My own personal views on this : Do you guys think nostalgia is making us vote for girls generation? Nope, I personally would vote for girls generation because I know they produce music that fits their demographics. Forever 1 sounds almost similar to something they would put out in previous decades- somewhere in between lion heart and holiday. So I think that them sticking to what their fan bases love, but also combining that element of nostalgia to know that- hey my idols are thriving, even though they aren’t in their teens anymore- makes me happy to still see them do what they love and have a passion to come back as a group for more. They deserve to win, especially if we consider that most music today (not saying that kpop idols in 4th gen aren’t talented), sounds quite similar to each other. There’s no huge differences between them. Would into the new world work as a debut? I’m gonna be honest, and say that I disagree with guy with the hat. As much as I love Into the new world, the time period for this piece led to incredible success. We have to remember that this song not only demonstrates a type of messaging that inspired many generation of idols to strive for their dreams, but also that many elements in it are a bit more retro than todays taste. This song came out when girls groups were just barely starting to become a new thing- it provides hope for these girls as they were an industry where popularity was given more to guy groups. If girls generation debuted this song once again ( a whole new start- nobody even knows who they are), it might not have as much of an increase of popularity as current groups. Snsd set many trends for girl groups and was a huge part of hallyu wave, starting from scratch in 2024 might pose a difficulty for many of their songs (as they are a bit more retro and sounding to their respective Years). I’m not saying they wouldn’t succeed or do well, because knowing snsd, they are more than capable to become new artists, but what I am saying is that into the new world (if just reposted in 2024), would probably not gain as much traction. Especially since with this newer generation, we have so many girl groups that aspire the same wants. The message, while strong, I feel like would be lost to the millions of girl groups that don’t receive the attention they deserve today. Plus, if you know snsd, you know that the way they talk and socialize with each other and other idol groups is way different than how a newbie group socializes today. I wouldn’t say they would be cancelled, but ima be dead honest and say that people may not like their humor as much for a newbie group.
@FloptropicanPresident
5 ай бұрын
Saying newjeans isn’t modern sounding when they literally just trendhopped with the rise of pinkpantheress and dnb.
@folkloreevermore2797
5 ай бұрын
True. And I heard some bunnies said pink pantheress sound like newjeans lmao wtf😂😂😂
@BoscoBosker
5 ай бұрын
@@folkloreevermore2797that’s a good one 😂 but hey, that’s how the pop scene has always been. You see the trend and give it your best shot at following it while adding your own twist on it. Even Twice has a new record that sounds like PinkPantheress literally produced. 😂 You adapt and if you are talented enough, your group evolves and stays relevant through all the trends.
@folkloreevermore2797
5 ай бұрын
@@BoscoBosker true
@ssj-rose4572
5 ай бұрын
Girls gen can probably out sing and 4 and 5th but they will definitely have to learn to dance again
@yuugael4010
5 ай бұрын
Againts gen 5 maybe its not as establish so I don't know, against the 4th gen though no. 4th gens are filled with giants because gen 4 is what I called the mainstream era of Kpop which is different compare gen 3 where its in the transitioning era (Blackpink and twice bringing western and global attention) this is due to things like social media (tiktok virality imagine cupid), 4th gen having established fandom (Izone separating into IVE one of the biggest in Korea being beloved by all age groups & Lesserafim which is in a non stop promotion from their debut) another thing talking about Lesserafim is the companies SM in gen 4 although big (Aespa) isn't as dominant as it was especially compare to other companies like hybe which rn hold both NJ and Lesse and of course BTS, so no GG will probably hit it big but won't be the monster as it was.
@SERIOUSLEE774
5 ай бұрын
new fans are pathetic. 4th gen is just disappointment because they can't drive the market that 3rd and 2nd already built. 3rd gen is just pretty much 2nd gen copycat nothing more. Snsd is the most loaded girl group ever. They were everywhere, they run every tv show. Each comeback they always show something totally new concept. Thats why they call them the blueprint of kpop because they are the OG. If they are debut in this era they will eat everything
@thanussongprasart2568
5 ай бұрын
The guy is full on Bias. ‘Into the new world’ needs the arrangement to make it work in this day and age. Newjeans using 00s theme for some, not all, of their visual cue, but not 00s sounds, story telling or even song structure.
Пікірлер: 9