I’m a winner? Me? I am a winner!!!!!!! This is awesome!!!!
@bryanbrett8943
Жыл бұрын
Thank you for saying that! Makes me feel better about my hd28 !
@paulkline3011
Жыл бұрын
🤣. I wish I was winning!!! But I'm not!!!
@multipipi1234
Жыл бұрын
And rich.
@johnwashburn3793
Жыл бұрын
@multipipi1234 no, not really
@LaskMaestro
2 жыл бұрын
So this was the best comparison that I have ever seen of the HD-28 and the D-35. It was so so good to hear them played in succession as you did so well. Thank you for the thorough specs too. I never quite understood the complete story about the brace structure. Thank you for your thoroughness I love the sound of both guitars and I see the problem of combining picking style with chordal technique. I have visited the Martin Guitar factory twice with my guitar students. We live in the NW burbs of Philly and it only took us an hour school bus drive to get there. 😯 Absolutely fascinating tour of a historic factory displaying the beauty of Americana! So I do own one of these babies. I bought the D-35 back in 2004. It is my child now for 18 years. I just love the fullness of tone projection that it delivers. Keep the great videos coming.
@timber750
Жыл бұрын
After watching this comparison (and several others) I opted for the HD-35. No regrets. Rich, full sound, but still articulates well enough for how I play--fingerstyle, occasionally a thumb pick, very occasionally finger picks as well, but mostly bare fingers. Thin bracing probably contributes to the beginning of a "belly" after just two years. Gorgeous tone.
@b1j
2 жыл бұрын
I’m with you for the HD-28 for all three of the reasons. To those I’d add that the HD-28 can deliver a robust strumming sound, while the HD-35, with its slimmer braces, can sound a little overloaded when strummed. I’m picking up an HD-28E this afternoon.
@robertnewell5057
3 жыл бұрын
Hey, Chris. That was a really, really good roundup of the history and specs of the two guitars. I have an HD35 and don't experience the playing drawback you describe. It is also a great fingerpicker. I listened to them blind and could always tell the HD35. That's really no big deal, but I have two other high end Martins and a couple of handmades, and my wife can always tell the HD35 FROM A DIFFERENT ROOM! So I'd ask you to give a bit more time before making your choice. My original reason for choosing the HD35 was because I prefer a bound fingerboard, but by the time I got round to buying one, the HD28 (and, as I recall, all other Martin Standard series) have pocket fret slots, which are indistinguishable in feel from bound, so it was the sound which tipped the balance. One piece of trivia - according to Chris Martin, it was actually the declining supplies in Brazilian RW specifically which led to the HD35 3 piece back, and they originally had a Brazilian offcut in the middle with East Indian on either side. They've been all EIRW for many years, of course. Finally, as far as I'm aware the HD35 is the only stock Martin with 1/4 inch bracing. Standard 000s have 5/16ths (I went to the Martin site to double check and only the 000 Deluxe has 1/4 inch!) and so the HD35 actually has LESS bracing than 000s generally, not the same! Some 'signature' models have 1/4 inch (notably the Stefan Grossman J38 - sadly long discontinued and a BIG body guitar for 1/4 inch). My friend has one and I have a J40. I can't hear a difference, even though the SG J38 has Madagascar RW. Thanks for a great watch.
@marksoftime
3 жыл бұрын
Hi Robert what are your thoughts on the J40?
@boshi9
Жыл бұрын
000-18 has 1/4" bracing (but not the standard 000-28 as you've said). Standard OMs (of all series) are also built with 1/4" bracing.
@ElMcMeen1a
Жыл бұрын
@@marksoftime Just to interject: I had one and loved it, but didn't like the 1-11/16" nut. The Grossman model, which I assisted on with Stefan and Dick Boak, is a tremendous Martin guitar!
@marksoftime
Жыл бұрын
@@ElMcMeen1a I ended up buying a J40 :)
@chrisb9740
3 жыл бұрын
My understanding is that the change in construction in the 28 occurred in the 40s not the 60s. People were putting heavier and heavier strings on them to get more volume, so Martin strengthened the soundboard in response to this. Unfortunately, this also changed the sound (not for the better) and many people would pay to have the guitars changed back to the original spec. This is why pre war 28s are the most valuable acoustic guitars on the planet. The HD was introduced to correct this but as you say the new spec 28 was wisely left in the line up - since it also had its fans and is still hugely popular. The HD28 is widely regarded as the best sounding acoustic you can get - at any price. Great video. Me and my HD28 thank you.
@iemgr2002
2 ай бұрын
That is wild. I heard what you heard on the articulation of THESE 2 guitars. However, I did this same test in Savannah on 2 different HD-28/HD-35s and this 35 was much more specific /articulate than the 28, which was washy, like i was hearing it through an imaginary flanger pedal or something. So at this rare air level, any 2 can be wayy different than the next 2. I obviously got the 35 and it is legendary. Also, its wayy more guitar than any 28, like $400 more. It is the only non custom shop model that uses #6 wood, because the 35 is a reclamation project off the custom shop cutting room floor, hence the 3 pc back. The D-35 reclaims wood from general production, the Hd-35 reclaims wood from the custom shop. It is finished & plekked in the custom shop, its just wayy more guitar than any 28. This may or may not go into your decision, but my HD35 is way huge AND specific. When i heard those 2, that was a 1 second decision right there. Go Dawgs.
@oldmanofcotati
2 жыл бұрын
Chris, Your presentation here was a "TEN!" . Seriously a very, really , very very good explanation with historical content. You are quality young man. Thank you for holding that standard. I bought a fabulous HD35 new in 1985. It was stolen in 2006. I tracked down the thief and cut off four fingers from each of her hands; Then I divorced her. I finally replaced her with a new 2018 D18. I am going to replace my stolen HD35 soon with a new traditional HD28. I find the HD28 & HD35 vastly different sounding guitars.
@lorigilmore5521
Жыл бұрын
I love the HD35. I like the neck binding, I love the three piece back. But mostly I love that big sound. Wonderful. Thanks for all of the insight Chris.
@foreststokes2276
3 жыл бұрын
I purchased an HD35 for my 60th BDay. I played both and love the sound of the 35. I quite looking at the looks of a guitar years ago. It could look like Willie's Trigger but if it sounds good, It's the one.
@tommythunder99
8 ай бұрын
About a month ago I finally did it. I bought a Martin HD35. This piece of art is simply amazing.
@ronaldjewell6255
2 жыл бұрын
Hello Chris; I am 72 years old and been playing guitar and performing as a side hustle since 1975. I am basically an Americana & Irish folk guitar player and singer. I also cover a lot of old school country songs in my repertoir. I have owned many acoustic guitars over the years. My main guitar I have right now is a 2001 Martin d16 cutaway with the fishman prefix blender system. A very nice guitar and I had been contemplating purchasing a d28. But after recently playing a d35 I'm totally sold on the d35 big sound and sustain and it's looks. My first guitar many years ago was a light toned sunburst acoustic Yamaha. I really like the look of Martin's Ambertone d35. Thank you for the demo of both the d28 & d35. After listening to how they both sound in someone else's hands I'm sold on the d35. Thank you for a very informative demo and history lesson about both of the iconic acoustic works of art. Take care and stay safe and may the fates be kind to you.
@danielcassidy4857
2 жыл бұрын
I agree on the No binding on the neck and open back tuners of the HD-28. It also sounded like you could articulate better with it as well but it might just be my ears.
@mikejackson3320
3 жыл бұрын
I personally like the 35 deeper sound & own a 35. Enjoy your videos. Thanks.
@charlottesimonin2551
3 жыл бұрын
For me the 35 sounds more like a loud guitar played as back up to a singer while the 28 sounds more like a soloist quality instrument.
@allenfowler1794
Жыл бұрын
HD-35 Owner here. To my ear the 28 is a tad bit deeper and a beautiful sound and beautiful guitar. Don't know how you could go wrong with either.
@michealhuskeymusic4508
2 жыл бұрын
I’m looking at a HD28 this week. I’m definitely leaning in that direction. Thanks!
@Ziraffe2
2 жыл бұрын
I totally follow your evaluation. And my acoustic ears wasn't born yesterday. The 28 is more defined. Keep the good stuff happening. Appreciated ^
@elliecutler6736
2 жыл бұрын
I love my HD28! This HD35 has some aural similarities to my Collings OM. Interesting! Thanks for the detailed review and history of these Martins.
@BoatersMarineSpply
3 жыл бұрын
Chris, Thanks so much for your detailed explanation of the bracing differences between the HD28 & HD35. I own an HD28E and didn't know this. I also own a Martin D18 Sunburst, DRS2, and DSS15M mahogany and now have to know the bracing for each. Cheers, Rick Louisville KY
@GregParkemusic1
2 жыл бұрын
Nice review! It just re-affirmed my choice to get a HD35. I played many different guitars, and I always went back to the Martin HD35. I sometimes get to perform on a concert system ( Avid SC48 mixer, Meyer FOH ) and the sound guy has told me several times that my guitar is the best sounding, and easiest to mix acoustic guitar he has worked with. I love the HD28
@GregParkemusic1
2 жыл бұрын
Oops, I accidentally hit the “post” button ……anyway, I was saying I love the HD28 as well, but the HD35 just has a richer, fuller sound for my playing style
@dixie2141
Жыл бұрын
Great comparison, I own the HD-28 and while I gave it the edge while strumming I gave the edge to the HD-35 while finger picking . So I thought they were even, a matter of choice. They are both Martins , you can’t lose.
@johnn2326
3 жыл бұрын
I love his information and history he provides us.
@paulstabin6233
2 жыл бұрын
Both great. The HD28 is clearer. The HD35 is a bit warmer- and better in the bass -but the treble notes on the HD 28 were actually sweeter. For balance and clarity- the 28. For more bass and warmth- the 35. But both great. I owned a D18 in the '70's, and played some of the earliest 35's in stores. The 28 was just easier to play and the 35 at that time was considered less desirable than the iconic 28 by musicians I knew. That was then. Now it is just a matter of preference. Johnny Cash among others was fine with his D35. I think, as always, it is case by case. There are great 35's and great 28's. Cost no object, I like the 41 or 42. None of these have the wood sound of an 18. And that is why many of us aspire to owning multiple great guitars.
@KeithVincentmusic
Жыл бұрын
I just bought an HD-28. I searched for a while and tried several guitars - Martin and other brands. I hadn't tried an HD-28 yet and while I was playing a different guitar the guy at the shop brought a brand new HD-28 from the back still wrapped from the factory. I got to open it and play it for the first time. It completely overshadowed every other guitar I had tried. It came home with me and it has been an absolute game changer.
@chrisgjelsten3621
2 жыл бұрын
Thanks, Chris. Great information. I’m waiting for my HD-28e
@StephenBommarito
3 жыл бұрын
Never played an HD35, but I own an HD28 and it is amazing. Certainly a purchase I will never regret!
@kevinmoss3144
2 жыл бұрын
I have an HD28 as well with Retro strings and it's cannon. My brother in law has a D35 and my 28 is the only guitar he's ever played that can hang with his 35. He's offered to trade but I have respectfully declined numerous times. I love the 35 but my heart belongs to my HD28.
@romerobinson8279
Жыл бұрын
@@kevinmoss3144 what year is your hd28? You got me wanting one!
@Thekarlskorner
3 ай бұрын
Hello Chris, I came across your video as I am seriously considering upgrading a Martin from my ten year old Martin GC MMV. Your video clearly goes way beyond in depth and answered all my questions on the differences between the HD -28 and the HD-35. My next move is find a store that has both in stock to compare, but bring along my MMV and compare all three. Thank you for a no nonsense video.
@gfurstnsu
Жыл бұрын
The Herringbone was not dropped from Martin Guitars soon after WW II because I was difficult to install but because it was no longer available from Germany where it had been sourced. They used it until all their stock was depleted. Your other information presented is right on. I have both a 1969 D-35 and a 1998 HD-28 and they are as you describe. Which do I prefer, the D-35 because it has a mellower tone for folk and the HD-28 to play blue grass and some of the beetles songs like Black Bird. The HD-28 has a very percussive tone that really projects. I did not know that the bracing on the D-35 was thinner then that on the HD-28. This was new information to me and explains the more mellow tone of the D-35. I really appreciated this information. Finally I understand what really appealed to me about the D-35. I love that unique tone and now understand its source. The D-35 sounds like no other Dreadnought. But I love both of them for their differences and similarities. After all they are both Dreadnoughts. I play them both nightly in a local "Live Caffe" here in Daejeon, South Korea.
@jeffreylewis2737
9 ай бұрын
I think that's a brilliant bit of work. I totally agree. I have a 1972 Martin D-28, but I've always loved that mellow, resonant, rich d-35 sound FOR SOME SONGS. But instead of buying a 35 for live performances, I bought a d-18 with the recycled timber top. It has the built in pick-up. Maybe it's not as pure a sound as the 28 or 35-but it works beautifully on stage. Few people in the audience would get the nuances of these guitars. Only other Martin guitarists. Probably the nicest Martin I've ever played was a very old Martin. Small body, old open machine heads. I can't remember the exact date, but it was probably one of their first. It belonged to Glen Shorrick who was the lead singer with an 80's group called The Little River Band. This little thing sounded like a piano. I wish I owned it.
@justinray9895
3 жыл бұрын
Love your guys videos! My opinion is the HD-28 is the best guitar on the planet. I'm the proud owner of a 2019 HD-28 and it's the sweetest sounding wooden box ever made. I love the HD-35 to though so it's definitely a battle there! Keep them coming Chris you rock bro!!🤘😎🤘
@bowenli9823
3 жыл бұрын
I also have a 2020 HD-28. Love it!
@kapstersmusic
3 жыл бұрын
I agree. I have a 2020-21 HD-28E and it's great for strumming, fingerpicking, and flatpicking. Tone to die for! The 35 did sound a wee bit louder, also very nice, but i don't think I would need it. One Martin dreadnaught is enough for me, took me a lifetime to realize I deserved one. I would honestly be worried in the long term about the thinner 000 bracing on the scale length of a dreadnaught, especially if you string it with the medium gauge strings Martin ships it with. Might be more prone to bellying around the bridge (just conjecture).
@toddjohnson271
Жыл бұрын
I have a 2017 HD-28.......it is complete.....from bass, to sweet top end w sustain. Play it light, or get on it to make it bark. It matters not, and makes me sound like a better player than I am.
@jamestoops7228
2 жыл бұрын
They compliment each other to my ears .Both sound outstanding as is your playing of them.
@yostie3832
3 жыл бұрын
I would pick the same HD-28 for all the same reasons you explain in the video Awesome video thanks for the insight as I was torn between both myself now I know witch one I’ll be getting. Thanks
@padrejohnruffle
2 жыл бұрын
I really go along with Chris on this. If you were putting the guitar into a mix, playing the HD28 would make it far easier to place, because the articulation is more distinct in the mid-tones especially. Some will argue that the sound can be shaped in the mix and of course it can, but you're only able to mix what the mic picks up. Although the HD35 obviously has more bass, the HD28 still holds that distinctive Martin tone that I've yet to hear any other guitar manage to replicate. The one real downside for me on the D28 is the lack of Grover tuners. Is it possible to get one custom made with Grovers I wonder? All my friends in the early '70s had Grovers on their Martins, and most of them are no longer with us or have jumped on the Taylor wagon. Comparison suggestion please: Martin v. Taylor!
@padrejohnruffle
Жыл бұрын
9 months later and I even forgot I commented, but to show how personal tastes change, (or how fickle I am!) I'm now going for the HD-35 over the 28. Why? I want as much of that Martin low end bass as I can have and the HD-35 has it. I'm also a lot less fussy about closed v. open back tuners than I was prior. Overall, I like the bound neck on the 35 and I've taken on board prior comments about the open tuners being lighter. And I'm surprised that the cost difference between he 2 instruments seems to be pretty marginal.
@cqmi2479
2 жыл бұрын
Love my HD35, although I'd never turn my nose up at either one. Fantastic guitars, both.
@RobTackettCovers
2 жыл бұрын
I heard the same thing...the HD28 sounded better as far as a focus...as in: in your playing, it came off as the notes you intended to pop in your playing were more prevelant on the HD28 vs the HD35...some of the sound on the HD35 was washing out for some reason...I'm wearing some pretty good 2 driver earbuds listening to this...just my opinion of coarse...and I really want to like the sound of the HD35 better because I prefer the look of the 3 piece back and the bound fingerboard...but as they say, looks aren't everything...thanks for spending the time to do this video...in reality though, if there was 2 great Martins on Craigslist, both from say 2020, both in comparably great shape, one was an HD35 and the other was an HD28, and the HD35 was selling for 2K and the HD28 was selling for 2.5K, I'd get the HD35....they're both great guitars if you're looking for a non-cutaway dreadnaught...
@lonniewerle5544
2 жыл бұрын
I own a D35 made in 1972. I bought in high school. I’m 65 now. If I remember correctly it sold 700.00 new
@ericoswood1856
3 жыл бұрын
I have a D-35 and it’s a winner. I compared both and the D-35 won.
@earlspearl2933
3 жыл бұрын
At least you were honest and made a comparison . didn't pick your dog till after the show .
@h2oloo1964
2 жыл бұрын
Awesome, detailed review! I learned a lot. Thanks Chris
@johnbevilacqua6751
2 жыл бұрын
Hi, thanks for that comparison. I own a Judy Collins Signature HD-35 SJC 6 string with a maple back in the three piece. What attracted me to this instrument was indeed the resonance. Every not or chord played sounded like one had a full orchestra coming from the sound hole. Mind you, I never take it to a gig as my Gibson Songwriter has that more focused sound that you were talking about Chris. But when it is just me and the guitar, it is always the HD35.
@tooter5250
3 ай бұрын
Terrific video, for both the history and the comparisons of the two guitars. I appreciated your variation in songs so as to bring out different musical aspects and show how well each guitar sounded across styles. I'm old and about to buy (finally) a Martin guitar, and I am definitely leaning toward the HD 28. Now we're talkin' the subtlties of two incredibly great guitars. Listening carefully to both, I find the HD28 has great lows, not as bassy as the hd35, but to me the latter lows are almost too much, as though they overpower the mid and high tones. Like one commeenter stated, it takes time to learn how to play the d35 and work with its acoustics. Nevertheless, overall, I prefer the sound of the hd28; just an amazing balance of tones. Again, thanks for a terrific video.
@elementaryprincipal4658
2 жыл бұрын
If I can ever get my hands on one of these, my choice would also be the 28 because I think its tone would go better with my voice. When I sang along with both, I felt I was competing with those sweet, ringing upper-mid tones on the 35. If I were more fingerstyle, I think the 35 would be the one.
@jerryashby8699
3 жыл бұрын
Got an HD28 reimagined. Awesome. Not sure if it sounds as great as the SC Tony Rice i owned from 99-04, but it is still pretty great. Also, Chris..you do the best job by far of anyone on you tube. In one of your videos you said you talk too much. No you don't. You give GREAT information and insight. Dont change thing.
@JerryHoward88
Жыл бұрын
I like the sound of the HD35, but both lovely!
@SuperScreamerBand
Ай бұрын
Thank you for a great explanation and review. Just as you I like the both guitars, but loves the HD-28. For me it is about the clarity and the astethics.
@jeffreybell5306
2 жыл бұрын
For what it is worth I heard more of the Clapton sound out the HD28, like you said better transition from single notes to cords!
@softsouthernknight
3 жыл бұрын
The HD-35 holds that bass tone all the way through. Very lightly braced guitar like my 000-17.
@leofransen
3 жыл бұрын
You need both!
@2tubeguitar
2 жыл бұрын
Great review!! Thanks a lot!
@thomasrusso4506
Жыл бұрын
I have both. I can’t say which I like best because it depends on the day and the music that they produce!
@mauronorbedo2576
Жыл бұрын
Thank you Chris, yesterday i could do my own comparison here in Milano. I ended up with very same conclusions!
@1funkybasslady
2 жыл бұрын
Wow!! That 35 is a CANNNNON! I would love to have that for finger style because I love the rich full sound that 000's and OM's don't/can't produce. Strummed chords on the 35 produce so much bass that it overpowers and drowns out the upper register notes of chords making the chords sound unbalanced. You're right, Chris, it would be difficult to play a combination of strumming/individual notes and have it sound articulate. My choice?? I'd love to add a D-35 to my collection, but without fingerboard binding, with snowflake fret markers and butterbean open-back tuners. In other words, I'd like to have the D-35 body with the D-28 neck/tuners. I'm suppose that if I really wanted those specs, I could always order one from the Martin Custom Shop. 😁 Thanks, Chris, for yet another great comparison video. Your videos are some of the best, most informative ones on KZitem! BTW, the reason Martin originally came up with the 3-piece back design was because of a dwindling supply/source of Brazilian rosewood with which to make full-sized backs, so I believe the center piece was BRW and the other two pieces were EIRW. Eventually, of course, the back became all EIRW.
@mikewheeler3994
2 жыл бұрын
Have an HD 28 VR for 24 yrs. Never looked back, it very sweet and dynamic if you want it to be.
@davidward5225
3 жыл бұрын
Love my HD-35 50th anniversary model
@johnsee7269
4 ай бұрын
Both are sublime but the 35 is more sublime... I'd just get both... Really enjoyed the passionate demo; well done! 🤘
@alestev24
3 жыл бұрын
I always thought that only the D-35 has quarter inch bracing, but non-scalloped (even since the reimagening), and the HD-35 has 5/16, and scalloped for the past few years. Whatever, I own a D-35, and I absolutely love it, because it sounds better for fingerpicking in my view than both the D-28 and the HD-28. It is easier to play it soft or loud, at least for me, mostly fingerpicking and using it to accompany my singing.
@aluminati9918
3 жыл бұрын
Wow, bigger difference than I expected. D-35 Lower mid & bass response had a bit of the D-15 oomph to my ears. And not in a bad way. Thanks for your detailed review!
@kihoalurocks
3 жыл бұрын
Maybe I’m the different one here. I’d get both. But that’s just me. I have not found any one guitar that suits my moods so I tend to go for multiples. I love my Martins, I also have some Taylors I love as well. Depends on my mood. The different sounds tend to make me play things differently. I also tend to lean towards different tone woods. I fingerpick mostly and never use a pick even when strumming so these will sound different with my playing as opposed to other people I play with.
@alanlittle8817
2 жыл бұрын
I personally lean towards the 35. I love the strong bass feel, and most of my playing is with my church’s praise band, chords primarily.
@texhaines9957
3 жыл бұрын
I didn't think there would be as much difference in voice as there is. I liked the voice of the HD-35. However, I have a D-14 Custom Shop that is effectively a D-28 with Adirondack top, amber tone finish and hide glue with Golden Era scalloped bracing. The D-28 Modern Deluxe is also nice but not in the comparison. Thanks Chris
@buskman3286
3 жыл бұрын
Nice Review! I've played a lot of Martins - D and HD 28's, 35's 41's and 45's. The best sounding Martin I've ever played was a custom D45 (hide glue/Madagascar RW sides and back/Alpine spruce top). Actually, to my ear that was the best sounding steel string acoustic guitar I've ever heard. BUT TBF, as far as the Martin standard models, the D35 is the one that sounds best to me and it's the Martin I've always wanted.. I also like bound necks, finding them easier to play because I can see the side fret markers better! Sadly, D35s are not in my guitar budget...:(
@watchfan6180
2 жыл бұрын
Very small differences, great professional guitars
@itaintmebabe714
Жыл бұрын
The HD35 is way bassier. You can hear the big differences through headphones
@jj8526
2 жыл бұрын
Great review.....👏👏☘
@Richard-uh8oq
3 жыл бұрын
I like both but the HD35 has a fuller body sound to me not muddy at all but I wouldn't mind either.
@powbobs
5 ай бұрын
I love my HD-28, D-18 and 00-15M.
@PeterFrancis-u5x
Жыл бұрын
I have a ‘97 HD28 Vintage. Love the sound. Easy to play. I also am the original owner of a ‘68 D18 ($300, thank you!). Both sound great. The HD provides a bit more volume….but they’re both super guitars.
@cookie_monztyr4678
3 жыл бұрын
I came here for one sole purpose... can someone please tell me whats the name of the song he always plays when he demos a guitar @ 10:56? I've watched a lot of his videos and i've been setting my eyes on either a 000-28 or the OM-28. I just want to know whats the name of the song and i never seem to get an answer lol 😂
@scrumpymanjack
Жыл бұрын
Great comparison. Thanks. I prefer the H35 in this video but I have the chance to buy an HD-28 at a total-bargain price so that's the one I'm going to have. Unfortunately, it's a 2012 model, so has the Grover tuners and dot markers but I can't argue. I own a Collings D2H so it'll be super interesting to compared those two.
@danielgregory9564
3 жыл бұрын
I like them both. But prefer the sound of the HD28 better.
@brianellis15
2 жыл бұрын
Just to chime in, the D-35 hasn’t always had Grovers. In the late 90s/early 00s they often used standard Martin-branded tuners. My father’s ‘02 D-35 is an example of this.
@boxertwinjeff
2 жыл бұрын
Which were Gotoh tuners as on my '99 D35
@MrMd5555
2 жыл бұрын
I always find it fascinating how the comments sections in these comparisons is always full of people claiming a hands down winner claiming one is definitely better when really they are just trying to justify their purchase for themselves, in many cases it almost seems due to insecurities about their purchase. At these price points, it's no longer about the "better guitar" or "clearly richer tone", it comes down to preference, playing style, technique & intended use. A fingerstylist isn't gonna look for the same qualities as a bluegrass flat picker or a rock guy looking for a good acoustic etc. It reminds of the tele vs les paul debate, fender v marshall,, 9mm vs 45,Ford v Chevy etc there is no clear objective one size fits all winner when comparing high end instruments. Not to mention idk how many times I've convinced myself I wanted a certain instrument based on a yt tone demo only to find in my hands & an a/b comparison that I came to much different results. These demos are a great starting point but can't be used as a substitute for playing & comparing in person. Ok off my soap box lol
@bobbyb1607
Жыл бұрын
I have an hd35 and I love it. To me it sounds fuller. Both are excellent guitars. I also have an OOOM. It's quite and sweeter sounding. Perfect for playing at night when everyone is asleep
@bobbybo3458
3 жыл бұрын
I love both of these guitars, but i own the HD35. The HD35, because of the lighter bracing and different construction is, I think, louder and delivers more overtones. I did find that as strings get older, they cut some of the overtones and it sounds more like the HD28, more focused. Best of both worlds. Now I heard from someone that the reason Martin discontinued the herringbone trim was that it was imported from Germany, which made it impossible to obtain during and after WWII.
@atxplankspanker
Жыл бұрын
The "muddy" HD-35 tone can be solved easily by the D-35. If you're looking for a clear full voiced guitar, check into the D-35. You get the bling and the clarity of a great dreadnought.
@YAKMANONT
Жыл бұрын
Both sound Great. I have a D35 and Love it.
@tommylitchfield3450
2 жыл бұрын
The D28 lost the herringbone binding in 1946. The herringbone inlay material was made in Germany. After the War, that was no longer available. That is why Martin discontinued the herringbone inlays when they did. They also changed from diamond position markers to plain dots. They also went to straight braces then, not in the 60's. People were using HEAVY gauge strings and bowing tops. They also went to Sitka spruce tops instead of Adirondack spruce for the tops. D 18s and D28s lost their forward-shifted braces in mid 1938. All these things are what make the mid 30's Martins the Holy Grail of guitars.
@robcaputo9708
Жыл бұрын
Okay great vid, you made my mind up. Its the 35 for me. But please please provide a list of that you play again and again. I want to learn some.
@MarkLysaght
Жыл бұрын
I think that forward shifting the bracing on the Reimagined HD-35 may be a bridge too far. I have the older model HD-35 and to my ears, the sound is really special. The Reimagined HD-28 is really a HD-28v with a different neck and nut width. I also have one of these, another fine guitar, so really I'm spoiled for choice! Well done Chris, a fantastic video!
@Joe-mz6dc
Жыл бұрын
Both are utterly beautiful instruments.
@linnmenzie9468
4 ай бұрын
I was set on buying a HD35 but now that I heard the HD28 I like the sound and I prefer it over the HD35
@fabriziomancuso6549
Жыл бұрын
I have long been considering getting an HD...28 or 35. There are several reviews around on the web and I have to admit that then the recording of the guitars makes a lot of difference. In this case, maybe it's because you don't have a long enough fingernail on your thumb, but in fingerstyle the bass is a bit too smoothy compared to the natural sound. The 35 has a more luxurious sound, it sounds much more like a D42 for instance. The 28 is perhaps more traditional and there is a different sound equalisation. An equalisation that allows a different, sharper division between notes. I'd probably take the 35 actually.
@randyshoop3214
2 жыл бұрын
Great review/comparison. Love your videos and all the comments that follow. I love my HD35V. Does the HD35 V (vintage series), no longer produced by Martin have material differences from the HD35 ? I’m also considering adding the HD28 to my collection. Speaking of collection, what is everyone doing with humidity control to properly maintain the wood. My luthier says he can notice some drying/curve in the top/back. I live in the northeast and humidity is low during winter months. Hate keeping these beautiful instruments in the case with various sponge systems.
@DeadReckoner
Жыл бұрын
I enjoyed the history and both guitars sound great (I prefer the HD35). I think the comparisons would be clearer if you stuck to shorter clips for each guitar, switching back more often. Just an idea :)
@alphasportstv
Жыл бұрын
Great vid Chris
@gloryman3634
2 жыл бұрын
I went through a sampling of Martin acoustics at a local music shop and bought the HD 28. (I think the D-35 wasn't the HD iteration.) To me that "particular" HD-28 was a superior acoustic. The next thing to consider is what kind of strings you use. (see my other comment here: kzitem.info/news/bejne/l6Ntr4GlkHyhnKA) I found that this is more important than most people realize. Also, from experience it seems that all releases of the same guitar model are not created equal. Some are just superior than others. So for me, "individuality" and "especially" string selection are important considerations when making a decision on which instrument to buy.
@CascaydAzgard
Жыл бұрын
HD28 for cords and HD35 for single string finger style is my prefrence as far as I can hear. The HD35 really talks well with single string plucking =)
@jackwallin
2 жыл бұрын
In listening to the recording, the D-35 had crisper sounding high notes and more balance. Almost like the strings were newer. I own both. A 40’ D-28 and a 76’ D-35. The tone in the pre war is completely different and better than the D-35 that I own. But side by side with you playing, I preferred the sound of the D-35.
@TheDavidfallon
Жыл бұрын
Shaved or not shaved is the difference between scalloped or straight bracing.
@ptournas
3 жыл бұрын
I purchased a new D-28 around 1989. I thought it had a great sound, but always liked the balance between bass and high strings on the D-35 better. Probably because I do a lot of fingerpicking and the bass lines didn't seem as strong on the D-28, so I ended up selling it and purchased a D-35 in 1998. As far as sound goes, my best sounding guitar is a 1966 Martin D-1235 (Brazilian Rosewood 12 string with a D-35 body), purchased in 1969 for $400! Of course it's got the old style neck and some friends have remarked that it's like playing a baseball bat :) I do notice that the bass seems improved on the newer D-28's. My preference is still for the D-35, but I can understand why some might prefer the D28.
@garbb5611
3 жыл бұрын
I find the 18 sound more balanced from mahogoney rather than rosewood. I have a hd28 and a guild d35nt built in 73. It is a mahogoney dread
@TheDavidfallon
Жыл бұрын
I'm sold. I'll take the HD 35 please! Not that I can afford either. 😋
@reedmelicher8658
2 жыл бұрын
What was the name of the last song you played? I really liked that!
@patrickroe3260
Жыл бұрын
String choice with both of these guitars is more critical than with some guitars. Mediums give greater volume but lights give greater articulation. With both of these guitars, volume isn't really an issue so do you need more volume?
@kyleharleyanderton
3 жыл бұрын
Save some money , get a Recording King RD-328! I loved it!
@Richard-uh8oq
3 жыл бұрын
I agree I have both rd328 and ro328 really superb guitars for the money
@pjiossi
Жыл бұрын
Helpful comparison! Can you do one that adds the 42 and 45 models as well?
@briandesjardins728
3 жыл бұрын
Hd35 sounds better imo
@jonnynevada8915
2 жыл бұрын
According to my AKG Studio headphones , in this particular video, the D-35 is the far superior sounding instrument .. Seems to have a more pronounced mids and a crisper top end with a full bottom end. 🤷♂️
@gabrielfort2574
3 жыл бұрын
HD-35 all the way baby!!!!
@williamnichols6253
2 жыл бұрын
What is that bluegrass pickin' tune?? (9:55) and that pretty fingerpicking tune? (10:57)?? Somebody help, I got to know!
@sherwinmina2563
7 ай бұрын
Did you ever find out? I really want to know the one at 9:55…
@williamnichols6253
6 ай бұрын
@@sherwinmina2563 No, but I was playing it in Guitar Center one day and this couple were shopping for a guitar for their 5 year old son and said, "Is that from KZitem?" and they meant Alamo
@dturner9343
Жыл бұрын
It's 1 and 11 sixteenth
@MichaelAppollo
Жыл бұрын
Does the D-35 split the difference in tone between these two?
Пікірлер: 369