I found myself captivated by each of your perspectives. Your collective insights have been incredibly enlightening. I've learned a great deal from your discussions. Your thoughtful analysis and valuable advice are truly commendable. Thank you all four of you.
@sajipaul1253
2 ай бұрын
Dear Kapil Sibel Congratulations for having such wonderful discussions with great minds across sectors. So many suggestions are made in these discussions. My suggestion is that you should bring all these ideas and suggestions out in the open through local language newspapers & radio programs so that it will reach the majority of people and they will start demanding for all these things to be implemented by the government ( both central & state). Please continue the good work you are doing👍🏻
@meashishh
2 ай бұрын
As always, enriching, exciting, enthralling, energizing and educating discussion at "Dil Se". This should be broadcast to Parliamentarians sitting in both Houses of Parliament and all MPs urged, if not forced, to emulate both spirit and manner of discussion in this series. Profound sense of respect for all panelists and the host. Thank you!
@vinod2915
2 ай бұрын
thank you Kapil sisal for doing this .. unlike most KZitemrs, who do it for money .. I dont think thats where your intentions are .. keep educating the country and me ..
@viswaghosh1
2 ай бұрын
One should also clearly mention that demonetisation was also a trickery. Only a fool will withdraw 500 and 1000 denomination notes and replace them with HIGHER denomination of 2000 notes. TO CURB BLACK MONEY ONLY A ULTIMATE STUPID PERSON WILL PERSON WILL CIRCULATE HIGHER DENOMINATION NOTES AFTER WITHDRAWING LOWER DENOMINATION NOTES! This is the fundamental flaw apart from the fact that demonetisation destroyed the MSME sector.
@vivekns1
2 ай бұрын
Thanks
@pritpalsingh5392
2 ай бұрын
Kapil ji This Budget has everything for the Corporate friends, China, something for Bihar and Andhra Pradesh and nothing of substance for the rest of the Country. New schemes to bleed the poor and the middle class have been proposed by way of increasing the tax burden, relief in direct tax is neutralised by subtle increase in indirect taxes. Shrewd but cunning and cooked.
@vpkreddykusumanchi
2 ай бұрын
@@pritpalsingh5392 then why to pay the tax from our state
@pritpalsingh5392
2 ай бұрын
@@vpkreddykusumanchi Sir, your comment is sketchy, kindly elaborate. I believe that taxes should be paid, but taxes should be levied judiciously keeping in mind the financial condition of the population to be taxed. When the Government loses connect with the common man,then an unrealistic and backbreaking tax regime comes into force.
@ShahulHameed-bv8om
2 ай бұрын
last word be '' crooked ''
@pritpalsingh5392
2 ай бұрын
@@ShahulHameed-bv8om Thank you sir, but you got the message. Thanks again.
@shubhamchande4360
Ай бұрын
💯💯
@PrasantaDatta-y1j
2 ай бұрын
Rural people are the backbone of India and this suggestion of emphasis on rural investment must be the priority for solving employment. Thank you.
@shrabonibabu
2 ай бұрын
Great discussion. Loved listening to Mrs Ghosh. She had been so crisp in her expressions and complete.
@mariamdaisy1719
2 ай бұрын
Shahanshah has distributed halwa to A1&a2 and a few more plus for his foreign tours and photoshoots
@bluefly1
2 ай бұрын
Double A variant😅
@manojoza2609
2 ай бұрын
better than to scamsters during UPA1 & 2.
@arjunlahiri8317
2 ай бұрын
Do you'll think that the India Alliance would ever be able to bring the funds percolating into the PM Care Fund and also the cash rich BCCI, under the purview of the Auditor General of India???
@sitanshurai892
2 ай бұрын
Very important questions. Both have to be independently audited, apart from many corporate giants we know.
@ivanlobo397
2 ай бұрын
Thanks for Himanshu's clarity.
@AapkaArunendra
2 ай бұрын
Nobody knows the ground reality. Sarpanch in villages get around Rs 5000 a month. Now, at such a low salary, they have arrangement with village people who will share 50% of their MANREGA income with the Sarpanch and don't do any work as assigned by MANREGA. Many such ground issues need solving along with the macro problems.
@b.k.choudhary6443
2 ай бұрын
Wonderful panel discussion on problems and solutions , so comprehensive it is.❤
@sharonrobert4324
2 ай бұрын
Truly awe-inspiring, just something I really enjoy watching. 😊
@rajuiyer6753
2 ай бұрын
Nice discussion. Ms. Ghosh and Mr. Arun kumar are always interesting but I was impressed by Mr. Himanshu.
@sarasumayya3839
2 ай бұрын
Thank you for the brilliant discussion which gave us some simple basic solutions to our economic problems.
@ritumukundan2280
2 ай бұрын
Should senior citizens beyond the age of 75 and also retired people not be spared of taxes ? Instead of us subsidising the industrialists , they should be taxed so that seniors and pensioners are spared heavy taxation. Today it is the other way around. Budgets always spare industrialists…
@apooru241
2 ай бұрын
The country needs. Industrialists more than industrialist need the country
@zenith808
2 ай бұрын
@@apooru241 as top earners, should we pander to industrialists and go soft on them?
@VijayPawar-sz6gq
2 ай бұрын
Thanks for having such Stalwarts including ur kindself....❤
@J_indian
2 ай бұрын
Tku sir for this excellent discussion with a panel of brilliant minds. The key area that needs top priority is creating "Demand for goods and services" and the govt.must come forward in boosting the rural economy & supporting the SME's, MSME's & small units as that is where massive jobs can be created. Resource mobilisation can come by taxing the rich & super rich through wealth tax, inheritance tax etc.
@pwaghmare1258
2 ай бұрын
This is amazing. thank you.
@soyebganja8632
2 ай бұрын
Thank you sir ji ❤
@SarvajitChakravarti
2 ай бұрын
Widen the direct tax net. Growth cannot happen by taxing only 1.6 percent of the population. I pay the same slab rate of 30% on my GoI pension as Messrs Adani, Ambani, et al. With GST on top, my cash in hand is only 17% of my last pay drawn. After retirement, household expenses rise as all perks are withdrawn. So how can we pensioners run our households?
@jackreacher4945
2 ай бұрын
Any economy will flourish when labor gets paid well and at the same time cost of manufactured goods and services go down. The government needs to focus on decreasing the cost of manufacturing excluding labor, and then force the industry both organized and unorganized to pay their labor well. Government should focus on reducing energy costs, optimizing supply chains, reduce wastage, increase agricultural productivity and remove red-tape.
@3123AJ
2 ай бұрын
Excellent discussion....thank you for enriching us...
@zenith808
2 ай бұрын
As someone from an educational background, we MUST have better trained teachers, we MUST build more schools so that teachers have no more than 40 students per class and we MUST revamp subjects taught to prepare our children for current global trends.
@AapkaArunendra
2 ай бұрын
Many teachers in villages are either not teaching properly or not attending schools every day! They are not properly trained as well!
@Suhas.
2 ай бұрын
Fantastic discussion especially Arun ji.
@soumyajeetchakrabarty6872
2 ай бұрын
Pleas have more of these educated discussions
@shashidharanm5553
2 ай бұрын
Nice discussion
@shubhamchande4360
Ай бұрын
There should be more of such discussions . Please And in my opinion taxes in stock market should be based on income tax the individual pays and the stinking rich who invest should be heavily taxed according to their wealth.
@srinivasd921
2 ай бұрын
Very humble
@devindersharma9921
2 ай бұрын
With a such high knowledgeable and eminent debate members, where will the FM Setharaman stand. As with Modi and his cabinet most are intellectual pedestrians, but experts in politicking and wrangling.
@rachnagupta8346
2 ай бұрын
Excellent discussion. Kapil Sibal sir should do programs on Urdu poetry. He has wonderful voice… would be great to hear him on poetry. 😊
@sapamsubhangker7267
2 ай бұрын
Kapil ,Manipur is A Forgotten State , Manipur Conflict Cross 470 Days Old, Still 60,000 IDPs Are Staying At The Relief Camp ,Two Time Flood ,Hailstrom in The Year 2024 ,But Forgotten To Mention Special Package in The Budget 2024 .
@mbponnappa9464
2 ай бұрын
Speaking is Easy - Doing is Tuff 😸
@samson13ng
2 ай бұрын
Yes it is. But these people are not ordinary people. They have achieved so much in their fields. Just give them an opportunity and they will show what they can do.
@aviraljanveja5155
2 ай бұрын
Not Sure how one set of economists, the ones who work with Government praise the budget and are obviously part of the team that developed it. Whereas the other side such as in this discussion call it bad. These isolated discussions won't help anymore. You should have both parties on the same stage, so that the viewer can get a more compete picture. Or else there is just complete disagreement and no one willing to engage with the other side.
@sitanshurai892
2 ай бұрын
Do you have to say anything about the content of the discussion, the ideas put forth and refute the actual criticism put here or you just don't understand enough to do so? If it's the latter, as it seems to be, please refrain from side, inane commentary especially moralising.
@virenrathore3191
2 ай бұрын
Also do you guarantee the safety of the other side ! ? It's enough that what is being said here. Pay attention and apply your intellect to what you see ..... Otherwise you will continue to see the bad situation and Dhoklam situation move to Dhokla area. May you live long and enjoy your swing in Sabaramati
@anthonyjudith491
2 ай бұрын
Sir we really appreciate that you are man of great knowledge. First you and your companion should take serious action on electon commission and the ruling party on the fraud done on the election towards the 79 seats.
@sareshn
2 ай бұрын
👏💯👏💯👏💯 Very informative session
@avnishpanwar9502
2 ай бұрын
One thing to be asked is that if the budget was for bihar, andhra people or for the politicians of those states? Because a principled budgetary allocation for the states would be effective otherwise useless.
@mohammedmurtaza3257
2 ай бұрын
Very Insightful... Thank you Sirs...
@nawalkishorpanday6262
2 ай бұрын
When a large section of the society, particularly a society having low licime, face uncertain future, the demand will suffer badly. People will just save whatever they can.
@ravindranmokkilmaruthur23
2 ай бұрын
If all economists are laid end to end they will never reach a conclusion. George. Bernard Shaw.
@ABBartan
2 ай бұрын
That is a nice quote. Except Shaw was a Fabian socialist himself, and he was referring to the dominant neoclassical economists who would keep supporting capitalism despite its repeated failures (the world wars and the great depression in that time). This applies more to the economists whom the Modi government employs to window dress its failures.
@arunardhanari9342
2 ай бұрын
Such debates by intellectuals is so important. I always wonder, Why in Modi Government we donot have even one good qualified Doctorate degree holders as ministers in respective sectors. Indians are leading companies all over the world, giving great ideas and implementing them. Why we donot have such people as ministries in government. The answer may be politics. Why not hire talented people and let the politicians rule as emperors and get the appreciation.
@jayaramprabhu5595
2 ай бұрын
VISHWA GURU doesn't want to consult any expert on economics & finance. 😊
@srinivasd921
2 ай бұрын
Good speaker
@vinita6856
2 ай бұрын
GBU JOURNALISTS WARRIORS 🙌 💓 💖
@JaiSahu-cf4mw
2 ай бұрын
A person earning 15 lac annually will pay 30% tax (4.5 Lac) to drive in a pothole, in poor hospital, schools and air pollution. Master stroke by Chaiwallah FM 😢
@mehulsingh1202
2 ай бұрын
in India with a usd 3000 per capita forceful formalization of economy will never ever work. Micro business tax reliefs and empowerment is the only way to produce demand. To produce financing the govt will have to think out of the box than thinking of innovative means of taxing the common populace. Else the common people being taxed hold 1 billion votes and they will reject through vote, This end needs to be realized and solutions created accordingly.
@shankaranjayaraman1155
2 ай бұрын
Even the senior citizens concession has been stop it from Railway. Which is
@stanleyfrederick2931
2 ай бұрын
Other countries' tax rates maybe higher but they give it back to their citizens through every service imaginable, viz. education, health, civil amenities, you name it.
@AjSugi
2 ай бұрын
I don't understand why Gov doesn't raise Minimum wage for unskilled labour, fixed minimum wage for graduate, engineering job. Basically what I am saying we should need fixed minimum wage in different job sectors like engineers, ITIs, delivery, drivers, domestic workers, cooked.
@nabarunchowdhury734
2 ай бұрын
Why don't these economists make their own alternative budget and then compare ...
@arunmishra4285
2 ай бұрын
Did u all read the budget n understand it?
@navinsardana5480
2 ай бұрын
Sorry to say....This conversation is nothing but text book economics which does not work in real life. Firstly the criticism is identical of what we used to hear when the UPA was in power. Secondly its all very well to say put money in the hands of the weaker sections to create demand. The money will go down the shute and will have to be written off just like Corporate loans have been written off. The banks which are finally out of the mess will once again jump from the frying pan into the fire. I want to ask Mr Sibal why the UPA Govt did not solve the employment problem when they were in power for 10 years? Why did the UPA not implement MSP when they were in Govt. ? The UPA also has alot to answer for instead of just passing the buck to the NDA.
@ujjwalkishore1888
2 ай бұрын
Arun ji’s comments can even make a non bjp voter to vote for them…in todays time one cant be so anti capitalism
@lalade3443
2 ай бұрын
This discussion should be included in the compulsory core curriculum of bhaktgan and their upper echelon 😂😂😂😂
@sydiptos
2 ай бұрын
What do you think about puting tax on farmers having more than 50 lacs annual income through agriculture without paying any direct taxes??
@gautamsen4195
2 ай бұрын
Public sectors used to build skills. By destroying them skills are lost.
@mehulsingh1202
2 ай бұрын
Sirs - Savigny's philosophy - what gives the people joy and their customs is the legitimate law. the 90% percentile absolute employment and demand creator is the Indian economy is the micro or super micro business, they need tax relief support and empowerment. If they have more disposable income, demand and employment would be an automatic result. Raising farmers + micro business disposable income.
@tinkeringdavid
2 ай бұрын
Karthik Muralidharan was missed deeply.
@progyandas9650
2 ай бұрын
Kapil Sibal , one of the architects of privatisation of the education sector during UPA era .
@Jayanthsanthosh
2 ай бұрын
The budget expose that BJP has no clue about what can be done to bring the economy back on track.
@mayankw9047
2 ай бұрын
Thing is these are all Ideal scenarios which should be followed if there was no resistance from the corporate sector and ultra wealthy. Govt will follow the least resistive path whenever making such decisions for the budget, and who resists the least? The common tax paying citizen. There needs to be a discussion about breaking the viscous cycle where these politicians and crony capitalists thrive off of each other. Fix the problem at the very core and everything else will follow through.
@mohankrishnakrishna3265
2 ай бұрын
Dear Sir, the highest tax evaders in this country are the government officials who are amassing properties worth 1000s of crores, even a small time clerk is able to earn 2 lakh rupees per month and no tax is being paid. You people are not discussing it.
@shrestaassociates4063
2 ай бұрын
Today RBI has said that all clerical posts will get reduced ...
@kusumjagtiani6680
2 ай бұрын
Tku for throwing a great big white light on the tricks this govt. Is playing on the unfortunate, long suffering Indian. With the way things are going downhill & the prices uncontrollabe things are ( if not already ) going to get out of control. Maybe Nero is still playing the fiddle or whatever instrument he played !
@kitchu1964
2 ай бұрын
Taxing the salaried class more and more like income as well as gst where they will go for their day today requirements with this much of inflation. The salaried people are not able to manage in these kind of multiple taxes.
@priyavksingh4187
2 ай бұрын
Not enough discussion about corporate income tax
@harinarayana8739
2 ай бұрын
Please speak something about the capital gain tax.
@dwightdabreo7478
2 ай бұрын
The very fact that the rich are getting richer and the poor poorer, common sense points to a tax structure that’s not fair.more money in the hands of tax payers will increase spending , and the demand for good and services will also go up, thereby creating more jobs.
@vasanthakumari-f5x
2 ай бұрын
We have discussed it at very begining of the 2016 that is first of modi-era. The request of forming again planning commission is not accepted. Now Kerala implimented as anti- corporate thesis. Development and investments done in health, education& reformed agriculture sector. Also tax reforms are also sugested by anti thesis and cooperatism should be retained under state subject. Stock market is syriging out the last drop from the middle income groups. That gambling sector is totally on collapse even in crony capitalist sector as it is reached the saturation. The problem solving is our prime motto and we reduced poverty to .45% Moreover we have promoted msme s and kudumbasree s Educational sector reforms has good hilight under ICT and artificial intelligence. The governance have a systamatic path under the great leadership.
@manujkdagar
2 ай бұрын
👏🏻
@virenrathore3191
2 ай бұрын
We are not listening .... 😂
@udayprakashsoni6304
2 ай бұрын
Kapil is doing wonderful job through these interviews!
@shrestaassociates4063
2 ай бұрын
Private sector needs to earn money not charity.
@birkaransingh6392
2 ай бұрын
In terms if businesses i think B2C e-invoicing will bring in the right amount if tax
@adarshr.k1969
2 ай бұрын
Someone suggested corporate tax on revenue as against profits. I'm wondering if they have any knowledge on how business runs.
@joaquimfernandes2369
2 ай бұрын
Kapil sir, Equity is the only hope for middle class. You want it to be increased more like in the west? Do we get services like in the west????
@matildalobo7267
2 ай бұрын
0.25 PC of Gdp.unbelievable. Wneh the Apka sevaks can go abroad for treatment at the tax player's money, why will they bother about common man?
@royrand8521
2 ай бұрын
Shrewd. Yes. Cunning. For sure. Devious. Who doubts that? Intelligent ? Uh oh ! Arrogant ? Ignorant ?...
@RichardHicks-sv9vk
2 ай бұрын
Why don't they wait for there turn to talk
@pun757
2 ай бұрын
Katakhat katakhat needed for short term.
@Thenobelfan
2 ай бұрын
What a ridiculous conversation , they are advocating increasing tax … including wealth tax and why do people then leave India … why should people work for a government for 30% of the time
@Dogmatix-24
2 ай бұрын
Since human intelligence has failed our FM may be she should use AI to formulate the budget.😊
@ravindranmokkilmaruthur23
2 ай бұрын
It is clearly a budget .It has got lot of numbers- George Bush
@Life.is.a.library
2 ай бұрын
In india there are many who still do not have any idea how bad the demonetization was for our economy, and poor implementation of GST also.
@ravisubhramanian8999
2 ай бұрын
Why should rich pay tax when there you are giving it as freebies . Don't you think you are promoting laziness and bringing down the overall productivity
@m.kumarjana7643
2 ай бұрын
Hoe long a system can survives without caring for science and educational
@SarvajitChakravarti
2 ай бұрын
Why is India the only country in the world that does not know how to tax agricultural income? What is the point of taxing GoI pensions? There is no surplus for investment or consumption led growth
@dayaprahlad6951
2 ай бұрын
Hello! The reason why agri income is not taxed is because most farmers are producers and not businessmen. They cannot control prices. Its the govt which limits prices in agrimarkets to keep consumers happy. In a bumper crop year, the prices are low and in a bad crop year there is not enough to cover losses. More over exports are also stopped. to overcome scarcity And dear friend, for every good crop year there may be four bad years. Factor in climate change too
@apooru241
2 ай бұрын
@@dayaprahlad6951 every business sees cycles of profit and loss.. thats not excuse .. Agri tax should be above 10cr annual income.. this has become a way to hide black money
@shrestaassociates4063
2 ай бұрын
Even teachers hide privatevtuition money
@engbio6920
2 ай бұрын
😊
@ilangkumarkumar377
2 ай бұрын
5 trillion economy not achieved yet as promised by this Jumla team. What happened to that?
@dhallvinod
2 ай бұрын
MoSha are highly accomplished Politicians: Saam, Daam Dand Bhed, is used unabashedly. And being Gujarati they are skilled in collecting Daam, which can ONLY be provided by the Rich. Who in turn work on quid pro quo. Aam Aadmi including the panel (except Sibal Saheb) can only dish out "morality". The System is now fulky skewed : Needs overhaul. Who will bell the cat?? Ram bhajo, bhai...
@abhisheikdeo
2 ай бұрын
Very nicely done!
@thambinelloore7795
2 ай бұрын
India is now the capital of poorest of the poor 😢😢😢
@mystifyingdude
2 ай бұрын
BJP is certainly loosing steam, but do not see congress gaining any steam. Nothing to help middle class. Even in this discussion.income tax has to be completely abolished.
@shrestaassociates4063
2 ай бұрын
Chk whether nimmy really studied in JNU
@milonbhattacharya4097
2 ай бұрын
please ask sibal how much tax did his firm pay this year
@shanmugampn4571
2 ай бұрын
Paid troll cooly perfectly working
@ijstoor5610
2 ай бұрын
SIR UNLESS AGRICULTURE IS MADE PROFITABLE AND VIABLE EMPLOYMENT WILL REMAIN PROBLEM FOR AGES TO COME INDIA OR BHARAT CULTURALLY TYPOGRAPHICALLY SOCIALLY CLIMATIC ALY WE ARE RELIGIOUS LY ATTACHED TO MATTI OR MITTI IAM RETD ARMY OFFR FEEL IF A YOUNG MAN CAN EARN 50 60 TH A MONTH AGRI INCOME WILL NOT ASK FOR NOKARI
@rajeshsolankiusa
2 ай бұрын
The budgwt is only worth the cost of paper or cloud file upload. Nothing will happen and no one will be held accountable because its SHADOW drama
Пікірлер: 181