个人过往的经验,以前就读某女子中学后来改男女制度的独中,每年举办义卖会之前叫学生出去卖票,有时候叫学生出去募捐,目的是给学校未来的建设,出去募捐卖票不算过分,最过分是这些募捐卖票是有target的,就好像你做sale有target, but 做sale就算hit 不到target也不要紧顶多没有commission或bonus, 但是这个募捐卖票如果没有到指定最低的target是要自己吃掉,就是学生自己吃掉,就是学生家长要自己买单,用很理想的理由为了学校建设来勒索学生一定要募款到多少钱或是卖多少钱的票,卖不完的票学生自己吃这样,个人经历过这些事情,已经很平常,当时没像很多觉得帮学校是好事,但后来我觉得,学费也不便宜,举办活动很多都是规定学生要达到什么目标最后都是学生家长买单,都是在加重家长的负担,如果有钱算了,没钱那些呢?因为家里收入很不好,每次看到爸妈还要负担这些额外的负担就觉得很心疼也很难过。我记得每次举办义卖会要学生自己出钱出力为学校赚取建设的费用,但是连成本都不愿意给回学生要学生自己承担,用学校未来建设前景来绑架学生一定要付出,要家长出钱,我现在真的觉得很不对,学校建的漂亮些不会让未来学生学习成果比较好。只要注重教育方式、设备齐全就好了,那些豪华漂亮建设根本没有必要,这些只是为了吸引以后更多学生而做很没有必要,因为这些钱并不是那些有能力的社会人士捐赠而是有学校未来的理念来绑架学生付出,最后也是转嫁到学生家长去承担,希望这种不良的风俗不要再持续下去。很多那些什么董什么董本身就很有钱,如果他们真的想要独中变好,自己捐款自己丢钱出来,他们出那笔钱根本不痛不痒,为什么要学生去募款,一边喊爱华教一边叫学生去募款,我真的觉得恶心,这些人真的只是想拿独中来赚钱吧,真的觉得看不过眼,是应该要批评的。
from a chinese primary school (SJKC), the school demand every student to pay some lumpsum money for a new building and was having a competition kinda thing among classes. but because I'm from a very poor financial background, i talked to my class teacher and got to "excuse" from paying the extra lumpsum: however - in return i got sarcasm treatments from the class teacher and since our class noticeboard will list out every student's contribution, and mine was "0" - it kinda got highlighted among my peers as well :') hence this is one of the reason im super disliking my primary school life so if and only the private chinese schools could encourage students to be creative or having a special club for entrepreneurship activities in co-curriculum to get donation would be a "one stone kills two birds" kinda healthy method (like what lucas mentioned, but also agreeing on jiawen also)
Another point is that, don't take the trust of the public and students for granted, the management need to report how the money is used to the stakeholders, not everyone trust the school management.
@banamonster2258
2 ай бұрын
@@pineapplecottage5235 definitely need to be transparent
Don't pressume every stakeholder has got clean mind and spirit, or students will be utilised as a tool to fulfill certain people's desires only in raising funds.
在国中时曾经有过筹款活动,本来就很穷,根本没办法叫父母帮忙,也许就一个2元吧。根本也不能找亲戚,后来是在我 Taman 附近,一间间地敲门筹款,还是廉价屋的区。后来学校还搞了个颁奖礼,给筹款多的学生颁奖。我班上上台的同学最基本的数额都是20, 50元起跳,父母都是校董,老师,生意人等。筹款居然还排名,我真是羞得...。贫穷,这真是我一生的阴影。
Jiawen. You have shown maturity in your reasoning and provide strong support in arguments. Do control your movement. Don't keep pulling your long sleeve. Look at how 卢卡斯. The ability to maintain one's coolness or calmness is crucial in front of the screen.
Пікірлер: 1 М.