Building infra in Mumbai is a temporary solution. In the long term, India needs to look at developing tier 2 cities, so people don't have to migrate to the metropolitan cities for employment.
@152manoj
Жыл бұрын
Exactly what I think. All this money being spent here should have been used in developing other smaller cities especially in Maharashtra itself. Now these so-called developmental activities are only going to attract more companies forcing more and more people to come to Mumbai and bringing it back to square one. Instead, infrastructure in other cities should be developed making it more convenient for companies to shift there. Facilitating this kind of growth concentrating on one spot is unhealthy and is probably being done because the side benefits for the administration for carrying out such projects is more here.
@Nirzar_R
Жыл бұрын
They are already doing it in Maharashtra... Maharashtra is developing its 2nd tier cities to attract FDIs and Inland investments and has been achieving it from last 4-5 years. Nagpur, Kolhapur is much favored cities to migrate to as they have every possible infrastructure to cope up with the replacement to the overpopulation of Mumbai.
@EagleOverTheSea
Жыл бұрын
@@Nirzar_R I have colleagues from Nagpur and Kolhapur that have migrated to Mumbai. I suppose it depends on which industry is being developed there. Mumbai still has the widest range.
@Nirzar_R
Жыл бұрын
@@EagleOverTheSea yeah Mumbai still holds the trend.. but it has declined if compared to previous years. Number games indeed makes it invisible for nagpur but the slightest change cannot be ignored.!
@Bridge_2702
Жыл бұрын
India needs more urban centres, especially in underdeveloped Ganga belt states.
@Vishwajeetvpsingh
Жыл бұрын
They consider ecological factors also don’t take ladie’s words as gospel truth. It took nearly 15 to 20 years of consideration and court cases India has strict ecological regulations.
@jai_yogi
Жыл бұрын
"ladie's words" got me 😅😅 I think her awareness level isn't enough to even make a guess😅
@nirvanabliss73
Жыл бұрын
India being ecologically friendly. Thats a big laugh
@Vishwajeetvpsingh
Жыл бұрын
@@nirvanabliss73 the context of the comment is infrastructure projects in Mumbai! And if they consider ecological factors before building infrastructure or not? the answer is yes they consider it. You can read the Bombay high court verdict and all the available information and environment clearance reports on each project. Surprisingly most of the people don’t know that India has strict environmental regulations and large amounts of bureaucracy is needed and clearance from all the stakeholders are needed before going forward on any infrastructure project. It is much easier to build a bride or a building in usa or UK but in India there are many limitations. You can laugh but India has least number of carbon emissions per capita and the forest cover of India is increasing every year. India is performing better than most of the countries in solar power generation and renewable sources of electricity. India comes in top nations in biodiversity and reserved national parks for different flora and fauna even if you talk about new trend of being vegan or vegetarian to save planet then one should know that India has most number of vegetarian population. It may sounds to you like a joke but by that logic everything is a joke.
@jai_yogi
Жыл бұрын
@@nirvanabliss73 not sure if you have ever heard term "EIA", Environmental Impact Assessment. This is a big deal & not easy to get through due to very stringent rules in context of big Infra projects.
@drvmlk
Жыл бұрын
An we all know how these court cases are settled. 😂😂
@infokites3994
Жыл бұрын
Indian metropolitan cities like Mumbai, Delhi, KolkathaChennai and Bangalore are already saturated interms of population, traffic and buildings . So don't migrate to metropolitan cities anymore. Govts also need to develop tier 2 cities with proper planning
@ranjeethavasudevan7087
Жыл бұрын
Mangroves are what protect us from flooding. I live in Navi Mumbai & we can proudly say when most part of Mumbai floods up with 3 days of rain, we dont have water logging all thanks to the mangroves
@RG-un2vl
Жыл бұрын
Mumbai is not mother in Marathi.Mumbai gets its name from deity goddess Mumba Devi who was called Mumba..aai ,or mother goddess as a term of endearment,as is often used to refer to female deities in Hindu culture..Aai in Marathi means mother not Mumbai. Also this documentary does what so many other western ones on India do.Be critical of both the infrastructure being built and lack of connectivity and ‘people’ problems if it is not.There are problems in Mumbai due to overcrowding.One remedy is to move Bollywood out,since half the people come to Mumbai hoping to make it in movies but never leave even if they don’t.Which city the size of Mumbai can practically and humanely support 6000 plus people coming in every day?The inevitable result if influx is not curbed by redistribution of these employment zones in the country is urban decay of bigger cities.Moving bollywood to where it better fits the people who wish to work in it seems like a good starting point.People working in other fields from around the country will continue to find employment in Mumbai but the numbers will be more manageable.
@pritamkallannavar9390
Жыл бұрын
Bollywood belongs to Mumbai. Bollywood and Mumbai is inseparable !
@RG-un2vl
Жыл бұрын
@@pritamkallannavar9390 Nope ...you will agree if you read the entire history of the Indian film industry.The country's first being Marathi(they made Marathi/Hindi bilinguals as well)in Mumbai, attracted people from all-around the country, especially the partition affected Urdu speaking northwest once it became profitable and there was money to be made in it.Then there was the impact of the emergency on it( through certain people) that further alienated it from its surroundings and changed the quality of movie making for the worst and ultimately it's separation into the culturally devoid hodgepodge that culminated into current bollywood.There were always some sparks here and there due to individual talent but it essentially became a coterie of a few families and their sometimes talented but mostly not kids .But the barrage of uninspiring movies kept coming.They never assimilated into the city( even to a small degree) and always stayed superior and exclusive even to their initial employers and the Native Marathi film industry which has been financially struggling since Bollywood emerged as an ungrateful step child😀.( Inspite of immense talent).Creating a unique situation in the country,where culture,language of movies and state did not match..Bollywood thus has nothing to do with the surrounding city of Mumbai except that it is located there.But it sticks out like a sore thumb and has been for the past 50 years.A glove that no longer fits.As a well wisher of the city who is not starstruck( still appreciate good movies) the choice is obvious.And honestly it will be good for Bollywood as well if they have to compete with other culturally well rooted industries.Bollywood needs to be closer to the location of the culture they represent and it is not Mumbai.
@praveenpillay4329
Жыл бұрын
Yes.
@riderchallenge4250
Жыл бұрын
Illegal rohingyas should be kicked out
@prashantchoudhary5241
Жыл бұрын
currently mumbai is developing world largest coastal road its about 150km on above sea❤
@SouthPawFrames
Жыл бұрын
Yes, I have been living near Gorai creek for more than 3 decades. And you cannot tell that you are in Mumbai such is the calmness of my place. But there are some negative points, I have to travel more than a 1km to reach a market 2km to reach the nearest petrol pump and hospital 7 km to reach the near train station. But I yes I do agree we don't need any flyovers here.
@M3sngR
Жыл бұрын
I think over the years that I have been watching you guys you have matured to the point where you can actually talk about things between India and US as democracies vs the world. I can actually sit down and watch a podcast from you guys about how your horizons expanded and how the world is in your perspective as an American who now know more about the world as well. Cheers, a subs since you were under 5K till eternity!
@adityadeopurkar3070
Жыл бұрын
If someone thinks environment factors are not taken in consideration for these projects then they are delusional. The amount of delays, cases and compromises caused by these are huge.
@jai_yogi
Жыл бұрын
we need a strict population control law as well as discipline in our behavior/manners. Taking public property for granted is intrinsic within us which needs to evolve.
@praveenpillay4329
Жыл бұрын
What? I agree on discipline in behavior and manners but population control law is draconian and wont even be considered in a evolving democracy.
@rakshit8570
Жыл бұрын
population is going down in india.
@shubham8264
Жыл бұрын
The fertility rate is exactly at the replacement level
@rajirvin1
Жыл бұрын
As a Mumbaikar born and brought up here I would say comparably Mumbai is one of the best cities to travel, live, work in India. I have been to cities like Bengaluru and Chennai but I find Mumbai having better connectivity in terms of roads/railways/airways, efficient cost, good and budget street food etc. Yes the cost of living is on the higher side but it gives that motivation to work hard and stay true to the spirit of Mumbai. The projects are something to look forward to, as the population is increasing and trains are getting packed. You can't drive out people coming to a city for their livelihood and it should be a proud thing. I feel proud of it that it has catered to their needs and in the end keeping their family back home happy. We as Indians here need to accept that we are part of a country and not as a state/city. Anyone can go anywhere and work and live anywhere.
@odomangulati7079
Жыл бұрын
LOL. As a Mumbaikar born, and brought up in Mumbai, I can CONFIRM that Mumbai is one of the WORST cities to travel, live or work. I could not get out of Mumbai fast enough and I HATE going back there. I go back because I have a house there and my wife has a house there and her parents live there. Its only gotten WORSE over the years. The streets are FILTHY, CROWDED, pedestrian unfriendly. The trains are impossible to get into except at during afternoons and against the office tide. There are NO SPACE for children to play and connect with nature and run around or cycle in safety. I have lived in Bangalore and now in Hyderabad and I have found Hyderabad the best so far.
@namanjain3658
Жыл бұрын
Next year or maximum up to 2025 india will be the 4th largest economy in the world and third largest by at most 2029 and eventually an economic superpower by half of this decade
@HumertOZ
Жыл бұрын
Modi raha toh pappu Aya toh top mai nhi rahega India
@jai_yogi
Жыл бұрын
My respect to Rickshaw driver uncle 🙏
@lakshmisivasankar6830
Жыл бұрын
Despite all the infrastructure, there is not enough long term maintenance work. Just look at things developed 5-10 years ago. Cleanliness is not a trait of Indians!!!
@desertstorm2156
Жыл бұрын
Rick, that was actually a very good impression of Micah in the intro 👍👍
@sunnyk007
Жыл бұрын
2:35 as a native Marathi speaker, Mumbai doesn't just mean mother. The Goddess that the island city gets its name from is Mumba Devi, where Devi means goddess. And the word Aai in Marathi means mother. So Mumbai is referring to Mumba Devi as the Mother Goddess.
@taslimasultanashishir1733
Жыл бұрын
The best reaction ever i seen... From BD🇧🇩🇧🇩
@sahilviradia6102
Жыл бұрын
ofc they did look into it, it's just an opinion of a journalist. if they want to address that waterlogging problem they have to build a mega mega project to pump the water from mumbai to the inner part of Maharashtra , right now its hard project, but I am sure they are looking into it. Right now , I am living in Canada and I have noticed that North American transport is heavily dependant on car ownership , to go to my college I had to travel for 1 hour by bus whereas by car its 15 mins.
@suvit_0110
Жыл бұрын
hope the gov also focuses on other small cities also...we from small cities suffer with 10 hrs electricity cut and worst road that you can barely drive no wonder everyone wants to go to metro city
@Praveenkumar-rk1up
Жыл бұрын
I like there reactions and their convo❣️
@Trains-A_Journey_Beyond_Tracks
Жыл бұрын
Did you guys watch MLC matches ? Major Cricket League - USA
@scorch3dmoon631
Жыл бұрын
I believe there are better solutions if we leave out the politics or greed inside us......there is always a choice to grow while saving the nature.
@moshinhitnalli4439
Жыл бұрын
That auto rickshaw driver speaking English better than the explanair 😱😱
@rajotavo
Жыл бұрын
Yes, your reaction was bang on! It's a double edged sword...to develop infra that is badly needed yet face the climate hazard that it's going to bring! Sustainable urban planning is one of the most challenging areas that fast growing economies face and unless there is a multifaceted approach, involving all stake holders things will go bad...that kind of enlightened govt is hard to come by across the world, except maybe in parts of North Europe...
@paulmuruganpandi8639
Жыл бұрын
Hit like from Mumbaikar 😃
@morgannamoorewhelan1692
Жыл бұрын
This video was amazing well spoken educational and informative. They really need to focus on the environmental impacts for sure. We all do.
@naughtyboy1500
Жыл бұрын
No city develops with infrastructure alone. civic manners, not spitting pan, Urinating in the open, road manners, maintenance, discipline are some of scales a city or a country reflects to the world. India is sadly deeply deplorable in these parameters
@jagdishprajapati9574
Жыл бұрын
and i haven't seen govt talk about it ever
@revanth84
Жыл бұрын
During my time in Delhi, I observed that ppl have no accountability or concern for their surroundings. Many streets reeked of pan masala and Gutka. Whereas cities like Bengaluru and Hyderabad were much better in hygiene in the public transportation, better road manners and thankfully no Pan Masala. I think its the leadership in North in some particular states where they can’t ban pan Masala as it is a huge revenue generator for them, so they avoid speaking about it. In south, I recently learned that states banned pan masala. And when actors like SRK, Akshay, Ajay devgn promote Pan masala - its gets tougher to eradicate it.
@naughtyboy1500
Жыл бұрын
Saw a vlog of Iran. The roads, the people, city curbs man it's like European. Even though it's the most sanctioned country on the planet. What are we talking about? Our indian people keep houses clean but spoil the environment. It has not changed to this day. That's deeply appalling
@Rahul-dy9wm
Жыл бұрын
Pan spitters are mainly from northindia... These ppl are coming to south and doing the same...
@rajirvin1
Жыл бұрын
@@Rahul-dy9wm Pan spitters are from North only as far as I know. In Mumbai anyways they are the workforce. You can see pan here and there even in high rise apartment passages/corridors. And then in South especially places like Tiruppur and nearby textile factory places they work for less pay.
@apoorvchauhan6258
Жыл бұрын
These Mumbaikar delayed the metro project for years to save couple of trees. So concerns raised by that woman are just hot air. They'll stall any sort of infra upgradation while Mumbai as a city crumbles
@santoshiyer78
Жыл бұрын
That lady journo knows more than the best engineers at work is it?😂😂😅. I visit Gorai beach once a month. It's an hour bike ride from my place. It's quiet and peaceful . I completely agree with the gentleman. Please don't destroy those mangroves . Let them be.
@varunkhugshal9049
Жыл бұрын
Any one with connection end up in these videos pretending to be experts .
@nirvanabliss73
Жыл бұрын
"That lady journo knows more than the best engineers at work is it?" > Why not? Is India built by engineers an ecological paradise?
@santoshiyer78
Жыл бұрын
@@nirvanabliss73 Lol. When she says "None of these been thought of" what qualification does she carry to make such lame comments? Will a land be reclaimed without taking into account the disaster, threat etc? Its like doubting the experience, expertise of the engineers at work. One need to watch and measure words before spitting it out.
@nirvanabliss73
Жыл бұрын
@@santoshiyer78 how do you know what qualification she carries? Isnt that presumptuous on your part to assume she isnt qualified? If you are assuming all civil work in India takes into account all disaster, threats etc. then india should be a ecological paradise and not a nightmare, right? but what is india in reality after the experience and expertise of engineers?
@santoshiyer78
Жыл бұрын
@@nirvanabliss73 ok .👍Enjoy
@anonymous-gz4ru
Жыл бұрын
india also currently constructing bullet train the first one ever in india the name of the bullet train corridor is from mumbai to ahmedabad consisting the total distance of 508 kms planned opening is on 2027 funded by japanese government to indian government. and also india has planned 7 more bullet train corridors covering major cities like delhi bangalore hyderabad chennai etc hope they finish it soon. and the metro under construction you saw in the video will be fully opened in june 2024 so when you come back in mumbai pls travel by the longest underground metro in mumbai . hope you come back in 2027 as well when you can travel by the ahmedabad to mumbai bullet train as well.
@psiddartha7115
Жыл бұрын
The main problem with tier 1 cities like Mumbai Hyderabad delhi is that they have huge population traffic is a big headache
@jyotiradityachoudhury7987
Жыл бұрын
It's not like they always had so much population. India's most tier 2 tier 3 cities are just hopeless because of which people tend to crowd these cities which must be stopped because it's now or never
@thetechreview369
Жыл бұрын
Hyderabad is not actually a Tier 1 city... Actual tier 1 cities are Mumbai, delhi, Chennai and kolkata
@shan25873
Жыл бұрын
Hyderabad is not a tier 1 city 😅
@psiddartha7115
Жыл бұрын
@@thetechreview369 and why do you think so
@thetechreview369
Жыл бұрын
@@psiddartha7115 I'm not thinking anything... just saying fact
@abhisek2012
Жыл бұрын
Say what you want, but Mumbai has provided bread for millions of people over the years
@chinakamaalmattle
Жыл бұрын
Both Mumbai and Delhi larger metropolis will have over 50 million people by 2035.
@alcatrazzzz
Жыл бұрын
Would you like to know what's happening in Manipur......it's India toooo🎉
@varshanimbkar605
Жыл бұрын
India speedy recovery......west bangal to Bangkok direct road projects started in India🇮🇳
@maitrayirajawat697
Жыл бұрын
I agree, along with that there must be a culture change where working remotely or hybrid. Making inter city travel fatser n cheaper, this will reduce the population pressure on one city.
@Karan-bp6it
Жыл бұрын
Lol😂😂 bad timing of the video, when the cities' infrastructure is being questioned
@priyamrocks2011
Жыл бұрын
Delhi and Kolkata metros are laughing in the corner 😂
@EagleOverTheSea
Жыл бұрын
How are they going to solve the congestion problem in Mumbai?
@CW-rx2js
Жыл бұрын
They were just built earlier...there's nothing to laugh about
@surajjadhav7827
Жыл бұрын
Amchi Mumbai ❤
@acommentor6413
Жыл бұрын
The only thing its transforming , is its transforming into a fucking waterpark in the monsoons ...... Bad timing of the video guys , Just moved there this year and i hate this city right now LOL
@RG-un2vl
Жыл бұрын
Maybe seeing how it’s well known that the city is in the Konkan area geographically,we can all sit and curse nature about doing it’s job so it doesn’t inconvenience unprepared people trying to get to there’s:)))
@riderchallenge4250
Жыл бұрын
Even shanghai is in waters now which has better infra than Mumbai
@siddhantshukla8102
Жыл бұрын
Check out what is happening in Beijing
@djsejwal2
Жыл бұрын
they forgot to mention the project in mumbai port city
@vibhanshuagarwal2000
Жыл бұрын
That is kind of you to say Mumbai is a beautiful city; it is anything but. Unfortunately, no major metropolitan city can qualify as beautiful. Sadly it is all a mess. The only nice areas are the ones built by the British. It may well become an economic powerhouse of the world in the coming decades, but the infrastructure will remain a mess. First, you need to move people out of poverty (Unlike the government), then systematically demolish and redevelop. , then perhaps, after many decades if not a century, Mumbai may become a beautiful city.
@helpbeka752
Жыл бұрын
Mumbaikars are intellectuals and they won't approve such projects if all prospects are not considered. With India progressing towards the EV mobility, pollution should not be a concern for the future.
@pardha18145
Жыл бұрын
guys i don't know if everyone is facing this same problem but... your accent is a little bit hard to follow, so I've enabled subtitles. then i see that video is being covered by subtitles. can u please change the position of video a little bit.???? i guess every indian finds following foreign accent a bit difficult so it's mandatory for many people to enable subtitles to follow what you're saying. if you think this is a small demographic that's ok but if it's a large population who are not following what you're saying then you better change the position of the video. FYI I'm an MBA graduate and i find it a little bit difficult following the accent
@jagdishprajapati9574
Жыл бұрын
Dhaka from bangladesh is the most dense city
@nikhilsahay895
Жыл бұрын
No Korbin, NYC does not even come in top 10 densest city not the Island part either ! I understand for you guys it is crowded, its not for Asians.
@wildnbluez
4 ай бұрын
Where do you live? I have been following you guys.❤
@equityboss5507
Жыл бұрын
Govt of India is following all the nature codes for any construction. All the expressways which are newly built are relocating plants and trees, they are not cutting down trees. You don't allow Govt. to build infrastructure and then complain for traffic problems. These so called Activists are parasite for this society. We cant say people who return back to their home but what we can do is improve the existing infrastructure.
@vikata5499
Жыл бұрын
No it doesn't mean mother in Marathi
@lakshmisivasankar6830
Жыл бұрын
First densely populated city I think is Mexico city
@otomackena7610
Жыл бұрын
It's not true that the ecological impact were not taken in to consideration there are National Green Tribunal and courts these projects were stuck in courts for decades over these issue it is now being implemented after proper research and permissions. That lady has no idea what she is talking about. Infrastructure in India takes decades to complete because of the same reason because it gets stuck in courts even if it benefits millions of residents. Even mass transports like Metro was stuck in courts which delayed the project. There is thousand of useless NGO's that files Public Interest Litigation stopping infrastructure projects some have vested interests it's not always in good faith or public interest.
@mridulagrawal6687
Жыл бұрын
Policy is all about trade offs,which is why there's no perfect solution ever,there's unintended consequences all d tym,but u need to make those tough decisions anyway,coz u loose more with inaction
@chi-8289
Жыл бұрын
More ecological damage is done in congestion and traffic jams in a few months than many of these projects do in its lifetime
@sjais600
Жыл бұрын
JAY MAHARASTRA🔥
@divyapatel3713
Жыл бұрын
I m live Mumbai Lower parel West
@arutko9147
Жыл бұрын
Don't worry mimbaikars we are going to live only for the next 50 years. After then the World ends.
@ivybhat
Жыл бұрын
Guys.. Just a small and useful suggestion.. Please dont talk in between the reaction b'cause you may miss many important points which are being told in the video. That discussion can be done later as well as half of the time goes away in it
@cric6945
Жыл бұрын
Mumbai is Capital of Maharashtra state ❤ .
@subharout2333
11 ай бұрын
Mumbai ❤❤❤
@neerajpurohit8044
Жыл бұрын
mega sunami predict to end of 2023 hit hard 40 mega world cities and
@shradhasanskriti4941
Жыл бұрын
Sir please karolina goswami wedding video pain and shock .Please ❤
@krug3588
Жыл бұрын
Kolkata had the first underground metro😑😒
@aschauhan9392
Жыл бұрын
Tokyo
@dhruvilkumpavat6037
Жыл бұрын
Believe Govt. look deforestation seriously here. Otherwise we would be in the list of Brazil and south american countries for that much deforestation. That lady was just giving side quests I believe. It takes so long to get anything done here when it comes to climate change and we are serious about it, otherwise we wouldn't be 5th Largest and the only Major country to rank highest in Climate Change performance index
@JackNikam07
Жыл бұрын
its a very negative view. i dont know who made this short documentry, but its very shameful work if you are an mumbaikar, mumbai needs a lot of infrastruucture projects like this, and those a stupid rikshaw driver who tells that he loves mangroves, can go to konkan and live there, this city has to develop infrastructure to benefit its local people, just remember that goverments are elected to serve people and not the enviroment. its sick to travel in train, and to walk in traffic with cars horning like crazy, its good that goverment is doing something even though its not enough, we have to do much more.
@Konyak45
Жыл бұрын
Once again Americans taking the credit.
@Gladiator_88888
Жыл бұрын
Would you like to review " Laxmi" movie starring Akshay Kumar.
@THE.INDIAN.REBELL
Жыл бұрын
Mumbai new York 🎉🎉🎉❤
@gauravkalra4
Жыл бұрын
Delhi is far far better and modern than mumbai
@Tgassassinsgaming77143
10 ай бұрын
His navi mumbai maharashtra
@ghanshyamdhruw483
Жыл бұрын
The main reason or cause is that bad and bloody politics of India .
@djsejwal2
Жыл бұрын
delhi set a great example for how metro lines are necessary and great solutions.
@solitudeking7939
Жыл бұрын
I am saying it again. We need barbie review from RICK.
@surajpatil286
Жыл бұрын
If Modi stays PM sadly Mumbai wont be mumbai anymore
@ChiSa123
Жыл бұрын
Oh shush you Khangressi
@taxgurutussh3112
Жыл бұрын
I dont like your reaction.. you arw comparing Indian city to your US city
Пікірлер: 163