That's a bad analogy because black people created rock n roll too
@jada8047
Күн бұрын
For me it's about dominance... More Rock Roll is white More Rap is black
@jasongibbs3713
Күн бұрын
@jada8047 that's just because they stole it from black ppl and then kept them out of it. So black ppl created hip hop and overtook rock music
@Muslim_Sneakerhead
Күн бұрын
Facts
@DonnyDrapers
Күн бұрын
💯 str8 facts!!!
@DonnyDrapers
Күн бұрын
& we created Country too & Classical; shyt damn near all genres of music!
@johnwill8084
Күн бұрын
Rocking roll was created by black ppl and the rest of America music what are you talking about..??
@jada8047
Күн бұрын
An black young people hate it they wear Nirana shirts for show
@YerpDerp17
15 сағат бұрын
It wasn't simply "created" by black people. That oversimplifies it so much. They vastly influenced it, absolutely. They invented ryhtem and blues, jazz and gospel. Which those did help make up a lot of the foundation of rock and roll. Which gave us artists like Chuck Berry. Rock 'n' roll was an inevitable outgrowth of the social and musical interactions between blacks and whites in the South and Southwest. To widdle it down to "this one group invented it" is dishonest and erases a lot of context. It was like any other genre of music, heavily influenced by many things, which formed a new thing. NO music is 100% original. Everything is influenced by something. Because if we really want to get into this meaningless argument, then we have to go back to what influenced everything and get to the root of music and ask who invented that. Black people should get a lot of credit, you could argue a majority of credit if you want, when it comes to rock music. But its not merely a black invention. It is a mash up of many different other genres meeting together. Not just black people. And I hope we someday get past this obsession with race and just appreciate music and art, honestly and freely.
@ruzen3803
15 сағат бұрын
@@YerpDerp17Don't cast pearls before swine. They will only trample them
@salj.5459
13 сағат бұрын
@@YerpDerp17 Guess what? Black Africans invented the ROOT of music as well
@keenkingjames
9 сағат бұрын
So should the white guys who created the samplers used to make a song be credited for all hip hop? Why is this a discussion?
@VocallyYours3
Күн бұрын
I don’t celebrate anything involving M&M!! 🙅🏽♂️
@WavyBoucherByTheWay
Күн бұрын
I salute you bro 🫡
@33GLOCK
Күн бұрын
Why celebrate any of them?
@Yo-Ah-Kim
14 сағат бұрын
Nothing against him but his music always been overrated.
@markhammett2377
14 сағат бұрын
I do. Plus, you spelled it wrong. Get your spelling up young man
@alkuya546
Күн бұрын
ED you wrong Rock and roll is black music so that is an inaccurate comparison to make with Hendrix and Eminem
@user-lq9mw1sb8d
Күн бұрын
But black people didn't fuck with rock music nearly as much as white people. Whites loved and moved that genre forward. Black gravitated towards pop and rap.
@ronaldolamont
Күн бұрын
@@user-lq9mw1sb8d I think the point is, rock and roll was not invented by white people, it was invented by black people. To say that white people may have moved rock and roll forward may be a good point, but they did not invent rock and roll, they did not invent rap & hip hop, therefore the comparisons are really not valid.
@MrSosa1969
Күн бұрын
So what about basketball ??? Who’s the best …by your analogy can’t be Michael Jordan. Black folks - didn’t create or invent basketball. See how that works ?
@33GLOCK
Күн бұрын
He want a co sign from em lmao
@bowlerfamily
Күн бұрын
@@user-lq9mw1sb8dfacts. N words ain't buying Bad Brains or Lenny Kravitz but want to talk about Rock being black.
@catchwreck928
Күн бұрын
and this is why we lose respect for certain so called elders... and its no wonder why we dont own nothing in none of the genres we created. cause of guys exactly like this. we need to do a study on the mentality in our community that makes some of us crash out and go Hard af toward our own but become docile when it comes to the people that literally oppressed you for over 400 years......
@aboveground1421
Күн бұрын
@@catchwreck928 I'm SERIOUS!!! We need to fund a study by professionals to look into this mental sickness in Black people GLOBALLY!!
@charlestonblack2149
Күн бұрын
Factz 💯
@dannydreadnought-xk4qx
Күн бұрын
Racial oppression, while important, is not relevant to rap skills. Should we deduct points from half-white J. Cole?
@wnnfrhrw4452
Күн бұрын
"You cannot revolt against a people whose values you share." - Dr. Amos N. Wilson
@puritanave313
Күн бұрын
Nobody was alive 400 years ago and sitting around saying Eminem can't be a goat in hip hop cause he white , when the major consumer is white sounds crazy 😂😂😂
@kharyvines6971
Күн бұрын
ED YOUR NOSE IS IN THE WAY YOU JUST NAMED MUSIC BLACK PEOPLE INVENTED SELL OUT
@TheRealLeonardWashington
Күн бұрын
Yea Ed been showing how much of a goofy he’s always been in these interviews. First it was him gossiping about Left Eye and Pac. Now this 🤦🏾♂️
@WavyBoucherByTheWay
Күн бұрын
He's a tom for sure
@33GLOCK
Күн бұрын
@TheRealLeonardWashington 😂😂😂😂
@gmon4058
Күн бұрын
Facts !
@YoungBlaze
Күн бұрын
but he's basing it off of of the odd example dr umar is trying to create, the context is what matters here
@TheRealVerbalAbuser
Күн бұрын
Rock and Roll is a Black artform. Country is a Black artform. The Guitar 🎸 is also a Black Creation. What are you talking about?
@marlonthemightysmith7836
Күн бұрын
Thank you what a moron
@liverpool666
23 сағат бұрын
Jesus is black too
@ShoeBoxJones_45
23 сағат бұрын
Guitar was invented by Spanish folks
@salj.5459
13 сағат бұрын
@@ShoeBoxJones_45 Nope, it comes from the banjo that enslaved Africans brought over to the Americas. The banjo comes first
@ChristoJohnSaaiman
11 сағат бұрын
@@liverpool666stop lying, Jesus is Middle Eastern.
@raajbundles
Күн бұрын
Whoever Anyone Says Is The Greatest Off All Time Is Just Their OPINION It Doesn’t Make It Factual, We Need To Stop Getting So Worked Up Over Peoples Opinions
@OrangeJuicePapi
Күн бұрын
You’re right but disqualifying someone cause they’re white is the problem. If he just gave us a top 10 and eminem wasn’t in there we wouldn’t even care. that’s his list.
@jada8047
Күн бұрын
Depends When you say GREATEST you speaking FACTS When you say FAVORITE you speaking OPINION Unless you say my opinion THE GREATEST
@meredithonline9784
14 сағат бұрын
❤❤❤❤
@DonnyDrapers
Күн бұрын
Black people created Rock & Roll, Country, Classical, & damn near all American music! C’mon Son 😂😂😂
@ILoveTheAllCreator
17 сағат бұрын
Exactly. Punk: Bo Diddly, Techno: Juan Atkins, Pop/Disco: Donna summers(Madonna stole her whole sound) etc
@el84oro
7 сағат бұрын
whites created basketball, so jordan (or lebron or kobe or kareem) can't be the goat right?
@703blakmavrik
Күн бұрын
We invented Country, Rock & Roll, Blues, Jazz, Punk and Rap.. You cant use that as an analogy, because we invented all those genres of music..lls
@rljuice
Күн бұрын
I think the point is, it doesn’t matter u dunce. That’s like thinking Michael Jordan can’t be the GOAT because James Naismith made the sport. Be your own Man, stop following talkin points from a grifter.
@jada8047
Күн бұрын
Rap is only important to most young black people
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@703blakmavrik basketball created by white folks for white folks. Jordan you cannot be the goat. Talk to your peoples. The reverse racism Dr. Umar loving people.
@NoLineNoWait123AbC
21 сағат бұрын
ALL of it.
@ILoveTheAllCreator
17 сағат бұрын
@@jada8047black isn't a race 😉
@MrHowse-rt5bo
Күн бұрын
There’s not a rapper to live that has had as much an impact on the world as Pac. All that other stuff don’t even matter…
@ILoveTheAllCreator
17 сағат бұрын
Word! 2pac would spit on em for ruining his mixes😂
@milihapi4866
Күн бұрын
There's no all out GOAT simple as. It is so subjective. There are at least 5 top tier rappers that cant be separated. They all have different characteristics that make them all 🐐's
@MT-ey7sm
11 сағат бұрын
Can't be more than one GOAT that means greatest of all time you people stupid
@Rebornjudah
Күн бұрын
You sound silly Rock n Roll was invented by black people too and so was country. Name 1 classic Eminem record that we are still singing!?! It's non existent. He's not even close to the 🐐 GOAT
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@Rebornjudah basketball was created by white folks for white folks. So using your reasoning Jordan is no longer the goat. Next up Larry Bird. You guys make not a lick of sense.
@kiandl00
23 сағат бұрын
How many black Rockstars and Black Country singers are there compared to white people
@quotifychannel
21 сағат бұрын
dance and trance music too
@Rebornjudah
18 сағат бұрын
@@mikemurray726 black people do everything better than white people hands down that's. That's why Larry Bird is Not the GOAT, Micheal Jordan, LeBron James, Kobe Bryant these are GOATS the only thing white people are the GOAT at is REDRUM of the innocent.
@Rebornjudah
18 сағат бұрын
@@mikemurray726 nobody is talking about Larry Bird anymore since the 90s. Jordan is a LEGEND Kobe & Shaq are legends. There's not 1 Eminem record that still on the radio and still being sung. He's far from the GOAT
@CharlesEdmond79
Күн бұрын
Talent is talent regardless of race or gender. 💯
@JennHayden
Күн бұрын
R.I.P Proof
@aboveground1421
Күн бұрын
I get sick and tired of Black Men like Ed Lover. We are the only people on earth who open our culture to outsiders who never include or invite us to ANYTHING. EMINEM did not invent scratch, graffiti, breakdance or beat box, HOW CAN HE BE THE GOAT OF THIS CULTURE???? These Black men hate reading, if Ed knew anything, he would know we invented rock and the early guitar came from Africa!!
@adamphillip5305
Күн бұрын
Never included? You've never invented a sport yet you're allowed to play
@gmon4058
Күн бұрын
Facts he’s not a man he’s a Boy
@orlandomolina7192
Күн бұрын
Drums come from Africa. Symbols from the Middle East. Guitars came from Spain. The saxophone from Belgium. Knock it the hell off already. #permanentvictimstatus ☝🏽
@blacktaxcollective5299
Күн бұрын
@@adamphillip5305 you sure about that? And who invented the slam dunk? Crossover? Street ball? And 1? And in sports you go head to head against competition.... it's not based off record sales where majority rules.... the fact you're using racism while defending a white rapper proves Dr Umars point. 🤡
@aboveground1421
Күн бұрын
@@orlandomolina7192 Ok conquistador grape baby👶🏻 👍🏿
@OfteninLondon
Күн бұрын
I love Eminem but after pondering this question myself, I couldn’t with good conscience put em above many black rappers. I agree wit Dr Umar on this one
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@OfteninLondon so your low key on that Dr. Umar reverse racism ish? What about Michael Jordan? Basketball created by white folks for white folks. Jordan can’t be the greatest then? Make that make sense.
@jordannorris4029
Күн бұрын
I’m from Detroit like Eminem and agree he is one of the best but the goat not even close. The goat is 2pac, Eminem has been in the game 26 plus years compared to 2pac only having 7 years in the game
@youngcezey
Күн бұрын
Respectfully disagree. I thought the same. But em has so much songs and different periods of time his music changed. I love pac but I'd rather hear em before pac
@Matroshka26
Күн бұрын
That's your opinion & you're entitled to it we all have our opinions not everyone's gonna think like you we all have different opinions that's the beauty of it all
@antony9630
Күн бұрын
Tupac was around for 5 years professionally which is insane considering the work and success he achieved. 1991-1996
@jordannorris4029
Күн бұрын
@antony9630 most definitely and we can’t forget his start with digital underground
@jordannorris4029
Күн бұрын
@@Matroshka26i agree
@Derryck-cu8fs
Күн бұрын
I’m with Umar, Umar never said EM wasn’t great as an emcee he just doesn’t feel he the goat. Nothing wrong with what he said. By the way country music, and Rock n roll is black music. Black people created the main genres of music so other races could make a living within in it and enjoy it as fans
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@Derryck-cu8fs white folks invented basketball for white folks. Sorry Jordan you cannot be goat. Using your criteria Jordan does not qualify because he is not the color of the people who made the sport. Make that make sense.
@israeliteprince9074
11 сағат бұрын
@@mikemurray726Eminem doesn't have the battle rap history to be considered the GOAT. His music doesn't reflect black culture enough to have a strong fan base among the people who created it. His wordplay and rhyming ability are talented, but some of his lyrics are corny and don't really hit that hard. To each their own, but there’s too much he hasn't accomplished to be considered the GOAT. Technically, that's indisputable. 🤷🏿♂️
@mikemurray726
11 сағат бұрын
@@israeliteprince9074 your on that racist Dr. Umar ish. Nuff said ✌🏻Eminem found himself in the rap battle scene in Detroit. Watch 8 mile lol. Either lying to yourself or skipping over the truths.
@israeliteprince9074
9 сағат бұрын
@@mikemurray726 Lol a movie in or just in his own hometown is your answer? Lol you can't be serious. Em lost against Juice in a California battle. We're talking about the greatest of all times everywhere not in 8 mile. Im not going to clown you but that statement wasn't a legitimate rebuttal.
@el84oro
7 сағат бұрын
@@israeliteprince9074 in fairness, even some of the people folks refer to as greatest have lost battles. its not uncommon for someone to have a bad day and lose a cipher. a lot of people (not me), like to say jay's the goat. Nas spanked him with ether. i do agree em's music doesn't reflect black culture, the topics he was rapping about, we considered it sort of taboo, talking about dissing your mom, killing your baby moms, i was going to say the drugs, but now these kids revel in rapping about using drugs. but music is opinionated. em ticks most of the check boxes. he isn't my goat but i can understand people putting him up there especially for his work prior to him going sober. its not as clear cut as say sports and even sports there's debates on who is or isn't the goat
@mindbully
11 сағат бұрын
Eric Clapton said the greatest guitar player was Prince, and blacks created Rock & Roll.
@AeRoGeZ
Күн бұрын
This is a man who makes the world a litle bit better instead of being negative on everything. We are all human.
@dwannb
Сағат бұрын
Jimi Hendrix invented heavy metal guitar that’s why he’s the GOAT. These hip hop heads don’t know anything about music outside of hip hop.
@ggbanks5763
Күн бұрын
Here we go with another brother defending Marshall Mathers. And they don't defend anybody else. Especially black people like that. I hate the best lyrics that black people ever heard of. Aren't you tired of other people telling you? Who is the greatest in your list?
@anothergamingchannel2656
Күн бұрын
🙄
@ChazzZimmermanMedia
Күн бұрын
In the hood i ain't never heard anybody say..."yo bump that new Eminem" 😂...he ain't the Goat
@Sam-mr2sy
Күн бұрын
From London UK i can confirm this is tru
@BROOKLYN1977
Күн бұрын
Thank you for your comment you are absolutely correct I've been saying that for many years a long time ago your comment is on point
@Brian00007
Күн бұрын
There is no goat but having your music played in certain areas doesn't mean you're the greatest ever
@JKaymitBindestrich
Күн бұрын
Your hood is full of idiots!
@BonusHole
Күн бұрын
The hood doesn't decide because the hood is a bunch of broke people preying on each other. Eminem took rap to a new level of technical ability. No rapper has come anywhere near that since Eminem. He brought white people level talent and genius into a black world and everybody is jealous. Yawn.
@covettamcsears156
Күн бұрын
Eminem us awesome but he is not the GOAT of all time I can think of better eeoecially when black folks invented rap they don't give us credit like that for their genre then why should we let them have any credit in our genre I disagree
@reginaldjackson7905
Күн бұрын
Right we created all music genres nothing is theirs
@Matroshka26
Күн бұрын
We all have our opinions on who's the goat some may agree some will not it's just how it is
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@covettamcsears156 white folks invented basketball for white folks dum dum. Jordan ain’t no goat. Legend Larry Bird. You make no sense on your reverse racism ish. Like really?
@anothergamingchannel2656
Күн бұрын
All genres huh? Lol okay @reginaldjackson7905
@Straight-Outta-Nottingham
23 сағат бұрын
Thats your opinion, theres no fact about whos the greatest its all opinion based
@benjamincole250
Күн бұрын
I don’t agree with everything dr umar say but this I do
@user-lq9mw1sb8d
Күн бұрын
Another thing going for Em(at least in my eyes) is he appreciates and understands the origins and essence of hip hop waaaaay more than a lot of black rappers. Especially young black rappers. Young black rappers literally shit on the great rappers and producers. Eminem has genuine respect for the art, unlike a lot of black rappers. Em has done and is fulfilling hip hops criteria. WRITE your own shit. Display your technique with dope wordplay and flow. And be the wittiest on the mic. Easily one of the best. Is he the GOAT? No one holds that title, in my opinion.
@Matroshka26
Күн бұрын
@@user-lq9mw1sb8d I like that
@Asa_Brownlee
Күн бұрын
💯
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@user-lq9mw1sb8d Big Facts 💯
@jonathangordon9397
8 сағат бұрын
Facts
@murphydaquan
Күн бұрын
That's like saying Jordan can't be the Goat of basketball cuz a white guy created it
@NativeAfroAmericanSoulTribe
Күн бұрын
Basketball was created by the ancient Olmec & Mayan civilizations.
@kingjoeblack5
Күн бұрын
No it’s not. It’s like saying Jordan can’t be white man of the year because he’s not white.
@ceeIoc
Күн бұрын
And they arent black @NativeAfroAmericanSoulTribe
@landsharkbang
Күн бұрын
No it's not. Cause it'll be over 100 names before it get to a white guy 😂
@gregpuryear8163
Күн бұрын
@@NativeAfroAmericanSoulTribewho told you that lie
@HarmlessComment
Күн бұрын
He has such a valid point about owning versus streaming. I used to be proud of my binder of cds, I would keep the paper insert too so you could see the track list. I had a 6 disc player in the back of my 89 prelude 💪
@Yo-Ah-Kim
14 сағат бұрын
Respect 🫡
@LordOsiris13
Күн бұрын
It’s the system. The colonists system.
@jonathancoleman6482
Күн бұрын
Eminem will never be the goat I Agree with umar
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@jonathancoleman6482 because you are on that reverse racism ish. Basketball created by white folks for white folks. Michael Jordan can not be goat. You guys make no sense. Reverse racism at its finest.
@mikemurray726
10 сағат бұрын
@@jonathancoleman6482 basketball was invented by white folks for white folks. Yet Michael Jordan is widely considered the Goat. Why can’t Em be goat of Rap? Make that make sense. Reverse racism ish right there. If you agree with Umar you agree with reverse racism. He makes not a lick of sense.
@Mr.Wayne.1
Күн бұрын
I’m still confused why people glaze Marshall so much man… Like fr. Legit question. I mean, he’s super nice but gawddamn…
@Silverback219
Күн бұрын
I ask the same question all the time
@wnnfrhrw4452
Күн бұрын
That's because Eminem is a Great White Hope, even an Elvis 2.0. The Masses keep falling for The Okey-Doke.
@Infinity-jn1nf
18 сағат бұрын
Hoping for a bag later
@AntonioSam-s4p
9 сағат бұрын
You said it yourself he's super nice. It's all on the listeners at the end of the day. I hear people listening to people and can't understand why and they think they are the greatest thing.
@el84oro
7 сағат бұрын
em was nice in his prime. his topics were way off, but i remember his verse on the anthem with xziibit krsone tech9ine, i remember his verse on off the wall with redman, obviously his renegade verse especially when it just came out....killing baby moms, dissing his mother, and rap about drug use aside, white boy could rap. i don't think he's that good anymore, but in his prime, other rappers who rapped and really rapped, knew em was nice, hell his verse on welcome to d-block with the lox. he's not my goat, but i'm not gonna say he couldnt rap. and being nice is a huge part of being a dope rapper/emcee. for me its the main thing, being nice, writing your own shit, and being able to make a dope song.....everything else is just extra and some not needed
@JayWerx
Күн бұрын
When it comes to the art form and craft of rhyming, Em is about as good as it gets. Now content maybe a different argument.
@badmarshall5556
Күн бұрын
Em got homo lyrics. Not pac, jigga nor big. Neither Nas.
@williamwalsh1533
Күн бұрын
Eminem is a great wordsmith. But so is Kxng Crooked.
@Silverback219
Күн бұрын
The question is why when black people get around each and talk there's always someone that has to brag up Eminem name?
@JumalHopson
Күн бұрын
😂
@davidmarcus6512
20 сағат бұрын
Cause if u got it, u got it
@JumalHopson
17 сағат бұрын
@@davidmarcus6512 Eminem Got it 👍
@ValerieCampbell-fz7zo
Күн бұрын
Eminem can be in the top five, but he cannot be the goat😳
@Matroshka26
Күн бұрын
So MJ can't be the GOAT in basketball right?🤷🏾♂️
@SBzKillFrenzy
Күн бұрын
Of course he can. Stop the foolery
@33GLOCK
Күн бұрын
@@Matroshka26 yall make us look bad " but but such an such"
@DJay98
Күн бұрын
Your about 60 gtfoh😂
@Matroshka26
Күн бұрын
@@33GLOCK you morons make yourselves look bad🤦🏾♂️You don't even know me chief
@MrORLANDO7139
Күн бұрын
Ed is trying to be politically correct here. Ed Lover knows the 5 elements of hip-hop. He's been around the culture too long to not know. Also, Eminem knows he has WP, just like Timberlake, Post Malone, and other people yt people that have been a guest in Black culture. I have also never been one to think record sale makes you a great MC. Eminem, appeals to yt kids all across America. I still to this day have never heard anyone of my black brothers or sistas say "Put on that Eminem"
@Duval-Dame
Күн бұрын
💯🎯🎯🎯 never ever not once in my lifetime and im in my 40s!!!
@dr.alexander7039
19 сағат бұрын
If he was black you’d rate him much higher than you do. Stop playing!
@MrORLANDO7139
19 сағат бұрын
@@dr.alexander7039 negative
@koffiged
Күн бұрын
Hip-Hop its not African! Its American!
@4thaculturetv
Күн бұрын
African American
@wnnfrhrw4452
Күн бұрын
Afrikan AmeriKKKan is Afrikan.
@marlonthemightysmith7836
Күн бұрын
Idiot
@ILoveTheAllCreator
17 сағат бұрын
@@4thaculturetvFBA is descendants from Mayan and Olmec Indian Civilizations, not from africa, do your research
@kennymack6492
13 сағат бұрын
Short bus🤔
@gmon4058
Күн бұрын
Ed doesn’t know music history what a shame.. black artist were guitar players. Stop fooling these kids lord Jamar and Ed lover are weak black men.
@landsharkbang
Күн бұрын
I would listen to young Michael over older Michael
@PR-WAY
Күн бұрын
Just because Eminem has sold the most records doesnt mean hes the goat cause trash sells to lol not saying all his music is trash im just saying. Tupac the only GOAT dont care what anyone says an the majority of the world agrees
@Matroshka26
Күн бұрын
@@PR-WAY that's your opinion...a lot say Pac isn't the goat some say Nas is the goat some say Rakim is the goat some say Em is the goat so it's all subjective we all have our opinions
@PR-WAY
Күн бұрын
@@Matroshka26 get out of a America your see
@jada8047
Күн бұрын
2pac is your GOAT an that's fine but there are a lot of people they think someone else's trash is treasure...
@jada8047
Күн бұрын
Eminem trash could be others treasure.... If you sold the most records you are a GOAT... MJ has the most FINALS MVPs isn't that why he's the GOAT
@Matroshka26
Күн бұрын
@@jada8047 well said
@Alexander-1989su
16 сағат бұрын
A white man invented basketball and people don't say that air Jordan is the best because he's black.... Hell no everyone knows that air Jordan is the goat
@gmon4058
Күн бұрын
But rock and roll was created by black people. That was the music black musicians were playing in that era.
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@gmon4058 white folks invented basketball for white folks. Sorry Jordan you cannot be goat. Using your criteria Jordan does not qualify because he is not the color of the people who made the sport. Make that make sense.
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@gmon4058 white folks invented basketball for white folks. Sorry Jordan you cannot be goat. Using your criteria Jordan does not qualify because he is not the color of the people who made the sport. Make that make sense.
@meboy3513
Күн бұрын
Ed Lover is lost. On MANY fronts. Em is nice but he's not the goat and it's not even close 😭🤣😭😭 SMH
@greglopez8206
Күн бұрын
Poor Ed is stuck in 90s tech. So many ways to convert digital media to physical these days. The music will never be lost regardless of any streaming services removing it. Music can be found in thousands of repositories.
@blackcherry6877
Күн бұрын
I cannot stand this dude. Thats why he got ran off of radio in New York.
@Duval-Dame
Күн бұрын
Ed up there C🦝🦝Ning... Bc Em can never be the Goat of a FBA creation... We are microphoned checked!!!
@AKAT1980
Күн бұрын
Obviously he didn't listen to what Umar said.🤷
@brem3985
Күн бұрын
Chuck Berry invited rock n roll… so yes Ed, jimi hendrix can be considered the greatest guitarist of all time, and not because eric Clapton said he’s the greatest.
@maddslander7359
Күн бұрын
I agree with Umar and Black's invented Rock n Roll too
@JM-st6ut
Күн бұрын
Umar ain’t no doctor. He’s as much a doctor as Julius Erving
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@maddslander7359 white folks invented basketball for white folks. Sorry Jordan you cannot be goat. Using your criteria Jordan does not qualify because he is not the color of the people who made the sport. Make that make sense.
@deshawnpeterson1538
Күн бұрын
This man is unqualified to comment on what Dr. Umar said because he doesn’t know that Black people created rock ‘n’ roll. Therefore, his example about Jimmy Hendrix not being recognized as one of the greats in rock ‘n’ roll does not apply.
@ReallyStrongGuy
Күн бұрын
0:34 Well Ed, because some of our people are petty kids.
@Bronxking81
Күн бұрын
I had CD books in my car and before that I had a cassette tape bag with a slot for individual tapes! Even when I get music today I make sure I have the files on my external hard drive! I don’t stream, it’s just a st*pid concept to me!
@fancynfreeme
Күн бұрын
Rock n roll was originated by Black folks. All soul music has an African origin.
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@fancynfreeme white folks invented basketball for white folks. Sorry Jordan you cannot be goat. Using your criteria Jordan does not qualify because he is not the color of the people who made the sport. Make that make sense.
@Octopus_MTEF_MinEco_BU
Күн бұрын
I can forgive Ed for claiming Rock N' Roll is white music. The reason is we as blacks have distanced ourselves from the genre. Like other black art forms, we can barely name current black artists who are in the genre.
@MrAwak3
Күн бұрын
Chuck D said it best…. Music is supposed to transcend color and bring cultures together. From a strictly lyrical perspective only Black Thought has the word play, flow, syllables and punchlines to compete with Eminem. I do think allot of his music is cringe but damn the man can spit. No great rapper has anything negative to say about him. They all love him.
@tjpopsit
Күн бұрын
Mike can easily be called "The king of Music" rather than the king of Pop. 👑 🎶
@Black_Picaso
16 сағат бұрын
Who said Ed Lover makes the rules for hip hop..
@charleshubbard7768
Күн бұрын
Does ED know anything about music other than hip-hop 🤦🏾♂️ . Rock n roll and country music was created by blacks artists
@MiC-T
22 сағат бұрын
Then Tiger Woods can't be the greatest golfer ever. Jordan can't be the greatest basketball ever.
@enjoy-ly7zw
Күн бұрын
I’m with Umar
@jada8047
Күн бұрын
Umar too caught up with bein a militant man.. He kicks Eminem in the nuts over greatest question but protects pedafile P Diddy 😂
@kelvinjohnson6539
Күн бұрын
Cause your lame
@salj.5459
12 сағат бұрын
@@kelvinjohnson6539 You're* Learn to type correctly first
@theFRIS
Күн бұрын
that's why I have over 1300 dvds...if netflix say this title is leaving soon, then its just a memory unless another service hopefully has it
@williemanchester3197
21 сағат бұрын
Rock and roll was invented by black people. Starting with the first rock and roll song rocket 88 recorded by the great Ike Turner. The guitar was invented by a black people as were most instruments. And who is Eric Clapton to have a say on anything. B.B. King said the greatest guitar player of all time was Ike Turner. Michael Jackson bought the Beatles catalog which had little Richard’s masters and he returned them to him free of charge. The same way people believe rock and roll is white genre. The same will be done to hip hop.
@Evan-memo
16 сағат бұрын
He is so right when I didn’t pay my Apple bill for a month after a year of paying which is over 1530$ in Canada I lost all my playlist and music so I spent 130$ and owning nothing
@stashingclips4706
Күн бұрын
Ed lover country music come from Black People respectfully
@gerardmarsh7396
22 сағат бұрын
Real Talk Ed Lover. Much Love From Little Rock Arkansas
@aaronc3396
Күн бұрын
I agree with Dr umar, black power
@JesseJones-oq9ty
Күн бұрын
Isaiah 40 6:8 . No 👎 power
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@aaronc3396 racist scum
@El_Nabi_Yahumitz
Күн бұрын
All the genres he named, we started. So the sense in Dr. Umar's statement would seem to he that since hip-hop also came from us, but representstrour struggle, let's not lose hand this one over for our future generations to speak from the place of confusion Ed Lover is speaking from pertaining to the other genres we started.
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@El_Nabi_Yahumitz white folks invented basketball for white folks. Sorry Jordan you cannot be goat. Using your criteria Jordan does not qualify because he is not the color of the people who made the sport. Make that make sense.
@DanielMarch
Күн бұрын
God created music !! God created colour !! Music has no skin - stay human
@yahpasion9231
4 сағат бұрын
Country is also black music
@VisuARISE
Күн бұрын
Umar is right. MTv Raps, Radio Shows...We Created RockNRoll...Ed Lover, all youve done is Commentate for HIPHOP...No Ownership No Mentorship...this why we so disrespected cause Our Elders turnout to be TopNotch KEWNS man...Clybourn Ass Nixxaz
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@VisuARISE white folks invented basketball for white folks. Sorry Jordan you cannot be goat. Using your criteria Jordan does not qualify because he is not the color of the people who made the sport. Make that make sense.
@kinglee270
Күн бұрын
Ed is full of ish
@africandna213
Күн бұрын
Event 2pac Shakur will agreed with Dr. Umar Johnson. Like Malcolm said, don't trying to join black organizations and be the head of it. So, stay back as the guest, and in black culture you cannot be the Goat. I m very disappointed of Ed lover that doesn't have any idea of with he talking about it.
@tripleog2783
Күн бұрын
You just racist 😂
@quintariosmith990
7 сағат бұрын
I agree with Dr Umar Ed Lover u tripping bro 🤡🤦🏾♂️💯
@JohnF23
Күн бұрын
OG Ed Lover…he’s making toooo much sense right now!!!✊🏾👍🏾
@greglopez8206
Күн бұрын
Spotify allows you to download music to your device. The music is ours when we download it
@j2323j
Күн бұрын
Eminem is just overrated.
@tonysnow2224
Күн бұрын
My criteria is to be a top rapper u gotta be versatile…you gotta make 1.) music for the club 2.) music with a deep message 3.) music for the ladies 4.) music to ride in the car too ….you gotta be able too do all them things well in my opinion and Eminem can’t do all those things very well…but Tupac,Jay-z, biggie,OutKast, and UGK could…
@arkhamknight6371
Күн бұрын
I got 7 huge cd books,miss them days going to sam goody, or the corner spots with the mixtapes
@BAD825
Күн бұрын
Word Motown Jackson 5 thriller sold 100 million copies
@EuniceRyan-yw1mr
Күн бұрын
Whoa, this was epic! Keep it up!
@julia2k8
Күн бұрын
True
@patone2184
14 сағат бұрын
I never owned any of Eminem albums.
@chriswil5919
12 сағат бұрын
Most black ppl In Detroit haven’t either..
@Thenameisboosta
Күн бұрын
Not gonna lie... I don't like this dude... This clown went from video after video hating on Pac... Then this goofy presses Eminem... In his world, Eminem can't do no wrong... This fool is corny
@KP43-08
Күн бұрын
7:58 that’s a very good point if you don’t pay your Apple Music bill, they will cut that shit off. Streams will never compare to Hard copies 🤷🏾♂️ everything‘s heading into a digital society these days smh and I can’t believe they try to compare Drake to Michael Jackson. That’s even more disrespectful & I love drake.but owning CDs was just different fr very good point ed!
@WhoCaresAnymoreTho
18 сағат бұрын
The top 10 we are told is the top 10 isnt real
@Yo-Ah-Kim
14 сағат бұрын
You have your own opinion right ?
@cyrusacre
10 сағат бұрын
James Naismith (white man) created basketball. Michael Jordan (black man) is considered the GOAT of Basketball. See how ridiculous Umar's argument sounds?
@missilecustoms
21 сағат бұрын
Still waiting on black rappers to ask white audience not to buy their music or go to their concerts.
@RichardMathis-hj1cw
Күн бұрын
I’m a black man and shady is one of the goats flat out. Nobody wants smoke with shady on the mic
@finaltouch998
Күн бұрын
Damn that’s true we don’t own our music 🤔🤬
@freefoodtv
Күн бұрын
We created country and rock and roll. So love Ed but bad points Cmon Son😂
@PapaPolo
4 сағат бұрын
Ed Lover thinks white ice is colder that’s why he speaking for that white man.
@amass2158
Күн бұрын
Not just the streaming...the Internet period..I grew up with 6 ft cord on the PHONE..land lines... CABLE TV.... let one storm come thru.. EVERYTHING OFF..THIS IS THEE STUPIDEST SHII EVER!! and we just let it happen... SMH
@ogbluefromqueenslive
Күн бұрын
Idk if he sold a billion records he ain't fugging with know of our brothers period let him go make rock raps I'm NY all day Queens in the building.
@alchemist1387
Күн бұрын
Other people put color on music which is y they run the music business
@SneakyNinja837
Күн бұрын
I mean if he’s supposed to be disqualified from hip hop YET became one of the goats that should say a lot
@achyld21
11 сағат бұрын
Black people didn’t create a single professional sport in America, Serena, LeBron, MJ, Jerry Rice, Kobe, are all GOATS. How is what he saying any different?
@ChristoJohnSaaiman
11 сағат бұрын
Black ppl invented Rock n Roll and White ppl elevated it, White ppl invented Basketball and Black ppl elevated it. Stop the hate on Em pls.
@OrinBattice
Күн бұрын
Blacks are the originators everybody else are imitators 😏
@mikemurray726
Күн бұрын
@@OrinBattice white folks invented basketball for white folks. Sorry Jordan you cannot be goat. Using your criteria Jordan does not qualify because he is not the color of the people who made the sport. Make that make sense.
@blackwhite2361
17 сағат бұрын
You have these black dudes dismissing what Dr. Umar said... And yet they all stay fuckin silent on Beyoncé's country music not played on country music radios and her album being snubbed by the CMA... SMH. Having said that i love they way he answered the question.
@beatthetrap777
Күн бұрын
Ed lover tripping
@QBell79-97
11 сағат бұрын
The criteria is flow and subject matter, lyrical ability. Sales have nothing to do with rhyme skills. So there u go Ed, now give us your top 10 Emcee’s of all time
Пікірлер: 827