related, the teachers' union or some state bureaucrat will obstruct you. Public education is a definite scam, and some of the worst scammers are the people always whining for MORE money. It's not a money thing. It's a product-quality thing. And nobody holds the public schools accountable. And NOWadays (and for the last 20 or 30 years), it's all been dumped on the COLLEGES to remediate all the damage done by k-12, instead of holding k-12 accountable. But "student success" means students pass. And the only way to guarantee that students pass is to lower standards, which they've been doing non-stop since I started teaching back in the 1980s.
@agustinbaletti
5 жыл бұрын
Free Market for all of education should be the norm. We need it so innovation and improvement can be a rrality! Make affordable schools possible by destroying state regulations! Libertarianism is the future.
@JohnHoulgate
3 жыл бұрын
@@ry-t-ster9512 Libertarianism is a philosophy of ungoverning. It is actually anti-politics. Libertarian pols would be good at repealing laws, regulations and cutting taxes. These aren't qualities you typically find in a charismatic politician because voters tend to go for pols who promise to do something, not undo bad things.
@JohnHoulgate
3 жыл бұрын
@@ry-t-ster9512 I understand the framing bit. However, I think the problem has more to do with conditioning people have had for generations, going back to the Great Depression. People believe that government intervention in their lives is a good thing and necessary. Ever debate with a retired schoolteacher about Roosevelt? I have and she actually believed that because her family survived the GD and benefitted from the New Deal, that she knew economics better than I did. Any amount of charisma and appeal to emotions has to cut through beliefs like this. It's not an easy task. Someone like Oprah Winfrey might be able to do it, but she's firmly on the other side. She gets away with handing young starlets over to Harvey Weinstein, then gives her "Times Up" speech. Now that's charisma.
@TickedOffPriest
7 жыл бұрын
Ideally we need to move away from the factory model of education as well.
@chrissnyder3809
7 жыл бұрын
I think that is what I am saying... desks in a row..marching in lines and uniforms are all carryovers from military obedience BS
@kpss4681
7 жыл бұрын
That is one reason I support school choice! So I can send my kids to a Waldorf or Montessori type school where their individuality is held high.
@vaibhavgupta20
7 жыл бұрын
TickedOff Priest but there is no alternative to factory model.
@liberdedeum6748
7 жыл бұрын
A renaissance of privately tutored children is the answer, we need more teachers, and more teachers who can "sell" their skill and talents to the families directly, that way a rigorous program can be developed for each family and child as need be. This will increase the job market for teachers and not place them in the monopoly of the school system. +pax Christi!+
@chrissnyder3809
7 жыл бұрын
More parents teaching trades again ....
@maybebabyny
7 жыл бұрын
This sounds very promising. I'm curious to know how the students do when they graduate to another school.
@reg3012
7 жыл бұрын
They do amazing. We hired a graduate from one of his schools who just finished up at NC State, kid is a superstar. Look at their Iowa Test results if you need more proof thalesacademy.org/academics/standardized-testing-performance
@evandill2430
6 жыл бұрын
I come from one of Luddy's high schools, Saint Thomas More Academy. I graduated with a 3.1 unweighted GPA and went to The Catholic University of America and now have a 3.9 GPA. I know people who have gotten into Cornell, Case Western, Aquinas in Grand Rapids, and several other great schools and are doing fantastically. I'm surprised they only mentioned Thales, but to answer your question: a high level achievement generally exists for everyone who graduates. Also, it may be noted that STMA, a school that's about a 5 minute drive from Ravenscroft, has a tuition of around 9k and will gladly subsidize that if you don't have a high income compared to Ravenscroft's 20k.
@aeroeng22
3 жыл бұрын
Perhaps the kid would have been just as much of a superstar if he/she had graduated from a public school. My point is there is a lot of self selection going on here---the parent with the not very bright child probably isn't going to bother with the hassle and additional expense of Thales. Frequently you could just as easily explain the documented success of private schools to the quality of the kids they are admitting. Private schools don't put up with kids who don't care. Here's an example. Neighbor kid went to private school, until he brought a knife to school..Expelled! Who had to take the kid in? The public schools. Private schools can get rid of their problems easily; public schools cannot as easily.
@maybebabyny
3 жыл бұрын
@@aeroeng22 Very good point.
@paulblart6411
3 жыл бұрын
@@aeroeng22 good point, but I feel like saying that’s the only reason is simplifying it. The public school system is really ass sometimes, and kids don’t do well in it, even if they’re bright. I know a kid who was crazy smart, went to a shit public school and graduated to do minimum wage stuff.
@TedSchoenling
4 жыл бұрын
I worked for Bob back in 1997 and was at Cap-Aire when he started the school. He had a great vision and it is working.
@Letrus100
7 жыл бұрын
Now this is the content I subscribed for.
@Siegetower
7 жыл бұрын
+1000
@AshFarlow
5 жыл бұрын
Illinois should hear about this. My state is literally closing hundreds of schools. Guess why... "not enough tax revenue." Yeah right! Illinois has some of the highest taxes in the country.
@dreamshooter90
Жыл бұрын
Consequently, the highest "payers" leave for elsewhere.
@wrongway1100
6 жыл бұрын
Private schools are what works in Japan. It does well there. Also You don't need HS in Japan to get a job. If you can provide proof you have a skill you can get a job. Plus they have cram schools to learn or improve basic education skills. (Math, language, history etc)
@IncredibleMD
4 жыл бұрын
The overwhelming majority of students in Japan graduate from high school.
@mr.jamster8414
Жыл бұрын
Japan is a cooool place I reckon gets a lot of BS slander sometimes.
@Jcolinsol
7 жыл бұрын
This is the best way to expound the principles of liberty, by demonstrating it philanthropically.
@AetherXIV
5 жыл бұрын
beautifully said
@limerickman8512
5 жыл бұрын
We did not have a cafeteria in my schools. We brought our own lunch to school and ate it anywhere. We had simple sports facility and we did fine.
@ohevshalomel
7 жыл бұрын
If the school fails to educate the pupils well, the parents can remove their children and stop paying. A monolithic public school system doesn't allow for that. The best you could do within the public school system would be to vote with your feet (to a better district) and hope for the best. If public schools are already failing, what do parents have to lose by going outside the system (the system they pay for whether their own children use it or not)?
@KnightofAntiquity
5 жыл бұрын
Usually poorly performing students are the result of shit parents. Shit parents usually result from shitty grandparents. You get the idea. A teacher cannot fix that shit unless they become a figure in a childs life equivalent to a parent.... something dofficult to do with 120 + students.
@elliotw4606
4 жыл бұрын
The unfortunate solution is a wave of anti natalism. And younger people do see that and don't seem afraid to use it. Look at marriage rates. Look at divorce rates. Look at if people are having kids. That's one way to enforce change is not give any fuel until it happens.
@grast5150
5 жыл бұрын
Gah another reason to move out of California. The teachers unions and state government would not allow such an expansive charter school system. Later
@abrahkadabra9501
5 жыл бұрын
OK, so let's do the math on Thales: 26 students (@ $5,500 a head) per teacher = $143,000 /year. Teacher cost is probably $60,000-70,000 / year. Cost of the building + power + water + insurance + maintenance + administration + taxes = about 35% per student. Remainder is about $40,000 per year for a class of 26 students. Any good businessman has to be good with money so Thales probably spent some time figuring all of this out and saw an opportunity to make a change. Remember Thales does not take kids with learning disabilities or special needs. Also, because Thales is not publically funded so politics does not play a big role in the way the administration works and just that is a huge savings. Not having to deal with the teachers union probably gives Thales a great deal of freedom to make the changes he wants. The real challenge will be to take in kids with learning disabilities and other special needs kids.
@williamadiputra2850
5 жыл бұрын
i wonder about that too. surely segregating special need kids is cheaper and more efficient. but what about those special need kids? are all special need kids gonna go to their special schools separated from "normal" people? is that desirable? is that cruel?
@parisgansmuelly1052
5 жыл бұрын
@@williamadiputra2850 No, it's absolutely normal. No "normal" (however you'd like to define it) kid wants to be around them. This might be a tangent, but it's always funny to me how the pro-abortion left all of a sudden starts worrying about the mentally special; can you imagine them saying they should be aborted in the womb BECAUSE of their disabilities?
@abrahkadabra9501
5 жыл бұрын
@@parisgansmuelly1052 I went to school where there were students with special needs and I don't remember feeling uncomfortable around them. If they needed help I'd help them if I could and so did my friends. This was not a great burden on me. I guess it was a different time when people weren't JERKS!
@iskdude9922
5 жыл бұрын
@@abrahkadabra9501 well where i went to school they seperated me into a esl class because i was asian and there were other special needs type people there as well if i recall correctly... So we were already seperated... Not sure how they do it elsewhere but public school is indeed a joke
@TedSchoenling
4 жыл бұрын
@J R The NCAE is a union in all but name....
@jonh4265
5 жыл бұрын
And every School Board and Public Union hates this man and what he stands for! That speaks volumes about the state of Educations in America.
@cubeincubes
5 жыл бұрын
my experience in school was seeing ALL the GIFTED kids classes CUT to cater to the DROOLING ones. MAKES SENSE TO ME
@BrotherWoody1
7 жыл бұрын
Another good thing about Thales is that parents won't be sending their kids there to promote their future careers in the NBA or the NFL. Let the "Parks & Recreation" take care of all that sort of thing, if the taxpayers still desire it. I was born & reared in Columbus & am an alum of Ohio State & I'm fed up with turning out spectacular athletes who can't speak a grammatically correct sentence. It's not merely how much you know but it's how much you know that you're able to communicate. If you don't know how to read, you don't know how to write & if you don't know how to write, you don't know how to think & you can't SAY something that's worth very much to anybody. You can't fake competence for very long.
@shaneayers4338
6 жыл бұрын
Professional athletes, even those not in the major American league, make so much more than the average person in the middle class that your argument can't be seen as anything but laughable. You don't think entertainment isn't "worth very much to anybody"? Their salaries argue otherwise. What's that libertarians say about markets again?
@STho205
6 жыл бұрын
Shane Ayers. But their approach is an academic education facility should not be producing that athlete. City/County Parks and Rec should provide higher athletic coaching, facilities and teams. Each school having a sports complex, large lawn/field/court maintenance staff and large coaching staff JUST so kids (even younger kids) can pretend to be Ivy League colleges in 1920 to have home and away games is in fact very wasteful. The universities now use the schools to feed their bloated sports programs and then those programs feed the pro leagues. It doesn't have to remain that way. It probably will, but it doesn't have to. Originally pro leagues drew players from city leagues, not university programs. That started to change in the 30s as more schools got into the business of sports and pro teams had more schools to do business with. Your Harvard graduate was unlikely to throw footballs for a living at 25. Your Ohio State graduate probably would. It may not be the only way to do schools but it is a way. His model looks very much like Catholic Grammar School in the 50s and 60s. They produced great results at low cost.
@shaneayers4338
6 жыл бұрын
Their approach as an academic institution should be to create the citizens we need in the future. This includes athletes. I'm not even sure how you can believe your argument has merits. We're in the middle of the worst obesity crisis our species has ever seen in this country. if anything, we should be placing an even higher value on the integration of regular exercise into everyday life, not suppressing it.
@STho205
6 жыл бұрын
Shane Ayers. Well the schools have been doing coached athletics PE since the 30s and 40s in MS and HS, and since the 70s in Grammar school as opposed to recess /free play. However obesity has been RISING since those times, especially after free play for elementary was nixed in favor of structured PE. If mainstream schools are supposed to keep kids fit, then they are doing a poor job (and the cheap junk food lunches help a lot too). Again, city and county parks and rec could handle the coached athletics after school and school could easily end at 2pm if just classroom time and one or two free play recess periods. After school programs would then have 3 hours till pickup at 5:30 or 6. It used to work. What we're doing now isn't. It may identify, sort and foster the elite athlete, but pretty much gives a wag to the average kids health.
@shaneayers4338
6 жыл бұрын
You didn't adequately address my point. The fact that public schools are executing a good idea poorly is not sufficient cause to leave it out entirely in this model. You're also conveniently leaving out the well-documented links between cognitive development and athleticism.
@jonathanalvarez3875
4 жыл бұрын
Wow I’ve been thinking about this a lot before I saw this video. Currently Sweden gives vouchers to each family, and lets the family decide where their kids should attend school with those vouchers, and guess what? They have a damn good privatized school system. As a libertarian myself, about to graduate with an ME degree, I hope to create either a stem focused charter school or cheap private school depending on how much beurocracy strangles us dependent on the state, and I would like to construct them in more impoverished areas. I want to show the country that the best way to tackle these educational problems is with using the competitiveness of the free market system as an advantage to solve many of our problems, instead of having people believe that just by funding public schools even more would fix them. I want to teach kids how “cool” and interesting math and science can be, on top of teaching them basics in economics and maybe even fiscal classes which teach fiscal responsibility and debts, to prepare them for actual life, and not have them take in thousands in debt to obtain a useless diversity studies degree.
@healthhavencom
7 жыл бұрын
Public School = Prison Training for Kids
@destroya3303
5 жыл бұрын
This what philanthropy actually looks like
@medaphysicsrepository2639
7 жыл бұрын
higher education sucks just as bad as k-12 education why not do the same in higher ed?
@tmac9938
7 жыл бұрын
agreed!
@Loathomar
7 жыл бұрын
There are TONS of for profit higher education schools. Turns out they suck. How does University of Phoenix compare to UCLA? It sucks. People see a four year degree from most for profit higher education schools and give it the weight of a 2 year degree. The only places that don't are government jobs where the box for education must be checked. It is why student debt is 65% more from a profit higher education schools then a public school and the default rate is 6 times as high. Really, US higher education is world class. We have student from all over the world fighting to get into most of our non profit and public schools. Not so much for all our or profit higher education schools.
@annemor7691
7 жыл бұрын
Loathomar
@arielsolomon5645
7 жыл бұрын
most of the problems in higher education stem from how we're handling our K12 education. We don't develop good math, reading, writing, or critical reasoning skills; we develop factory workers... where its "ok" to be a little under the bar. The problem is that isn't what we need, we need people who can read and understand the information presented to them, understand when numbers don't add up, reason their way through problems, and be precise and accurate in their language skills when they need to express an idea. The second biggest problem is that collage isn't for everyone, nor should it. The problem is that many of the common place jobs that pretty much any modern dick off the street could do, is covered by a liberal arts degree and not a technical degree. The difference being that a technical degree focuses on doing one task, while a liberal arts degree is designed to provide broad intellectual exposure. A computer technician used to need to be a straight up scientist who could do high levels of math and a broad understanding of physics and engineering, that isn't the case anymore. Basic math skills are acceptable, high levels of English skills and understanding of broad network construction is more important. That's something a technical school is ideally suited for. I'm an art major, my job is communication. I need a broad understanding of language, culture, history and philosophy so I can create products that are meaningful to the largest markets OR be able to single out very select markets. Arts benefits from a liberal arts education. Can it be done without a degree, sure, happens all the time, but usually takes less time and luck with a degree. Our higher education isn't designed to handle the number of people coming through and it often has to retrain people on English and math skills.
@theicedragon100
6 жыл бұрын
you get great returns as long as you go into a major that has demand like computer science or engineering.
@Jack2488
7 жыл бұрын
Excellent video - been talking to 'big government' types all day, this makes me feel much better :)
@taxslave5906
4 жыл бұрын
@taxation is theft memes news & more, one thing that the government can do that a private group cannot do is put innocent people in prison for victimless crimes. One thing that the government does efficiently: Ruining people’s lives.
@LibertyDownUnder
7 жыл бұрын
Though far from perfect, I would gladly send my kids to one of these schools. Also, congratulations ReasonTV for finding "substance" again after your slew of MTV / Buzzfeed style productions.
@benawesomebw1197
4 жыл бұрын
LibertyDownUnder they’ve become libertarian buzzfeed at this point lol.
@Mooja12
7 жыл бұрын
Mr Luddy mentioned that he first tried a charter school then went private. Does this mean that private schools are less regulated than charter schools? If so do you have any information on where the regulations differ? It's a shame that people don't have the option to voluntarily send their children to school wherever they choose without the government interfering.
@1_Storyteller
4 жыл бұрын
Indiana has a 6000 dollar voucher system that goes through the parents to the school of the parent's choice. True school choice.
@johnnybartonjb
7 жыл бұрын
School uniforms serve various functions but the main one is for the students to focus on education rather than fashion. In public schools where a free dress code is allowed students compete with each other in clothing, sometimes to the embarrassment of children whose families cannot afford trendy clothing. Also uniforms are usually well made and look sharp, boosting the self esteem of students. My children attend a charter school that also requires uniforms and has no cafeteria and I couldn't be happier with the concentration on classic education they promote.
@chrissnyder3809
7 жыл бұрын
School uniforms serve various functions .. But the main one is to comply and form good citizens
@chrissnyder3809
7 жыл бұрын
Randy Perez OK smart guy tell me what purpose school uniformity serves besides to stifle individualism ... Now explain what you mean by discipline and obedience as it pertains to society
@chrissnyder3809
7 жыл бұрын
Self discipline and obeying the social norm of respecting the person and property of others conflates to military type enforcement and uniformity how?
@foxjumper
7 жыл бұрын
LOL. You are trolling in your other comment and then try to troll with a guy who actually has kids in a private school. How about you tell us how many kids you have in elementary or middle school?
@arielsolomon5645
7 жыл бұрын
Wearing a uniform is somehow "military type enforcement"? Wearing uniforms unifies people, be it work, a factory or the military. Social norms are how societies form and fuction, lacking a uniform we naturally seek other things to identify our social group, say skin color, slogans, political parties, ect. If I wear a mohawk and a spiked jacket with patches, I must be a punk. That is the punk "uniform" as is culturally precieved. If I wear business suit, polished shoes and comb down my mohawk I'm a business man. If I call my mohawk a high and tight, strap on my uniform and carry a rifle, I'm a soldier. I do all of those things, what am I? An individual who chooses who and what he is. Someone who lacks a uniform isn't an individual, they're baseless. I'm also a furry, many furries have no social ability and do not fit well in social situations. Often, in normal every day life they wear things that are totally inappropriate for their situation. The lack the skills to recognize the "uniform" they should be in to be accepted in any society. Yes, they are individuals, but they are often practically incapable of interacting with the rest of humanity. They can be smart, talented or just good people, but they do not fit in anywhere(often not even with other furries).
@SayNoToDemocide1
7 жыл бұрын
This video was just added to my playlist "Truth about school & education exposed, plus education reform, student's rights, & is school a waste of time?" (youtube. com/playlist?list=PLkYQwSCzfVRERfuAcTGRqm6AvwbEx0WYW, also listed on my channel's homepage). The education system in many parts of the world (in this specific case, the U.S.) needs some serious change. But, if the system doesn't change, we'll have to replace it with homeschooling programs such as the Ron Paul curriculum. One way of re-doing the education system for people who can't afford homeschooling or private schooling that I've came up with is to combine charter schools with school choice to force competition between schools to up their quality big time. Now that's a step in the right direction.
@grantcivyt
7 жыл бұрын
Godspeed, Bob Luddy.
@robertleelandjob
7 жыл бұрын
This is basically every church school out there. they've been doin it for less for decades to boot.
@mycupoverflows7811
4 жыл бұрын
@ I homeschool using ACE. Would love to start an ACE school at my church one day. 😊
@TheRealFollower
4 жыл бұрын
Absolutely no bloat in staff. No wonder it's so cheap.
@goofinhiemer1153
5 жыл бұрын
Charter schools will eventually get access to the gymnasiums and fields because they will be held to all other access standards. Current charter students don't have alternatives to infrastructure. Soon county developers will include charter/home schoolers in their common use facility plan as a stakeholder support base who pays taxes and doesnt get access. Go charter, save the future.
@curioustgeorge
7 жыл бұрын
they talked about outcomes but didn't show what differences in student achievement or performance compared to charter or public schools. make a part 2 explaining that! the only outcome they mentioned is competition to get in..
@theuglykwan
6 жыл бұрын
I'd like to know more too but I'd assume his expansion is based on demand which is a general indicator.
@camd3511
5 жыл бұрын
Whenever there is competition to get in, you know the word is out on how good they are doing.
@iskdude9922
5 жыл бұрын
Of course its great. I didnt learn jack shit in school and i live in one of the highest taxed states in the country.
@goodgoyim9459
2 жыл бұрын
student outcomes is largely determined by race, IQ, family situation and not schools, proven with science, nicer schools dont make better performers.
@joshuaziegler1
7 жыл бұрын
This is a huge reason why I like the Trump pick for the education dept. Do away with the failing public education system and move to a voucher system that you choose the school with the money you pay vs funding the public school offered in your district, pay the teachers what they are worth not what the school district can afford.
@chrissnyder3809
7 жыл бұрын
Nice to have those dreams ... Trump loves the state
@DavidHDennis
7 жыл бұрын
I think he's pragmatic. He loves the state when it works well for him. In the case of his nominee for Secretary of Education, her commitment to vouchers and charters is extremely well known and well respected (and of course loathed but by all the right people).
@osaabd390
7 жыл бұрын
are you kidding me? did you see the senate hearing session? she is incredibly stupid. I don;t know how her family trusts her with their business. I live in Switzerland and lived in Sweden and Denmark. I also studied in Switzerland and Sweden and taught in some other places. and these countries have public school system and it is totally working where the state actually invests in its people. where the majority believes that education is a human right not a privilege.
@whitefox998
7 жыл бұрын
"This is a huge reason why I like the Trump pick for the education dept..." *Facepalm* Does anyone else remember the days when Trump supporters were trying to get libertarians to vote for him back when he was talking about abolishing the DoE? Trump voters seem to have shorter memories than leftists.
@Siegetower
7 жыл бұрын
Yes, abolish the federal dept of education. It fails kids across the country.
@GONZOMAF
6 жыл бұрын
That part about shitty teachers with masters degrees is something that hits home for me as a high school senior. All my teachers are coaches first and teachers second so I️ may be top of my class but what that really means is that I’m good at hiding my phone while look for answers not actually doing work
@repker
7 жыл бұрын
No mention of what the (arguably) primary goal of education: to educate. An education system's success isn't measured only on if the business runs well, it's also measured on how well it actually educates.
@destroya3303
5 жыл бұрын
This is really exciting. Larger class sizes...seen a good sign. Cutting out unnecessary bureaucracy. Doing something about a problem without waiting for government to make a law.
@iowasenator
3 жыл бұрын
Mark my words, the powers that be simply CAN'T let innovation like this succeed! I guarantee that they'll soon be marshaling their forces in opposition to the successful implementation of such freedom and quality results! If they are unable to CONVINCE free thinking people, they will seek the adoption of laws (or FORCE) to shutter the doors of these wonderful schools. They don't care about liberty or the success of these students. They want what is best for themselves and they're happy to utilize government to force the rest of us to participate. I'm not psychic and I can't predict the future. It's just that statists are as transparent as glass.
@roysmith3198
4 жыл бұрын
That's getting started, some people with money doing some good. Thank you.
@davidking4779
4 жыл бұрын
The Liberal teaching style Montessori schools didn't seem to get as much push back as conservative schools do.
@austingeorge6659
3 жыл бұрын
Woo-hoo! Doesn't have to be a Christian private school for me to praise Jesus! He's moving mountains in our nation!
@spikedpsycho2383
3 жыл бұрын
Lesson: ANything government can do, private does better.When govt finds out, they cripple alternatives.
@karlcraig3680
5 жыл бұрын
What everyone seems to be missing is that the only way they are able to afford this is by picking and choosing all the students. It is fine for a private school to do this, however this is not a model for the rest of the country.
@pneron2032
4 жыл бұрын
Ir doesn't have to be a model for the whole country. The whole point is to move away from one size fits all models. It is good for the country, as a whole, however because it is lessening the cost of public education with every child that it takes.
@mr.w8802
7 жыл бұрын
No food, no disabled kids... well duh its cheaper it's not even fair to compare this with what public education has to deal with...
@barsoom43
5 жыл бұрын
To reform the public schools, first close down the Federal Department of Education.. Get the Feds totally out of the schools and, BTW, keep the First Lady out of the school lunch menu.. Then, de-unionize the teachers.
@PUNKDUDE1991
4 жыл бұрын
Nevertheless here in Puerto Rico where I live there's a proposal to turn all public schools in to Educational Co-operative run by teachers and parents without intervention of the state. We are talking about 700 plus schools system with 300,000 kids rigth now we spend $15k per kid a year Wich The state will pay in form of tuition.
@Nah_Bohdi
7 жыл бұрын
Thank you!
@solb101
2 жыл бұрын
If someone can make private education affordable for working class people, that would be good indeed.
@Felix_Ruber
7 жыл бұрын
I love this.
@torbreww
5 жыл бұрын
But how do we know if their education is any good? What are their standardized test scores?
@chrissnyder3809
7 жыл бұрын
Still using same type system of desks in a line ..uniforms etc Need to abolish all these militarized ideals
@Paul-A01
7 жыл бұрын
Chris Snyder Like discipline?
@aaronneil7
7 жыл бұрын
How about you do it? Or would you rather gripe about a business man making education better for students and their families?
@chrissnyder3809
7 жыл бұрын
Yes ... it came from Germany to "form good obedient citizens " .... People that voluntarily enjoy and come to learn don't need to be treated like the military..
@chrissnyder3809
7 жыл бұрын
Trying to improve society ... didn't say this was bad. In fact in the video he says he is still under state BS regulations
@alexjones1017
7 жыл бұрын
Well under free market schools you'd be able to send them to more individual schools. Some already exist like Waldorf schools, while not really that great, are an example of what could be offered.
@zadkiel242
5 жыл бұрын
"We don't want regulation in schools." OK so those people want schools to teach young earth creationism, flat Earth, and antivax? OK no problem.
@bobsaget7315
7 жыл бұрын
Sports is one of the things I really love about high school though.
@araci88
5 жыл бұрын
In Peru the regulations to open a private school are not as restrictive and the free market has allowed the massive growth of private schools. I studied in a very respectable private school in Lima and my parents only payed 100$ a month for it. No sports, no art, no religious teachings, no extra curricular activities, no cafeteria, just classes from 8am to 6pm, with a break at 2pm of 1 hour. The goal of the school? Make your child ready to enter college, and the percentage of teens entering college after high school was almost 100%.
@ahokay3119
3 жыл бұрын
This is fucking beautiful. I wish all schooling in the USA was like this.
@marcmeinzer8859
Жыл бұрын
Right on the money. Public schools are over-complicated daycare facilities which largely cater to the uneducable. In a nutshell, if you’re teaching a self contained sixth grade classroom then everybody in that room better be able to do grade six material. Then also the chronically disruptive kids need to be dumped back into the public schools so the suckers can babysit them. Eventually the public schools will have to automated since they’re alienating all of the teachers. If the public schools want to specialize in babysitting then their teachers should be replaced by computer terminals for online academy and babysitters. And to belabor the obvious, both online academy and babysitters are far cheaper than phony teachers with phony master’s degrees in “education” instead of some content area.
@libertariantranslator1929
5 жыл бұрын
Libertarian Spoiler Votes are an exit strategy. To keep from losing to opponents, Kleptocracy parties have to change laws and their own platforms.
@juanvaldo666
5 жыл бұрын
I just hope they teach the children here matters that really are important and not that crap of sexual ideology or how to wear a condom.
@walperstyle
6 жыл бұрын
FYI: 'Thales' comes from possibly the earliest known (not known) physicist.
@frocco7125
5 жыл бұрын
I like what this man is doing. In an individualistic society, education is a RIGHT, not a privilege.
@williamadiputra2850
5 жыл бұрын
why is it a right? is it because education improves my chances of making a better living? if that's the case, then why isn't my laptop a right? everybody should have a laptop since it improves their chances of making a better living. i should have a right to a factory or a company, since that improves my chances of making a better living.
@marksdaman9408
7 жыл бұрын
I am just curious who decides the curriculum?How is proficiency determined? Are the children ready for college afterwards?
@erinmontoya1128
5 жыл бұрын
If a kid has to go through 12 years of schooling and comes out not having the adequate skills to compete in the job market, why do they need college?
@basteagui
5 жыл бұрын
@@erinmontoya1128 they need college to get the adequate skills. because middle and high school are bullshit. at least elementary school teaches you reading, writing, multiplication, adding and substracting.
@iskdude9922
5 жыл бұрын
@@basteagui yes and its generally easier to make friends in elementary school before everyone starts getting in their cliches and other stupid shit
@robertlarrypoor1465
4 жыл бұрын
We need to remember everything is a business, nothing is free so therefore we pay for everything, so why not have competition which can save us money?
@shashipancholi
5 жыл бұрын
Schools can be treated like a factory: pumping out children like items off a construction line, but going to school is more than just entering a building and downloading information. I do however like the idea of getting parents more engaged with the eduction of their children
@mylaisms7908
3 жыл бұрын
You are being a shining example !!! Thank you 💗
@mr.w8802
7 жыл бұрын
When over 85% of all people in the nation graduate from HS idk why people keep saying the Education system is failing. The reality is it could be improved, but I would love to see someone come up with a realistic solution to fix it. If you can fix the 15% that don't graduate but it costs 2x as much does that work? Or are we ok with only 75% of kids passing but it costs half as much... I don't have the answer but I can tell you this, this is WAY more complex than just what we provide. A lot of it comes from our culture and weather or not BOTH parents are in the home.
@Fallout777
6 жыл бұрын
43 thumbs down, Hmmmm must be teacher union members.
@KevZen2000
7 жыл бұрын
Actually, education should be dramatically dropping in cost. The reason, is that technology has mad education more efficient, and at a faster pace. What use to take 4 years to train, now can be done in a year or less. The problem, is that it isn't profitable to educate properly, as you can always expand the demand to other unnecessary services, which should have been taught properly in the traditional schooling.
@assault410
7 жыл бұрын
But how can they get to the school if there are no roads? Checkmate
@parkerwilson7860
6 жыл бұрын
assault410 lol, I think most libertarians believe in a road commission 😂
@Warrenmitchum
6 жыл бұрын
Parker Wilson they do and honestly who paves the road is it the city or a company the city hires to do the job if the city can hire them why not you.
@CheapSkateGamer96
6 жыл бұрын
Toll roads my dude.
@kyled1673
6 жыл бұрын
The private sector can and has built our roads. Checkmate.
@analienfromouterspace
5 жыл бұрын
My father back in Iraq paved a city road for his projects, he knew where to get cheaper labor and less expansive materials for it. Know your market!
@jamescash2773
6 жыл бұрын
Interesting. My spouse was co-owner and director of a Traditional Montessori school (private for profit). For the 17 years that the school operated in Texas, the majority of their students had comprehensive test scores that far exceeded comparable students that were in the public school system. The school also had scholarships for parents who could not afford the annual tuition of $6600 (Kindergarten through 6th grade). The difference is that the school and the Montessori method helps the student develop a “love of learning” and can lead to lower expenses for students, their families and the overall school costs. Rest assured, the Montessori method is just one way for better school instruction. There are other methods that may also be effective, but any method that only “prepares” students to take a state/government designed and implemented test is an abject failure.
@freeinghumanitynow
6 ай бұрын
Lol. Imagine making parents take their kids to school and feed their kids instead of relying on the school. I'm cackling. Most "parents" aren't going to go for that.
@SajaStoica
7 жыл бұрын
This is interesting, but how are the results? There's no data provided on how successful these schools are.
@simplestatic
7 жыл бұрын
Samuel Morales Jr. well considering a parent has to put out a chunk of change, drop their child off every morning, pick them up in the afternoon, make lunches, and there is a 4:1 waiting list, it must be at least better than the public school it is competing with where all of that is "free".
@joshuahand407
6 жыл бұрын
Samuel Morales Jr. It really doesn’t matter when you have a choice. If the school is inferior to public schools, then it’s your fault for choosing it. That’s the point of privatizing the education department. It’s not just about better test grades, or having a sports team. I should get to choose where I send my kid to school.
@sakaue
2 жыл бұрын
i never learned what an object of a preposition was until i was in german 1 in 8th grade, but these kids are actually learning it in english class in elementary school
@joeblow7111
4 жыл бұрын
I don’t wanna go to a charter school cuz I like regular school and being able to make fun of it
@GordonTurnerpark
7 жыл бұрын
You kind of lost me when you said they don't serve students with severe learning disabilities. That is a major cost right there and public schools are required to make accommodations. I was actually wondering how this school can legally violate the ADA. If this system were implemented on a nationwide basis, how would students with learning and behavioral disabilities receive an education? I do appreciate the fact that you did include that in the report as it gives viewers a more complete picture. They had a great point when they talked about the cost of sports and sports facilities. I personally would love to see public schools get out of the sports business. Are students who attend the school allowed to use the sports facilities at the public school? If so, are the parents reimbursing the public school?
@DavidHDennis
7 жыл бұрын
A private school should not be required to take students who are unsuited to its curriculum. I seem to remember that the public school solution is often to put disabled students into special private schools for them, since mainstreaming them is frequently disruptive. This really isn't any different. When I was in college, I checked out the School of Education catalog. There was a one year course series about the Exceptional Child. Children who were disruptors, who couldn't learn, etc, were considered. There was a quick mention of the gifted, but as the very last thing taught, likely to be pushed aside by more important stuff. I would rather live in a society that puts the gifted first and the disabled last than our current situation of putting the disabled first and the gifted last.
@Mooja12
7 жыл бұрын
I'd simply like to live in a society where each person is free to make their choice who to associate with. Public School? You pay or they take your house.
@GordonTurnerpark
7 жыл бұрын
You are misinformed concerning students with special needs. They are included in all classrooms now. It started when I was in high school in the 1990's and is standard practice in all classroom today. It was ruled a violation of the ADA to not include children with special needs in classrooms.
@GordonTurnerpark
7 жыл бұрын
Agreed. I think people should have the ability to make their own choices. I think you are missing my point. Just pointing out that this isn't a solution for all things and it is a bit of an over simplification. I was questioning how they can violate the ADA and turn students out who have disabilities.
@Mooja12
7 жыл бұрын
Thinking that there is one solution for all things is one reason why government fails so miserably. No one is claiming that this is the solution for all things. But this seems to be a solution for some.
@maambomumba6123
3 жыл бұрын
Thank you Mr. Luddy. Thank You.
@fornello123
7 жыл бұрын
i'm all for free-market efficiency especially in education, but half of this guy's cost savings are simply due to cutting services. oh wow you saved money by not having school buses or a guidance counselor
@MrThinkEncourager
6 жыл бұрын
Some of the guidance counselors suck anyway. And some children need to WALK for exercise. I remember walking to school and even running sometimes if I was going to be late, lol. A lot of what's going on in public schools are a waste of time and taxpayer dollars. Children would be better off working at walmart or something. At least they'd be getting paid for something and maybe learning some type of skill. They could even save up enough money to pay for their own education. Some colleges cost less than public k-12 schools! I'd like to see community colleges (trade schools) compete against traditional schools.
@lithium25693
6 жыл бұрын
Taiwan and China agree with your child labor stance.
@MrThinkEncourager
6 жыл бұрын
@ lithium25693 So working at Walmart is child labor, lolol. I worked in crops and mowed lawns with an uncle and his sons during the summer while I was in junior high school. We made MONEY! That's something public schools don't give out. You sit there and get PIMPED while someone else (teachers) make money off of you. Also, as someone who played sports high school, many athletes work out and put their bodies through more physical (and sometimes mental) work than what's put into public schools sitting in a chair all day and being given unhealthy food for lunch. I wanted to learn computer tech, but my school wasn't even offering it. I also attended schools in different districts due to my dad moving around and being a teacher. I can tell you that some schools are more retarded than others! At one point in history schools actually had work shops and APPRENTICESHIPS (get paid to learn), but those have been slowly taken away. The founder of Zoho was helping children who can't afford to go to college by giving them apprenticeships. He attended Princeton and even states "We have a thousand engineers. We're been in business for 15 years....When's the last time anyone in our company use calculus." kzitem.info/news/bejne/u6prq4GkeoaKkoY P.S. I also stated SOME children. Those who'd want to stay in public schools can, but give others who might be POOR another choice! And I'm stating that as someone who lived in a single parent home until my mom got married! Oh and I use to help my grandpa sell hotdogs and watermelons make change on the side. I guess that was slave labor as well, lolol!
@Distress.
6 жыл бұрын
I think part of the point is freedom of choice lets parents customize what they're paying for. Remember this school is supposed to be low cost
@dab0331
5 жыл бұрын
Which is the cost is lower for the parents. Duhhhhhh.
@anthonyemmm
6 жыл бұрын
Charter isn’t always the answer. It is still a government funded program. I’m all for school choice but a large number of students in our district went to charter schools only to come running back a semester later to public school because they didn’t like it and said that the curriculum wasn’t up to par. Cool idea and kudos to this man for trying to do something different.
@dcavic6157
5 жыл бұрын
Please come to Massachusetts good Sir, our "best schools, colleges and universities" need a wake up call.
@whatthefunction9140
7 жыл бұрын
smart guy. he created a factory that creates factory workers.
@Norie92
7 жыл бұрын
Dylan T, no he created a private school, not a public school as you mentioned
@pavelthefabulous5675
6 жыл бұрын
Better than the publicly-owned factories that produce worthless students unworthy of a factory job.
@PrimaDel
6 жыл бұрын
+Norie92 What's the difference? it's literally same useless educational system, just state doesn't steal someone's money to pay for your "education". I want privatized system to see new forms of education emerge , to have diversity and competition of schools, I mean someone might like that charter schools, but I really don't, because it literally is factory to make brainwashed and obedient factory workers, I want to see private schools that respect my freedom to study what I want, and not force me to learn some useless shit.
@GAPIntoTheGame
5 жыл бұрын
To be fair, the historical reason for schools becoming more available was because they needed more workers back in the Industrial revolution. And the model from back then has barely changed
@a.i.marvin6180
5 жыл бұрын
Not only do states increase regulation on charter schools, they try to put well performing charters out of business.
@baylenlucas8923
5 жыл бұрын
This model is great for elementary school and middle school but it would not work for high school.
@CountArtha
7 жыл бұрын
"The Masses?" That's a very un-libertarian thing to call regular people.
@dab0331
5 жыл бұрын
Regular people? That's a very un- libertarian to call individuals. We're all great and special. Now give me a trophy
@pedarogue3163
7 жыл бұрын
As someone who has grown up and works in a completelly different school system and who knows only few about the probelmes of the US-School System I honestly don't know yet what to think about this example. But it is intriguing.
@theatheistpaladin
7 жыл бұрын
Private Schools for the Masses... unless you're disabled...
@CrusaderLogan
7 жыл бұрын
With more innovation and money, they can certainly provide for them in the future.
@theatheistpaladin
7 жыл бұрын
They specifically state that they save money by not teaching the disabled. Why would more money fix it? That will make costs go up, yet their selling point is they are cheaper. Did you not watch the video?
@seavisions
7 жыл бұрын
TheAtheistPaladin In wich the public should not be responsible for their financial burden. Disabled children should be the responsibility of the parents, not society. If they cant provide for the disabled child, then they should give it up for adoption. My cousin has a disabled child, he is taking on the burden alone. He dosent want his child to be a burden on others. That is whats called personal responsibility.
@theatheistpaladin
7 жыл бұрын
Personal responsibility or not, They didn't say they would teach if the disabled paid more, they just said they will not teach them, peroid.
@Mooja12
7 жыл бұрын
@TheAtheistPaladin It's an opportunity for you. Figure out how to educate disabled children at a low cost and you'll be a very wealthy person. Caveat, you can't rob people to pay for it like government does.
@TJtheHuman
7 жыл бұрын
I common problem with academies is that they over focus on vocational education, and not enough on basic life skills, philosophy, humanities, well being.
@simplestatic
7 жыл бұрын
TravistheHuman well the parents made that value judgement still chose Thales which is evidenced by the waiting list. You may be right though. But it should ultimately be a choice by the parent. I just looked at their website and they state they follow a classical curriculum.
@TJtheHuman
7 жыл бұрын
simplestatic, that brings me to another common problem with private education. I was homeschooled by homophobic creationists. Parents shouldn't be making these value judgments, and many know it. Their job is to help keep the child safe and healthy. Many just want to give their children their own religion bias and skills, but are simply unqualified to judge themselves or predict future trends. Many parents will still put their children through bad education centuries after it is proven to be bad.
@zfan2591
7 жыл бұрын
No cafeteria or guidance counselors? That would seem to me to cause pretty legitimate problems. I'm not sure if that model could be replicated nationwide.
@Bourikii2992
6 жыл бұрын
zfan2591 pack a lunch???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? Problem solved. Grand majority of students never go to see guidance counselors. It's a school not a psychiatric building.
@nathanielscreativecollecti6392
5 жыл бұрын
"Merry Christmas!" Love it
@gapipotok1876
5 жыл бұрын
in slovenia in high school there were 33 people in my class and in collage there were 75.
@ryuranzou
5 жыл бұрын
I'm just fine with private schools. Those parents that take their kids to private schools still pay taxes for the public schools even if their kids don't go there. The less students in those public schools the less workload needed and that also saves money for the taxpayers.
@rosiesneed6188
3 жыл бұрын
A big chunk of the private vs. public school debate is about perceived value and prestige. People perceive anything that is available to everyone to be lesser. Add a price tag and limit access, then that thing becomes valuable. If private education was the only choice, private schools wouldn’t be special anymore. Instead, people would complain that their vouchers are not sufficient to cover tuition in the “better” private schools. If you want to see what a Milton Friedman-style libertarian school system looks like, look at Chile. 100% school vouchers and many children stuck in mediocre schools because they can’t afford better.
@honkhonk8009
3 жыл бұрын
They should adopt a better system. I dont know which states, but apparently some states pay the school $1k a year for every student thats enrolled. Imagine if the government would pay companies depending on how many kids are enrolling. Imagine Amazon for school. Imagine instead of kids going to school for 6 hours just to learn shit 10x better on Khan Academy, we could skip the middle man and skip right into Khan Academy.
@chadthurs8078
5 жыл бұрын
If this is where private / charter schools are trending then public schools have nothing to worry about.
@Vandal_Hawk63
5 жыл бұрын
I would like to do this when I get out of school. Public schools have always sucked and it will be up to business people to change the nation.
@justinwilliam2865
3 жыл бұрын
Bravo for doing Public Service for your State/Country!One question though;IF you're doing the govt's job,what's the govt doing,on taxpayers money??
@terrifictomm
Жыл бұрын
Why does no one understand that mixed age classes are the way to go? The older are motivated to learn because they will have to teach the younger and if they don't learn it they will be embarrassed when the little kids find that out or when the little kids start teaching them! The little kids will learn because, with supervision, it's easier to learn from "the Big Kids" and they are naturally very motivated to impress their "teacher." They also know one day it will be them teaching the "little kids."
@TD-qi9gz
5 жыл бұрын
A few points why you can't do it everywhere: 1. No classes for a disabled child, which means that they will be shoved in a special school. 2. Large classes, with less attention to each kid. 3. Cheap schools will rely on public infrastructure. This one does not provide school buses 4. There is no social workers or guidance teacher, I don't need to tell you why it is bad.
6 жыл бұрын
Traditional, Conventional, and Individualized. Traditional was the old one room schoolhouse where older students taught the younger. Individualized is the future. Conventional is what the gov. schools uses now.
@masscomnet
3 жыл бұрын
How will the Public Teacher's Unions tolerate this insurrection!??!?
@reaper10unleashed
5 жыл бұрын
Ironic that the very same people that say every child deserves quality education as a right are the same people that fight allowing private schools to educate our children.
@Javiervs258
Жыл бұрын
Well, it's an important detail that not servicing kids with learning difficulties is one hell of a "little trick". Reduction of unnecessary expenses is probably the better trait of the private sector, and although segmenting kids by levels is certainly much more efficient than individualized attention, it has many detractors as well, since it is usually seen as classist and segregatory.
@jillpatton3432
Жыл бұрын
Yeah, I grew up in Baltimore that might be the worst example of public school spending and waste. They spend approx $18k per pupil which is way above national average but the schools are terrible. An audit found that only 2 of 5 district employees were teachers. Lots of graft and fraud.
@LaOrajPantalonoj
3 жыл бұрын
1. the school is a business for school owner. 2. the school owner wants to maximize its profit. 3. the parents (indirectly students) are clients. 4. the parents wants the highest education effect for posible lowest cost but at least same significant level is desired. 5. the parents pay for promise that the effect will be. 6. the income for the school owner is today the promise is in future. ==== So who and how evaluate that effect is as was promised? And who gives money back in case when promise was not fulfilled?
Пікірлер: 1,2 М.