Some new points here - kzitem.info/news/bejne/mLB4yKxtpWmAlo4
@FreePalestine_____
3 жыл бұрын
'Sister of Aron' issue: "oh sister of Aaron" what was coming out of the jews mouth whom saw saint Mary with her child and not as an statement from God telling us to whom mary was sister to. Quran does not state that Mary is the sister of Aaron, it quotes a man who said "Oh sister of Aaron" - sarcastically reminding her she is named after Miriam the sister of Aaron (and Moses). The Hadith also is consistent with this explaining that Maryam was named after Miriam. In their Bible, in the Gospel according to Luke, it says on the first page that Zakariyah(as) was married to Elizabeth, and Elizabeth was "of the daughters of Aaron (Harun(as))". Now if you look at their genealogies, they do not attribute any daughters to Harun(as), only four sons. And yet, in Luke, Elizabeth (who lived much later than Harun(as)), is given this title of being of the daughters of Aaron. This then has to be interpreted to mean that she is a descendant of Harun(as), through one of the sons of Aaron, via the female lineage that reached all the way to her time. So I'm always amazed that Christians criticize this. Because Mary and Elizabeth (peace upon them both) were actually contemporaries, and according to the Bible, they knew one another, and lived with each other for three months while (both) being pregnant (of Eesa and Yahya, respectively). So in their books, Elizabeth is called a daughter of Harun, and in our Book, Mary is called a sister of Harun. If the Quranic title is wrong, according to them, then they should apply this same 'logic' to their Bible, and reject Luke's title (for Elizabeth) as an error. It should be clear that the Jews at that time did in fact refer to honorable women by mentioning pious ancestors; and in this case, both are being connected to Harun(as).
@tzahi9671
3 жыл бұрын
You got to be kidding me
@tzahi9671
3 жыл бұрын
Read sura 66:12 please and tell me if sister of aharon and Amram's daughter is talking about another miryam.
@hsdjsdshdhsdnsmsd6247
2 жыл бұрын
Calling someone "son/daughter of xy" who is actually a great-great-great-great-grand-son/daughter is not a mistake. Great-great-great-great-children are still children. Luke obviously didnt believe that Elizabeth is the literal daughter of Aaron. However the author of the Koran seems to believe that Mary is the literal sister of Aaron. Why is the Koran saying that her father was Imran?
@IbrahimKhan-ri6qx
2 жыл бұрын
@@hsdjsdshdhsdnsmsd6247 no it didn’t lmao, it wasn’t even Allah saying that but He was quoting the people. And if the Quran messed up we would have seen that mistake in Moses peace be upon him story but it never does... I wonder why
@hsdjsdshdhsdnsmsd6247
2 жыл бұрын
@@IbrahimKhan-ri6qx Surah 3 clearly says that Mary is the daughter of Imran.
@Servant-Of-Al-Qudus
Жыл бұрын
Mughira ibn Shu’ba reported: When I came to Najran, the Christian monks asked me, “You recite The Verse, ‘O sister of Harun,’ (19:28) but Musa was born long before Isa by many years.” When I came back to the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, I asked him about it and he said, “Verily, they used to name people with the names of Prophets and Righteous people who had passed before them.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2135 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Muslim Ibn Kathir said, “This is like saying to somebody from the Tamimi tribe: O brother of Tamim, or to somebody from the Mudari tribe: O brother of Mudar.” Source: Tafsīr Ibn Kathīr 19:28
@osuclassof88
Ай бұрын
this question was raised by Christians and was answered 1400 years ago
@brokenangel7972
3 жыл бұрын
to every christian your bible said that the man who was with mary called joseph son of jacob ..... was him the prophet or their name is the same ? .... Easily, and according to Quran and islamic sources .... Imran has two daugters and one boy .... Marie . Elizabeth and Aaron.... so quran explains clealy that this marie not sister of moses ... finally , don't give me your bible to prove that's wrong beacuse I don't believe in your bible
@brokenangel7972
3 жыл бұрын
@@tzahi9671 Here is my article ..... Some Christians say that the Qur’an said that Mary is the daughter of Imran, and this is similar to Moses’s sister. They say it is mixed ... well, we will come with evidence from the Bible about the similarity of the names with the prophets and the previous ones ---------------------------------------------------------- First: Joseph son of Jacob (mary's man) "And Jacob begat Joseph, the man of Mary, from whom Jesus, who is called the Messiah, was born - Matt 1:16 And Heli is Jacob's brother, he died without having children, so Jacob married his brother's wife , as is the practice in the Old Testament. Therefore, he is the natural father of Joseph (His name is completely identical to the name of Prophet Joseph in his name "joseph" and father's name "jacob") ----------------------------------------------------------------- secondly: judah son of jacob Judah was one of Jesus' followers note:James is Jacob in hebrew but in english it is james in hebrew it is jacob and original is Jacob "" Judas son of James, and Judas Iscariot, who became a traitor." Luke 6:16 this verse according to new international version (His name is completely indentical to the name of Prophet Joseph's brother in name judah and father's name jacob) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1-Now we have Joseph and judah (during time of jesus) their names and father's name are exactly the same with names of sons of prophet jacob's sons (joseph and judah) .... did bible mix between them as they did with mary and merriam ?? because their names are similar ! let's see what our prophet say about both of mary and merriam about similarty Mughira b. Shu‘ba reported: When I came to Najran, they (the Christians of Najran) asked me: You read "O sister of Harun" in the Qur'an, whereas Moses was born much before Jesus. When I came back to Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) I asked him about that, whereupon he said: "The (people of the old age) used to give names (to their persons) like the names of Apostles and pious persons who had gone before them." (meanning that Aaron in this verse another one not brother of moses) here our prophet explained that .. 1-The Jews gave names to their sons like the names of the prophets and the righteous because they were very imitated by them so both of mary and merriam not the same 2-when Quran said " O sister of Aaron" .. Aaron here wasn't brother of moses but another Aaron and was brother of mary 3-Imran father of mary gave names to his son and his daughter like First Imran (father of moses) because he was imitated by him - some will ask but bible didn't mention that mary had a brother ? Ok we don't have to believe in bible none can take the bible to prove things was right or Wrong :) - Aaron who was Mary's brother, he was from another mother Because Mary's mother was barren -finally christians have no right to say this is mix because their bible has the same thing with Judah (follower of christ) , Joseph(mary's man) and Judah and joseph ( sons of Prophet jacob)
@drewtraver2947
Ай бұрын
Muhammad believed in the Bible. He affirmed the preservation of it as the word of God too. You're not a Muslim are you? Why is an atheist like you making this argument? If you are Muslim than happy 100th year anniversary to your Cairo edition Hafs Quran.
@muezamueza2797
2 жыл бұрын
1). Mary and Miriam are different Christians apologist often question a confusion between Mary mother of Jesus and Miriam sister of Moses. They often use this issue as an big mistake in Quran and an undeniable proof that Quran is wrong. This problem has been answered by the prophet himself more than 1400 year ago. Mughira ibn Shu’ba reported: When I came to Najran, the Christian monks asked me, “You recite the verse, ‘O sister of Aaron,’ (19:28) but Moses was born long before Jesus by many years.” When I came back to the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, I asked him about it and he said, “Verily, they used to name people with the names of prophets and righteous people who had passed before them.” (Sahih Muslim 2135) Ibn Kathir said, “This is like saying to somebody from the Tamimi tribe: O brother of Tamim, or to somebody from the Mudari tribe: O brother of Mudar.” 2). In the Bible Elizabeth is Daughter Aaron and in the Quran Marry is daughter of Imran The four Gospels do not mention who is Marys Father. But Gospel of Luke began his birth story for Mary with a birth story for Mary Cousin “Elizabeth daughter of Aaron”. In the days of Herod king of Judaea, there was a priest named Zacharias of the priestly class of Abijah; his wife was of the daughters of Aaron and her name was Elizabeth. They were both righteous before God, walking in all the commandments and ordinances of the Lord blameless… Luke 1:5-6. Mary cousins, Elizabeth is not daughter of Aaron, so this title of Elizabeth in the Bible can have two meanings 1) Elizabeth father was a Priest from Priestly House of Aaron lineage. 2). Elizabeth is daughter of Aaron in lineage. If you accept Elizabeth was called Daughter of Aaron in the Bible, why do you object Quran called Mary daughter of Imran. This title of Mary in mother of Jesus the Quran could also have two consequences 1) Mary’s father was a priest from priestly family of Imran father of Aaron 2) Mary is daughter of Imran in lineage. 3) Mary is definitely not sister of Aaron but she is sister in lineage. In the Qur’an Mary father name is Imran a priest from priestly family of Imran, Remember what prophet has said, “Verily, they used to name people with the names of prophets and righteous people who had passed before them.” Mary’s father name Imran is different from Joachim a name in the apocryphal Bible. Since anything apocrypha’s are all banned by the church, we can ignored Joachim name as Mary’s father. We stick to Islamic tradition that Mary’s father is Imran, a priest from Imran priestly family. 3). Genealogy of Jesus was Wrong The four Gospels do not mention who is Marys Father. Is that a problem ?. Why is that ?. Marry is Theotokos, is Her father not important to be mentioned .... hahaha. In the gospels of Matthew and Luke there are two versions of Jesus lineage that are disconnected and funny. Those who made this genealogy must have made it up. It shows the Geneology of Joseph, not Jesus because Joseph is not Jesus' father. Tribemanship in the Jewish nation is descended from the father's line. Since Jesus has No father, Therefore it is impossible for Jesus to be a descendant of David. Although his mother may have descended from David From marys mother, but marys father was priest. Jesus could not be called king because he had no father. Joseph is not his father. Jesus could only claim descent from his mother. That's why in the Quran Jesus is often called Isa Ibn Maryam. Jesus son of Mary. Jesus was not decendant of David, therefore he cannot be the promised-kingly mesiah. That's why in the Gospel of Matthew 16:20, it is told Jesus ask His disciples not to tell anyone that He is the Messiah. Why did Jesus Forbid his disciples to call him mesiah in public ? Jesus knew the messiah had to be a descendant of David, while he had no father to claim the lineage of David. So Muslims have known this story for a long time. It's a pity that there are billions of Christians do not know that Jesus is not the promised Kingly Messiah, because he is not decendant of David. But muslim know that He is a prophet and a priestly mesiah. 4). Conclusion The purpose of Maryam being called Aaron’s sister and Imran's daughter is to confirm that she is Imran daughter and that Imran is a descendant of Imran who is Aaron's father. No one can disprove that. Jesus was a rabbi, that's irrefutable proof that he was like his ancestors Aaron and Imran, they were all Levites. Jesus was not a descendant of David, he could not be the promised kingly-messiah.
@prophetic_dreams_and_visions
8 ай бұрын
So a clear contradiction and error made you stronger in your faith?! How now! hahaha
@MohammadQasim
8 ай бұрын
Maybe you missed it, in reality it wasnt. They were 'Apparent contradictions'. Hence the weak attacks of the opponent strengthen his faith
@jesterblue6466
22 күн бұрын
Dude saw the title , skipped the video and commented .... 😮💨
@joexviii8662
2 жыл бұрын
Huge problem with this interpretation. The Quran claims to be a confirmation for the children of Israel. So when they read ‘Maryam sister of Aaron’ in chapter 19 or the family of Imran being mentioned as chosen, they are familiar with those terms. Instead today, we have a radically different interpretation. Family of Imran doesn’t include Moses but just ‘Mary’ and ‘Jesus’. So Moses gets excluded from his own Father despite being the most important prophet in the Quran as someone who supposedly spoke to God? Just for the sake of keeping this idea that Isa and Musa are not from the same era. I don’t think Isa is the Jesus we know of today. I’m not claiming the Quran is in error, perhaps there’s been some tampering with historical timelines.
@MohammadQasim
2 жыл бұрын
Sadats video sheds more light on it kzitem.info/news/bejne/mLB4yKxtpWmAlo4
@joexviii8662
2 жыл бұрын
@@MohammadQasim I’ve watched it. I’m still thoroughly convinced Isa is nephew of Harun.
@MohammadQasim
2 жыл бұрын
@@joexviii8662 if ur conclusion doesnt lead to quran being in error or hadith, then what possibility wouldnt be a deal for me. Main thing is, when a alternative *possible* interpretation exists then it can not be class as an error
@Needlestolearn
2 жыл бұрын
I’ve also came to this same conclusion, even in the gospel there hints that Mary and Isa might of lived at the same times as Moses and aaron. Ie Elizabeth who is the daughter of aaron. However, it could also suggest that Mary and Miriam both had the same name for their brother and father.
@Needlestolearn
2 жыл бұрын
@@MohammadQasim the Quran isn’t in error, but the Hadiths and tafsir should be questioned, as they make the prophet out to be someone who didn’t know who was Mary. And that people were at his time were confused regarding these ayats.
@tzahi9671
3 жыл бұрын
Read sura 66:12. Amram's daughter too. Explain that please
Doesnt the Quran say that the Israelites escaped from egypt and went to Israel? So the author of the Quran could have thought that Moses is the uncle of Jesus. This is supported by the fact that Mary is also called daughter of Imran.
Muslim lies !!!! Tafsir ibn khatir Quran Donate Kat . 3.35-36 The Story of Maryam's Birth The wife of ` Imran mentioned here is the mother of Maryam , and her name is Hannah bint Faqudh . Muhammad bin Ishaq mentioned that Hannah could not have children and that one day , she saw a bird feeding its chick . She wished she could have children and supplicated to Allah to grant her offspring . Allah accepted her supplication , and when her husband slept with her , she became pregnant . She vowed to make her child concentrate on worship and serving Bayt Al Maqdis ( the Masjid in Jerusalem ) , when she became aware that she was pregnant. WHY PEOPLE MUSLIM LIE ???? HUGE MISTAKE IN THE QURAN
@MohammadQasim
Жыл бұрын
Wheres the lie
@doubleshadow4748
Жыл бұрын
@@MohammadQasim IMRAN IS THE REAL FATHER OF MARYAM MOTHER OF ISSA That mean huge mistake ! IMRAN father of aaron and moussa ! The same one ! He cannot be the father of maryam mother of issa !!!!!
@MohammadQasim
Жыл бұрын
@@doubleshadow4748 You need to learn how to read sources, lets say ibn kathir held both shared the same father, why is ibn kathir view divinely chosen? He isnt a prophet he can mk mistakes #reflect
@doubleshadow4748
Жыл бұрын
@@MohammadQasim in the quran surah 3 verse 35 and 36 ! Please read ! Who is the husband of the mother of mary ? If he is the husband of the mother of mary , he is the father of mary !
@MohammadQasim
Жыл бұрын
@@doubleshadow4748 why cant two families share same father name Watch this kzitem.info/news/bejne/mLB4yKxtpWmAlo4
Пікірлер: 47