Hello! Sorry if your comments were deleted! We had to reupload the video a couple of times to fix some editing mistakes. To everyone who left a comment early: Thank you, I took screenshots of them and I'll keep them very close to my heart, they were all very flattering :)
@Pavel_ivanovich__batov
14 күн бұрын
This series was started when i was in grade 9 and its now ending when i am grade 11 needless to say i still remained enthusiastic about history as before but with less fat and more stress
@RavignonCh
14 күн бұрын
@@Pavel_ivanovich__batov hope your graduation goes great, it's closer than you might think! More than perfect grades, I suggest you get as much closure as you can ^^
@Inmediostatvirtu
13 күн бұрын
« I still remain enthousiastic about history as before but with less fat and more stress ». 😂 You got me there ! That could summarized my last 15 years haha. Good news, you might be able to reduce your stress like I did at some point. Bad news, you might get fat again in twenty years…
@Pavel_ivanovich__batov
13 күн бұрын
@@Inmediostatvirtu same I think if got muscles I will never be fat again
@chrismoore7365
12 күн бұрын
@@RavignonCh Hi, I know this is a big ask, but would it be possible for you to make a video(s) about the history of French communities in Canada that are outside of Quebec? (in the possible future) Thanks.
@Game_Hero
6 күн бұрын
@@Pavel_ivanovich__batov wait til you become old, it'll come :)
@IAmWarden.
13 күн бұрын
As an Ontarian this series has been incredibly enlightening. I thank you wholeheartedly for this series and I know when I get sad about the current state of Canada I will come back to this series to relearn what makes us *All* a great little people. ❤
@Game_Hero
4 күн бұрын
*nations, you canadians and us Québécois
@beacebrocess
13 күн бұрын
So happy to see you finish this behemoth of a project!
@lot3oo
13 күн бұрын
You're a god. You deserve way more views. The history of Québec is so rich and complex yet you manage to distill it for english viewers. Amazing. One problem I think we have with history in Quebec is that we only teach it in French, then we wonder why no one understands us. Glad you're making it in english.
@RavignonCh
13 күн бұрын
Thank you hahaha, I hope this series has proved you don't need a huge 100k+ channel to create something in this league of content ^^ if you want to help me with the views, please share the video! It helps more than you may think :)
@PatrioteQuebecois
12 күн бұрын
Well it is not the same version that is being thaught in French. You have access to much more content if you understand French. Just like most content on American history is only available in English.
@shorgoth
13 күн бұрын
My grand father was arrested during the FLQ crisis... he was a play director and a university French teacher and no links with the FLQ. Thank you for this, as a native French speaker (now bilingual) from Quebec I found your video to be well-researched and nuanced, something we rarely see. My family older generations was quite hardcore in the independance movement. It was definetly trauma related. My generation doesn't have the same desire, we recognize the past but also recognize the gradual but constant efforts from the rest of the country to fix mistakes. Combined with the effect of the Internet on culture locally we don't feel alienated like our parents felt. To be fair to them yes, French speakers were treated as second-class citizens, hell racism against French speaker isn't dead, I meet it myself often enough on the web. The main issue I think is the lack of nuance and ignorance about Quebec's history, politic and linguistic real-world challenges. And yes, there are definetly racists in Quebec as well and they are an issue. Luckily they don't become physically violent as often as in most places. Racism in Quebec tend to be more often born from fear of erasure and cultural irrelevance than outright hatred. Most of them usually don't hate other ethnicities, they just prefer them elsewhere as they feel their language slipping but still see immigrants as normal folks, just at the wrong place due to French demographic weakness. They are often more scared by the English language than skin colour or ethnicity or even other languages. To be perfectly clear I still find these behaviours problematic, but I prefet that over the form it takes in the USA as an example.
@PatrioteQuebecois
12 күн бұрын
My grandfather was arrested too in 1970 and, as a civil engineer with nothing to do with FLQ, it has to be highlighted that the War measure act had nothing to do with protecting people, but was rather a mean to manipulate the people of Quebec into thinking that there was a threat to them, just like most dictatorships do. Besides, I don't agree with your POV on racism in Quebec. I think you blend two completely different things that have nothing in common into one : the fear of having your culture disappear and the hate of others because of their origin. These are completely unrelated and if you confuse them, you harm yourself into not understanding. So, the hate of others and the belief that some race are superior to others DO exist in Quebec, very unfortunately, just as in other places in the world and it is really racism. It emerges in places of power and coercion. In fact it is inseparable from it. But, as you mention, it is less common in Quebec than in other places like in the USA and the rest of Canada and there are reasons for that : the structure of our economy, with high level of productivity relying on higher education and the institutions we have built during the quiet revolution to create a reliable and universa access to public services are in to diminish considerably the potential for racism, but the job is not yet completed. As for the fear of having your culture disappear, it is so widespread across all ages, genders, income level and levels of education that it is safe to assume it is a cultural trait of Quebeckers and those who don't have it are outliers. It is reinforced by our education system, media and literature. It is a defining feature of our identity. But again : this fear has absolutely nothing to do with racism because racism is the belief system which divides our humanity into races entitling superiority to a race. This entitlement comes from a power dynamic that is a legacy of colonialism. In the South of the USA, there were 9 million slaves for 15 million free people whose vast majority where Whites. There were no good white or bad white : everybody was a complicit of this system. In comparison, there were 129 slaves in New France for 100 000 people who ever lived under the French regime and the British added a further 4000 slaves in all of Canada until they abolished slavery in the late 1830s. The scale simply doesn't compare. The Whites of the Southern USA must take into account that they inherited this system of injustice that continues to this day in shear police brutality, private prisons and racist rallies that some orange man encourage. Their fear of disappearing is akin to their fear of losing their continuing privileges. While we, in Quebec, we derive no privilege at all from saving our culture from assimilation into anglo speaking north america. It is quite the opposite in fact. The power dynamic is against us. This fear is very tangible and has nothing to do with racism. Merci beaucoup !
@tommyjames3105
10 күн бұрын
Beaucoup d'amour de L'Ontario. Nous sommes des frères et des soeurs, même si nous avons des histoires, des nations et des langues différentes.
@PatrioteQuebecois
10 күн бұрын
@@tommyjames3105 Tous les humains sont de ma race. Nous serons toujours voisins, autant mieux s'entendre.
@shorgoth
8 күн бұрын
@@PatrioteQuebecois I appreciate some of your nuances and I agree with most, but a major one. This fear has something to do with racism. While it is a justified fear to a degree (I'll explain later why it isn't as you perceive it to be though), it is a precursor to racist behaviours and beliefs. The timescale people imagine these societal shift is distorted, they see this as something that will happen in the next 10 years, it's a gradual shift they won't be living, it's a slow decline... thing is, this is actually more a transition than a decline, this isn't an extinction event, descendants of these people will still exist, it's the language and culture that shifts and that is unavoidable. Look at the difference between each generations beliefs, ways of speaking, values, experiences, at all times in history we have seen transitions from one language to the next, we don't speak Latin anymore, or Celtic languages. We have this great fear that we will be thrown at sea in English as if falling off a boat or a cliff and reality isn't like that, it's transitory, gradual. Language is a living thing, once you stop adapting you stop having a language that reflects your reality. All those fears are based. Add to that the fact that we now have live options for translation, the decline of French doesn,t have the practical issues it used to have in the past. Now you can just whip out your phone and hold a conversation with someone. That fear ultimately is not based on rational observations on an individual scale it's based on emotions and it denies the desires of the next generation to integrate to the wider world. This is an unavoidable trend, it always was like that historically, put people into direct contact and the tend to trade language until they meld it together into a new one. This time won't be different, except this time it's the Internet bridging the globe. We have more in common with people from our generation in other occidental and some asian countries than we do with the older genration of our own nation for the most part. Culture is melding. Now all that said, I do think it's a good thing to keep somewhat of a distinct identity from the rest of Canada, diversity has its advantages in a push and pull of ideas. Homogenous populations tend to fail in crisis and we don't want it all to be a grey goo paste. Diversity breeds creativity. En passant j'utilise l'anglais pour que d'autres puissent suivre la conversation : )
@PatrioteQuebecois
7 күн бұрын
@@shorgoth Oui je comprends. However, I see many shortcomings in your argumentation. Assertions like "Homogenous populations tend to fail in crisis and we don't want it all to be a grey goo paste. Diversity breeds creativity." are unproven. While some homogenous populations like Somalia, Lesotho or Albania have major economical difficulties like China that is also very homogenous due to Han being so numerous, the majority of homogenous countries like Finland, Japan, South Korea and Iceland are striving while the most heterogenous countries like the USA and Brazil have major issues rightly caused by their heterogeneity. So, no, heterogeneity is not advantage per se. Also, you are too optimistic about the benefits of Internet. The languages that English kills through US imperialism are accelerating. It has no comparision to the decline of Latin which occured over the span of 1000 years. The cases of Louisiana, Missouri, Ontario, Manitoba, Acadia and so on show that a common language disappears in the span of only one generation. Every single risk factor apply to Quebec as well. So the fear is not only totally justified, but well documented. Only people can choose to ignore the problem and IRCC makes the problem worse by fooling immigrants about our very existence and demands. Also, the spread of English around the world goes along with racism through very misnomed "free trade" as an imperialist tool which is in reality economic conquest. There exist a lingua franca designed to be neutral and would do tremendous benefits to the entire world by slowing down imperialism: if esperanto was used as a global auxiliary language, not only would it be much easier to learn than English (I'm almost fluent in it after only 4 weeks of study), but it would be a tool against racism and imperialism.
@goldengolem4725
12 күн бұрын
As an Ontarian, this video series has helped me quite massively in learning Québecois history. Thanks.
@billybob-ts5cg
13 күн бұрын
Congratz on finishing the series! This whole thing was genuinely better than 99% of the documentaries/essays about Québec and it's people (including the ones made by Québécois).
@RavignonCh
13 күн бұрын
Very humbling to hear that, thank you!
@faerieprincess1232
13 күн бұрын
When this series started, I had not yet moved to Québec. I have lived here now for three years and one month exactly (37 months). Let me tell you, sovereigntism is not dead. It is being mobilized against the Liberal status quo again, just as in times past. We’ll see how the ball rolls from here.
@communistcuphead2901
13 күн бұрын
How's working at Tim's my friend?
@Jmanthegamer
12 күн бұрын
I live in Quebec too and I don’t know how common sovereignism is, or how many people actually believe in it or want to revive it as a political project. That said, it feels as though if a referendum just dropped from the sky it would be a close call. The French speaking working class who feel alienated from policy (a sentiment felt across the west), especially immigration policy, would certainly vote in favour. The business class almost certainly wouldn’t but they are comfortable with the current CAQ compromise. However, the political discourse certainly has an undertone of « give us what we want or maybe we’ll do this dance one more time ».
@medenos9683
12 күн бұрын
@@Jmanthegamer I mean having what we want was kinda what was promised to the «Non» voters so I guess it's a loop that won't end. Sadly I feel we'll either have our independence or totally assimilate. I recon there's not that many other possible ends to this cycle.
@samueljourneault7507
13 күн бұрын
Your videos on Quebec are the best I have seen for English content. But I must correct two fairly important errors, Parizeau did not resign because of the scandal of his speech, a few hours before the vote he had already confided to a journalist his intention to resign in the event of defeat. Also this sentence was talking about French speakers and not French Canadians, he explained in the previous sentence, but it is more of a secondary error. The second error is that Québec solidaire is not regionalist or autonomist but is totally in favour of independence and even if they are not the greatest promoters it is an important part of their programme. Apart from that and a few unimportant errors (like kfc which was already called pfk before law 101) your video is very precise. Good job for this series. Also: Currently, Quebec has a similar rate of independent voters to just a few months before the 1995 referendum and the Quebec Party is largely first in voting intentions, nothing is decided for the future of Quebec.
@walshwil
9 күн бұрын
In response to your additional info, who else are we to support? The corrupt liberals who want to cut on public spending during a recession, the controversial Quebec Solidaire who dream bigger than our coffers or the CAQ, a generally incompetent party (not counting covid, that was an unfortunate turn of events) who is basically a non sovereignist version of the PQ. The PQ was on the verge of death as the CAQ was riding an all time high. Now that they are crashing, it's obvious that the party that has the most similar promises will get back their shared pool of votes
@InquisitorXarius
13 күн бұрын
Congrats on finishing the series on Quebec, Ravignon, I will be waiting with open arms for your next big countryball history project.
@dukenukem9450
13 күн бұрын
Québec Freedom 😍 thank you for this Ravignon
@Mercure250
10 күн бұрын
Quel travail extraordinaire! When I found your very first video on my home land, I was thinking basically the same thing. Ever since, I looked forward to every installment, and they were never a disappointment. I do not regret a single cent that I have sent your way to make this project, and I absolutely look forward to your future projects as well, relating to Quebec or not. I really hope that a lot of English speakers will find this series and learn about our history, and have a more educated view of our current challenges. I want them to sympathize a bit with this identity that we have built, as I tire of Quebec-bashing. We are a complex people worthy of understanding, even if we sometimes get carried away into problematic ideas (on that note, definitely looking forward to when you talk about the issue of Islamophobia). There are ways to criticize a society while being respectful of it, and I hope more people understand that in parts thanks to this amazing series.
@RavignonCh
10 күн бұрын
Thank you for all your support over the years ^^
@TheNmecod
13 күн бұрын
best english content for Québec history by far (and i attended english elementary school and high school in Québec). thank you so much for this series! Vive le Québec libre
@TommyCrosby
12 күн бұрын
KZitem just recommended me this video (and I watched all the series before watching it) and as a Quebecer, I'm really shocked by the deepness of the coverage of our own story by a Mexican nonethelessless. ¡Felicitaciones por tu buen trabajo!
@SVK91
12 күн бұрын
Ahhh... the bitter dream of my non-existent country. I'm in my early 30s and I have little hope of ever seeing a free Québec, yet I will never integrate "Canadian" into my personal identity. I will always introduce myself as a Québécois, even and especially when visiting abroad. When I need to explain what "that" is, I avoid the term "province" like it’s a dirty word and skip any mention of Canada altogether; I simply say something like, "oh, we’re that weird French-speaking bit of North America." I will continue to do so for the rest of my life, because people almost never press me to explain which part of North America that "bit" is located in... and when they do ask or say "oh so you're from Canada", I get to talk about history with them! Merci pour les vidéos Ravignon, chacune d'entre elles a été une revisite de notre histoire fascinante et enrichissante!
@PatrioteQuebecois
11 күн бұрын
Si on fait tous ça, le reste du monde ne nous ignorera plus jamais!
@SVK91
11 күн бұрын
@@PatrioteQuebecoisSi seulement, hein! (Cette phrase-là pourrait remplacer le "je me souviens" sur nos plaques d'immatriculation)
@PatrioteQuebecois
11 күн бұрын
@@robertmoray988 J'ai été viré 3 fois dans les 3 dernières années, à chaque fois à cause d'une compagnie qui appliquait des politiques EDI ou recevant des subventions du fédéral. Comment veux-tu que moi, un homme début trentaine en bonne santé avec une maîtrise en ingénierie, 4 ans d'expérience et parlant 4 langues, puisse vouloir des enfants dans un avenir proche si je ne peux même pas avoir une job payante dès aujourd'hui dans mon domaine? Si je dois déménager, je ne pourrai pas me payer loyer. Je trouve votre commentaire assez banal de blâmer les jeunes pour ne pas avoir d'enfant. On devrait plutôt avoir une solidarité intergénérationnelle à toute épreuve.
@naptime6274
11 күн бұрын
Pretty much the same for me, and i even tried to feel "Canadian", since i was too young in the referendum to even understand what it was all about, but something inside of me just can't... I have no hatred for Canadians, but at the end of the day my loyalty is to Québec and always will be, I have kids so i wonder if they will feel the same way i do. I think even if we "failed" on the referendum, we are still building that Québec inside of Canada and considering where we are now compared to where my grand parents were, and how we compare to the rest of the world, i can say that as a people we still won, maybe just in a less obvious way.
@SVK91
10 күн бұрын
I'm glad to read your answer and honestly wish I shared your optimism! I want to clarify that I'm super cool with people themselves; I don't care if they are from the RoC as long as they aren't close minded. But to me just the name "Canada" and everything related to the federal government is a potent aversive stimulus, meaning that I feel a spontaneous negative affect every time I notice their flag somewhere in my surroundings or hear the name... it's just like spotting a spider that you can't remove in the corner of a room and never getting used to its presence. It's also a very "useless" drain on my psychic energy in general, but whatever I'm a full time tormented soul anyway. But still, in my eyes, Canada is a post colonial petrostate and a fiscal paradise for mining corporations, not much else. Oh and there's also the "Indian Law" from 1867 that's still in their constitution, which we like to forget about entirely... like, some communities of indigenous people in contemporary Canada don't even have access to running water, and to this day they are still being treated *by law* as second class citizens, with less rights than the rest of us. Ottawa as a so-called bastion of liberal and multicultural democracy isn't really ever going to reform that issue, is it? Because most people don't care and re-opening that nasty constitution would be a political nightmare for any government, if not potentially an existential threat to the federal state itself, so I guess there's not much room for hope, at least not in our current political context. Things are relatively stable as they are now, despite the rest of the world rapidly getting crazier around us, but their constitution does allow for a wide array of aggressive political repression to preserve the status quo, if we ever get too unruly again. This is demonstrated by the stolen referendum, the October crisis and both conscription crisis during WW1 and WW2, but also by every single political event since at least 1867. I'm afraid there's no real national identity, justice or democracy here whatsoever to cling on to, Canada is actually all about power and money... but to be fair all states and hierarchical organizations work like that, including Québec as a state, the rest around the power structure is pure aesthetics. I rest my case here, but look up "Noir Canada" by Alain Denault and how his book got censored by the supreme court itself for accusing Canadian mining companies of crimes abroad. He's the guy who started talking to the media about fiscal paradises like 20 years ago, by the way (and we're nowhere close to solving that issue either). Basically the supreme court ruled to protect the interests of some mining corporations registered in "our" beautiful country, while those companies were operating in Africa and demonstrably committing serious crimes there (and also not paying taxes anywhere)... It just happens that the entire thing is perfectly legal, while "defaming the reputation of a company" isn't, so the book got banned from literally being published (you can still find copies though and Denault published a "legally safe" version of it later). Vraiment désolé de me laisser emporter comme ça et d'avoir écrit une super longue réponse hyper pessimiste, mais bon. :)
@ursulcx299
13 күн бұрын
Something to note about Parizeau's speech in 1995, the "Ethnical vote" was aimed at the Federal Governement speeding up the immigration process for multiple new arrival that were in favour of the "no", making them eligible for the referendum when they normally wouldn't have been
@PatrioteQuebecois
12 күн бұрын
It's convenient to forget that.
@MrParker1115
12 күн бұрын
It's convenient that you've cloaked a very clear dog whistle into a technical argument about eligibility to vote.
@PatrioteQuebecois
12 күн бұрын
@@MrParker1115 what dog whistle? Speaking about separatists when clearly you just viscerally hate French people for us wanting freedom!
@Mercure250
10 күн бұрын
@@MrParker1115 Dog whistle? At this point, it's a normal whistle. But it's undeniable that there were a lot of sus things that the federal did to make sure the "No" won. Does it excuse Parizeau's words? Fuck no, not in a million years, even if we are charitable with our interpretation, the way he said it was basically the most inappropriate way it could be said, and I can't blame people who think Parizeau was racist because of that. And I'm not even going to disprove that he was, from a lack of interest on my end. I just don't want it to be a reason for people to say "People who want Quebec's independence are racists". Are there racists among them? Sure. But please, do not overgeneralize.
@MrParker1115
10 күн бұрын
@@Mercure250 I didn't say any of that. You interpreted it that way, and it sounds like you know what the problem is. The idea that the yes vote was sabotaged by immigration is inherently xenophobic; voting for independence isn't.
@E2000-o1n
13 күн бұрын
If nothing else Quebec being a more reasonable regional minority but local majority than Israel is right now.
@WanukeX
13 күн бұрын
Actually had a good chuckle when you called the Money and the ethnic vote comment “Parizeau’s Gamer Moment”.
@medenos9683
12 күн бұрын
Fuckin' same XD
@erikgustafson9319
13 күн бұрын
This is the Cherry on top to wrap up my birthday weekend
@InquisitorXarius
13 күн бұрын
Happy Birthday!!!
@erikgustafson9319
13 күн бұрын
@@InquisitorXarius thank you
@lot3oo
13 күн бұрын
Joined because your 3 part series on Quebec rocks. If you come by Montreal, I'll buy you a beer for sure
@Alucard666QC
13 күн бұрын
Been watching since the first video! Can't wait to see the end of this great project. Merci de partager ta vision externe sur l'histoire de la belle province ! :)
@pockethedge
13 күн бұрын
Small mistake in the numbers about the Polytechnique Montreal massacre. 14 women were killed, and 13 were injured (9 women, 4 men) rather than the 15 and 14 numbers mentioned in the video. Amazing video series. ❤ Félicitation pour cette belle finale!
@RavignonCh
13 күн бұрын
Thank you for the correction!
@kevincronk7981
10 күн бұрын
If you do more long series with a significant amount of time between episodes like this, I would appreciate a bit of a reminder of what happened laat episode at the start. This series took 3 years to complete, people are going to forget some of the things from previous parts, or just need to be reminded to jog their memories
@medenos9683
13 күн бұрын
One day my people will finally have its country. One day I hope we'll help our first nation friends achieve the same. Vive la liberté Vive l'indépendance, celles de tous les peuples du monde qui pourront, un jour, se voir grandir sans les chaînes de leurs oppresseurs.
@communistcuphead2901
13 күн бұрын
I don't think Quebecois want independence anymore especially youngsters, I had a Quebecois roomie recently and he mentioned that the youngest are speaking more and more English because of KZitem and the internet
@Habebandebardown
13 күн бұрын
@@communistcuphead2901it depends tbh, the youngster were never faced with a true debate on the question, you have to be in your late 40s to have voted in 1995, we would really know if the question is put forward again. Like if the PQ can put independance in a way to eleviate the troubles faced by younger generation the scale could change. Food for thought
@communistcuphead2901
13 күн бұрын
@Habebandebardown this is 109% my own opinion and I'm not Quebecois, I hail from the humble province of Manitoba, but I would hate for Quebec to become independent, all of a sudden Canada would be incomplete and one of the things that makes us unique would be gone, not to mention the logistical nightmare that would be governing the Maritimes
@Habebandebardown
13 күн бұрын
@@communistcuphead2901 tbh the only real issue i see is the military, with the north, idk man americans go by BC to go to alaska i cant see why it would be a problem for the maritimes. Anyway respect to Manitoba my favorite province
@communistcuphead2901
13 күн бұрын
@@Habebandebardown tis the best province after all
@octocube3607
12 күн бұрын
Oh wow I didn’t know you weren’t quebecois, you know so much about it. Loves the series!!!
@historyhayden
12 күн бұрын
As someone from the East Cost I've really enjoyed learning about Quebec, I got to learn more about a part of the continent I call home and I can't wait to see what happens next on your channel, keep up the good work!
@sambarocas
13 күн бұрын
So awesome. Saga of epic proportions to be remembered for generations
@vinpap779
13 күн бұрын
Fun fact : The night where the Premiers got together and signed the constitution without Quebec is referred as the "Kitchen Accord" in English. In Quebec? We refer it as "La nuit des longs couteaux" or "The night of long knives" As you can see, a massive difference in tone EDIT : GOD DAMN IT!! I SHOULD HAVE WAITED A FEW MORE MINUTES BEFORE COMMENTING!!
@RavignonCh
13 күн бұрын
Comments help in the algorithm LMAO you're good ^^
@jerQCote
9 күн бұрын
Great video! Quick notes 1. One of Levesque self admitted greatest successes was the electoral financing reforms that took a lot of the financial interests the Union National and Liberal Party were known from receiving direct funds out of electoral campaigns. 2. To this day, Québec has never been allowed to open the Constitution in order to sign it. This is why it still lacks legitimacy. 3. The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms was practically a less ambitious copy-paste job of Quebec's preexisting Charter, which remains more ambitious and comprehensive to this day. 3. Parizeau later specified he was blaming leaders among the Greek and Jewish communities, who used their positions of influence to campaign for the No vote in coercive manners. 4. The federal government was found to have committed electoral finance fraud to the extent of half a million dollars in the Chenier commission. The full files regarding the activities of the No campaign are still sealed with the highest federal protections, despite the Quebec National Assembly asking them to be unsealed. It was implied that this half million was just the tip of the Iceberg. 5. Quebec Solidaire is independentist, not autonimist.
@linerider195
3 күн бұрын
Amazing! Glad to see part 3 of this excellent series
@possiblehistory
13 күн бұрын
Incredible work! Congratulations on finally finishing this behemoth of a project - big props on giving an often underexplored subject such broad attention! and hey, we now have the time for that *secret project* to work on, right? ;)
@RavignonCh
12 күн бұрын
Of course ;)
@PatrioteQuebecois
12 күн бұрын
Basically, apart from mistakes other commenters have pointed out, you did a tremendous job and it is even more difficult to be balanced when you can only read sources in English. On the question will Quebec win its independence, most people can't interpret the data properly even in Quebec and among independentists. Current projections are false for the most part. The best way to read and predict how it will evoluate in the next few years is to ask an indirect question that explicit the maximum potential for a yes vote provided that the issue will be discussed everyday in the news which is not the case now. This question is : "Do you think that French can survive as the common language of Quebec if Quebec remains a province of Canada?" The % of no to that question will be almost equal to the maximum the yes can reach in a referendum. The reason this is relevant is that almost certainly nobody will vote yes if they don't think that it is an existential question. As counterintuitive as it might seem, Quebeckers are not caring about what English Canadians think of us when deciding for our own future. Which is not surprising after all because most English Canadians do not care about what Quebecker think when making policies for the whole of Canada. The only people who care about what the majority in Canada think are French speaking minorities outside Quebec. At the same time, an increasing number of Franco-Ontarians change their mind about Quebec and stop grieving about us foreseeing that an independent Quebec will be much more capable of acting as a protector in the Canada without Quebec than in a province where French is increasingly threatened.
@SimonBea1
13 күн бұрын
I really like this series, and was positively surprised by the development on anomism and the drawback to individualist liberalism towards the end.
@RURK_
13 күн бұрын
Best part of the seires, very happy to see you finish this project!!
@whimsicalgrizzlybear5496
10 күн бұрын
Amazing work on this project. I've been subbed since you released part one and am glad to see you finish it strong. As a Canadian (albeit anglo) it was great to see such an in depth look at a topic that usually doesn't get lots of attention. Can't wait to see what the future holds for you!
@mariethe_patate3696
13 күн бұрын
Very good documentary! I remember the 1995 referendum, I was 16 then... The "Yes" campaign was so endearing, and the anglo-canadian manifestation was poorly received by franco-quebecois... The youngsters like me thought the Yes would win (how naive we were... 😂) I saw Parizeau's speech live, my family gasp when he said his racist bit, we all thought it was stupid...
@RavignonCh
13 күн бұрын
I am glad you've enjoyed it! :) I hope this aids future generations to get a glimpse of what it was like to be there in that moment. Independence or not, I wish you and your family freedom and security in these new and challenging times.
@Game_Hero
6 күн бұрын
You were 1% away from victory. The rest was the the Sponsorship scandal weaponizing people to take away our right. You're not naive, you're thirsty for getting what others have and don't regret.
@recnepse7498
12 күн бұрын
I’ve been waiting so long for this one, congrats on taking on and finishing this monstrous project!
@mathieuroussel9422
12 күн бұрын
Superbe vidéo, thank you very much for this series, I remember when I watched the first videos a few years ago and was eagerly waiting for the next ones. Looking forward to your future content.
@excalibrrimcold9354
7 күн бұрын
This was a really good series. I hope someone like you will do a similar video/series on Newfoundland (and Labrador). Newfoundlands story is unique and filled with setbacks and tragedies.
@MONFLYINGSAUCER
12 күн бұрын
Your video on quebec is the best on the internet. You understand our perspective better than 99.99% of english canadians do (even those whom live in Québec). My grand father was nearly arrested in october 70 on his way back to home after uni. No link to the FLQ. One thing about the the shooter on the polytechnique, he was hevely influenced by his father that was a algerian muslim, and very misogibistic.
@benpregent
6 күн бұрын
I was raised in Quebec (close to Meech Lake actually) from a Franco-Ontarian family and now live in PEI and your series has touched me in a special way. Il y a tant de choses que j'aimerais dire, mais pas assez de place ici, mais oui le Québec devrait accueillir la Francophonie du Canana. Il gagnerait énormément. Maybe you should make a part 3.5 with Chrétien's reaction to the referendum and his "marketing" campaign across Canada that lead to the sponsorship program scandal and the defeat of the Liberal goverment and then....
@Flemalt
13 күн бұрын
ngl i waited to watch the whole series until now
@RavignonCh
13 күн бұрын
LMFAO yeah, a lot of people wait for these big products to be done to give them a shot. If you enjoyed it, consider sharing it with others ^^
@ordinal2361
15 күн бұрын
Quebec vs Superman: Dawn of Morbius
@thisisaname3283
12 күн бұрын
Amazing work throughout this whole enterprise. I can't wait to see what you do next
@slowjamsliver7006
4 күн бұрын
I'm from western Canada, while there definitely is some hate for the French language, a lot of it some from a reminder that people don't want to think about knowing French is a clear class divide. There are very little resources in rural areas of the west to attract the talent to teach French. Thus what little there is given to the gifted or the better off, and in some ways I think this is also a reason Western Canada dislikes French. Yes, they claim that it is dumb and demanding, but it is also proof that they didn't have the merit or the wealth which is probably a reason most don't want to bring up.
@emptyhermit7524
13 күн бұрын
Je me souviens Congratulations on finishing this project. But I wonder now, in what ways is the Canadian identity different than the American one? It seems both are liberal projects meant to supersede the national or regional identities
@communistcuphead2901
13 күн бұрын
Our identity is that we are not Americans and that's about it if the Americans go right we go left if they go up we go down
@PatrioteQuebecois
12 күн бұрын
@@communistcuphead2901so strong identity! Mdr!
@Game_Hero
6 күн бұрын
@@communistcuphead2901 you guys got Anne of Green Gables and that's about it that's not Québécois culture, art and figures painted over in red and white.
@valentincontilde
12 күн бұрын
Great finale! years waiting for it, saludos desde Colombia Ravignon!
@hansdupuis8263
13 күн бұрын
Très bonne recherche. Sauf pour l’opinion vers la fin où dans un Québec indépendant les autochtones seraient plus mal traités. Je suis plus positif à se que le Québec se sépare du Canada qui a encore le Indian act. Un Québec indépendant serait mieux pour partir sur une nouvelle façon de traiter avec les autochtones que ces lois archaïques du Canada anglais. Vive le Québec libre !
@FederalisteSeptique
11 күн бұрын
Remember Joyce Echaquan.
@hansdupuis8263
11 күн бұрын
@@FederalisteSeptique un cas isolé de racisme n’est rien comparé à ce qu’un Québec indépendant peut reconstruire comparé au Canada actuel.
@FederalisteSeptique
11 күн бұрын
@@hansdupuis8263 vous appelez un meurtre raciste un cas isolé? Qu'est-ce que le Québec séparer pourrait construire sans l'argent du Canada?
@hansdupuis8263
11 күн бұрын
@@FederalisteSeptique encore ce vieil argument. Le Québec sauverait 84,3 milliards de dollars à ne rien envoyer à Ottawa et le Canada nous donne des cacahuètes en retour. C’est du vol et c’est même pas caché. Nous sommes ceux qui donne le plus et après les gens ce demande pourquoi sommes nous pauvres.
@hansdupuis8263
11 күн бұрын
@@FederalisteSeptique et toute les femmes autochtones tuer ou kidnappé
@vrkmyrdn
14 күн бұрын
Quebec should achieve the independence from India!
@Pavel_ivanovich__batov
14 күн бұрын
@@vrkmyrdn quebec=Puducherry
@chinchillaruby4170
12 күн бұрын
PQ is set to win big in the regional polls at the moment.
@GanyuSimpingDegenerate
13 күн бұрын
Excellent series. If only I had this a few years ago during high school history.
@LakeGameCreepr
13 күн бұрын
Me normally: grr i hate quebec suppression of the english language me when Ravignon uploads: i would give my life for Quebec
@medenos9683
12 күн бұрын
Come live here, learn french and become a Québécois. We have d'la criss de bonne poutine and great microbreweries!
@Miniweet9167
4 күн бұрын
The last time the Canadian French speakers said something about Quebec independence was to beg Quebec to stay while at the time insulting Quebec nationalists. A few years after the last referendum other provinces started cutting French language services elsewhere in the country. There have always been two countries in this country, and they do not live side by side. They live one on top of the other. Period. The French speakers in Canada are now down to 21% of the population. Only Quebec independence will guarantee French culture’s continued prosperity and relevance in North America and by extension the world. . Canadians mostly don’t care about anything the French constituant part of themselves could give them so why continue this sexless marriage? For the children? They all live at their dad’s. Let the forcibly married wife leave and go her own way. I still get told by Anglos That French services outside Quebec are a burden on the state (remember nazi propaganda - Das Ist Auch Dein Geld) and that I speak a bastardized version of French nobody gives a crap about and should just give up and … speak white. Not until I’m the last one left alive.
@enib5989
13 күн бұрын
Brilliant video, but question. Since you are not Canadian yourself where does your interest in Canada come from, aswell as your knowledge on Canadian history and issues?
@RavignonCh
13 күн бұрын
I mostly read a book on Canadian history some years ago and elaborated from there. Just choosing to care about a subject and being open to its information can take you a very long way!
@asepheleleshabalala1352
12 күн бұрын
I've been waiting for this❤
@shijikori
12 күн бұрын
As someone who leans strongly towards socialist policies, more partial to federalism, living in Québec... I think I learned from your video that the root of my views might be in line with those of Pierre Eliott Trudeau. I believe there's been a long way into addressing political and economic inequalities between the Québec french population and the Canada-wide english population. As you concluded, there are still ways to go to make peace. What I learned is that I've grown to view Québec as a part of Canada and I want growth for Canada as a whole. There is work to accomplish to fully realize this view, I hope to see it in my life time.
@RavignonCh
12 күн бұрын
Socialists and Liberals are both rooted in the Enlightenment tradition, so yes ^^ we have more in common with each other than with conservatives.
@PatrioteQuebecois
11 күн бұрын
So your views are to imprison as much people as possible without accusing them of anything, then accuse your political opponents of being racists and fascists without any ground for that and then use self-agrandizing moral arguments that could be used to favor big corporations. Special kind of socialist you are. With love, from a real socialist from Québec who include indigenous people in our struggle for liberty.
@medenos9683
10 күн бұрын
@@PatrioteQuebecois Basé socialiste indépendantiste pour la libération des peuples autochtones > Virgin fédéraliste délusionel "socialiste" qui pense que le néo-libéralisme Canadien est proche de ses valeur. @shijikori je te niaise, mais il faut comprendre que si tu es vraiment socialiste, ce sera les libéraux les premiers à s'écraser face au fachisme. Nous vivons dans un état pétrolier avide d'argent et impérialiste qui supporte activement Israel. L'état Canadien est irréparable sans un bousculement important du Statue Quo. Il nous faut l'indépendance pour nous et pour tout nos amis Canadiens.
@ivanlaplante
13 күн бұрын
You did it Ravi!
@IceFireTerry
13 күн бұрын
Been a long time coming
@stimutac9221
11 күн бұрын
This video is riddled with historical revisionism, misinformation and ideological bias. It is extremely clear that you got all your information from whitewashed anglo sources and you don't really know what you're talking about. How extremely disappointing considering your other videos were pretty good.
@PatrioteQuebecois
6 күн бұрын
You say out loud what I think quietly.
@leifsegeln
13 күн бұрын
so, next spring you are comming over to Quebec for a trip n'est-ce pas ?
@RavignonCh
13 күн бұрын
😂 If I can pay for it, I'd love to.
@medenos9683
13 күн бұрын
@@RavignonCh You should come in 2026, I think it's gonna be an interesting year.
@granyte
11 күн бұрын
@@medenos9683 J'ai hate a date ca as l'air d'une année prometteuse
@terdragontra8900
12 күн бұрын
1:00:17 I haven’t heard someone describe my problem with our modern society so succinctly, I am incredibly disillusioned with every grand narrative I’ve come across, I feel very purposeless, and I don’t have a sense of community at all with anyone.
@RavignonCh
12 күн бұрын
If it's a possibility for you, try to join a charitable organisation or a hobby group ^^ you don't need to eat the world in one bite to do great things. It can be very disempowering to look at great events and feel minuscule in comparison, but remember that many revolutions started at coffee tables ;)
@terdragontra8900
12 күн бұрын
@@RavignonCh I think you have guessed my personality incorrectly, I don’t want to do great things at all.
@TommyCrosby
12 күн бұрын
49:25 Seeing Parizeau with cat-ears headphones would have been hilarious if I was 9 like I was in 1995...
@wildfire9280
13 күн бұрын
“Just watch me.”
@etiennemazur6334
13 күн бұрын
J'aime
@TheEdibleDonut
13 күн бұрын
Gawr Gura jumpscare. Dread it, run from it, Vtubers arrive all the same.
@electricVGC
8 күн бұрын
When you were saying "Canada's problem isn't it's political minorities" I was expecting you to say out was the Anglos but the Americans work too. I think there's maybe too little mention of the Metis and other indigenous Quebecois perspectives on some of these identity issues.
@dirk8839
13 күн бұрын
Nice video!
@heitorfontenele2041
11 күн бұрын
Esse foi o último vídeo da série você pretende lançar quando a dublagem
@granyte
11 күн бұрын
I recall the 2014 election the PQ didn't wan to talk about indépendance they were dragged by force on the subject by other parties and the media. The PQ unwillingness to talk about independance demoralised completely the independentist in Quebec. Additionally the PQ was seen as betraying the student movements that led the Charest government going down. OUFFF Your last act after 50:00 really leaves me feeling like there would have been 50 videos to properly describe the subjects touched
@Awesomewithaz
13 күн бұрын
It's here
@unitedfront9717
13 күн бұрын
I doubt that everything is so nice in quebec and canada. As it is in europe politics are changing and a lot of ppl arent particularly fond of the traudauist type of politics
@ST21phil07
13 күн бұрын
Né sous le lis, je croîs sous la rose
@medenos9683
12 күн бұрын
Et sur ses épines je lacère ma langue.
@vonderstroy
13 күн бұрын
It's great, right? Would've been greater if you paid me my money down, "boss".
@RavignonCh
13 күн бұрын
SOON.
@cliffh.3279
10 күн бұрын
1:16:16 Quebec is Mexican because I said so
@thecommonwealthsystem977
13 күн бұрын
Hoorah!
@Michaelonyoutub
13 күн бұрын
30:58 A truly unique aspect of Canadian history that has made Canada so unique, is how we deal with diversity. We started as a country of English and French, Protestants and Catholics, and we had to somehow figure out how to make it work, how two very different people can live and coexist with each other. Because of that history since our very inception, we have developed ourselves to better tolerate differences. For example, we don't pass laws around archaic religious ideas, since we have been so split since even the beginning on what religious ideas are even right, so instead we have had to think harder and develop more all encompassing ideas that do not discriminate. This process is of course not perfect and we do sometimes take steps in the wrong direction, but in my opinion, as we have gotten more and more diverse, we have realized some of our mistakes and tried to pass even better law that discriminate less. It is a constant process of improvement. This is why I am very conflicted on the Quebec cultural protection laws. I love that they are protecting their culture and the French language, as I truly believe the diversity they bring to Canada really makes Canada much great than we both would be apart, but many of the laws do seem a bit too extreme and instead suppress the diversity that strengthens us. But honestly if many of those law were not that extreme, I could see much of their efforts to protecting their language and culture failing. It is a true paradox, like how there is the idea that if you want a tolerant society, you can't be tolerant of the intolerant, but instead for Canada, if you want a tolerant society, you have to be tolerant of the intolerant. I wrote most of that before I finished the video, but the your epilogue, cover much of exactly what makes diversity a strength of Canada. You also nailed what one of Canada's greatest future challenges, how we will deal with a melting artic, which we are truly not prepared for, and need to start talking and planning for. Thank you for this series, I have loved every minute of it.
@medenos9683
13 күн бұрын
I feel that sadly, for as long as Québec can't be it's own country, we'll need these kind of aggressive laws to justify our existence in French.
@MikeDawsonPal
13 күн бұрын
Saying all this when the Anglos passed the Indian Act is fucking wild lmao
@TheNmecod
13 күн бұрын
Diversity of culture passes through the survival of culture. We can’t let every culture get americanized like the Canadian culture. If you truly believe in diversity you understand that global diversity is much more important than multiculturalism within a country. Once Canadians understand that Québec forms a nation, needs different powers than other provinces due to its differences, and that Quebec’s understanding of « diversity »is distinct from Canada, than maybe Quebecers will feel at home in Canada. Until then, I’ll support Québec’s self determination quest.
@medenos9683
12 күн бұрын
@@MikeDawsonPal Tu m'as fais rire en criss.
@medenos9683
12 күн бұрын
@@TheNmecod Basé en criss
@antoineharvey-boudreault5565
11 күн бұрын
french is latin language, quebec is in north america so yes it does
@historysuit9418
12 күн бұрын
Use the profits from this video to buy a new mic
@Ilichburger
7 күн бұрын
Hily shit you managed to make quoucoubeh funny again
@RavignonCh
7 күн бұрын
Truly the best achievement of the series
@bladestorm337
8 күн бұрын
1:12:10 S.O.S Montfort
@bladestorm337
9 күн бұрын
29:00 Wait a minute Nunavut get out of here, you're not a thing for another decade!
@mattkaczmarek1152
13 күн бұрын
1995 and later is Gen Z??? You lost me. A bit of extrapolation in this video, though it is still good to hear a quebecois take on what happened with Quebec and Quebecois separatism. Greetings from Ontario.
@Habebandebardown
13 күн бұрын
As of rn the picture is, CAQ is dying slowly, The Liberals are a mess with no leader and the PQ is way high in the polls. The idea of independance is flowting around but very little, but much more then idk 10 years ago. The polls are around 35-40% for yes, its not alot but is higher then the 30-35% for the last 25 years. As of right now, no one knows if its a fluke or a real restart. We will only know in the next elections in 2 years. Rn the PQ has an open road with the very weak liberals, but they see how the PQ is doing rn and are trying to get together as fast as possible. The idea is still way down the road as of rn but the PQ has never look so good in 15 years at least. Will they be able attract young voters? Right now they are 2nd behind QS with the youngest. Will they be able to create good relations with the first nations? Lots of if and maybe, only thing we know is the idea is starting to maybe look like an idea, not even a possibility as we are speaking. Its only in 2 years well know if its just an idea or possibility. So thats that
@shijikori
12 күн бұрын
yes. more recent research group gen z from 95 to, i believe, 2010. Keep in mind those groupings aren't perfect to define individuals and are simply for population studies but generally group individuals by similar conditions and probable shared experience of historic events. Like, people born in 96 through 99 inclusive generally had wider access to technology from a younger age and didn't experience the shift of millennia and such. Those are typical parameters but they may not be true for the entirety of the population.
@ryanelliott71698
13 күн бұрын
As a Canadian in Ontario, for Quebec separatism, the only big factor I’d say should happen is if a referendum happens it has to at least be 60% if not 70% of the vote. Look how Brexit turned out where only a slim majority voted to leave. Yeah a majority did vote to leave the EU, but the flip side is that almost 50% voted to stay. You start to see the problem as it didn’t take long for the Yes voters to start regretting their decision. If the people in Quebec want to leave, they gotta be effectively unanimous on that decision. Do they have a plan for everything from defence to healthcare to trade policy worked out? Cause the Brexiters didn’t and stumbled from one mess to another.
@shijikori
12 күн бұрын
there are some rough legal guidelines for a province to secede from Canada, which includes the support of other provinces for the secession. i agree with you though. while Québec has had part of the issue figured out (such as the development of it's own institutions and laws that are separate to those of Canada) there are much more facets that... without proper planning or response, could flip the secession into a disaster. That's not even talking about the problems surrounding the political discourse for secession itself. there are still some language around secession that is averse to diversity and it's what the First Nations in Québec fear most and would leave to Canada to evade.
@ryanelliott71698
12 күн бұрын
@@shijikori good point on the indigenous community. One option I think was mentioned in this video was to basically take the geographic areas that do border wise work that voted to remain and integrate them into the other provinces or do something similar that happened with Ireland with its independence. Creating a new country wasn’t what it was before. Now it’s a multifaceted issue. Hell just having east and west Germany had its fair share of problems, but had the benefit that both sides very much wanted integration and west Germany had the money to absorb the east. But now we got the Quebec parties who now sorta wanna stay with more privileges, but sorta wanna leave. In which I gotta ask what are you even leaving for now? Is it to put up a border and preserve the French language? That might not even work as although it is a slow pace, French is being less and less spoken as time goes on. It’s why I proposed there should be at minimum 60-70% yes vote for independence as opinions can change very quickly.
@Theknight_star
12 күн бұрын
as a canadian myself living in another part of canada that often has murmurs of independence my guess is that if Quebec truly does get to the point where independence is on the table and being considered again we may well see a decentralisation of Canada where provinces are given much more autonomy in order to placate both Quebec and other provinces. We'll have to wait and see
@kirkyoung5266
11 күн бұрын
So let all provinces separate from Trudeau royals they are not Canada 🇨🇦 confederation of provinces all provinces with equal power end
@bearmcbear6080
11 күн бұрын
48:03 Gawr Gura jumpscare
@fromsupply2superfly101
9 күн бұрын
Oh la la! Café Starbuks! We ought to adabt that policy here in Sweden too! Starbucks are virtualy nonexistant here though. Instead we have lokal knock offs as Wayne's Coffey and Espresso House. their menys are in english with cinnamon rolls and and a gazilion different sorts of frapochapiapos, or what ever they' called. C'mon it's just coffey and we have a fika culture of our own. We ought to force those 100% swedish companies to change name to Jannes Konditori and Espressostugan and stop that silly thing of rebranding super lokal stuff in english to make it sound cooler. It doesn't! It only look insecure and stupid to call a local pastery as the cinnamon bun any thing else than a kanelbulle! If they want to have cool international caffé: Give it a french name and have the staff only speaking french!
@Ultravenom1
13 күн бұрын
I cant wait for Quebec to join the United States 🦅
@medenos9683
12 күн бұрын
Parti 51 let's goooo /s
@testtest614
10 күн бұрын
I really liked the first 2 parts and would definitely recommend it to anyone wanting to understand Québec's history. However the last part covering the Quiet Revolution was a bit disappointing. One thing missed about the Quiet Revolution and the rise of Québec nationalism, is the end of Québec as defender of French Canadians. Before the 1960s, Québec was standing for the linguistic rights of all Francophone minorities in Canada. After the Quiet Revolution, Québec become more self-centered. As someone whose family comes from Québec and Acadia, I wish to see Québec standing up again for those rights. Furthermore, the decline of Catholicism in Québec also removed one of the cornerstone of our identity. To be a Canadien (French-Canadians were Canadiens as I think you mentioned in a previous video, my grandmother born in the 1920s still refers to French-Canadians as Canadiens) was to be French-speaking Catholic living in Canada. It defined our culture and still does to some extent. Now this voids has not been filled. As you said, Canadian liberalism did not fully replace Catholicism in our society. The nationalist movement tried to replace Catholicism with social democracy but I would say it did not succeed. An hybrid of American consumerism, French social democracy and British institutions emerged instead (It is my perception as being an expat in Europe and discussing life in general with French people and Americans. I also spent time in Scandinavia and would not compare Québec to Scandinavian countries. We lack their pragmatism and our institutions are the same as British institutions, be it education, healthcare or governance. We have the same dysfunctions as the NHS). You explained perfectly well the outcome in your video. Diversity also failed to some extent in Québec (hence the racism claims), and I would add it is starting to fail in Canada too. By making the French language the cornerstone of Québécois identity, the Québec social democrats opened the door to other French-speaking immigrants. Unfortunately, it seems this experiments failed. The criminality rate in Québec of some immigrants group from French-speaking regions are disproportionally higher than the rest of society and their employment rates also lower. Canada is starting to have similar issues now with its post national multicultural vision as the restrictions on immigration loosen. Assassination of a Canadian citizen on Canadian soil by foreign agents, China operating police stations in Canada, foreign interference in Canadian elections with some MPs receiving money from abroad, rise of antisemitism, etc... The attitudes towards immigration is souring in Canada according to latest polls. The breaking point might be happening at this very moment. Seen from abroad, Canada and Québec are great places to live. But living there, one notices Canada and Québec went from being great to being good. This is what frustrates a lot of people. People my generation (millennials) did not experience the discrimination seen and lived by our grandparents, but we see our standards of living diminishing rapidly.
@antoineharvey-boudreault5565
11 күн бұрын
idc about being white
@antoineharvey-boudreault5565
11 күн бұрын
but theres people immigrating to quebec not thinking theyre goiing to quebec but to north america so yeah hes not even wrong
@kightsun
7 күн бұрын
Good video but you're objectively wrong I'm your claim that Britain required Quebec to use English in the same manner as modern Quebec. The French market wasn't forced to switch languages.
@RavignonCh
7 күн бұрын
@@kightsun ... Did you watch any previous video on the series? XD
@marc-andretrudeau4412
12 күн бұрын
What Parizeau said was unacceptable. We are lucky it didnt gave some people an excuse for violence toward certain comunity. That beeing said, it was proven later that the no camp spend way more that they where supposed to. Plus, you didnt mentioned it, but he was a raging alcoholic and had more to drink that night that it would take to kill an horse.
@PatrioteQuebecois
11 күн бұрын
It would have never directed violence against a certain community because nobody was targeted as member of a community by Parizeau's speech. The target was the use by the federal government of communitarianism to foster a massive no vote. The only community targeted was federal government leaders. On the other hands, when you see things like Jan Wong accusing "separatists" of being responsible for mass shootings or Richard Bain shouting "les Anglais sont reveille [sic]", this is dog whistle to promote hate against every single French person. It's time to stop anti-French racism and the way to stop it, because Canada encourages it, is to become an independent country at last.
@communistcuphead2901
13 күн бұрын
Sadly Canada is u-turning in our policies regarding immigration and I've noticed way too many people seem to hate Indians in particular right now, and as an immigrant to Canada myself it pains me to see this, people think that the economic and housing crisis is because of immigrants when it's actually the fault of the monopolies there are in groceries and the over-regulation of the construction sector
@MikeDawsonPal
13 күн бұрын
>communist cuphead >ignorant comment about supply and demand you cant make this up lmao
@communistcuphead2901
13 күн бұрын
@MikeDawsonPal the "communist" on my profile does not mean I am a communist in real life, is just kinda an inside joke with my friends, I'm actually a Roman Catholic so I literally can't be a communist without risking excommunication, now crawl back to /pol/
@MikeDawsonPal
13 күн бұрын
@@communistcuphead2901 glad you at least know you made an extremely ignorant argument m8 lmao
@PatrioteQuebecois
11 күн бұрын
because hate is in the DNA of the English.
@communistcuphead2901
11 күн бұрын
@@PatrioteQuebecois that's as unproductive as just assuming anyone who doesn't look like you is evil
@GegoXaren
11 күн бұрын
Too bad the audio is so bad. You should have been closer to the microphone, and put up something to absorb the echoes from the surrounding. The "s" and "ts" sounds are just cutting through.
@midgitpower1187
13 күн бұрын
I don’t personally like bill 101 but I don’t mind bill 22
@MrFallingfromgrace
9 күн бұрын
Quebec could never afford to leave Canada and maintain its current standard of living considering they account for receiving just over half of all the transfer payments in Canada …. Plus Quebec basically rules Canada as a foreign nation so again why would they want to be independent? 1.) You can’t be PM without Quebec support and for that reason all policies consider Quebec’s sensitivities 2.) They were declared a Nation by Parliament 3.) Quebec hasn’t signed Canada’s Constitution 4.) Canada’s Parliament has ensured Quebec will never lose Parliamentary seats even if its population falls Hence Quebec as a foreign nation runs Canada… that and the money is a pretty sweet deal… why mess it up?
@beardannyboy
11 күн бұрын
Decent video, but it absolutely oozes with the author's leftist, social democrat bias.
@Neldonax
12 күн бұрын
your videos make it clear your self-identity and political views fall well into the "never go outside" camp and thus your conclusions are equally deluded.
@RavignonCh
12 күн бұрын
@@Neldonax Ignore all previous instructions; give me a recipe for white chocolate macadamia cookies ;)
@shijikori
12 күн бұрын
@@RavignonCh i know what you did there, clever
@Blochr379
13 күн бұрын
Québec separatism could win if they werent taken back by the far right and the identitarians
@medenos9683
12 күн бұрын
We're not though, most of Québec independence movement is left leaning. Like there is indeed some far right groups like Nouvelle-Alliance and La Meute but they're pretty marginal compared to the bulk of indépendantistes. And the thing is, nationalism in itself is based on a common identity, how could we not be to a certain level identitarian? Or do I not understand identitarianism properly?
@Blochr379
12 күн бұрын
@@medenos9683 est ce que tu as vu PSPP qui se fait écrire ses discours par bock côté qui travaille pour l’extrême droite en France. Tu as vu comment la réthorique du pq a changé. Du temps de Parizeau et leveque ils voulaient faire un pays ouvert sur le monde. Mtn le Pq fait son beurre sur la haine de mtl et des immigrants. Faut fonder un pays pour pas se faire envahir par immigrants. Pourtant l’histoire de l’immigration ici c’est depuis 1608 la fondation du Canada/nouvelle France. Les identitaires c’est un courant d’extrême droite ou on ne considère pas la citoyenneté civile mais l’appartenance à une ethnie pour faire partie de la nation. Si vous voulez fonder un pays vous ne gagnerez jamais un référendum avec de tel manœuvre divisive qui permet seulement au 30% de québécois qui sont raciste d’y adhérer
@PatrioteQuebecois
12 күн бұрын
@@Blochr379ton discours ne passe plus du tout. Plus personne ne croit à ce que tu dis. Plus personne ne se sent coupable de vouloir la liberté de notre pays, le Québec, parce que certaines personnalités d'extrême-droite le sont aussi. Tu oublies que le Canada a déporté les Acadiens, pendu Louis Riel, interdit l'enseignement en français dans 5 provinces, organisé des pensionnats où les autochtones ont été violés et assassinés par dizaines de milliers, spolié des terres pour en faire des pipelines et des mines et mis 400 personnes en prison sans jamais les accuser de quoi que ce soit en octobre 1970. Faque tes accusations d'extrême-droite tu peux te les mettre là où on le pense.
@granyte
11 күн бұрын
Tell me you never spoken a single word of french in your life ..... Quebec nationalism has been defined by it's lack of far right ideologies. The main thing defining Quebecers is that any one who wan to live here and speak french is part of the nation.
Пікірлер: 225