juria being last for her group but 5th for dance on this list just shows what amazing dancers xg are
@user-cf9jl3pk1n
26 күн бұрын
AUTHOR I HOPE YOU'RE JOKING, HOW CAN YOU NOT KNOW THAT ROZE IS A VERY STRONG LMAO DANCER, SHE IS TALLER THAN MINNIE AND MIEN FOR SURE!
@Lss125
28 күн бұрын
Ningning is G3 ~ C5/C♯5 ~ E♭5/E5 Miyeon is G♯3 ~ A4/B♭4
@Moonpak
11 күн бұрын
NingNing is not that consistent with C#5.
@Lss125
11 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak she's more consistent with C♯5 than with F♯3
@CheShiny
28 күн бұрын
Okay so Wendy: Leader, Main Vocalist, Lead Dancer Ningning: Co-Leader, Main Vocalist, Sub Rapper Jihyo: Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist Jungkook: Main Rapper, Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist Miyeon: Lead Vocalist, Visual Chisa: Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer Rosé: Lead Vocalist Seungmin: Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer Juria: Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer Lia: Sub Vocalist, Sub Rapper Sieun: Lead Dancer, Sub Vocalist, Sub Rapper Minnie: Sub Vocalist, Sub Rapper Mia: Main Dancer, Sub Vocalist, Sub Rapper Since the whole concept of this group is them being Main Vocalist, the best Vocalist is getting the leader position
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
Great!!! Maybe Sieun Sub Rapper too???
@CheShiny
28 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak so I looked for Sieun rap and ye I think so too now
@hyungnounou
28 күн бұрын
• C5/C#5 in Ningning supported range , u can check Sootzubæ community • Mia (20/20) > Onda (18/20) in SP Mia is the third best performer in 4th gen after Soyeon being first and Jurin being second • Jihyo (20/20) > Rosé (19/20) > JK (18/20) > Ningning (17/20) > Wendy (14/20) > Sieun (13/20) • Rosé (Group Rank : 1/4)
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
NingNing is not that consistent with C#5. I don't need to check SooTzuBæ because I know. Stop talking like Stage Presence is objective because it's not. It is 100% subjective. Jennie & Lisa captivate me more than Rosé when they are on stage, Rosé isn't bad but she looks she so dead on the stage sometimes, Lisa is definitely better to me. Onda is impressive, I can't take off my eyes of her. No way, you really find Rosé better than Jungkook? I know that it is subjective but, seriously??? If Rosé and Jungkook were on the same stage, would it be Rosé that you would be looking at???
@user-cf9jl3pk1n
26 күн бұрын
WHAT ARE YOU UNDER? LMAO
@thiyamradharani4001
28 күн бұрын
What do you think about Seulgj sp Around lisa level maybe imo Masculine charasmatic
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
I find Lisa better, for me Seulgi's Archetype is ‘Masculine Overt Dominant’. To me, her face and body looks a little uncomfortable in animated or cute concepts but when she's in something like ‘28 Reasons’ or ‘Monster’ she's REALLY good and ATE the stage.
@Bangpink1201
28 күн бұрын
From my perspective she isn't on the level of Lisa's sp, she is somewhat around Rosé or Sana's Sp for me. Neither in hyping,charisma, consistency, she is better than Lisa. But at last its subjective, but if we see objectively she definitely isn't on the level of Lisa.
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
@@Bangpink1201 She's around Mia & Ryujin for me.
@Bangpink1201
28 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak ya you can also say that.
@thiyamradharani4001
28 күн бұрын
@@Moonpaksince sp is subjective I don't care
@user-cf9jl3pk1n
26 күн бұрын
I REALLY LOVE NINGNING, BUT WHAT ARE YOU SAYING IS FICTION!
@Moonpak
26 күн бұрын
No, it's not. Have you ever heard her recordings? She supports an E5 and B4 with a good quality.
@hypemusicccc
27 күн бұрын
bro are u okey rose is not a below average she is lead dancer She has enough technique to be the main dancer in other groups. Obviously, if you haven't watched it, I recommend you to watch it. And also she is doing rap
@Moonpak
27 күн бұрын
No, she doesn't have it. I've watched enough BLACKPINK stuff to conclude that she's a weak dancer. There is a lack of proper body control, proper coordination and then proper execution. Lacks the basics of groove, hiphop foundations (Pretty Savage is a disaster). Isolations, locks, pops, hits, stops, all weak because of the lack of proper muscular strength and she is textbook, that is, without dynamics, without own style. And what Rap? None of them have a good flow.
@hypemusicccc
19 күн бұрын
Do you evaluate only based on Pretty Savage? Well, if you look at that, in general, Jihyo's performance at Twice's Billboard Music Awards was terrible in terms of vocal dance. Is it possible to become a good dancer only based on muscle mass? According to the features you mentioned, you can watch Blackpink Predebut Rihanna B Better Have My Money video, Beyonce Episode and 16 Shots videos. As far as I understand, you haven't watched it and the highest rap in terms of SPS is 6.29, which is quite high for a main vocalist and a member who is supposedly an all rounder for a member who can't rap. You just ignored it because Rose's talents are not a joke. If you haven't listened to it, you can listen to the unreleased version of his song with Gdragon without you. Even if the company does not see her talents, she is the most talented member of the group. You made the list by shaking it. If a blind person made it, it would have been more popular. You said 3/4, it is too good for the group. Who is the 2nd one? Is it Jennie or Jisoo? You only despise her talents. Best F Dancer
@hypemusicccc
19 күн бұрын
Beyoncé partition*
@hypemusicccc
19 күн бұрын
unreleased black pink songs especially two faced and too late
@Moonpak
19 күн бұрын
@@hypemusicccc Pretty Savage was just an example, in all the choreographies she is like this, lacking proper body control, etc.
@Bruhhhhhhhhhhhhh8
9 күн бұрын
Ningning is developed dance
@Moonpak
9 күн бұрын
I don't even use this Tier 😭 stop comparing my videos with Minty Sana's or anyone else, different dancers have different analyzes and priorities and Minty Sana herself said that she use Commercial Dance as a base too (mixing with Urban), I only use Urban Dance as a base.
@furuwy
11 күн бұрын
Where's Lily bro..
@Moonpak
11 күн бұрын
Sorry, I didn't know she had this position officially 😅
@furuwy
10 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak wait, they haven't announced their official position yet? then how did you know jiwoo is the main rapper of nmixx?
@Moonpak
10 күн бұрын
@@furuwy It was officially announced. Lily & Haewon are Main Vocalist, Jiwoo Main Rapper and Kyujin Main Dancer.
@furuwy
8 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak oh ok then, why wouldn't you put both of them in the video. Anyway, great video tho..
@Moonpak
8 күн бұрын
@@furuwy I didn't know that, I found out in the time interval between the “ranking main vocalists” and the “ranking main rappers”.
@raindrop9985
28 күн бұрын
There's nothing for Seungmin in the all rounder ranking?
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
Sorry, it's a mistake haha Vocal: Above Average Rap: Below Average Dance: Above Average He is interchangeable with Juria.
@pIantasia
27 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak girl he is so good a rapping that his band joke he is main rapper 😭
@Moonpak
27 күн бұрын
@@pIantasia Are YOU kidding? Are jokes true now? What will you say later? That Jin is a good Rapper because of the “angry-jin” joke? When did Seungmin have a good verse within STRAY KIDS?
@pIantasia
27 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak he doesnt have rap lines in the songs but you should watch his verse when he covered muddy water, it was really good
@Moonpak
27 күн бұрын
@@pIantasia WOW! She has a cover, oh my God!!! He is the best Rapper in the world!!! I can't even really evaluate his rap if he doesn't have anything original, reproduction doesn't count. Anyone can learn to reproduce a verse that already has a flow, delivery and rhymes ready, the ‘original’ is what matters.
@andriandwi190
29 күн бұрын
Where is winter? She is also main vocalist now
@Moonpak
29 күн бұрын
She is Lead Vocalist.
@andriandwi190
29 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak okay i'm confused. On their debut, winter was lead vocalist. Months ago, she was main vocalist. And now also lead vocalist on kprofiles. 😂
@Moonpak
29 күн бұрын
@@andriandwi190 Honestly, 2 Main Vocalists & 2 Sub Vocalists makes no sense. Right now on Kprofiles and Kpopping she is a Lead Vocalist.
@andriandwi190
28 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak i see. But how about purple kiss? 3 main vocalists and no lead vocalist
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
@@andriandwi190 Serious? I mean it's just weird. They know Goeun is the best, even though all three of them are good. Or simply given the position of Lead Vocalist for Dosie.
@WinayaBudiastama
28 күн бұрын
Why mia is not average on rap?
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
Inconsistent, she can't even be considered a rapper if she raps every now and then. + her flows, deliveries and rhymes are very basic, even to be considered Average.
@WinayaBudiastama
28 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak is yeji, lia, chaer better than her? Or just yeji
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
@@WinayaBudiastama I would say she's better than them because I see a little more potential in Mia.
@reidavi2323
28 күн бұрын
I think Mia, Ningning and ofc Wendy are average at rap!
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
No they are not. There is no really good or impressive flow, delivery or rhymes and mostly they are extremely inconsistent because they rap every now and then. Average rappers would be: Dahyun, Karina, Yuna, etc.
@reidavi2323
28 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak For me, put Karina at same level than Dahyun is so much crazy lol And I think Wendy is the best RV rapper 👀
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
@@reidavi2323 What's the best about Karina's flow besides Savage? Consistency is Wendy's biggest problem, there's no way she can be the best in the group if you can't tell me anything ORIGINAL about her, especially in Title Tracks. I mean, She can't be the best if she only raps SOMETIMES, even Joy, who is also inconsistent, is still more consistent than her.
@reidavi2323
28 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak I like Karina's rap, she's a great rapper... Dahyun is a good rapper, but doesn't have so much fast raps like Karina...
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
@@reidavi2323 Fast raps don't mean that much. Honestly, I didn't ask if you like her rap I asked if you can show me her best flow without being ‘Savage’. You can? Or do you not understand about flows?
@Wicked_sua
29 күн бұрын
Mia 2nd best in sp (everglow) who is best in your opinion onda?
@Moonpak
29 күн бұрын
Yes, Onda.
@k-popmusicalworld4567
7 күн бұрын
Chisa is better dancer than a vocalist
@Moonpak
7 күн бұрын
All of them are, dance is their strongest point
@user-cf9jl3pk1n
26 күн бұрын
THAT NINNING CAN'T HAVE BETTER VOCALS THAN THE PREVIOUSLY LISTED LMAO + IS A PRE-RECORDING AND NOT A LIVE SOUND!!
@Moonpak
26 күн бұрын
Are you trying to say that NingNing is a bad vocalist? Think about it... You really believe what you're saying? She's a little unstable but her technique is very good, range, agility, control, pitch.
@getuliocesar6275
25 күн бұрын
Seungmin vocals 2 in his Group?
@Moonpak
25 күн бұрын
Han is better
@user-cf9jl3pk1n
26 күн бұрын
SEUNGMIN DOES NOT HAVE A HIGHER DANCE LEVEL THAN ROZE LMAO, ROZE HAS A LEVEL OF 84\100 AND SEUNGMIN HAS 68\100
@petucals
27 күн бұрын
Don’t use tiers
@Moonpak
27 күн бұрын
These tiers are literally based on technique. Or you don't know what Below Average, Average, etc. means?
@petucals
26 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak they’re nonsense and non reliable
@laracosta7882
24 күн бұрын
Just cause your fav main vocalist isn’t high in the list doesn’t mean the criteria is wrong 🫣
@gugsu
28 күн бұрын
remember that Winter is also a Main Vocalist now 🤓
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
No, she is not You can open Kprofiles and see 🤓
@gugsu
28 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak not they changing it again
@Wicked_sua
29 күн бұрын
Sieun 2nd best? She is better than isa afaik
@Moonpak
29 күн бұрын
1. Sumin 2. Sieun 3. Isa Or are you talking about Vocal? Then Isa is better.
@Wicked_sua
29 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak sorry yes I mean vocally
@clpexlsa
10 күн бұрын
Yoon is NOT a better vocalist than sieun☠️
@Moonpak
10 күн бұрын
It's Isa
@ggstan2439
27 күн бұрын
Hm agree but Minnie and Mia doesn’t sound as bad as Sieun tho… Being slightly better at supporting (idk if she is in fact) doesn’t make her that better, she is always strainning and sooooo thin. I mean with mia is arguable but minnie is not as bad as people make her to seem only bcs she can’t support. I mean I never saw her failing at singing, she is very good at “pretending” she is a good singer. Idk if you get what I mean.
@Moonpak
27 күн бұрын
Minnie sounds good, but her technique is poor, Sieun's technique is a little better but Minnie sounds better (for most). Vocal tone is subjective so it's better to base it on technique, Sieun's pitch, agility and control is better. Minnie and Mia can support too, but it turns out that Sieun is more consistent, Minnie and Mia also strain anything in the 5th octave or sometimes even things close. (example: Minnie's high note in ‘I Want That’)
@Moonpak
27 күн бұрын
“Pretending” that she is a good singer doesn't mean anything, tone doesn't mean anything because it's subjective, for many Rosé's tone is bad and 'hurts the ears' for others she sounds like an angel, that doesn't take away the fact that she's an 'Above Average' Vocalist.
@ggstan2439
27 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak I’m not talking about tone tho. Minnie sounds pleasant, it’s not her tone, it’s the way she sings. And if someone sounds good singing there’s no reason to say they are undeveloped or non-vocalist. That’s why a lot of people take tiers as a joke because putting Chowon, Minnie, Eunha, Mia at the level of Momo, Kazuha, Sakura just doesn’t make any sense at all. While Lia and Sieun not being able to sing well to save their life are somehow “better“☠️☠️☠️ Nothing against the two of them but the fact Lia got more hate than the whole itzy as singer (while being way better than all them) and Sieun being only recognized as a vocalist because of her (strained) high/whistle notes says a lot about their skill.
@Moonpak
27 күн бұрын
@@ggstan2439 Minnie, Mia and Sieun are Weak not Underdeveloped. Sounding good is just about vocal tone, technique is what matters. Jimin, Lisa, Dahyun, Sana and even Momo sound good and are stable that doesn't mean they are able to use the correct muscle to sing and hold the pitch, agility, control the breathing and then support the note (whether it is high or low). Minnie is nasal, that is, she has some problems with breathing control and agility too.
@Moonpak
27 күн бұрын
@@ggstan2439 In ‘Lion’ Minnie is strained. (B4, A4 straineds) (E4, A4 relaxeds) (E5 extremely unhealthy and strained)
@aeNaevisOfficial
27 күн бұрын
Mhh... NingNing has an average rap, I don't know why you deny it too much. I think you need more to see performances where she raps.. And winter was also missing, rn sm positioned her as the main vocalist with NingNing
@Moonpak
27 күн бұрын
Winter is not a Main Vocalist anymore, you can check Kprofiles. NingNing can't even be considered a rapper if she doesn't even rap consistently and frequently, plus she doesn't have any good flow, delivery or rhymes. All she has is a half-decent verse in ‘Drama’.
@dianaalejandraacostatorres3423
10 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak girl ningning can do anything kzitem.info/news/bejne/1Jqfy598s5l-lqgsi=pCzfdwzkRoO92mTg
@Bangpink1201
28 күн бұрын
Well Minnie and Rosé are interchangeable. Minnie average in two categories and below average in one. Rosé above average in one and below average in two. Minnie isn't above average in any category like Rosé and so is Rosé not being average. Both are same. Rosé is literal average in dance for me. She isn't like Lia who even lacks basic idol dancing. And Miyeon is just like Lia, just below average for me. So for me ,Rosé is average and has improved from her debut. Jk is 3rd/4th best in Sp in BTS. Jhope and V's stage presence are definitely better than him. Either its charisma, hyping, facial expressions etc. Jk is pretty similar with Jimin but sp is subjective so okay.
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
Rosé is Below Average is 2 categories. Sorry, but for me this is more important than being Above Average in one categorie. This is not a Idol Dancing ranking, that's why lacks basic Idol Dancing don't matter to me. Rosé lacks the basic of Urban Dance: groove, proper body control, coordination, and the basic of powerful moves (isolations, locks, etc.), just like Lia. Miyeon, at least, have some groove sections.
@Bangpink1201
28 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak no need to be sorry, it's ok. Ya I was just saying urban dancing is too far for Lia as she even lacks basic idol dancing.
@Moonpak
28 күн бұрын
@@Bangpink1201 Yeah, I understand, but Lia missing even Idol Dancing basics doesn't really matter to me. I mean Rosé is definitely better, but, ah... She's not enough to be average, not for me...
@Bangpink1201
28 күн бұрын
@@Moonpak yah got you. For me Rosé is average and for you she isn't. I am saying this after seeing her strength in urban dancing like footwork, musicality, artistry, consistency. Jennie is better than Nayeon but why everyone ranks her Lower because of her inconsistency. Consistency is somewhat important in urban style dancing and that's something Rosé has as a plus point. Still okay with your ranking 😊
@amethgonzalez471
27 күн бұрын
I hate when the rankings try to put rose a a terrible dancer and stage presence like????????? bruuuuuhhh, she's fucking amazing
Пікірлер: 122