Tbh if idol doesn't write their raps, the only categories you can use to evaluate them is flow and delivery
@FeelsLikeHeavenFeelsLikeHell
Жыл бұрын
I did that, but I divided delivery into breath control, flips and enunciation.
@feonix813
Жыл бұрын
so i have a few things to say. 1. I like your definition and interpretation of flow. it's similar to how i and a few ppl i talk to look at it as well. but i wanted to ask what methods you use to analyze flow 2. i don't quite understand 'flips'. is it ability to use different flows? different deliveries? 3. i think enunciation can just be part of delivery tbh. also, some rappers intentionally slur/don't properly enunciate for stylistic choices, for example Changbin, Suga, Bobby 4. i don't really agree with breath control being a criteria, a lot of k-pop rappers perform live while dancing, which can easily cause them to become short winded 5. i like 'rhymes' being included, not many people talk about rhyme scheme when it comes to k-pop rap 6. vocabulary and personal should just fall into the 'lyrics' category. but didn't you say you're not going to evaluate lyrics? 7. should freestyle really be a category? very few rappers in k-pop actually engage in freestyle. besides Han Jisung, Mark Lee, maybe RM, and perhaps some of the rappers who've been on shows like SMTM/Unpretty Rapstar (for ex. Mino/Soyeon/Bobby/Zico), i have yet to see anyone in k-pop freestyle raps. and even the ones who have done freestyle aren't outstanding, except for perhaps Mark Lee or Han Jisung. plus, there are many rappers outside of k-pop who don't freestyle and are still considered good. so maybe i'd reconsider including it as a criteria
@FeelsLikeHeavenFeelsLikeHell
Жыл бұрын
1) Thanks for that. I will take a look if the rapper is on the beat and not sounding out of tune. 2) Yes, it's that, but also the ability to adjust speed and enunciation. A good example of a rapper that can do flips well would be Eminem. 3) I divided enunciation into flips, breath control and enunciation as a way to be more transparent with how I analyse and be more perceptible about the flaws and strengths of each rapper. These stylistic choices, in rap battles, are considered a weakness if their use is a problem for understanding. It's the same way as how nasality is seen as a problem in vocal technique. 4) I will try to mostly use examples where they are standing still, but I can't ignore breath control since it can change the delivery and how it's received by the public. 5) Thanks. 6) I am not going to evaluate lyrics in KOREAN raps. I will if they write something in English. Also, I may analyse an English native rapper, so it's important to already define the criteria for that. 7) It's one of the most important things for a rapper, so it should be included. Not to mention that in this way I can showcase the difference between idol rappers and real rapper
@FeelsLikeHeavenFeelsLikeHell
Жыл бұрын
Freestyle doesn't define who it's a better rapper, but it counts and should matter. The same way agility and musicality do to a singer, or freestyle to a dancer.
@FeelsLikeHeavenFeelsLikeHell
Жыл бұрын
Still, rap started to gain popularity due to rap battles on streets. That's one of the abilities that should be apreciated and count to judge a rap. So, I will include that on my criteria. It's the same as judging a comedian based on their ability to make people laugh at the spot.
@FeelsLikeHeavenFeelsLikeHell
Жыл бұрын
Not that much, since Wendy - who doesn't have pitch issues - has more problems with runs than Taeyeon, who does have pitch issues. Another point is that if we go by that logic, freestyle should matter because it judges the ability of a rapper to write.
@IntrovertNopromises-wv9cs
Жыл бұрын
Just found your channel I agree with your vocals analysis but not your rap especially how high kpop rappers ranked they should be no more than 50 or 60 except for soyeon she is one of few actual rapper in kpop.tbh she is best female kpop rappers way better than Cl ,Jennie or Jessi
@FeelsLikeHeavenFeelsLikeHell
Жыл бұрын
I will change everything about the rap analysis I did until now. This is a new criteria that will be used from now on.
Пікірлер: 10