This Discussion's aim was to highlight whether the questions raised in BukhariGate hold their strength or whether they may be easily dismissed as being built upon a frail foundation.
I'll allow the viewer to make up their own mind on that.
It was a pleasure to have this dialogue and the respect & love from and to Dr Majid was testament to the fact that such dialogues can be had despite polarising differences of belief towards the sacrosanct phenomenon of Bukhari. Enjoy mi gente! 😉🤟
Navigating through Crucial Conversations & Difficult Dialogues on Faith in our World today.
*[Timestamps below]
00:20:14 Discussion begins. Mufti's reason for Bukharigate.
00:32:33 Question: Is Sahi bukhari established with certainty like Qur'an or is there some doubt.
00:55:12 Bukhari's student Farabri had an incomplete draft copy which was later edited by his (Farabri) students.
1:10:54 Mufti reveals that Imam Bukhari used to do Tadlis, that is hide name of his sheikhs. Abdul Majid reveals that even Imam Muslim did the same thing.
1:16:39 Mufti mentions two other features of Bukhari that he never translated exactly how he heard it and used to paraphrase the hadith.
1:33:53 Mufti argues that nobody from Muhadditheen vouched for Farabri during the time he was alive.
2:09:28 Mufti argues that during Bukhari's time his Sahih bukhari was not highly rated and his other books were more highly praised.
2:35:00 Mufti's answer to BukhariGate rebuttal that even if Bukhari is removed, the same hadith are present in other books.
3:02:27 Discussion on Hadith about slaughtering of alcohol by Sun and Ninan
3:34:25 Discussion on Hadith about Prophet(pbuh) forgetting verses from the Quran.
4:05:29 Discussion on Hadith where Prophet(pbuh) says to a woman to give herself to him.
4:23:00 Discussion on Hadith about Prophet Moses(pbuh) bathing and a stone running away with his clothes.
4:36:10 Discussion on hadith about magic being done on Prophet(pbuh) and him having false memories.
5:00:29 Discussion on Hadith of Isra, hadith number 7517 in Bukhari.
5:31:52 Conclusion
Today's Guest:
Dr Abdul Majid
Imam,
Luton, UK
*The objective of these videos is to bring to the public such conversations that have for too long remained private for the privileged and seldom spoken before the flock.
And so the legend has it, the noose eventually loosened from around the neck of Liberty.
With Love / un fuerte abrazo ❤🤟
Muft Abu Layth al-Maliki [MALM]
Timestamps:
Негізгі бет Dr Abdul Majid | BukhariGate Unhinged or Unhindered? You decide | MindTrap 47 |Mufti Abu Layth
No video
Пікірлер: 680