It is easier to reveal what we do not know, than it is to explain what we think they know. Everyone is just watching and listening. Which of the disrespectful comments on this page come from Tai Chi practitioners or even true internal martial artists? It is all part of a deeper understanding of the natural potentials of a human being, set on a path of limitless refinement in the art of yielding. Arthur Clark said" A sufficiently advanced technology appears as magic". Same thing goes for this
@hellmoth
16 жыл бұрын
I was taught by Master Chu in the 1980's. I took part in some of these demonstrations both as an individual and in groups. He did the same with all comers. It was something very strange, but boy that guy had something. Many people have since said it's nothing special but I have NEVER met anyone who could do anything anywhere near what he could do.
@jsmith4447
11 жыл бұрын
I am a student of Master Chu's Lineage and have been instructed by his disciple of 20 years. The Taijiquan I have been taught can only be described as outstanding. I have been taught the Taijiquan curriculum so far. This includes Standing Post (Of which there are many postures), The Slow Form, The Fast Form (small circle), Push Hands, Da Lu, Ball Exercises, The Sword Form, The Whip Form and a myriad of moving Qigongs. As far as the form goes my form looks like YSC's form,
@youfafao
15 жыл бұрын
Je me suis entrainé avec un de ses élèves..très puissant et impressionnant..i trained with one of Master Chu'sstudent...very impressive and powerful. Thank you Master Chu,friendship from France!
@beategoessler6160
3 жыл бұрын
a real divine master , I could feel it through my whole body...
@microcosmic2
16 жыл бұрын
what a amazing demo ! all the parts of the body of Chu King Hung can be powerful and dangerous.I think a lot of people will not believe there eyes but it is a long and hard work.Special students can demonstrate things like that too.
@JazzRastaf
12 жыл бұрын
@araynier le T'ai Chi est dévalué depuis longtemps: la plupart des maîtres n'a aucune notion de ce qu'est l'interne, le ch'i est devenu une métaphore pour certains "trucs". Si Yang Lu Chan lui-même faisait une démonstration aujourd'hui on le traiterait d'imposteur.
@JonValkenberg
12 жыл бұрын
Some comments are really funny. There are a lot of fakes, true. But this one isn't, Actually it's a rather often demonstrated technique and not that difficult; it only looks so "supernatural", but its skill and physics. Dont judge so fast. And the hate comments are really hard to understand.
@wingchuntaiji
13 жыл бұрын
This is a very good exhibition of natural attributes developed through basic Yang Taiji training!
@JazzRastaf
13 жыл бұрын
To those with an open mind: In his seminars, master Chu often pushes rows of about 20 people. Those in the middle or on the end of the row do not see him and have no clue what he's doing. But when he sends the chi, the last ones in the row fly away. Those in the middle often do not move. I this was hypnotizing or suggestion, they would have to see when the action is done. Anyway, believe it or not, his power ist just amazing :))) And being pushed that way feels very special, very nice!
@huzhuiwei
14 жыл бұрын
Chu has real ability - it is sad to see him wasting his skills doing circus tricks.
@JazzRastaf
15 жыл бұрын
Calomnies et mensonges. Même si c'était vrai, d'ou vient alors sa puissance? J'en ai personellement fait l'expérience maintes fois. S'il n'a pas été disciple de Yang Shou Chung, alors il a du génie hors du commun. Lies and slander! Even if it was true, where does his incredible chi-power come from? I experienced it a lot of times myself. If he is not the disciple de Yang Shou Chung, then he truly is a genius!
@daveygrokit
14 жыл бұрын
if you are not physically fit, then you will not have enough presence to sense the action at a distance. It is tied to ability not fakery. The same people also would have no chance moving a tai chi master. Try dribbling a basketball with low air pressure. It is difficult to grasp and I appreciate your efforts to understand, but this is one of those things that must be attained by perseverance in practice. As a result of their years of training, these men 'are' most unusual humans. Regards
@geromino2007
13 жыл бұрын
I was in one the master Chu's seminars. He did this yi/chi sending multiple times. usually i was in middle of the row. If i had choose not to move, i would have not moved. Those demonstrations back then were not THAT strong. But the chi can be felt easily. And i descripe him as small nuclear reactor :) But when he demosntrated some the from movement I fly backwards with stupid expression in my face. Whoah, that was something..
@CT2507
2 жыл бұрын
"If i had choose not to move, i would have not moved" that kinda says it all. what we see in the video are idiots under the influence of mindwash. they WANT to react to his push to belong to a special group. bunch of idiots.
@daveygrokit
14 жыл бұрын
Well it's absolutely amazing how misunderstanding can produce such aggressive disrespect. The mere idea that these honorable practioners would sell their years of dedication to an art form like Tai Chi, to become charlatan fakers for the sake of fattening their wallet is undisputably 'SILLY'. The manipulations of living bodies by these advanced artists does look most strange, but anyone who spends their time running down these great souls will most likely never achieve such marvelous movement
@joshpickles9022
11 ай бұрын
Go ask what Chu charges to be a teacher for an area. You might see a different side to him. It's a busy for white people who think that tai chi some how makes you a saint.
@geromino2007
12 жыл бұрын
have any of Chu's students achieved yet high level? From the fruits one knows the tree...
@joshpickles9022
8 жыл бұрын
Why did you cut off the part at the end where somebody took the microphone and said these kinds of demonstrations are a disservice to chinese martial arts? Real or not it just makes people think tai chi is esoteric and mysterious. It isn't. Tai Ji being a martial art that relies on internal movement it's easy to bullshit people with. Look at Chen Xiaowang or Fu Qing Quan for clear examples of genuine masters. You'll notice there is never this kind of demonstration. This is just pure ego and it's sad that people get suckered in by this.
@hsiaoming1874
5 жыл бұрын
Not only he said this is shame but first stop their demo, and they obey !
@jnanamarg
9 жыл бұрын
When humble is the master, there is possibility of tai ji for disciples
@chiki283
14 жыл бұрын
He was teaching tai chi in London in the 1970s long before Yang died. Erle Montaigue was one of his first students but then I suppose you'll say he's a fraud. Why don't you pop down to Wales and try him out? Post the results on youtube will you?
@acquachescorre
15 жыл бұрын
I asked once Master Chu through his italian reference to take part in one of his demo, being completely still waiting to be pushed from a distance. According to him, I was not suitable for the most incredible reasons. If you are not one of his conditioned students, you won't ever have the chance to test him. Fake. Stealing.
@acquachescorre
14 жыл бұрын
Ripeto, è impossibile "raggiungerlo" se non appartieni già alla cerchia degli allievi inconsapevolmente accondiscendenti. Le scuse che il suo entourage adduce sono fantastiche, da crepare dalle risa. Una volta, incautamente, ha incrociato fisicamente le mani con un praticante inglese ed è finito più volte contro il muro e addirittura a terra. Alla faccia dell'energia a distanza, chissà dove era andata a finire in quel momento. Il pavimento inoltre era scivoloso, ovviamente :-)
@acquachescorre
14 жыл бұрын
@geronimo 2007: As i said before, it is impossible to "reach" him if you don't already belong to the circle of his unknowingly condescending students . The excuses put forward by his entourage are fantastic, to die from laughter. Once, uncautiously, he physically crossed hands with a English practitioner. He ended up against the wall several times and even to the ground. So much energy at a distance, who knows where it ended up in that occasion. The floor was slippery, of course :-)
@JazzRastaf
12 жыл бұрын
Don't believe the envious rants in these commentaries. Chu King Hung is possibly the only master today able to demonstrate chi as we heard about in the old stories about the Yang family. Dan Docherty's claims to have defeated him are untrue. Read his other articles to see his mindset. Back pain from ITCCA Tai Chi? Never heard of it in 20 years of practice. My personal experience is that this master's chi amazing. This is the Tai Chi I want to learn!
@youfafao
15 жыл бұрын
free fight= sport tai chi chuan = traditionnal art for health
@geromino2007
12 жыл бұрын
The people i have talked to all respect master Chu as skilled internal martial artist. After meeting him i also say he has lots of chi! I have although severe doubts that his ITCCA training will make one like him and it's not bringing out the martial qualities yang family was famous for. Of curse, i am happy to be wrong, but i need to seed high level student of ITCCA to confirm this.
@geromino2007
12 жыл бұрын
Of course in beginning of the training one should use very little force so the student can learn to relax, but later one needs to add more power, because otherwise it's never gonna work in martial way. I never saw this done in ITCCA. Also another thing that was missing was the whole concept of listening energy, which is vital point in tai chi training.
If he only learned for 4 months in 1985 why was he teaching classes in the 1970s in London. Many tai chi instructors on youtube were taught by him. Erle Montaigue for one. Or is he a fake as well. Pop down to Wales and try him out. Be sure to tell us all about it eh?
@geromino2007
12 жыл бұрын
My personal theory of why ITTCA teaches to keep the elbows so high is that I believe Chu started learning tai chi elbows low, but have risen them to draw out more power and open the joints. Might work, i don't know. I seriously doubt that people should not start to learn the Tai Chi that way, because it makes almost impossible to really relax shoulders..and elbows for that matter.
@chiki283
14 жыл бұрын
@Ghostfuture common consesus got us magrat thatcther, tony blair and gorrdon brroooon. Erle Montaigue is not a fraud even if your common consensus whatever that means says that he is. If you have proof that Erle Montaigue is a fraud show it, demonstrate it. Sorry, you're a big muscle fan aren't you? Didn't mean to offend ...
@MrOphachew
13 жыл бұрын
Dan Doherty of WuTang Tai Chi claimed he and his students easily defeated this guy and his students when they came to his school and challenged him. check out the article by typing in "Dan Doherty Tai Chi gladiator part 2" here on-line.
@amakrid
12 жыл бұрын
@JazzRastaf When 20 people are ready to fall because "being pushed that way feels very special and very nice", then the last on in the row flies away since there is noone to back him up - and then the man before him.
@daveygrokit
15 жыл бұрын
Most great practitioners of an internal style like Tai Chi, have no interest in exposing themselves to a physical contest in order to prop up their egos. Tai Chi empowers the self, while it balances out the ego. The masters would go have tea, instead of engaging in a contest of besting. Peace
@joshpickles9022
11 ай бұрын
Yer but the danger is that you don't know anything about tai chi as a beginner. So you might waste an awful lot of time with someone who is actually not that good because they never openly allow their skills to be tested. They all say exactly what you did which is that we aren't interested in fighting. You don't have to be but you do need to be able to demonstrate the nartail elements of tai chi if you're going to call it a martial art. Which Chu does call it quite frequently but hasn't stepped in to a ring ever.
@geromino2007
12 жыл бұрын
in ITTCA training the elbows are so up that it's easy to lock ones shoulders. When this happens energy is stuck in upper torso, and one is very easily pushed over. There is benefit in opening the joints, but if it's done too much it's impossibl to move fast thus martial side of Tai Chi is not working.
@JazzRastaf
12 жыл бұрын
@MrOphachew Problem is: the students of master Chu who were witnesses tell a very different story about the event. Some fights between the students were won by Docherty's students, Dan Docherty was pushed by M. Chu, lept back to hide it. Second time M. Chu followed and D. Docherty claimed he lost because he stepped forward. More: D. Docherty was hit on the side of the neck and tried to hide this by raising his collar. Read the articles by DD and you will see his mindset.
@joshpickles9022
11 ай бұрын
Then Chu weirdly left all his schools and students in the UK behind for Germany. Funny coincidence huh?
@geromino2007
14 жыл бұрын
@acquachescorre I don't know if it can be done trough distance. I've heard you need to bodily contact for energy to pass one person to next. Energy is real. Students learn to feel it in order to correct the posture. I have not have the honour to meet this master to see if it could be THAT strong to trhrow people around..let's see.
@jsmith4447
11 жыл бұрын
The only people who know what happened between Chu and Dan Docherty where in the room when it happened. Rather than base judgement on stories isn't it better to go and find out for yourself? Because without meaning to start a pissing contest I heard an entirely different version of events from people where present when the challenge took place. As with all arguments the truth lies somewhere in the middle :-)
@geromino2007
12 жыл бұрын
i think the in ITCCA training one gets away with locked shoulders, since al the test are done (at least in my class) downwards towards the center. This in a way forces shoulders down. And shoulders being locked is not discovered.More realistic test is to push horizontal or a bit upwards, then it's easy to see if one locks the shoulders or is able to relax them.
@wingchuntaiji
14 жыл бұрын
You can only say that you don't know enough of what he did! The demo was not too successful because there were simply too many students who don't commit to the push at both ends. The guy was just trying to show the attributes that he developed through his training.
@yourdrchan
15 жыл бұрын
Many demos are done for theatrical effect, and have little value in the truth. Example: sleeping on a thousand-nail bed may seem impressive, but the master would not sleep on a one-nail bed. Just physics (pressure and surface area), not qi. Another example: breaking concrete slabs with a sledge hammer over the masters body/head. If the master is for real, just use the hammer over his head, no concrete slabs to absorb the force. These tricks can even be done with a 7 year old.
@JazzRastaf
12 жыл бұрын
@seessari1 I won't change your opinion, but you're the blind one. I witnessed his chi many times first hand, flying several meters away and he barely moved! This can't get more real. Here is an oppurtunity to learn the real stuff. I'm not the one who'll miss it.
@JazzRastaf
12 жыл бұрын
@geromino2007 in ITCCA most of the tests are not done downward, I don't know where you learned this. If you have stiff muscles your shoulders may be locked, but there are lots of exercises to loosen them.
@chiki283
14 жыл бұрын
why's he doing it in Hong Kong then. Won't the real tai chi men come and have a go at him for tarnishing the memory of Yang Sau Chung? He didn't do push hands with Dan Docherty, read Docherty's article again.
@FoxGhost7
14 жыл бұрын
Hmmm, do you guys know any people from Mr. Chu's school which you could call competent? You know, there are really fantastic people from a martial arts standpoint. Even if Master Chu was teaching something of his own creation this would be an incredible art. Believeable from a distance? Hell no.
@AudioFreqx
14 жыл бұрын
@pitviper328 you just are not seeing what this demonstration is about or you are a troll after seeing you try to 'prove to the world' how bright you are by posting so many times. If you were really bright AND not a troll, most would think you could do that in single post.
@JazzRastaf
13 жыл бұрын
@MrOphachew You people think all you find on the internet is true. Students of master Chu who were witness of the event tell a completely different story.
@Nessunego
11 жыл бұрын
The dao that can be named is not the eternal Dao
@JohnMartin-jx1wz
5 жыл бұрын
The root of the word spirit is spiritus. The Chinese call it chi, the Hindus prana. Spiritus is literally breath but not the breath of the lungs.
@realkungfu-gr
14 жыл бұрын
Well, it seems they have a problem when cutting pasta!
@ATMfromNJ
15 жыл бұрын
got a little cult like following going there. happens a lot in these more esoteric studies...
@MrOphachew
12 жыл бұрын
Dan's article is interesting. check it out.
@MrOphachew
13 жыл бұрын
@JazzRastaf --I'm just tellin yeah what he said. You can check it out fo yoself.
@JazzRastaf
14 жыл бұрын
@hodmeist That's because Dan Docherty lied.
@vuth1968
13 жыл бұрын
looks like 29 people hit the dislike button
@sskfrey
16 жыл бұрын
What are these so called "CHI DEMONSTATIONS" good for? If the are goog for fighting, why are his students not showing up at MMA events. Even if it works, for it to work u have to make contact. And if u make contact w/ someone skill at BJJ u ll find yourself on the flour. Anyway Tai Chi has no ground fighting technicks. Has Chu ever won any fullcontact contest or any pushhand contests? What about his students?
@AudioFreqx
14 жыл бұрын
@pitviper328 . are you one of those people which thinks that real power comes from PX90 or something?
@MrOphachew
12 жыл бұрын
@JazzRastaf - I didn't say I believed him; I just said, that's what he said.
@cyzam
3 жыл бұрын
Asked about his reputation from yang family. Man this guy is hated 😅😅😅
@GojuBob
13 жыл бұрын
Why do people fall for this? A large part of it is wishful thinking/self-deception. The students need to believe that the master is what they want him to be. That's how "cults" happen: the coming together of suggestible personalities who act out a common fantasy together.
@sskfrey
16 жыл бұрын
BIG MINUS: all the people being pushed look like his students. Com'on I can do this w/ my brother! Push someone from another school or try to push a sumo!
@AudioFreqx
14 жыл бұрын
@pitviper328 It would be rather entertaining to see you 'pretend not to fall down'.
@wingchuntaiji
14 жыл бұрын
@pitviper328 You do sound like a lay person that you don't see how he released.
@chiki283
14 жыл бұрын
First of all I believed that Chu did push them over but reading the comments here I realise I was wrong. If you look closely you can see that it's the bloke at the front stopping everyone from pushing and then he pushes them all backwards when he's told to do so. Must be some guy eh? Thanks for pointing me away from ignorance, we must let the audience know they were all fooled and get this sort of thing stopped.
@SergeiBocharov
13 жыл бұрын
Yes Dan Docherty is a liar many people know
@Jazzadrin
2 жыл бұрын
Doesn't seem real
@huzhuiwei
14 жыл бұрын
Chu has real ability - it is sad to see him wasting his skills doing circus tricks. What a waste.
@catbiscuit2345
11 жыл бұрын
This reminds me of the Keystones Cops. If any of you people believe this you shouldnt be allowed out on the streets
this is totally faked. look at 4:27, all the people (especially the 2nd one) left their right (back support) leg to make themselves fall backward.
@araynier
12 жыл бұрын
Mon dieu quel cinéma voilà pourquoi le tai chi est dévalué avec des guignols pareils qui vénèrent un être très malin qui fait leur miroiter le nirvana moyennant finance. Pitoyable.
@baltoxerror
9 жыл бұрын
chu is not so humble ^^
@jnanamarg
8 жыл бұрын
this is why, I see no master here and therefore no disciple...
@acquachescorre
14 жыл бұрын
@daveygrokit bullshit: in this case they sholuldn't either expose themselves to this kind of demo. That's what props up their ego and their wallet too. Master Chu should better have tea, instead of engaging in a demo of fake stuff
Пікірлер: 93