Ouran has always been one of the few unfinished anime adaptations where you must absolutely read the manga after watching the series, the last half of Ouran perfectly develops its characters in ways that the anime simply never got the chance to
@rosedotmov
6 ай бұрын
I’ve actually picked up the manga recently.. I’ll try to read it soon. I’ve heard it fixes a lot from the anime
@callistified
5 ай бұрын
ohshc was literally my gay awakening. haruhi is the most gender ever, and that whole speech the english va had made me rethink a LOT. and the manga is a billion times better, where ryoji (haruhi's dad) point blank says "FOR YOUR INFORMATION, I'M BI!! BUT I DECIDED I WON'T LOVE ANY WOMAN OTHER THAN KOTOKO"
@RoweReviews
Жыл бұрын
"Big fights, big dudes, big boobs" is one hell of a quote
@wetsocks2897
Жыл бұрын
Idk how to describe it but tamaki didnt feel very homophobic to me, i think he is just a typical teenager who doesnt know a lot about the lgbt community. Like, hes saying some bad words but he doesnt do it maliciously, he does it because he doesnt know any better/what other words to use (at least thats how i remeber it). Hes not a bad guy or anything. Tho i have to say, that i did not watch the english dub, so maybe that makes a difference. For the kyoya scene...... it was definitly weird but haruhi knew that he wasnt gonna do anything. Like, she knew not to take that seriously, hence her not fighting back at all. Was it still inappropriate? Yes. Yes, it was. And the twins... well its just a show they put on. Definitly weird but theyre not serious and very self aware so i guess it doesnt count (???) The show has its flaws and some thing were just unecessary but i wouldnt say its 🌟problematic🌟 But maybe thats just my enby ass defeding my comfort anime
@rosedotmov
Жыл бұрын
Yea that’s defo fair. I mainly addressed it with the English dub’s Tamaki cause it seems like he is straight up vitriolic about the matter compared to the JP version. And the twins I tried my best to not make it the biggest deal cause I knew it was all for show and nothing else. I addressed that cause I’m sure people did interpret their relationship that way. I don’t think the show as a whole is problematic or anything but it has quite a lot of elements that I’m sure many would be uncomfortable with. It’s still in my top 5
@wetsocks2897
Жыл бұрын
@@rosedotmov oh ok then, since i would still recomend this show i guess ill make sure to tell people to just avoid the english dub and to not take it too seriously👌
@rosedotmov
Жыл бұрын
@@wetsocks2897 thats fair! the voice acting i think is still immaculate. i really love the performances but thats on the person. i think the show still has those moments of discomfort either way. i think its on the viewer to determine what version they'd watch
@karatecat1368
Жыл бұрын
Omg I just watched the video and as I scrolled down thinking it was gonna have a few thousand likes, but like only 50!! You did a great job ❤
@rosedotmov
Жыл бұрын
Thank you! Share it around if you feel and who knows.. it could lol
@GenAqua
Жыл бұрын
This was the first anime I watched all the way through in English and Japanese
@astroworfcraig9164
3 ай бұрын
I was in my mid-50s when I bought the Ouran Blu-ray set and thought it might be the most delightfully subversive thing I'd seen. That's probably why I love the twins so much.
@ashlaskash
Жыл бұрын
This is possibly your best video yet, or at the very least up there. I'm very impressed with the sincerity and quality and knowledge on display, and will definitely prioritize trying OHSHC, which has been on my planning list for... a while. And it was a pleasant surprise to hear that my comment about Kaorin had an impact on you. PS: As a transfem I can't really relate to being a hopeless romantic as a kid, at least not from my memory. However, I think there's a good chance I was just repressing, because I'm fonder of the romance genre now that I, like, let myself enjoy it. PPS: Thoughts on Maria Holic?
@rosedotmov
Жыл бұрын
Thank you very much! Yea that comment did stick with me lmao especially making the video lmao! Also I’ve never heard of Maria Holic
@ashlaskash
Жыл бұрын
@@rosedotmov Yeah, when you mentioned the T-slur being used in the OHSHC dub, it just reminded me of the one use of that slur in the Maria Holic dub, and how it almost made me do a spit take. But I did honestly really enjoy Maria Holic and would like to rewatch it some time. It's essentially about a huge lesbian named Kanako who breaks out into hives if she touches a boy. She ends up living in a dorm with the titular Maria, who is what else but a boy who's essentially half-forced to live as a girl. Antics ensue.
@RoweReviews
Жыл бұрын
That was quite the video, rose. Probably your best in terms of presentation and writing. I have little to say about the subject, but it was interesting. In terms of weirder media, I've seen a lot of people who cant get behind Weezer's Pinkerton cuz of the lyrics. I know haha weezer but I find the raw lyrics to be a benefit. Cuz your right, stuff that explores the human psyche is bound to get uncomfortable sometimes, but its not a bad thing.
@zahrahd_
7 ай бұрын
I watched this anime when I was like 9-10 and it quite literally changed the course of my life. It's still my favourite anime of all time and I'm in my mid 20's now. Hearing your take on this idk made my heart feel kind of warm? Just goes to show how much the manga and anime holds up, outside of its obvious issues. The beach episode always strikes me weird bc the more I rewatch the more it feels like a way to show that Haruhi is too used to taking care of herself and that she needs to understand she can rely on other people but written and played out in a way that REALLY missed the mark especially with how the rest of the club treats Haruhi after the incident and going in on pointing out her gender lol. Also the issues with Tamaki hoenstly just read like a dumb, ignorant teenager who puts on the act of a womanizer for his club lmao - leave the wasian king alone sdfjkdfgjkdfj Either way, loved watching this! Also highkey the way I loved Haruhi so intensely was such a precursor for me realizing I'm non-binary lmaooooo
@rosedotmov
7 ай бұрын
i'm really glad i did that for ya.. i tried my best to defend tamaki otherwise cause on the inside he's a sweetheart lol
@MinaTheAlien1
5 ай бұрын
ngl this is one of the best review vid I have seen
@rosedotmov
5 ай бұрын
thank you a ton!
@gesundheitlads5599
Жыл бұрын
man i love ohshc
@rosedotmov
Жыл бұрын
Yo same??
@JeayK
Жыл бұрын
Heyyy I love your video! I just wanted to say that the beach episode is pretty different from the manga and since you seem to really enjoy the anime I would suggest you check it out (in many ways the “beach dilemma” is resolved much better)
@rosedotmov
Жыл бұрын
I really should check it out! I defo will after I finish some of the other ones I’ve been meaning to collect
Пікірлер: 30