Surely it's not just me but Ollie Wines has had a really quiet few years after winning his brownlow
@blakebird4496
Ай бұрын
He has, he also played wing last year when he's been a rover player. He's definitely not the same form he used to be in, but he also now contends with Butters, Rozze and Horne francis.
@Oracle550
Ай бұрын
When wines won it the game was very contested style period,alot of flooding lots of numbers around the ball,it suited him because he is not fast then they introduced the stand rule and 6 6 6 rule,which suits faster game style
@messi4brownlow
Ай бұрын
Paddys been quiet since the brownlow, tom mitchells been quiet and fyfes been in a god damn coma since brownlow
@DylanFoster87
Ай бұрын
I forgot he even won it 😂
@alexsoundias1974
Ай бұрын
@@Oracle550 6-6-6 has been in since 2019 and the stand rule was introduced the year Wines won the brownlow. Wines winning was because (aside from being a symptom of the brownlow voting system) it was the one year where Wines really add spread from contests to his contested ball winning ability
@afllegend1613
Ай бұрын
2022 is controversial as Cripps should've been suspended and 2023 is controversial as Neale polled 3 votes for a 20 disposal game over Cameron kicking 7 along with Neale not making the AA team
@Tosicc567
Ай бұрын
Neale should've made the AA team he only didn't because of Nathan Buckley trying to get headlines by saying he was underperforming, then he proceeded to get three bog games in a row after it. Idk what merret and serong were doing in there over Neale
@TotalDramaOwenandNoah
Ай бұрын
@@Tosicc567 merret and serong were way more consistent and impactful to their teams than neale was. selection justified.
@Tosicc567
Ай бұрын
@@TotalDramaOwenandNoah Hard disagree, neale was the best midfielder in the team that came second and averaged more clearances than anyone.Serong and merret didnt even make finals. He didnt make it because of nathan buckley, similar to Taranto not making the squad of 40 because of Kane. Dusty was in a similar boat, him and neale get compared to their previous seasons rather than the league as a whole. If merret and serong had so much impact where were they in finals?
@TotalDramaOwenandNoah
Ай бұрын
@@Tosicc567 that argument is so special. "Serong and Merret didn't even make finals." Fyfe won a brownlow when his team didn't make finals. Cripps won a brownlow when his team didn't make finals. Ablett did, Priddis did, Trent Cotchin did (techinically Jobe Watson did) but his team didn't make finals either.
@TotalDramaOwenandNoah
Ай бұрын
@@Tosicc567 i dont disagree considering neale got 3 votes for a 20 disposal game which really says enough about the voting that year
@jeremycurnow1587
Ай бұрын
1993. Wanganeen beats Greg Williams by one vote. Williams gathered 44 possessions in rd 10 against Melbourne, zero Brownlow votes. Rumour abound that umpire John Russo refused to give Williams votes.
@johntoth1264
Ай бұрын
I put $5 on woewodin in round 5 at 250 to 1. He was one of the first players to bleach his hair and stood out because of that.
@StuTheDon17
Ай бұрын
Regardless, he had a damn good season and was the best midfielder in a side that made the GF. He was always going to get a lot of votes. I remember watching the Sunday Footy Show in the lead up to the count, and 3 of the 4 fellas that gave their Brownlow predictions either had him finishing top 3 or as their dark horse. It's a myth that he didn't deserve that Brownlow
@Cash_Welch
Ай бұрын
I mean none of them were rigged the umps decide between 3 players each game so with wines and Bont for example just cause Bont has more impact in a different match doesn’t mean wines can’t poll votes out of his own match. I certainly think that the umpires just choose who they see with the ball the most and that is also why I do think they should be allowed to see some stats to make it more of a fair award
@doylersafl8728
Ай бұрын
2022 definitely was, the VFL had to know Cripps had polled the most votes to overturn his very obviously deserved suspension. Shouldn't have been eligible at all imo, Neale was better that year anyway
@TotalDramaOwenandNoah
Ай бұрын
@@doylersafl8728 imo, Touk Miller should have won
@trentmatthews5521
Ай бұрын
Give jobe watson his brownlow back
@ramonecricket5183
Ай бұрын
I don’t think these were “rigged” as such, but it just feels so unjust that Scott West (a bulldogs great), Matthew Richardson (a Richmond great) and Bontempelli (who I genuinely believe will retire a top 10 player all time) lost Brownlows to fly-by-nighters Woewodin, Cooney and Wines, all of whom have had one or two great seasons max. Same thing with Tom Mitchell and Matt Priddis having Brownlows but Scott Pendlebury and Joel Selwood not, despite the latter two being all-time Collingwood and Geelong greats. Sometimes there is no justice in sport. However, I still have faith that Bont will win it one day.
@deanterra1357
Ай бұрын
Well even if not "rigged". Certainly begs the question how umpires really view games and do voting. On top of that there has been very lenient let offs for players who should've or could've been suspended. But known to be high in Brownlow race and let off. Surprise, surprise they won it that year. If gambling is involved or allowed, it'll always leave question marks over intentions and gain for individuals to make calls
@jimmyriddle5246
Ай бұрын
Lol. Those "fly-by-nighters" have played nearly 700 games between them
@MrCartoonlife
11 күн бұрын
@@jimmyriddle5246all the more reason they should be better known.
@jimmyriddle5246
10 күн бұрын
@@MrCartoonlife anyone that follows footy knows them.
@MrCartoonlife
10 күн бұрын
@@jimmyriddle5246 just coz he’s your mate doesn’t mean everyone else knows him
@tonyemini9642
Ай бұрын
1993 when Greg Williams was robbed of a 1 billion percent brownlow.
@mabiorcholappreciationpage
Ай бұрын
Geoff Raines 0 votes in the 1980 brownlow count after going in as the overwhelming favourite
@sports78443
Ай бұрын
chol glazer and change your pfp to chol in hawks jumper
@bliesjc
Ай бұрын
Very strange to say Wines didn't impact games when it's based on what the umpires saw.
@kelstra1997
Ай бұрын
Interesting video Kaleen but I would suggest you're drawing a long bow suggesting any of the "unexpected" Brownlow wins were rigged. No one is more critical of umpires and their very questionable judgement at times than me but I certainly don't for a moment believe their votes are "rigged". Voting of this nature can never be totally fair. It's much harder to regularly catch the umpires' attention in a very good team boasting a lot of good players than it is in a lower ranked one - Premiership teams have very rarely also had the Brownlow winner. The other point of course is the umpires get an entirely different perspective on what's happening than the rest of us. Great little summary and one that certainly gets you thinking - I look forward to the next one.
@bliesjc
Ай бұрын
Agreed. Very strange to say 2021 was rigged, but not back it up with any data, and just rambling on about "impact" which was false
@mikaham681
Ай бұрын
I don't know about the Brownlow being rigged, but I was dissappointed for Bont when he was knocked off by Ollie. I hope Bont gets one, he is the best player I've seen since Judd or Ablett Jun. I'm a Saint, and unfortunately we took Jack Billings ahead of Bont in the draft. Woops!
@ChrisCarver23
Ай бұрын
This might say more about the AA team than the Brownlow.
@rivinio6128
Ай бұрын
Bontempelli had a very quiet end to the season. Wines did not. That's why he won.
@anthplayz1363
Ай бұрын
Yes
@bliesjc
Ай бұрын
The dude rambles on about Wines not having any impact, but clearly dominated in round 23 and getting his team over the line. Not to mention literally having 38 and a goal in the PF smashing.
@shatogirl
6 күн бұрын
😂😂😂😂
@devilwarr1or
Ай бұрын
...so you do a rigged brownlow medal video and leave out Greg Williams in 1993...... Diesel was hated by the umps for the way he treated them but his talent was undeniable. He already had 2 brownlow medals but was runner up in 1993 to Gavin wanganeen. The controversy though happened in the final round where he got something like 40 disposals BACK THEN and didn't poll a vote and one of the umpires admitted to diesel years later he wanted to give him votes but was denied by the other more senior umpire who hated diesel. This is LITERALLY a rigged brownlow result. All the others you mentioned all had the same one theme.... the winners of their year's brownlow didn't have team mates to steal votes off them and they pipped the line. In 2000 essendon had a champion team taking votes, Melbourne had woewodin In 2008 Geelong had ablett, bartel, Corey, enright... dogs had Cooney 2021 who was around wines to take votes? Dogs and demons had plenty In 2014 who was around priddus to take votes? Hawks, swans, freo had plenty. The voting wasn't rigged it's simply a case of being the best player in enough games which is easy to do if you're a step above your team mates in those years.
@user-ti9yt2kd5t
26 күн бұрын
Priddis was the leading disposal getter that year. Umpires really like players who handball and share around disposals, as opposed to taking long runs and shots on goal like Ablett Snr. He also managed to tackle whilst virtually never giving away frees. Well deserved.
@kailroberto263
Ай бұрын
Bonts “star power” should’ve made him win it, personally I find Bont to be the better player however considering he went missing throughout the season and his team wasn’t very as successful in the regular season wines deserved to win it
@bliesjc
Ай бұрын
I don't think the dude knows how the brownlow works. It's fine
@doylersafl8728
Ай бұрын
I hope you left out 2022 for a part 2
@cheesezus
Ай бұрын
As a Bulldogs fan Bont has been robbed 2 times brownlow, he should be a two times brownlow medalist
@user-kw5hq6mj7g
Ай бұрын
what was the other year
@Tosicc567
Ай бұрын
Robbed by his team last year for not getting enough wins
@samuelbartel3104
Ай бұрын
Bont didn’t deserve it at all. Played terribly the last 4 weeks. Wines also tied dusty for the most votes ever and also polled in the most games ever. Wines 100% deserves it. Just doesn’t get recognition because he plays for a non Victorian team
@Samuellikeslollipop
Ай бұрын
In 2023 it should’ve been bont, pettracs,or Nick daicos
@leftovercrass5210
Ай бұрын
"Bont didn't dsserve it" is where everyone will start ignoring you @samuelbartel3104
@gasparddelaforce2764
Ай бұрын
Chris Grant.
@patitude
13 күн бұрын
Priddis getting left out of the AA team was typical blind spots to interstate players from the panel. Priddis averaging 29 possessions 8 tackles and half a goal a game is insane. Give him a bit more respect than that
@user-uo3gr9xj4w
Ай бұрын
You just can't look at statistics and say someone else should win. The award is for the best and fairest you can measure performance but you cant measure fairness that's a subjective assessment of the umpire.
@csbenzo
Ай бұрын
At last, someone calling it right. For all the talk about who should have won it or had more disposals etc, generally the guy that wins it is a fair player i.e. eyes for the ball, playmaker, skilful use of the ball, not known for underhand tactics, etc., and importantly doesn’t backchat the umpires. There will be the occasional exception to the above, but it generally holds true.
@MrCartoonlife
11 күн бұрын
Fairness is measured by suspension, and everyone watching can measure it too. If fairness has more impact than that what a stupid medal and the mvp trumps it
@harleyevans6563
11 күн бұрын
2001 Brownlow, McLeod 38 touches and a goal and didn’t get a single vote, Akermanis later said in an interview “I stole the Brownlow from Andrew McLeod”.
@stupendous1068
Ай бұрын
I've always thought it's unfair whenever a player is suspended that they're ineligible for the Brownlow.
@scottbennier1335
Ай бұрын
Ollie Wines won a Brownlow off the back of a stellar season, you’re a flog if you think for a moment that Wines didn’t earn the Brownlow. He was the favourite……. As for Wines getting 32 possessions and getting 2 votes and Bontempelli getting no votes as a midfielder getting only 15 possessions……. seems very reasonable to any right minded person. Including any final is totally moot as the Brownlow votes are not counted in finals.
@bliesjc
Ай бұрын
I'm totally with you on this one man. Saying its rigged when the umpires on ground clearly thought Wines had a bigger impact on the games, and stats backing it up as well. If he played for a Vic club there would be no complaints.
@SKIPPAFC
Ай бұрын
Istg if I see Cripps on here😂😂😂
@boxescutting7808
Ай бұрын
Cant really say Priddis was rigged what a Joke. Had an amazing year. 72 more clearance than anyone else averaged 29 disposal. And I forgot he also holds the AFL record for tackles.
@lain_2339
Ай бұрын
Yeah this was a terrible take
@phillipmorphett8412
Ай бұрын
Hey bro 100 % priddis shouldn't have been in the video he was a beast for tackling
@GianniRossi_
Ай бұрын
Agreed. Stiff to say it was rigged when Priddis almost snatched back to back brownlow’s if i remember correctly 🤔 just shows he backed up his season form helping lead WCE in to the GF the next season If anything that 2015 brownlow was rigged, Fyfe was injured and missed a handful of games toward the seasons end🤣
@bliesjc
Ай бұрын
90 percent of the takes here are garbage mate don't worry
@susanmurphy8635
Ай бұрын
Bont should be a 2 time Brownlow medallist
@deanterra1357
Ай бұрын
You were quite harsh on Priddis. His handballs were not standard. He always did a great job of releasing the ball to others in open space. which made them look good. It was good to see an inside mid get the medal they deserve for doing the grunt work
@zanea6307
Ай бұрын
All the whinging about Cripps and Carlton in particular lately has been fantastic. So good to be hated and relevant again 🔵🔵🔵
@shatogirl
6 күн бұрын
always nice when the umpires back ya isn’t it
@riley420
19 күн бұрын
While Priddis definitely didn't deserve the 2014 Brownlow, he was definitely robbed of being an all Australian
@Boxing4K
Ай бұрын
The most BS Brownlow I can remember was Keith Grieg's first Brownlow in 1973. He wasn't even mentioned as a possible winner prior to the count. Kevin Bartlett was the overwhelming favourite pre-count, but the umpires didn't give him the votes he deserved. I remember there were several Richmond officials making statements to the media after the count, saying Bartlett was robbed, and it's hard to disagree with them.
@mikaham681
Ай бұрын
I watched Keith Grieg play one day at Arden St. He was absolutely amazing, no one could touch him, he always had so much time, great kicking skills and fast. He was always considered one of the fairest players. Maybe Hungry was better that year, he was always great when I saw him play, but he did a lot of good players around him, that would have taken some votes off him.
@Boxing4K
Ай бұрын
@@mikaham681 Fair point. I will make the point that Keith Grieg played in the same team as Shimma, Barry Davis, Doug Wade, Sam Kekovich, and John Rantall among others. That was the time of the 10 year rule, whereby, if you had 10 years at a club you could go to another club without any transfer fee. Keith Grieg was a very good player, but Bartlett was getting 35 possesions pretty much every week. In my opinion, Grieg deserved his second Brownlow way more than his first. And BTW, I'm a Geelong supporter, so I have no dog in this fight.
@User-7.7771
25 күн бұрын
Don’t diss woey like that he was unmatched extremely underrated, and him, Neitz and Farmer carried them to the granny
@exoticgamer5165
Ай бұрын
Wines deserved his Brownlow ur delusional talking about finals even though finals aren’t counted towards the Brownlow wines outperformed bont final round and so he won the Brownlow
@bliesjc
Ай бұрын
Thank you bro his takes infuriate me
@max_rowlandsmtb
Ай бұрын
ollie wines was clear that season, bont did nothing end of the season.
@dangledip1134
Ай бұрын
One that was missed was Chris Judd's 2010 Brownlow. Dane Swan hard carried Collingwood's midfield to minor premiers and a premiership that year. Averaged 31.5 disposals with 19.4 average kicks. 0.9 goal average a game including finals. Judd standing out in an average Carlton team i guess and umpires not liking Dane Swan. Swan won AFL Players Association award 2010.
@omgnumbers9944
Ай бұрын
iirc Judd should have won the previous year but yea thats a good example of rigged same as Williams taking the 94 medal over Matera when his previous year was better
@alexsoundias1974
Ай бұрын
@@omgnumbers9944 Judd probably should've won 2011 and Swan should've won 2010. i guess it managed to even out there
@dangledip1134
Ай бұрын
@@omgnumbers9944 It's corruption. There should be a broader collective of voters for the medal.
@cardguyakasmurfcat1469
Ай бұрын
The Bont got robbed
@cardguyakasmurfcat1469
25 күн бұрын
Who liked this comment because thanks
@Cold-cheese69
Ай бұрын
So you’re saying Ollie wines didn’t deserve the Brownlow because he didn’t look flashy enough?
@shannonpincombe8485
18 күн бұрын
Cooney's Charlie was a joke. Buddy Franklin was the most exciting and dominant player all year. Maybe he copped a suspension....? I cannot remember. Scott Wynd winning in 1992 over Jason Dunstall who had kicked 145 goals in a season is insanity. 145 goals in a season wins a Brownlow...no questions asked. Brad Hardie's win in 1985 was another ridiculous one. Judd's second was a laugh too.
@user-xs8qw3vd9z
Ай бұрын
Only Collingwood supporters says Cripps Brownlow was rigged just jealous he’s a gun
@shannonpincombe8485
18 күн бұрын
Nah mate. Cripps should've been ineligible. Overturning that suspension was bogus and everybody knows it. Chris Grant missed out on a Brownlow the same way. He understoid why he didn't deserve the prize. Cripps actions were not thise of the "fairest" player in the comp.
@user-xs8qw3vd9z
18 күн бұрын
@@shannonpincombe8485 cry some more stop being jealous was nothing in it
@Tosicc567
Ай бұрын
People forget how much it is based on what umpires see, if you think about it when a player kicks 50 meters it goes to the next umpire. They dont get the topdown view we get, so thats probably why inside mids that are crazy clean with handballs get noticed a lot. Neale is pretty much the perfect example. I dont think any brownlow has been won undeservedly, every player thats won one has a good case for it. Wins are also super important, something bont sadly had a lack of last year which would've cost him a lot. Some players just dont get votes, Josh Dunkley and Ads for some reason dont tend to poll. The stars have to align with being best on in wins with a team that gets enough wins, also a bit of luck with how the other teams mids played. Neale last year basically had the god run of BOG games with tons of wins, yes he got a 3 vote game where he shouldn't have. People forget he also got two games he was best on and only got 1 vote and 2 votes, it always evens out. As much as I was hoping for Bont to finally win one he had too much downtime with not enough wins, whilst Neale was more consistent and won more games. Similar to the 2021 season with Wines and Bont. The Bont is far more impactful than any player in the comp, issue is he has some down games because of how hard he carries each year he cant do it for an entire season. Praying he has a nuts year this year and makes finals because we all want to see bont playing finals footy again
@jackhardison7962
26 күн бұрын
chris grant 1997 got an undeserved suspension and finished 1st
@sliccj3249
Ай бұрын
Bont robbed 2023 how did Neale win
@Sauraus1
Ай бұрын
Honestly, even Daicos did better than him.
@JackMcSomeone
Ай бұрын
*Daicos
@Tosicc567
Ай бұрын
Neale played in more wins and was best on in most of them. Umpires look for inside mids because it's the easiest for them to see and he's pretty much the best for that sort of thing. If the dogs had more wins Bont probs would've won it
@TotalDramaOwenandNoah
Ай бұрын
@@Tosicc567 this is a bad take but a truthful take. I don't agree with the approach but you're not wrong.
@darrenoleary5952
Ай бұрын
@@Sauraus1 better than Neale, Bont or both???😂
@nathand4500
13 күн бұрын
your youth is telling. ablett in 2008 was in a side that won 21 games, with ablett himself missing 3 games.
@bliesjc
Ай бұрын
Brother how did you come to the conclusion Wines didn't deserve it lmao.
@OgTC2024
Ай бұрын
Bont Def Deserved It In 2021 And no one can tell me otherwise.
@lolnotamber
Ай бұрын
He's been robbed so many times
@the-king-of-afl
Ай бұрын
i know
@JackMcSomeone
Ай бұрын
Agreed
@samuelbartel3104
Ай бұрын
Bont didn’t deserve it at all. Played terribly the last 4 weeks. Wines also tied dusty for the most votes ever and also polled in the most games ever. Wines 100% deserves it. Just doesn’t get recognition because he plays for a non Victorian team
@alexsoundias1974
Ай бұрын
if he'd shown up in round 23 against port then he probably would've won it
@michaelhutchings8599
Ай бұрын
5:46 Broke my left wrist in a similar tackle. Momentum can be damaging!
@brodiegriffin1711
Ай бұрын
Why even mention finals ? Saying Priddis's team didn't even make finals thebyear he won yet saying Ablett the same year was a certainty if not injured while playing for the Suns who never have is strange
@kyalking1313
Ай бұрын
Priddis was lucky there were a few players that were suspended that year.
@LucUltraRWB
Ай бұрын
3K! Congrats Kaleen
@Kaleen_YT
Ай бұрын
Appreciate it 👍
@papaproduction
Ай бұрын
Kouta was favourite in 2000
@unlisted2875
Ай бұрын
None of these IMO it's Lachie Neale. And I'm questioning why it wasn't included when this only dropped 5 days ago?
@Rusty_Gold85
Ай бұрын
Bonce vs Wines : "Umpires are to blame " ????? WTAF ? WHO gives the votes ? Tissues are in Coles aisle 7
@ayden1311
Ай бұрын
THE umpires don't get to look at the statistics they go by what they thought in the game,
@valvoline3365
Ай бұрын
Where is Neale and Cripps’ Brownlow
@DarkEnigmaShadow
11 күн бұрын
Lachie Neale in the 2023 season. Bont should have won considering Neale got 3 votes for a 12 disposal game.
@james124___2
Ай бұрын
What about Gavin Wanganeen? That was the most rigged Brownlow
@Code_breaker_
Ай бұрын
Round 10 1993: Carlton vs Demons: Greg Williams 44 disposals and 1 goal. Received no brownlow votes for this game. Lost the 1993 Brownlow Medal by 1 vote. 10 04 2024
@ashleyadsett2302
11 күн бұрын
What a load of sh1t. Wines was a beast in 2021, absolutely dominated in the middle that year. You don't accidentally get 36 Brownlow votes 🙄 Also, that wasn't a dangerous tackle on Ablett by todays standard let alone back then. It was a completely fair tackle.
@braydendoyle5511
29 күн бұрын
People saying Cripps was the most rigged like are you kidding yourself, blame the afl for there shit rebuttal you wanna see rigged look up the 93 Brownlow
@trystanweir745
8 күн бұрын
Priddis was absolutely good enough to make all Australian in 2014, selectors are just morons
@alexsoundias1974
Ай бұрын
i know it's probably just for clickbait but calling these rigged is really stupid. the wines v bont one in particular is just a fundamental misunderstanding of what the brownlow is (and yes it's flawed and bont is a better player, but that doesn't make it rigged)
@bliesjc
Ай бұрын
Bont is a better player yes. But that's the misconception with the Brownlow. The better player in that particular season will win it, regardless of whether they're a "star" or not
@ianraper4304
11 күн бұрын
I don't agree. I guess that every man and his dog will have a say on who performed well and who was best on the ground for a particular match - this includes the spectator, the commentator, the reporter - and the umpire. Curious to note that when the two newspapers - Herald Sun and The Age cast their votes for a match they do NOT always agree. I am an Adam Goodes fan but when he won his Brownlow he polled three votes in the final round (if memory serves me correctly) but he wasn't in the top 5 for best on the ground that day - in my humble opinion. Anyway, I don't believe the voting is rigged - although the counting may have been although since the date and match have been added to the voting ticket it has been impossible to rig a grand finish (unlike the 1970 Brownlow count - yes, I remember that one - the year Peter Bedford won). So, people can argue from now until doomsday as to who might have won or been the best but the Brownlow is for the umpires to decide, no one else, so leave it at that.
@HorizonOfHope
Ай бұрын
I still have no idea why the umpires thought Bartel deserved more votes than Ablett. That shoulda been his, too. And bear in mind he was doing all of his work against blokes like a prime Dane Swan.
@BG-id2cv
Ай бұрын
I reckon in his early days, Gazza didn't have too many ump friends as he did complain a lot on the field. Kevin Bartlett had the same problem all his playing career. The umps for some reason didn't like him. He was one of the shortest priced favourites ever to win the 1974 Brownlow but came a distant 3rd to Keith Greig...who the umps loved.
@Zelmazam1
Ай бұрын
Butters hit on Banfield isn't even being looked at.
@LuckygamerYT-vc6yj
Ай бұрын
2023 was rigged, nick daicos getting over 35 disposals and having a massive impact in most games but no votes while lachie Neale having 20 disposals every game somehow getting 3 votes is very rigged
@jeremycurnow1587
Ай бұрын
Neale getting 3 votes in that 20 possession game was ridiculous, but there were games where he was best on by a mile and only polled 1 or 2. Neale averaged 26, same as 2020 when he won. Daicos probably would’ve won if he didn’t get injured.
@RGDGAME
Ай бұрын
The most rigged 3 votes I saw was L.Neale got last year with 20 disposals 😂 and Daicos had a 38 disposals game and didn’t get a vote these umps are clueless
@bliesjc
Ай бұрын
Oh never mind this is biased asf
@b3npeters
Ай бұрын
Richo was Robbed!!!
@mattyey
Ай бұрын
Yeh I’m an Eagles guy and I am friendly when it comes to Freo now, but I was an absolute dick at the time in terms of bias lol. I damn well knew that in 2014… that the Pridda Brownlow was more of an umpire favourite then the actual legit worthy winner. So it wasn’t the greatest robbing in history but ahhh… very lucky (I’m being generous 😂)
@mattyey
Ай бұрын
I think in that year (2014), Freo lost the qualifying final, home semi final (out in straight sets)… Eagles didn’t make the 8 and Pridda somehow won the Brownlow. I’m very sympathetic now to Dockers, but back then to say I enjoyed trolling was an understatement 😂.
@RileyGames95
Ай бұрын
love the content
@jasonunsworth7775
Ай бұрын
Woewodin #22. Stephan Tingay #2. Both peroxide blonde???
@JaxonRuhl
Ай бұрын
bit of an odd video tbh as most of the takes weren't very good including the one about priddis and talking about fyfe even though he was suspended??
@wbadventures2024
21 күн бұрын
Wines and Bonts are both great players but I think in 2021 season Wines won over the umps
@dylan95murphy
Ай бұрын
ANDREW MCLEOD 2001
@hotkeyafl
Ай бұрын
Garry Hocking deserved a Brownlow. Greg Williams got robbed in 93, he got 45 disposals against Melbourne but didn't get the 3 votes.
@omgnumbers9944
Ай бұрын
was given the 94 medal over Matera as compo lol
@scottM-ws7yo
28 күн бұрын
He didn’t get any votes that day. What a joke!
@callummitchell6876
16 күн бұрын
what about 2019 fyfe vs dangerfield freo came 13th while geelong came 1st and Danger was just far better than fyfe that year
@Aryan_Gupta11
Ай бұрын
In 2022, I think Touk Miller should've won, in 2023, I was torn between Daicos , Bont and Noah Anderson(I said this bc im a suns fan)
@jezuz9734
11 күн бұрын
You're delusional if you dont think Wines deserved that Brownlow.
@itsben354
Ай бұрын
Cripps should never of got his, and Fyfe should have three
@reversedizzythebackwardsth7800
Ай бұрын
I was about to say Cripps isn’t a great afl player
@zanea6307
Ай бұрын
@@reversedizzythebackwardsth7800you are either delusional or just stupid. He is a fantastic player and carried the Carlton footy club from 2014-2022. Now he finally has some support and look at the Carlton team.
@PallazoFreddo17
Ай бұрын
@@reversedizzythebackwardsth7800bro stop being salty he is one of the best blue baggers of all time and clearly deserved it in 2022. You’re just saying that cause he didn’t make finals. He has been one of the most impactful players and captains of the 2010s and the early 2020s.
@reversedizzythebackwardsth7800
Ай бұрын
@@PallazoFreddo17 omg I’m so sorry my son commented that I didn’t realise he went on my phone but anyways , I’m not the biggest Carlton fan being a Freo supporter but I can’t deny Cripps is a good player and w/e
@kyalking1313
Ай бұрын
One not on this list the Cripps one was the most rigged
@tonyl6520
17 күн бұрын
The brownlow has been rigged for a very very long time 😢
@user-jk9kq8he3p
10 күн бұрын
Kaleen, to suggest that the Brownlows are rigged simply is not true. Surprising winners yes, rigged no.
@gwilkes5325
Ай бұрын
Neale shouldn't have even been close to Daicos or Bontempelli
@darrenoleary5952
Ай бұрын
hard to get votes when you don't play due to injury. Neale didn't votes or scored 1's and 2's in games where he probably should have got 3's.
@sullyed1tsfooty146
Ай бұрын
I don’t think these are rigged but 2023 was
@Muffin_Masher
Ай бұрын
These weren't rigged, a "star" player in a team of average players stands out a lot more to the umpires voting. Better performing teams, or teams with multiple "stars" tend to steal each others votes through the season. There are plenty of rigged brownlows though, Like Adam Goodes, not once but TWICE. Literally the most overrated player in history, never had a hard ball get in his entire career, despite being the biggest heaviest guy on the field he was a sleazy little seagull waiting for easy handballs metres away from the play, and he very rarely got tackled, because he threw it away and sold teammates with hospital passes every time someone came within 5 metres of him. THAT is why everyone booed him, not racism as that flog claimed. Even Sydney fans hated him. Absolute unit of a man, and athletic AF, but played like he was scared of the ball and loved to act for free kicks.
@DylanFoster87
Ай бұрын
Bartlett and Raines robbed
@BG-id2cv
Ай бұрын
And you haven't mentioned Patrick Cripps' completely rigged Brownlow?!!!! It has been by far the worst. He shouldn't have been playing that last game where he got 3 votes....Carlton's lawyers should be getting the Brownlow for that year. Lachie Neale should now be a triple Brownlow medalist, although I don't think he deserved his 2023 medal.
@braydendoyle5511
29 күн бұрын
Cry some more about it
@BG-id2cv
29 күн бұрын
@@braydendoyle5511 OK I will. Thanks for replying.
@jamesmunn867
24 күн бұрын
Left Tom Mitchell out 🐑🐕
@the-king-of-afl
Ай бұрын
love the video and bont deseverd it it in 2021 and 2023
@JackMcSomeone
Ай бұрын
2021, yes. 2023, no
@samuelbartel3104
Ай бұрын
Bont didn’t deserve it at all. Played terribly the last 4 weeks. Wines also tied dusty for the most votes ever and also polled in the most games ever. Wines 100% deserves it. Just doesn’t get recognition because he plays for a non Victorian team
@BaileyRickerby
Ай бұрын
Bont got robbed
@harrydocwalkerharrydocwalk5998
10 күн бұрын
Brownlow is an ump medal,the format has to be changed,this year t stewart,but hes a defender,b medal sucks.
@CharlieRichards-ox6kf
Ай бұрын
The 2012
@petert4599
Ай бұрын
Could easily add 2023 to this list. Daicos and Bont both played better than Neale
@sports78443
Ай бұрын
No
@WD-4T
Ай бұрын
You dont give a single reason saying why you think it's rigged; who benefits other than the medalist?
@bus5683
25 күн бұрын
Duntstall 92
@epicindian1013
Ай бұрын
Most rigged is nick daicos not winning Brownlow last year
@BRAN_BOSS
Ай бұрын
lachie neale this year, robbed daicos and bont, should have been either of those 2 players
@darrenoleary5952
Ай бұрын
pretty hard to get votes when you're not playing for the last half-dozen games or so. Was Daicos in the same situation as Ablett was before busting his arm??? Maybe. Maybe not. Who knows? Neale might have got the 3 in a 20-posession game where Cameron kicked 7 goals, but he also missed out on 3s with 1's and 2's in games where he was clearly BOG. What goes around, comes around.
@BRAN_BOSS
Ай бұрын
@@darrenoleary5952 he should have polled 32 for the season there was a game where he got 38 disposals and 2 goals and didnt even get a vote bro, also lachnie neale polled votes when he did nothing, shouldnt have won it, he himself said before the count that he didnt think he was going to win it at all
@darrenoleary5952
Ай бұрын
@@BRAN_BOSS and there were games where Neale polled 1's, 2's or nothing at all, despite gathering 35+ touches and being instrumental in the game. No player in the history of the game has ever gone into the Brownlow thinking that they were going to win. They've always got their own thoughts on who.
@shatogirl
6 күн бұрын
marcus bontempelli robbed TWICE
@greyhairedphantom4038
4 күн бұрын
Suggesting rigging of votes is a terrible denigration of the players who won the medal. Unless you have proof it was rigged, keep your flapper shut!
Пікірлер: 240