I like how the lowest tier is just normal trauma because one piece is so traumatic
@shwildin
17 күн бұрын
the one page of kuma running throughout his life just before the bonney crying page hit hard
@booksandtropes
17 күн бұрын
that still hurts my heart :(
@venmissa
17 күн бұрын
Add to that. Kuma asked how much of a nuisance he was. And while Vegapunk is about to take his free will away crying the entire time, he says “your death is a nuisance… to every person who’s ever known and loved you.” Like come on Oda! I think I’d rather him come and stab me. And of course the flashback ends with the final panel of the chapter being Bonney crying her eyes out after hearing “tell her I wish her a very happy tenth birthday.” Nah! I’m not okay. I’m going to cry my eyes out when that gets animated, and then scream with excitement when the greatest punch in manga happens a few weeks later. If you know, you know.
@JPRequiem
17 күн бұрын
You know it's a trauma moment when you think of it and you start crying
@Novikous
17 күн бұрын
The most traumatic thing in One Piece, is the day it says, "THE END!"
@booksandtropes
17 күн бұрын
TRUE!!!! 😭
@achatmaster95
17 күн бұрын
i've read and watched one piece for like 20 years now ... i can't even begin to imagine what that would do to me ....
@Artimao
17 күн бұрын
Just to add a little something, you said Sanji sacri8fices himself to protect Nami against Enel, but it's important to remember that he saved Usopp, whom he said he didn't care for a little previously. It's important exactly because it shows that Sanji is nice to women, but his kindness reaches everyone.
@mynamedontmatter4796
17 күн бұрын
I also want to add to your thing Even though he said he doesn't care if ussop gets sacrificed to save nami But I always viewed it as I will Die first and then if that still doesn't work Im fine with you dying to save nami
@char1194
17 күн бұрын
Hell yeah we traumascaling now
@rcookie5128
17 күн бұрын
xD lol
@MisterTwit
17 күн бұрын
Merry's funeral really hit me in a personal way. My first car was an old hand-me-down that I loved dearly, I made a lot of memories with it doing fun and crazy things with friends. But as a fairly clueless teenager I was too clumsy about keeping it healthy so after 5 years it broke and became irreparable and I had to abandon it. So when Luffy starts apologizing to Merry the shame and guilt and depression of that hits all over again
@TheCommentaification
16 күн бұрын
I feel like that some of these actually would rank different if you watched it instead of read it. The anime adds things like music, atmosphere, and direction to some of these moments enhancing the experience.
@AkahigeNoAmo
15 күн бұрын
that Koala keeps smiling while cleaning the deck scene, added to that the shocked reactions of all these hardened fishmen ... when it was first published I wasn't really emotionally mature enough yet to appreciate it fully ... but these days I can plundge myself into a ugly bawling frenzy just thinking about it (there is a good dozen other scenes in OP that can do that too, especially if start thinking about the bigger picture beyond the individual, sometimes leaving me in a dark mood for a whole week/while )
@royalfun1031
17 күн бұрын
Even after all the bs Sanji has to go through I still think he's the best character🚬
@thehobbyist7275
17 күн бұрын
Whole Cake Island saved a LOT of the grievances I had with him after the whole Fishman Island fiasco. Will it ever be as good as his early moments, like standing up to Kuma or being the one to talk to crocodile in Little Garden? Time will tell
@royalfun1031
17 күн бұрын
@@thehobbyist7275 He's gotten better and is the most fleshed out SH It's more abt his true self now than the Mr. Prince persona he had
@Chaos_Vergil
16 күн бұрын
Luffy giving Nami his hat was the reason I fell in love with One Piece. It's such a perfect moment that shows how despite Luffy being kind of a dumbass, he emotionally understands people and knows that words are meaningless in comparison to action.
@matheuspastorelli3925
17 күн бұрын
3:38 if i remember correctly its said that not only Bellemere wanted to reaffirm she was their mother but also as a former marine she knew how dangerous the Arlong crew was, she knew it was probable they wouldnt let anyone escape the island (as they did) and the navy probably wouldnt be able to handle them (they sank 5 ships shortly after they took over) and even if she was not sure, she wouldn't risk Nami's and Nojiko's life in a gamble. It was really brief and easy to miss but this explanation happened in the conversation between Gen and the local doctor. One of the things she taught them was that as long as they lived, fun things would happen. Being enslaved by Arlong is far from ideal but everything turned out ok. All of this makes me not resent her choice, not even a little bit. Her death ranks higher in my list lol Yeah, Nami asking for help is such a great moment. She had been so strong, putting a fake smile all the time. And she hit absolute rock bottom. She realized she had no escape from Arlong and her village would die fighting to preserve their dignity. Peak Lol saying Dr Hiriluk's death hurt me a lot is an euphemism
@koubalt5574
17 күн бұрын
All of those Luffy and Nami moments(Arlong park, Drum Island, Wano) and countless more, are starting to make me believe Oda is planning to pair them together in the end. I remember a scene in weatharia where Nami told Herades that Luffy would die if she's not with him😂. Also, Oda's wife is apparently very similar to Nami that he uses her as a reference for post-ts Nami.
@imatiu
17 күн бұрын
Yeah, pretty much anyone with a bit of sense knows that the endgame for Luffy is no one or Nami, with Nami being a much more likely outcome. Fun Fact, Nami often has a Queen's crown in the color spreads she is in, just like Luffy has a King's crown, this by itself isn't that big of a deal, but even in a color spread where Nami and Hancock were both in, Nami still had a Queen's crown, while Hancock had a princess tiara.
@char1194
11 күн бұрын
I dont see why Luffy needs to pair up with anyone, he's never shown any interest in such things nor is it in any way relevant to the story or themes of One Piece. We gotta move on from thinking a story's end has gotta involve characters pairing up man.
@lucasberlitz2689
17 күн бұрын
Robin, Chopper, Nami and Law’s backstories always make me tear up whenever I remember them. On the other hand, one moment that people usually say really affects them is Sanji’s whole cake flashback, but it doesn’t do much for me. Like, I recognize that what he’s been through is horrible but it just doesn’t get me emotionally. Also, during Sanji finding out about Pudding I was kind of like “that sucks, but come on, you were head over heels with Viola just two weeks ago and now you don’t even remember her name now, do you? You’ll be fine.” Lol
@Artimao
17 күн бұрын
The whole point about Pudding's betrayal is not even about Sanji being in love for her, is the fact that she only thing he still had at that moment, and she was saying the exact same thing he used to hear from his abusive father and siblings childhood. It's not about love, is about reinforced trauma.
@naviro6672
16 күн бұрын
The most devastating moments for me are in this order 1. Luffy loosing his Crew on sabaody 2. Crew falling apart in Water 7 3.1 Corazons death 3.2 Bellmere hugging Nami with her broken arm Just to be able to hugg both her daughters 3.3 Robbin screaming for her mum while being draged away by Saul 4.1 Sanjis real backstory in combination with Puddings betrayal 4.2 Luffy gets beaten up as a child in order to get a friend in combination with loosing both his sworn brothers and knowing how broken Luffy is in the present time 5. Merry saying sorry for not being able to go any further
@happinessiseasy5
17 күн бұрын
I recently saw a fanart where Dadan is celebrating her birthday with adult Luffy, Ace and Sabo. I think Luffy is hugging her and she is crying with emotion and happiness. I don't know when I cried like a little baby😂 I still remember and hold in my heart your reaction to Marineford. I laughed at you because you were a crybaby like Shirahoshi, but I also cried with you😅We have similar tastes in arcs and moments in One Piece, although I rate Sanji higher (nasty and mean Oda takes it out on him because he's constantly courting his wife😂). If you want more trauma, watch Neon Genesis Evangelion. I watched it on TotallyNotMark's recommendation and was both enchanted and devastated😊
@ReyReyzzz
16 күн бұрын
Oh girl people are gonna cook you for not putting the ‘nothing happened’ moment at the top 😭
@Omegateck16
17 күн бұрын
Everything to do with Kyros and Dr Hiruluk hit me harder then the average person. I also think the moment when ussop tells robin on the sea train to trust in luffy, is a sleeper moment.
@aohige
17 күн бұрын
One Piece is basically Trauma Factory: the manga Celestial Dragons are one of the most despicable villains in all of fiction, ngl.
@DeeeJay07
16 күн бұрын
I like how you chose the Hiyori scene in chapter 1044 even though a lot of people didn't like that moment But that moment is for Hiyori, she wants that revenge on Orochi. I also like that moment
@shadowofthetree8293
16 күн бұрын
For me, the best arc is Water Seven/Enies Lobby, because there is a kind of an "in closed door", where we see a familly being broken under our onw eyes. We know this familly, we have a lot of affect for all of those members, so this drama is the saddest. Of course, there are a lof of things happening next to that (the government, the betrayal of galley-la company, the aqua laguna, the franky familly theft)(this is why this is not a "in closed door" story), but those things prevent the right solving of our main familly issue. And during this arc, we understand why some members of the familly left, because they consider themselves as a burden. Usopp as a useless burden, Robin as a threat. So of course, when the going merry comes to save the familly, it's a familly reunion, we could even say that when a familly reunies, it becomes stronger. And after this reunion, one of the member died. It is even sadder because the going merry is being personified, and is able to say his lasts words before being gone forever. This is why my favorite moment/most emotional is the end of the going merry, for what it represents to the crew.
@olahisawsome
16 күн бұрын
Oda spends so much time giving fake out deaths, and the first thing he kills is the Going Merry.... when that happened, i yelled, "REALLY THAT'S THE FIRST DEATH F$#$ YOU ODA"
@sfguzmani
16 күн бұрын
That's why the anime is sometimes better than the manga. It elevated most the emotional scenes because of the music. No way chopper's backstory is in "normal level" but the cherry blossom in "broke my heart"?
@asphyxia2267
17 күн бұрын
I needed this :'))
@brodash-bal4833
17 күн бұрын
Robin i want to live is my traumatic experience ever 😢😊😊
@jackipiegg
15 күн бұрын
2:45 Yea, netflix didn't get that memo. They cut the whole damn thing, WTF?!
@imatiu
17 күн бұрын
Luffy did not fail in Marineford, he saved Ace and was successful despite so many obstacles and enemies. Ace just did a stupid afterwards, but that is entirely on him and his stupid ass.
@jamesaulner8958
16 күн бұрын
*My fav character is Usopp and recently is Kuma🐾*
@stephwiller9089
15 күн бұрын
Gotta say I agreed with only a fraction of these placements but it was fun. Oda does trauma well. He is able to make you care deeply about people in such a short time and then kills them. I feel like I'm the only one that doesn't like Vivi and 100% don't want her back on the crew.
@thepokekid01
17 күн бұрын
I think a part that hit me a little hard, that obviously must not have hit others was when Black Maria was casting the illusion on Robin and Brook, but it didn't work, and then having Robin and Brooke kind of bond over that after. For some reason, the cruelty of that hit me a little hard.
@booksandtropes
17 күн бұрын
that was a great moment :)
@Omegateck16
17 күн бұрын
Jessica, there is so much sanji slander in this video! Tell me how you really feel lol. (Sanji is in my top 10 characters) lol
@booksandtropes
17 күн бұрын
Hahaha he is a great character but that one trait/running gag ruins him for me 😭
@royalfun1031
17 күн бұрын
@@Omegateck16 top 1 here
@thehobbyist7275
17 күн бұрын
Aside from Kuma not being above everything else and maybe some of the Wano stuff, I pretty much agree with this list. It's merely a personal preference as a tier list normally is as a reader. In the moment, a lot of these are really high. In retrospect, especially since Egghead is over, some early moments age better or worse. Edit: As an example, the Sabody moment at the time completely broke me, but because of Kuma's flashback, it's nowhere near as high and hits COMPLETELY differently than before
@tfunkman
15 күн бұрын
I love you but why'd i watch this?! Hahahaha 😅😭😂😭😂 Honestly though, well done.
@leonardo835q
17 күн бұрын
I think hirurul death should be a little higher, leta not forget than chopper poisoned him and he blows himself so that he doesnt die to the poison.
@rcookie5128
17 күн бұрын
I find it funny how emotional you get when you talk about the merry, because I feel represented in a way I don't like. xD Yeah, a few moments are missing, like the squidward one you mentioned.
@TyRendition
17 күн бұрын
Luffy climbing the drum kingdom mountain in live action is gonna move mountains for me especially with a good OST behind it😢❤. Also Jess I was about to digitally shake you up through my screen for not putting Robin and her mother reunion in you could stab me and it’d hurt less because there no way Robin saying “do you remember me I’m a little bit taller” didn’t break you cuz it broke me 🥹
@booksandtropes
17 күн бұрын
"Do you remember me I'm a little bit taller" yes!!!! oh my god that was heart breaking! everything with Robin's backstory was so sad 😭
@kevinbryant3291
17 күн бұрын
Mary is still my top. Just thinking about it makes we well up
@booksandtropes
17 күн бұрын
It was heart breaking, I cried so hard :(
@naviro6672
16 күн бұрын
Just a small friendly reminder... Outsiders and newbys think One Piece is a funny goofy little adventurouse pirate Story
@booksandtropes
16 күн бұрын
I was not prepared for this level of trauma when I started!!!!
@naviro6672
16 күн бұрын
@@booksandtropes Not a single person in any univers could be prepared for that... Especially with the fassade One Piece has...
Пікірлер: 59