Thats the issue with video game adaptions when sometimes lesve stuff out many fans just automatically know what happens even when they dont see it for fans it feels odd but they know what happens but for a new comer it can make them get very confused
@unkillerrise8688
9 ай бұрын
great video. snake, keep up the great content. like those videos of yours. your reviewing style for adaptation materials is always through and well searched. props
@Vegitodraws
9 ай бұрын
You should do a parallel plots with the Lizard and Man Bat
@josepbuigues1336
8 ай бұрын
What's next? Are you going to do a review of the persona 1 manga next?
@The4thSnake
8 ай бұрын
I don't have much interest in P1, generally.
@heroicgangster9981
8 ай бұрын
Nah the thief in Futaba's arc is peak character. He's a cool thief man that does cool thief things B) Fanservice meant for thief lovers like me B3
@SharpestSniper99
9 ай бұрын
Good video as always. Unfortunate they felt the need to add royal’s material into the manga far later than it should have. (Looking at you Spider-Man 2 for shoehorning Donny cates Venom stuff into the black suit story) Though I disagree with your point about challenging Maruki’s resolve in Royal. Yes it would’ve been interesting if Ren got some more independence as a character and mad his own debate, sure. But I don’t really think the third semester as a whole really was really made with a grand debate in mind, nor did it really need to be one. It was made with a clear message and point in mind, and it’s honestly one that hard as it is, everyone needs to hear. (Also aren’t Atlus narratives centered around a debate normally reserved for Megaten? Persona’s narratives are usually more linear and clear cut.)
@connorharnage6697
9 ай бұрын
Yikes. So this is how the Netherrealm fanboys feel. That comment about Maruki hurts me to my very soul First, not once in my five playthroughs of this game do I remember anyone outright saying Maruki was wrong besides Akechi who of course is biased due to spending his whole life under someone else's control. None of the Phantom Thieves really say he's wrong, just that they want to earn their happiness instead of forsaking all their growth and have everything handed to them. It's just a difference of belief that doesn't leave much room for compromise, not objectively right or wrong The game even goes out of it's way to show you how happy everyone is. Sumire, despite still having her problems, is clearly a lot happier while pretending to be Kasumi. Ryuji's on the track team again, Madarame is still teaching Yusuke and Futaba has her mother and their all clearly happier for it. Overall, the game tries to make you see just how good Maruki's reality can be if you just let him and it's up to the player to decide who they think is right
@alistairmarston9405
8 ай бұрын
As a proud Maruki apologist who is autistic and neurodivergent, I deeply empathize with you. Despite how harshly some people bash him, I’m grateful that the Thieves (minus Akechi, of course) were actually thankful towards Maruki and appreciated all that he did for them. This can be seen during the Thieves Den conversations at the display of Adam Kadmon. I am deeply saddened by how many people despise Maruki despite the fact that millions around the world (third-world countries, those caught up in wars, people with struggling mental health such as myself, and people who have just been screwed over by reality in general) would benefit from an ideal reality. Pain is not necessary for growth, and those who cannot handle their problems deserve sympathy instead of contempt. As you pointed out, all of the trauma that the Thieves experienced is undone, and they’re able to live improved lives. Returning to the “original” reality means that they’re dooming so many others to go through the same situations they did, only that there won’t be a Metaverse for them to save themselves. If it hadn’t been for the Metaverse, the Thieves would be in the same shoes as the people whose lives are improved via the actualized reality.
@connorharnage6697
8 ай бұрын
@@alistairmarston9405 I partially disagree. I do think that, depending on the circumstances, pain is necessary for someone to grow. But that's exactly what makes this choice so interesting to me. This isn't a case of Persona 3's big decision where the right choice is obvious even though most normal people wouldn't take it. P5R does it's best to show both sides and even I, someone who firmly agrees with the canon decision of working to earn the life you want, can't say what he's doing is a bad thing because people in this situations you mentioned would benefit
@Ninja07Keaton
8 ай бұрын
@@alistairmarston9405 The issue is the scale and how one person(Maruki)is arbitrarily deciding what's best for everyone. Oversights, unintended suffering, conflicting variables in such a world would be inevitable. Another thing that I'm shocked that people haven't discussed, is that what Maruki was actually doing was running away from his trauma, albeit in a compassionate manner. This was the thematic reason for Maruki's persona being the idiot god Azathoth from lovecraft myth. To say the Phantom Thieves were fighting solely to reclaim their original reality is a fairly skewed perception of events. Just as Azathoth needed to awaken from his dream, the Phantom Thieves needed to wake Maruki from his nightmare. Hence when we see Maruki at game's true end, he's genuinely happy for once.
@vadandrumist1670
9 ай бұрын
Honestly I don't see the need to speed along the story for a manga. I mean, many shonen manga go on for well over a hundred chapters; is it really such a big issue that the story already exists in another format? The only big requirments I see are writing the fights in a more interesting fashion, putting the emphasis on "adaptation" when it comes to the protagonist's personality, and being vague on the calender dates so character arcs can be fufilled without putting strain on the pacing.
@SithLordMalco
9 ай бұрын
I wonder if eventually we will get a Persona 5 spin-offs (and 4 to lesser degree) falling into a bit of a plot problem of the brand new charcter being the sole focus with the Phantom Theives getting little to do other then interact -acting as bystanders to the new charcter (Strikers is the least bad with this and Q2 being the worst)
@SithLordMalco
9 ай бұрын
P5 Spin-Offs Video
@nightwish1453
8 ай бұрын
despite that i like Q2 more mainly that Q2 had more interesting dynamics in the side quests some of which had interactions that were suprising to think would happen like Yusuke and Yukiko, whilst strikers is just a retread of the original and mostly done worse other than Haru getting her deserved screen time the villians in strikers feel even more reptitive cause we just expect a reveal to happen that explains why they ended up that way.
@isauldron4337
6 ай бұрын
Minish cap manga might be more to your liking
@kawaiiempoleon8721
9 ай бұрын
Can you call it a 100 hour game for adaptation resdons when only like 3/10 of that is every single possible bit of dialouge in the game another like 90% you can ignore for being pointless
@reddeath5791
9 ай бұрын
Eleventh
@IzukuTheStoryMaker
9 ай бұрын
I’d say first but I’m honestly probably second
@The4thSnake
9 ай бұрын
You're probably the first person to say "first" who actually is.
Пікірлер: 22