@@sjpanfengcustomer service 多數都有三千只要spm.bukit bintang,pudu,chow kit這些市中心區有不少四層樓的flat,屋齡有30-50年,面積1000-2000sf freehold,10多20萬。你講外勞多,大把30-50萬的700-1300sf的公寓不但離市中心半個小時車程,遠離lrt MRT,而且外勞也很多。是你們自己看不上市中心便宜的四層樓flat,偏偏要偏遠又死貴的condo
@nikkikhooniqi
8 ай бұрын
13 years ago, as a Singaporean, I shared with people that I stayed in a public housing and I was confused with the way people reacted to it. Now I know, public housing elsewhere is nothing like Singapore. I’m blessed.
@DJYinxHiLighter
8 ай бұрын
🥲 It’s weird isn’t it? Right become wrong, wrong become right?
@weikwenju5261
8 ай бұрын
@@DJYinxHiLighter Because of different landscape within SG and MY. SG is modern and advanced country by science based management. MY is full of ideology and any how do pattern. After 30 years, a different landscape is there. Today SGD 1 = Rigit 3.51
@Buttercookies0
8 ай бұрын
Some even called them social housing. Our public housing is truly different from other countries' public housing. In other countries, the public housing is usually for the poorer citizens. But in SG, once you know the value of the public housing, you know that is not true.
我自己住landed的啦~工作后有去过朋友租的人民组屋。环境真的oh my god... 还电梯坏掉~ 后面听过新加坡工作的朋友也说新加坡hdb真的还不错,环境、公共设施交通和保养都有做到位。希望倪可敏和陆兆福可以和安华商量这些规划希望以后马来西亚的城市规划会越来越好~加油!期待可以有part 2~
@DJYinxHiLighter
8 ай бұрын
公屋part 2就要說得更細了~~ 可能講都市更新與重建?
@goggles7777
8 ай бұрын
倪可敏? 口沫横飞厉害!做不了事的
@Y3llow_Submarin3
8 ай бұрын
actually flats got a few types, those over 30 years are only 5 floors. more spacious and not as bad compared to those high rise flat with lifts. No parking issue here too. It all depends on the people. When I was young all are majority are chinese because it's a Chinese taman, got Malay & Indian also then slowly, they have more money and rent out the unit, when foreign workers come they for sure make it messy, and they sell things anyhow they like. You look at happy mansion PJ, still well maintained, clean.
@yonghao9125
8 ай бұрын
现在新的很漂亮了,有一马clinic其他公寓的东西都有,就差游泳池1200sqf 320k😂
@pineappleloverify
8 ай бұрын
内容精采,主持人功力超级棒, 加油。 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
@peipei6319
8 ай бұрын
馬來西亞能夠把公屋住成這樣,主要是人民素質,特別是“主要人口”的素質😞
@hong9537
8 ай бұрын
???
@eateveryone
8 ай бұрын
也就是华人的素质
@818y7
8 ай бұрын
????
@chingqh
8 ай бұрын
我觉得这就回归到教育问题了
@peipei6319
8 ай бұрын
@@chingqh 固然最根本在教育,特別是家教。
@melvintan6231
8 ай бұрын
我住punggol 4 room HDB, 住了8年,今年重新油漆,又乾乾淨淨了🎉
@DJYinxHiLighter
8 ай бұрын
小編表示 曾經住過punggol hdb幾天~
@davidtang5986
8 ай бұрын
Good job 👍 Very informative and interesting 👍 Thanks 👍❤
@@DJYinxHiLightergoogle 一下 Singapore long island 就可以看到一些资讯
@kktan7206
8 ай бұрын
Singaporeans in their lifetime have two chances to apply for a brand-new HDB flat. Many have stayed in their original flat for many years and sold in the open market for a good profit before buying a second new flat and starting the 99-year cycle again. You may want to consider a topic on Singapore's public hospital today. You will be amazed by the layout and facilities.
@DJYinxHiLighter
8 ай бұрын
Thank you for your suggestion. Maybe we can compare the medical system of Singapore and Malaysia too!
This is the exact problem with public housing in the US and in other ASEAN countries nowadays - they're usually built far from downtown areas, which means people relocated there will also be far from work opportunities. With shitty public transportation networks, people will be forced to simply leave and go back to the city.
One of the photos that you have shown with bridges linkage between HDB flats at Chinatown is built by a couple from Penang with an award naming. So ministers also required good architects and engineers to plan an estate.
@DJYinxHiLighter
8 ай бұрын
you mean The pinnacle?
@alexlim4508
8 ай бұрын
Correct. Your research was very well done. HDB uses technology to model air breeze circulation in their new flats besides using digital flat screen panels as their notice board. Your team should make a trip over there to see and video the new development. 🎉
Very impressed with this video, espeically the amount of research. I also love how you inject some old memories like "TVB de B ah". I would say that Singapore is also have been downsizing their HBD with the newer HBD units only have 63m sq per units for a 3 room(3 room means only 2 bedroom) flat. The government would also announced mega projects for 10-50years ahead for the whole country so you would know how the landscape would changes over time and may eye on potential HBD new BTO(Build To Order). Yet, as you may also know that Singapore is really attracting a lot of wealth to flow into Singapore especially these few years, the property market is just getting out of control. There are more and more cases whereby the HBD flats are selling for over 1million SGD. Even now a 4 room BTO(new HBD, 3 bedroom,~95 m sq) at a mature estate can cost $650k SGD.
@DJYinxHiLighter
8 ай бұрын
Thank you for your support! We need to reduce some info due to the limitation of video length🤣 Actually the way Singapore announces mega infra 10-50years ahead is the best way to develop the country. At least all of us know what gonna happen first, so that we all can adapt to that plan.
I grow up in a 3rm HDB flat with my grandparents, parents, an uncle, a older sister and a older brother. That 5 grown up and 3 children living in flat with 2 bedrooms, 1 living room and kitchen/dinning room. All the "children" sleep on thin mattresses lay out on the floor in their parents bedroom. So my uncle between the age 16 to early 20s slept in the same bedroom as my grandparents, while my siblings and me slept with my parents in the other bedroom. And the mattresses will be folded up and kept under the beds during the morning. Mealtime is split into 2 with us children eating first and the grown up including my uncle will eat after we finish since the table cannot fit in so many people at the same time. Now most families are only around 2 to 5 people living in a 3rm to 4rm flat and they complaint about the lack of private space 😓
@DJYinxHiLighter
8 ай бұрын
Never thought Singapore had this phase! I think newer generation will have higher expectation😅
@EJUser-kp2oe
5 ай бұрын
建议新的公屋可以和时代接轨, 比如可以把方便接收外卖食物纳入设计考量,还有收快递等等
@DJYinxHiLighter
5 ай бұрын
這個建議太好了!馬來西亞各州的公屋真的不該繼續用最minimum的設計。
@tobynagreanu
8 ай бұрын
Error: HDB does not hold jurisdiction under urban planning, it's URA (Urban Redevelopment Authority) that does urban planning in Singapore
@DJYinxHiLighter
8 ай бұрын
Thanks for reminding! Actually we are saying the public housing/HDB in Singapore was built with good city planning, not saying HDB plan it.
多講一樣香港公屋的東西,那就是申請資格。香港單人申請的最高收入大概是 12K,但是拿這個錢肯定不夠在香港生活,所以現在一份月薪 Full time 是不可能開這種工錢,更不要講隨時要等個30年以上,有些人帶賽點的真的到死都分不到公屋。雖然 limit 會隨著申請家庭人數增加,但是這個收入是不會 guarantee 任何生活品質,在外面繳完房租水電也不會剩多少。這也變相讓香港的公屋變成社會底層聚集的地方,因為政府從制度上就區分了窮人和中產居住的地方。屋邨雖然稱不上貧民窟,可是治安確實比較差,生活環境根本比不了新加坡的 HDB。如果說當年香港的公屋是模範生,現在來看真是莫大的諷刺。
No comparison, nothing in this world compares to Singapore from what I know in terms of public housing. Not even if you narrow that down to only a city. Nothing compares well.
@DJYinxHiLighter
8 ай бұрын
Singapore set the bar too high~
@limbehh8494
8 ай бұрын
@DJYinxHiLighter MY is blessed to have this talented n knowledgeable gal like you. Greeting from a Singaporean. 😊
@cminghan
8 ай бұрын
You must goto those low cost flat for once , sometime it’s the resident discipline , better education level also play very important raw
The job of the government, as far as public housing is concerned, is to provide accomodation and not ownership. For example, all people at bus stops definitely would like to own a Mercedes sedan rather than to take a Mercedes bus. Definitely, the government just does not have that sort of finance to burn. Now, the major difference between Hong Kong and Singapore lies with this fundamental difference. Majority of public housing in Hong Kong are in the form of rental flats rather than ownership, though it does have small amount of ownership flats. It is the government's strategy that if you want to improve your livelihood, you must rely upon your own efforts, that is public housing on rental basis is not going to be upgraded in quality, and you must move onto private housing if you have the means. In fact, the rental collected by the government hardly enough to pay for the maintenances, as such public housing is a big drain of the public finance. Even in early 90s, the government want to offer public housing on rental basis up for sales to their existing tenants, but not enough people want to take up. And at the same time, public housing on ownership basis, are not appealing to people. Why not I go for fully private property, an upgrade not just in quality but also status. If I tell you I stay in mid levels, the rest just go untold. Now, let us look at Singapore, most of its public housing are in the form of ownership basis (HDB, HUDC, BTO, DBSS and EC all the way), some of the finance come from the retirement savings (CPF), thus less strain on the government. Like Hong Kong, if you want to stand out, please work hard and buy private property to upgrade. There is nothing Hong Kong government can do to match with Singapore, as it is not a lame duck government. Even if all these public housing on rental basis are going to give free to existing tenants, not many people would take them up, as rental payments are cheaper than even maintenances, no mortgage instalments as the flats are given free. And the government just cannot impose and dump the flats, though free on existing tenants. I am a naturalized Singaporean from Hong Kong, so I understand the policies of these two governments. I stayed in a very small private flat of 370 sf nett, in a family of 5, and even in the most hardship time, we rent two rooms out, so a total of 11 people in the nano flat. Now, this flat is worth SGD2 million, yes two million Singapore dollars, as my parent flat is on a lease of 999 years, since Hong Kong was given to the British - in fact, most flats in Hong Kong hardly have more than 20 years to run, and some of them might even have expired, and pay lease on a annual basis. In general, I uphold the Singapore model of public housing, though I am a liberal and still believe that the government's job is to provide accomodation and not ownership. I have never lived in any public housing, and I believe, and have seen on longer term basis, private housing payoffs much - in fact, most of the retirement savings of people are in the form of property.
@DJYinxHiLighter
8 ай бұрын
Thanks for your great comment again! Rent or own a property is another great issue to discuss about, especially many youngsters can’t really afford any houses in the major city. Property market in Hong Kong is really a tough problem. Perhaps Europe countries like Sweden is a good example for all of us? However we face different situation in different countries.
Пікірлер: 510