"Everton are the WORST run club in the country" | Carra and Neville ARGUE who should replace Lampard

I'd absolutely love to see a conversation between Carra as a pundit, Carra as a player and Carra as an Everton supporter

Wow as an Everton fan my respect for Jamie carragher has increased tenfold. Spot on with every word he said. balanced, informed and fair analysis.

As a united fan couldn’t agree more on Jamie’s analysis here, especially his bit about the board demonising the Everton fans and the people of Liverpool. A city which has been forever demonised by mainstream media and the board knew they could use this to their advantage

Best option would be to appoint Sean Dyche, considering the longevity he gave Burnley with the lowest budget in the league then surely he’s a worthy candidate

MNF is more entertaining than the actual games themselves.

REMINDER: The last time Everton played a non top flight season was 1954-55. For reference Liverpool's last non top flight season was 1961-62, Manchester United's last non top flight season, 1974-75. Only Arsenal can claim a longer stay in the top flight than Everton. 69 years, of top flight football. And it's all about to come crashing down.

Jamie Carragher is 100% spot on in his analysis even with the bit Neville disagreed on, as an Everton fan seeing that statement from the board it was an attack on all fans when it's obviously a teeny tiny group of people who call themselves fans who would have made these threats, change at the top is imperative

As a Liverpool fan, I agree with every single word Jamie’s said here. It’s very sad to see a club like Everton being reduced to relegation fodder, regardless of rivalries. I saw one Everton fan saying about Bill Kenwright, “Imagine someone wants to sell you their car and then says ‘hold on mate, I want to keep the logbook’”. That club has stagnated over years, and the downfall has now come for them. Hopefully for them, they can avoid the drop but, if they do get relegated, the owners would surely have to sell up

Carra talks sense. Never been his biggest fan but he’s spot on. Same with all these clubs who keep sacking managers and don’t get any better, Everton, Watford…. The chairmen think they should be top 6, based on some idealism to justify their investment. The reality is they won’t let the managers manage, then blame them when it goes wrong.

Carra is fantastic as a pundit. As an Arsenal fan I have a tonne of respect for him.

Carra was spot on again, its obvious to see what is happening at Everton

Honestly as a non Everton fan, when I saw the statement about the Board being ordered to not attend the game due to safety threats, I can say say I was convinced it was because Everton fans were being vile and hooligans. But after listening, and seeing what’s happening to the club from the top down makes it way more obvious that the statement put out was just a way for other fans to attack evertonians. The board and owner are disgraceful and wishing Everton all the best.

Carragher is spot on 99% of the time about Everton. He really understands the club. Lampard should never have been hired. Someone like Emery or Tuchel should've been, a proven manager who can turn crap teams into very good ones. Tuchel wanted to come in 2017 or 2014 but we never wanted him. Apparently we're trying to get Marcelino who has proven himself as a good manager.

The statement wasn't from the Police. It was from the health and safety team at Everton. That's a big difference.

The situation between Everton and Man United owners are identical except that the Glazers take money out of the club, and Carra has always focused more on the United managers and even lazily commented on how the Glazer's spent money (but not investment), so poor performance is the managers fault. He's been way more fair and honest about his analysis of Everton and defensive of the fans than he has of United.

I feel so sorry for Frank. He really felt the spirit of the club. But no matter who comes in it will be a tough job and the main reasons are these. One the board are treating the club as a social club not a business that should be looking to improve the Club, team, and financial health of the club. Two the crap players on the pitch. Whenever you see them play live or on the telly. There may be 2 or 3 passes and then a breakdown. Not one of them can tackle win the ball and make a successful forward pass with a goal making chance. Apart from Pickford the rest would not be sold at a profit.

Thank you Sky Sports for the Everton content. Thank you Carragher for straighening out the non truths in the media about Everton.

Wasn’t a surprise frank would be fired , but still not the answer , he was let down by every one at the club from top to bottom, this proves how much of a disarray this club is in, bringing another manager in is just putting another target on his back unless you cut the rot out, thank you frank for your service

Wouldn't be a Gary Neville video without the infamous phrase "at this moment in time"

I really hope Carra has helped non-Everton fans watching to see what is really going on at the club.

The emotion in Jamie's voice... he isn't acting but if he were acting he'd get an oscar.

You can feel the passion and emotion in Carra's voice. He is still an Everton fan of heart I believe. It hurts him personally to see the club in this state. Respect for everything he said - He is right

There's absolutely no way on this earth Bielsa goes to Everton. Marcelo will not work with owners who don't live up to his standards, not to mention, he's never gone to a club midway through the season like this. Bielsa has rules, he follows them and he expects others to follow them too. 1000% there's absolutely no way Bielsa goes to Everton. I've never been more sure of something in my life.

They need a manager to keep them up and stabilise them. Season 2023-24 consolidate (if they stay up) aim for 12-15th and build foundations. Then season 2024-25 build for top 10. Could be 2 more managers until they're back on track though.

whatever happens my respect for everton fans has increased tenfold over these last couple of seasons. Used to be my clubs 'bogey team', and a lot of rival fans are happy to see them near relegation and their struggles, but as a neutral, the way fans backed the team at the end of last season (and frank this season) i have found admirable. the opposite of how NU fans acted towards Steve Bruce. cue the hate, but I wish everton luck with whoever comes in

To answer Carras question on teams looking for certain style of managers - Barca (possession focused), Bayern (free-flowing systems), Real Madrid (another attack focussed) save for when they had Benitez and did poorly, RB Salzburg / Leipzig. Most top top teams have a preference. I'd assume when/if Pep and Klopp leave the clubs would aim to bring in someone of similar play styles

Spot on about managers what's been at Everton an it's a shame to see a club like this in disarray

You can tell Carra has a love for Everton by his emotion in his voice

I’m an Everton fan and I laugh at the fact that we have come into money and end going backwards like look at Newcastle at the minute their flying . Thats Everton for you

Jamie goes high pitched,Gary returns with a high pitch note 😂

Arsenal went from Wenger to Emery lol completely different managers then went full circle back in terms of playing style to Arteta, clubs can't always pick a certain type of manager especially mid season - other factors are how big of a club are they, what type of situation they're in that needs addressing, how big of a job is it The nostalgic Everton with Pienaar, Arteta, Cahill etc are the ones we all as PL fans miss, it's actually sad seeing them spiral like this, maybe it'd be a good thing for them to get relegated so they can clear out deadwood, hopefully be sold and start from scratch, sometimes teams need that fresh start just look at Fulham this season as an example, couldn't stay up more than two seasons in the Prem, went down, managed to keep a majority of their squad, built a rapport and a bond then came back stronger than ever

👏 well said Jamie! As an Everton fan of 40 years he is bang on! I was at that Everton game v Southampton with my 7 and 10 year old kids.... there was no threats and at no point did I feel threatened. People in the city like, Jamie, know absolutely that the threat was complete nonsense... who 'ordered them not to go? Merseyside police have said nothing was reported to them so we know it wasn't them... I have the up most respect for Bill Kenwright, I was there when he saved us from the knightmare of Peter Johnson, but come Bill, Denise... you know what the right thing to do is.

Still amazes me to this day how Everton got Ancelotti

Once again Carra shows why he's the best Pundit.... Of course you'll disagree with certain things he say sometimes but the critical thinking awareness behind his analysis and thoughts every time is spot on more than when he's not!!

I wonder what the fans and Jamie think about the possibility of Hasenhüttl being appointed as new manager. He did a good job at Southampton for a long time and they haven't really improved since he was fired there.

One club that had a sustained plan for a period with similar managers and by their size and level had success was Swansea City

I think sky hiring these two has been the best decision made in the last 10 years of punditry. I think deep down they’re friends, but everything riles them up. Great engagement.

this just made me more embarrased to be a season ticket holder at Everton , its that obvious how inept our board is

As an Everton fan,i feel embarassed at the current situation.carraghers spot on.i feel bad for frank aswell,he had little to no chance tbf.

I feel bad for Lampard. He's still learning to be a manager, but nobody wins without strikers on the roster.

Everton reminds me of Brighton from 2018/20. People wrote them off and predicted them to get relegated. Never underestimate any team. Just a decent manager and a few signings and they could make a comeback just like them.

Carragher is absolutey spot on in this video. Our owner and board have made their position at the club untenable.

Imagine thinking Lampard is a better Manager than Benitez

The first thing that Everton have to do is break the cycle of WHEN they change manager. No-one can come in now with a week to go in the transfer window and make changes that will make any difference, and by the time summer comes around, any new manager will need a full season to put their own team on the pitch.

We need a Monday night football on a podcast! I love it but can’t always catch it because it’s so late on at night and clips aren’t as good as the whole shabam

All they need to do is start winning games. They have these problems because they are losing. If a new manager comes in and plays a system and formation that suits the players they have, Everton will improve in all areas. Playing possession based football does not suit this squad. However, playing direct, on the counter, and crossing the ball into the box does suit this squad.

Hiring big time managers as an almost big club can go badly , sometimes having a moyes type manager can give you long term stability as big managers will always have heads turned

Everton fan- carra was spot on. In touch with what is happening at the club. Unfortunately especially about the boards statement about the threat.

Arsenal have set the new blueprint. Owner - Sporting Director - Manager. That's it! Three men running the club, one runs the team, one controls th in's and out's and one sanctions the clubs purchases and finances. If those three are totally in harmony the club will go forward as Arsenal have shown.

Thank you Jamie I have been an Everton fan for all my life, and they are the decline. Although, we were in Europe league football 4 years ago. So I think we need to sack the board.

Gary losing an argument is things you love ❤️ to see as a Arsenal fan.

Spot on CARRA! Stepping up and keeping it real.

Lampard has had a massive issue with organising a coherent defensive system at Chelsea and Everton. Until he fixes that he won't be successful.

Love it when these two go at it 😆 🤣

I love that the longer Neville and Carra argue the higher their voice pitch goes

both arguing makes me laugh. I love both of them 😂

Carra unlocked his childhood everton fan today

And yet we get told by fans of other clubs that our owner and board have tried and that we should be grateful. Anyone that knows anything about football knows we’re the worst run club in the country and we have every right to want them both gone.

A good owner is a good delegator. You have to appoint the right personnel in the right positions and allow them to do their jobs accordingly. Moshiri and the board need to recruit proper football people with proven track record throughout the spine of the club from youth development to player recruitment to marketing. Bring in an experience old head to steady the ship while you build the infrastructure and once the infrastructure is in place bring in a young progressive coach like Poch to revamp the club

Spot on Carra from an Evertonian. A real sad time to be a blue.

Think the Birmingham board with our half broken stadium - Points deductions - unknown owner being investigated and constant sacking of managers - as well as numerous relegation battles (with most days just staying up on the last day) could give Everton a run for there money 😂

“In Liverpool you back your own family, football club” Also Carragher…. “Im saying it as an ex Everton fan”

Everton need a relegation to steady their ship and decide what they are actually going to do. Its helped many a team before but need to ensure they can bounce back within 2 seasons. Look at Villa, Newcastle, West Ham who went down and able to come back up quickly or they end up doing a Sunderland who still cant get back or Leeds who it took nearly 15+ years to get back.

As an evertonian I think Jamie has quite a few valid points, I have been saying more or less the same thing for years now

I exactly remember Gary said that he didn't want Ten Hag to be the manager but preferred Porch

Most of the players Everton's been bringing in the last 6 or so years have been outcasts that haven't been good enough to play regularly for their previous clubs.

I remember when these two grilled Ten Hag at the start of the season after a couple games. Never have I seen that before from Sky. Yet Lampard hasn't had a bad word said against him til now. Just remember that.

Both of them are right tbh. It makes no sense for a club to go from Koeman to Allardyce to Ancelotti to Benitez then Lampard. It's just complete mixed messaging for the players. Top clubs always choose similar managers even if the style and tactics are different for e.g. Bayern, Ajax, Barcelona, Madrid, Dortmund.

Police didn't tell the board not to go. The clubs own security did.

Jamie’s upset about his beloved club

I’m pleased that Everton fans are allowed to have an issue with their owner in the eyes of the media. We (Newcastle), were deluded and ungrateful every time we grumbled about the relegations and constant battles against it. It’s sad to see what’s happening to that club. Brace yourselves for a relegation. It’ll be soul destroying but it might be just what you need. There’s enough there for you to stay up with a new manager but I can see more seasons of mediocrity trying to put past mistakes right. It might be better to rip it up and start again in the Championship.

The root causes of our problems are that we are badly run, and badly managed and we’ve been used to mediocrity for decades

As a Liverpool fan as much as i hate Everton i respected everything Jamie said in this video and i can understand the anger from Everton supporters on the current situation with the club. It's fair to say that Liverpool and Everton are both in need of new owners.

The way their voices get high when they argue with each other is hilarious 🤣🤣

I love when pundits go in at clubs.. I love it more when those clubs upset the league leaders after being laughed at and criticized

Think dyche would be my choice he'd probably stabilise the club then wait for an elite manager too come along . Everton need sorting out there a mess . Good club deserve better

At 9:55 there, the squeaky voices from Carra and Gary are absolutely hilarious 🤣 You would think they got turkeys in the studio

It seems that Everton have lost their way for quite a long time and as carra said why has things gone wrong and the entire team need a damn good clearout and start from scratch and rebuild and all clubs go through a clear out and rebuild

Jamie Carragher and Gary Neville are talking sense! And more so in this case the former because he is more familiar with the subject. And yes, the Everton fans are the most passionate there are! 🤗

If there players aren't scoring, there passes are terrible and there defensive has been diabolical how can u blame Frank. Its crazy how the world of football works

You have to get Sean dyche in... he's the best one available and I think he can turn it around but they still might drop

9:52 it’s hilarious how both their voices go high pitch when they argue 😂😂

Neville only looks at the symptoms but Carragher points out the actual problem.

Wait... it's just "ARGUE"? Where's the "HEATED" gone?

For an EX fan carra sure is passionate about Everton he still wears Everton pj's round the house

“As an ex Everton fan” is hilarious to me especially knowing I cannot and will not. Under any circumstances. Change the club i grew up loving and supporting

If you want to be in the exact same place you were last season then Franks your man.

Neville hit the nail on the head, style of play. Get Phil Neville in.

Funny when Jamie says “as an ex-Everton fan” when he gets passionate and personal every time he talks the toffees.

Respect to Jamie for this as an everton fan

Merseyside Police have stated, as Carra said, no evidence of any threats to the board have been recorded.

There's loads of clubs in the lower leagues ran far worse than Everton

Always thought Duncan Ferguson should have been given the job. He came in for a short spell a while back and seemed to do alright.

As an Everton fan....we need Avram Grant next.

If Carra played for Everton and supported Liverpool as a kid there’s no way in hell he’d now be an Everton ex Liverpool fan.

Newcastle fans aren’t just happy because Mike Ashley isn’t there, if they were bottom of the league the fans wouldn’t be happy just because Mike Ashley has left, sometimes feel like Carra doesn’t like Nev and part of him loses it with Nev straight away, almost like anything he says just irritates him so he’ll argue anything with him

Jamie, every word you said is what I've been thinking for over 1 year

I think Jamie carragher would do an amazing job at everton.really knows his stuff.😑

Don't forget Jamie that some of the fans ran down and confronted players so some of those fans deserved to be thrown under the bus, absolutely worst supporters in the country and let's hope they go down into the championship, wonder if they'd turn out massively then

An ex-Everton fan? 🤣🤣 I can't believe they're STILL making excuses for Fragile Frank. It's hilarious.