If this man were sitting in India, modi will set ED and CBI on him! They will slap UAPA on him! If he is outside India they might send RAW to get him.Please stay safe Sir. ThankGod he has explained all this to us. One of your best programs Karan!
@Victor-y9g1w
10 ай бұрын
did you get rice for this month? I didn't/ :(
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
@@Victor-y9g1w church mein sprinkle kiya.. lol.. unko bread diya gora ne
@ArunGupta-wj1xl
10 ай бұрын
Mr Khaitan and Wires are being funded by Gorge Soros and China
@alburj1
10 ай бұрын
Usual firangi bakwaas
@lalit00731
10 ай бұрын
Biased narrative, without appreciating the reason for CAA and it’s necessity to stop demographic imbalance occurred due to unlawful infiltration.
@sajijohn1425
10 ай бұрын
Only when we lose it do we value Democracy
@Myfirstproject296
10 ай бұрын
That’s true
@hiteshpunjabi9413
10 ай бұрын
Yes it's time to let it go and let people miss its absence. There is no point in trying to get your point across to people who do not want to understand it. Time and karma always haunts one back.
@ravikumarbs7298
10 ай бұрын
To a large extent we have already lost our democracy in the last couple of years.😢
@noize2sound
10 ай бұрын
Your Democracy is toxic & Fascism for us.
@haribabue4202
10 ай бұрын
If someone becomes PM with majority in the LS or if someone becomes CM with majority in an assembly, it is not democracy. Legislative and Executive power should be separated In democracy,
@philipjohnify
10 ай бұрын
The Judiciary, even at the very top, has been the greatest disappointment for the Indian Democracy. Complicit.
@sridharrao7117
10 ай бұрын
There is no control of corruption in Judiciary and Medical profession
@dr.bhimraobandgar2069
10 ай бұрын
❤
@ytuser903
9 ай бұрын
Despite this institute of judiciary remains last hope.
@sunilranjan6825
9 ай бұрын
If judiciary goes against the BJP led government then it's independent & effective???
@Lazarus365
9 ай бұрын
@@sunilranjan6825 Yes, it is. If it does something that requires that kind of action. We have seen over the last few years how the BJP has a influence over all the governmental agencies and even non governmental agencies for fear of retribution.
@sureshksureshk8053
10 ай бұрын
The Supreme Court should take the hard line against the BJP RSS executive. When the government is blatantly opposing the judiciary, the courts should come down heavily on the government in order to not let the executive repeat its arrogance
@Dogmatix1950
10 ай бұрын
What makes you think the entire judiciary is opposed to what the BJP-RSS regime intends? Many in the judiciary and executive branches as well have been hand-picked to ensure they support the agenda of this dispensation. There is a deep design behind what RSS does.
@lgopalakrishnan3181
10 ай бұрын
@suriyhaprakhas356 WOW Mr Troll you are really minting money today by posting so many messages.
@budsurtees4224
10 ай бұрын
@@Dogmatix1950 Correct! They have filled the judiciary with large numbers of their own people.
@budsurtees4224
10 ай бұрын
@suriyhaprakhas356 You need to chill. You've already exceeded your daily 10 rupee allowance limit for your ridiculous exclamations.
@chander3338
10 ай бұрын
BJP lacks spine. The way it put Nupur Sharma under the bus cannot be forgotten.
@satyajitmahapatra
10 ай бұрын
Legitimate way to portray the darkest phase India is currently under.
@Trichambaram
10 ай бұрын
Though most of us know what's happening today, the insidious authoritarianism we have been experiencing, it is stll terrifying listening to Prof. Khaitan.
@emperor2267
10 ай бұрын
If you go through the economic conditions under Manmohan faced Sonia Govt and multi-billion dollars scams of that Government, you will certainly feel extremely comfortable of the Modi Government esp. Inhis 2nd term. You got to recollect the days India was shit scared of India, the weakened Indian military deprived of high tech hardware, the hazy foreign policy, the appeasement policy of the then Government when a particular was said to have first right on resources, missing terrorist blasts etc. etc.
@ChandraSekhar-zy8hi
6 ай бұрын
What you said are things to be done inevitably for goodness of the nation
@moderndemocracychannel4699
10 ай бұрын
When ratio of educated Indians were less in numbers or about 12 % nearing 1940s people opted for democracy, secularism, constitution and practiced it . But in 2014 education about 80% to present times democracy is being 1000 cuts and indian voters are sleeping and unlike French , Israel voters. Very unfortunate. We are untrained practitioners of democracy and moved everything for Supreme Court.
@krishnaraocolluru5333
10 ай бұрын
Education is vastly different from ‘awareness’ and the eagerness to remain informed and to believe that one’s judgement of matters are relevant enough. I came across many highly educated who simply shrug their shoulders and proclaim ‘in which way my own individual opinion matters or makes a difference’. This is dangerous for democracy.
@mncbabu
10 ай бұрын
Education not produce knowledge and wisdom everytime to everybody. Most educated can be cheated by nationalism and religious grounds..
@Dogmatix1950
10 ай бұрын
@@krishnaraocolluru5333 Unfortunately, 'politics' has been given a rather unsavoury connotation in public mind, so 'good' people try to avoid it like plague. It is unfortunate because politics is integral to our existence; when we shun it or turn the other way, we give unscrupulous people the opportunity to exploit us. It is being naïve and education does not cure naivete.
@anusholly
10 ай бұрын
Just because someone in a foreign University says 1000 cuts doesn’t make it correct. In the 40s and for 40 years after that there was no opposition as well. Yet we believe that was better democracy, funny.
@neevan7292
10 ай бұрын
kindly look beyond 1940 in reverse years, if You sincerely wish to EDUCATE YOURSELF' And about the rest of you Words conveyed by You here before and between commas, ESPECIALLY the last one before the dot. (in your own sentence showed above). i hopefully wish would find yourself knowing better.
@manoharanthottarath7071
10 ай бұрын
This is a good interview. It has touched upon almost all areas afflicting the country. At present, there is a near threat to India's democracy. The dictatorial style of functioning of the government by misusing the investigating agencies, massive corruption vis a vis cronyism, undermining judiciary etc are only a few examples. The economy hasn't performed well, resulting in massive unemployment and poverty. Winning elections somehow has become the major agenda of this government. But, majority of the people are not bothered about all this. Religious polarisation is the main handiwork of the government to remain in power. But, the opposition has failed to stand up to the ruling regime. That is very unfortunate. India's image as a liberal democracy stands shattered. It is all despair.
@Dogmatix1950
10 ай бұрын
Wish more 'thinking' Indians would stop sleepwalking and wake up to the insidious way our nation is being transformed. This conversation with Prof Khaitan ought to be an eye-opener.
@agnescraig2912
10 ай бұрын
There are people speaking out. Some lawyers like Bhusan Dave come to mind
@Dogmatix1950
10 ай бұрын
@@agnescraig2912 I presume you mean Dushant Dave.
@budsurtees4224
10 ай бұрын
@@Dogmatix1950 He means both Prashant Bhushan and Dushyant Dave.
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
do you need someone to open your eyes.. man this is the height of laziness. It is involuntary for most people
@Jt61603
10 ай бұрын
Admiring the boldness, Professor!
@drsudhiragrawal
10 ай бұрын
Corporatocracy हटाओ, Democracy लाओ! नरेंद्र मोदी हटाओ, भारत माता बचाओ!!
@jatinnath.
10 ай бұрын
This was an amazing interview! Prof Khaitan - you have been fact based, calibrated and example based. It would be very hard for anyone to shoot your argument down. RESPECT.
@venkataramamuthuswami
10 ай бұрын
Khaitan ilks are just examples of democractic freedom to choose where he wants to live and thrive, and whatever subjective analyses they are capable of. Citizen laws are a must for any nation and proper governance. India is not a perfect democracy because we are not perfect people, educated, mature, to understand spiritually how to live, share and care. Again, Modi sarkar may not be the great example, but his intention to do good to all is well taken. People like Wire guys are always aggrieved because of change in game rules.
@AshokJayanthi
9 ай бұрын
One fake supporting another fake
@sajijohn1425
10 ай бұрын
I hope the Congress and especially Rahul Gandhi is watching this program and learns a few lessons
@agnescraig2912
10 ай бұрын
Sadly NO it is the Gandhis who must step aside but will NEVER give up that slot!! Her Italian heritage + the Indian maternal DN A is very powerful nd she will see the siblings rule
@budsurtees4224
10 ай бұрын
If the Congress had practiced true democracy in their own party and followed the dictum "Let those who can, do." a lot of suppressed talent would have risen to the top and it would have been a formidable opposition instead of being the emasculated party it has become.
@SV-kx6lm
10 ай бұрын
He is learning it from George Soros
@rajeevpalthukral764
10 ай бұрын
Yes, he will be visiting your sister
@budsurtees4224
10 ай бұрын
@@rajeevpalthukral764 But I was under the impression that it was your mother that fancied him? If so, he could very well be your father.
@mohammedzakaria2409
10 ай бұрын
Suggestions of Mr.T.Khaitan are really Eye-Openers. When will the people understand? Then? When it will be too late and too bad for the country!
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
bhaisahab aap pakistan mein hi jaiye. A muslim is never going to be satisfied. That is certain
@Govindarajan-rf5kk
10 ай бұрын
Why Pakistan ? Why not Bangladesh or Afghanistan ? Why andh bhakts are so obsessed with Pakistan and not other neighboring countries ? Is Pakistanis are their jilted ex ?
@reloaderify
10 ай бұрын
@@Govindarajan-rf5kk Andhbhakts can never see anything other than Pakistan😜😜
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
@@Govindarajan-rf5kk yeah afganistan and bangladesh are model democracies.. poda patti
@HeMein
10 ай бұрын
It is the EVM that is playing the game.
@romeochetri9934
10 ай бұрын
Gujarati murderer has become the constitutional murderer
@Victor-y9g1w
10 ай бұрын
hey, your sister was crying saying that Abdul enjoyed but didn't pay.
@anupsharma9442
10 ай бұрын
Strongly agreed with all the observations made by Professor Khaitan except that Congress was responsible for Modi's rise and only regional parties are fighting Modi. Regional parties fight for their existence and don't want to lose their control. In fact, regional parties weakened the Congress in the fight against BJP by directly or indirectly supporting BJP. Congress is the only party fighting for the people much more than for themselves. Congress needs people's support and is the only party that can lead India to progress in a democratic and peaceful manner.
@Dogmatix1950
10 ай бұрын
It has taken ten years for Congress to wake up and realise they are fighting an existential battle for survival. In 2019, the same Congress party's counter to the BJP juggernaut was an utterly juvenile slogan "chowkidar chor hai" which needless to say failed to make a dent on the Teflon-coated Hindu Samrat. If Congress had been serious back then, they would have stopped bickering among themselves and instead put together their minds to come up with a counter strategy. Whether one agrees or not with RSS political philosophy, one has to give them credit for deep and long term strategic thinking - over the last few decades they have built what seems an impregnable & unassailable political fortress. This year, in my state of Karnataka, Congress proved they can fight BJP and its dog-whistle politics if they get down to the basics but the big question is, has Congress learnt its lessons or are they still going about like an ostrich with its head in the sands?
@anupsharma9442
10 ай бұрын
@@Dogmatix1950 Congress doesn't have an existential crisis. Congress is the conscience of Indian people. Congress gets stronger with awake and conscience public but fails when people believe in hate and propaganda.
@Dogmatix1950
10 ай бұрын
@@anupsharma9442 To me Congress has been more a political movement that mobilised Indians than a political party as such. True, it carried everyone (barring a few) under the banner of freedom movement but it lacked a singular political ideology to hold it together; 'swarajya' as the rallying cry was good enough to suffice. Both to the right and left however we have had parties like RSS-Jan Sangh-BJP and the Communists who had a more sharply defined ideology and therefore a more committed cadre. Fortuitously, Congress had some stalwart leaders who were able to impart a forward-looking direction to the nascent nation after independence. In the ensuing ideological vacuum, in the late 60s and 70s, the party sadly became a reflection of one family, and after Nehru that family hadn't been blessed with a far looking visionary or even an ideologue. The party had been plodding along on its own momentum but lacked the spirit to drive it forward; it became a fractious coalition of various vested groups. Gandhi family was the glue that held the party together rather than leading it. Congress, no doubt, has a critical role to play but it needs to reenergize itself first with a clear-cut purpose. It did show a glimmer of hope in the recent elections in my state, Karnataka, by coalescing the disenfranchised people cutting across communal sectarianism. It did catch the aspiration of a rising middle-class between 2004 and 2009 but then its inner contradiction came to the fore and got swamped by a well-designed campaign by the BJP in 2014. It has no answer to a demagogue.
@anupsharma9442
10 ай бұрын
@@Dogmatix1950 India won't survive if BJP come to power in 2024 again. It's that simple for me. Congress with all its flaws is the only option to save India.
@Dogmatix1950
10 ай бұрын
@@anupsharma9442 India will survive but not the Idea of India as envisaged by our founders. Since I was born closer to the time of Independence than you perhaps, I cherish the India I was brought up in. I will certainly mourn the demise of the democratic and secular India with its composite culture that shaped me. If that happens, I will blame the Congress for not fighting hard enough for the ideals the founding fathers had bequeathed the nation.
@abhilash4479
10 ай бұрын
Grateful for Mr khaitan's clear analysis of 10 yrs of Modi govt.. thank you thapar for bringing him & patiently listening to his answers..❤
@ArunGupta-wj1xl
10 ай бұрын
Mr Khaitan and Wires are being funded by Gorge Soros and China.
@ArunGupta-wj1xl
10 ай бұрын
These spanners like Wires Digital Channel, Karan Thaper, Avinabh Khaitan , Arfa Khanun Sherwani, are being financed by foreign powers, Mainly China to disrupt India's march to become a developed and a powerful country by somehow dislodging this government and install a weak pappu so that the development speed is thwarted. and India or Bharat does not become a great Power. But few people like those who patronize wire will buy these arguments of Prof Khaitan. Good Luck.
@arupgoswami8581
10 ай бұрын
Yes, the Congress Party should have acted how it does today in 2023 as back as in 2019 .
@Dogmatix1950
10 ай бұрын
Till date I haven't heard or seen a credible counter-vision from the Congress Party. Does Congress have an alternative to RSS-sponsored Hindu Rashtra?
@atompf24
10 ай бұрын
The book “How Democracies Die” by Steven Levitsky, Daniel Ziblatt is a must read, especially chapter four.
@Lazarus365
10 ай бұрын
@shaktiman4231Like lakhs of Hindustanis.
@RichardGKhan
10 ай бұрын
A very insightful and eye opening episode which must be taken into cognizance by those who would like to ensure the sanctity and safeguarding of the Consitution of India as it is now & therefore the politicians & Parties which subscribe to it should wake up and not be complicit any longer!
@aviralnarain7468
10 ай бұрын
I equate the current govt to the East India Company and the way they made their establishment legitimate by years of bribing and maligning the rulers, each tactic used by the ruling govt equates to the 17th century when the indian public was in fact being ruled by those whose lack of awareness and personal petty musings led the whole country to 350 years of loot and exploitation. Even then we sleepwalked into it and even now WE ARE
@budsurtees4224
10 ай бұрын
You're quite right. And if you look deeper you will see that their authoritarian acts and measures eerily resemble the Nazi party's methods during their rise to power, using intimidation by the Brownshirts and whipping up anger and resentment among the marginalized and the poor Germans by using demagoguery and nationalism. Someone in their party is reading Nazi history and methodology and taking cues.
@sajijohn1425
10 ай бұрын
We took Democracy for granted. I was born into a free Democracy butnow I believe I am a subject ruled by king Modi 🤴
@samratroy7100
10 ай бұрын
Some people exactly feel same when gandhi dynasty rule india.
@sujithkumar2041
10 ай бұрын
@@samratroy7100so it’s always all about personality, not about democracy itself?
@netaambani
10 ай бұрын
But what has Modi done to personally affect you? If nothing than its your mind hoing wrong..
@suyashprksh
10 ай бұрын
@suriyhaprakhas356thats how u were brainwashed. Read Constitution and u will come to know who is more democratic
@proudandpeaceful3491
10 ай бұрын
Converts think they are still the rulers. Democracy was destroyed by Nehru and his fakery litter for 65 years
@T18338
10 ай бұрын
The people of India who weren’t sleeping have already taken shelter in other countries:) and the rest who remain have probably surrendered to fate!:) in the hope that some magic will save the country. But Mr. Khaitan summarized the whole situation perfectly and brilliant on-point analysis .
@Seshamani99
10 ай бұрын
😂
@pranavvenugopal2609
10 ай бұрын
Smoking weed lately?
@adityatripathy8868
5 ай бұрын
Absolutely right.
@sheelamahar5711
10 ай бұрын
I found Modi is a great danger to this country 😢
@neevan7292
10 ай бұрын
which country do u belong to
@SV-kx6lm
10 ай бұрын
@@neevan7292She means Pakistan 😅
@BRBHARDWAJ
10 ай бұрын
Yep hes a danger to pakistan and current situation of pak is due to his deeds like stoping trade and fatf and anti terror and notebandi 😂😂
@roshrishi
10 ай бұрын
@@BRBHARDWAJ He is more dangerous to India than Pakistan. Adani Aambani ka ghulam
@SV-kx6lm
10 ай бұрын
@@roshrishi Adhani and Ambani are two major businessmen. If the nationalized banks and foreign banks are willing to lend them bn$ what's your problem.
@123xyzabccba
10 ай бұрын
43:08; it’s not just the non-hindus who wld be the second class citizens under hindu rashtra but they will have the company of 85% of hindus who are considered as Shudras (obc sc st)…..Because hindu-rashtra is actually Bamman-rashtra where the minority bammans will rule with the help of the bania+kshatri (the indian version of KAPOS ) …
@samratroy7100
10 ай бұрын
Secular nation is nothing more than rule by naxals, muslim, Christian rule nation sare hindus will persecute converted govt. Control temple destroy gurukuls and make hindus against there own faith and ritual and government will interfere hindus personal ritual and distorted.
@Seshamani99
10 ай бұрын
😂
@tindrums
10 ай бұрын
Kaunsa phuka bata de. Bahut powerful hai.
@balajiraju4157
10 ай бұрын
@@Seshamani99 65% obc people vote for bjp....most liberals in india are upper caste
@DevRajIES1999
9 ай бұрын
I am Tribal man(ST category) from Rajasthan but I support and will keep supporting because What BJP has done for indian Development, No Government ever thought of it You all just keep barking 😂 Actually you are the fools and andhabhaktas who even after independence still to be Ruled by Dynasty Politicians What the representation we tribals, scheduled Caste has got in BJP regime we didn't got in Congress Rule Now tribal CM of BJP CM of Chattisgarh CM of Arunachal Pradesh
@budsurtees4224
10 ай бұрын
Democracy is more than just about the right to vote, which is how most Indians view it. It is about an attitude, an act of the spirit, a mindset, and a recognition of the state of being equal in status, opportunity, and rights. In that sense, India has NEVER been a democracy in its most essential sense - it's been a feudal state that masquerades as a democracy. The "raja and praja" attitude of pre-independence Indians has now become the "mai baap sarkar" attitude of Indians. In both cases, there is a recognition of a superior entity "ruling over" the inferior entity (which is why you always hear the phrase "the RULING party" in India). In a true democracy nobody "rules" over anybody - they administer and govern, and most importantly they SERVE. Try telling an Indian bureaucrat, official or politician that they are "public SERVANTS" and their angry/arrogant reaction will tell you how they view democracy. Anyways, even by these low and weak standards of government in India, where all governments have failed miserably in respecting and serving the citizenry, the BJPee has failed more miserably and spectacularly because they don't even "pretend" to be democratic like other governments. They are brazen about their autocracy and arrogance, and India may never recover from this wounding. As far as the Congress party is concerned, one can't expect it to succeed in opposing the tyranny of this government or gving India true democracy because in its own workings and functioning it is not democratic and revolves around one person, and its members accept this absurd reality, which is yet another display of the servile mentality that afflicts most Indians. Around the world we see and have seen examples of governments being toppled through sheer people power and protest, whereas in India we see a propensity among Indians to remain indifferent and not extend themselves. This is absolutely possible in a country or society where large numbers of people are illiterate, semi-literate, badly educated, ignorant, and shackled by centuries of religious dogma, superstition and a self-serving ethos. That other tyrant-posing-as-a-democrat Donald Trump used to loudly say "I love the poorly educated". That's exactly what the BJPee knows and thinks and exploits, even if they don't say it.
@agnescraig2912
10 ай бұрын
An educated comment covering many root causes in India. One that rankles most is Indian politicians nd their entitlement nd arrogance
@michelledatey
10 ай бұрын
Well written!
@purushottamkute7485
10 ай бұрын
@budsurtees4224 extremely well written
@sonabarnes6670
10 ай бұрын
God bless you for highlighting the root causes and presenting it so well. 👍
@rajValath
10 ай бұрын
Indians have not evolved for democracy. Still, more than fourty percent of the Gau patta is illiterate, which means they have zero political awareness. However, we progressed quite a bit in 65 years up to 2014 even though the Gau patta lags behind the south. With this government in power, there is so much crookedness exploiting the loopholes inside the constitution. For example, because of their IT cell and massive dissemination of misinformation, the other parties are forced to do the same in their capacity. These are all non-entity in mature democracies. This will put a thwart on the progress of India and I don't see India catching up with China in another hundred years, let alone the West. However, the more important thing is replacing the constitution with a Brahminical one scripted from Nagpur.
@sajijohn1425
10 ай бұрын
Brilliant 👏 Thank you Karan Thapar.Thankyou Prof Tarunabh Khaitan for your Brilliant Analysis
@ArunGupta-wj1xl
10 ай бұрын
Mr Khaitan and Wires are being funded by Gorge Soros and China
@Dogmatix1950
10 ай бұрын
The moot point is do we want a Hindu Rashtra as designed by RSS, with a mono culture (one nation, one party, one leader, one religion, one language, one thought...), or do we want a Hindustan with a composite culture of many streams of thoughts and beliefs?
@SV-kx6lm
10 ай бұрын
Don't worry by 2050 there will be a Gjazwa E Hind and you will either be a partner or victim to the peaceful religion.
@VivekVerma-zh2wk
10 ай бұрын
Verdict is clear bro : Hindu Rashtra. Look to migrate if you don't like it.
@Victor-y9g1w
10 ай бұрын
he already lives in Waste Bengal. He does not have to go Paxtan.@@VivekVerma-zh2wk
@VK-md7jm
10 ай бұрын
* India was divided in 1947 to accede to the demand of Muslims of homeland (on the principle - they cannot exist with other religions and need 'land of the pure' - no other religion) and two Muslim countries were born - Pakistan and Bangladesh. Hindus thought they will have peace after giving 30% of the land to muslims who were only 16% at that time. Muslims had a better deal in partition. Many Muslims stayed back. But now they want all. They want to convert India into an Islamic state. Hindus feel cheated now. * 3 million lives (mostly Hindus & Sikhs) were lost because of partition of India. Jinnah and Muslims said they did not want to co-exist with others and wanted Pakistan (land of the pure). Just to remind look for Direct Action Day, Noakhali etc. * There are 57 muslim countries that follow Islamic laws, there is 1 country for Jews, there are 117 countries that lean Christian. Hindus have NONE. Why???? Even the President of USA takes oath on Bible and most Americans say it is built on Judeo-Christian values. Have you ever thought about or questioned it? Are YOU, Hindus INFERIOR to other religions????
@ridhamatri9447
10 ай бұрын
@@VivekVerma-zh2wk not Hindu but Sanatani.
@peacepenglam
10 ай бұрын
Please elect any Govt other than present one😂
@ayush8705
10 ай бұрын
Andh-hater
@SV-kx6lm
10 ай бұрын
You mean the person who met George Soros in Uzbekistan
@ridhamatri9447
10 ай бұрын
Lalu Prasad is best.
@Indu-uw3nz2rt9i
10 ай бұрын
Stalin ( with his own ideology) !
@user-lx3om2rs7e
10 ай бұрын
Modi will be kicked out in 2024... God has his own ways... wait patiently
@AnirimaGhosh
8 ай бұрын
I wish but it’s not gonna happen 😢
@abhijitchatterji7587
10 ай бұрын
Blame the Congress as usual. If the voter votes overwhelmingly for the retrograde bjp, what can one do. But better late than never- the Congress has taken the lead.
@bhaskardas6295
10 ай бұрын
Greatly analysed and summarized by two experts. This is an eye opening for the educated and aware population having their undying spirit for the true essense of India. Thank you Karan.🙏
@blueheaven4838
10 ай бұрын
Right. However common sense among his supporters is rare. Nothing makes a difference. And if you actually look, his supporter base is very much amongst those semi- educated rural population. The RSS VHP acolytes.
@jitkr1489
8 ай бұрын
@@blueheaven4838 sorry buddy, his base is also a very progressive educated upper middle class Hindu base. People who oppose him are communal bigots.. i.e. the minorities. I'm sure you are one.
@ashokkumarsharma1362
10 ай бұрын
It is not right to say that Supreme Court lacks authority to pass and get order be implemented , Article 144 of the constitution gives full executive and judicial power to get any order passed by it to be excited.
@Lazarus365
10 ай бұрын
I would not have known all this as I am an ordinary layman. Thanks Karan for bringing this program. It has proved to be very valuable to us.
@eonworldwide4724
10 ай бұрын
This is a classic example of electoral autocracy that is the most dangerous of rule because all extreme cruel atrocities are justified Thapar and Mr Khaitan must also state that this was the handiwork of RSS with the full backing of intelligence bureaucracy and judiciary of Sanghi Brahmins and Sanghi Hindus If you don’t state this now When?
@shrikantmahajan3750
10 ай бұрын
Why can't prof khaitan talk in favour of mody and bjp ,is he anti modi. No ! precisely he keeps on talking on the basis of what is being seen ,talked and felt all over in the core atmosphere He deserves salute and praise of his talking.The time has come now to talk freely and boldly and emulate prof khaitan to save democracy and humanity
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
talk re.. talk is cheap!! public taai bajayega
@MatheenKhan-ln4xq
8 ай бұрын
What is being seen is the truth and that is what he speaks
@Lazarus365
10 ай бұрын
I would love to have another interview program with Karan and Professor Tarunabh Khaitan as soon as possible. What he says is very pertinent and meaningful. We feel privileged to have such an erudite person who can be so open and lucid amongst us. Kudos to you both.
@Khukhum9
10 ай бұрын
The irony is that,the educated who are aware of the heinous policies din't vote or do not participated in Voting. The least educated ,the poor the fanatics who are not aware of the policies behind turned up huge in number during voting.May God gives us the light to defferentiate......
@agnescraig2912
10 ай бұрын
True but the poor and uneducated turn up because they get a free ride or outing with free food. Very sad really. Voting is a welcome distraction for a day in an unforgiving nd desperate daily existence
@saq3329
10 ай бұрын
My reading of the situation is that the educated too voted whole heartedly because they do not stand to lose under a supremacist regime bcoz of their privilege.
@Dogmatix1950
10 ай бұрын
@@saq3329 Educated Germans had voted Hitler to power, didn't they? Here too, many so-called educated Indians are fine with majoritarian fascism. Let's not blame the poor who are taken for a merry ride by all political parties.
@omkarnathkamalapurkar5530
9 ай бұрын
By sitting in studio you can't decide what is the fate of democracy in India Don't measure India from colonial mindset
@AlokAsthana1954
10 ай бұрын
It is true that Modi’s cunning has won him handsomely. If this smart guy had even some pro-India intentions, India would indeed be a super power by now. But evil just can’t pay for long. Though the logic of this can’t be explained, but it is true. He will be brought down by nine other than his own shadow.
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
bhai hindi mein hi likh de.. kuch samajh mein nahi aaya
@Dogmatix1950
10 ай бұрын
It is called hubris of power. It brings down great kings and dictators alike.
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
@@Dogmatix1950 but not if people wilfully elect them back again. And that we will
@Dogmatix1950
10 ай бұрын
@@jitkr1489 Well, most dictators don't get voted out of power (Indira Gandhi being an exception perhaps), they usually drown in their own hubris. It seems the Greeks knew a thing or two about hubris of power.
@AlokAsthana1954
10 ай бұрын
@@jitkr1489English पढ़ना सीखो। या हिन्दी के videos देखो।
@_M_D_M_
10 ай бұрын
Wouldn't want to vote a person back to power who just stood silently as 2nd wave of pandemic killed many. No discussion, no interviews, no press releases. He has to go.
@idaraj8742
10 ай бұрын
Good exposure of a government that is heading towards an autocracy by Prof Khaitan of LSE. God save us!
@sunclimate
10 ай бұрын
wonderful analysis by Prof. khaitan on the Indian Constitution.
@promodinivarma6198
10 ай бұрын
We as citizens need to wake up too. Let us stop blaming everyone else.
@anupamverma7749
10 ай бұрын
Very well explained, and very alarming. Just on the point of why Indra Gandhi ended the emergency and declared elections, Ramachandra Guha has explained it well - after the 1971 war and creation of Bangladesh, she was a national hero. India was Indra in the eyes of the masses. The emergency made her into a hated villain, and she yearned for the popularity and support the she once enjoyed. Hence the rollback Seems to be a credible theory; happy to learn if there are other explanations.
@raxas7378
8 ай бұрын
You're paraphrasing the statement "It is lonely at the top".
@SunilFrancisGeorge
10 ай бұрын
Modi's constitutional 'thousand cuts' - turns out, it's not a recipe for progress but more like democracy's worst haircut, and while some were snoozing, others were holding the scissors with a guilty grin. The overall assessment is that the government's actions pose a serious threat to India's democratic principles.
@srinivasrao369
10 ай бұрын
Nice interview pls support independent and fearless journalism Rare today
@achoushamjetshabam3247
10 ай бұрын
The Worse part of 2nd Modi Term is various Deadly Experiments such as Farming bills Corona fiasco and most severe is about Deadly Experiments in Kuki Meitei Manipur violence and remaining silent
@csyiem1438
10 ай бұрын
Farm bills was initiated by Canada to let farmers of India turn against Mr.Modi.Corona fisiaco as you said blaming mainly to Mr.Modi Government but in fact it is Global problems facing by all countries of the world. With regard to Kuki and Meitei problems in Manipur it seems, it is self created by outsiders in collaboration with main opposition parties in India to let Modi Government down.. .
@SeemaDevi-nd3vh
10 ай бұрын
Excellant analysis. Yes we people are responsible to undermining our democracy, judiciary, and many instituitions, changing the texture of our India. Congress sluggishness too is responsible.very saddening and fearful too.
@saroshbharucha
10 ай бұрын
This is a very unfortunate scenario.
@vijay682004
10 ай бұрын
Why you interview someone from UK about Indian Constitution ? The UK have no constitution.
@VIKASHCHUDIWALA
10 ай бұрын
SALUTE TO PROFESSOR KHAITAN FOR CORRECTLY UNDERSTANDING WHATEVER HAS HAPPENED + HAPPENING IN INDIA EVEN WHEN LIVING OUT OF INDIA ESPECIALLY IN COMPARISON TO THE LETHARGY OF THE PEOPLE LIVING IN INDIA & SEEING EVERYTHING ACTUALLY HAPPEN EVERYDAY UNDER THEIR NOSES + HAPPEN IN FRONT OF THEIR EYES BUT NEVER NOTICED DUE TO THEIR SLEEPING BRAINS .
@agnescraig2912
10 ай бұрын
It is not just that. 80% of Indians are poor . India ranks low in the UN social indices. Existence is a chore. Very sad. Indian origin but chose to migrate to the West in late sixties
@shantakaram1
10 ай бұрын
I am lucky to watch this Interview before it will be banned as Anti-National.
@ArunGupta-wj1xl
10 ай бұрын
Mr Khaitan and Wires are being funded by Gorge Soros and China
@soninos7395
10 ай бұрын
@@agnescraig2912 why didn't the Congress do anything about the poor for so many decades?
@soninos7395
10 ай бұрын
Why were our intellectuals given such a bad deal that they decided to move abroad in the 60s 70d 80s ...
@amardeshpande
10 ай бұрын
Indian judiciary works on constitution but it failed to give justice to common people. So in my opinion constipation must be replaced as it failed.
@macbookpro1232
10 ай бұрын
What ails India? Perhaps, this interview handles this question quite well and in all entirety . Thank You !
@lalit00731
10 ай бұрын
Again the judges who were rejected were highly impartial, but who can say the judges who were appointed were not impartial.
@pallawichhabra1666
10 ай бұрын
Actually he has echoed sentiments of almost every sane Indian citizen but the fact that Indians don't have any choice other than choosing Modi as leader is a harsh reality.
@Anonymous-nt4sz
10 ай бұрын
We always have a choice. The Congress may have been not as good in the past but they are no way like the bjp. The bjp has done worse in just 10 years. So yes, the Congress is a Much better choice.
@shekharmenon5626
10 ай бұрын
First and foremost congress has to take ownership of the fact that after sixty years of congress rule, this country had 83 percent illiteracy. Caste discrimination exists, there were Dalits, SC, ST. Sixty years if you are not able to remove that from the Indian dictionary, then you have failed as a party. Congress themselves were counting votes based on caste and religion. We need to hang out heads in shame, if after 75 years we identify based on our caste n religion. Can they publicly admit this. We all want a united india. But isn't the situation of today a byproduct of congress doing Nehru got a clean slate - india after independence. People of India in 1947 revered every word of leaders then. All he had to do was insist that discrimination anywhere in the name of religion or caste would be zero tolerance. But I was surprised last week when I read that Reddy's of Andhra is a congress stronghold. Nehru weren't treated as party leaders. They were treated like emperors why is the matrimonial law in the constitution based on religion. Does that give us a sense of unity or that we r different. Horse trading, winning elections with money - is this a new practice was it existing during congress era... Is congress a rich party. Is it true their coffers are bigger than our national budget. Is it true that people were fed up with the corruption and threw congress out. Congress ensured that if any party comes into power, it will be one term wonder, and congress will come back with money power. They did this with M orarji. Isn't that why BJP came in. Is the nehru clan holding onto power lest they get exposed of money laundering. .. Why don't the nehru clan get out of the way. Why do they feel that congress will break up without them at the helm. Isn't nehru clans foreign policy responsible for Siachen and PoK. Did they play religion politics to their benefit. How did nehru shape congress such that it will always be led by his family members. Did he bring Indira overtaking a whole bunch of people into politics Did he put a secession policy in place Did nehru want to emulate Gandhi and want to known internationally as 'CHACHA' and isn't that why he ran to UN at a time when Indian army was winning and this created PoK. It was difficult for BJP to do their job and still Modi has done a lot of things which normally any other party couldn't do... All other party weren't rich and couldn't stand the might of congress Let's face it Modi has done a lot against odds Today the mother and son duo brought in Kharge against Shashi Tharoor, made sure all these congress leaders know that kharge is a family favourite, and therefore that 80 year old man won hands down... Mocking democracy, showed that they don't know what is the democratic way. Waiting for him to die, cause then this Rahul can become the president of congress.. Sad they have mocked democracy
@sgbckup
10 ай бұрын
In this supposed-to-be 'democratic' echo chamber, surprisingly there are only one odd disagreements like this one. At least if the drift of the argument were in favour of a non-Rahul, non-BJP alternative, one could understand. I'm glad the nation is no longer supportive of pseudo-liberals. Modi or BJP may not be ideal, but the alternatives are far worse.
@PMPatel-np5jq
10 ай бұрын
I'm indeed deeply grateful to this engaging but worrying discourse on our immediate present & distant future.
@ArunGupta-wj1xl
10 ай бұрын
Mr Khaitan and Wires are being funded by Gorge Soros and China
@sureshksureshk8053
10 ай бұрын
It's not modi's authoritarianism, but the RSS'S. The sangh parivar cannot be ignored
@baldevsinghkohli9644
10 ай бұрын
Great insight of gradually ENCOROUIHG the rights of citizens. Bringing hinduata in our secular Democratatic country by various means. Ultimately the will be loser. People of India has to protect democracy and secularism.
@agnescraig2912
10 ай бұрын
Would help if people in their immediate family nd friends challenged Religion. Any Religion as bigots manipulating by fear to power
@indersinghmalik8359
10 ай бұрын
Corruption legalise like pm care fund Rafael deal covid pulwama etc
@AnwarHussain-ip6yd
10 ай бұрын
People are most unfortunate to have a Govt like that of BJP
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
pakistan ka haal dekho bhaijaan.. owaisi ayega to aisa kuch hoyega
@prabalpal1922
10 ай бұрын
Sir burning and zeonism in Manipur Ram mandir judgement love zihad sir rammandir judgement arbogation of 370 and electorial bond killing of Dalits rapeing of woemen rapeing of kukis woemen sir deeply done research work very good sir good reasearch work
@UjjwalKumar_234
10 ай бұрын
Dear Wire, Thanks for such nice discussions. I wish that these ideas/revelations could be made consumable for the larger public.
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
its on youtube bro.. what else do you want? lol
@hemikovsky
10 ай бұрын
Modi is not only a great danger to India but also to the world at large. He has endangered Indians across the world. Especially the new generation.
@NibaranNath-bx4ee
10 ай бұрын
The constitution of India has been killing by cutting since post independence and the consequences are with us in the shape of poverty, illiteracy, communalism and many more.
@drshokatalisaiyed4733
10 ай бұрын
"Bhay, bhukh, bhrstachar" Policy for the public in the democracies nation of the world???!!!
@bluesque9687
10 ай бұрын
Modi's supporters and bhakhts knew his intentions and what he was capable of even in 2014. They have always known... and Modi has delivered. If Modi decides to turn secular or more morally accountable then he will be toppled by his own people. So, please don't waste your time to increase awareness of what he is upto... majority of Bharat is complict. When a political goon becomes the hero of a people they will argue back and defend just like cunning and conniving politicians!!
@ramchander1688
10 ай бұрын
Excellent Analysis 👌 and explanation. SAVE Democracy, SAVE CONTRY
@sarangib
9 ай бұрын
A benevolent and enlightened autocracy is preferable to a perverse and chaotic democracy that India has been.
@shafkathussain490
10 ай бұрын
Very good & very thoughtful, important interview 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
@vinoydubey9620
6 ай бұрын
The Judiciary in general and the SC in particular has witnessed a Civilisational Decline and Degeneration in the last Decade.
@gurindersingh8109
10 ай бұрын
Narender Modi is a true gujarati hindu vaishya man and behaves like typical gujaratis of his caste cult
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
typical communal viewer of the wire! uncouth and full of hatred.
@budsurtees4224
10 ай бұрын
@@jitkr1489 A hate spewing BJPee troll calling someone else "uncouth and full of hatred" must be the irony of the century.
@1980raj
10 ай бұрын
Typical Gujju cheater.
@anangshiray2079
10 ай бұрын
This gentleman was told in his grade 5 by his English teacher that no matter how indian your accent is, if you have to sound like Europeans or American, replace P with PH and T with TH. And bouy, this guy remembers that lesson very well.
@ileenollukaren6244
10 ай бұрын
Awesome Prof thanks for the eye opener interview
@subbaraoraavi8586
10 ай бұрын
Judiciary is scared is the stark truth!
@txlish
10 ай бұрын
SCoI being pushed around - Well what do the poor Judges can do when Bill IB ED CBI have files on them and Ranga with a bait for Lt. Gov/Gov./Rajya Sabha posts/...
@kaiseransary6707
10 ай бұрын
Excellent and really bold. At the same time, very very alarming! Hats off to Karan and Prof. Khaitan.
@humptydumpty4773
10 ай бұрын
Inside out on Modi government. Very well explained. I would rather go to bed half stomach at night than give up my hard earned democracy.
@SV-kx6lm
10 ай бұрын
When was the democracy hard earned. The British wanted to get out after WW2 financial losses and MKG used it to his advantage. Period
@ytadltspv
10 ай бұрын
@@SV-kx6lm wow! lakhs of people mobilized by the then congress and MKG were beaten up or killed or jailed and exiled to andamans by the whites' brown slaves - the police, millions starved to death by the looters and u say it wasnt 'hard-earned'. in place of armed revolution with a few betrayers & traitors amongst them, unarmed struggle was the only option. what modi is doing is not a patch on what the whites did all over the world, so be more fair to those that sacrificed and are gone so this land's people could live on
@humptydumpty4773
10 ай бұрын
@@SV-kx6lm typical of you to end the freedom struggle like the predicted ending of a typical indian film. There is a history of struggle prior to 1947. Do read. Historians weren't bewakoof.
@SV-kx6lm
10 ай бұрын
@@humptydumpty4773 As your name says you are sitting on a wall. 😆. The fact of the matter is the British wanted to get out after being satisfied with the 45tn $ loot and the post ww2 situation. Now explain how did Srilanka get its independence? Did they fight against the British and lost half the country ? NO. So update yourself with facts. MKG was the biggest artist who ensured the country was split and millions lost their lives. Period.
@humptydumpty4773
10 ай бұрын
@@SV-kx6lm dude even your grandpa may have looted someone or harmed your neighbour to make gains. Occupiers don't occupy a province to do charity. History is repeat with such colonial rules. Except for Moghuls including Aurangazeb the great who stayed put with all their wealth. When you go to bed thank MKG that you are free and safe. 😇
@alburj1
10 ай бұрын
Does the esteemed professor think that the violence in WB was democratic?
@HeMein
10 ай бұрын
BJP
@mujahidzaidi1135
10 ай бұрын
Karan Thaper: I salut you for the brave and honest talk you provide against the Modi direction for dictatorial rule on India. Mujahid Ali.
@ranmalgadhvi5666
10 ай бұрын
But Mr. Or ms. Karan Thapar is kafir how can you praise him 🤣🤣
@alburj1
10 ай бұрын
Consider one point: Hundreds of millions of Indians did not benefit from the so called democracy that was there in India. So maybe they want a different type of system. This may be theirbway to get that system.
@sukumarsourirajan8050
10 ай бұрын
Very good questions and very sharp answers.
@antoniodiniz131
10 ай бұрын
It's a very scary scenario. Will Indians allow themselves to be trampled upon by their own elected leaders and be subjected to invisible authoritarianism?
@venkatabutchiramaiahmuttan8451
10 ай бұрын
Very good analysis
@subbaraoraavi8586
10 ай бұрын
A thorough diagnosis of the danger to the constitution of India!
@Savi3_1
10 ай бұрын
A good video. Informative. I saw this 3 years ago and migrated.
@budsurtees4224
10 ай бұрын
You're lucky and smart. Congratulations.
@mjwarror3372
10 ай бұрын
To where jihadi Oman
@budsurtees4224
10 ай бұрын
@@mjwarror3372 The same places where 1 million Indians have given up their passports and emigrated to since 2020 alone. Maybe you should ask yourself why Indians are happy to leave your "vishwaguru" country where everybody is supposedly happy and healthy and there is no hunger or poverty.
@blackdoesntmeanbad6058
10 ай бұрын
@@budsurtees4224the same reason why Europeans migrated a century back to find alternatives of living...
@budsurtees4224
10 ай бұрын
@@blackdoesntmeanbad6058 colonization and earning a living are fundamentally different in character and intent. Your equivalence is faulty.
@shamvaid4788
10 ай бұрын
Only one advice to this guy K. Thapar: The famous saying goes: The dogs go on barking but the caravan moves on!
@johnjoseph3622
10 ай бұрын
It's very informative and responsibily put forward. Thanks to both of you.
@i_fuk_religion
9 ай бұрын
lol... "Killed the Constitution By a 1000 Cuts", he doesn't know what congress did to India, especially Indira gandhi...
@stephandharkahit7249
10 ай бұрын
I am very much aware... Since 2014 ... Tried my best to make people aware through various social media but very very few believe that but act passively. Am resigned now .. who care .. let it comes and see public face the music.
@kr.manishpratapsinghchauha1837
10 ай бұрын
Very articulately expressed and summed up by Mr Tarunabh Khaitan. That comes out from a very detailed research. A good interview to watch for any one who believes in constitution and democracy of India drawn by the ones who faught for Freedom of India .
@kbabaria
10 ай бұрын
Thanks!
@charulatabhagwat1167
10 ай бұрын
Very well said kick BJP hatao Bharat bachao
@SV-kx6lm
10 ай бұрын
Make way for Ghazwa E Hind
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
you are right kich 'BJP hatao' kiss 'BJP bulao'
@aryabhat_online
10 ай бұрын
Every voter should watch this. Thanks 🎉
@user-ji1rz9hx1i
10 ай бұрын
So refreshing to have Tarunabh's perspective on the goings on.Thanks Karan❤
@renukabhattacharya8008
10 ай бұрын
In spite of all that has happened during the last 10 years, I don't think common people attach too much of importance to the concept of India becoming a Hindu Rastra. I do not think that the theocratic states - currently prevailing worldwide - are doing better notwithstanding the example of Israel. We need to do an objective and scientific survey of the peoples' mind to come to know what they are actually thinking - are they economically well-off? do they enjoy more freedom now? are there more opportunities now than ever for improving the living standard? what are the new prospects opening up in front of common people? In-depth data collection across the length and breadth of India and analyses of the data would quite possibly throw the Hundutva agenda and the rhetoric of the ruling party out of the window. India is a confluence of many ideas, many communities, many different cultures. This diversity is the soul of India. This is the very essence of India. And India will prevail. But the opposition - especially Congress (as rightly pointed out by Prof. Khaitan) - needs to try for preserving the pluralism of India very very hard.
@shaikhiqbal1877
10 ай бұрын
In India ruled by goondas, in goondagardi fashion. Khaitan explains very well.
@emperor2267
10 ай бұрын
It's been a wonderful journey of growth, development, progress and peace since Modi came in 2019 for second term. It's just that the Chanchas, Commission agents and paid Media aren't getting the son-in-law type appeasement and preferential treatment they were so used to since independence of India, Karan Thappar included.
@junee11100
10 ай бұрын
One of the best diverse cultures we all proudly defend biggest democracy country has turned into autocracy..
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
bhai dekho gaza mein kya ho raha hai?
@junee11100
10 ай бұрын
@@jitkr1489 I know but you cannot compare with Gaza with our country..I was a BJP supporter at the beginning I thought Modi could do something for our country especially poor people. Today I have learned that he has only focused on rich people. He completely ignored our diversity as the principal of our founding father. Very disappointed Bhai..
@jitkr1489
10 ай бұрын
@@junee11100 really the rich don't vote him to power. They are always Anti Modi because it is fashionable to be so. The poor vote him back to back and will vote him back because of everything he does for them. Modi has done more for the muslims than any other administration.. thoda padh le.. acha se
@budsurtees4224
10 ай бұрын
@@jitkr1489 He does absolutely NOTHING for the poor. India still has the world's largest population of abjectly poor people (almost 300 million) and among the world's 10 lowest rankings in terms of GDP when measured in per capita terms, instead of the meaningless GDP in purchasing power parity terms they keep claiming as an achievement, and which incidentally would have happened even if another party was in power.
@MatheenKhan-ln4xq
8 ай бұрын
@@jitkr1489demolishing masjids and madrasahs, removing Islamic rites and customs, removing halaal quota Hajj quota azaan etc What apart from this has modi done to Muslims except being so anti Islamic?
Пікірлер: 1,1 М.