On Battle For a New Champion how come they didn’t have guys like Leroy,Cory,Nelson,Fessy,Josh,Kyle those guys aren’t champs either. They could’ve had the best to have never win it. Leroy probably would’ve actually won this one.
@mattviggiano
Ай бұрын
Would've been cool to have a team of prospects vs a team of best to never win.
@dcanngieter
Ай бұрын
They are looking for a bunch of Horacios to carry the future
@AliFrankTheTank
8 күн бұрын
Dat shiii was another fresh meat BUT they already been on the grill 😭😭😭🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️
@U2BearCat
Ай бұрын
I admire your stamina it was tough for you and tough for us trying to watch and comment on everything.
@BlackHawk9615
Ай бұрын
Absolute hand clap to you and your dedication to creating this list before the premiere tn. Couldn’t have been easy. I agree with a lot of the list (except WOTW1 which should be higher and the Island which should be last). At the end of the day a lot of this is very subjective. But overall the list looks pretty solid.
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
Much appreciated! And I’m telling you, WOTW1 has the loudest supporters, you’ve got a lot of people thinking the same on that one.
@Cameron_David_
Ай бұрын
Really well thought out list. I am in the camp that wotw1 should be top 10 at least. Turbo coming out of nowhere and dominating combined with the hardest final are huge franchise moments for me. It was also a great Wes season.
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
It’s fantastic, I think it just shows the depth of great seasons the show has had
@AliFrankTheTank
8 күн бұрын
5:35 Double Agents is fire lol, Ride or Dies 2 needed wit better cast (as you hinted, cast was ehhh),Dirty 30> Vendattas, Invasion, WOTW1&2🔥🔥🔥, Free Agents & Rivals 🐐🐐 (Johnny !!!)
@JacobElyachar
Ай бұрын
Bravo, Jacob!! Your recaps were phenomenal! Thank you for bringing us up to speed!
@TheToxicMermaid
Ай бұрын
You’ve done great! I’ve really enjoyed this month!
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
Thanks for watching along!
@Bangbang-xt7kf
Ай бұрын
I agree with 98 % of the list (im just on the side of the fans that think Final Reckoning is the worst 😂). I'm soo glad that you are showing love to WotW 2 bcs (hot take) i think this season have the best edit and EVERY elimination is brilliant. Not just good,great.
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
The edit is for sure one of the best they’ve ever done, a major part of why that storyline has me so wrapped up all season long
@Iucas4
Ай бұрын
Loved your ranking! Here's mine: (also would love to see a spinoff ranking eventually) 1. Rivals (21) 2. The Duel (13) 3. Free Agents (25) 4. The Inferno II (10) 5. Final Reckoning (32) 6. Rivals II (24) 7. War of the Worlds 2 (34) 8. Fresh Meat II (19) 9. Cutthroat (20) 10. Battle of the Exes II (26) 11. Battle of the Exes (22) 12. War of the Worlds (33) 13. Vendettas (31) 14. The Duel II (17) 15. Invasion of the Champions (29) 16. The Ruins (18) 17. XXX: Dirty 30 (30) 18. Battle of the Seasons (2012) (23) 19. Fresh Meat (12) 20. The Inferno I (8) 21. Total Madness (35) 22. Battle of the Bloodlines (27) 23. Double Agents (36) 24. The Island (16) 25. The Gauntlet III (15) 26. Rivals III (28) 27. The Gauntlet 2 (11) 28. The Gauntlet (6) 29. The Inferno 3 (14) 30. Battle for a New Champion (39) 31. Spies, Lies & Allies (27) 32. Ride or Dies (38) 33. Battle of the Sexes 2 (9) 34. Battle of the Seasons (5) 35. Battle of the Sexes (6) 36. Extreme Challenge (4) 37. Challenge 2000 (3) 38. Road Rules: All Stars (1) 39. Real World vs. Road Rules (2)
@ZavidWebster
Ай бұрын
My Rankings: 53. The Island 52. Rivals 3 51. Ride Or Dies 50. Total Madness 49. Bloodlines 48. Spies, Lies & Allies 47. Gauntlet 3 46. Double Agents 45. Spring Break Challenge 44. Seasons (2012) 43. All Stars 4 42. WOTW 2 41. Final Reckoning 40. Road Rules All Stars 39. Challenge 2000 38. RW Vs. RR Challenge 37. Extreme Challenge 36. Battle For A New Champion 35. Argentina 34. Inferno 3 33. Invasion Of The Champs 32. UK 31. Champs Vs. Stars 30. Dirty 30: XXX 29. Exes 2 28. Vendettas 27. Seasons (2002) 26. Champs Vs. Stars 2 25. USA 2 24. The Ruins 23. Champs Vs. Pros 22. Australia 21. USA 20. Fresh Meat 2 19. Rivals 2 18. Sexes 2 17. World Championship 16. All Stars 15. The Duel 2 14. Sexes 13. Inferno 2 12. All Stars 3 11. Gauntlet 10. Exes 9. Gauntlet 2 8. All Stars 2 7. Fresh Meat 6. Cutthroat 5. Inferno 4. WOTW 3. Rivals 2. The Duel 1. Free Agents
@brettscott1797
Ай бұрын
Great list!
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
Thank you! Appreciate you tuning in!
@SamWilliams-w2j
Ай бұрын
Really great list! Personally I would have bloodlines, battle of the seasons, and exes two in the great tier instead of challenge 2000, gauntlet, and invasion.
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
Whoa, there is a Bloodlines defender out there? What makes it great for you?
@ajskdhfg
14 күн бұрын
For those who like to reference the season number, this was his list: 1. Rivals (Season 21) 2. Free Agents (Season 25) 3. The Duel (Season 13) 4. Rivals II (Season 24) 5. The Inferno (Season 8) 6. War of the Worlds 2 (Season 34) 7. Fresh Meat II (Season 19) 8. The Inferno II (Season 10) 9. Cutthroat (Season 20) 10. Fresh Meat (Season 12) 11. Battle of the Exes (Season 22) 12. War of the Worlds (Season 33) 13. The Gauntlet (Season 7) 14. Challenge 2000 (Season 3) 15. Final Reckoning (Season 32) 16. Invasion of the Champions (Season 29) 17. Battle of the Seasons (Season 5) 18. Battle of the Exes 2 (Season 26) 19. Vendettas (Season 31) 20. Duel 2 (Season 17) 21. The Ruins (Season 18) 22. Dirty Thirty (Season 30) 23. Real World vs. Road Rules (Season 2) 24. Battle of the Seasons 2 (Season 23) 25. Battle for a New Champion (Season 39) 26. The Gauntlet 2 (Season 11) 27. Road Rules: All Stars (Season 1) 28. Rivals III (Season 28) 29. Total Madness (Season 35) 30. Ride or Dies (Season 38) 31. The Island (Season 16) 32. The Inferno 3 (Season 14) 33. Extreme Challenge (Season 4) 34. Spies, Lies & Allies (Season 37) 35. Double Agents (Season 36) 36. The Gauntlet III (Season 15) 37. Battle of the Sexes 2 (Season 9) 38. Bloodlines (Season 27) 39. Battle of the Sexes (Season 6)
@ChallengeHistorian
13 күн бұрын
Thanks for typing that all out!
@Defundthenavy
Ай бұрын
Great job
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
Thanks for tuning in!!
@robinkelly6860
Ай бұрын
I'm a big fan of #RHAP but there is just something lacking on their Challenge coverage. I think I will enjoy your coverage a bit more!
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
Hope to prove you right!
@loganbrown6987
Ай бұрын
39: Battle Of The Seasons (2012) 38: Road Rules: All Stars 37: Challenge 36: Extreme Challenge 35: Challenge 2000 34: Spies Lies and Allies 33: Battle For A New Champion 32: Inferno 3 31: The Island 30: Battle Of The Bloodlines 29: Gauntlet 2 28: Battle Of The Seasons (2002) 27: Battle Of The Sexes 2 26: The Ruins 25: Ride Or Dies 24: The Gauntlet 23: Vendettas 22: Double Agents 21: Duel 2 20: Total Madness 19: Battle Of The Exes 18: Rivals 3 17: Battle Of The Sexes 16: Battle Of The Exes 2 15: Gauntlet 3 14: Fresh Meat 13: Fresh Meat 2 12: Invasion Of The Champions 11: Dirty 30 10: The Inferno 9: Final Reckoning 8: Rivals 2 7: The Duel 6: War Of The Worlds 5: Rivals 4: Inferno 2 3: Cutthroat 2: Free Agents 1: War Of The Worlds 2
@ChallengeHistorian
29 күн бұрын
Solid list!
@AliFrankTheTank
8 күн бұрын
Free Agents goat but W WOTW2 praise
@TPD45
Ай бұрын
I would like to see your reviews on USA 2 and World Championship
@bigbuffguy9589
Ай бұрын
I really like both seasons (and USA 1). World Championship is my second-favorite pair season format behind Fresh Meat 2. I have a preference for team seasons, but I think World Championship might be top 10 overall for me.
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
I covered those seasons live, so there are full episode recaps and a full end of season recap available (lot longer than these videos have been)!
@bigbuffguy9589
Ай бұрын
Great job on these recaps. I'd bump Fresh Meat 2 and Inferno 2 into the A tier, War of the Worlds 1 into the A- tier, Battle of the Seasons 2 and Duel 2 into the B+ tier, Gauntlet 2 into either the B or B+ tier and The Island into the B- tier. I would also have War of the Worlds 2 and Inferno 1 in the A+ tier. They're my two favorite seasons of The Challenge and two of my favorite seasons in the history of reality TV almost on par with S-tier Survivor seasons (e.g. Pearl Islands, Cagayan).
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
Love this. I think Inferno 1 is my quickest regret on the list. I’d already actually drop Free Agents down to 5 and get Inferno up one spot, if not all the way to the 2 spot.
@calebmccalla4715
Ай бұрын
For the love of god can you and anybody else who has any pull get WOW1 & 2 back out so we all can watch them again. 2 of the best seasons ever.
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
lol I have 0 pull or connection to anyone with the show. If I did there would be plenty I would push for, including that
@calebmccalla4715
Ай бұрын
@@ChallengeHistorian I mean, you got an interview with TJ which has to count for something lol. Which is pretty cool btw, props for that.
@diegoprodriguez
Ай бұрын
Really hoping AS5 does well so maybe we can get a Flagship Rivals season in the next year or two.
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
I think it could happen if the cast was on the smaller side, I’d imagine they will play the hits for the next couple flagship seasons
@TPD45
Ай бұрын
Does anyone know where I can rewatch seasons 33-35?
@rnbjunkie89
Ай бұрын
where can we watch War of the World 1 and 2 and Total Madness?
@rnbjunkie89
Ай бұрын
also the first ten seasons
@minerzach1236
Ай бұрын
Think gauntlet 3 is better than 36 and 37
@TPD45
Ай бұрын
Honestly you can just do Total Madness review the seasons after that are dog 💩
@ingridmoran7497
Ай бұрын
no the island is the worst lol. 0 redeeming qualities unlike other seasons. actually painful to sit thru (at least for me, a woman) sexism is unbearable. at least the constant loud wind noise in the back drowns out the men talking a little. just trash. bloodlines is so much better by far. bloodlines isnt like nails on a chalkboard to listen to. maybe it doesnt bother male fans much, but the island is literally unwatchable to me
@ChallengeHistorian
Ай бұрын
I get that, and I'm sure it is a very difference experience for women watching vs men. But it has a lot of stand out moments and interesting sub plots that keep it from the very bottom of the list for me. Kenny/Johanna hook up is a vital piece of one of the shows storied rivalries, Evelyn's speech is iconic, Ryan not taking the shot at the end and then Evelyn turning to the dark side is super memorable, Rachel vs KellyAnne endurance elim, and a few more from there.
@ingridmoran7497
Ай бұрын
@@ChallengeHistorian if your judging the seasons by historical importance to the franchise then ig its better. but idc abt that too much. I care abt the actual quality of the season. And bloodlines had more and better standout moments that weren't ruined by loud ass wind. I watched both seasons super recently. I feel like your just nostalgic or something. it's a terrible watch to sit thru. u can imagine back to the few good moments, but actually sitting down and having to watch the whole thing is like torture. bloodlines is a fun watch. its consistently adequate at least. u should rewatch cuz it's trash. I'm sure the 10 mins worth of good moments is worth watching the entire rest of the season which sucks consistently. made me hate characters I used to like too
@bigbuffguy9589
Ай бұрын
@@ingridmoran7497 I've watched both seasons in the last year or so for the first time, and in the case of Bloodlines, I watched it in the last month. The Island is significantly better than Bloodlines.
@ingridmoran7497
Ай бұрын
@@bigbuffguy9589 why
@bigbuffguy9589
Ай бұрын
@@ingridmoran7497 The Island has a unique format that is actually pretty interesting (once I stopped comparing it to Survivor because the conditions they whined about would be by far the cushiest conditions of any Survivor season). It has good drama, and the winners' games are all interesting for different reasons. With Bloodlines, it just dragged with about double the number of episodes of The Island. The only saving grace was Cory and Mitch.
@rogerdodger1984
28 күн бұрын
Battle of the Sexes in last? No need to watch the rest of this video.
@Johnlocke-q6q
Ай бұрын
I can't argue with this great list except for season 39 should be dead last.
Пікірлер: 55