+Engineering Explained I love these dual videos with you both. very informative
@mojojoji5493
8 жыл бұрын
Thanks for existing
@repeatrepeatrepeat
8 жыл бұрын
great guys!
@mikehawk4517
8 жыл бұрын
+Engineering Explained Now kiss
@sharpjm85
6 жыл бұрын
As an engineer, my best tool is the technician I work with. And I'm not saying that in any derogatory, "you're just a tool" kind of way. I mean it in the most humble, "I value your input" type of way. I have turned wrenches and I have learned to use new tools. In my first year as an engineer, I got to try the jackhammer, acetylene torch, and sandblaster, among others. Usually I try these things for no other reason than to demonstrate my dedication, interest, and curiosity to the technicians I work with. Doing so helps me to determine a couple of things: 1) how proficient is the technician, 2) can the technician teach others to do mundane jobs, and 3) is this task more of an 'art' or more of a 'labor'? Over time, you can develop a great relationship with coworkers that builds mutual respect and allows for simple and efficient communication of problems. You get less of the "the technician assembled it wrong" and "the engineer designed it wrong" type of finger-pointing scenarios. There do exist bad technicians. There do exist bad engineers. But when good meets good, careers can be accelerated and innovation can really happen.
@MrSuperX5
6 жыл бұрын
Having actual engineers and mechanics talk about how they initially did not know how to do anything on their first day has really boosted my confidence about choosing engineering. Thanks guys.
@johnbenson4927
5 жыл бұрын
Likewise my friend!! I´m also an engineer (mechanical).
@mccabe8818
3 жыл бұрын
High school here, it does help
@cloroxlysolbleachwhipes8658
3 жыл бұрын
@@johnbenson4927 going into college this year I Plan to study mechanical (automotive ) engineering but not really sure exactly what i want to do within automotive field if it makes any sense, any advice?
@johnbenson4927
3 жыл бұрын
@@cloroxlysolbleachwhipes8658 Yeah sure bro. My advice is go for a broad field of engineering, like Mechanical engineering. If you enter a very specific branch (like automotive) you'll end up forced to find jobs that revolve around that specific engineering branch and you will struggle looking for other options. The broader the field, the better. That's why Mechanical is one of the best choices you can make 😎
@jojoessuman4730
3 жыл бұрын
@@cloroxlysolbleachwhipes8658 see John's advice below.....I concur..... don't pigeonhole yourself so early
@PoeRacing
7 жыл бұрын
Jason, how did you skip the classic Mechanical vs. Civil engineer joke??? Mechanical engineers design cool things like fighter jets and missiles. Civil engineers design targets!
@TBoy205
5 жыл бұрын
Honey Badger Offroad Or the things that support your cool things like runways and anti aircraft sites
@SourStrawberrys
5 жыл бұрын
@@TBoy205 I rather design a jet than a darn runway.
@alileevil
4 жыл бұрын
SourStrawberrys without a runway you don't have a way to move your plane. Both are very challenging
@dstblj5222
3 жыл бұрын
@@alileevil sure you do, jump jets are cool
@TahirRaj-ix1uf
2 жыл бұрын
@@alileevil then i would design a jet that don't requires a runway!
@lordchickenhawk
8 жыл бұрын
Funnily enough, old mechanics and old engineers seem to tend to migrate toward each other's fields. Old mechanics get a better grasp on theory and old engineers experience application "in the wild" so as to speak. These young fellas seem to have an early insight to each other's perspectives.
@lordchickenhawk
3 жыл бұрын
@Thomas Brennan Yeah... I miss being able to do simple repairs on my own stuff...
@Alex-mp4kl
8 жыл бұрын
My education was in Computer Science. It was the same problem. A few years of programming projects. All summed up senior year with make this more complicated problem. But even then we didn't have a finished product project ever. So you leave with your degree with no concept on how a piece of software goes from start to finish. There are SO many things you don't know, that the real world does all the time. How are the files organised? How will we be accessing and storing data? What will the finished product look like? None of those things are touched in school. It's about history of programming and architecture.
@TrevarLadd
8 жыл бұрын
Alex Ferraro yea same here. I'm a senior Computer Science (BS) and basically it has all been basic optimization and architecture and a ton of math both CS based and general. I'm only now in a software design class applying some things a lot more. I feel going into the workforce next year is going to be really crazy
@chillingmeko
7 жыл бұрын
Welcome to the club. XD I'm CS and EE. It's going to be a wild ride when applying for jobs since I have experienced the same issues you both have.
@MrFE-wp6bf
5 жыл бұрын
A comparison video of computer science and engineering would be a better video. At least both are within the STEM world, but they are very different at the same time.
@blammers
8 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much for making this video. I'm a sophomore engineering student and among these endless math and physics classes, it's easy to get lost and lose sight of what I'm working for. Hearing you both talk about your work is motivating.
@ODIOPOWER
8 жыл бұрын
I hope this collaboration between you (EE) and Humble can become a series, maybe on both channel ;)
@HumbleMechanic
8 жыл бұрын
We have done a handful of videos together. Maybe Jason and I can create a cool playlist or something to put them all in one space. Thanks for the support, it's much appreciated
@hugosanchez7592
8 жыл бұрын
+HumbleMechanic where do you go to college? what are basics tools to have?
@hugosanchez7592
8 жыл бұрын
+Hugo Sanchez good video
@repoman54r35
8 жыл бұрын
Thanks so much for making this video guys. After attending tech school I worked as an auto mechanic for several years. What I found out was that I really loved the diagnoses and problem solving portion of the job. I always wanted to do things the right way while everyone else was just cutting corners. The guys who cut corners were looked highly upon by management because they sent cars out faster than I did, even though a lot of there cars would come back. When I repaired a car I really solved the problem. Now I'm going to school for engineering with the hope that I can actually use my problem solving abilities as opposed to just doing mindless part swapping (what my management wanted).
@ddoyle11
8 жыл бұрын
After being a mechanic for over 20 years, my take is simply this; all engineers must spend their first year in the field working with technicians on maintenance and trouble shooting. This will lay the ground work for an intelligent and maintenance friendly machine.
@asaikaly2
8 жыл бұрын
when someone asks me what I am going to be as a mechanical engineer, I tell them I have no idea because it's such a broad field to the point that I can end up designing the paper towel dispenser for the restroom.
@imaskater3297
8 жыл бұрын
+asaikaly2 That's exactly my situation, I know I want to be an engineer but I can't give an answer to WHERE I want to work or WHAT I want to be doing. My main goal though is to be able to work with my hands like Jason did as a Test Engineer or at least with CAD.
@xxslayaxx8584
3 жыл бұрын
Finally i find people who explain what a mechanicle egineer is i need to start to plan what job i want to have because i am about to go into high school and soon collage.
@jl2705
8 жыл бұрын
Just subscribed to @humblemechanic after seeing this. Owner of a '13 MK6 GTI with a K04 setup! Also an engineer with a dad who started as a union machinist who later went to Purdue to become a mech. engineer. Both avenues of vocation are great!
@Don-fu2ib
8 жыл бұрын
I'm majoring in Mechanical Engineering in China, these videos makes me optimistic. I like this
@HutchCoRacing
8 жыл бұрын
What I've learned from my time being a Mechanical Engineer, at least in the field I found myself for 9 months, was that the engineering was pretty much non existent. It was basically all about looks and what the customer would "feel" is sufficient. I mean to me, engineering is pushing the limits, and cutting costs but still reaching the performance that is required. I used to design transition bases for electric motors, custom junction boxes, redesign motors for different HP, but we ALWAYS over engineered. The business didn't care about using less material (to a certain extent) when it came to a base. I tried showing with solidworks FEA that we could reduce the thickness up to 1 - 1-1/2 on certain ones and still get the same performance, but it was, oh the customer won't approve that cause it didn't "look" robust enough (no one believed it due to their "Experience"). Same with the redesigns, it's all laid out for you, there's almost no effort. You take the amount of turns in the winding and slots in the rotor, do a simple equation, and your answer tells you if it's possible or not. Really interesting field, just a lot simpler than "Theory" or school makes it seem while an undergrad.
@TheRonin508
8 жыл бұрын
Performance engine builders, Engine tuners, Race car builders etc, regularly disregard automotive engineering and construct some amazing things. Some things defy textbook knowledge and are only learned from experience. An engineer can tell you what SHOULD work. Sometimes pretty accurately. A sharp, hands on guy will tell you what ACTUALLY works. And can tell you exactly why.
@techobsessed1
4 жыл бұрын
No.
@OverlyCuriousEngineer
8 жыл бұрын
The biggest difference between being a mechanic and an engineer is the stress level and the fact that engineering is way more demanding. I mean i'm a mechanical engineering student and we have about 56 courses to study over a period of 4 years. And then suddenly you're thrown into the industry and you have to design/analyze/optimize stuff and those are things you've only studied the theory of, and now you have to do something that you aren't certain how to do. And then there's the stupid deadlines that literally kill you. Tons of sleepless nights, coffee and headaches along the way. A mechanic at least knows a set of procedures to follow and really, the only tough part of being a mechanic is the physical labor and the challenge of diagnosing stuff, which with newer technology is much easier than it ever was. Not belittling mechanics but engineers and mechanics are leagues apart when it comes to the effort that they've put into getting where they are.
@SirMugdi
8 жыл бұрын
I got you :(
@OverlyCuriousEngineer
8 жыл бұрын
+Sir Mugdi :(
@DrJosh-zp8xe
8 жыл бұрын
+Godzilla555 ...and thats where the huge difference in pay comes from
@DrJosh-zp8xe
8 жыл бұрын
yea but its a hell of a lot easier to make money as a beginning engineer vs a beginning mechanic. you have to remember where the comparison is..
@OverlyCuriousEngineer
8 жыл бұрын
So eventually, we're back to where we started. There isn't really any comparison between a mechanic and an engineer. They belong completely different class of professions.
@salsamancer
6 жыл бұрын
I studied ME for years, got a BS and an MS and worked for three years in a manufacturing line machine company. I hated it. All the passion I had for math and science proved useless, I was expected to jocky a desk for 9 hours a day and wasted most of those on BS. I felt like I had just signed away the next 40 years to my life to meaningless drudgery and existential terror. My advice to aspiring ME students: do a lot of interships. Don't get blindsided into a corporate nightmare the year after you graduate.
@SourStrawberrys
5 жыл бұрын
You can also apply for other jobs while you're working their. You do not have to stay as it is not your only options. But I can understand what you're saying. Some "engineering" jobs like quality engineering doesn't really require and engineering degree. So you will end up doing things that you find boring because it doesnt really directly relate to what you've been studying for as a ME. It is general work that people from different educational background can do. You're not really using all your learned so you end up being bored with your work. I noticed that in my internship.
@DandoyJames
6 жыл бұрын
I really appreciate that both of you mechanic and mechanical engineer try to make videos about the difference between your jobs or works. Greatly I watch this video that make me happy. Beside from the advantage and the disadvantage it reveal the truth from the reality on how it feel, how hard being a mechanical than mechanic
@TioDuw
8 жыл бұрын
great video!! I swear it sounds like my life...I am a 2-year automotive graduated engineer and I also had the exact same scenarios which you, Jason, described. I went from being called as "intern" to "specialist engineer" within 3 months after the beginning of my internship and the feeling of being called like that in front of the customer is very freightening...I actually laughed hard when you said: "I did this one time!". Again, nice work!
@NorthOCkook
7 жыл бұрын
Civil engineering consists of not only structural engineering but also geotechnical, environmental, hydraulics, traffic, etc. and structural engineers study structural dynamics in order to design buildings, bridges, etc. to withstand the ground movement/accelerations caused by earthquakes
@abrahamnoriega3344
3 жыл бұрын
Guys, I just love the way you make it look so simple regarding the difference in both areas, but more important is that you both realize how much both areas rely on each other, the just graduated is supported by the technical expert and technical expert learn some methodology as well! Cool humble video, congrats!
@heartattakjoe7152
7 жыл бұрын
great video. i was planning to become a mechanical engineer but life took me down a different path. now i wish i was a mechanic it is possibly the most useful trade there is
@nolanmann3730
7 жыл бұрын
Everyone... The engineer designs/innovates a new cylinder head using 3D modeling and a deep understanding of how heat transfer, hot spots, air/fluid flow, and material cross-sectional properties effect the combustion efficiency, pre-detonation, flow capability, and longevity of the cylinder head. The mechanic bolts the cylinder head on... An engineer is a designer, a mechanic is a laborer... Any GOOD engineer can do the mechanics job, but a mechanic can NOT do an engineer's job!!
@markflierl1624
5 жыл бұрын
You sound pretty arrogant. I'm a mechanical engineer. I've met a lot of engineers who can't do the work of a mechanic!
@ApethGrader
5 жыл бұрын
Agree with Mark. Not likely an engineer can troubleshoot a system failure. Mechanics aren't just parts changers.
@scamfather2663
5 жыл бұрын
Nolan Mann why u tryna make it a vs. competition....
@Unb3arablePain
8 жыл бұрын
Here at UNCC you're taught skills of both. Our Mechanical engineers work in machine shops, drilling, milling, lathing, etc. The Motorsports guys also build and repair go karts and even rebuild full engines. I know of at least one senior who rebuilt an AMG V12. IMO, I think it's best to become an engineer first. You can learn the theory and how everything works, then work in practice.
@Davidjune1970
8 жыл бұрын
I have been a design engineer for over 20 years. The knowledge you learn in school is almost completely irrelevant as the theory does not usually have a practical application. I do not design automotive parts, my career has been completely designing hydrocarbon plant or power plants. To design those you learn about the different codes and standards related to those facilities .... university does not teach you anything about the codes and standards followed by working engineers. Engineering is the toughest undergrad degree you can enroll in. The math and other subjects they teach you will make most other students wince. Starting wage for me 20 years ago was $32,000/yr. Today new grad students are hired at $60,000 to $70,000/ year depending on how good they are at negotiating. It took me 7 years of working before my salary exceeded $60,000/year but that was just the way the market was. My salary has since gone above $170,000/year. Consulting is a tough and thankless job though.
@jamesvillano5202
8 жыл бұрын
+Davidjune1970 Starting wage in 1996 is irrelevant to today, just as my starting wage as an engineer in 1969 of $7,200 does not compare to today. In 1969 a new Corvette was $6,000 and not $60,000. Today the price of a new Chevy Tahoe would buy a nice three bedroom house in 1969. My 1969 Corvette's 14 mpg was acceptable when 100 octane was $0.28 per gallon.
@Davidjune1970
8 жыл бұрын
+James Villano you totally miss the point. I was sharing what the wage is for the job today which is what they were discussing. If I were to compare that starting salary to average salaries ... Back when I started the wage was average, for today's starting wage it is 1.7 times average. So the pay has improved significantly .... and it pays significantly above other average income earners.
@jamesvillano5202
8 жыл бұрын
OK, define "average". Average for a college grad, 2 year degreed technician, construction worker? We comparing ME to EE or?? Salaries vary by locale and industry (what is left of industry).
@chiefjohnson8344
8 жыл бұрын
videos like these would make an excellent podcast to listen too on my daily commutes to college. I really like watching these videos, thanks.
@brycemoon2712
8 жыл бұрын
So glad to finally here some real world examples of what you can possibly do because I have always wanted to be a mechanical engineer and am going into college now to finally become one so i just wanted to say thanks so much for all of the different automotive videos you have made over the years because I really enjoy watch all of them and provides so many answers to all of the questions I've gathered over the years!
@HasanKhater
3 жыл бұрын
I love being an engineer, fix problems, find solutions to problems others can’t solve, it’s always thrilling!
@carson0425
8 жыл бұрын
you and the humble mechanic should get together and do a project or something together... i currently am getting my Associates (2year) in automotive... i love both of you guys videos. And i have always thought technicians and engineers should work more along side one another. They compliment one another well.
@loganpe427
4 жыл бұрын
Well guys, I'm both, master mechanic & applied engineer. The engineering part is mostly self taught & experience, the mechanic part paid most of the bills. I'm retired now at 59 but it's because I'm physically beat up. I absolutely "hated" flat rate. Auto shops always try to make more by paying the tech less. Plus every minute you're not turning a wrench you're not getting paid & bosses try to get you to do all kinds of stuff between tickets. My last job was as a maintenance technician in an industrial molding plant plus I had the forklift fleet. Great job, great pay & benefits. Go with a large company and steady salary!
@darcylafleur3177
8 жыл бұрын
Being both a Mechanical Engineer and a current Heavy Duty Mechanic Apprentice This video is quite accurate!
@terryc6420
7 жыл бұрын
I'm in the software engineering field (yes, I realize that sw engineering isn't "real" engineering), and it's fascinating to hear all the pros and cons in the mechanical engineering field are almost identical. I really enjoy watching this video.
@aaronpops4108
8 жыл бұрын
In Canada you need 8 months of technical school spread over 4 years, as well as about 2000 hours job experience before you get certified.
@franksalazar4576
8 жыл бұрын
Since I'm an engineer I have a biased coming into this video
@lordchickenhawk
8 жыл бұрын
Since I'm a techy I completely grok that...
@jackrichter6400
8 жыл бұрын
As a engineer and a diesel fitter i make a good living .I have my machine shop at home and can give my customers good service. You have to find the right market for your skills and you be set for live.
@AuMechanic
7 жыл бұрын
The main difference between Mechanic and Engineers is that Engineers work at the peak of a field of expertise, Whereas Mechanics require a less complex but sound enough comprehension of many fields of expertise, including Mechanical, Electrical, Electronics and basic Physics and Chemistry in addition to skills for survival in a hazardous workplace. Engineers are taught to adhere to scientific laws and standards and materials specifications like an Accountant of all things material, and risk averse, Engineers also struggle with the terms "Affordable" and "Timely manner" when it comes to getting the job done, a 3 year project is better than a 3 month project. Some engineers will also attempt to reinvent the wheel when a perfectly good design already exists off the shelf. After 40 years of Mechanics I took up manufacturing things for the last 12 years that Engineers first said couldn't be built but after I built it and showed them the engineering sums used in the design they approved the calculations just like my Tax accountant does with my books.. That's is when I finally discovered what Engineers really do. Engineers don't agree with each other which is why if you have an engineer that says you cant do something you may find another engineer that says you can because he knows some unknown knowns the previous engineer didn't know or think to ask.
@evilplaguedoctor5158
8 жыл бұрын
my dad's a Mechanic, I'm an Electronic engineer (student) I found being raised by a mechanic helped a lot.
@ChrisCapoccia
8 жыл бұрын
some of the undergrad engineering experience is that the universities are focused on trying to prepare people towards grad students and research opportunities as a revenue stream for the school.
@Herbertin1
8 жыл бұрын
Charles was my teacher in vw. he was a great teacher I learned a lot and he went to the same school I did. NASCAR tech
@eagle94haslanded
7 жыл бұрын
Any kid who has never used a tool by the time they get to senior year of college has no business becoming an engineer.
@bandnerdo2000
7 жыл бұрын
Joe Blow I mean he went to NC State and they have a nationally recognized engineering program. I do agree learning about tools before senior year is important though
@ichbinzirkel
7 жыл бұрын
Joe Blow Don't you have mandatory internships where you use tools in the US?
@eagle94haslanded
7 жыл бұрын
You cant turn a bolt with math.
@eagle94haslanded
7 жыл бұрын
You cant solder with math either.
@miyabe_k195
7 жыл бұрын
Joe Blow so true... Having done sth practicly before doing the theory is so much better
@chrismcilravy30
7 жыл бұрын
everything can be sold , its what can be sold easier is what gets sold , and as far as customers buying that , they can only buy what options have been presented
@sranjesuper
8 жыл бұрын
I live in Canada, worked 8 years as a mechanic and my box has about $20,000 worth of tools inside, and I am STILL buying more tools once in a while
@tylermcginnis9277
8 жыл бұрын
I went to college for engineering, and decided last minute that I didn't want to do math problems for the rest of my life. I now own 3 automotive shops in Dallas, and love what I do. Unfortunately, automotive technicians rarely get the respect they deserve. I have technicians that make 70k-80k a year. It truly is an art form that has been cheapened by imitators with a cheap scan tool and no understanding of how the systems they are supposed to maintain, work. As a technician, you never stop learning new things. That being said, I have nothing but respect and admiration for the engineers that design the tech that goes in to modern autos.
@nunya7888
8 жыл бұрын
+Tyler McGinnis doubt it... Decided last minute? hahaha in other words you couldn't get past calc I...
@tylermcginnis9277
8 жыл бұрын
+Nun Ya No man, switched the end of my Junior year. Believe it or not, you can change your major for reasons other than "it's too hard"
@worldofai-games1036
8 жыл бұрын
+Tyler McGinnis You can change at anytime. At most, you'll probably have to take extra classes and get extra units to make up for all the deficiencies. I know some California schools (like the UCs) kick students out after 4 years to make space for new students..
@h.mushmann2351
8 жыл бұрын
This conversation was a good perspective to get a glimpse of what goes on behind the making and maintaining of things and the challenges faced to do the jobs in question. Thanks! I've been pretty harsh before on technicians and on the design of products I've purchased in the past. I hope I can be more understanding when my expectations aren't met, since people have worked hard behind the scenes to make it all happen.
@bret9492
7 жыл бұрын
I'd love to see this conversation from an aviation and aerospace perspective
@MaxSpd1998
8 жыл бұрын
After reading the comments and watching the video glad you two actually respected each other lmao. Great video!!!
@theGoldenDiaper
3 жыл бұрын
Interesting point you had on engineers working efficiently. Sometimes the greatest and most efficient creations are not received well by the masses, for example CVT transmissions are incredibly efficient and give a vehicle the highest possible acceleration to date; but people don't like it. It's as though there is efficiency and consumer opinion/ enjoyment at opposite ends of a sea-saw. Best of luck to you, balancing that sea-saw.
@toobeetoobeetoo
8 жыл бұрын
This is probably the coolest video I have seen in a while. While I am a Computer Systems Engineer well into my career, it is completely awesome hearing such clear and well thought out statements of the compares and contrasts of 2 similar type careers. I already sub to Engineering Explained but I am totally checking out Humble Mechanics channel too.
@AlehandroDebono
8 жыл бұрын
technicians, believe or not, are in a better position for initiating new ideas then fellow engineers. the reason behind this is that technicians will work on many different vehicles in one day and gather a far far broader understanding on how things work from different designs and how to improve. like the video and engineer can work on 1 job for 3+ years...
@BigGeeMan
5 жыл бұрын
I'm an engineer and love being on the tools ripping engines out etc. It's more fun than pissing around with computers and calculators all day. It does pay well though (if you can get through university). The best happy medium would be: a mechanic owning they're own garage; better pay and freedom. Some mechanics get payed terrible money even with big companies shame, as they have good skills and knowledge. It's true about engineering tuition - it's just maths and physics. You have to try to relate to it yourself. Interesting video none the less thanks.
@jeremyj.5687
8 жыл бұрын
Very interesting video, does really give a lot of perspective. By the way, as an automotive engineer (AT, MT, DHT), I can confirm that marketing is the WORST.
@josesousa7452
8 жыл бұрын
As an engineer in formation, this was actually pretty interesting! Goes to show no one is more important than the rest. The mechanic cannot work without the engineer and the engineer without the mechanic :D
@davemartin6452
8 жыл бұрын
Being in the automotive industry almost my whole life this was an interesting perspective video. Thanks.
@jmorenop13
8 жыл бұрын
I am stjdying mechanical student and my personal experience is that I have learned a lot more while working in an internship than at school. specially since at school it is mainly theory and theoretically everything works but in the field that is not how it works. I love the field but I do hope that I would do more hands on stuff at school
@mauricemotors8207
8 жыл бұрын
Im going to school for diesel technology and i think technicians shoulf get more credit its hard snd tough but you can spec youre car out to how you want it :)
@krismichalsky
6 жыл бұрын
Why not be both? I've regularly had to be both sides. Especially when the part or something you are trying to install either doesn't fit right, or something is wrong mechanically wise. So, say you're installing a new intake on car-X. Well, typically there's no instructions for things like this, meaning no one gives you an order of events that should take place. On many aftermarket parts, things don't always fit correctly, so you have to take measurements, remove metal, plastic, etc.... Or maybe a hole has to be tapped for a different sized threaded bolt, or you have to make a new bracket to hold your throttle cable because the old one won't work anymore. To me, if I am having to design a part, especially a part that has to swing, or make any type of arch from one resting point to another is requiring a level of mechanical engineering here. To me, and not to offend anyone here. Mechanical engineering takes much more patience than being a mechanic. That is solely my opinion. Funny thing is I went to college for electrical engineering.
@MrRlik
8 жыл бұрын
I am a Systems Engineer and still a great Mechanic. I think you need to be a bit of both.
@TheRepairSpecialist
7 жыл бұрын
Great explanation. Thanks guys. You have a thumbs up from me.
@KemDIY
8 жыл бұрын
Would be cool to hear from a formula 1 technician who are usually engineers as well. I had a college room mate who was studying jet propulsion (rocket science) and he couldn't work on his own car. Goes to show you know what you learn.
@Cole13517
7 жыл бұрын
I'm studying computer engineering now but, I really love hands on work like technicians and mechanics more than typing on a computer for x amount of hours, the pay really made me choose engineering though
@markitoxi
8 жыл бұрын
Thank you very much Jason, I'm about to graduate in Mech Engineering (Bachelor) this summer, and this video resolved a lot of inner questions now I'm a bit more confident and eager to graduate!
@twn000
8 жыл бұрын
Engineer here. Have developed back and wrist problems from just sitting all day long.
@lukaszrabiniak6307
8 жыл бұрын
That's one good side view on that natter. I work in industrial environment for last 14 years. Through that time did my National Diploma, HNC, HND and now a full Degree. And I can see right from the bottom how point of view changes. Now if we have a new Engineer coming from Uni down to shop floor is like speaking with my 4 years old daughter. Why is it like that and not like that. Why is that making that, why is that movingion that direction and not other, it should move other direction... etc.
@bair24
8 жыл бұрын
Every engineer needs to be a mechanic before they design anything. that would make it a lot more pleasant for all mechanics.
@oldshreddies2080
8 жыл бұрын
I like the idea of techs having input with engineers. It'd be nice to know, do actual end users ever have input with engineers or at least with companies? I ask because as a shipper and forklift operator,it seems like there could be some improvement with input from people who actually use the machine for 8 hrs a day. Excellent episode and thank you for posting it.
@EngineeringExplained
8 жыл бұрын
Yes this absolutely happens. In fact, in my first job I would talk with folks who actually used our forklifts every day for work, and work with them to decide things that would be helpful for specific applications.
@oldshreddies2080
8 жыл бұрын
+Engineering Explained I'm glad to hear that there were interactions like that. The older machines we had were terrible ergonomically. And, I always wondered if companies looked for feedback on their products. Btw, ergonomics are much better on the newer machines.
@brendanleonard1375
4 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much! I'm a high school senior and leaning towards the technician route. Just facing a lot of decision anxiety. I do worry about how electric cars may affect job outlook since they typically require less maintenance. But I cannot look that forward into the future and I will just be adaptable. Thanks for the video!
@75randomdan75
8 жыл бұрын
'Iv been an engineer for 2 years' This explain sooo much about the channel!
@jamiestobbs3945
8 жыл бұрын
I've been a mechanical engineer for about five years now, working with CNC machines but also studying the mathematical, physics and CAD etc type of things too. It's surprising the gap in occupation respect/pay from England where I am and other countries. 60k is a lot! Think I might have to move haha
@daybrown3221
7 жыл бұрын
Between yawl is the machinist, who maybe be trying to fabricate from a blueprint or trying to replicate a defective part. Its the machinist who sees failed parts and often comes up with design improvements, or similarly, spots problems in the blueprints with the materials or fabrication limits in hand. Likewise, the training and pay is medium.
@2007drh
8 жыл бұрын
The difference between engineers and mechanics is this. Engineers are the people that mechanics and car owners swear at when they have to take the front clip off of a car to change a $2 light bulb. On the flip side, I used to work at an International dealership. I used to thank the engineers for my job security.
@InNoTime3377
7 жыл бұрын
I studied bmw level 3 training at uti and then started at the dealer making 15 an hour and stayed making that same pay for over a yr , pretty sad imo , they don't pay techs enough
@patrickblair2818
2 жыл бұрын
I feel like it's a lot of checking things to see if they work...
@thatguy83ful
8 жыл бұрын
poor mechanich works 10x harder for half the pay. that's difference number 1.
@rustynugget2288
8 жыл бұрын
becoming an engineer is difficult and careers that are hard to get into usually reward better
@big_0
8 жыл бұрын
1/3 the money
@markflierl1624
5 жыл бұрын
@@big_0 That's not true! Engineers are NOT well paid. 3/4 the money to the same amount of money. Engineers have high starting pay. The pay doesn't increase much after that! Mechanics get better pay with experience. Engineers usually don't.
@jjy365959
5 жыл бұрын
I want to be an engineer in canada. But i don't know what kind of engineer i want to be.
@grizzlydan8
8 жыл бұрын
Very interesting. I started out as a mechanic, but the investment vs. pay, vs. difficulty level did not seem like a winning proposition. I have now retired from a job I did not like, but paid better than most auto mechanic jobs. I really don't know if I should have stuck with mechanics or not. I have continued doing auto repair as a hobby and on and off as a sideline.
@OwenWalker
8 жыл бұрын
I'm kinda surprised that a mechanic working in a dealership garage would have to buy their own tools...
@adolfshitler8341
7 жыл бұрын
Close to finishing high school, doing very well in my Atar classes predicted for a score of 90, I plan on going straight for an apprenticeship in vehicle mechanics first and then going to university and completing a masters in mechanical and electrical engineering, yes I'm fortunate enough to have parents that will let me stay until I graduate uni. But if I really enjoy the apprenticeship work then I'll most likely stay with that line of work, having a high Atar score though from school I can go into the engineering courses whenever I want without worrying about bridging courses. If all else fails I have a cert 3 in hospitality so I can easily get a retail job.
@MrZooaf
8 жыл бұрын
Thanks very that talk was really useful for me now I have a better vision about what I'm going to be after I finish my degree
@Alorand
7 жыл бұрын
Mechanics have great, powerful, handshakes; from all of the wrenching that they do. I can crack two wallnuts by pressing them against each other, my friend can take one and somehow pinch it open just with his fingers.
@profoundmood
8 жыл бұрын
I think that mechanic and engineer are technically same, they are both of great technician.The problem thing is that we're not treating them fairly.Actually i don't know well another countries, but it's really serious problem here in Korea.I hope to disappear all kinds of job discriminations.
@zimmyflip
8 жыл бұрын
this is cool and all but it doesn't explain why they put a 6inch bolt in a spot you can only pull a 3 inch out of
@int53185
8 жыл бұрын
Jason: there is no need for you to turn a wrench, you can do so with your mind.
@Newbport849
4 жыл бұрын
The difference is is that mechanics are bearable to be around
@danielcogzell6979
8 жыл бұрын
I was EXACTLY the same.. I thought I would end up designing my own car or engine when I finish my degree in Mech Eng.. Sadly one would be lucky to design any 1 single component of a mass produced car.. There are big teams designated to design one component of a car..
@Valkyrie612
7 жыл бұрын
There is no substitute for hands-on; but, without the foundation of theory, your education will be incomplete. I have 4 degrees: Associates, Bachelors, Masters, and PhD. All my degrees are in Psychology. My hands-on experience has been incredibly important and informative; however, without my formal education, I would not have been able to understand or appreciate the knowledge offered by my hands-on experience. Whatever you want to do, first get the foundation of knowledge in your field. Then, find a good internship, and learn how to apply your knowledge. As for how much formal education you need...License requirements notwithstanding, you really only need as much formal education as it takes to gain a strong foundation of knowledge.
@dlobom
8 жыл бұрын
I'm an engineer outside the US with 6 years experience, and the mechanic in the US gets paid more.
@kolideoskope
8 жыл бұрын
Not all mechanics have to buy there own tools, and those that do have a higher base pay to make up for it.
@AshwinKrishnanAK
8 жыл бұрын
Most useful video. Period.
@jeriwolfcr7838
8 жыл бұрын
Can you do Technician vs Technologist vs Engineer?
@enfynet
8 жыл бұрын
I really need to finish my BS degree. Nice video guys.
@onixtheone
6 жыл бұрын
Here’s what the working class customer wants, a VERY reliable, cheap to maintain, as many MPG as possible, good looking, comfort and intuitive, NOT expensive, and maybe even a nice sounding exhaust to impress the wife or the girlfriend..
@rickyde0255
7 жыл бұрын
Another good educational video.
@martinmeredith8964
6 жыл бұрын
Awesome video guys !
@eduard9452
2 жыл бұрын
Wow, to become an engineer practically means creating vehicles from 0, that is genius, of course it is so well paid.
@raffanimam9745
6 жыл бұрын
Hmm any videos on how sir suspension works and if it’s ideal to throw away a stock to install one? Also is coil any better?
@CPTME90s
7 жыл бұрын
I wish Lockheed aerospace engineers loved us.
@wingryda
8 жыл бұрын
+Engineering Explained in the video you mentioned you worked at an engineering company and that you didn't like it, do you work at another company now or are you solely doing the KZitem videos? Are you making more with what you're doing now than what you were doing before? Great videos by the way!!
@markteague8889
8 жыл бұрын
Only problem with engineering fields is that they must surely be on decline in the United States since most everything is being manufactured overseas these days.
@jackallen6261
8 жыл бұрын
My dad when working on his Cummins engine in is truck would always say that the damn engineers wife ran off with a mechanic and now he's taking it out on all of us, lol.
Пікірлер: 1,9 М.