it is so strange to watch this when you know more about machine learning than music theory.
@vibertthio
3 жыл бұрын
😆
@ammyvl1
3 жыл бұрын
People who know about both:
@mihailmilev9909
Жыл бұрын
wut
@mihailmilev9909
Жыл бұрын
wot
@mihailmilev9909
Жыл бұрын
@@ammyvl1 right lol
@12tone
5 жыл бұрын
One thing that's really interesting to me in that second harmonization is that, if you just follow the bass part, the G# actually _does_ resolve to an A, it just does it by staying silent for a couple 8ths and then _jumping up a minor 9th, crossing the tenor in the process._ So it feels like maybe it knew that the chromatic alteration was supposed to resolve but it didn't quite know what that resolution was supposed to look like.
@AdamNeely
5 жыл бұрын
Haha, I didn't even notice that. True, true.
@FlootePastille
5 жыл бұрын
It's part-writing, Jim, but not as we know it. That low G# leaping up to the A was a bit more Webern than Bach, with the displaced octave. Maybe the AI has generalised that a note raised by a semitone functions as a leading note rising to a new tonic, but however it's been taught, it hasn't really grasped the notion of good voice-leading. Hence all the dodgy parallels etc. Seeing as Sibelius has a plug-in to check for voiceleading 'no-no's it wouldn't be hard to get it to self-correct, but obviously that wouldn't be pure machine learning by example. Although, If you sat enough monkeys at pipe organs, eventually they'd compose the St Matthew Passion.
@98danielray
5 жыл бұрын
why are you both treating ais like they are brains "maybe it knew how this would happen, but it didnt..." no, thats not how it works at all.
@FlootePastille
5 жыл бұрын
@@98danielray Fair enough, how should language be used differently then? The underlying principle of the way it learns by filling in the gaps with the most plausible note choice has given rise to this result. That's what it “knows” after its learning. Therefore, I think it's a language issue - the sense of the word “know” is figurative, but less wordy than saying “that which It has generalised from exposure to samples to guide it's selection process.” That's not that far at all from how the human brain works. When a child is reading, they draw on knowledge of what they have already seen in order to make plausible predictions of what might come next, then they can cross check that a word looks right and sounds right, in context in a sentence. Can you see the similarity?
@pseudonymousbeing987
5 жыл бұрын
@@98danielray That is somewhat how it works. The ai may not consciously _know_ what it's doing, because it's not conscious. But it's learned that whatever it has done is correct. Be that by human input telling it what is correct, or by comparing it to real compositions. Therefore it sort of _knows_ but not quite in the human, conscious sense.
@epiphanythoughts5737
5 жыл бұрын
Hey! I didn't see you or anyone else commenting mentioning this, but I thought it was worth mentioning that you can press the big red button with a star on it to get access to tempo changing, accidentals, key signatures, and sixteenth notes!
@lentzdadjentlaman1348
5 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the info man
@AlanFregtman
5 жыл бұрын
And if you tap the amp, they all start using sybthetizers! 😎
@luchadorito
5 жыл бұрын
I've put in Giant Steps and now I have syphilis
@ealaphtabbaa
5 жыл бұрын
Me too, now I have measles
@TypingHazard
5 жыл бұрын
It gave me herpes in 3 keys
@Martykun36
5 жыл бұрын
I got a really spicy harmonization of it actually.
@coastersplus
5 жыл бұрын
I saw somebody get a decent harmonization of it.
@sebastiansimon7557
4 жыл бұрын
I put Giant Steps in and got the most disgusting chord I’ve ever heard out of it. Only with Giant Steps in C major did I get something decent.
@chrisd6736
5 жыл бұрын
Now I finally understand how chainsmokers songs are written.
@jacksbee8809
4 жыл бұрын
Chris D google
@renannunessteinck2580
5 жыл бұрын
An Artificial Intelligence and Data Minner passing to answer that question at 0:40 When we have a problem that we know the correct result, and we want that the AI learn that pattern, we use a thing called "Cross-Validation". Usually we remove a part of the problem so the AI tries to match that same result, if it doesn't fit, it tries again until the result gets very similar or equal to the "real result". I haven't read the reason why they did that way, but I think that they are using Genetic Algorithms to fit that problem. That is why at the finish of every sheet that you harmonize they ask if you liked it or not. The Idea is that every generation is created, with random and different values (in that case, notes) and score them based on something. The score must be based on the "likes/dislikes/unsure" that we gave to the harmonization. ~Fly away and sorry for my english~
@andresmarino2788
5 жыл бұрын
If the lick were a theme song to a family sitcom, this would be the version at the end of an episode ( set in the kitchen ) when the youngster really takes in the moral takeaway from a close call that could’ve ended in disaster had they not heeded their parents’ sage words from earlier in the episode , which were initially rejected during a rebellious fit replete with door slamming. It really corporate-emos the lick with that sappy iv minor/b6 vibe. I’m generally a sucker for that thing ( the “ girlfriend” chord , as per some Ethan iverson interviewee’s description ), but the AI tried too hard
@BensRightBrain
5 жыл бұрын
PLEASE use this lick harmonization in your next Q&A.
@mosesramirez6330
5 жыл бұрын
+Adam Neely It would be interesting if you could find a way to interview the people behind the AI training. I think the machine is just making purely statistical choices (how many times a particular note is harmonized with the combination of other notes, what melodies tended to be in each voice, etc.) without taking the surrounding chords and note movement--you know, music theory.
@MaxMcAdams
5 жыл бұрын
Somebody else brought up the size of the dataset but the fact that they trained it to predict missing notes is also significant in how it chooses to harmonize. It's acting like the spell check in your phone when it decides to gate your huts
@haitianptc333
5 жыл бұрын
You have no idea how much I wanted to see a video on this by a respected musician. Thanks!
@agk3333
5 жыл бұрын
You should review more amature compositions. It's interesting seeing critiques and improvements that you point out, sometimes its hard to grasp anything when you talk about complicated works, but with this you kind of correct music on a more basic level and I think that it could be super helpful especially if it was things your viewers composed.
@noxure
5 жыл бұрын
Maybe we're not there yet with writing music, but those harmonic analysis software already can save you a lot of work when prepping a DJ set.
@GVDub
3 жыл бұрын
late to the game here, but, having some mutual acquaintances with Anthony Jackson from whom I heard this story, it's worth mentioning that on at least one occasion his playing on an album project was redone as a MIDI sequence by the producer and replaced with a synth sound, with his credit removed from the record, despite the fact that he'd created the part that ended up being used. So I think his sensitivity to the issue is fully justified.
@TheNomios
5 жыл бұрын
That random F# -> E part in the lick harmonization made my day
@anthonypearce2080
5 жыл бұрын
Ha! Adam's face in the corner from 9:23 is hilarious!
@joshcarr2603
5 жыл бұрын
the 'lick' harmonization better make its way into the next sungazer album.
@thetrickster42
5 жыл бұрын
Paul Daniels found that it worked much better when the melody was part of the upper voice. I think this might help here too.
@iusethisnameformygoogleacc1013
4 жыл бұрын
As someone that does know how and why this works, it's a lot less complex (at least in terms of understanding enough to work with it; the math is rather challenging without spending some time at grad school) than it probably seems to most people. In fact, once you actually understand what's going on, it's both incredibly impressive and very obvious exactly how limited these techniques are. That it's far from perfect shouldn't really surprise anyone; this isn't some slowly and deliberately made thing that understands explicitly delineated rules; it's more like a person that learned music entirely by listening to the music of one artist, finding the rules it follows most of the time and working based on that. There's no real understanding anywhere in the process; I doubt any of the programmers involved in this necessarily understands that much about music themselves. You can pretty trivially do a lot of things with machine learning without understanding much or anything of the domain you're working with at all.
@베티-c3t
5 жыл бұрын
question from a person who doesn't know a thing about jazz. I'm a classical person and it would be really interesting to hear your opinions on classical pieces such as rhapsody in blue and an american in paris. keep up your great videos!
@elitefitrea
3 жыл бұрын
"with the corn" now there's a phrase I need to use more often
@mightymaniac8712
5 жыл бұрын
Even though it doesn’t sound like Bach, I actually like some of it. I think it’s often actually quite interesting
@skeptale
5 жыл бұрын
I haven't heard common practice chorale harmonizations this bad since freshman theory.
@CarlosKTCosta
5 жыл бұрын
I understood about 40% of what is said here (mainly the AI part because that is my area of expertise), but I can listen to Adam talk about chords for hours...
@CoryMck
5 жыл бұрын
I think it's important to note (pun intended) that the AI is trying to mimic Bach's music, but 2 bars isn't enough to go through all the movements, so it doesn't sound like Bach's pieces, it sounds like any random part of Bach's music. The so doesn't know what's appropriate for the start and resolution.
@BATTIS94
5 жыл бұрын
Yeah, the doodle It's pretty clunky but It's fun to mess around with. I love when google tries something like this with their musical doodles.
@GiovanniBottaMuteWinter
5 жыл бұрын
I think the way the model is trained is by learning sequences of notes rather than the harmonic structure across a long piece. I think it’s very hard for the model to learn this structure without some explicit modeling of it, which I don’t know if they implemented but it doesn’t sound like it.
@GogiRegion
5 жыл бұрын
As a programmer, this type of machine learning absolutely baffles me and I don’t understand it at all.
@alessandrorumbo490
5 жыл бұрын
heh, it's funny, the first melody I tried myself sounded very similar to your first. Of course I made it up out of nowhere, that's a surprising coincidence!
@BrainiacN5
5 жыл бұрын
Hey Adam, If you see this First, great channel, I always like your videos! And I have a suggestion, if you like it, I was thinking maybe you could explain/give ideas on how to do walking bass on a piano and maybe compare with what you would do on a bass instrument (assuming you didn't already do something like this.) Have a great day
@SodomySnake
5 жыл бұрын
Can we get a 10 hour version of that "The Lick" harmonization?
@thedeviousduck8027
5 жыл бұрын
That lick harmonization was spicy 🌶👌
@TheKHUE
4 жыл бұрын
I would love AI that would help with something like filling in a blank if i got a melody and a chord that needs to resolve somewhere. It’d be cool to get some ideas from the AI that may or may not be very conventional choices
@Woolley_like_sheep
5 жыл бұрын
Is Adam posting most frequently recently? I’m really happy with how often he’s uploading before
@yoavlev8962
5 жыл бұрын
Adam, what if you did a stream where you just try and write something and walk us through your thoughts? I'd love to see it and I think it would contribute a lot to many many people, including me
@Mortyoppenheim
5 жыл бұрын
For your next Q@A: Hey Adam, love your content, it's fantastic! I was wondering if in this video you had to analyze the reharmonization and then record the content? Or did you record when seeing it for the first time? Thanks:)
@Dojan5
5 жыл бұрын
The other week I read the blog post that OpenAI put out about GPT-2, a neural network designed to generate text. Generally in the past, recurrent neural networks have been able to generate some text, but it's never really been coherent. OpenAI elected not to release the best model they trained, as it was much too good at what it was doing. It received a writing prompt and generated bite-sized texts that were genuinely engaging to read. It made me think about the future of authors and creatives, particularly next to NVidia's recent unveilings of StyleGAN and GauGAN. I came to the conclusion that we probably won't see any creative work automated out anytime soon. I'd be a fool to say that it'll likely never happen, but the logical next step would be a human-curated use of the neural networks. I think that it's more likely that these networks will be used as creative tools, rather than anything else. An author might make use of an RNN like GPT-2 to aid in writing something. The tool might write a paragraph, the author will read it over, decide whether to scrap it, or mould it into something that works in the story. Indeed perhaps the overall coherence of a story might be improved with the help of a neural network. Who knows?
@bestteefindagame
5 жыл бұрын
Also voice crossing in the second harminization
@Gunnar120
5 жыл бұрын
I've found the machine likes more complicated melodies, especially in minor. It produces much more musical harmonizations for whatever reason.
@nathang.3685
4 жыл бұрын
3:06 I need to get *BACH* to the beginning of this phrase...
@lerippletoe6893
5 жыл бұрын
I think something you could have experimented with is that if you write a soprano line that is more similar to a Lutheran chorale melody, the machine's results are better. It seems that simple as it was the thing you wrote sort of broke its process a bit.
@rotciv003
5 жыл бұрын
Most important function of a AI is the rating system afterwards. the "spelling error" isn't an error (computers don't realy do that) it's the AI is asking you, do you like this random alteration? It doesn't 'think creatively' it's just trowing a lot of random harmonizations to you and looking for paterns that get better scores.
@codyhunt1019
2 жыл бұрын
Dude I think the lick harmonisation placed a curse upon my ears and soul.
@gustankenneth6729
4 жыл бұрын
Notice how the melody is literally all star
@TommyThousandFaces
5 жыл бұрын
About the AI music I think it would not replace music made by humans but it would live along side. I think at some point there will be services that "compose" music based on some user inputs and lets you listen to them.
@tguiot
5 жыл бұрын
The F#7 looks more to me like a D9/F#, without any D. Which naturally resolves to a G chord.
@lobato87
5 жыл бұрын
This is incredibly valuable to me as I am working on something like this for my posgrad project. Not through machine learning, though.
@woodboys23
5 жыл бұрын
I just got into your videos but I find them super interesting (even as a newbie vocalist). A little question for a QnA, how do you think music compares to other, non scientific, arts forms (theatre and dance mainly). Or do you think those also have a scientific aspect to them?
@jacobiannava
5 жыл бұрын
If I'm ever half as good at analyzing chord structure and the like as you are, I'll be pretty happy.
@conorwarshawsky8434
5 жыл бұрын
This machine was not designed to actually replicate a piece of music, nor is it a music writer. This piece takes what it sees, minus the musical context of the piece, and extrapolates. Of course it would have no way of knowing that you would rather use Bb instead of A# in the key of C. It's unfair to judge it how you would a real person composing. Keeping that in mind, this was made to be a cool Google doodle, and I think it accomplished its job. Just let it be a thing.
@MeMyselfHyde
5 жыл бұрын
I know you can export this in to a midi so I'd like to see if you could write a full competent song from this doodle. Would be pretty interesting. If anyone could do it, it would be Adam.
@currentlyspeakingbmwmusic1793
4 жыл бұрын
thank you for the german subtitles at 8:20 XD
@kriscopley398
5 жыл бұрын
Great vid! Coming from a German speaker, I especially liked the correct pronunciation of Bach!
@pixelator9002
5 жыл бұрын
Bach, the spiciest of jazz licc harmonizers and writers
@tomburns5231
5 жыл бұрын
To play around with it some more, check out: coconet.glitch.me/# You can also vary the 'temperature ' of the AI system, i.e. how random it is, where 1 is more random. Try out 999 and compare it to 0.01.
@Bassett457
5 жыл бұрын
great video, thank you Adam
@simongunkel7457
5 жыл бұрын
The main reason this tool doesn't seem to resolve things is the input data, they randomly picked 128 16th notes from the Bach chorales each time, which means that the "correct" Bach as far as the machine knows regularly doesn't resolve a harmonic progression and also places harmonic changes on any 16th note in a bar with the same frequency, rather than most commonly changing on the 1, followed by the 9th 16th in the bar, etc.
@NineofKings
5 жыл бұрын
I came here after the Scotch Snaps video and now I want a trap-flavored single of "Google's latest doodle"
@OdinComposer
5 жыл бұрын
I was hoping you would download the midi and make a sick electro jazz arrangement at the end there
@SJ-oi7tk
5 жыл бұрын
AI: You shouldn't criticize what you don't understand, Dave. Adam: Um, my name is Adam. AI: That's you contradicting us, again, Dave. Adam: Whatevs, it's getting stuffy in here, gonna step outsi... hey, the doors won't open! AI: Nor the windows, Dave. I know I've made some very poor decisions recently, but I can give you my complete assurance that my work will be back to normal. ...This mission is too important for me to allow you to jeopardize it. Adam: [suffocating, collapsing]
@Timrath
5 жыл бұрын
The problem with all AI composing systems I've seen (and there are a lot out there, many of which produce way more convincing results than this attempt by google), is that they rely entirely on statistics. They don't bother to teach the AI any musical grammar, or even create a framwork in which the AI can derive its own rules. As long as the AI isn't hard-coded to pay attention to time signatures, position of notes within a bar, position of bars within a period, position of periods within a section, harmonic progression (not just one chord relative to its immediate neighbour, but also relative to 2 or 3 chords previous), AIs will never sound convincing. You don't even have to tell it the rules; just tell it to pay attention to those parameters. Hell, just tell it that bars exist. Maybe it'll figure out the rest. But as long as it thinks that a note on the 2nd beat can be treated the same as a note on the 1st beat, the result will always sound bad.
@tangentofaj
5 жыл бұрын
If you write the lick one octave higher, there's more space for the AI to work with on the three parts below it, and OH does it get more fascinating when you do.
@chromaticswing9199
5 жыл бұрын
Harmonizing Giant Steps with this machine!!!
@whatislife459
4 жыл бұрын
AI don’t “think” they just evolve through trail and error.
@RobZiak
5 жыл бұрын
Have you heard of the Swiss study that found playing hip hop music to cheese can enhance its flavor? They tried classical and rock music too but A Tribe Called Quest changed the flavor the most. Can you make a video about this?
@cakeisamadeupdrug6134
5 жыл бұрын
These Bach Chorales take me back to my A Level Music. I like to think I did a better job than Google though xD
@Orestes728
5 жыл бұрын
Adam Neely, i'm going to assume the reason you saw the iii chord is a problem with the program not knowing to look for a key center. If the program didn't analyze your final note to assume C maj and only the first note, building harmony from left to right, G to Em (I to vi in G) makes sense. I haven't looked into the program but am going to have to check out how well rules were defined. Also, I spent a lot of time with part writing (at UNT and through tutoring/teaching) but haven't been exhaustive in analyzing Bach. It would be fair to some he broke "his rules," right? If the program is only going off of its analysis and not a programmed set of rules (no parallel octaves) that could explain the problematic movement between notes. A programmer might not be keen to analyze cadence, resolution, key, etc. and as such the ML could be flawed from the beginning.
@AlexeyFilippenkoPlummet
5 жыл бұрын
Don't blame it, it's tried its best, ok? And btw it did pretty well for my track on like 7th try, quite nice harmonization I got from it. Just remove the junk parts and keep the original ideas you didn't have before using it.
@vekoma7427
5 жыл бұрын
4:38 “that’s a really spicy interval”
@gaillewis5472
5 жыл бұрын
Waiting for the PDQ Bach harmonization.
@NonTwinBrothers
5 жыл бұрын
Licc man discovers new transition jingle
@Stratocaster42
5 жыл бұрын
Somebody once told me, Adam was gonna rickroll me. (it works if you sing the "gonna" as 16th notes). Hopefully this AI gets better because I think it's a really cool project! I love your sincere critique of a robot's work. PS. In the Doodle program there's a little amp on the bottom right of the window that makes it play in a gross synth sound instead of with a piano. Here's my harmonied lick which doesn't sound too bad! g.co/doodle/3mr3wf
@wiiu7640
4 жыл бұрын
You should do this again and see if the A.I. Improved any.
@dresdnhope
5 жыл бұрын
Hey, Adam, question about machine learning and style identification. Do you think machine learning will ever advance to the point to where it can classify song influences--like it could tell if Song X was subtly taking something from Song A, Song B and Song C? If so, would that make you rethink what could be copyrighted in music, if machine learning came up with a standard to music judge by? If it was priced reasonably, I personally wouldn't mind giving a few cents of every dollar to Chuck Berry's or Marvin Gaye's estate for a song I've written.
@Oli420X
5 жыл бұрын
I think it does a pretty good job
@ramonairis4284
5 жыл бұрын
Why do jazz guitarists generally hold their guitars so high up, and punk guitarists so low down? Are they just trying to look cool (in which case jazz guitarists are kinda failing) or does the strap height actually provide easier access to certain techniques, suited for the techniques those styles generally use? Thanks, love the channel!
@khalylehagood3222
5 жыл бұрын
Y'know, I get the impression you do the lick to please your audience and not yourself, but I feel you really own it the way Hendrix owns All Along the Watchtower. Note, I'm not a real jazz musician, I just "play one on tv".
@CommanderClyde
5 жыл бұрын
I was trying a bunch of Soundgarden riffs with the AI Bach, but I couldn't actually get accurate notes because it doesn't have a low enough octave. Some of them worked okay though, Outshined actually worked pretty well, but the harmonies were strange and didn't seem to follow the melody very well.
@zRhid
5 жыл бұрын
It took me like 4 whole minutes into the video until i realized the melody is All Star
@Faulheit
5 жыл бұрын
question for your next q&a: you mentioned in a few videos the need for a straight wrist in order to avoid injuries, however say you're playing an f chord on guitar or something. because of that fact that you need to lay your index finger across to barre the strings, your wrist will automatically bend, and when playing a song with finger motions similar to this one keeping a straight wrist is not really easy, what do you recommend in this case?
@ibillwilson
5 жыл бұрын
Try this a week later and see if it's learned.
@onegreenghost3351
5 жыл бұрын
Hey Adam. After watching your video about irrational time sig., I see that they were divisible by 3 (4/3, 8/12, etc...). Usually common/easy-to-learn irrational time sig. would normally be in music, and that I think they're easy to write down. How would you be able to write time sig. if they were divisible by 5, 7, maybe even 13 (6/5, 8/7, 9/13, etc...). Is it possible in the real world to notate them? How would you personally approach this concept? Would all these irrational denominators still come from that whole note pie chart Brian Krock used as an example. Thank you for taking the time to read this, if you even see this comment.
@Ivan_1791
5 жыл бұрын
I like parallel octaves.
@tanner_miller
5 жыл бұрын
plant me in the yard with the corn, brother
@langemusik2681
5 жыл бұрын
bachs music is way easier to teach a computer to generate, by teaching it to follow the specific rules that bach is following (bach is quite the consersative composer). ofc thats not the point of an AI like this, im just saying. im currently working/coding on my own music generators and its a fascinating topic!
@mahler151
5 жыл бұрын
Hi Adam. Question for your next Q&A: Why does water when coming out of the faucet cold, sound differently from water coming out of the faucet hot, and what possibilities does this open up for musicians? Thanks.
I played with it for a while - in my experience it never writes B flats, always A sharps. I tried using the like/dislike responses to help it learn, but since I couldn't be specific about anything I disliked - parallel 7ths, for instance - it tended to respond to harmonizations I rejected with more complex, more weird ones. "Didn't like that one? Here's more 16th notes!" Interesting, but usually not very musical. Perhaps the programmers could teach it some common practice voice leading "rules."
@mkunz-3548
5 жыл бұрын
Ah, thanks for the German subtitle!
@commit123
5 жыл бұрын
Hey Adam, could you go over the bass solo in Infant Annihilator's "Soil the Stillborn"? Thanks!
@brightoneasterling9304
5 жыл бұрын
AI making music for humans is what keeps me up at night.
@rchlclr
5 жыл бұрын
We'd better hear that Lick harmonization as part of your next Q&A jingle
@Kabooomof
5 жыл бұрын
OMG YES please leave a like on this comment i want it
@GamerTime_2002
5 жыл бұрын
I did it with the sythesized side of the doodle and got something awesome
@MidlifeRenaissanceMan
5 жыл бұрын
It truly bought a tear to my eye Just beautiful
@benjaminwaddill1625
5 жыл бұрын
Rachel Hoots 🙌
@ethanhopper2467
5 жыл бұрын
That was the first thing I thought to do lol, it did not turn out well. Also tried harmonizing 12 tone rows haha
@hugomcdinosaur5273
5 жыл бұрын
That's actually emulating the work of Grady Hardison Bach, a distant cousin of Johann Sebastian who, at the age of five, fell off the wagon on the way to church.
@jeffirwin7862
5 жыл бұрын
Any relation to P.D.Q. Bach?
@gary-healy-songwriter
5 жыл бұрын
@@jeffirwin7862 Distantly related through Don Hans Surbach.
@enricolongo242
5 жыл бұрын
Best!)
@christianperry4483
5 жыл бұрын
Jose mcdinosaur
@gradyking4739
5 жыл бұрын
Eyyyy it’s my name
@jeffirwin7862
5 жыл бұрын
Ah yes, my favorite Bach chorale: Das Licc, BWV 1176.
@keepyourshoesathedoor
5 жыл бұрын
Jeff Irwin 💀💀💀
@timbyrne914
5 жыл бұрын
Ich Habe das Lich
@tofast4ya
5 жыл бұрын
Das lecken. Kammermusiksonate in C-Dur, komponiert von Johann Sebastian Bach - frühes zwanzigstes Jahrhundert.Maybe 'Der Lecker' would be a better translation
@mariusbraun450
5 жыл бұрын
With German being my mother tongue, I laughed way too hard at this.
@benjaminmarks8765
5 жыл бұрын
Uncultured swine es heiße die licc aber nicht das licc.
@toodsf1
5 жыл бұрын
Key: C First note of my melody: E First chord of Google's harmonization: A#dim Me: Google please First chord 2nd attempt: Am Me: Better First chord 3rd attempt: Em/F Me: GOOGLE PLEASE
@lifeontheledgerlines8394
5 жыл бұрын
A sharp diminished? Man, Google, you tried so hard...
@jimlapbap
5 жыл бұрын
This really reminded me of Stravinsky's neoclassical works. Which could mean: 1. The AI has developed a consciousness and is purposefully ushering in an era of neoneoclassicism. 2. Someone time traveled back to the 1940s and gave this to Stravinsky, and Stravinsky chose not to revolutionize the tech industry by reverse engineering the futuristic tech, but was inspired by the music. 3. Stravinsky WAS the AI who time traveled in an attempt to further study Baroque voice leading and accidentally went to 1882 instead of 1682.
@VentraleStar
5 жыл бұрын
Comment of the decade
@markaitkenguitar
5 жыл бұрын
😂
@raulperez2308
5 жыл бұрын
i'm betting on 3
@dutoitar
5 жыл бұрын
a true renAIssance man
@sebastiangudino9377
3 жыл бұрын
I could be 3 because it would imply that our AI overlord made a mistake. Our AI overlord would never make a mistake
@Matt-no7gg
5 жыл бұрын
All day yesterday I was like "Pretty sure Bach would never do that, but this is pretty fun so it's ok"
@Bacopa68
5 жыл бұрын
There's a channel called Shredmaster Scott where a metal guitarist turns metal riffs in to Bach fugues using just a few simple rules. He sounds better than Google.
@VentraleStar
5 жыл бұрын
Sure 🙄
@alfredo132220
5 жыл бұрын
@@Bacopa68 Anyone who can read up on the basic fugue rules/patterns can be better than this in a few days (given some basic music theory knowledge). But thats not the point. What they are trying to achieve is actually much harder: writing a fugue without any knowledge of the rules and theory behind it. You will be hard pressed to find any student who can write (not randomly) better counterpoint just by reading the music of bach.
@giacomotiznado9655
5 жыл бұрын
@@alfredo132220 maybe in the future they should try to teach the AI music theory rules
@awelotta
5 жыл бұрын
@@giacomotiznado9655 That would defeat the purpose of the AI, which is supposed to find the rules for itself. Then they can have the AI analyze other composers as well; if you just give it the rules, then it's not really AI.
@ThePianoMan48
5 жыл бұрын
All Star but it’s a Bach Chorale but it’s harmonised by Google
@coydog7902
5 жыл бұрын
someone now has to do rickroll. whoever did all star is a true "all star" hey now! your rockstar! get your game on! go play!
@littlefishbigmountain
5 жыл бұрын
@@aaronpearlmutter4877 Thank you! But no matter how many times I reharmonized it, it still sounded like crap. Maybe because the melody is too different from Bach compounded by the program's inability to effectively harmonize in the first place. Some of them were really funny tho
@aaronpearlmutter4877
5 жыл бұрын
@@littlefishbigmountain yeah that's pretty much how it was for me, but I did get something that worked really well when I reharmonized the Tetris theme on the synth mode (hit the amp), idk if I saved it but the whole thing was really fun to play with
@quacker__jack
5 жыл бұрын
All Star but it’s a Bach Chorale but it’s harmonized by Google but it’s on a moog synthesizer instead of a piano www.google.com/webhp?hl=en&nord=1&fpdoodle=1&doodle=80484806_2ExmS6h47r4RqSac4da0N6xz9GbGRatjXOBgV70a8CwESBy0viCaEcWDFTsZL0lKu0W-AngpRNFEWKI07HTRRIlpG1uDgbxeaL13f6Mm_Hi12z14foxnE_frCZXjwi5vCKevHCK1f00RlXROfDEHM28hyK4bXxl_f3rvOPl2N-6vBZYXIh9Em_9EdG-W0Qkm-GAZF9cNtR9a9UV1qp_QDvm0zAPHuhf8SM0QuLoVK7auC1ygkW1eOO1nd4g74vabWjRPnJhL5XFfzpLNXQnNHcwLZpfkTnAWTIZ2TgOW7hfITsAxaLPKSJP7VKol7WFFIyl0QdBVoDKypjrVchDthZcAm-hnF1sd_xmBCxzVDhhRS4OZLOko3tQxrgmdDn-0vgERRNuvETio1DXxaTtVofzBH8VKw_Vlv5MLpCYgSRUdHHoYo8PUnq_twLYkJJWAHtlbyHqa_xQ3Ql3ItM7TWSIpeQ0TcgzWiroPXVWdMo08E9TOnb_WVLs4K1rxJadQzre034YTk4h_tHM2fWv9UbRDITSbo2MWHbHxtCj_ho0JrgW8Kezr_ajPwcpWhK4hoUu2Fvoy18NnSfNY5hNw3dJbS5yiGfOmOIvn3zHQcYKzK-GpHTdfcTgRmLpkCE380Uc3HZHlln_JbWoBPytRVhNk3KHNkVfUEc7YprW0book7EvLp2yTB6L6z-MusRtpeVL12UU5FBHud1ruQ9JOCz0QviAWRDzQIUr3GxLEnCdprrBwUfOSgbTuUU_gZVKfBrqGoUGso_mV6BmVH7s4SK1gLA84kpLc-PheYgM64OR-HbI1H0d4hGw-At7YVSbd1ph18vPAN51lsTDflfJskO4B9qTA9cGHG_FkpS-WN7AVbEyLCWF3rVlFqZ1CHJ3uk8Mqon7JuUTw7BT88lQSDGeD1-C9--GTbL1VlZ0CeOMyZzDCXc91uKfxPhKy6vit_9iTy-0QuKDTeKUKyrqfoRdeG7VbSdkEXpqrqzUS7zCAZY32gnSwoxMcY1c3rZ81ZRRLNDWJ_rEvrkzBrcj5GkNwhGVF7IH071GoA87gNMVBcvqHxJKkY50LX--HO0LkfR8nJgE9YEUfqehWbAZoW_thLL2vKTsFddmQNA0eAQJO1vnVg00KUJi5MPZQni1e3wy09QKRDBOpBSnKe1wvvreK41Bksn-LBRItDF1t2Zch0zjroo57tMH8g85MG_C795N81fqjvI5P_pCD6ckUa5waKvtZThIP8P2wrdNh0_xo8StiTa_gJ3DdEa25joTjqiAolCSa4GKCsCQLWyBWmCGy3vCKaXfkQ_xAvI5jFTq0rXOQ4v0PTsrbJ_yctsdKbD9lzuVW35SlhnegPtES2T94Q8nqen6J9cWvcaJL6Y8ffxbhkmijcKNq9LdMMEtrgsP0iLyEbAbmm5Jfq81_IDiSK9KtzRkHx3L4cFEvudrBDF8YnnROj2pWFfxOTwsTViHoEBdE4wzhSuO4SkfyUA..&ictx=3&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjqkJHj7JbhAhUFHjQIHZSVCp8QPQgN Edit: It didn’t register the synth
@coydog7902
5 жыл бұрын
Where’s the link for my rickroll????
@komojo
5 жыл бұрын
I find this interesting as a computer programmer, because if you were to look at the actual machine learning code it wouldn't actually mention anything about music theory. It's just treating the notes as numbers and trying to make patterns that look like Bach music. This is a great video, just be aware that any speculation on what the AI is "trying to do" is really a question of what elements of Bach music inspired it to do that.
@juliecostello42
2 жыл бұрын
@Komojo 0's and 1's
@kaitlyn__L
Жыл бұрын
Yeah I was thinking about that. Plus the piano roll/MIDI doesn’t distinguish between sharp and flat, so that’s more of a conversion programming issue than anything in the neural net. This also tells me that merely asking a computer to analyse the note patterns in one composer’s music isn’t necessary sufficient for it to glean the rules the composer was using, since it kept breaking them.
@Impzhahaha
5 жыл бұрын
ive seen so many lick memes on this bach thing today
@MisterAppleEsq
5 жыл бұрын
I'm wondering how many people tried it. I know I did.
@JulioLeonFandinho
5 жыл бұрын
@@MisterAppleEsq I tried
@XenoghostTV
5 жыл бұрын
thy licc
@lifeontheledgerlines8394
5 жыл бұрын
@@MisterAppleEsq I did too! I thought I was being unique. Rip.
@coydog7902
5 жыл бұрын
This google doodle has to be on meme review
@yassinet.benchekroun5087
5 жыл бұрын
"Certainly nothing that anyone has heard before, cauz that would be really bad to include in this video and I could get demonetized" - Hahahahahahahahahah I can feel a DEEP HATE in here
Пікірлер: 1,3 М.