Kudos to Sarmila Bose. Scholarly, clear headed, candid and brave
@swapandas9433
2 жыл бұрын
if i am not mistaking Ms.Bose is the sister in law of pak historian Ayesha Jallal who is married to her brother another historian Mr. Sugoto Bose.
@DurrenayabSahibzada
9 жыл бұрын
Tahira Abdullah, You nailed it!
@anashammad872
5 жыл бұрын
Actually numbers are important to determine the nature of the conflict.
@rossgolla876
2 жыл бұрын
Islam of Pakistan and Napak Army failed & defeated and surrender against Islam of Bengali and Bangladesh in 1971. Bangladesh is a historical fact & reality. Its result of tragedy and unlimited injustice happened with Bengali peoples from 1947 to 1971 by west Pakistan. Last 75 years people of Pakistan living in lie and denial and conspiracy mentality. Hope Pakistani people will take a lesson from Bangladesh and Bengalis that how to save and protect own people , Culture, Language & Tradition and hard work for bright future of Bangladesh.. Pakistan as a country has no culture to apologies because 75 years passed but they did not apologies to east Pakistan now Bangladesh for the tragedy and unlimited injustice happened with Bengali peoples from 1947 to 1971 by west Pakistan now Pakistan..
@abdullatifkhan4518
6 жыл бұрын
I selute the last lady speaker
@nangamujra
8 жыл бұрын
india was never a country it was a region transformed into a country by the British. It is subcontinent. The entire population of the subcontinent is now about 1,7 billion people. It is even more than the entire continent of africa. British should have never made it a country. They should have made several small countries in the subcontinent. They should have given all the provinces of india independence or even should have made those provinces smaller and then have given independence. After that all the provinces of the subcontinent could make a confedreration like european union. It is the most popolous region in the world. If Britishers had done that then we would not have all that violence, disputes or ethnic provincial hatred what we are facing or have faced in the subcontinent like Balochistan, kashmir, Punjab, Naga land, Assam, Haiderabad, Junagadh, Travancore.
@TheValobalok
4 жыл бұрын
I totally agree . European Union is the right kind of model for a true sustainable development of sub continent. It's sad that very few still realizes it. The recent killings happened in Delhi is another testimony to the tally of such events happening in this region. A foreceful identity of being "Indian" wouldn't help on long run. There is no harm in having multiple countries if there is cooperation collaboration and economical unity through same currency and economical structure.
@نادرالیراحمان
4 жыл бұрын
@Amb Dar Bharat was one kingdom within what is today India. Also the original India referred to Sindh & Punjab, not the modern day country that took the name in 1947.
@نادرالیراحمان
4 жыл бұрын
Not only is "India" a British creation (derived from the Greek name for the land of the Indus in Pakistan) but so is "Hinduism." It was the British who introduced the concept of "Hinduism" in 1830 as a name for a multiplicity of religions. Read Pankaj Mishra "the invention of the Hindu"
@swapandas9433
2 жыл бұрын
@@TheValobalok Actually exchange of population did not happen at the time of partition due to gandhi and nehru,but afterwards the pakistan and bangladesh did the job but that did not happen in our india due to democracy and vote bank.
@KonarkB
11 жыл бұрын
Kudos to Sarmila Bose for being so bold
@zubaidafaridi1908
3 жыл бұрын
Will anyone talk about the biharis who died in this conflict? And those who are still living in abject misery - unrecognized by both Pakistan and Bangladesh.
@swapandas9433
2 жыл бұрын
salute to the lady who spoke in the last and i am also happy that some balance thinkers also exists in pakistan.
@2sridhark
11 жыл бұрын
This army chap Siddiqui seems to be confabulating! One needs a scholarly person to dissect what went wrong and what is the solution. Kudos to Sarmila Bose for being so bold.
@AbuRushd
Жыл бұрын
Military should not get involved in politics- yes, Ms, Bose nailed it. Beiing a Bangladeshi I would just say that even Pak army killed or raped one East Pakistani, it was a crime. You did commit crimes against us- who had been the majority of the population of Pakisitan. Your military never think in a civil way, still they don't... I personally don't have any grudge against anyone, but it's your duffer military-military and military...why? Why did you do that? And thank you to all those Pakistanis who raised their voices to bring the criminals/killers/rapists to justice, even it was one even...
@abdullatifkhan4518
6 жыл бұрын
Don't forget it's the Bangali Muslim who created the Muslim league..... Jinnah later encashed ..... Jinnah himself didn't know how to write Urdu but imposed as state language ..... Don't forget how economic robbing was done on Bangladesh .....
@BMhere
4 жыл бұрын
You're saying this about a person who lost everything for your freedom? And you call us betrayers. Have some shame.
@نادرالیراحمان
4 жыл бұрын
He advocated a lingua franca.
@BMhere
3 жыл бұрын
@Badal Hossain yeah yeah first remove hunger and thirst from bangladesh than we talk.
@BMhere
3 жыл бұрын
@Badal Hossain I don't make arguments over people's misery. Good day
@BMhere
3 жыл бұрын
@Badal Hossain Get a life bro 🥱
@palashmaiti3178
5 жыл бұрын
In unpar logo ko expert Pakistani srif bana sakte hai
@sheikhkhalid5969
4 жыл бұрын
Creation of Pakistan was NOT a mistake, but creating Pakistan as ONE COUNTRY was a MISTAKE, THREE COUNTRIES should have come out of Indian Partition NOT TWO COUNTRIES. read history of the region along that line. its a shorter narrative and clearer thought.
@unknownindian6531
3 жыл бұрын
Best would have been five Pakistans
@sheikhkhalid5969
3 жыл бұрын
@@unknownindian6531 starting with hyderabad and kashmir 😂
@koowasha
3 жыл бұрын
54:09 says it all. Anyone who don’t agree with her, can go to hell.
@KonarkB
11 жыл бұрын
Bangladesh is getting real freedom by banning religion in politics parties & giving punishment to culprits after so many years.
@2sridhark
9 жыл бұрын
Audience is full of it.
@BMhere
4 жыл бұрын
This is a big misconception among people especially indians that basis of Pakistan was religion. No it was not. Let me tell you why 1: The very reason Quiad left congress was ghandi's policy of provoking religious sentiment for political gain. Quaid was AGAINST linking politics with religion. 2: Ullema organization and individuals of that time and STILL majority of so called Ullema are against the idea of Pakistan. They call it work of devil to separate Umma. A grave mistake some call it. They even termed Jinnah as "yahoodi agent" ( even though now selling Islamic Pakistan is bread and butter for children of same so called ullemas) 3: Jinnah was the BIGGEST advocate of Hindu Muslim unity before joining Muslim league. Do ask this question then what lead him to make a demand for a separate state? The answer is quite obvious if you see the state of current day India. This is what lead to Two nation theory. This ideology of Hindus being Superior and others religious minorities as second class citizen was what lead Jinnah to create a sperate state for MINORITIES. YES Pakistan was NOT created only for Muslims, the reason this narrative became so popular was because muslims were the second biggest population and mostly the victims of hatred of radical hindus, that is why Quiad put case in the name of Muslims to make BRITISH understand that creation of Pakistan was need of the time. 4: Pakistan was created as an ideal state where everyone would be treated equally regardless of their religion, cast, color. For a muslim ideal state is the state of Madina and in state of Madina everyone was EQUAL. Quiad mentioned in his famous speech vividly that your religion has NOTHING to do with the matters of government. “You are free; you are free to go to your temples. You are free to go to your mosques or to any other places of worship in this State of Pakistan. You may belong to any religion, caste or creed-that has nothing to do with the business of the state.” Though it's true that some opportunists took over the country after his death and used several types of narrative to use this state to make money and bank balances. This also gave a chance to mullas to manipulate majority Muslim population into thinking that this state was created FOR Islam or to serve Islam which is A BIG lie. Pakistan was supposed to be a walfare state for all minorities and thats it. Past 70 years were nothing but failer in the lights of our ideology and purpose of making a country but now we are heading towards that. We will make Pakistan what it was supposed to be .
@نادرالیراحمان
4 жыл бұрын
Exactly
@prabhaskumarmohanty5910
4 жыл бұрын
then u dont believe 2 quomi nazariyan. right? hypocrisy is at its best
@BMhere
4 жыл бұрын
@@prabhaskumarmohanty5910 go read "2 qoumi nazariyan" first and come here. I will reply you.
@newcoc8067
3 жыл бұрын
Exactly jinnah was anti israel beacuse he knew what nobel prize and war winners can do.
@newcoc8067
3 жыл бұрын
@@نادرالیراحمان yup what next pakistan pays for its own petrol and f 16s.
@skkhurshidulalam5742
7 жыл бұрын
Kudos to the lady who spoke in the end and I spit on those people's mouth who were on the stage and twisted the history including sharmila bose.
@نادرالیراحمان
4 жыл бұрын
She did not twist history. She further documented it.
@newcoc8067
3 жыл бұрын
@@نادرالیراحمان that allah has given f 35 to people who deserve it
@Pagalchhagal
4 жыл бұрын
Disappointed with Sarmila Bose speech. There was no real connection between 47 and 71, at least to East and West Pakistanis. 71 was a carefully planned operation by Soviet Union and Indira government. 1971 is totally unique and an anomaly to events of 1947, 1911 and 1905
@TheValobalok
4 жыл бұрын
Your level of ignorance is outright creepy! Do you even understand what really an anomaly is?
@Pagalchhagal
4 жыл бұрын
@@TheValobalok my disagreement with your pro-india views does not mean I don't know the meaning of a word I used
@TheValobalok
4 жыл бұрын
@@Pagalchhagal once again an outright ignorant's comment! Your cliche thought process simply assumed that I will be a "pro-indian" where in reality many of my views would actually be considered as highly "anti Indian theory"! Only a highly biased, ignorant or maybe sheer liar can think of 71 as an anomaly in the historical backgrounds of this subcontinent. Those who do understand the natural consequences of historical events along with its socio political and cultural impacts; would see how deeply connected 71 war is with nineteenth century Bengal events, 1905, 1911, 1921 (creation of Dhaka university), 1947, 1952, 1962, 1966 1969.
@Pagalchhagal
4 жыл бұрын
@@TheValobalok are you a comedian? You are downright celebrating Indian destabilization and invasion of East Pakistani soil, ruling by proxy to this day, who cares if you say a word or two against Modi? What part of the facts that I stated throughout do you disagree with? Which other event you mentioned was engineered by foreign intelligence agencies? Or achieved through a military invasion by the enemy? You sound like you are a part of the "3 million" club, and someone who would've served tea to the invading Indian military with a smile
@vickyvicky2734
4 жыл бұрын
@@Pagalchhagal you asshole, nazayaz aulad of arbii, qasim no other things could be expected from you!on this barbaric act!
@khalidzaki6699
5 жыл бұрын
Creation of Pakistan was a blessing for the Muslims in Pakistan and Bangladesh . The BJP GOVERNMENT has proved it beyond any doubt. The grand alliance that Bose talks about will be good for Pakistan and Bangladesh , but India will not let it happen , bcuz India wanted no Muslims in India , so the help create Pakistan.
@نادرالیراحمان
4 жыл бұрын
India was also created in 1947. If not for British, there would be no country called "India" today.
@newcoc8067
3 жыл бұрын
@@نادرالیراحمان yup dab in alternate history. Failed state
@swapandas9433
2 жыл бұрын
@@نادرالیراحمان Go and read the history again.
@vickyvicky2734
Жыл бұрын
That's why East Pakistan cut off from West Pakistan 😎😀😂 during the search light operation by pakistan army in 1971... Nearly 7 to 8 lakhs of women were being raped....
@akibchowdhury4927
7 жыл бұрын
she has a very cunning brain... she is trying to tell 1947 is a mistake.. she never liked "islam" taking a part of indian sub-continent. She and her family had a rival against bangali muslim. Her grand father netaji subhas chandra bose who created the slogan " Bande mataram" and bangali muslim opposed it vigorously. And so, writting this book, she took a deliberate revenge...
@unknownindian6531
3 жыл бұрын
Please do not betray your ignorance about this subject
@swapandas9433
2 жыл бұрын
@Akib Chowdhury there are two points subhas bose created Jai Hind not Bande mataram. second all the muslims of the indian subcontinent were once hindus and later converted.
@rossgolla876
2 жыл бұрын
Bangladesh at 50: From 'basket case' to rising economic star: Before the onset of the coronavirus pandemic, the economy was growing rapidly, recording an annual expansion in the range of 8% for years. The Asian Development Bank said that despite the hit from the pandemic, Even in coronavirus pandemic GDP growth was 4.5 in 2020. the Bangladeshi economy is recovering fast. "Bangladesh also grows enough food now to feed its 165 million people. The country has a significantly reduced maternal and infant mortality rate than many other countries in the world," Rahman said. Bangladesh achieved middle-income country status in 2015 and is on track to leave the United Nations' Least Developed Countries list. Currently, 98% of children nationwide have finished primary school, with more girls in secondary school than boys. Literacy rate rose to 74.9 % in 2021 from 26.8 % in 1974 According to Global Gender Gap report 2021 by the world Economic forum, Having closed 71.9% of its overall gender gap, Bangladesh is the most gender-equal country in South Asia for the seventh time in a raw. world Economic forum say the Muslim-majority nation over the years has invested heavily in the lives of women and girls. It has also made progress in combating child malnutrition and reproductive health. With a GDP of over $409 billion (€362 billion), Bangladesh currently has the world's 37th largest economy and forecasts suggest that the size of the economy could double by 2030. Bangladesh has became a food sufficient Country ,the country became 4th largest producer of rice 3rd in vegetable and 4th largest producer of fresh water fish in the world . Over 97% of medicine made in Bangladesh , Currently Bangladesh export medicine more than 140 country . The garment industry emerged as one of the nation's success stories in recent decades. It is the second-largest globally, only surpassed by China, and rakes in over $35 billion a year from exports.in 2022 only RMG export crossed over 42 Billion USD The sector employs 4 million people, the majority (80%) of whom are women, contributing to female empowerment. Meanwhile, the Bangladesh government has set an overall target for exports amounting to $51 billion in 2022. Remittances also play a major role in the economy, with Bangladeshi workers employed abroad transferring nearly $24.7 billion in the fiscal year 2021. "Per capita income has increased in Bangladesh. Now it is 2550 USD higher than India .Foreign reserve almost 45 Billion USD The improvement in female education has transformed the socioeconomic structure, Providing scholarships for women's and girls' education is another factor. The women are now more articulate. Net Enrollment in primary school 97.91%. Life expectancy more than 73 years .poverty rate is decreasing less than 10 %. more than 100 million people are using internet regularly. Power sector also made huge milestone of 100% access to Electricity in the golden jubilee year. The country successfully launched its first satellite " Bangabandhu -1 "on may 12, 2018 and became 57th country to have own satellite in space. Bangladesh is not resting but building 100 Economic zone almost 11 Economic zone ready for production and also building 28 hi-Tec park for ICT export .Bangladesh has set a vision to be a developed nation within 2041..
Пікірлер: 69