Agreed. I think almost all the One Punch Man redraws are more detrimental than helpful to the story. Not only do they often make prior events have less impact or just straight up make them worse, but they also make it kind of hard to keep up with what's canon and what's not anymore. When prior events of the story get changed every few months, it's hard to keep track of what actually happened and what didn't in this new "official" version of the story.
@kiratwo4u
7 ай бұрын
bro how does a random youtuber acts like like they can write better 😂😂😂. your videos are not even good
@caindain2179
6 ай бұрын
@@kiratwo4uYou stfu it’s just an opinion! Jesus Christ Like sure you can agree or disagree with someone, but at the end of the day. It’s One’s or Murata’s choice We can’t do jack shit about it
@Arcadia_warlic
6 ай бұрын
I think it is to set up future events that once they are all laid out make it more clear.
@Garvant_
10 ай бұрын
Damn i only read the version where he obliterated them and i thought it was so good how the disciples were like "i wonder how hes gonna save them" and amai masks just like "lmao im not" it was really good for his character. Murata is a godly artist but i think he needs to slow his roll with how much he changes stuff
@villagetale7450
11 ай бұрын
Your content is ELITE, keep up the good work.
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
Your kind words are truly appreciated! Thank you for the motivation
@messsop
11 ай бұрын
I agree, and not to mention, this redraw just ended up causing like five other chapters to need to be redrawn, which was completely unnecessary because, just like you said, the mercenaries served absolutely no purpose. All the redraws also made this arc last much longer than it needed to.
@Arcadia_warlic
6 ай бұрын
It did serve a purpose, showing Amai Mask's hesitation when Iaian tried to stop him.
@crow7976
11 ай бұрын
Great vid and I'm glad to see all the positive feedback you are getting despite there usually being this weirdly vocal mob of people that treat ONEs/Muratas final version of chapters as perfection and disregard any other opinion as nitpicks or hate for some reason.
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
I’m glad you enjoyed! Haha yeah I’m just as surprised as you, it’s really gratifying to see how many people share a similar opinion to ours
@Raymundosan
11 ай бұрын
I like the style of your videos essays. Keep up the good work subed👍
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
Your support is highly appreciated! I'm glad you enjoyed
@evronian1129
10 ай бұрын
He should've brought them back so that Gums could get the killing blow!
@boxinthejack2166
11 ай бұрын
8:43 I hate that part too, but I love how it shows that Pig God is one of the only genuinely kind S-Class heroes
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
True, Pig God is a gem.
@nicolasborges7905
11 ай бұрын
When I saw amaimask obliterate the heroes I got scared and thought "holy shit this guy isn't joking!" and then they release the redraw... Maybe they are trying to make the series more "family friendly", I don't like most redraws.
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
That’s what I think too and I absolutely hate it.
@abura2980
11 ай бұрын
One Punch Man should move to Jump+ then just like Chainsaw Man or Hell's Paradise
@zf2275
10 ай бұрын
i dont think we have to worry about that since we see monsters vaporized and get there tops blown off@@mediumbeetle9964
@NamelessDragon21
11 ай бұрын
As a one punch man fan I’m not as interested in it I think what really made me drop the manga was the personality change from earlier chapter garou to the garou we have after he surfaced I did like the part where he accidentally saved people but I feel like that should have been saved later in delivery man garou arc I know that he killed everyone with Radiation poisoning by getting gods powers but personally i think it would have been more personal if he fought all the heros there and showed them fear with true power with strength and fighting capabilities and without outside help I’m also kindof disappointed that garou’s arc is now just a joke in the manga I wish the manga did a lot more of show and not tell in garou’s story and a lot more darker in my personal opinion I think it would have been better if they use what happened in the webcomic like (garou fighting the S class and expanded it by showing garou fighting all the hero’s in the Ma raid including the S class and A class and B class hero’s and C class hero’s) and have saitama fight garou like he did in the webcomic while adding bigger feats to it while saitama is being casual and no genos death so the manga doesn’t back itself into a cornier like the who time travel thing TLDR the fight could have been more grounded Also I agree why remove this chapter of amai mask it seemed useless if they were just going to die later And your video was great a 10/10 it’d nice seeing opm content being critical of the manga and webcomic
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
You make good points, there was a lot of 'tell' rather than 'show' for garou. I also agree the 'saving stuff' coulda been saved for later on, although I felt like based on some of his previous good deeds, involving Tareo, and also stopping a mugging, it made enough sense to where could let it go. And while I don't like time travel stuff, I gave that part a pass cuz of how cool I thought the serious Saitama panels were. I don't think we ever saw him actually feel emotionally attached to anything for more than brief instances, so to see him lose his cool in that moment was pretty wild. Like it turns out Genos meant a lot to him, and I did appreciate that. But I did think the radiation was implemented to avoid Garou taking the entire raid party down, for sure. Also thanks for your stellar rating! Your support is tremendous!
@NamelessDragon21
11 ай бұрын
@@mediumbeetle9964 in my opinion I kindof didn’t mind the time travel stuff even tho it was just a way for the writer or artist of the opm manga to get out of a wall they put themselves in and the saitama be garou was epic like I liked when the chapter came out but in my opinion the webcomic had a more satisfying ending. I liked how they expanded and fleshed out on the characters in the story but I didn’t like the garou and metal bat team up I like that it was a reference to garou fighting him earlier but imp it kindof seemed out of character for garou to work with hero’s when in earlier chapters he wanted to take down the hero association the ma association arc was good but it had some problems in my opinion even in the webcomic it has some minor problems but i digress. Im more sad about the community of opm and how divided it got on one hand you have people who will defend the manga even if some of the things that don’t make sense and then argue that people who say they didn’t like it a webcomic enthusiasts or send death threats to one and the people who like the webcomic and stuff like that. And then there’s webcomic fans who defend the webcomic no matter what and call the people who don’t like it manga retards and send death threats to murata or people who like the manga. I’m honestly in the middle ground of one punch man I wished that the one punch man community would have an equal ground and agree and disagree in a civil argument instead of the community being divided like TLoU and the SW community Alright rant over are you ever going to review other series other than one punch man like chainsaw man or Vegabond and sorry if I didn’t respond earlier I was busy
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
@@NamelessDragon21 Lmaooo no worries, your rant is valid, and I also wish that the fanbase were more accepting of criticism. Cuz some people act like I'm not a fan just cuz I didn't like something. Blindly enjoying anything given to u is unhealthy. Uhh maybe chainsaw man at some point? Haven't read Vagabond yet, but a few of my friends have recommended it so I'll check it out. I might do a vid on why I enjoyed the live action remake of One Piece. Funny you mention TLoU, cuz I'm gonna do at least one video on why I thought the game was leagues better than the show. But atm, I have a few more OPM complaints I gotta deal with so I'll probably release 3-4 more of those before branching out to other mangas/shows
@NamelessDragon21
11 ай бұрын
@@mediumbeetle9964 I see thats nice anyways keep up the great work
@sxbmissive
11 ай бұрын
Actually an awesome video !! I haven’t read fully through the manga yet but I probably will now. I look forward to the new season in the anime too though. You make a lot of really good points as well. Keep up the good work ! PS., Your editing is actually so good too!!
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
Thanks so much! Your kind words mean the world. And yeah if you liked the show I'd definitely recommend reading it; as much as I may complain, the majority of it is really friggin good.
@DPDM44
11 ай бұрын
I should put more memery and funny into my videos, this one was really good to watch!
@hexlarroshin4598
11 ай бұрын
I somewhat agree with your video. However I kind of disagree about the situations where a mercenary got his arm ripped off and Iairon's arm getting destroyed. The difference is that the mercenary's arm got ripped off while, Iairon's arm got completely obliterated to the point that there was not anything left. If Melzagard was able to completely destroy rubble to bits, what is the chance of Iairon's arm surviving a hit from his strike. But overall I enjoyed your video. It's at least original compared to about 70% of OPM content on KZitem.
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
Ok that’s a fair point, I agree. I guess I was mainly trying to make the point that Murata put so much emphasis on this mission to save this guy’s arm when we’ve already seen people we care about more lose arms before. It just felt so unnecessary. But yeah, Iairon’s arm was probably destroyed haha.
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
And thanks for watching! I appreciate your keen observation skills
@GenUrobutcher
11 ай бұрын
Amai Mask was fine SOO dirty in the Manga. He was one of the MVPs in the webcomic, now is just a jobber in the Manga.
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
I don't mind that he lost to Fuhrer Ugly; he can't stand who he is beneath the surface, so FU was worst matchup possible for him. And I enjoyed seeing his face caved in and his body torn in half; all good stuff. Hopefully in this upcoming arc when he meets up with Saitama, he'll be done some justice.
@GenUrobutcher
11 ай бұрын
@@mediumbeetle9964 Bro Amai Mask was fighting Black S and Evil water simultaneously in the Webcomic, was literally praised by Atomic Samurai. Amai was pretty awesome in the Webcomic
@adonaimelles2317
11 ай бұрын
@@mediumbeetle9964 I feel the reason they retconned amai mask killing the mercenaries is so that amai mask wouldnt have innocent blood on their hands which they feel would make it hard for him to become human again/justify saitama behaving towards amai mask the way that he did in the wc by saying he didnt have any innocent blood on his hands
@adonaimelles2317
11 ай бұрын
@@GenUrobutcher I feel that this shows that if you let your guard down you can get fucked up plus the heroes are smarter in the manga version so they could notice that amai mask was a monster if they saw him continue fighting ( like him reattaching his arm
@GenUrobutcher
11 ай бұрын
@@adonaimelles2317 so the story just demolished his character. He was competent in the webcomic, now he is useless. Terrible writing.
@setleyeso
11 ай бұрын
Thanks man, more criticism of the atrocious retcons must be put out.
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
Don't worry, I guarantee this video won't be my last! I appreciate you
@abdaf8706
11 ай бұрын
Good vid, subbed
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
Thanks so much!
@bettysaccount
11 ай бұрын
Great video!
@mariotheguy123
11 ай бұрын
Wow so true!
@snowqueen_8958
7 ай бұрын
I wish they kept some of the gore in fhe manga..... It makes it more viseral and ahows how fucked monsters can be
@mediumbeetle9964
7 ай бұрын
I always appreciated that their monsters acted like monsters, and that they were legitimately dangerous
@snowqueen_8958
7 ай бұрын
@@mediumbeetle9964 exactly I was hoping that there was a lot of the og stuff kept in the manga i.e tank top master dieing and other things Can you do a video about Amai mask (I'm kinda an Amai mask fan hehe)
@mediumbeetle9964
7 ай бұрын
I plan on doing a Fuhrer Ugly video some time in the future, and within that I definitely plan on exploring Amai Mask’s character. Also idk if u read the webcomic but there’s gonna be some Amai Mask stuff coming up in the manga soon, so me talking about Amai Mask in depth is a strong possibility!😀
@snowqueen_8958
7 ай бұрын
@@mediumbeetle9964 nice I can't wait and the whole fight with FU and Amai mask was just fucked up Like he wasn't ready to fight FU like he was outmatched
@mediumbeetle9964
7 ай бұрын
The thing I love about it was that Amai wasn’t necessarily weaker, he was just unable to come to terms with FU’s ugliness. Which has to do with his own internal issues. Yeah, Sweet Mask’s character is one of my favorites too, he has such a unique and complex perspective. Doing a deep dive into his character is gonna be fun
@Yurie13
11 ай бұрын
tf.. they retcon a good chapter to make a shitty pondering story.. bruh I'm OK with redraws, like that child emperor mecha scene .. but this ain't it
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
If you’re talking about his fight with Phoenix Man, they redrew that too🤣. Making a video about that as well, although, like you said, some parts of that redraw had some merit
@myusername3689
11 ай бұрын
@@mediumbeetle9964If I remember correctly, it’s because Phoenix Man was too OP before the redraws.
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
@@myusername3689 He still has the power to resurrect the dead in the redraws, and NOW he has the power to teleport people into a spiritual plane of existence, so I think you may be a little off base in regards to nerfing his abilities. I'm gonna cover the ins and outs of that whole saga in the video after my next.
@myusername3689
11 ай бұрын
@@mediumbeetle9964I’m referring to the brilliant eagle mode mostly. But honestly, that mode and the fast, humanoid version of Orochi, probably shouldn’t have been redrawn.
@GBlockbreaker
11 ай бұрын
I hope Murata one day does the mother of all redraws by redrawing the entire Monster Association and Garou arc to be faithful to the original webmanga
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
If he did that then the Narinki squad still wouldn't die, so I will still be dissatisfied. I demand Narinki slaughter!
@bettysaccount
11 ай бұрын
🔥🔥🔥
@mrkiddlez391
6 ай бұрын
The anime adaptation would 10 years but when it comes i hope they go with the original chapters instead of the redraw
@Arcadia_warlic
6 ай бұрын
I think the point was that Amai Mask would never really be forgiven if the viewer knows he killed innocent people (the one Darkshine killed was likely beyond saving altogether), whilst in the redraw, it is still clear he was willing to, but now he has the added dynamic with Iaian which he did not have originally. Murata is not the writer, and the writing covers all shades.
@boxinthejack2166
11 ай бұрын
3:39 I’m pretty sure that executive guy was already dead. That monster drilled into his brain and used the guys corpse as a host.
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
It's possible, but unfortunately we'll never know for sure. As far as I could tell Destrochloridium only drills to enter the host; the brain could have remained intact while being controlled.
@nicolasborges7905
11 ай бұрын
Both Murata and One are to blame for the changes made
@mediumbeetle9964
11 ай бұрын
I'll remember to call out One as well in the next vid haha
@lixydead3665
9 ай бұрын
well let's think here and i came after 2 months because well i did not know better about such changing happened when i got back on reading manga the machine god 5 (aka the one who controlling it) shown interest in their suits and wanted to collected more data by emplying using them as dummies to fight(so maybe morata wanted to do something with that in future chapters who knows) along with that you would not take the samurais who known for their moral code would just listen to a pretty by saying he would do what ever it takes to kill the monster and they have to leave because it will get bloody redrawing was a mistake yes but at the same time not depending on how Morata will use it in the future + fan service of course comes to play the most memorable question in the fans and readers is the tasumaki wearing panties or not
@GigaGooberTheBoneless
7 ай бұрын
I have a theory, its just a stupid theory, but still. Maybe he redrew that scene for just 1 reason, it was not to change Amai's psychopathic personality, but he wants to keep it more of a secret in front of other people. In this case, Atomic Samurai's students were there. And if anyone knows that he kills humans without hesitation, that might hurt his career and reputation. But still, this is very unprobable, and he probably just changed it for pittyness
@mediumbeetle9964
7 ай бұрын
Actually, your theory is NOT stupid. I think that’s definitely a possible reason for the switch. But my counterargument to that is that the events after the slaughter could be written where either no-one found out what happened, or the bodies were found during the cleanup, leaving people unsure as to how they had died. Amai coulda been questioned, which coulda lead to some interesting dialogue and conflict. I think it was a huge missed opportunity regardless of the reason.
@caindain2179
6 ай бұрын
Again it’s just an opinion and opinions can be agreed or disagreed on But you gotta be honest It’s Murata’s choice.. HELL it wouldn’t be out of the question if One himself asked/demanded Murata to redraw it And we can’t do anything about it
Пікірлер: 69