As an Israeli, what really saddens me is that the kinds of people who need to see this would never watch it, saying something like "Why would I waste my time on that anti-Semitic garbage?" Only people who already have misgivings actually try to look into it.
@middleagebrotips3454
2 жыл бұрын
Sounds a lot like China: If you criticize the Chinese government policies you are racist against the Chinese. Authoritarians governments like to do that.
@GotA_Bot
2 жыл бұрын
if u live in israel i am a fucking egg.
@danielzak4405
2 жыл бұрын
@@GotA_Bot I currently live in Cambodia, but am still an Israeli citizen.
@dBO123
Жыл бұрын
So I'm an Israeli too, and I wouldn't call Israel an apartheid state myself. Still watched it. It didn't really change my mind. I guess you already doubt how brainwashed or dumb I am, but let me explain anyways. First of all. In Israel - he claims that the definition for apartheid is that it has the intent to create a system of domination againt the palestinians, and that Israel is doing so by wanting a jewish majority. That is not the case. I myself am quite torn about the jewish majority. In one hand I want jewish people to have a place which they can be safe in. Maybe it's the history of my family in poland and Iraq, but I can't easily shake that feeling away. On the other hand, it's impossible to maintain jewish majority when the arab population growing faster, and we can't and should not take measures to prevent that. Point is, the jewish majority thing isn't about dominating, it's about the need to have a safe place - so it's not fitting his apartheid definition. He also brings up israeli politicians who shout out some awful shit, but that's politicians being politicians. There are also arab politicians in the Knesset who shout out some awful shit too. Palesitinians can't get back to their homes is another claim. Both my family and I can't return to our home in Iraq or Poland also. That's not something exclusive to Israel. All that being said, there are still some issues like the *temporary* law in which the partners of Palestinians can't get citizenship. The reason why I highlighted temporary is that it was supposed to be temporary but always gets elnogated. That needs to be changed. Wouldn't call it apartheid tho, as spouses can still enter and live in Israel in an all around all year permit called "family reunion", which I was printing tons of in my service at COGAT. When you talk about apartheid in the west bank and Gaza - the way I and most other Israelis see it is that they are not citizens of Israel - hence no apartheid. Which is true. Doesn't mean we have no responsibility over them, and we should strive for improving their well beings. Palestianis in both the west bank and gaza don't see themselves as Israelis citizens too. A big majority wouldn't take Israeli ID if they were offered one. And the average Israeli wouldn't want them to take it anyways since it A. lowers the jewish majority. B. They see most palestinians as terror supporters. There is nothing Israelis hate more than terror supporters.
@dBO123
Жыл бұрын
What really saddens me is that most of the people won't read my comment too saying something like "why would I waste my time on that pro-Israeli garbage?" Only people who already have misgivings actually try to look into it.
@noahschwartz1222
2 жыл бұрын
Will just say I respect you leaving the comment section open to comments VERY critical of your perspective and points!
@LIETUVIS10STUDIO1
2 жыл бұрын
No joke, this is a great video. I had traditionally been on quite the sceptical side of the assesment of Israel as an apartheid state, in part due to people and rhetoric used to introduce the claim - often by either Leninists or Hamas apologists. Since you are quite clearly neither and give an actual, concise and fair breakdown, I think it is fair to say that yeah, systemic, instutionalized apartheid is in fact part of Israeli laws (and also history of state actions). This genuinely kinda shifts my assesment of the conflict. I have previously talked about the idea of a federalized Levant under the framework of Israel, but it is pretty clear that such can only happen when Israel stops trying to enforce an ethnostate. Though it is less prominant in this attempt today, it still very much is there. Prerequisite to the peace process in my opinion, is a system where if say some Arabs or some Israels ended up in the "wrong state" (given a 2-state solution) thi wouldn't be a horror show. Until Israel gets rid of ethnic discrimination, this is not possible.
@xXFebo92Xx
3 жыл бұрын
Great video! The music is a little bit too loud, but that's the only real critique I have right now. Really enjoy your content, keep it going!
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
Thank you, I’ll make sure to lower it next time
@newsaxonyproductions7871
2 жыл бұрын
I concur that the music was too loud, but only slightly so, I think
@bly2790
5 ай бұрын
Nah I loved the music volume was just fine
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
If I had to describe this video, it is essentially an 18 minute long attempt to get people to read the HRW report.
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
@@מ.מ-ה9ד Did you read the report? Did someone other than me read this report?
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
@@מ.מ-ה9ד how abt this, join my discord and dm those critiques and I will read through them and see if they are relevant
@modesskiy774
3 жыл бұрын
@@beacebrocess keep us updated on any of the points if relevant. Ill see if I can get some reading in tomorrow.
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
@@modesskiy774 nothing has been dmd to me
@modesskiy774
3 жыл бұрын
I read the whole thing and gotta say, your video is a decent representation of it, at least as a good introduction level to understand this report. The details of the report are admittedly like stats for each player and of course, may require some additional research outside the report to paint the picture a bit clearer for some folks who are curious. However, as is, the article is merely an argument for citing Israel as committing an apartheid by international law. I might make a smaller version of notes on this in the future, just so that those who didn't read the report actually end up reading it fully. (Because 60 pages of reading doesn't get into the juicy bits.) ;)
@GwainSagaFanChannel
2 жыл бұрын
This has been very informative and educational. Great work of effort you put into your work I hope it pays off for you.
@Michael-do2xf
2 жыл бұрын
First off, I really liked the video. Great visuals and concise information. A few things I'd like to add if I may: Apartheid was a system characterized by a policy practised in South Africa, and as you dutifully point out it's not possible to do a one to one comparison, as then the term wouldn't be strictly appropriate. Why not used the term that is unabashedly accepted and which means the same thing: Hafrada means separation in Hebrew and is the institutionalized policy of separation between the Palestinians and Israelis. The term is tailored to the situation, use it instead of Apartheid. Not every genocide is the Holocaust, but every genocide is bad. Likewise, not every system of institutionalized separation is Apartheid: in this specific case the term that should be used is Hafrada. Another thing I'd like to add is that I'm disappointed by the lack of context: this conflict is complicated, the region is complicated, and imposing 21st Century humanistic morals on the situation is at best anachronistic. One could begin with the rise of nationalism, paralleled to the numerous persecutions of Jew around the world, giving rise to the idea that Jews too could have their state. They felt vindicated when years before the state even existed Jews were expelled from Iraq, chased out of Hebron, massacred during pogroms, and all that culminated with the Shoah. And it didn't end there, during the Naqba, the untold Naqba, 80'000 Jews were expelled from Arab-held Palestine and became refugees in Israel. (For a strange reason, they were assimilated out of refugeedom into the new Israeli society: the Palestinians evicted during the same Naqba, half of which ended up within Palestinian territory, never were given the same privilege by their own people and remain refugees 5 generations later, but that's a story for another time). 850'000 more Jews would be expelled out of Arab lands during the next years, and all were granted unconditional access to Israeli citizenship. Israel was fulfilling its role, and filling a need: the need for Jews to have a land to call their own. How could we have ended up with any other system considering the situation? There are no more Jews in Arab lands, nor will they ever return or be compensated. Many Jews saw an opportunity for payback by grabbing onto as many hilltops as possible after the 1967 conquests. The more the better, before peace can be signed. But peace was not to be. Most Palestinians today unequivocally reject Israel's existence. A minority consider a two state solution based on an outdated situation that doesn't reflect the reality on the grounds any more. In any case, they won't accept nor consider any less than what they today officially claim, which is a right of return into Israel, Jerusalem as capital (including the Jewish quarter and kotel) and a return to the lines of 1948. According to polls, only a minority actually wants that, many are willing to consider the offer only as a trampoline to get more, to eventually reconquer all of Palestine, from Nazareth to Haifa and to Jaffa... You can't fathom what it is to be born Israeli today. We've inherited this whole mess and have no idea what to do with it. Peace on our terms is rejected, while we reject peace on their terms, which from our point of view is no peace at all. Why would we abandon our gains and high ground if it means losing the tactical advantage and potentially inviting unwanted influence into the region? (Iran...) We have enough enemies to deal with without having to deal with another militia so close to our heartland. We've disengaged from Gaza and there was no blockade. Rockets were launched and suddenly, blockade. Violence is all we know so our only answer is violence. Political rights are to be earned, some would say, and not by consistently relying on shows of violence the likes of which the morally complacent West has never known (waves of suicide bombers and sleepless nights of rocket rains) Palestinians will never be granted any form of autonomy as long as they reliably prove to be mortal threats. Also, did I mention there is no real "We" to even speak of? "We" have presented 40 different political parties at the last elections, "we" are divided into many coalitions and ideologies that all want different things, although one thing is clear for most if not all Jews: we'll never accept a situation in which we'll be threatened again, in which we'll have the weaker hand. We will never be able to build up the political capital required to effectively abandon our tactical advantage by unilaterally disengaging from the West Bank and uprooting hundreds of thousands of Jews in the process, there is too much inertia and the status quo is preferable to a risky change of paradigm that would see the whole West Bank become one big Gaza. I wish the situation were easier. I wish the Palestinians had accepted a Jewish state back in 1948. I wish we would have had the wisdom to unify under a single, more rational binational banner, but we haven't. We're more attached now than ever before to the illusion of our identities, what it means to be Jewish, Palestinian, Arab, Israeli that it's hard to see a solution on the horizon. I wish that Gaza had become a Singapour of the Middle East, a shining beacon of democracy and peace: but it became a fascist, Islamist haven hell bent on the destruction of Israel. The situation you've described is terrible, but that's only because the whole conflict is. You decry the judaization of Israel and Jerusalem, but omit that the opponents did just the same: the islamization of Jerusalem during the years preceding 1967 involved the destruction of synagogues and the Jewish quarter. It's the grim reality on the ground, that this conflict is sectarian in nature and thus such policies are common on all sides, let's at least accept that reality and not unilaterally point fingers. Peace
@beacebrocess
2 жыл бұрын
I'll respond to the points that pertain to this video. Should we call it hafrada instead of apartheid? it doesn't make a difference, the important thing is whether or not it is a crime against humanity which I think u agree w. Intl law, specifically the Rome statute, uses the word apartheid not me and not anyone else. They attach the word apartheid to a description of the policies described in this video and in its provisions, so naturally that is the word that is used. The importance is that a crime is being recognized. if u want to call it hafrada go ahead, so long as u recognize it as a crime against humanity still
@Michael-do2xf
2 жыл бұрын
@@beacebrocess Thank you for replying. Your video unfortunately didn't do what it purported to do, ie figure whether Israel was guilty of the crime of Apartheid. You've made the case that it is the case. You haven't however provided any counter-arguments to then conclude whether you personally believe whether it is or not. That's unfortunate. Let's imagine the case of the nuclear bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. One could show only one side and conclude it was indubitably a crime against humanity. That would be odd, and would lack context. If one would also provide context, and explain the counter-arguments (such as the loss of life that an invasion would have incurred), suddenly the picture becomes less black and white. You have chosen to show only black, whereas the reality is grey. It's a choice I respect, but at least change the title of the video to "Why I think Israel is guilty of Apartheid without having bothered with the counter-arguments, which I can simply brush away as hasbara I guess". I'm in any case subbed and will follow your work. Good day kind sir
@ChangedNames
2 жыл бұрын
Simply saying "separation" is an understatement to what the palestinians are experiencing under zionist terror. Secondly, If jews desire land they should not take it at the cost of others. And if you want revenge on those who wronged you then look at Europe, arabs and muslims tolerated you the most and you always have backstabbed us. Once again "Institutionalized separation" is making light of the situation, why would the Palestinians be a part of unified government with you? if you treat the ones in your territory so harshly (and dont get me started on how you treated them back when saddam was throwing missiles) Also you dont need morals from a certain century to realize what is happening here, its cant get anymore white and black, oppressor and oppressed (simple its doesnt have to be a philosophy)
@ChangedNames
2 жыл бұрын
Also funny thing about you supporting the judaization of "israel" and jerusalem is equivalent to you supporting what the iberians (and many other europeans) did to muslims and jews where the forced them to convert, leave or die. I guess when you guys do it its different? I guess youre are the Chosen people after all
@ShnoogleMan
2 жыл бұрын
@@Michael-do2xf He did provide counterarguments. He highlighted the common counters that Israel is not *exactly* like South Africa and that Arab Israelis have legal equality. I consider myself a Zionist (at least in the classical sense of the term anyway; fuck the bastards who ruined Zionism) and I think he did an excellent job highlighting the issues with the current State of Israel and explaining how its actions constitute apartheid.
@nocturnenugget
3 жыл бұрын
Thanks for covering such a heavy topic. I appreciate your work on this a lot.
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
Thank you, I hope I did it justice
@צאדמגה-צאד
2 жыл бұрын
So in short... yesn't'yes? By the way, great video. I see you put a lot of effort into the drawings.
@newsaxonyproductions7871
2 жыл бұрын
Omg, yes. The drawings are so good, actually illustrating the issue well and definitely providing life to the otherwise kind of dry summarization of a long document
@danido9938
3 жыл бұрын
Great video. I've been aware of the actions committed by Israel in the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem for awhile but I was hesitant to call it apartheid. It is only recently when I realized the massive inequality in which Arab citizens of Israel live under which was what broke the camel's back for me. Hopefully the new government can deal with at least some of these issues. I'm optimistic.
@teardataco8913
3 жыл бұрын
If you mean racism inequality then yeah racism exists everywhere but other than that arabs with Israeli citizenship live exactly like israelis.
@danido9938
3 жыл бұрын
@@teardataco8913 nope. That's not true
@teardataco8913
3 жыл бұрын
@@danido9938 it is though...
@yko_7313
2 жыл бұрын
@@danido9938 it's true this video is misleading as hell and uses a biased source.
@alrighty4456
2 жыл бұрын
@@teardataco8913 even Israeli academics would disagree with you
@2027frfr
3 жыл бұрын
I can’t believe this channel doesn’t have more subs, I subscribed
@Adelink_lol
2 жыл бұрын
The world needs more nuanced thinking like yours; its the only way we’ll solve problems. Usually I see far too many ignorant and biased takes from both sides that do nothing to help because by denying any given internal problems, you drift farther away from a solution.
@anneboleyn1357
3 жыл бұрын
Incredibly well-researched, great visuals. Obviously it's a complex issue but you gave a good starting point for more research.
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
Yes, pls someone other than me read that god damn report lol, thank u for watching pls subscribe
@anneboleyn1357
3 жыл бұрын
@@beacebrocess Already subbed, will (try to) read the report. Lots of people aren't great readers, some need visuals like this video!
@anonymousnoodle8445
Жыл бұрын
Thanks for covering this topic
@KommentarSpaltenKrieger
2 жыл бұрын
In short, Israel tries to maintain itself as a Jewish state with a comfortable Jewish majority. For this purpose, the movement and settlement of Arabs will be restricted (at times severely), which is only possible via granting them fewer rights, both formally and materially. Hardliners even try to enlarge Israel to the detriment of Arab populations (see settler movement, mostly dating everything back to history), and the state does seem to favor them vis-a-vis the Palestinian locals. (Whenever hardliners succeed, Israel is enlarged, but at the same time, it also "receives" a higher share of Arabs, which then leads to calls for more containment measurements and for harsher politics vis-a-vis the non-nationals.) For all the alleged "complexity" of this issue, this basic point seems easy enough, no? The principle which ties everything together here is "demographic control" in an area formerly inhabited by an other national group. This very principle makes almost everything that happens in Israel on a big-picture scale very understandable. As long as this dispute is not solved and the whole situation is not stabilized, we are still grappling with the consequence of the problem that there wasn't a Jewish homeland for millennia. Only if Israel has a secure existence and only if Palestinian Arabs are rectified in some sense, politics in Israel can cool down and normalize.
@ShnoogleMan
Жыл бұрын
I think the issue is that there are basically two mutual exclusionary nationalisms. Historically not all Zionists and Arab nationalists held an antagonistic view of each other- sure, there were disagreements, but that didn’t stop many from dreaming of a society where the aspirations of all were realized. However, throughout the mandate period, escalating violence made the hardline position the norm for both groups to the point that in 1948 Jewish forces were pushing out Arabs and Arab forces were pushing out Jews out of the fear of the other guy taking control and being a continuous threat. Obviously today the dynamic isn’t even. Israel holds all the power, and is using it to oppress the Palestinians to maintain control, and a lot of that oppression is unjustified, but some is based on the very real and legitimate fear of what could happen if they let down their guard, and what would have happened over the decades had the other side won. The only way I see this ending well is if somehow binationalism is renormalized among both populations, but that seems highly unlikely.
@funveeable
Жыл бұрын
If the one thing all of Israel's violent enemies have in common, is that they are Arab. They would be fools not to use that fact to keep their people safe. That's why Isreals airports are the safest in the world.
@oryxcalrissian6917
Жыл бұрын
@@ShnoogleMantrue, but their fear of what happens if they’re not the majority is no justification to practice what is essentially settler colonialism. Not saying the Jews need to leave, but you can’t just erase the fact that many Palestinians live in refugee camps in Jordan and Lebanon, while still owning the keys to the homes and deeds to the lands that were stolen from them. Any plan for peace would have to include the right to return,or at the very least substantial compensation to the Palestinians must be made, in addition to ending the settlements and allowing Palestinians to actually participate in the political system that oppresses them.
@ShnoogleMan
Жыл бұрын
@@oryxcalrissian6917 I agree, it’s no justification for a lot of the shit they’re doing. My point was that there’s no real easy fix for everything, at least not short term. Long term I’m a binationalist though, and short term I do think we should do everything we can to stop the worst actions of the Israeli government.
@daddykipperflipper4600
4 ай бұрын
@@ShnoogleMan We have seen recently that Israeli citizens are just as intoxicated on the power as their government. Something radical will have to come here, this is madness that we are still discussing a 2 state solution after almost a century of inhumanity.
@nashleef
2 жыл бұрын
Commenting for the algorithm. Also subbed!
@jeyolikemayo
Жыл бұрын
Goes to show, no matter the history, oppression or status you have had, a group will always have the capabilities to be evil.
@TJ-ij2rd
3 жыл бұрын
I came here cause of its unique style of teaching history and modern day problems
@danido9938
3 жыл бұрын
12:29 this law has been overruled by the supreme court
@jabobok786
3 жыл бұрын
I’m so glad H0ser recommended your channel
@thundermanmcbunbun4799
3 жыл бұрын
Came here from there as well
@papastalin7705
3 жыл бұрын
Me too
@alucard347
Жыл бұрын
This is an interesting piece of knowledge. My assumption about apartheid was that if it has a legal definition (which it clearly is), it would be difficult to apply it to israel because of the fact that Palestinians get different rights depending on the different places they live in, with the gaza strip effectively being a blockaded foreign territory rather than an incorporated part of israel. I will also argue that because israeli soldiers cannot enter gaza without a fight, it would be impossible to classify gaza as an occupied territory, since the assumption is that if you occupy a land, you control it, and while controling water, electricity, and everything in between give you a lot of power, it doesn't mean you actually control that land. Overall, a very interesting video!
@smorcrux426
3 жыл бұрын
Hey, not anything political but I was going to read a bit about this HRW before reading their report, and I just noticed one weird thing that confused me: Robert L. Bernstein, who founded or was very important in creating the HRW, is very often quoted against the HRW in the Criticism of Human Rights Watch Wikipedia page. How can that be? Not to offend anyone, just confused.
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
That may be but first and foremost we must judge the content of each report. That’s the primary concern
@smorcrux426
3 жыл бұрын
@@beacebrocess yeah, I was just doing song background checks before I'll start reading the report. BTW, 200 pages is too much for my little brain, is there any shorter version of the report? Like a summary for policymakers?
@krecioks2598
3 жыл бұрын
Great video although in my opinion you should have defined what’s apartheid at the beginning more clearly
@sertralinadeavena
Жыл бұрын
Is there any book that you can recommend to learn more about this?
@jonyprepperisrael60
2 жыл бұрын
now it raises some questions: how many other countries currently have apartheid? cause one can make the argument towards USA,Canada,Syria,Turkey,Iran,India,Pakistan and China,and probably more countries. which makes for another questions, what does it mean for the world if so many countries currently have apartheid,and what does it mean for Israel in that context?
@williamthebonquerer9181
2 жыл бұрын
India and Pakistan would be apartheid due to Kashmir
@williamthebonquerer9181
2 жыл бұрын
As well as Russia easily with Chechnya and it's nations within nations
@cme5673
3 жыл бұрын
You teach more than my teaher
@stylianstamatis8000
3 жыл бұрын
Amazing art!
@jonyprepperisrael60
2 жыл бұрын
what do you think about arabs in Israel that dont see themself as palestinian,but as Israelis? and what do you think about the lawlessness in the Negev that resulted in major bedoin familys arming themself and engeging in what is essensaly tribal wafefare? but other than that,great well made video.I have some disagreements but overhall I respect your position.
@yamen2903
9 ай бұрын
because Israel deleted most of our identity, hi Palestinian born in Israel with an Israeli citizenship here. Israel ever since its existence has attempted at deleting the Palestinian nationality and identity from its citizens, be it by banning the flag, destruction of villages, construction of kibutzem above those villages in attempts of deleting that history, and much much more.
@hothdog
2 ай бұрын
nas daily?, nah, he's a hypocrite
@Indian_Marschall
2 жыл бұрын
By contrast we call Pakistan as aparthied state
@jakobhopfer1997
2 жыл бұрын
FYI my parents are South African Jews and left in the 1980s. The Amnesty report didn't make the splash they hoped for (outside of the usual suspects) and it's largely been ignored or condemned as nonsense. They used such a loose standard ('apartheid' meaning merely "oppression") that it could apply to nearly every nation, but as usual it's one standard for Israel and another for everyone else. For example in Lebanon, Palestinians cannot buy property outside their refugee camps, hold citizenship, vote or work certain jobs, but you know fine well Amnesty would never in a million years call that Apartheid. The whole purpose is to put a negative label on Israel to encourage their isolation, the entire report and the timing is calculated because of the Abraham Accords and the growing investment and normalisation in the Middle East had made the same old pro-Palestinian narratives obsolete, so they're scrambling for a nuclear option.
@gusgrow9768
2 жыл бұрын
TO be fair that is what the UN use in its definition.
@philo9046
2 жыл бұрын
we can discuss what lebanon is doing and i to some extent agree with you that palestinians in lebanon are treated like shit but remember that has nothing to do with israel being actually an aparthide and ofcourse israel gets bad reputation because there are literaly millions of people "palestinians" who are pushing for their cause to be recognised even the ones in lebanon the palestinians in lebanon want their right of return to their homeland which Israel ethnicallly cleansed them from which Led them to be at mercy of the lebanese socity which is racist to syrian and palestinian refugees.
@philo9046
2 жыл бұрын
it really amazes me how you guys hate palestinians and hurt them and at the end cry antisemitism when they speak against you .
@mohd8218
Жыл бұрын
Maybe if Israel lets the palestinians go back they wouldn't have to be refugees and treated the way they are in lebanon. Besides, the abraham accords did a really great job in normalising ties with the governments but in all but 1 the people are still clearly pro palestine and refuse to recognize israel.
@reddragon3163
Жыл бұрын
@@philo9046even more irony is the support for Ukraine
@SomasAcademy
2 жыл бұрын
"I will never make a video this long again." So that was a lie lmao
@beacebrocess
2 жыл бұрын
My next video is gonna be nearly two hours long so yeah lol
@elhood5469
3 жыл бұрын
I love your vids! Your drawing style is awesome! But I would like to give some (hopefully helpful) constructive criticism: you sound very monotone during the video. You should try to be more emotive when you speak, you might want to try to overemphasize some of your emotions.
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
Thank you for the critique and thank you for your appreciation, I will try to be more emotive next time. make sure u subscribe tho lol or there might not be a next time
@dmman33
2 жыл бұрын
I appreciate that the performance style is less emotive. The internet has enough emotion!
@beacebrocess
2 жыл бұрын
@@dmman33 when ur understood
@SolarFlareAmerica
3 жыл бұрын
So by this metric, with it's reserves, is Canada an apartheid state, or could it have ever been considered one? I think so, in a sense.
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
I’d have to look into it but overall I will always respect and encourage bullying Canada
@SolarFlareAmerica
3 жыл бұрын
@@beacebrocess my country has so much potential. Such a shame it continues to exist in apathy to better possibilities. Loving your work, btw.
@SolarFlareAmerica
3 жыл бұрын
@@beacebrocess honestly the further I get into the video, the more and more examples (at least historically, if not outright recently) I can draw from to support the conclusion that the answer is yes.
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
@@SolarFlareAmerica if you are convinced from what you have read I’d be interested in seeing your sources. Would you mind sending them to me in discord?
@SolarFlareAmerica
3 жыл бұрын
@@beacebrocess ah I don't really have any sources, it's mostly just stuff I've learned throughout my life about aboriginal experiences in Canada, online and verbally, since the news doesn't tell you much. Take ramming an illegal pipeline through wet'su'weten territory while the international human rights organization and UN both condemn it as an extremely blatant act of settler colonialism. Or, if you want a more established example, try the fact that the reserves STILL EXIST at all, and the people living in far too many of them have little to no access to basic human resources like clean drinking water, and decades, sorry, centuries of liberal/conservative government handwaving at the problem like it will magically go away, all while going after residential school survivors in court. The trickiest part I can think of to calling Canada an "apartheid state" in the modern day (historically I feel it's entirely true I'd you look at Canada's residential school policy ALONE) is nowadays Canada doesn't have, to my knowledge, any legal framework for the systemic ethnic eradication of aboriginal peoples living in Canada. But there have been, localized, unconsentual and unknowing forced sterilizations. Add the very real racial and systemic violence and discrimination, and top it with the severe lack of opportunities presented to the first peoples, and I can say with full confidence that Canada is 100% a white supremacist state, if not an apartheid state. Because the thing is, Canada already achieved apartheid goals, and now exists st a point where the aboriginal people are so disenfranchised that any space outside of the isolated reserves is dominated by white or "anglicized" (or quebecois-ized?) people, and their representatives, like the Palestinians, are mostly unable to change anything.
@Benedek1st
Ай бұрын
why is evry sign in israel on arab hebrew and english?
@marwanv2363
3 жыл бұрын
Incredible 👏🏾👏🏾
@OSD001
3 жыл бұрын
I Support Palestinian Indpendance.Just like All of the people of my country.Morocco
@Yah474
6 ай бұрын
Of course it is.
@jebbo-c1l
29 күн бұрын
if it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, its a duck
@honeybeechanger
4 ай бұрын
Okay I might be making a comment that contradicts what you're saying but I have to say that I really love this video even if I disagree with some parts of it I think that it's well made and you produce a a factually based argument. I love it! Okay yeah well I'm Jewish and I tried to make Aliyah to Israel and I had to prove that my mother was Jewish by proving that my grandfather was buried in a Jewish cemetery and my mom had to prove that she had a Jewish upbringing. Bad proof had to be approved to buy a rabbi. I can't help but try to find an analogous situation in the who's the world to the creation of the state of Israel and I can't think of anyone Nation more analogous to Israel than Pakistan. It is an ethno-religious state that was specifically created for the exact same reasons that Israel was created several months before. I mean the partition plan for Pakistan India was technically in 1946 and the partition plan for Israel Palestine was in 1947. Both of the people requesting the partition the israeli Jews and the Pakistani Muslims each couldn't see themselves in a democratic country as a minority. Can you tell me what Pakistan would do if a bunch of Hindu Indians wanted to have the right of return to Pakistan?
@Whatever4867
3 жыл бұрын
Yo beace, what's the name of the song?
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
which song?
@Whatever4867
3 жыл бұрын
@@beacebrocess the song used in the video
@modesskiy774
3 жыл бұрын
@@Whatever4867 The dramatic music piece is Dvorak's New World Symphony. Not sure about the rest.
@MrMineHeads.
2 жыл бұрын
Hey I would appreciate if you could share the sources you used for this video
@beacebrocess
2 жыл бұрын
in the description
@amnont8724
2 жыл бұрын
The definition here is pretty bad and these ministers were pretty racist. I am an Israeli and I think the nation state law is provoactive and should be changed. But if apartheid means ensuring the domination of one people over another so aren't the Gulf States and other countries in the Arab world apartheid states too? Isn't every ethnostate is an apartheid state then?
@UnionPacific2014_
2 жыл бұрын
Keep kvetching jew supremacist
@amnont8724
2 жыл бұрын
@@UnionPacific2014_ With Anti semites like u don't wonder anything changes on the ground.
@deli_isle
2 жыл бұрын
how many other nations are unabashed self-declared ethnostates the likes of israel? there aren't many arab nations that I know of who currently evict and displace residents and citizens solely due to their ethnicity, and if there are who do they would be diplomatic pariahs.
@amnont8724
2 жыл бұрын
@@deli_isle Israel doesn't displace them but he complains about the fact that it wants the Jews would remain a majority and not anyone else. And tell me how hard is it to become an Emirati or Qatari or Bahraini citizen? Where's the outrage as Lebanon and Syria treat their Palestinian refugees as 2nd class citizens?
@amnont8724
2 жыл бұрын
@@deli_isle Kuwait displaced its Palestinian population after the Gulf War. Any intenrational outrage against Kuwait?
@spaghettimon3851
2 жыл бұрын
Yes!
@ketch_up
2 жыл бұрын
In fact, the first Israeli Apartheid Week was organized by the "Arab Students Collective" at the University of Toronto in 2005. This was, however, the same year as the launch of the BDS movement.
@_golden_9626
2 жыл бұрын
I love to hear the statements of people that disagree with me, and I understand that this video is too short for a topic like that could miss some points. I tried to be open minded, since I really appreciate your work, but I can't ignore how biased this whole video that meant to pass a specific message. Can't blame you, here I am with my also pretty biased counter. I think Israel is being as fair as it possibly can allow it self to be (since Israel is still having an ongoing war). I meant no offence, just a counter argument, keep up the good work, all the best. ------------- 6:36 For that part, to 'Judaize' could mean many things. Mainly when people here are saying that, it isn't to kick out that Arab living in the area, but to encourage more people from central areas to move to other parts of Israel, to develop and yes also to be used as a shield against potential arab insurrections and terror attacks since isolated villages are always a good place to store weapons and other illegal things, as what happens in the negev with the illegal Bedoin 'villages'. About the Bedoins, when they were talking about 'our country is getting stolen' is because many Bedoin families create illegal Bedoin settlements in the desert, connect illegali to the electricity, and again being used as a great place for crime families.' Our country getting stolen' was said because they literally act without any regards to the laws, shoot with M16 on the roads, harss people with their reckless driving, upload that shit on tiktok and run back to their isolated village in the desert. And about the birth rate, I really can't recall what happened with that topic, but for now birth rate in Israel is higher for the jewish side, so I guess their problem got solved. - 7:30 That's the first time I'm hearing about that, because I know which law it is and it just meant to determine that Hebrew is the official language of the state and the jewish faith is the official faith of Israel, so by that this law is just a statement that never got added (and politically meant to show that Israel is strongly against the idea of a one state solution) , it didn't really affected or changed really anything of how Israel operated. - 7:44 recently many "family reunifictions" got accepted by the Israeli government, I mean it is a problem, but Israel can't allow it self to be nice or fair in giving out citizenship to people that could be influenced or used by let's say 'radical movements' from the place they mostly coming from and risk them committing 'acts' or helping the local 'radical movements'. In almost every democratic country you got minority with minority treatment, and many times it ain't fair because for an example they can't get citizenship easily as the jews but that ain't a sign of an Apartheid state because it is possible to do legally. And about the people the came from family reunifiction, -out of my experience -when I interacted with few locals from a village in the north, they say that the people that commit terror acts majority of them are outsiders, people that came from family reunifictions. - 8:08 I didn't understand what you meant by that, but I can say that in the kneseet with a FEW arab representatives across multiple parties that strongly speak about the jewish connection to the land, supporting terror attacks publicly, and ain't afraid to put out speeches in the knesset in the middle of everyone denying the Israeli legitimacy. - 8:17 It makes sense, they ain't doing that directly and and if it's a private person or cooperation they got every right to decide to who they are selling the land to.It makes sense because arabs would tend to be less loyal to the state so why should that state aspair to give them power? that state gives them the minority rights that lets them govern the lands they already own (villages, cities) with their culture and language. And many parts of the lands was already purchased by private jews from arabs, for an example Caserea, bought by the Rothchild family. - 9:00 I mean, that's wrong. At least by what documented only two events in two different villages in the north suffered from an ethnic cleansing and soldiers were jailed, and fact still stands that the arab countries exaggerated about ethnic cleansing and mass killing to get public attention and help against Israel. Palestinans just were sure that there's no way a little just born jewish state can win against 6 arab organized armies, the Palestinians were promised that they will soon get back to their homes after the win, that's why they left. They didn't want to get involved, simple as that, people do that in a war, the problem is that no peace agreement was signed in 1949 it was ceasefire, that means they can't go back to their homes since there's still clear hostilities. - 9:25 ... so when do the jews that bought land in Syria, west bank, Jordan (with clear proof) gonna get it back? the jewish owned lands in Germany, France and Spain? the answer is never. As one person said, the biggest problem of the radical Palestinans is that they can't move on, millions of jews had less than nothing after ww2, but they still moved on to establish themselves. While there's still many hostilities between the two people there's not a chance, But that mean Israel is an Aparthied state? because they refuse to give back land to people whose leaders that represent them refuse to acknowledge an Israeli state and negotiate with them? - 10:30 again minority status in a democratic state - 10:56 For an example the recent massive despuit over houses in east Jerusalem. The jews legally owned the houses that got taken from them under the jordainan rule that gave it to the Palestinans, they couldn't demand them while at that time because it was under jordan, now they demanded it back. In matters like these you can clearly see, jordan favored other arab group over the jews in matters of land, but when it comes to Israel.. that's an aparthid. - 11:07 that topic now very associated to politics, right will give out less to the arabs, left will give our more, because they know what kind of support to their power they'll get out of it. the majority just opposed to an idea of any Palestinan expansion under Israeli rule. it's more of a political tool than a will to opress not jewish people, you can't help it, much of what Israel does is associated with its inner politics. - 11:37 the odds are they were demolished as kind of the punishment for terror attacks. Instead of expaling the attacker's family (where it will hurt the most) Israel just destroys his house, and many many times even that doesn't happen, over thousand of terror attacks were committed in jeruslam alone over the years.. - 13:13 an attempt? it was just a populist move, it was obvious he will never do it, because it would bring many problems, like what to do to with the arabs living in the annexed lands? can Israel support so much people? he just said he would and let it fade away just to boost his support. - 13:40 there's a difference between C,B,A areas.. so yea in C area in which is the jewish majority it's like that, but hundreds jewish settlements are destroyed by the army while the PLO builds without problem in the C areas, against the Oslo agreements with EU money, but somehow the IDF and Israel let's it slide, it's weird. In C area since it's under Israeli law and majority Palestinans their are not their civilians, they can't rule them under regular civil rule. - 13:58 what do you mean they don't have free speech? what? so why am I hearing every evening about them all the time in my Israeli TV, why I always hear about how evil the settlers are and how some times the Palestinian 'youth' sometimes stab jews (but reported only about what happens outside of the west bank), hearing their complains on how they need to go through a checkpoint the go through Israel territory or to go to work in Israel(I mean that's why borders are for). - 14:00 You want him to get a warrant for arrest after he stabbed or threw a Molotov on soldiers? sounds rediculous, the soldiers now anyway are tied to very strict rules that forbid fire unless in a really life threatening situations unless ordered by high commend (very rare), but that's it's when too late to react, and they go back home either with broken teeth, almost burnt or barly alive really, because they're more afraid of going to jail, remember that the service is mandatory, so Israel just sends it's own sons to get killed by mobs. With jews sudden terror attacks like that are non existing, so if a settlers commits a crime the idf able to get a warrant for arrest, but with the Palestinans a action is required on the spot because these are different actions and events. - 14:18 Settlers can't enter the A areas at all. They also pass through checkpoints but they got their Israeli citizenship. - 14:55 both sides are committing bad things, there are radical settlers that are aggressive and hostile and there's also radical Palestinans that are aggressive and hostile.. - 16:08 ignoring the side of Egypt completely, ok. Controls the airspace and the transit? Airspace? the one with flying ebay drones, ballons that set fields a blaze and rockets? what transit? the west bank cut ties completely with Gaza after Hamas took over -------
@robertortiz-wilson1588
2 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much for taking the time to write all this! I agree!
@jasonfrancis9262
2 жыл бұрын
You are an apartheid denier on the level of holodomor deniers.
@subifyouhatetiktokandreddit234
2 жыл бұрын
@@jasonfrancis9262 Yeah you didn't read his comment
@crediblesalamander8056
2 жыл бұрын
I don't understand how you can "both sides" Israeli settlements, they're illegal. There shouldn't be settlements in the first place, that's the bare minimum for an actual peace negotiation. But that's beyond the realm of possibility for Israel. Even if you assume that Israel treats its Israeli-Arab citizens completely fairly, How is there any way that the conditions in the West Bank or Gaza are anything short of Apartheid?
@khaledaldekaer8459
Жыл бұрын
That's so cute! 2018 the nation state law was concerned about the languages, ZOG bots are cute
@01iviaa
Жыл бұрын
why did i get an advertisement for "israel foreign affairs ministry" on this video
@mahnas92
2 жыл бұрын
Great video, I have only watched two of your videos so far an wish to giv so feedback, since I believe good content with bad execution/presentation undermines the content's potential. many times I have been confused with lack of sync between "infographic" and what you're saying. E.g when you talk about WB, Gaza shows up, when you talk about Gaza, E.Jerusalem shows up, etc. But the more unbearable element was your very heavy american accent. It is not the american accent itself, but rather the very slurry pronounication! Your talking pace is optimal, but if the slurry pronounciation can be eliminated by you talking slower and clearer, that would be a better option to go by. Thank you for doing this video! 🇵🇸
@Eliran-z7q
2 жыл бұрын
this video is definitely way too pro Palestinian, in the last half of the video you kept talking about israel's "illegal" settlements in the west bank, although, the Palestinian authority AGREED to give Israel 60% of the west bank which is where the settlements are, so showing the entire west bank as "Palestine" and showing Israel taking from a land that's ALREADY THEIRS is just false information, you've done a terrible job speaking the facts and rather showed whatever you want the viewers to think. and did u think that the reason Palestinians in the west bank don't have equal rights and freedom of speech is that they are NOT ISRAELI CITIZENS but rather "palestinian" citizens belonging to the terror group called "the PLO"
@BenjaminStruthers
Жыл бұрын
Where did they make such an agreement, and if so, what were the circumstances?
@Eliran-z7q
Жыл бұрын
@@BenjaminStruthers 1993 oslo accords. Concequences are very complicated you can read about it if u want
@hothdog
2 ай бұрын
@@Eliran-z7q besides the fact that that was the closest thing they could ever get as a state, a bantustan(after years of rioting and revolutions mind you), and besides the fact that settlers has been confiscating land and stealing homes with the support of the IDF from that 40% left for palestine ever since... i guess that palestinians were just ungrateful brats, huh... /s and also, te PLO is widely not accepted among palestinians aswell, y'know what happened when they got a chance not to get ruled by it anymore... , and let's say what you said IS true, that the PLO is a terror group(it's not), israels still basically controls ALL OF THE west bank, that 'terror group' basically has no authority in that land, and therefore , those palestinians are to be considered 'citizens' of israel(if you plan on staying on the west bank and east jerusalem which you should not) and should at least vote and has similar rights to the arabs in israel...
@puffydadestroyer9632
3 жыл бұрын
Epic video keep up da good work
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
Thank you very much! will do
@Aiham
2 жыл бұрын
Yes
@MaccabiHaifaVideos
3 жыл бұрын
NO
@il967
2 жыл бұрын
Yes
@harrisrobin
2 жыл бұрын
Great video
@Benedek1st
Ай бұрын
is gaza apartheid?
@dirtyox6862
3 жыл бұрын
Love Israel from Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦❤️🇮🇱
@papastalin7705
3 жыл бұрын
Stfu troll
@thealligator918
3 жыл бұрын
Love Saudi Arabia from Israel! 🇮🇱❤🇸🇦. My best friend is a saudi
@aslav162
3 жыл бұрын
Paid hasbara
@teardataco8913
3 жыл бұрын
@@papastalin7705 you're the troll here.
@thesaracen3992
2 жыл бұрын
typical zionists troll
@williamthebonquerer9181
2 жыл бұрын
What Israel is doing in west bank is what Russia did in Chechnya just slower and with less artillery
@perniciousseizurehellio3438
2 жыл бұрын
Eh I dont know. Is it? Israel is essentially practicing colonialism slowly making more and more settlements and pushing more and more palestinians out
@williamthebonquerer9181
2 жыл бұрын
@@perniciousseizurehellio3438 what do you think Russia did in Chechnya
@perniciousseizurehellio3438
2 жыл бұрын
@@williamthebonquerer9181 russia bombed the shit out of Chechnya and killed a bunch but did they move in a bunch of russians? I dont really know that mucu about the conflict
@williamthebonquerer9181
2 жыл бұрын
@@perniciousseizurehellio3438 they did. That's Russia's MO. Russia always sends Russians to settle conquered land. In the 40s they deported 2/3 of Chechens and settled the region.
@williamthebonquerer9181
2 жыл бұрын
@@perniciousseizurehellio3438 en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circassian_genocide this is Russia's mode of operation
@benahiezer2295
2 жыл бұрын
So, after seeing all of the video I have a few things to mention: In your video you didn't mention the main reason Israel does what it does. The Palestinians would never be satisfied, once they would have the west bank they would ask for east jerusalem and once they would have that they would ask for all of the land. Every Palestinin government has said that this is their end goal. It's because of this reason that Israel doesn't want the Palastinies percentage in the population to grow. It's afraid that the Palestinies would take over and then do with Jews as they wish. And it's a reasonable concern as Hamas which is the de-facto ruler of Gaza shoots thundsunds of rockets into Israeli cities. Aiming at civilians. Now the issue of East Jerusalem is quite simple. Jerusalem was and still is the capital and cultural hub of the Jews for over 3000 years. East Jerusalem in particular is the home of the old city and most importantly The western wall which is the only holy site in Judaism. Almost all Israelis agree that east Jerusalem is not negotiable. In 1949 Israel controlled West Jerusalem and Jordan occupied East Jerusalem. which led to a population transfer between jews who lived in east Jerusalem and Arabs who lived in west jerusalem. After the six day war Israel annexed East Jerusalem into Jerusalem proper. In the west bank the situation is very comlax. The west bank or Judea and Samaria were the heart of the ancient Israeli kingdoms and it plays a big part in Israeli culture. combined that with the fact that it almost around Jerusalem and 15 minutes off driving away from Tel-Aviv and there also Israeli radicals which are crazy, and you got yourself a very complex issue. Gaza is a sad story, Its a story about a terrorist group wich controled the lives of 2 milion man woman and children. Israel left the Gaza strip to its own in 2005, Gaza was seemingly heading toward democracy, but in the elections they picked Hamas to lead them. Hamas was, from day one hostile to Israel and had sent tens of thousands of rockets from civilian territory to Israeli cities with the aim of killing civilians it stores ammunition in hospitals and schools and uses its own population as meat shields. Israel is blocking Gazien sea and air cases because they know that Hamas will use it as a way to import more rockets. If hamas would have spent the money the have on the people they could had become a city state like Singapore. when Isreal bomb Gaza it uses a safty rquierment wich was not see in any army in history. Israel choses a target, It then calls every single one of the people who are living in the building 2 hours in advance letting them know that they need to evacuate. It uses the most advanced technology they have to minimize civilian casualties. I have no problems with the Palestinies, I have Palestinians Friends I respect arab culture and I even learn Arabic, I hope that one day we could all live in peace….
@dazingarctic7873
2 жыл бұрын
The least fascist jew
@jellybeaneatcerealwithwate3306
2 жыл бұрын
@@dazingarctic7873 yes
@crediblesalamander8056
2 жыл бұрын
You're saying the Palestinians would never be satisfied but I assure you that more than 90% of Palestinians would accept a peace settlement in a heartbeat with just 3 conditions: 1- All of the West Bank (Israeli settlements are illegal by international law) 2- A shared Jerusalem (Jerusalem is equally important to both religions) 3- Right of return for all refugees to West Bank and Gaza. (Israel already has a law of return for all Jews (even for non-Israeli jews)) These are all fairly straightforward terms that would seem reasonable to anyone if you treat the Palestinians as an equal party, but the Israeli government has never shown any signs of accepting anything close to them. It seems to me like the Israeli government is the one that'll never be satisfied. Again, I also have nothing against Israelis (unless they're settlers) or the Jewish people in general.
@philo9046
2 жыл бұрын
you are a racist person and a fascist it doesn't matter what friends you have when you accuse an entire population of people as inherently bad just for being palestinians to justify your ethnic cleansing and aparhide is sickining.
@alilefta-xg2wq
8 ай бұрын
"they wouldn't be satisfied" Israel as a government has never recognized Palestinians as having a right as a native people That is a contradictory claim as the vast majority of Israeli Jews are or are descended of immigrants be it Poland, Russia, Ukraine, Iraq, yemen, Ethiopia Hamas is indeed a terrorist organization, but to use it as a pardon for Israel's continous commitment of violence, systematic inequality, and promotion of ethnic apartheid on millions of people who have no say on what is enforced on them is acting as if all 7 million Palestinians are all themselves full on armed Hamas members 7 million Israelis do not have the right to oppress and persecute over 5 million Palestinians because they fear them and Hamas any more than the 5 million Palestinians have a right to oppress and persecute Israeli Jews becuase they fear them and Israel's government
@shainazion4073
2 жыл бұрын
Where else does a group of people that attacked another group of people get to be invited into the country they are trying to destroy?
@tellmey1
2 жыл бұрын
y does report not talk about border to egypt? just go to egypt and from there fly to west bank
@Thedimensionalwarrior
2 жыл бұрын
Egypt blockades gaza as well for security reasons (terrorists go from gaza to sinai were they creat islamist armed miltias)
@isb3050
2 жыл бұрын
I love you
@minutemanchan7232
2 жыл бұрын
What song did you use in 5:40
@paranodrum9171
2 жыл бұрын
The Blue Danube Waltz from 0:00 until 6:06 and From the New World from 6:07 to the end
@yusufdaoud5491
3 жыл бұрын
Nice
@moe3235
Ай бұрын
Ferda algoe
@michaels.6141
5 ай бұрын
The more I listened, the more depressed I got. It is genuinely despicable America supports Israel despite all these racist laws and systems. There needs to be more conversations about this.
@theculturedjinni
2 жыл бұрын
سيكون هذا تصريحا جدليا لكني لا أرى جنبا بريئا في هذه الأمور . نعرف أن إيسرائيل عنصوري وعدائي لكن هناك العناصير المتطرفة بالجنب العربي أيضا و أظن أن التركيز المفرط على إيسرائيل قد يأدي إلى إغفال الأمور الكبرى التي يعاني العالم العربي منها.
@perniciousseizurehellio3438
2 жыл бұрын
Well I disagree the hostility and aggression you see from arabs is the result of decades of oppression from western powers.
@theculturedjinni
2 жыл бұрын
@@perniciousseizurehellio3438 Yes, it has contributed but I still think that an over focus upon Israel and the west misses the internal problems facing the Arabic world that are not due to it. The Arab world has also not been passive. . Even before colonialism the Arabic world has had a long history of power projection long before the powers of Europe were even a thought. Much of my channel (but not all) actually deals with the middle east (or comparisons to it) and you might want to check it out and subscribe as I am just getting started and the Ukraine-Russia war kind of interrupted my flow. I am actually open to disagreeing view points.
@perniciousseizurehellio3438
2 жыл бұрын
@@theculturedjinni the middle east would have been better without israel and western colonization.. europeans stole democracy from the arabs after ww1 and treated the arabs worse than their german enemies despite the arabs fighting alongside them against the ottomans. The rise of violent anti liberal islamist groups such as the muslim brotherhood is an almost direct result of western imperialism
@perniciousseizurehellio3438
2 жыл бұрын
I would be surprised if arabs didnt have extremist elements knowing what they went through. When Britian and France destroyed the Syrian congress in 1920 and split the middle east among themsleves this caused a split between islamists and liberals as the liberals were now seen as western puppets. Prior to that liberals and islamists worked together to establish a democratic state in Syria and the syrian Congress even drafted a constitution that disestablished islam in favor of equal rights for everyone. The destruction of this congress, the partition and subjugation of the middle east and the later rise of israel inavertably led to the many violent groups in the middle east today (aswell as contributed to the general the shitty state of the middle east)
@philo9046
2 жыл бұрын
@@theculturedjinni what Focus on israel many arabic countries have had peace deal that they initiated not israel because they don't care to Focus with israeli apahrtide . but ofcourse for certain arabs like the palestinians thats a central problem but what people like you try to do is not to shift Focus for the good of the arabs they actually try to make palestinians shut up and not ask for freedom and equality.
@Tatopatato
3 жыл бұрын
Palestine rocks 🇵🇸 ♥️♥️
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
Someone has to think this
@Tatopatato
3 жыл бұрын
@@beacebrocess what the heck do you mean bruv
@beacebrocess
3 жыл бұрын
@@Tatopatato lol I’m just being self deprecating I assure u I believe Palestine rocks too
@robertortiz-wilson1588
2 жыл бұрын
@@beacebrocess sure...
@arrielradja5522
2 жыл бұрын
4:25 why dont you use UN ball
@DogesBasement
2 жыл бұрын
No,because Palestine is different state. Can an American commit apartheid on Canadians?
@il967
2 жыл бұрын
Yes?
@אדםגולוב
2 жыл бұрын
True, but Israel is not.
@ShnoogleMan
2 жыл бұрын
It should be, but de facto it’s not. It would be one thing if Israel just had troops in the territory, but they’re actually moving in settlers. They treat the parts with large Arab populations as a separate entity to be subjugated while treating everything between as part of their country. You can’t have it both ways. You can’t claim it’s just a military occupation of another country when you’re moving your own settlers into that other country.
@DogesBasement
2 жыл бұрын
@@ShnoogleMan That other's country borders are not written or decalred anywhere. Troops must be there to defend the country from rebels who stab people. Troops must be on roads and crossing points. We have to make an agreement on which there will be written what is theirs and what is ours. But now,all the attempts to make any agreement have been failed. There are 500,000 people. You can't do anything with that fact,so the only way is to divide the area. Pay attention to the other side of Oslo agreements. Have they destroyed the militias? No. It was an important part of the agreement,but to this year there are a lot of millitias,and Palestinian police can't do anything. There is no contact,no compromises,no agreements. They want to eat more than they can swallow. There won't be any progress with this way.
@ShnoogleMan
2 жыл бұрын
@@DogesBasement You can argue that the PA has failed in many ways. I think Arafat is largely responsible for the failure of the peace process, but two wrongs don’t make a right. Israel can’t just have its cake and eat it too. Maybe the exact borders aren’t currently set in stone, but moving settlers into occupied territory in the meantime is going to be another barrier to Palestinian self-determination. Imagine if when the US was occupying Iraq or Afghanistan they just settled Americans all over the country. They’d have a lot less legitimacy in their actions.
@Sean-ht7fs
2 жыл бұрын
I know its been a few months, but here's another comment for the algorithm
@TayTayMakesBeats
2 жыл бұрын
Q: "Is Israel an apartheid state?" A: "Definitely. Semantically? Depends on who you ask but legally? Absolutely inarguable."
@jakobhopfer1997
2 жыл бұрын
As per usual you people never provide any evidence, just name calling. This is why your cause is dead
@thealligator918
3 жыл бұрын
the true question should be asked: "Is Palestine an aparthied state?"
@williamthebonquerer9181
2 жыл бұрын
When u think about it many countries commit apartheid. Russia in Chechnya. India and Pakistan in Kashmir. Even Finland with its Mongols that I can't spell
@abdelkaderalikhoudja7540
2 жыл бұрын
I think that you need some education on top of a lot of common sense..
@roadman_hanzi
Жыл бұрын
Well , do they even have many jews in the first place? Even Jewish Palestinians are oppressed , not every jew is an Israeli, some choose to be Palestinian by choice bro , because some jews were in Jerusalem before Israel even came and heck , Israel could've helped the Palestinians and all set their state in peace while living in harmony but no , the reason that Palestine isn't apartheid while Israel is , is because Israel started it and Israel has a system that ensures that every enemy to the state (Palestinians in this case) should die, meanwhile Palestine barely even has any law that discriminates Jewish ethnic groups , sure there may be some discrimination from our side , but it is not systematic, Israel has a system that ensures our failure, see the difference?
@אדירנצח
Жыл бұрын
@@roadman_hanzi what you said isn't true and I have documents to back it up
@SaxonYear410
2 жыл бұрын
Betteridge's law of headlines.
@perniciousseizurehellio3438
2 жыл бұрын
The answer is yes
@henrydrake4870
2 жыл бұрын
no
@Master-ep8be
3 жыл бұрын
YES
@ThiccPhoenix
Жыл бұрын
🇵🇸💙🇮🇱 🕊️🕊️🕊️
@yiannisroubos8846
2 жыл бұрын
Very good video
@amitsharvit8504
2 жыл бұрын
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
@r7ahtesham885
2 жыл бұрын
Smartest paj33t that supports israel
@Eran_Haim
2 жыл бұрын
Israeli here, gotta say this was interesting but too short of a video. You can’t discuss the Arab-Israeli conflict without giving a full context of 100+ years of history, both parties’ narratives and misdeeds… it’s just unfair without understanding it all. I admit that Israel was founded on a victory in a war, but it all could’ve been avoided had the Palestinians agreed to the two states solution proposed by the UN (Israel agreed) instead of lunching a war. The situation now is that There are Palestinian authorities in the west bank and in Gaza which govern and represent Palestinians. Had they not chosen violence, Israelis wouldn’t be afraid of Palestinians and most likely there would be a fully independent Palestinian state. It is because of the intifadas and countless never-ending terrorist attacks that most Israelis lost faith in the peace process. Palestinians need to change their ways, the Islamic extremists need to be condemned and kicked out of public discourse, and political leaders need to express their recognition of Israel’s right to exist, and their willingness to make a peace deal with it. Until this happens, one cannot look merely at Israel’s wrongdoing, but to understand that there are two sides to every coin - the Palestinians are also to blame.
@beacebrocess
2 жыл бұрын
that would be like 20 hrs of material homie.
@jellybeaneatcerealwithwate3306
2 жыл бұрын
The most fascist zionist
@Eran_Haim
2 жыл бұрын
@@jellybeaneatcerealwithwate3306 did you even read what I wrote?
@perniciousseizurehellio3438
2 жыл бұрын
Who would agree to give most of their homeland to outsiders?? Much less the best parts of it. Also you paint the 1948 war as starting out of palestinian aggression but you fail to point out that israel had destroyed hundreds of villages and expelled hundreds of thousands of palestinians prior to the war
@robertortiz-wilson1588
2 жыл бұрын
I agree.
@skidelrymar
3 ай бұрын
Apartheid is committed when certain minorities suffer from segregation under the law of the land. when minorities (by race, gender, religion, etc) are forbidden to work in certain jobs, vote, attend the same schools, those things. the israely arabs BY LAW have the same rights as the jews or any citizen in Israel. when the youtuber talks about Israel being Apartheid he's conflicting with the Palestinians in Gaza and the WB and they are not israeli citizens. Israel has a history of being the target of multiple terrorist attacks from Gaza and WB. until the end of the 90's there were almost no boundaries, Israelis could buy groceries in Gaza and Palestinians from Ramallah could go to the beach in Tel Aviv. until october 7 Palestinians from both WB and Gaza were welcome to work in many jobs in Israel. they couldn't vote because they are not citizens of Israel, like the Israelis can't vote in Gaza or WB. so how is Israel committing the crime of Apartheid? according to him by restricting the entrance of possible terrorists. what in your naive world happened in October7? and if anybody tells me that Israel shouldn't close the borders after two Intifadas they are telling me that Israel should get attacked over and over until everybody dies?
@zachtyson-s3u
Ай бұрын
You conveniently left out a key aspect of apartheid, which is the domination and oppression of a group of people. Israel has already started this in the West Bank by illegally building settIements and setting up multiple checkpoints in non-annexed parts. In addition, you have neglected to address the causes of the Iead up to October 7 and the inception of the two intifadas. IsraeI is an occupying apartheid state, currentIy engaged in the illegal occupation, annexation, and settIement construction in the west bank to which it has no Iegitimate cIaim to.
@skidelrymar
Ай бұрын
@@zachtyson-s3u blah blah blah, you didn't address my comment. Israel does not oppress the Palestinians in WB, they have their own government, Fatah. and the checkpoints are the consequence of the intifadas, not the cause. as i said in my comment (that you apparently didn't read) before the 1st intifada there were almost no borders, Palestinians from Gaza and WB could enter Israel very easily
@stekra3159
Жыл бұрын
Can I say that this is a shitty situltion,
@haarahld4959
3 жыл бұрын
Tldr: No.
@Aiham
2 жыл бұрын
القدس لنا
@jellybeaneatcerealwithwate3306
2 жыл бұрын
Yeah
@jellybeaneatcerealwithwate3306
2 жыл бұрын
The ours is commie word
@dominikzelenak7423
Жыл бұрын
No
@YaYeet47
2 жыл бұрын
It isnt apartheid. Plain and simple. No need to watch. Edit: the very HRW founder said that the organization he made turned into a political one that is just against Israel and makes up stories, that ignores Iran, Iraq, Syria, Cuba, North Korea, Russia, China, etc'.
@lysenkotheory3400
2 жыл бұрын
Lol just believe me!!!
@YaYeet47
2 жыл бұрын
@@lysenkotheory3400 ?
@il967
2 жыл бұрын
Substantiate your claim. Counter his argument
@YaYeet47
2 жыл бұрын
@@il967 I just did
@il967
2 жыл бұрын
@@YaYeet47 you made a claim. Now counter the UN's argument
@Tamir-Barkahan
2 жыл бұрын
Israel isn't an apartheid state, but your whining makes me wish it were :)
@perniciousseizurehellio3438
2 жыл бұрын
From the article: "Jabareen presented his bill in advance of the 20th anniversary of the Aqsa Intifada, which has become a cornerstone in the collective consciousness of Israel's Arab citizens, who make up 20 per cent of the population. They suffer from institutional discrimination, exclusion and hostility. Despite the bill highlighting the need for human rights and democracy to be available to all in the Zionist state, it was rejected by a majority of the ruling coalition and opposition parties."
@perniciousseizurehellio3438
2 жыл бұрын
Anyways this same bill is rejected every single year by the parliament
@Tamir-Barkahan
2 жыл бұрын
Cry more.
@perniciousseizurehellio3438
2 жыл бұрын
@@Tamir-Barkahan article was deleted . But thanks for admitting that you have nothing your filthy country ruined the middle east and is an apartheidal ethno state not unsimilar to the nazis
@mxkinist
2 жыл бұрын
your kind's cruelty makes me wish the Austrian funny mustache man finished what he started
@mr555harv
4 ай бұрын
He neglects the overarching problem that the Palestinians are governed by two terrorist orgs, Hamas and PLO, each conducting terror raids. The restrictions are needed to maintain peace. Ver biased reporting.
@rustinusti
4 ай бұрын
That's a red herring. Hamas and PLO are not affected by the regulation of Bedouin residency and Arab freedom of movement. Where is security for the Bedouin man that does not know if he will be expelled from his home? Is segregation a legitimate form of 'security?'
@Canada4Israel
5 ай бұрын
Bless Israel and stay blessed. Curse Israel and stay cursed. EASY! STAY BLESSED! Genesis 12 Numbers 24 Romans 11 🙏🇮🇱🇨🇦❤🇨🇦🇮🇱🙏 Read your Bible and stay blessed. It beats whining:)
@GotA_Bot
2 жыл бұрын
1,957,000 Arabs citizens of Israel, 21 percent of the Israel population. all of them have the *same* rights as every other jew in Israel, they can vote, they can be in the government and several people in the government are Muslim Israeli Arabs. In addition, there are Israeli Arabs who are in high positions in the army, police, hospitals, courts, and more. as an Israeli Jew, I have in my *Jewish* school, Muslim, Christian, and Druze teachers. You expect Israel to give the residents of Gaza Israeli citizenship they hate Israel and in general the Jews, In addition, they are run by the Palestinian Authority or rather Hamas, a terrorist organization. How many Jews live in Area A? The clear answer is 0. I would like u to answer this.
@alonkatz4633
Жыл бұрын
After reading your comment, I have several questions: 1. True, they technically have the same rights, but are these laws enforced equally? If not, then it's a case of systematic racism. 2. There really are Muslim Arabs in the *current* government. Does it make Israel not racist? 3. Are all Arabs Muslim? 4. How many Muslims who aren't Circassians or Bedouins serve in the military? 5. Which school do you go to? Depending on where you live in Israel, the demographic can change drastically. I live in the Tel Aviv area, and haven't seen any non-Jews during my 12 years of education. I could have missed some, but not too many. 6. Did he say he wanted Israel to give citizenship to Gazans? 7. Have you asked Gazans what they think about Israel or the Jews? 8. If Jews living in area A aren't the problem, can you suggest what is?
@guyvaiman1613
2 жыл бұрын
This has to be one of the most biased videos I’ve seen on this subject, how can there be an apartied on Palestinians if they are not even citizens, they belong to the pa which abuses them even more than Israel itself, plus as a person who actually lives in the country, Israel citizens including Arabs are constitutionally equal in their rights, with an Arab party even being part of the government coalition for the first time
@abdelkaderalikhoudja7540
2 жыл бұрын
You are such a liar. Additionally, although the party you are referring to is not perfect, you cannot suggest in all seriousness that israel has been kinder. Hamas doesn't kill journalists nor does it bomb buildings. They do not imprison children or women, as well. Nor do their soldiers shoot citizens for sport. And maybe you'd side with them if you knew the many wrongs the Palestinians were subjected to... during the SIX DECADES and + which preceded Hamas' foundation! You seem to turn a blind eye to all that happened before Hamas and especially 1948.
@roadman_hanzi
Жыл бұрын
What a lie, this guy have read you facts from international sources that are not biased against you but against us yet you deny what he said? Not only that but even some Jewish organizations condemned yall for your discrimination against us, yet you don't even recognize what your government did? Truly fascist
@abdullahinaziz3785
2 жыл бұрын
Long story short : YES
@GotA_Bot
2 жыл бұрын
"Israel is Aparthied State" also israel is the only country that being lgbtq is allowed while in palestine and gaza its not allowed.
@i_likemen5614
Жыл бұрын
What does gay rights have to do with anything with apartheid???
@BenjaminStruthers
Жыл бұрын
I'm queer and that doesn't fucking disprove anything.
@i_likemen5614
Жыл бұрын
@@BenjaminStruthers Honestly, I feel half these people saying this are probably homophobic themselves, and are only using this argument as a "gotcha" point
@BenjaminStruthers
Жыл бұрын
@@i_likemen5614 I agree. PragerU and other conservatives do this a lot, they hate the LGBTQ+ but then they bring up this stupid talking point. They don't really care, it's just a way to deflect from criticism. Liberals do this shit too.
@DKaldes
2 жыл бұрын
L opinions
@shainazion4073
2 жыл бұрын
If that is the definition of Apartheid. Every Arab country is an Apartheid state. Living as a dhimmie was Apartheid.
@eidorm.7953
2 жыл бұрын
Never thought a video could ever change my mind to such a degree... Apartheid is FRICKIN AWSOME
Пікірлер: 333