So happy to be covering this topic fully finally. Thanks for being here for it!
@TonyLambregts
12 күн бұрын
@@MindShift-Brandon thank you for doing these.
@patrickthorpe422
12 күн бұрын
Keep up the great content brother!
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
@@patrickthorpe422 Thank you, will try!
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
@@TonyLambregts Its always my pleasure!
@rokkitserjun
12 күн бұрын
This video was definitely a Magnum Opus on the subject. I think it was so nice of @imbeggar to do such a comprehensive video of the lousy apologetics, allowing you to shoot them down so succinctly. It was like he was setting up the pins just right for you to bowl a strike.
@bobbarron1920
12 күн бұрын
If boring means no disease, no poverty, no torture, no suffering, no starvation, give me boring.
@thing1thing2themediamaniac43
12 күн бұрын
DAMN RIGHT
@aliyyenman6181
12 күн бұрын
Well said!!!
@greg-op2jh
12 күн бұрын
💯
@davidgalvez5341
12 күн бұрын
Remember that Chinese curse: "May you live in interesting times."
@SteveLomas-k6k
11 күн бұрын
God created a world with no suffering, no pain, no grief or tragedy. And that world still exists to day.. for jellyfish. Hence they experience no joy, love, motivation either. Would you trade? Me neither.
@alexanderbean7737
12 күн бұрын
Imagine telling a grieving parent who lost their child in the most horrific way possible "hey, at least it ain't boring!"
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
right?! It's infuriating.
@BluStarGalaxy
12 күн бұрын
They might as well say, "You wouldn't appreciate your remaining kids as much if you didn't lose one."
@BenJones-d8p
12 күн бұрын
Imagine saying "your child is up in heaven flying around on that big marshmellow cloud in the sky." 🤔
@discontinuedmodel232
12 күн бұрын
@@BenJones-d8p Or imagine saying "your child is in heaven PRAISING GOD for all eternity - and totally forgot about God letting them suffer a painful early death!" 😇
@BenJones-d8p
12 күн бұрын
@@discontinuedmodel232 Or maybe just saying "I don't know" or "from what I can gather we don't have an afterlife." I'd rather be honest than live in some lie. I get it though. Death is a very scary thing for many people, and the possibility of an afterlife is a very comforting thought.
@Ywabag
12 күн бұрын
Calling a world without suffering "boring" is cartoonishly evil
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Agreed!
@christasimon9716
12 күн бұрын
So either eternal heaven is boring or it contains suffering.
@martin2289
12 күн бұрын
In the case of the subject video, quite literally so.
@TaeyxBlack
12 күн бұрын
@@christasimon9716yup. it’s one of many situations where apologists forget all of the elements of their belief system. they’ll make all these excuses about how the earth needed evil in order to be perfect or we’d just be robots or something, but then go on and on about how great it will be once we get to the place with no evil. it’s like they get amnesia. you realize you’re trying to sell an afterlife with no evil to me, right? in your efforts to explain away the problem of suffering, you’ve cut the legs off your sales pitch
@Deconstructures
12 күн бұрын
It really is. The apologetic here seems to be that most sapient beings are going to suffer for eternity because God finds that interesting.
@smoldragon339
12 күн бұрын
Funny how a perfect world without free will is existentially boring when an apologist is justifying the existence of suffering, but NOT existentially boring when the apologist is justifying the concept of Heaven
@johnfauxnom4221
5 күн бұрын
Don't worry, there will be cancer in Heaven, too. Gotta keep things interesting!
@AdamKlownzinger
12 күн бұрын
A perfect God would require no apologetics
@Karessertin103
8 күн бұрын
this is such an underrated comment
@newme1589
6 күн бұрын
That argument doesnt make sense because you cant describe a perfect God because you dont have all the knowledge and capability. Anything resembling "perfection" coming from you would be heavily tainted (and everyone, im not attacking you haha) Also, this perfect God gave us freedom of will ... So if someone wants to be an apologetic, they can. I just didnt understand your argument, im sorry
@shaqyardie8105
5 күн бұрын
@@newme1589 Where does it say that god gave us free will/freedom of will in the bible? I'm not convinced that this god gave us anything becauseI'm not even convinced that this god even exists.
@JeffryBozes
4 күн бұрын
@@newme1589 why do you believe in free will? Just an assumption? You should be careful with those.
@moon_wobble7782
4 күн бұрын
A perfect god would communicate more clearly and not need the interpreters to speak for him and get it all mixed up. Also, why would I only show myself in one form in one small part of the world at a time when documentation is lowest
@astrinymris9953
12 күн бұрын
Pausing at 14:25 to note that I find it interesting that he doesn't acknowledge that anytime someone uses their "free will" to rape, enslave, rob, or murder *that takes away the victims free will to live as they please*. So in a system with truly free will for everyone, no one would be allowed to commit crimes against against other people's person or property. The system would cause the aggressor bots to freeze up if they tried, or allow the innocent bots to teleport out or throw up a force shield to protect themselves if threatened. Eventually, the evil-intentioned bots would learn, "Well, *that* doesn't work." and try something non-evil to fill their time. Or maybe they'd stubbornly continue to try doing evil, but since they couldn't actually harm anyone, all the good people could go on with their lives unmolested. There you go: Problem of evil solved, while retaining free will for everyone.
@goldenalt3166
12 күн бұрын
Exactly, God needed to make evil profitable so it would be attractive because ?
@terrellkirkman2078
12 күн бұрын
Vote @astrinymris9953 for God 2024.
@astrinymris9953
12 күн бұрын
@@terrellkirkman2078 🤣🤣🤣 Thank you!
@Uryvichk
12 күн бұрын
Same problem with Satan, except worse, because many denominations say Satan is irredeemable and can never be saved. But they do think humans can be. So... why does God allow Satan to go around violating human free will, dominating and misleading and tempting and insulting them, potentially resulting in their damnation? It can't be because God values Satan's free will to choose good, because Satan can no longer choose good. So like... make it so he can't interact with human beings at all? You don't have to kill him, just strip him of any power to influence the free will of beings who can still make a meaningful choice.
@greschenglin-dz7wj
3 күн бұрын
@@UryvichkGod says one thing, Satan says something to the contrary. Ball is in your court. The only thing the devil has in this scene is his words, and the only influence they have here is suggesting an alternative that goes against what you have been told before. You can either stick with the former and show your trust in God, which is to allow Him to influence you, or choose the latter, putting your trust in someone else and ceding yourself over to their influence in like fashion. Much like the Garden of Eden. The fruit was never the problem. It's trust.
@chameleonx9253
12 күн бұрын
Ever notice how every single time an apologist makes an analogy for God, they conveniently forget about the "omnipotent" and "omniscient" part?
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Yup lol!
@JDrocks4ever
12 күн бұрын
Absolutely! Frank turek got nailed by some dude who’s name I forget rn in a debate when he brought up how sin coming into the world is Gods fault for placing the tree in the garden, while knowing they were going to eat from it before placed it. Franks rebuttal was to suggest that God “couldn’t do better” I.e. this was the best world he could create. Immediately diminished the characteristic of omnipotence lol
@chameleonx9253
12 күн бұрын
@@JDrocks4ever Honestly, I don't know why they ever thought it was a good idea to claim their god was literally omnipotent and omniscient. It would save them a hell of a lot of trouble to just admit that's it's an incompetent loser who can't figure out how to build a halfway decent lifeform without filing it full of hundreds of obvious design flaws. Their whole moral philosophy is based on "might makes right" anyway, so what does it matter if their god is a moron? They would still be obligated to obey him out of terror of his unquenchable bloodlust, so why the massive PR campaign? Oh... right... it's because he's not real. 🤭
@toonyandfriends1915
12 күн бұрын
@@JDrocks4ever God can't, again do away with necessity so it is consistent that there are things God can't do while being omnipotent and theist since the middle ages never denied such a thing. Or else you get things such as God being able too create a square circle or doing things against his nature(he can't) and this was affirmed since the middle ages. There are other things you could respond to Frank Turek on this matter as a rebuttal, but i am just here to clarify that this response does not necessarily diminishes omnipotence. I will have to add that i'm doubtful about the specific christian God existant and it seems i have to say such a thing before people start saying things about my intentions.
@Explodington
12 күн бұрын
@toonyandfriends1915 listing a bunch of things god can't do certainly does diminish his omnipotence. I am also omnipotent, if you don't count all of the things I can't do.
@JeffryBozes
12 күн бұрын
"Sure, God *could* make a universe without babies that get flesh eating disease & experience agony for their short life... but seeing babies suffer is just so much fun!!" - Christians, apparently "Sure, heaven is perfect & there is no suffering... but there are no babies in agony?? This place is BORING!" -Christians, apparently
@sorryifoldcomment8596
12 күн бұрын
@@JeffryBozes Yeah, I immediately started thinking about all the species I would simply not create. It would be so easy for me...definitely a lot easier than actually creating them. I would also have no trouble creating an ecosystem that didn't require them, if I had God's absolute power. Just...why??
@TheMilitantMazdakite
12 күн бұрын
Lies. When Ahura Mazda created the world, they made it perfect. All of our problems are man-made, or, more accurately, HIERARCHY made!
@_ben_miller
12 күн бұрын
the god of the bible is described as being able to create and destroy and resurrect at will, and exists in an eternal plane. why would this matter to him? also, your logic in your bottom paragraph is nonsense. jesus said his kingdom is not of this world. the people who reject him are the ones who choose this world and all of its evils. the ones who accept him desire to be with him in the plane he exists in. as to why he allows it at all: to show that man is so evil and foolish that he would choose all of it rather than anything better that involves him. unless you believe there is another way of escape of this world other than faith in Jesus of Nazareth, every belief in your worldview will, by default, serve to make you choose this world and choose all the evil in it. ie, you are no different than what you project about the creator, except you don't have the power to make it happen. you still want it, though
@gregsanich5183
12 күн бұрын
Remember that unless they were grown in a lab, every one of those babies is guilty of violating a womans bodily autonomy without her consent. A crime that is equivalent to grape, and rightly warrants capital punishment without any trial or due process. Skin disease is getting off easy.
@JeffryBozes
12 күн бұрын
@@_ben_miller Why do you assume it is a choice to not be raised in an environment that leads me to believe that a particular mythology/religion story is true?
@MrDumdas
12 күн бұрын
05:00 so god is entertained by our suffering. Sounds like a super loving dude.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
To be fair i think his point was its boring for us, the bots, but its just as dumb
@MrDumdas
12 күн бұрын
@MindShift-Brandon ohhh, that actually would make more sense. Still a bad argument, but seems like a better point than "god delights in our suffering"... which actually does sound familiar for some reason 🤔. I guess I'd wonder how we'd even be capable of getting bored if we're perfect.
@sauron69447
12 күн бұрын
@@MrDumdas So much for being the God of love his followers claim he is
@vitriolicAmaranth
12 күн бұрын
@@MindShift-BrandonFor what it's worth, the argument that we only seek struggles and require strife to avoid boredom because we are adapted to a world full of struggle and strife makes the same mistake as most arguments for the existence of God, which is assuming from the start that God exists or God's existence is the most likely explanation for any apparent anomaly (or in this case, that evolution is a real phenomenon or evolution is the most likely explanation for an anomaly in human nature). Of course, if we assume there is no evolution and genetics are, I dunno, explained by God making children resemble their parents as an aesthetic choice, we must ask _why God made us capable of boredom._ Also I realise that you axiomatically disagree with the idea that without struggle we become bored, but I disagree; That is not only not axiomatically false, there us overwhelming evidence that it is true. I think your mistake in reasoning, based on the video, is unintentionally assuming that as boredom is a type of misery and struggle and strife cause misery, struggle and strife cannot be a requirement to stave off boredom.
@chameleonx9253
12 күн бұрын
@@vitriolicAmaranth Boredom is an evolved characteristic of certain tetrapods that encourages us to explore and discover new resources to exploit or habitats to colonize. Most likely because the organisms that weren't as curious just hung around doing the same thing until all resources dried up and they died.
@BluStarGalaxy
12 күн бұрын
A chef is making a cake and while preparing the batter half a dozen cockroaches fall in. When guests at the restaurant are served the cake they have a feeling that something is very wrong and inquire to the chef. The chef admits that he allowed the cockroaches to fall in and that it was something that was just bound to happen. When the guests get mad about his carelessness other guests defend the chef and berate the guests that are mad saying that they wouldn’t have been able to do any better and in reality they should not have expected to have the cake any other way.
@AdamKlownzinger
12 күн бұрын
Well said. Except we’re not even just talking about a chef, we’re talking about the best possible chef. And yet not only would the best possible chef not do such a thing, your run of the mill chef wouldn’t either
@CatDaddyGuitar
12 күн бұрын
@@AdamKlownzinger 👍🏼👍🏼
@CatDaddyGuitar
12 күн бұрын
@@AdamKlownzinger lol and who's running the kitchen for roaches to be around in the first place??
@ellyam991
12 күн бұрын
"Which cake would you rather have? A perfect cake that would be BORING or a cake full with surprises - sometimes not good ones?"
@abiliv-lf9tz
12 күн бұрын
@AdamKlownzinger Naw he was the best chef in the kitchen cuz ik there's definitely better chefs out there 😭
@il.anshin
12 күн бұрын
The ironic thing about apologetics is that its primary purpose isn't to convince non-believers, but rather to ease the cognitive dissonance of believers who hold their faith primarily due to spiritual experiences or emotional reasons. For these individuals, any self-defeating argument is irrelevant because they believe that, in the end, God will make everything right. William Lane Craig once admitted that he would still hold his beliefs even if all the evidence contradicted them, because his experiences, filtered through a religious and cultural lens, are what he interprets as divine.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
yes its for the choir for sure, my only hope is some of the choir sit in my pews for a few minute and get disillusioned with the lies they are being fed.
@gleidhold
12 күн бұрын
exactly
@IsMaryStillPoppin
12 күн бұрын
@@il.anshin yep. believing in god requires complete absence of reasoning, cognition and logical thinking. Otherwise the whole thing falls apart. That's why believers need to have "blind faith" so they don't question or analyze anything and remain in the bubble where they (falsely) feel safer.
@bluecrystal3900
12 күн бұрын
Very well said 👏
@johngavin1175
12 күн бұрын
@@MindShift-BrandonI mentioned your video in the comments section of his video. Dunno if that was a good idea or not.
@mibph9548
12 күн бұрын
this video can be summarized in: congratulations now heaven is pointless
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
indeed!
@johngavin1175
12 күн бұрын
Reminds me of Godless Engineer's opinion of heaven. Definitely dont wanna go.
@MrFiddler1959
12 күн бұрын
I think the only argument worse than "perfection is boring" is "evil/suffering is the refiner's fire." I taught elementary school for 38 years. If I had used any of the tactics the biblical God used to teach a lesson or to discipline I would be rightly incarcerated for life in solitary confinement.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
100%!
@erinimagines
12 күн бұрын
I never understand when people say God allows bad things to happen to bring him glory and that it's worth it?? NO It's not!
@iwilldi
12 күн бұрын
God is glorious in his absurdity.
@2pacaveli257
12 күн бұрын
Thank God's Angel Lucifer for his assistance 😂
@blueStarKitt7924
12 күн бұрын
😔😔😔
@Existidor.Serial137
9 күн бұрын
Yes! why does he need to be glorified?? He is 100% perfect. He doesnt need anything. Is he narcissist?
@ShadowTheHedgehog56696
9 күн бұрын
@Existidor.Serial137 Not only is he A narcissist, he is THE narcissist!
@survive323
12 күн бұрын
God can't be around evil yet he created it. Knowing all along what he was doing.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
One of s thousand issues!
@CatDaddyGuitar
12 күн бұрын
And yet, apparently, no one can escape his presence, according to David.
@MarkMiller-gt5tu
12 күн бұрын
@@CatDaddyGuitarIf you want a good 😂 laugh watch "Little Darryl The First 48"
@Chuck-se5hh
12 күн бұрын
Well said!!!!!!
@charlesclaridy8646
12 күн бұрын
Go read 2 Samuel 24:1 and 1st Chronicles 21:1. Use a KJV. Notice who prompts David. Not the same? Or is it the same?
@Ponera-Sama
12 күн бұрын
Hot take: If unspeakable evil and horror are the logical and inevitable result of free will, then free will is evil, and God is evil for creating it.
@andytyler6252
12 күн бұрын
@Ponera-Sama The only thing free will can do is damn us, if you believe you can't save yourself without jesus.
@judethree4405
12 күн бұрын
Simple, yet hard hitting point!
@Headroomtalking
12 күн бұрын
Which would be true if Enoch died
@Uryvichk
12 күн бұрын
Yep, that's the fundamental fatal flaw of the Free Will Defense: There is no good, principled, ethical reason why God should prefer the expression of free will to the point of allowing every other bad thing. Nothing about it is inherently good, at least not enough to be more valuable than everything else; and if it's only instrumentally good, then to whatever extent it results in the opposite of good, it shouldn't be valued by God.
@justanotheropinion5832
12 күн бұрын
@@Uryvichk another fundamental flaw is all of the evil that has zero relationship to free will. Natural disasters. Childhood cancer. There is immeasurable pain and suffering in this world. It serves no purpose and cannot be defending by free will. According to biblical logic God caused it with intention, rendering the bible logically impossible.
@narellepayne1455
12 күн бұрын
If a real-life clinical trial was failing so spectacularly, the Ethics Committee would stop the trial.
@daysoftheboo
12 күн бұрын
Defending god is like defending an abusive husband/ boyfriend/girlfriend/ parent, defending god is basically the same as defending and making excuses for an abuser It's unhealthy and toxic
@pratiwi16
12 күн бұрын
If things go well, then it's all because of god.. If things go bad, it'S because our fault to be tempted by evil... Exactly like an abusive partner / abusive parent!
@daysoftheboo
12 күн бұрын
@@pratiwi16 you spoken like a victom who makes excuses for their abuser
@daysoftheboo
12 күн бұрын
@@pratiwi16"he abuses me because he loves me"
@pratiwi16
12 күн бұрын
@@daysoftheboo nope.. I agree with your statement!
@daysoftheboo
12 күн бұрын
@@pratiwi16 oh, I got confused Because my parents are extremely religious and then and they're crazy religious friends make the most extreme insane excuses for god Very very offensive to survivors of abuse of any kind , so I wasn't sure if you were also making excuses for god AKA the man or men who invented god
@kevinnazario1015
11 күн бұрын
On the 2023 earthquake in Turkey that killed over 45,000 people there was a story that totally demolished me. There was this man who was working when the quake hitted. When he returned home, his entire neighborhood was gone. It was a set of six story buildings. He lived with his elderly mother, his wife, his two boys and one girl. While looking through the rubble the found the girl's arm . She was alive under tons of debris. There was no way to extract her. The man sat next to her on a chair, holding her hand as she slowly died asking him to save her. She died. The girl was already decomposing, the man was still there holding her hand. His eyes lost. I cannot imagine what was in his mind. He lost his entire family. His entire neighborhood. And for what? Is someone gonna have the balls of quoting Job on me? I don't give a shit about the divine plan. If the plan is more important than the suffering of the innocent,then there is no benevolent god. Is a cruel sadistic overlord. I don't know what happened to that man. But the image if him holding his daughter's hand from under the rubble will forever haunt me.
@njhoepner
9 күн бұрын
God wanted the entertainment value.
@stephenbedford1395
9 күн бұрын
That tragic story encapsulates the problem of natural evil, which no Christian has ever been able to 'theodicy' their way out of.
@BenJones-d8p
8 күн бұрын
@@stephenbedford1395 It just is. Bad things happen because we live on a rock. A rock that has hurricanes, tornadoes, earthquakes, etc.. Bad things happen to good people because that is life. It has always been like that throughout the 300,000 years that humans have been on this rock.
@badboyb123-n9k
7 күн бұрын
@@BenJones-d8pso... You're agreeing on the biblical God not being omnipotent?
@Michael-el7iy
2 күн бұрын
it's a long read but please read this You understand a lot more............... Before I begin, I want to acknowledge something upfront: words often feel hollow in the face of overwhelming tragedy like this. What that man went through is beyond heartbreaking. No human being should endure such pain, and any answer we try to offer has to begin from a place of humility and respect for the depth of his suffering. I don’t claim to have a perfect answer. But I’ll try to offer a perspective that grapples with both the agony of this situation and the profound questions it raises. The objection here is clear, and it cuts deep: How can anyone reconcile this kind of unspeakable suffering-of a father watching his child die slowly, unable to save her-with the belief in a benevolent, all-powerful God? Isn’t such suffering proof that God either doesn’t exist or, worse, that He is indifferent or cruel? So, the first thing we have to admit is that this suffering feels like a cosmic betrayal. Not just of the father, but of all of us. And when we're betrayed, we look for someone to blame, and in this case, God becomes that target. And rightly so, because if God exists and allowed this, doesn’t He bear the ultimate responsibility? Now, let’s take this head-on. The idea that God has a ‘divine plan’ can feel deeply unsatisfying in situations like this. It feels almost callous to suggest that this father’s loss was part of some grand narrative. So, if there is a God, how do we make sense of His silence in such moments? There are a few things to consider, none of which erase the suffering, but they do force us to think deeper about the nature of the divine. First, we have to reject a simplistic view of God’s plan, one where God micromanages every event and deliberately designs every tragedy. If God were a puppet master pulling every string, then yes, we would be right to call Him cruel. But what if, instead, God has created a world with genuine freedom-freedom in human choices, freedom in nature-and that freedom comes with risk, randomness, and the possibility of immense suffering? What if God is not the architect of every event, but the force that seeks to heal and redeem even the worst moments You mentioned Job, and I get it-Job’s story often feels like the ultimate cop-out when it comes to suffering. But maybe there’s something deeper there than just ‘God works in mysterious ways.’ In the story of Job, God doesn’t give easy answers to suffering; instead, He challenges Job by showing him the vastness and complexity of the universe, a universe that operates on principles far beyond human comprehension. But here’s the kicker: God never dismisses Job’s pain. He never minimizes it. Instead, Job is invited to wrestle with his grief, his anger, and his sense of injustice-because these feelings are real and valid But here’s where the real existential challenge comes in: If God doesn’t exist, does that make the situation any better? Does it erase the suffering or make it more bearable? If there is no God, no transcendent reality, then suffering like this becomes pure absurdity. It has no meaning, no purpose, no hope. The father’s pain, his daughter’s death, all of it becomes just a cruel twist of fate in a meaningless universe. But if there is a God, even one who we don’t fully understand, then there is at least the possibility of redemption. Maybe, and I emphasize maybe, this suffering can be transformed-not erased, not justified, but transformed-into something that we can’t yet see It’s not a comforting answer, but it’s a profoundly different view of reality. Either the universe is utterly indifferent, or there is a God who grieves with us, who suffers with us, and who ultimately promises to make things right, even if we can’t see it in the moment. And perhaps, this is the hardest thing to accept: that there is meaning and hope, even in the face of unimaginable suffering, but we may never fully grasp it in this life I know that’s not a tidy answer. There’s no ‘silver lining’ to a tragedy like this. But maybe, just maybe, the existence of a God who allows freedom, who weeps with us, and who ultimately offers redemption is not as absurd as it first seems. Maybe, when all else falls apart, we’re left with two choices: despair in a meaningless universe or cling to the hope that somehow, in ways we can’t understand, suffering will be redeemed. I’ll leave you with that to think about
@reneeweber7102
11 күн бұрын
Many aspects of the Christian world view can be summed up with this: “From what position of privilege” Nailed it Brandon.
@swagpenguin2151
Күн бұрын
There’s people in Africa who die for there faith I beg to differ.
@CJoyArt
12 күн бұрын
One of my best and dearest Christian friends asked me (after I admitted I'm agnostic), "Are you just letting your emotions get the best of you since you god has not intervened in so much suffering?" My response was that it would be emotionally easier to believe in a loving god that cares about not just me, but the rest of the world." She didn't have a response. Thank you Brandon for this excellent video. I am always blown away with your ability to show, with scripture, the audacity of this god.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
its so frustrating to see believers miss the point so hard and at the same time be so hypocritical. Thank you for this!
@shiroamakusa8075
12 күн бұрын
You know, at least the Jews admit that God's the author of both good and evil and the only reason to submit is because you're terrified of the guy.
@chewxieyang4677
12 күн бұрын
And so did almost every polytheist adherent of every mythology ever. They never had to pretend their gods are of any embodiment of moral virtue, and are instead someone powerful you beseech for favors, and respect for their authority.
@riseofdarkleela
12 күн бұрын
I accidentally read that as “terrified of the gay” and it still worked 😂😂
@Uryvichk
12 күн бұрын
Also they had a contract with him. Sometimes you sign a contract with a real jerk, but a deal's a deal, y'know?
@apokalypthoapokalypsys9573
12 күн бұрын
@@Uryvichkwhy, of course the jews would make a deal with even their own god. Classic jews, I bet they even sneaked in a few fine print clauses.
@shiroamakusa8075
12 күн бұрын
@@Uryvichk It's funny how God's covenant with Abraham contains almost no real duties and obligations for God to fulfill, but requires Abraham's descendents to follow a plethora of rather arbitrary rules and a hard non-compete clause. Old Abe should have hired a lawyer before signing. Suddenly that Baal guy looks like a really swell deal.
@kyrroti
12 күн бұрын
As a god with perfect foreknowledge, he’d be able to iterate on the program BILLIONS of times. He’d be able to fine tune all the variables in order to get the outcome he wants. According to this guy, the world is exactly how god wants it to be.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
exactly. this is the best of all possible worlds according to Yahweh and this logic, and yet i can remove one single tornado and improve it.
@Uryvichk
11 күн бұрын
Weirdly, I'm not clear on what the difference would be between God imagining something and God actually creating it. Would God actually create every universe iteration to see how it goes, or is God somehow capable of imagining a universe without creating it? How would we know whether we're in an actually-created universe or one God just imagines?
@incredulouspasta3304
12 күн бұрын
_"At least they could say, 'we did it on our own'"_ I immediately thought of the Tower of Babel.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
right?! its such a weird claim of goodness
@incredulouspasta3304
12 күн бұрын
@@MindShift-Brandon Honestly, it's kind of refreshing to hear a Christian say that. I personally value personal accomplishment, but the Bible story condemns it. I think he'd have a ghost of a point, if he weren't trying to argue on behalf of Christianity.
@FeliciaByNature
12 күн бұрын
As a software engineer, this guy's understanding of AI hurts like hell. It belongs on the SyFy channel not in a real discussion about anything.
@dasbus9834
12 күн бұрын
Whenever apologists try to use computer-related metaphors, they fail miserably. Without exception.
@archapmangcmg
12 күн бұрын
@@dasbus9834 Whenever they try to argue cosmology, they fail. Biology. Geology. Car design. In fact, they're all failures and almost always in ways you don't need to be an expert in order to spot the lies.
@TaylorReedHudson
12 күн бұрын
I don’t understand AI that well, and even I listened to that thinking, “This sounds all kinds of wrong.”
@Shattered3582
12 күн бұрын
I cringed so hard at that part
@terrellkirkman2078
12 күн бұрын
I'm no software engineer but I know ChatGPT doesn't run on Asimov's 3 laws. 😂😂😂
@beanpie2912
12 күн бұрын
The way that I saw the I am Beggar video and thought "Brandon should react to this, I hope he does." I guess prayer does work 🙏😅
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Lol!
@riseofdarkleela
12 күн бұрын
larf larf
@johngavin1175
12 күн бұрын
I hope others react to it too. Like Rhino or GMS for instance. Or maybe SirSic?😅
@AztecLos13
12 күн бұрын
So this guy watched the Matrix and heard Agent Smith’s story about the first Matrix was paradise and perfect. But people couldn’t handle it and it crashed and the lost many crops. Definitely reminded me of that scene.
@Llortnerof
12 күн бұрын
This guy sounds like all his knowledge about the topic comes from science fiction. Because holy crap, that's not how any of this works.
@michaelhenry1763
12 күн бұрын
Excellent analogy. That’s funny. I thought he was thinking about I am Robot. But your pick makes better sense.
@andytyler6252
12 күн бұрын
My middle daughter was 10 years old before she found out some parents hit their children. She was horrified when she witnessed that at Walmart for the first time. Kids grow up just fine without physical punishment. Teaching and guiding by example produces much better adjusted adults. I have 3, beautiful, adult children to attest to my words.
@MrBBaron
12 күн бұрын
As an old Boomer me and my brother were frequently given "the belt " even for minor transgressions .It hurt like hell. The same could be said of the other kids I knew. The parents didn't hesitate to use physical force to correct bad behavior. It was accepted as normal parental behavior. Even our teachers could use physical punishment in paddling a problem student. Me and bro and my friends turned out to be good productive citizens. I never had kids but I would have never hit them to correct behavior.
@katherineg9396
12 күн бұрын
God is great at making rules, but he's not much of a teacher.
@sorryifoldcomment8596
12 күн бұрын
Yeah, I was never hit as a child and somehow I was the best behaved child around! Same with my brother. I genuinely can't think of any way it could've benefited us...much less benefited us in ways that could even come close to compensating for the incredible damage it would cause. (I already suffered terrible anxiety, without the fear of being physically assaulted at any moment.) Even when I hit puberty and broke my track record of perfect behavior (by self-medicating with the only substances I had access to, which were illegal drugs & alcohol)...physically assaulting me would have been the LAST thing that would've helped! I was already suicidal, in incredible mental anguish, and self-harming as an additional coping mechanism. The only thing that would have helped is the one & only thing that has helped: getting the officially prescribed medication I needed the whole time (because my brain actually needs additional drugs). It's terrifying to think about how many people would've looked at my situation and thought the only reason my "bad behavior" continued was because my parents weren't willing to hit me. 🤢 I am truly horrified when I imagine how my life would've gone had I been raised by Christian/religious extremists who believed their almighty God actively disapproved *not* beating me, and possibly would punish my parents if they didn't physically assault me...plus, they would definitely think my substance use & mental health issues were purely spiritual problems (if not demonic possession), only solved by prayer & physical punishment (maybe an exorcism too). 🤢🤮 My life was hard enough! 😭
@andytyler6252
12 күн бұрын
@@sorryifoldcomment8596 I was beaten regularly as a child. It definitely didn't help my anxiety at all. I hope things go well for you. I know it's difficult at times, but it gets better.
@andytyler6252
12 күн бұрын
@@sorryifoldcomment8596 I had a Christian friend at the time. Even though I stayed overnight a few times, after the cops were called to my house, his family dynamic was always odd to me. They weren't physically abusive, but they NEVER talked to each other. Not even a greeting when you walked into the house. I've always thought it was interesting how similar our childhoods were, even though they were very different on the surface. They were the family going to church 3 times per week with a nice house and lawn. I believe their intentions were good, but we don't necessarily get what we actually need from our parents. I can honestly say I feel pity for my father more than anything else. It's a cycle that's difficult to break. In a strange way, I think I was fortunate because it was very obvious that I needed help.
@Porthidium
12 күн бұрын
34:07 Damn man, this brought tears to my eyes. You worded that perfectly. As an former Christian father in a Christian family: thanks for doing what you do.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
appreciate that! thanks for being here.
@newme1589
6 күн бұрын
To point out what you said, as an ex hardcore atheist, now Christian: You not following Christ doesnt make you a bad father. If one of your children becomes Christian, and you're against that, thats another case. The priest that does evil but follows Christ, ending in heaven, is from what i understand, a bit of a strawman argument, because yes, path to heaven is through Christ. However, if that love for Him is genuine, you're not gonna do evil. And if you do, you repent and you always improve. So the priest that does evil, cannot have a relation with Christ, as He is described in the bible (it can be an imagined Christ to fit his needs, so therefore a false Christ) In your case, from what i understand, God is just. If you were given information about Christ and you reject Him for your own satisfaction/superiority/pride etc, then thats bad news. However, (i assume you did this) you looked at your life, at knowledge presented, and concluded Christianity is fake, however you will apply Christ teachings to your children (love, humility, etc) ... I cant say whats gonna happen, but i cant say you will go to hell, but because He is just, you will not get tricked into hell if you genuinely dont deserve it. Sorry for the bad experiences with Christians, as an ex hardcore atheist, i can always relate to atheists ! Take care 😊
@JumpyDragon56
12 күн бұрын
This was one of the biggest problems I have when I was doubting. There was no good answer to all the suffering and evil if God was as all-powerful, all-loving, all-forgive, all-knowing, etc. Thank you for talking about all the cop-outs that results in these questions. Huge like!!! I'm going to save this for future use because I know I'll need it in my back pocket.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Glad you found it so useful. Thanks for watching!
@iwilldi
12 күн бұрын
Just make god as foolish as causality and give god a companion Satan as unreliable as chaos and there you go.
@Hexsmasher2099
12 күн бұрын
Every single apologetic that tries nullify the reason for evil to exist is nothing but horseshit
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Agreed
@littlebitofhope1489
12 күн бұрын
Be nice. Horseshit is very useful and is good in the garden. It holds a lot of moisture. Use Carnivore shit as an insult because it stinks to high heaven just like apologetics. Pun intended.
@Uryvichk
12 күн бұрын
Many of them come from Alvin Plantinga. Hint: There's a connection between this point and your point.
@advocacynaccountablity
12 күн бұрын
That part.
@littlebitofhope1489
12 күн бұрын
Well, I don't know why you can say Horseshit and I can't. But here we are.
@funkypunkypine
12 күн бұрын
Huh, my bad. Here I am thinking that woodworking and sewing and skiing and reading and sculpting are things I can do to stave off boredom. If only I had known the only way to not be bored is to be bad I could have saved myself a lot of missed time and missed opportunity.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Yes how naive of you. Dont you know war and pain is all that is fun?
@ayemiksenoj5254
12 күн бұрын
The biggest problem with this "boring" argument is no one would KNOW life was boring!! All they would know is good and perfection is NORMAL! One of the major problems with evil is how NORMAL it is. Due to that we've become complacent, apathetic, disillusioned, hopeless, ect to the trauma, illness, pain, and suffering of others and at times ourselves. We've simply resolved ourselves to "it is what it is" because the world's issues are so severe what can we really do?
@CalamariPlaysStarfield
12 күн бұрын
As a dude with Autism, Hydrocephalus, Has lost both my brothers and my stepsister for reasons that we're totally out of my control, Has more body issues than I'd like to admit. I could do a better job than this God, blindfolded, hands behind my back, and with a full blown Concussion. This God can shove it
@joshuamoody7729
12 күн бұрын
I am also somebody that has autism, but I also have a rare disease on top of that called Tuberous Sclerosis that causes it. The main things I deal with are noncancerous tumors on my brain and cysts that grow on both of my kidneys. I have no doubt in my mind that I would’ve done a much better job than whatever supposedly created us. One thing I would do to start with as an example is: making it extremely punishable or hard for folks to get wealthy off of the backs of those who are suffering with an illness/disability no matter if it’s mental or physical.
According to the OC God made you that way and put you through all of that trauma because otherwise, your life would be boring! (Note he doesn't say who it's boring *for* )
@CalamariPlaysStarfield
12 күн бұрын
@@terrellkirkman2078 Than that God is an absolute fucking dick for even allowing me to be born in the first place, assuming it knows I would feel this way, and get a one way ticket to the burning place because he set my ass up. Again, this God can take it's plan, flip it sideways and shove it up his "All Powerful, All Knowing" ass, I would put all Good, but we all know that's fucking false
@quinn0517
12 күн бұрын
Autistic, narcoleptic, idiopathic chronic inflammation, and I need a heart transplant. At least that imbegar guy isn't bored though, right?
@Nick-Nasti
12 күн бұрын
Love your work. Summary of apologist arguments: “don’t think too hard about it”
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Thank you!
@BladeValant546
12 күн бұрын
This was my issue growing up as a Methodist preachers kid with a sick mom and being poor. I was always upset how my dad served and the Bible says he takes care of his own we always seemed to be struggling and my mom never was healed. Basically, I prayed and served myself even going to Bible school and always was met with silence. So if there is some plan I'm not aware of it. Not to mention the plethora of fictional universes that are awesome. Why didnt god make star trek, pokemon world, insert better worlds we created.
@terrellkirkman2078
12 күн бұрын
TBH the idea that God is a barely adequate software engineer who likes reality shows like Locked Up Abroad and 90 Day Fiancé over Star Trek and Pokémon makes more sense than most Christian apologetics.
@Chronorust
12 күн бұрын
The scapegoat for them in this situation is "it's god's plan that you suffer and things will eventually get ebtter" over and over until something finaly does go right, or it never does and that's also "God's plan". Like with what happen with the Trump rally atendee that died protecting his family from getting shot. Very convienant for them.
@kevincrady2831
9 күн бұрын
Why didn't he make a world without smallpox? _We_ managed it, and the universe didn't fall apart.
@terrellkirkman2078
9 күн бұрын
@@kevincrady2831 but imagine how exciting it is for him to watch and see if the ani-vax people can bring it back? Creating a world without small pox (or any other disease) is like creating a reality competition without an elimination ceremony .
@suicune2001
12 күн бұрын
One issue with the whole free will argument is desires we're born with. I was born with a high amount of empathy. I don't WANT to harm anyone. I feel bad when I make others feel bad. So, do I lack free will? Do people who are just genuinely really nice and good people lack free will? Do priests who prey on children have more free will than me when their actions are also a result of a desire they were born with? Free will goes out the window when we're not all on the same playing field.
@blueStarKitt7924
12 күн бұрын
Yes, but those who prey children are not born with that desire, if I get it right.🤷
@suicune2001
12 күн бұрын
@@blueStarKitt7924 Some probably are since it's sooooo widespread. Others it might be a consequence of their upbringing which they had no control over.
@blueStarKitt7924
12 күн бұрын
@@suicune2001 🤔
@jamie5mauser
12 күн бұрын
Dang even a world without human trafficking alone would be so much of a better place. And the lack of trafficking would somehow make this world boring? That’s a serious stretch
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
yup, its a truly gross excuse.
@firebornliger
12 күн бұрын
I do love how, in order to defend their "tri-omni" God, they have to make his utterly incompetent, moronic, and an absolute rat-bastard. Of course, the tri-omni thing is so obviously a retcon to the mythology, that it alone creates all sorts of issues in elevating a former war-god into the entirety of his pantheon.
@AssassinoJake
12 күн бұрын
14:29 "religion and philosophy, [but if you choose the wrong religion you burn for eternity]"
@DIYWeekend
11 күн бұрын
Judgement day won't be a theology exam.
@jordanrobinson9064
12 күн бұрын
As a quote from the fictional character in Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Fuhrer King Bradley once said: “God is nothing but a construct created by man to inspire fear and promote order”!
@iamdanielmonroe
12 күн бұрын
The problem with the “boring” issue he stated is that boredom is an emotion that we feel and perceive as the flawed and imperfect human beings that we are. If God made us perfect and content, we would not even fathom the concept or feeling of boredom because we would not want for anything outside of what was set before us and programmed into us. Sure it’s boring to “us” as we currently exist, but that’s because we crave drama, excitement, highs and lows in order to have a sense of fulfillment and value. Perfectly designed beings wouldn’t need that to even have a sense of something being boring.
@roykalager2360
12 күн бұрын
The people who think a peaceful world would be boring. Are not creative. People would be more open and fun in general. If they didn't have to worry about so many things. If they realized how much suffering stifles/restricts people.
@whitemountainapache3297
12 күн бұрын
Yes, pain doesn't bring people closer to God, but makes them angry.
@roykalager2360
12 күн бұрын
@@whitemountainapache3297 Happiness is a way better way of bring people together.
@michaelhenry1763
12 күн бұрын
I know right. That is why societies do not flourish is war zones.
@timothymulholland7905
12 күн бұрын
God's only fault, only weakness, that excuses everything, is that he doesn't exist.
@MarkMiller-gt5tu
12 күн бұрын
I'm never "bored" watching "mindshift"😊.
@CatDaddyGuitar
12 күн бұрын
Is there a sufficient amount of evil? 😂😂
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
lol thanks!
@charlesclaridy8646
12 күн бұрын
Definitely.
@johngavin1175
12 күн бұрын
I agree as well. This was a good one and a doozy,for sure.
@johnnybravo9972
12 күн бұрын
Comparing humanity to a computer program is so idiotic because the engineers can pull the plug or reset the program at literally any time, like God who is outside of Time and Space
@charlesclaridy8646
12 күн бұрын
God can't pull the plug or do a reset if he chooses?
@archapmangcmg
12 күн бұрын
They could also pull out one person, one instance of the code, run debug on it and do whatever changes, pop it back into a smaller simulation to see if the patch worked after running all their pre-checks, before putting it into general use. So damned many options for the engineers, including rewinding time locally (since they apparently have COMPLETE logs of everything already) or just .. yeah. God would have literally infinite better options than Original Sin, Heaven and Hell and natural disasters and all the BS.
@riseofdarkleela
12 күн бұрын
@@archapmangcmgthanks for this comment that warms my nerdy heart
@war6nheaven
12 күн бұрын
@@charlesclaridy8646it can't do anything as far as i'm concerned. especially when outside space and time.
@John-PaulHunt-q3z
12 күн бұрын
Just be the victim and they see you as weak minded and stupid not a savior to lead them! DUH!
@californiadoll6273
12 күн бұрын
You deserve an award!!! The way you use logic is incomparable to anyone else. You're definitely the #1 BEST atheist channel on KZitem!!! ❤
@Chuck-se5hh
12 күн бұрын
Indeed.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
far too kind, but thank you.
@Jake-zc3fk
12 күн бұрын
Yes he is!
@TaylorReedHudson
12 күн бұрын
Agreed. There are other atheist KZitemrs that I think might be a little more entertaining, but here he always gets straight to the point and hits the nail on the head so hard in ways that are just undeniable.
@Chuck-se5hh
12 күн бұрын
@@TaylorReedHudson Definitely true.
@TaylorReedHudson
12 күн бұрын
Hell isn’t for wrongdoers. It’s for non believers, regardless of how good or bad they were. The Bible makes that explicitly clear.
@BeccaYoley
12 күн бұрын
Bingo!
@Johnathan1800
12 күн бұрын
Do you not realize how screwed up that sounds though oh never mind I forgot you Christian’s don’t have an ounce of empathy.
@pratiwi16
12 күн бұрын
Exactly like what a childhood teacher of mine said... No matter how good you are as a person, if you don't believe in god, you will end up in hell.. But if you are a bad person and do lots of bad things, but in the end, you surrender yourself to god and ask for forgiveness, every bad things will be forgiven and you're gonna go to heaven My brain as a child could not Accept it, so does my brain as an adult now
@thegreatgazoo7579
12 күн бұрын
Let's see... God created hell because not believing in him is infinitely horrible, yet he isn't going to show you he exists well enough to make you believe......or......Priests invented the idea of hell in order to scare people into accepting the religion that supports them as priests. Which of these two is more likely?
@Johnathan1800
12 күн бұрын
@@TaylorReedHudson do you not realize how messed up that whole idea is so everyone that never believed in their particular god gets torched forever not very loving or just.
@ellyam991
12 күн бұрын
Imagine programming these simulations in a way where there's freedom, but only between good choices. There a bot could choose between excercise or visiting their grandma, we just erase the possibility of thinking about, oh idontknow, child abuse. No rewriting of anything, no monitoring bad thoughs, just not even having the capacity to from the get go. We could have greatness in exploring the universe, in developing art, in teaching one another stuff, all without things like cancer. Maybe the programmes wouldn't find such a world as interesting, but why is their opinion the only one that matters here and not the ones from their test subjects?
@DIYWeekend
11 күн бұрын
Good cannot exist without evil. If you could put a computer chip in your child's brain to force them to only ever do or be good, would you? Do you not see the ethical problems that arise when robbing someone of their agency? Would your kid be better off living like some sort of ant drone, only doing what you tell them to do, or would it be better if they had the ability to be evil but chose to be good instead?
@ellyam991
11 күн бұрын
@@DIYWeekend no. I'm not talking about forcing people to follow one straight path, but to choose between a giant collection of good paths. That doesn't take agency away, and makes for a better world where cancer and child abuse are not concepts one could even consider
@DIYWeekend
11 күн бұрын
@@ellyam991 good compared to what?
@ellyam991
11 күн бұрын
@@DIYWeekend against what god/the programmers knew could happen. They are said to be all knowing after all. If this seems strange, consider they designed a heavenly place where the good bots go where no evil happens, so they could've just done that from the start
@Uryvichk
11 күн бұрын
@@DIYWeekend "Good cannot exist without evil. If you could put a computer chip in your child's brain to force them to only ever do or be good, would you?" No, because I don't believe in violating someone else's consent, but you've poisoned the well by phrasing it this way. Let's remove the well-poisoning and ask the real question: Would YOU put a computer chip in YOUR OWN brain to force yourself to only ever do good? The answer is yes, yes I would. Obviously I would. Why wouldn't I? The chip makes it so that I can only ever do or be good. That's good, by definition. I want that. I SHOULD want that, because I should desire to do more good things and fewer bad things, and this chip lets me do only good things and no bad things. So obviously I should get the chip installed in my brain. Would you not? Why do you want the ability to do evil? What possible reason could you have for leaving open the possibility of not doing good? Do you WANT to do evil? You see, when the question is put this way, suddenly it no longer is quite the gotcha you might think it is. It is in fact perfectly rational to render yourself unable to do wrong and only able to do good. Everyone of sound mind should get such a chip installed, provided it is safe and can't malfunction and actually does what it claims to do.
@jmwild1
12 күн бұрын
God is perfect, I guess that makes Him boring. "But He's God so He can't be boring!" Special pleading!
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Indeed!
@kevincrady2831
9 күн бұрын
Also, he can't suffer adversity (well, except for that one time when he incarnated as a human and had a really bad weekend for your sins), so he can't experience strength, victory, or heroism. Glory hog that he is, that must make him utterly miserable. Maybe that's why he's such a giant torture-monster.
@jmwild1
9 күн бұрын
@@kevincrady2831 God's a diva. He also gets really jealous if you even look in another deity's direction.
@James-wv3hx
12 күн бұрын
And if God knows the future. Then he wouldn't kneed to spend All of his time keeping track of everybody's sins.
@johntiggleman4686
11 күн бұрын
@James-wv3hx BINGO!
@tonymiller3788
12 күн бұрын
Not all suffering comes from other people. Natural disasters cause plenty of suffering. Diseases and parasites cause suffering. Finitude of resources cause suffering.
@blueStarKitt7924
12 күн бұрын
Yes.😔
@future-ui2be
8 күн бұрын
here is where atheist completely are ignorant. The etherial/spiritual part of mankind, has a massive collective influence over the physical realm over time. So far a very negative one. This changes our biology, the physical events of the earth, our immunity against parasites, our ability to heal ourselves, to sedate physical pain naturally and causes us to age more rapidly, to be forced to eat more food, resources etc. It causes predatorial and poisonous creatures that reflect the evil of humanity on this world. Also in this fallen state of humanity, we are disconnected from our ability to perceive warnings and guidance from God and people in the spirit world in cases of natural desaster. The pure physicalism has left atheists completely clueless to any resolve for these "natural" desasters. Why does God allow the collective effect of human bad actions and attitudes to impact everyone on a physical level, isn't that unfair? Remember there is a long afterlife for everyone, which is the actual real Life, with your spirit body, your soul and chance for eternal Life with God. In the greater sceme, dropping the physical body is comparable to losing your milk teeth. Nobody complains "why is God allowing people to lose their first set of teeth" Now the most important thing here is to realize that I do not have to prove any of these things in order to show a philosophical defeater to the claim "A good God and natural desasters are incompatible" or that you are even justified to assume they are in fact natural. Philosophically that claim fails because there is still a lot of potential resolves to this. Fallen world and fallen Humanity. Ignorance about what humanity is, and that the spiritual aspect causes the physical to be the way it is. But scientists are getting more proof for that.
@AV-of6yj
12 күн бұрын
You know that feeling when someone says something and you go, “that’s exactly what I was thinking, I just didn’t know how to put it into words and articulate it”…that’s how I feel whenever I watch these videos. Thank you, Brandon🙌🏼
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
So glad to help vocalize!
@Dzemaily
12 күн бұрын
OMG.. so many valid points man.. Every Christian needs to watch this.. the only answer is to say ‘his ways are not our ways’ cos there’s no way to explain this logically
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Appreciate that very much!
@meertin298
12 күн бұрын
Pain could hurt half as much as it does and it would still provide enough evolutionary impetus for the species but would limit our misery.
@kettei7743
12 күн бұрын
Before going further in the video, one problem I found with ImBeggar's argument is the statement he does later on that a "permanent punishment" (alluding to eternal hell), this while small, is a devastating flaw because as you all know, no crime deserves infinite punishment. This is a problem that makes the PoS infinitely worse
@archapmangcmg
12 күн бұрын
Do you mean Problem of Suffering or Piece of Shit? I mean, the sentence works fine for both meanings!
@kettei7743
12 күн бұрын
@@archapmangcmg uhh, problem of suffering
@archapmangcmg
12 күн бұрын
@@kettei7743 Okay cos a being that would hurt someone (much less a lot of people) infinitely is also a PoS.
@BenJones-d8p
12 күн бұрын
Yea. The Christian argument fails when it comes to why people go to hell. Imagine: You told one little lie before you passed away. God: To hell for ETERNITY! It makes no sense.
@archapmangcmg
12 күн бұрын
@@BenJones-d8p Meanwhile, you're sentenced to go there for lying to Nazis to protect Jews. And next to you, a career politician who told nothing but self-serving lies. God's "justice"!
@goldenalt3166
12 күн бұрын
Proposal for free-will preserving world patch 4.0: 1. Children under age 3 are immune to natural disasters, infection and cancer. 2. A person who's suffering can accept heaven and immediately die. (Engineers confirmed these patches don't break free will or turn everyone into robots.)
@adriani9432
11 күн бұрын
Why only children under the age of 3? Why can't everyone be immune to cancer?
@goldenalt3166
11 күн бұрын
@@adriani9432 Apparently, some people may want cancer, or to cause cancer, or to overcome cancer, or to cure cancer. I figure 3yo is about the emotional age of Adam and Eve's sin so we start getting into conflict with the Bible at some older ages. Apparently, God is mighty invested in free will until you die.
@James-wv3hx
12 күн бұрын
This is a perfect example of why I believe that it is All made up to scam people out of their money 🤑.
@n.c.1201
12 күн бұрын
@@James-wv3hx Exactly. All the way back to Ananias and Sephira!!
@justanotheropinion5832
12 күн бұрын
Money plays a role, but politics/power is the raison d’être. Kinda convenient how god always favors the victor, and the victor is always the good guy.
@tradergirljam
12 күн бұрын
Scamvangelism in a nutshell 😂
@ulysses7653
11 күн бұрын
I think religion was the first attempt at answering questions. It was the first attempt at philosophy. But as the age of religion increased, so did the number of opportunists and conformists.
@Anyox17
12 күн бұрын
Brandon!! This really is your magnum opus. So eloquently and intelligently articulated. It’s very interesting that suffering is what seems to make so many people turn toward/need religion. It was the opposite for me; facing the realities of immense suffering is what made me turn away from religion altogether. The magnitude of suffering that exists in this world should be enough to break any theological spell a person may be under. The fact that people see this suffering and double down defending god, even becoming pompous and narcissistic about it is absolutely mind blowing. Maddening and sinister! Thank you for your stellar work. Your channel has become my favorite!
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Thank you for all that very lovely feedback!
@saifernandez8622
11 күн бұрын
Thats the point, when you overfocus on your own suffering and feelings (narcissism) you belive on a personal being that somehow gives meaning to your life. when you focus on the whole picture, other people and creatures then you stop believing in personal gods.
@infinitedeath1384
10 күн бұрын
@@MindShift-BrandonI can't help but reinforce the point. This may be the best video that any Atheist could possibly make, I really don't see anyone doing a better job than you.
@SydBodeker
12 күн бұрын
Hearing problem of evil apologetics makes me wanna stick tooth picks in my eyes. Great video so far, every point you're making is on point. I appreciate you and what you do
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Same, its just so inexcusable. Thank you!
@justadude7752
12 күн бұрын
Ok but right from the beginning: no, if I was a PERFECT being I wouldnt even have the desire or want to create anything (nevermind not be able to create something without suffering). Because me just being me is perfect enough as is. No need for anyone or anything else👌
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Exactly! I get to this for sure
@justadude7752
12 күн бұрын
@@MindShift-Brandon guess I spoke to soon^^
@airbus7373
12 күн бұрын
Makes sense but ultimately they means you wouldn’t be here
@justadude7752
12 күн бұрын
@@airbus7373 yeah, and it wouldnt hurt me one bit, would it?
@airbus7373
12 күн бұрын
@@justadude7752 indeed, if that's how you feel, then there are options available. Options that I and everyone else would never want you to take. But also options that can heal you and make you come out the other side, like I did. I just can't fathom a world in which we don't exist. Bodies trapped, in nothing but blackness, without the ability to do anything.
@martin2289
12 күн бұрын
It's impossible to make sense out of nonsense, which is what all religious apologetics try doing but always fail at miserably.
@aaron_thatsmyname
12 күн бұрын
28:09 "Oops! Does that offend someone?" Had me rolling. It is so ridiculous when you say it out loud. Thank you for continuing to take on subjects like this. It is so helpful in navigating the BS engrained in my thinking.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Lol thank you!
@DavidRichardson153
12 күн бұрын
"You know there's a saying among us veterans: 'For those who had fought for it, life has a special flavor that the protected will never know. You have never lived until you almost died.' And it is us veterans that pray for peace most of all, especially the wounded, because we have to suffer the wounds of war." - MSgt. Roy Benavidez "This special flavor sucks. Inflicting suffering upon others is the perfect spice for me." - God and IMBeggar, apparently
@DoloresLehmann
11 күн бұрын
Just to answer one of the many questions you asked: What rate of people going to hell would make the experiment worth it? None. One person alone going to hell would render the whole thing a failure. I say that as a Christian.
@karenlankford8558
12 күн бұрын
My version of the problem of evil has always been: Why do animals suffer? If you want to say that human suffering is caused by human sin (original sin or otherwise) or that suffering was necessary for human growth (intellectual or spiritual), then why do dogs get cancer? Why do birds and every other animal suffer from parasites? Why do wildfires burn dear and koala bears to death? Even if you can make some kind of excuse for human suffering, why do animals have to suffer? What good can possibly come from an animal drowning or dying from dehydration and thirst?
@BeccaYoley
12 күн бұрын
Great point!
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
1000%!
@Llortnerof
12 күн бұрын
Especially from animals that never even get anywhere near a human, so their suffering has no impact on us.
@Uryvichk
12 күн бұрын
The old answer was, and I'm being quite serious here, that animals just couldn't suffer. You basically have to deny that they can to make any sense of these theodicies. The problem is, people darn well know their pets can suffer, and research has shown how insightful and empathetic some animals are (such as crows). Everybody knows animals can feel pain, so the question comes roaring back.
@MrBBaron
12 күн бұрын
That is one main argument against a benevolent deity. I love animals. As a child, I could not understand why a god would create a world in which animals had to be killed for other animals to survive. Even the intense suffering and savagery the animals endured such as being eaten alive made me realize that there is no loving god. It is really a brutal world. Also, the vast destructive natural catastrophes that continually plague our planet prove there is no god that gives a crap about his creation.
@CatDaddyGuitar
12 күн бұрын
Haha, so the "engineers" who can intervene into the thoughts of their "robots" have to have a mediator now to communicate their thoughts and intentions for them? Perfectly logical conclusion.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
lol! yup
@johngavin1175
12 күн бұрын
I dunno if I considered it clever or obnoxious how he just slid robot Jesus in there. 😂
@RegalLouise247
12 күн бұрын
I think the "you'd have done it the same way" argument is so privileged. Imagine going to a starving child in Turkana and tellin him, "if you had God's power and were the one who made it, you'd have made it so you'd still have to slowly starve to death ".
@Shventastic
12 күн бұрын
I just can't understand the lack of imagination that goes into how they would create a world different than the god of the Bible. "Nope, ship shape!"
@brenatevi
12 күн бұрын
They are benefitting from the way the world is, so any change is seen as an attack on their benefits.
@archapmangcmg
12 күн бұрын
Omni-impotence and omni-incompetence are the hidden attributes of their omni-god.
@ziploc2000
12 күн бұрын
I sometimes use the expression god-goggles, but really it's god-blinkers or a god-blindfold. Once you lock your thinking into "god-dunnit", and that god is a tri-omni god, you have to ignore a lot of things to retain that way of thinking. It curtails curiosity and imagination.
@hamobu
12 күн бұрын
If suffering is the result of free will, I wonder if there's more free will in Sudan then in Sweden.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
really interesting point that would be fun to play with.
@airbus7373
12 күн бұрын
Admittedly I have a friend from the Dominican Republic, going to college in the US, who says there’s more free will there, although it’s less safe. People do get used to their environments
@michaelhenry1763
12 күн бұрын
Ironically, people in dire, suffering situations have less free-will, not more.
@JamesRichardWiley
12 күн бұрын
Pointless suffering perfectly cancels out the claim of a loving, compassionate all powerful god. God does not "allow" suffering, He CREATES suffering. He is the Creator of all things. The twisted logic of mister anonymous @imbeggar is a perfect example of what religion (god belief) does to an otherwise intelligent person. This is how you share and spread cognitive dissonance.
@blueStarKitt7924
12 күн бұрын
😔😔😔
@NightmareRex6
11 күн бұрын
well humasn free will cause lots the suffering, God is reponsable for etenaly roasting in hell tho for not beliving right "faith"!
@biologezwei
12 күн бұрын
28:59 Oh my god, this is so funny. "The world is unfair, but afterward, there will be perfect justice." For me, that has always been the biggest tell that this was a religion invented by people. It is the ultimate revenge fantasy. "Yes, everything is unfair now, but just you wait! In the end, the bad people will get what they deserve, and you will be rewarded!" It's pure cope.
@JoshuaMakar
12 күн бұрын
Imagine you write an AI and instruct it to follow some rules, like, "Tell me how great I am every day." That AI then has a bug that after 1999, it resets to 0, and now day is returned as false. The AI then stops saying, "You are so great," every day. Instead of fixing the bug or deleting the AI, you begin feverishly writing another component that when the AI's life counter reaches zero, the code sets the AI's pain value to 1 and then exits.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Great example
@TaeyxBlack
12 күн бұрын
this is one of the biggest points of double-speak in christianity: adam and eve were terrible sinners who wanted to go their own way and defy god, sinning against a perfect being and dooming all of humanity to death and eternal suffering. through the exact same action, they were also responsible for instantiating the very element necessary for the best possible world, saving us from a life of robotic boredom. they are simultaneously our undoing and our saviors.
@williammcfarlane6153
12 күн бұрын
The analogy I always use is that if I were to put my kid in a room with teddy bears and knives... Would I be responsible for him cutting himself or would he be?... We all know who would be rightfully held responsible in our society even among the religious, but the religious do not hold their deity /father to the same standard.
@balanc-joy9187
12 күн бұрын
They absolutely refuse to under any circumstances. I liken the "God needs us to have the choice to love him or disobey him despite all the good he does for us and how much he loves, and it still isn't his fault for suffering and Hell _isn't_ infinite torture" sort of thing I've heard before with this analogy: A parent has a small child, and the parent chooses to leave the back door open every day. Every day, they shower their child with love, affection, and warnings to _never_ go out the back door because there is a dangerous road that will get them killed. One day, the child does go out the back door, and gets killed. The authorities find the body and immediately go to arrest the parent. The parent defends themselves, with genuine tears in their eyes and grief, but also anger and outrage at being arrested, "I didn't MAKE them go out into the road, that was just a _test_ I NEEDED to know whether they loved me or not, whether they would CHOOSE to stay with me always or not. I am NOT responsible for this, this was _their_ choice!". One way to add on to this is to put a second child who's slightly older, and tries to ask questions about _why_ the road is dangerous, or how to better avoid its dangers, and what the parent's big plan for their life is and how things work, and the parent just scolds them and gets angry, yelling "My ways are not YOUR ways, you CAN'T understand anything like that, stop asking questions and just obey me!" The point of analogy is-Would the parent _genuinely_ be not at fault or not? My answer, and the sane one, is yes, of course they would be in the wrong. I wish I could test how a theist would respond to this. I know it isn't perfect, and probably could be improved quite a bit, but I like what I've come up with so far. I know they'd try in some way to argue that God having more responsibility, which is the point of the above, is not applicable until they were blue in the face, but I'm curious how they'd put it.
@genomasmysteriousbr5100
5 күн бұрын
@@balanc-joy9187i would tell you the following. The way my parents, very catholic and all have raised me, they would not leave the door open. Nor would they leave me out of their sight, without knowing for sure i wouldn’t be able to even attempt to go to that back door. I guess from that alone, they are already better parents than God himself. Reading many, many comments in this video, i really get one of the many problems present at hand: The lack of actual good education and conditions to grow up being taught well without tragedies happening to you or your family, or without having horrible parental figures. On that regard, i don’t think i’ll stop fully believing at least in some regards of the bible, though i understand that you don’t need to be catholic/christian to do good acts or be a good person, or on the angels, as if you think about guardian angels, they can somewhat also be an extension of you in spiritual form, or you talking with your own spiritual beliefs and reassuring yourself. As we are humans and have the need to Believe in something, i’ll wager that this is an acceptable way to exist. The most damning point for me in all this is that, really, when you stop to think about it, by not believing in God, you deserve hell. And i used to believe that you could only be judged by what you knew, so someone that wasn’t taught anything couldn’t be judged. Yet, canonically, before Christ’s coming, pretty much everyone went to Limbo at the very least, since there was no salvation. Furthermore probably any who do good things but don’t believe in God would go to hell then. So that means that i can help as many people as i can, save my friends from suicide and do whatever i can from the goodness that i know i can do, yet at the end deserve hell if i’m like “hmm, you’re not really a good example, God. I decided to live life in a good way and i’m happy with what i chose, since they are things considered good by most, if not all. If i go to heaven? good. If i don’t? Then i suppose there was nothing worth looking forward to, and my last act will smile, having done what i believed in during life, not expecting any reward at the end.” If i go to hell for this, then.. as some have said, i suppose heaven wasn’t all that jazz to begin with. I do want to believe in purgatory and that good people despite not necessarily believing, go to heaven, but i can’t help but somewhat feel i’m a bit naive in regards to all the theological discussion going on here and out in the world. And the factual evidence present. I really want to believe that not all was written clearly and we’re missing some information, or bad people, maybe the devil himself has distorted passages so that our logical brains would be irritated. I truly don’t know what to believe, except in myself and the empathy i was taught to have. But even that goes down the drain when you consider the Lucifer Effect, described in a book with that same name. Basically, it doesn’t matter if i was taught to do good. I can still be distorted and broken, and turn into a completely different person. Or well, act differently, by tapping in some obscure truths about myself that hide deep in my mind that i don’t give credit to. So what does it matter at all? What if everything is a human construct? I’ll choose to believe, as we all must, that i’m doing what i want to do, and that it is right. Others can and will disagree with me, and that is all. There is no absolute truth, only laws we believe. I hope this ramble can suffice as the insight of a brazillian catholic, which is a country with many religious beliefs among its populace, mostly revolving around christianity and some ramifications. I hope you and other readers have a good day or night wherever you are. I have no powers to do anything, but i can pass that hope onto you, if you’ll receive it.
@balanc-joy9187
5 күн бұрын
@@genomasmysteriousbr5100 You're clearly a very rational person who is more enlightened about the difficulties of religious belief. It's clear this is a struggle for you, and I wish I could help. I wish you the best nonetheless. You're answer is fascinating, and I'm glad you gave it. You aren't really the type of theist I'm talking about though for testing this though, I mean the ones that would believe all of the terrible things you've noticed without a flicker of doubt. I'm glad you had good parents! If only we all were that lucky... As to your rant, just to give some brief replies to some of it: Yes, going to Hell, or as it's formally called, the Problem of Hell and all its facets are a HUGE problem with Christianity and other various denominations of the faiths worshiping Yahweh. It simply does not make sense that a God that loves us in a genuinely caring way, at least by today's standards, would be so controlling and selfish to torment anyone forever, especially for the crime of not believing in Him. Even worse that there isn't some clear as crystal evidence that he _does_ exist, if believing is so important. It's a narcissistic and petty choice by what is supposed to be a loving father. I hope you keep doing your best to make your life, and the lives of others, brighter, healthier, and happier!
@Nero-Caesar
12 күн бұрын
The amount of suffering that happened on the island of Haiti/Hispaniola alone is enough to show this god is not all loving or all powerful or either. From human caused suffering to 250,000 people dying because of an earthquake.
@blueStarKitt7924
12 күн бұрын
😔😔😢
@Venaloid
12 күн бұрын
I think the analogy of a computer simulation really obscures the fact that we're talking about thinking feeling beings here. I think most people, if faced with the choice of creating one of those two simulations, if they were reminded that these are real thinking feeling beings they were about to create, would create the perfect first world to avoid having all the blood on their hands from the other one.
@Charlotte_Martel
12 күн бұрын
This truly is your best video, Brandon! Mazel tov! You could not be more correct: if an existence w/o suffering is "boring" (the most insipid excuse that I've ever heard), then how will that change in heaven?
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
appreciate that so much!
@dasbus9834
12 күн бұрын
Conscience as proposed by Christianity is putting a bias into people's thinking and behaviour. That's already infringing on free will, regardless of how subtle it may seem. So much for the "absolute control" vs. "absolute freedom" dichotomy.
@widescreennavel
12 күн бұрын
In Exodus, God clearly states that if "God lets it happen" a murderer can go to a designated safe zone. That's pretty on the nose.
@VelmadeM0naco
12 күн бұрын
It would a good idea Brandon to do a separate video on the zoroastrian influence on Christianity, esp given the problem of evil argument.
@chig0mate18
12 күн бұрын
imbeggar used to be my go-to channel when I was a Christian so I was READY for your response to this video
@thomashugus5686
12 күн бұрын
You sir are my favorite anti-apologist!! Extremely well presented, logical and rational!!
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Thank you so much for that!
@BeccaYoley
12 күн бұрын
17:42 Great point! If suffering is necessary for happiness, then why do Christian parents strive to keep their children away from harm?
@jtmusson
12 күн бұрын
The idea that suffering leads to greater enjoyment is psychotic and sociopathic. We know that trauma is always negative and experiencing a traumatic event can, at worst, haunt someone for their entire life, or, at best, shape years of their life. The argument that suffering builds character is a ridiculous, naive, outdated comfort to a person of privilege. Take it from someone who’s experienced trauma and who sees the effects of trauma on others every day.
@Karessertin103
8 күн бұрын
Some of my family members died and my religious friend has the audacity to say it happens for a reason.
@studiosandi
12 күн бұрын
I'm like 3 seconds in, and I'm already annoyed with his pomposity.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
i wish i could say it gets better!
@tradergirljam
12 күн бұрын
"Pomposity"...let me dictionary search for definition 😂😂😂
@davebowman760
8 күн бұрын
That's the exact word, thanks!
@jerrycasper614
12 күн бұрын
Finally found someone who has wrestled with many of concepts that are problems in every religion. The one concept I can never understand is "eternal punishment". What would be the point of it?
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
to make people who want to get even feel better, thats literally it. Its quite sick.
@infinitedeath1384
7 күн бұрын
@@MindShift-BrandonI personally think it's even more sick that a pedophile could go to heaven if they repented, but an honest hard-working man with a family, who has never in his life hurt anyone would go to hell just for not believing in God.
@26beegee
12 күн бұрын
I don’t know anyone who doesn’t believe the world could be improved. That guy either has no compassion or no imagination - or both!
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Oh i hear you but you might be surprised. The “best of all possible worlds” argument is way more common of a response to the problem of evil than it should be. Essentially the idea is that god knows and has a plan for every single amount if suffering that occurs and has tuned it just right for maximal good in a free will system.
@tonymiller3788
12 күн бұрын
Suffering and evil make perfect sense in an indifferent naturalistic universe. I don't have to jump through a single hoop to explain evil and suffering in that world view.
@smidlee7747
12 күн бұрын
This is false. In order to suffer you must first be alive and conscious and there are the two areas naturalism completely fails to explain. There is no natural explanation of pain and suffering since it's part of our conscious perception. Naturalist can't explain what makes pain so painful.
@tonymiller3788
12 күн бұрын
@smidlee7747 obviously some living thing with a goal to stay living must exist before any notion of good or bad makes sense. Good and bad are subjective and thus require a subject. But naturalism easily explains all of it. I don't see where you can't comprehend a natural explanation for pain. Evolution by natural selection almost guarantees it. Any living thing that willy-nilly does things that cause it harm is not going to be around for long. But organisms that sense harm and react to avoid it will be more likely to survive and reproduce. There's no problem with a natural explanation for why pain exists. There's even a condition in humans where the person feels no pain and they have to be protected and watched closely because they will badly harm themselves otherwise. From the National Library of Medicine: Congenital insensitivity to pain and anhydrosis (CIPA) is a very rare and extremely dangerous condition. People with CIPA cannot feel pain. Pain-sensing nerves in these patients are not properly connected in parts of brain that receive the pain messages. CIPA is extremely dangerous, and in most cases the patient doesn't live over age of 25. Although some of them can live a fairly normal life, they must constantly check for cuts, bruises, self-mutilations, and other possible unfelt injuries. Self-mutilation is an almost invariable feature of this disorder, most often involving the teeth, lips, tongue, ears, eyes, nose, and fingers
@smidlee7747
12 күн бұрын
@@tonymiller3788 Naturalism doesn't explain life nor consciousness. There is no natural explanation for pain. Evolution doesn't explain anything about pain. We already have natural reflexes without the need for pain. Your eyes will automatically close when something threaten to enter them for example. Pain as I see is part of conscious perception which there is no naturalistic explanation. Yes, there is a serious problem why pain exist under naturalism.
@raptormage2209
10 күн бұрын
@@smidlee7747Its an alarm or warning, thats the goal of pain. It can also be used to identify aflictions like Apendicitis.
@smidlee7747
10 күн бұрын
@@raptormage2209 You can have an alarm and warning without pain. That surely doesn't explain what pain is and how we experience it. Naturalism doesn't explain what pain is. We have reflexes that happens automatically without the need of pain.
@michaelhenry1763
12 күн бұрын
32:51 excellent breakdown of the problems of heaven and hell as a way to reduce chaos. Now the engineers still do not stop the chaos in their world, they just bring the “ good” ones to their first world that they previously deleted.
@ReasonQuest
12 күн бұрын
Brutal honest insight, Brandon. Excellent video. Your point about natural disasters could have applied to question #6. "If all the bots freely chose to follow the protocols, or Him, would there be any evil and suffering?" Well, evil (depending on how it's defined) no. But suffering, yes, because there are outside influences not controlled by the bots, nor written into their protocols (that the engineers allow), such as natural disaster.
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Thanks so much!
@TheRatzor
12 күн бұрын
Suffering is in this world because of SIN! also make zero sense! One of the things that bother me so much is why does God allow one person to suffer so much who is good but another person get a fantastic life - not a good person or vice versa - I can't defend God when it comes to suffering because saying it because of sin or free will is a cop out maybe there is something we don't understand but nope not going to defend it
@michaelhenry1763
12 күн бұрын
If we take Genesis 3 literally, we have suffering because we were cursed by YHWH. We did not sin. We were cursed.
@2pacaveli257
12 күн бұрын
Good comment 👍!
@JDC2890
7 күн бұрын
As a Christian, I can certainly understand the 'maybe we don't understand' part, but I sure cannot defend God's ways. Why? I'm not omniscient and cannot see what allegedly perfect master plan he has in his mind that fully justifies all of his behaviour as 100% morally good. I'm baffled and in the afterlife I want answers. If he can't prove what he does is actually fully justified, then nope, not going to trust him.
@michaelhenry1763
5 күн бұрын
@@JDC2890 that is a good answer. However, is not the afterlife too late to decide whether YHWH should be trusted or not? Would YHWH, allow you to leave heaven if you decided you could not trust him?
@moon_0207
12 күн бұрын
I’m just appalled. That they think people suffering is entertaining to them. That’s just a truly evil and wicked way of thinking. Plus why the hell would you want to go to heaven then? If you think suffering, war, and evil is entertaining then why the hell would you want to go to heaven. A place without suffering. Wouldn’t you be bored?
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
Exactly
@maggiebarrett7300
12 күн бұрын
But there are some theologians who say that the inhabitants of heaven will be entertained by watching the horror movie of hell; “The sight of those tormented in hell will enhance the happiness of the saints in heaven” Jonathan Edwards
@clarkkent2379
7 күн бұрын
When I had cancer, it sure wasn't boring, but I'd trade every moment of that excitement for nice, boring health and ease.
@BluStarGalaxy
12 күн бұрын
In Imbeggar’s example he has the individuals given the concepts of right and wrong when they were created. So not like the Genesis account where knowledge of right and wrong is only obtained after eating from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. You need knowledge to be able to resist the temptation but the temptation is the knowledge. Insane.
@niddy-2.0
12 күн бұрын
Not to mention that post-fall, whatever the "embedded goodness & evil" software patch is an absolute joke. PROVE that all societies, for all time, didn't accept at least ONE violent, oppressive, dismissive, ignorant with no ability, or understanding to push back on it. They may have some consensus on some, but the point is one disables the patch for that time & place.
@norrecvizharan1177
12 күн бұрын
I know right, and that’s on top of how ridiculous it is to put the “do not touch!” Tree right smack dab in the middle of their living area (aka the garden).
@BluStarGalaxy
12 күн бұрын
@@norrecvizharan1177 Yep, putting the tree there and then creating the snake to tell them to eat from it. Seems like this deity was literally doing everything in his power to make them disobey him. Omniscient yet pretends like he is giving them a choice. He knew what the result would be. It’s like a game of “how can I mess with them to keep myself entertained.”
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
yes, quite a few times he was unwilling to have it all start as poorly as the perfect god of his religion did.
@BluStarGalaxy
12 күн бұрын
@@MindShift-BrandonI bet it was very intentional also. He didn’t pick the plan in Genesis because it would make his deity look bad. He picks a different one. How can one improve on perfection? 🤪
@WilliamDavis-lf5bq
12 күн бұрын
Thanks so much for these... they've helped me explain things to my family
@MindShift-Brandon
12 күн бұрын
My pleasure!
@Kveldrunari
12 күн бұрын
The only thing I can think of is that eternity is long and gods get bored. Gods always have to shake things up to keep interested in the sitcom of their creations, so they throw evil and disease and natural disasters to spice things up and make the drama more interesting
@sorryifoldcomment8596
12 күн бұрын
I get that for Gods which aren't all-powerful...but an all-powerful God can't get bored. It has the power to prevent boredom! And it definitely has the power to erase any boredom that for some reason it allowed itself to begin experiencing. The idea of an all-powerful all-knowing entity being actually bored, uncontrollably (which is a necessary characteristic of "boredom"), is ludicrous. It's so clearly humans projecting human problems onto God. I don't think believers have taken the time to actually contemplate how they would experience being infinitely powerful, omnipotent, and omnipresent, for all eternity. I truly have done my best to spend time contemplating the concept and even trying to imagine such a state of existence is wild.
@ajharris2690
3 күн бұрын
@@sorryifoldcomment8596 erase the consept of boredom from themseIves
@aliasfakename3159
12 күн бұрын
When I play the Sims or a game that requires me to look after virtual beings, I like to make them happy. For example, if a city of mine is starving or sad in Civ 6, I'll build them stuff. God is omnipresent, omnipotent, omniscient. He could totally end all wars and mind-control billionaires to distribute their wealth but he's not. He could snap his fingers and grow a billion trees or remove CO2 from our atmosphere to fix climate change. But he's not
@pratiwi16
12 күн бұрын
It means that this god is using his power to create chaos / be a bystander and still shamelessly demands us to worship him.. Yuck
@darbymori350
12 күн бұрын
It was this exact line of thought and painful, personal cognitive dissonance that led to my eureka moment realizing 'there is no god' last year.
@jackgreenearth452
12 күн бұрын
Also you're not even god in civ6, You didn't create the world or the rules, but you still have a certain degree of power and use it for good. Imagine if you were designing the world and rules of the game too how much better it could be. You wouldn't need to exploit your people for ages using their production to build scientific buildings to achieve scientific 'victory' by launching some satellites. You don't need to go through a series of bad governments before getting enough civic points to get Communism/Democracy. You don't need to fight others, even to defend yourself, as they wouldn't fight you. For that matter, you wouldn't have one chosen group of people you were involved in, you would represent everyone.
@infinitedeath1384
10 күн бұрын
I liked to build walls around them or purposely cause fires 😂. It wouldn't be funny if it wasn't a video game though, and if it was real I'd never do such a thing.
@timschantz3233
11 күн бұрын
Knowing this scenario isn't real gives me great relief.
Пікірлер: 2,3 М.