**** PLEASE READ BEFORE COMMENTING! ***** Yes. I am well aware that "technically" certain characters couldn't actually be certain witches. I am WELL AWARE that a certain character dies. Thanks to all the comments who decided to spoil it for me even though I admitted in this review I haven't watched it yet. Thanks for that. You all can STOP commenting about how "uhm, ACTUALLY" about how certain witches'/girls couldn't match. I KNOW. I didn't make this video to be like "look! a definitive answer!" This was just something for fun. A "what if" sort of concept. Now Please stop commenting the same things over and over again.
@LooneyLei
3 жыл бұрын
Ah shoot, did people really had to spoil stuff? What a bunch of clowns
@StrawberriCleric
3 жыл бұрын
Oh my gosh I'm so sorry they spoiled you!!!!
@wingednotepad
3 жыл бұрын
@@UltimateGenosyko hey bro, you might wanna take some time off the internet to just cool off. there's really no reason to be this mad.
@BlaireDaAngel
3 жыл бұрын
@@UltimateGenosyko jesus christ dude, its almost like there is just so much content to consume that not everyone has the time. Unlike you some of us have jobs and school or contribute to society instead of being upset over literally the dumbest thing to be upset over.
@user-sr6ui7ph1g
3 жыл бұрын
@@UltimateGenosyko OFF TOPIC BUT I FINISHED READING MGRP RESTART 2 WEEKS AGO AND I LOVE GENOPSYCHO
@MegaLpso
3 жыл бұрын
Keep in mind that hair isn't always going to be a match when it comes to the witches and the magical girls. Nagisa had white hair and Charlotte has pink hair.
@thoth7290
3 жыл бұрын
plus the fact that doppels arent always 1:1 to a character's witch form. gretchen, for instance, looks almost nothing like the kremhild gretchen we glimpsed in the show
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
@@thoth7290 it actually does at a degree. Kriemhild Gretchen as a Doppel looks too similar to Kriemhild Gretchen's (witch) nucleus, which lead many fans to belive that's actually Kriemhild Gretchen's true form, while her Shadow body is just an extention or proyection of the real witch's body.
@ashleykent3044
3 жыл бұрын
Nagisa actually has very light pink hair
@emmasuarez9475
3 жыл бұрын
And!! Sayaka’s outfit doesn’t have any fish or mermaid visuals like Ocktavia, so it’s not like something like wings couldn’t be added to a witch form
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
@@ashleykent3044 Nagisa's hair is white, the pink one is her school's uniform.
@devonwilliams5738
3 жыл бұрын
And in 6 months, they'll all get doppels and render your theories obsolete.
@Missing-Ace
3 жыл бұрын
That would be tragic
@madisonwithalaurenspicture7033
3 жыл бұрын
What is a dopple?
@cherami-nox-fleuret
3 жыл бұрын
@@madisonwithalaurenspicture7033 the girl's witch forms, but without fully becoming a witch
@GorochuVA
2 жыл бұрын
They gave Konomi a Doppel and I will forever be salty that it isn't Gertrude
@devonwilliams5738
2 жыл бұрын
@@GorochuVA I wonder if they'll ever reveal what the OG witches' human forms are?
@Mistress9Tomoe
3 жыл бұрын
Next Madoka Witch video idea : Looking at Each Magical Girls' Doppel, and imagine what kind of witch she could be
@toxicalyss
3 жыл бұрын
Their witch and doppels have same names with slight adjustments.
@moonfrostsketches
3 жыл бұрын
@@toxicalyss i think OP is referring to the girls who don't have canon witch designs. so it would be more of a "what would their labyrinth/familiars look like?" rather than "what would the design look like"
@ninicom3710
3 жыл бұрын
@@moonfrostsketches thats sounds like a amazing idea
@lanutellaanonima823
Жыл бұрын
yes please i need that
@theoreinshagen4934
3 жыл бұрын
The differences between Konami and Gertrude could allude to the reason her gem hatched. She wears a white flower, that might represent innocents, and Gertrude has a strong theme of red roses, which are associated with romance and death. The butterfly-theme could be seen as a representation of her desire for a change in her appearance or to be there for someone in their time of need and and the way muck is flowing down her face reminds me of tears. Konami might have been rejected by an romantic interest based on her looks, someone might have died, leading her to develop guilt for not stopping it and/or being abused by someone (the minions might represent a "deflowering", the wings and muck her thinking that her appearance was to blame).
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
Both flowers are different. Konomi's flowers are peonys while Gertrud's flowers are Roses. But althought Konomi might not be Gertrud it still is a good headcanon. *Also curiously both have flowers that are the same as President Rose and his brother Peony from Pokemon Sword and Shield...
@philipcheung63
2 жыл бұрын
@@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094 Aaand she recently got a Doppel, which is named Heidesommer. And it’s nothing like Gertrude.
@katiejuby
Жыл бұрын
in japan, white is also a symbol of death hence why white flowers are put on a dead classmates desk. a pure death rather than the red sinful death.
@theoreinshagen4934
Жыл бұрын
@@katiejuby in Germany, white roses are put on children's graves/memorials for the same reason, didn't know japan shared a similar tradition
@weirdo5933
3 жыл бұрын
I JUST HAD A MEGAMIND MOMENT. The magical girl we think is Gertrude has a bow on the back of her outfit, so maybe her witch form translated that as butterfly wings since butterflies love flowers, as much as she loves flowers. And the vines that hold her scissors in witch form? She grows flowers. SHE GROWS, FLOWERS. I feel very big brain right now😆
@EspeonaSparkle
3 жыл бұрын
I headcanon that Albertine's parents were very neglectful and never wanted to spend time with their daughter. Albertine loved playing hide and seek and when she got too annoying, asking her parents to play with her, they told her that they'd play hide and seek, Albertine hid somewhere and her parents used that opportunity to leave the house, leaving Albertine waiting for them in her hiding spot for hours. Since very young children often don't think bad about their parents, she probably assumed that her parents just weren't able to find her. Her description says: "She loves Hide and Seek, however, her minions are unable to find her, since they aren't very intelligent." Whenever she was alone she would scribble and draw, imagining friends for herself. That habit would later allow her to turn her drawings into allies while fighting witches as a magical girl. An ability that she would keep as a witch. By the time she became a witch she must've realized that her parents were constantly lying to her, resulting in her familiars turning humans into balls. "A human turned into a ball can only transform back if they are bounced against the floor for every lie they've told."
@Ramsey276one
3 жыл бұрын
Last line: we need some NBA pros over here! XD Q_q
@arcikkus8227
2 жыл бұрын
thats so sad
@areionamckeegan2533
2 жыл бұрын
That's heartbreaking 💔
@magicaldemonboy100
3 жыл бұрын
Maybe some of these girls could be the witches but in alternate timelines sorta like how sayaka's witch has a different design in alternate timelines when Homura is doing hooshafloof.
@faceoctopus4571
3 жыл бұрын
Hooshafloof? Also the images here wiki.puella-magi.net/Gallery:Oktavia are pretty consistent. I do know that Homulilly from Portable looks somewhat different from Rebellion. And The Witch of salvation (regular Kriemhild Gretchen) looks substantially different from The Witch of Despair.
@GE-0530RN
3 жыл бұрын
I heard a theory that in a different timeline, Madoka's teacher became Roberta.
@thejudgmentalcritter6584
3 жыл бұрын
I could totally see that!
@box6758
Жыл бұрын
i looked up roberta on the wiki recently and it said in rebellion her minion was carrying madoka's teacher. this seems like a good theory
@u_nderscore1
Жыл бұрын
Yeah, i’m convinced lol
@krspaceT1
5 ай бұрын
That's trying too hard to pair on my opinion, like Momo is Elsa Maria. Plus that teacher is at least 30 and has a BFF, Madoka’s mom
@aliasfakename3159
3 ай бұрын
@@krspaceT1 It's stated that Roberta is a weak witch because she managed to stay a magical girl for a long time, maybe into her late teens or early twenties. Madoka's teacher laments she's unmarried and Roberta's familiar are just buff male torsos fluttering around her so maybe she couldn't find time for love as a magical girl which made her fall into despair and turn into a witch.
@bluebiscuit1520
3 жыл бұрын
Ayame doppel be like: "They see me rolling, they hating..."
@GorochuVA
3 жыл бұрын
I have a theory that it actually wasn't Patricia that was molested- it was someone she knew, and the person responsible got away with it. She couldn't get her friend out of the *web* of lies they got caught up in, hence the spider theme. In fact, for the sake of debate, let's say this friend was male and the perpetrator was female. Y'know what they say, men are usually willing. Except, no matter how you look at it, Patricia's friend wasn't... Other male friends congratulating him for "getting laid" and asking questions along the lines of "was she hot?" might've angered Patricia to the point of becoming a Witch
@arcikkus8227
2 жыл бұрын
I like that! it also shines light on males getting molested and showing that Patricia was pissed off at how someone could get away with it
@GorochuVA
2 жыл бұрын
@@arcikkus8227 Not just that males can get molested, but that women CAN molest and that it shouldn't be treated as a joke/feminist movement
@libraeevee9467
2 жыл бұрын
Plus the familiars she has are named iirc ‘Matthew’ so it could just towards the said friend who was molested
@OperatorError0919
Жыл бұрын
I'm not sure why it has to be someone else in order for the spider theme to apply. I agree that the theme of being caught in a web is important, but the detail of it necessarily being someone she knew instead of herself seems unlikely to me.
@iceluvndiva21
Жыл бұрын
Personally I think she could be a victim but she tries to find comfort in other people who were victims. Like an anonymous helplines group
@dr.ducttape2161
3 жыл бұрын
Talking about Itzli! Soo recently a new project was announced, Magia Record: Scene Zero. It's supposed to be a scenario for Magia Record, a new story involving Madoka, Homura's time-traveling, AND a new Magical Girl, "No one remembers there was one more magical girl. The magical girl whose existence was erased." Mabayu Aki. Anyway, what matters here is that she has a film and memory motif, her weapon is scissors, and she sports rather messy green hair, quite similar to Itzli! so lots of people are theorizing that's who she is, I think it's worth looking into!
@dr.ducttape2161
3 жыл бұрын
Should be noted, some people also think it could be Walpurgisnacht's magical girl form, but that's up to debate, personally I think Itzli is a much better fit.
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
The girl name is Mabayu Aki, and yeah she probablly is Iztli (and is possibly the only new meguka that is a form of a Madoka Magica witch) 😁
@dr.ducttape2161
3 жыл бұрын
@@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094 thank u I edited to the right name
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
@@dr.ducttape2161 You're welcome 😁
@alpha8here
3 жыл бұрын
Is this new project separate from the New movie announced?
@elysainempire4628
3 жыл бұрын
who's ready for the fourth movie that's coming out. we got confirmation and a trailer
@zhongli8697
3 жыл бұрын
me
@EspeonaSparkle
3 жыл бұрын
ME!!!!! :D
@donnamitsuki281
3 жыл бұрын
ME. I'M SO SO HAPPY
@zhongli8697
3 жыл бұрын
@@donnamitsuki281 I'm so excited when the movie finally gets released
@louised2818
3 жыл бұрын
Me!
@Quartz_111
3 жыл бұрын
Coiro being the chocolate witch does actually fit, her wish was to have the boy she likes confess to her. That romance wish possibly relating back to her witch's chocolate theme. In the anime she's the one that tries to convince the lead to come be freed from her wish, so it's ironic that as a witch she's now trapped in the form resembling an already existing witch made of the thing that brings her pain Also I feel witchs designs tend to be more similar to the magical girls weapon rather then the girl themselves. Just look at Nagisa's trumpet looking like Charlotte's snake form, Sayaka's sword matching Octavia's armor, even Gertrude's branch like design matching Madoka's bow
@SiriProject
3 жыл бұрын
I think that's a part of it, but also she's a Valentine's Day character and chocolate is the ordinary gift in Japan!
@LucreciaCrescentIsBestGirl
3 жыл бұрын
1. Candy’s ear-mouth attack features a pelvis inside, which coupled with the ballerina legs could hint at a past similar to Patricia’s. 2. Maybe Quitterie’s needles could be a reference to how accused witches were often poked with needles to see if they bled or felt pain. Overall, great analysis.
@hexxblade1534
3 жыл бұрын
Something that could strengthen the bond between Konami and Gretchen regarding the lack of butterflies in Konamis design is that butterflies drink nectar from flowers which leans into her love for flowers
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
Don't you mean Gertrude? Gretchen is Madoka
@donnamitsuki281
3 жыл бұрын
AH YES WHAT BROUGHT ME TO THIS CHANNEL IN THE FIRST PLACE,THE OUTSTANDING MADOKA MAGICA Any thoughts on the announcement of the new movie? I'm so happy about it!!
@EspeonaSparkle
3 жыл бұрын
I can't wait!!! :O
@danielbricker9041
3 жыл бұрын
I'm ecstatic beyond compare
@blaze7664
3 жыл бұрын
Aww this brings me some Magia Record nostalgia, it's been a while since the last time I played it... I'm still mad about NA dying -.-
@devonwilliams5738
3 жыл бұрын
Me too.
@RoseProseFroze
3 жыл бұрын
@@devonwilliams5738 Me three
@Max_is_weird
3 жыл бұрын
You can join the JP server,right now there's another Tart event
@alex-8736
3 жыл бұрын
@@Max_is_weird I tried to stay but I was there for the story and characters, by entering now you basically missed everything and you can't read stuff plus I also lost everything I had in my NA account lol
@outrunthestars4938
3 жыл бұрын
I'm just glad I left before the game shut downed.
@mako_toons
3 жыл бұрын
This video: *releases* Magia record 2 days before : *reveals 4 doppels from corbeau, lapinne, Minou and the queen Isabeau*
@Kittytale468
3 жыл бұрын
i just had a thought could elsa maria be two witches that combined in to one those possibly being tart and liz's witches. I mean liz's whole power is blending into shadows like elsa maria and tart has the same position as elsa maria. That might also be why the only colors we see in elsa maria's barrier are black and white, white is tart's mane color and black is liz's mane color. plus who said that walpurgisnacht is the only witch that is made of several different wiches.
@nassimmebarki7452
3 жыл бұрын
In all honesty, that could be def possible. I mean we have the Alazea trio to prove that Doppels can combine if the owners share a strong bond, so Tart and Liz could def had their witches fused to become Elsa Maria. That would even explain how only a magical girl that fell in deep despair can only defeat the witch since she existed for many years. (AND because I see it coming: yes, we "technically" saw Tart as an adult being burned alive at the end of Madoka Magica, but if her Soul Gem wasn't damaged, this means she would've survived (or at least in the form of a Soul Gem). I haven't read Tart Magica so idk if Liz is alive by the end of the story but if she does, she might even recovered the Soul Gem of Tart and somehow became a witch, corrupting Tart's Soul Gem at the same time and giving birth to Elsa Maria)
@ameintherain4965
3 жыл бұрын
my first thought when you mentioned himena being able to swap powers (specifically with oriko) with other magical girls, was that she swapped with oriko and saw into the future and most likely saw something that scared or terrified her so badly that her soul gem hatched. (also really great video! i love these types of explanations and this series is one i tend to watch over and over again adsfaf)
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
Yeah but the problem is that Himena can't get the powers of other girls, she just pass them to other magical girls, that why her power is called "Synthesis" as she is just doing the transference but can't get any of those powers, and it is temporary. Eventually the girls get their unique power back (Himena said that is within an hour).
@ameintherain4965
3 жыл бұрын
@@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094 ahh i see
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
Yes please, make a video of the Doppels lore!!! Also don't forget to look into Konoha and Hazuki dual unit, since they have also an interesting Doppel repersenting all Azaleas. 😁
@alex-8736
3 жыл бұрын
I always thoughts Kuro's witch looks like that because Kuro always said that she felt unimportant, not the main character so her witch is just the copy of another one, with the chocolate theme being there solely because of the days it happens
@poppunpresents
3 жыл бұрын
I think I may have found the perfect candidate for Elsa Maria: Claire, from the previous Madoka Mobile game. There were four girls in one of the side stories and Claire not only looks like a nun, but the information given about her fits the notes for Elsa Maria "Though unseen by you I want you to be happy"; which fits for Claire becoming a magical girl because she was lonely from her parents neglecting her. (Actually, Madoka Mobage has a few witches and girls that could be interesting to look at) Seika could actually be Patricia if we take a different view of the witch: Seika's story chapter shows that she has social anxiety, which could tie into the "Classmate" familiars not having an upper half; according to information from Magia Record it's from Patricia's girl always looking down and only seeing the lower half of her classmates, and her profile says that before becoming a witch that she tended to stay on the side lines which is why she has a by-stander nature. This could fit with Seika's social anxiety making her feel isolated, especially since her chapter shows that she tends to look irritable when she's stressed and drive people away, her chapter is about her trying to open up more, which could explain Patricia being the "Class Representative Witch", since that's a role that involves interacting with your classmates a lot, it could be something she was striving for. Patricia being Seika's witch could also explain the roof top since Seika's wish was "To make it as if Leila never jumped" and bringing her back to life, I couldn't find the full story for her wish on the wiki, but it would fit. I don't know all the girls in the game, but watching the newest video made me wonder, what if Candy's girl was actually older? I admit, it's partially influenced by another magical girl series based on people's wishes, Shugo Chara, where one of the girls has a baby themed transformation as a result of her becoming a big sister. Admittedly she was still the youngest of the group, but she was the eldest in her family and the desire her transformation resulted from was due to her no longer being the center of attention, it could be that Candy's girl was someone who had to cope with becoming an older sister, or who had to grow up quickly and wanted to return to a time when she could be a little girl and be taken care of. Isabel was another one that it was interesting to see the different interpretation of; to me her notes felt less like intentional plagiarism and more like how younger artists, around junior high school age like many of the characters, get really into art and think very highly of their work, which can often end up being very similar to the piece that inspired it, or that they fantasize about making works similar to their favourite artist. At least, her nature being vanity and her belief that she has a gift reminds me of the afternoon art program I was in once, and her familiars containing pieces of her victims fits with the edgier artists. Then again, she might also be a reference to how some artforms in Japan are taught by first having students re-create iconic pieces to learn the techniques. I also wonder if the sculptures on her arc might be her magical girl form, similar to how we can see H. N. Elle's on her screens
@bastard9290
3 жыл бұрын
Finally found someone else who thinks that ayame's doppel doesn't fit her
@nenosuns
3 жыл бұрын
everyone thinks like this lmao
@Mr.EintheMorning
3 жыл бұрын
This is where we ask ourselves what Critter would look like if she was a Witch. I'm sure whatever her witch was, it would be in contrast to Twiins's like how Madoka's contrasts Walpergisnact.
@mizumafusotrue
3 жыл бұрын
Correction: Sakuya was part of a gang: Torayamachi to be exact (Now part of Promised Blood, formed with two other gangs: Ryuugasaki and Hebinomiya.) Edit: It's actually Janomiya not Hebinomiya.
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
Also Sakuya didn't assult anyone, she was caught on a fight on her school and they thought that she was also involved and they weren't gonna let her run so she wished that the assult made by her classmates was forgiven so she could participate
@mizumafusotrue
3 жыл бұрын
@@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094 Good point, because Sakuya assaulting someone doesn't seem in character for her.
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
@@mizumafusotrue Yeah! I used to think the same but a few folks told me what was really the circunstance of her wish and that made much more sense. 😁
@odysseylotus4
3 жыл бұрын
I’ve never watched the show, but I love hearing you talk about it!
@thisisacomment.
3 жыл бұрын
I highly recommend it. it's amazing!!
@lieegou6212
3 жыл бұрын
it’s fantastic, and it’s pretty short if you stick to the main series! it’s really an experience!
@PristineMess0906
3 жыл бұрын
I imagine that Therressa's magical girl had the ability to essentially take a moment in time and save it being able to live it again therefore denying the passage of time (like throwing away the numbers on a clock).
@beigecharley7080
3 жыл бұрын
I think you might have been on the right track thinking Elsa Maria might have previously been Tart, but instead of Tart why not Liz? Liz's Doppel and powers are similar to Elsa Maria using Shadows and in her Dopples' description it states that she surrounds herself with her heroes light that shines to bright much, like the walls of Elsa Maria's labyrinth , while her doppel acts as a shadow to the heroes light and she makes sure those blanketed in shadow ( Like Sayaka was when fighting Elsa Maria) Will never have the light shine on them. What if after so long Liz's doppel shifted so much to become Elsa Maria instead of Obscuritie. Plus you could keep the religious themes that Elsa Maria has since she's supposed to be emulating Tart even in her with form.
@nyawrcut
Жыл бұрын
If you look at ashley's doppel ITS THE WIGS!!! THE WIGS IN THE AUDIENCE OF CANDY'S LABYRINTH.
@samanthot_
3 жыл бұрын
I think we actually have an answer for who Paola is. Her ghost appears in the Magia Record event, Beachside Bonds, where it is explained that she turned into a witch after drowning. If you can get the time to read the event, please do. It's pretty damn creepy but also really cool.
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
No that wasn't Paola, that was the ghost friend of the magical girl Yuusa "Yuu" Yumeno. That's because Paola also appears at the end of the event and magical girls that become witches can't become ghost since they lost their soul when they turn into witches (lkke Sayaka on Madoka Magica and Mel in Magireco). Kei's ghost was beign controlled by Paola's curses
@slingshot8740
3 жыл бұрын
I remember watching a random clip of this show on youtube, i was surprised how watchable this show was despite i have no idea what's going on, meanwhile in RWBY volume 5.......
@akito1555
3 жыл бұрын
Im still sad the magia record servers closed.
@primisimperator2189
3 жыл бұрын
3 Years Later....FInally, a third part of the witches explained!! RIP MagiReco EN (2019-2020)
@lizabey
3 жыл бұрын
"Ayaka is also generally too upbeat" Also Ayaka: Screaming internally but can only smile because yay happy
@aiai_uiui
3 жыл бұрын
Honestly I don't think any characters were created to match any of the witches, but it's still pretty cool to see your theories
@Kittytale468
3 жыл бұрын
i'm not sure if you know this but some of the characters you talked about like oriko, tart, and yuma are from the mangas. They were put in magia record as crossover/reference characters to those stories.
@unbreakable333
3 жыл бұрын
You have great analytical skills when matching with the girls. It's just unfortunate that you miss many aspects to take into account, such as: Konami is alive when Gertrud is present in Magia Record. In addition, Ayame gets a doppel during the week you released this video I believe, although would've been a great fit for Candy T-T (I paused the video to write this comment then saw you noticed the doppel! Sorry ahaha). BUT IT'S SO FUN TO SPECULATE, and I love matching them up to witches. In the game it's fun to fight Gertrud with Konami. My favourite was using Mel's doppel against her own witch for example. So definitely using your videos to make fun Magia Record teams in-game :))
@ericmeme1038
3 жыл бұрын
Hey uhm, when you were talking about the new witches one of the magical girls was actually confirmed, her name is Mel and you can see the resemblence between her doppel and witch and both of their significant ties to fortune telling and tarot cards
@dreamscapeexp9927
3 жыл бұрын
19:51 she is apart of a “gang” called Promised Blood
@lonely_space_egg
Жыл бұрын
12:55 An argument in favor of Tart being Elsa Maria is that Elsa Maria's tree symbolism might not actually be a reference to the fall of man. Elsa Maria's familiars are called "Sebastians," potentially in reference to Saint Sebastian, who was tied to a tree and shot with arrows. Joan of Arc and Saint Sebastian are both saints/martyrs.
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
10 ай бұрын
But Tart's witch symbolism is actually of Fire and swords/crosses, not shadows or trees.
@turiniti
3 жыл бұрын
Kuro and Kuroe are actually separate characters! In Magia Report, they treat em as separate characters. But I can understand the confusion since I also thought the same way. (Kuroe I'm gonna go ahead and tell ya she doesn't do much. At all. akjnegalk) But I really, really love this series! I'm a Madoka Magica NUT and seeing this made my day. I love these theories and I highly suggest checking out Magia Record if you're a fan of the franchise itself. A lot of people tend to compare it to the original Madoka, saying it's not as deep or dark-- but I promise imo, Magia Record as an anime, while it isn't perfect, is totally worth it.
@KazuhaEien
3 жыл бұрын
I think the Magia Record game has the better version of the story, while the Magia Record anime has the better transformations and visuals. Both are great! But I think that both should be enjoyed at the same time. The Magia Record game actually might be my second favorite app of all time, and would be my all-time favorite if it weren't for the horrible treatment of the North American version. I'm becoming quite nostalgic for it that I will be making a Japanese Apple account to play the Japanese server. "Kakawari" is a very underrated song, and my favorite opening song of all time, OMG...
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
@@KazuhaEien in my opinion the anime told the story better. The only thing I actually didn't like was Kuroe, she has no point beign there 😅
@flo8324
3 жыл бұрын
It honestly feels weird to come back to this after 2 years and see how much it has changed
@Everythingwillsurelybealright
3 жыл бұрын
Heck yeah loved this! I haven’t kept up with Magia Record (sadly) so it’s so fantastic to get a glimpse of all the incredible designs they’ve made for it! As always I adore your analysis too, and I’m a big fan of how you mention the candidates for each theory that you considered but still discarded. It really strengthens all the points you make AND it’s fun as heck! I can’t thank you enough for reinvigorating my interest in this series and all the fascinating lore behind it.
@mruwu6837
3 жыл бұрын
unfortunately i don't think ryo can be the last witch because SPOILER SPOILER SPOILER She died in arc 2 because someone broke her soul gem so she did not have the opportunity to become a witch (but there are still examples like kanae who happened the same thing and has doppel or Meru they gave her a doppel after a long time even when she turned into a witch in the past) so it could be a 50/50
@lanutellaanonima823
2 жыл бұрын
Honestly, I always thought Elsa Maria was the witch of Eve, of Adam and Eve, after all, her religious theme makes a lot of reference to the creation of the earth and instead of being the devil tempting eve, it may have been kyubey. It would explaine everything about her familiars, since they blindly believe and always look for companions, like anyone who's religious - also, her being the "shadow witch" ties in the blindly believe theme.
@tkjk0481
3 жыл бұрын
Sakuya is technically in a Gang. She’s part of one of the Magical Girl Gangs in Crimson Resolve.
@godomoths242
2 жыл бұрын
So.... If witches can change, this means they can think and work on themselves. I wonder if a witch could potentially, after many many years, come to process their grief and actually turn into something entirely different?
@Lia_-kz8sr
3 жыл бұрын
I’ve really been missing this game since the NA server died, so this was a nice video to watch
@justyouraveragetrashbag5718
3 жыл бұрын
I honestly think the thing that made Zenobia a witch is her family being torn apart or the environment becoming barren and lifeless. A biome usually depicted as barren and lifeless is a desert, which would indicate why Zenobia is Sandy and not grassy. The building-like structures could represent the fallen structure/stability of her family, or that's what I at least speculate.
@lavenderandchrysanthemums9441
3 жыл бұрын
Whoooop! I'm hyped! Also it's an interesting thought that the Magia Record girls are some witches tho I've neevr thoguht of it. (Probably because I've never played Magia Record)
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
Yeah many (my self included) thought the same when some characters were shown (specially with Konomi beign Gertrude and Ria beign H.N Elly Kristen) but now is very likely they aren't (since their personalities or stories don't match the witches in some ways) :( *Also if Nagisa didn't exist is more likely that I thought at first glance that Moka Megumi was Charlotte.
@ladylunaginaofgames40
2 жыл бұрын
There some magical girls in the comics you probably missed that explains some of these witches. I remember reading about one magical girl in a spin-off who's life goal was to kill Madoka before she becomes a magical girl and later the apocalyptic witch. Her story ends with her slowly dying, so its possible that in that timeline, she became that washing witch after Homura went to a new timeline.
@LadyYamiofLight
2 жыл бұрын
That’s oriko, who in the video was pointed out to already have a doppel that isn’t any of the current unsorted witches
@cristiankennedy7463
3 жыл бұрын
At long last 😭 these are how I found your channel way back in the day 😍😍
@bootao7354
3 жыл бұрын
Me too!
@cubedsquared7909
3 жыл бұрын
Same here!!
@samanthalozano2857
3 жыл бұрын
I do want to say something since this is my second rewatch of this amazing vid. In the first magical girl that is theorized to be Gertrude she has the flower aesthetic and the weapon we are looking for. You may see it and I hope I am not the only, but in the weapon's handle when opened it sort of takes on the shape of BUTTERFLY wings. That's all I wanted say, thank you for coming to my TED talk.
@Art-zp1qg
3 жыл бұрын
GenPrey on the Magia Record subreddit has done analyses on most of the cast, at least he’s covered more than the main characters. He really goes into detail with all of them too.
@DaSpineLessFish
3 жыл бұрын
Was just rewatching them the other day lol
@wansper9297
3 жыл бұрын
Aaahhh magia record, put a sh*t ton of time into it and then they just announced they were trashing the EN server... great times
@alex-8736
3 жыл бұрын
I was so excited we were finally getting to arc 2 :(
@wansper9297
3 жыл бұрын
@@alex-8736 yup.... there goes an uncountable amount of hours, I am honestly surprised doing that is legal, think about all the people that put in thousands of dollars just to get the whole thing shut down, actually insane
@KaoriV3
3 жыл бұрын
These have to be the greatest theories for Madoka Magica and Magia Record I’ve ever seen! Please, keep up the great work!
@yumiendercat3685
3 жыл бұрын
Oh wow! I only just realised there was a new video! Thanks for making this, it’s as amazing as usual and also this series encouraged me to check out Madoka Magica (I was already heavily spoiled) Looking forward to what you think of the new movie coming out!
@artafluent8485
3 жыл бұрын
I haven't thought about Madoka since i watched it when I was much younger, it's so cool seeing so many new magical girls and witches! I always loved the lore of madoka magica.
@OphiuchusTheBeheaded
2 жыл бұрын
Rika popping back up to be a witch in the video like 5 times: 🕺
@philipcheung63
4 ай бұрын
She finally got her Doppel- Belladonna!
@piscespuppyXD
3 жыл бұрын
I think the exact same about Gertrude, I have for while. There is the off chance however that Oriko could be Gertrude according to some theorists from before the game. Also the issue with tart being elsa maria. The problem with that is the fact that she was burned to death centuries ago in England and I think she’d be more powerful as a witch.
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
Yes, Kyubey said that Tart/Jeanne's witch (La Pucelle De Blancheur) would destroyed the hole Europe continent.
@laurawasnewsky155
2 жыл бұрын
Well, since Sasara now has an official Doppel, the theory of Rebecca being her Witch is deconfirmed. But fortunately, there is another Magical Girl without a Doppel that I think fits Rebecca just as well: Hotaru.
@NapaCat
3 жыл бұрын
I don't think Konomi is Gertrude because A) The costumes don't match; B) all they share is the theme of roses; and C) Konomi is cheerful and optimistic, not depressed and trapped like Gertrude was implied to be.
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
Also Konomi's flower theme are peonys. But her beign Gertrude is a popular headcanon since Magia Record came out.
@chibi3593
3 жыл бұрын
she could have becomed depressed and felt trapped after something happend
@NapaCat
3 жыл бұрын
Also Gertrude appears in the anime in events before Konomi's appearance.
@ManzanaDeMuerte
3 жыл бұрын
i may be off on this but doesnt a witch's theme/labyrinth have a lot to do with WHERE they turned into a witch? Sayaka had a lot of train tracks in her labyrinth due to where she transformed. So like... Zenobia probably snapped at the beach instead of it being that she liked the beach. I dunno. I love this video loads and I love hearing you talk about this show and theories!
@thejudgmentalcritter6584
3 жыл бұрын
It's hard to tell? Because with Sayaka, once you got deeper into her labyrinth it changed to feature a giant stage with a concert happening behind her. So it was a little hard to tell where the environmental designs stopped and the character driven ones began.
@magicaldemonboy100
3 жыл бұрын
I'm getting nostalgia all over again lol
@meowthefluffy
3 жыл бұрын
IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS HECK YEAH
@EspeonaSparkle
3 жыл бұрын
Great video!!! ❤️ I love your Madoka Magica videos! :) My headcanon is that Gisela was an unknown girl (at least up to this point) who was in a motorcycle gang and wished to be stronger. However, one day she got into an argument with someone because of one of her strong opinions that are mentioned in her familiars' description. The fight escalated and she ended up hurting, probably even killing that person. When she realized what she had done she drove to the coast and stared into the sunset, trying to process what had just happened. Her Soul Gem filled with too much grief and she became a witch.
@dajaphrodite2781
3 жыл бұрын
Because we know that witches can change over time Zenobia most likely to be Chika because a forest could be in a mountain all the trees die than it just leaves a bare mountain that will erode into sand and she keeps trying to build her forest back but forgets because its been so long. If this makes sense we still don’t know how much a witch can change though and this can be a stretch.
@0Trixa0
2 жыл бұрын
Kanoko is one of my fave MagiReco designs, and I love the idea of her witch being Quitterie. She's getting a Doppel soon, fingers crossed it confirms your theory.
@lustyburgundy
3 жыл бұрын
I haven't played/watched Magia record but as far as I'm aware witches can have different forms in different universes, so even those with doppels could be the magical girls behind the witches
@Akanina_Gacha
3 жыл бұрын
Ayame: *Has a doppel* Critter: I'll pretend i didn't saw that
@robertkovarna8294
2 жыл бұрын
30:10. That mantis is a psudeo-witch. The person who became it being a detective in Kazumi magica. With said detective lady trying to kill Kazumi when she had turned into that. As for what could make a normal person become a psudeo-witch? Evil Nuts.
@SolsisEquone
3 жыл бұрын
i would highly recomend looking at Lapine. shes a tart magia girl and her thing is turning into a witch and being reborn as a magical girl, shes also in magia record with a doppel.
@Lucas-gy5yr
3 жыл бұрын
I like your videos, I didn't know a think about madoka magica before the KZitem algorithm recommended me part 1
@SpringDragonfly15
3 жыл бұрын
Hmm, I know this is more of a what if, but based on the lore of Magia Record, I don't think any of the Magia Record characters could be any of the game-only witches. Your analysis is solid, and I'd love to see more Madoka videos on your channel.
@snqoqo
3 жыл бұрын
About Ryo, I don't really think her and the witch fit but the biggest aspect which shapes my opinion is : SPOILER FOR THE MAGIA RECORD STORY She's killed by Ao Kasane before ever being able to turn into a witch
@artistperson5785
3 жыл бұрын
I absolutely love this series and I'm so happy that there's a new video for this!! I always rewatched the other witch videos because it was just so fun to watch and it even helped me make different witch forms for my own OCS! I can't wait to see more!
@pennycat6317
3 жыл бұрын
in the Oriko Magica manga at the back it actually shows the magical girls who became the witches in the manga
@zombinary3138
Жыл бұрын
I still think ashley could be Kandi, because the wigs in Ashley’s doppel match way too well with the decapitated heads! The pink and pastel theme is still there too, and the fashion that Kandi is wearing is also very similar. Remember that the Doppel is only a part of the witch they would become, so just the decapitated heads/wigs being the doppel would still be fine.
@bronzedarkness12
3 жыл бұрын
ohhhh snappp!!! Guess who's back!!!
@shybiscket
2 жыл бұрын
Only just now idealized my favorite RWBy reviewer was also my favorite Madoka content maker
@haileyc4738
3 жыл бұрын
Even though some of these characters already have canon witch designs already I absolutely ADORE your thoughts and connections!!! You’re super good at analyzing and connecting designs to witches!!
@rubiepie
3 жыл бұрын
Kuro is spirit Guardian of Homura from the event (Is a Valentine event) Homura and Kuro becomes friends but because of Her soul gem about to Release (they are outside of Kamihama) Homura is forced to Kill Kuro. This is also an easter egg. Another event A summer event Dead magical girl tries to Possess Homura but failed because someone else is present inside of Homura The battle begins With Kuro's Witch form.
@honestlyboringperson
3 жыл бұрын
Konami has a peony, not a rose.
@Ramsey276one
3 жыл бұрын
KONAMI XD Never heard it as a name before...
@fruit4evr
3 жыл бұрын
Omg we both like Yokai Watch and Puella Magi :0
@danielbricker9041
3 жыл бұрын
So do I
@winterbreezesrule9583
3 жыл бұрын
To note, Kuro (in the game) and Kuroe (in the anime) aren't confirmed to be the same characters, though it is implied. With the rewrites the story of Magia Record present in the anime, it is possible they will be the same characters (Kuroe made her wish to be able to date someone, but they broke up amicably), but in the gag 4koma, they are separate characters. (Though, who knows, that could be retconned too, it's a gag comic.)
@OneTaker
3 жыл бұрын
Feel alot of people will want that clip of Gir going " FINALLY!" XD. I am still the confused. Are these girls from a spin off or game ( or both)? I love how you can derive so much info from just outfit looks on these. I look at them and just like " oh ya, now you mention it". All just goes over my head.
@dr.ducttape2161
3 жыл бұрын
Its the spin off gacha game, Magia Record, which also happens to have an anime adaptation if you're curious!
@dr.ducttape2161
3 жыл бұрын
Oh there's also this other PSP/PSVita ish?? Game, as far as I know it's kinda bad. But eh, that's where the witches that are in 3D are from
@senpaiisofty4393
3 жыл бұрын
YAS I love your series so much! A lot of your theories and analysis of each girl is fascinating, I hope that in the future you might figure out what each Doppel would be as a witch (aside from the ones we’ve already seen as both Doppel and Witch). I have always wondered about this, but I haven’t seen anyone actually go into it yet. Again, love your videos and can’t wait for more! ❤️
@gurenmarklaurente3762
2 жыл бұрын
Its announced that Konomi Haruna will have a doppel and to my surprise its not Gertrud at all. Now I learned that we wont really know something until its finally announced.
@thejudgmentalcritter6584
2 жыл бұрын
WHAT!? I'm blown away!!! I thought for sure if anyone, I was right about her!
@spring626
3 жыл бұрын
Loved that video! Keep working hard! I'm kinda surprised that you didn't do walpurgisnacht. Edit: I also think if magical girl raising project and madoka were in the same universe, sister nana would be a good candidate for elsa.
@thejudgmentalcritter6584
3 жыл бұрын
I thought about it, but the conclusion I had come to was that Walpurgisnacht is not only extremely old (like, the medieval ages old) but also that she was a collective. I think a whole coven would've become Walpurgisnacht, that and none of the girls from Magia Record would seem like a good fit for her. :)
@CherryCoffee420
3 жыл бұрын
Your the entire reason I watched Madoka, and I don’t regret it! Thank you for uploading this!
@CherryCoffee420
3 жыл бұрын
Also! Not all the Doppels are similar to the witches, such as Madoka’s, or Mami’s
@cookiesandcream7668
3 жыл бұрын
3:29 The thing is (I'm not sure if this is how it works) but she became depressed and that's how she became a witch, it ties a link between her depressed form and shows why she isnt depressed And the butterflies are associated with her flowers, maybe she felt like she had to be free? Like she wanted to fly away like them, what if becoming a magical girl eventually made her depressed and she wished for a way out, like how a butterfly is free to fly wherever they want
@gabrieldossantossanta5656
3 жыл бұрын
Rebecca could be the friend Yachio see turning into a witch in the anime: her ability is to "read" the future whit taro cards, Yachio even say she should stop, because If the cards say someone is going to die, someone will die. It make sense for me, since her ability is related to supernatural, use things to keep spirits away make sense, and the despair of losting a friend and being capable of prevent it, make she feel guilty.
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
Rebekka's eye Symbol is more related to sleep than to the future, since her nature is insomnia. Also Mel's witch is Etteilla, the Fortune Teller Witch.
@toxicalyss
3 жыл бұрын
Oh god the whole video is shouting "nice meguca you got there, what if their friends DIE and becomes a WITCH?". Poor Masara...
@SiriProject
3 жыл бұрын
Rena Minami was a perfect match for H.N. Elly; she denies her loneliness by longing after idol culture, has the twin tails and even the blue theme. But her doppel is totally different, sadly!
@fernandocuauhshihuacarbaja3094
3 жыл бұрын
H.N Elly's/Kristen's theme revolves around happy memories and friendships, while Rena theme's are mirrors and changes/transformation. Rena doesn't fit into that since she didn't have many friends when she became a magical girl and her wish was about changing herself, not about a memory with her friends.
@MordredPendragon7997
3 жыл бұрын
So happy that this is finally out. I've been waiting for this since I first saw part two, and when you mentioned in your Magical Girl May announcement that you would be doing part three finally, I was so excited.
@medifeuer9683
Жыл бұрын
I love your videos to the witches so much
@wahajhaider6313
3 жыл бұрын
Im not a Madoka Magica fan but my god do you make it so fun
Пікірлер: 583