“Path is much more relaxed” *laughs in Adolescent*
@KaliMontenegro
3 ай бұрын
LOL if your just trying to grow in pot people just don't care and will kill you even if they won't get alot meat or a trophy💀
@jurassicjuice2479
Ай бұрын
@@KaliMontenegrohate it when that happens
@selite5007
Ай бұрын
path is aas
@christiancastillo-tamayo495
Ай бұрын
@@selite5007 your spelling is aas (also respect your opinion, but it isn’t welcome if your reason is ass lmao)
@selite5007
Ай бұрын
@@christiancastillo-tamayo495 path is still ass tho
@kearsargeyt8848
5 ай бұрын
Ignoring the lags and bad optimisation. I think we all can agree that the reasons that Path of Titans is more popular is either because it’s more accessible or arguably more developed, relatively speaking. Not a solid superiority.
@tandava-089
5 ай бұрын
Path is to The Isle what Roblox is to Minecraft >.>
@TheKingofCoral
5 ай бұрын
@@tandava-089no Roblox is an app where you can play games Minecraft is a game completely different and a terrible example
@MrTickles445
5 ай бұрын
The isle is still a bad game. Bad gameplay loop and it’s infested with hackers. No amount of graphics and animations can change that.
@tandava-089
5 ай бұрын
@@MrTickles445 I mean, It doesnt have a bad gameplay loop, although it needs more 'end game' content. People can nest, they just choose to be impatient pvp trolls. Also, not everyone feels that way anyways(that the gameplay loop is bad, even with 'bad' 'endgame'). I think the gameplay loop is not only fine, its WAY more finished and WAY better than POT by every metric and its not even close in any way. And that has nothing at all to do with graphics or animations.(or movement, or combat more broadly and dynamically, or resource management, all of which the isle has in spades over pot)
@MrTickles445
5 ай бұрын
@@tandava-089 I mean, majority of the isle comments refer to graphics and animations being much better than pots which is very true but doesn’t change the fact that the game is still poop. The game play loop is quite boring because you spend a few hours growing which only when you’re fully grown is when you start having fun and I wish there was customization to your Dino’s in terms of abilities and gameplay styles like BoB or pot.
@D1rt_Block
5 ай бұрын
I remember when path of titans was new and The Isle was the best dinosaur survival game at the time
@christianfernando4070
5 күн бұрын
The isle continues to be
@SaurianCYH
5 ай бұрын
PoT's dinosaur models aren't especially unique, but are more grounded and informed by modern science, thus attracts a certain audience who don't want to see dinosaurs thirty years out of date (cough, omniraptor)
@goldfishmentality
5 ай бұрын
Definitely. Although I think they get way too much wrong to be called a realistic dinosaur game, which is unfortunate
@alunaticwithashotgun9840
5 ай бұрын
@@goldfishmentality PoT's realism ends with the accuracy of it's dinosaur designs. Because when you try to make everything else realistic you get The Isle's performance and along with pretty much every balance problem it has.
@dr.archaeopteryx5512
5 ай бұрын
@@alunaticwithashotgun9840 Realism works on a "good enough" principle, and even the biggest realism nut will prefer optimisation and 'game design existing whatsoever' over "realism". What you want is immersion; not realism.
@StelloTyrannus
5 ай бұрын
Paths designs aren’t perfect. While for the most part they are good, there’s a few nitpicks. For one ankylosaurs cannot move their tails that high vertically, so Anos tail slam in reality would be unfeasible to achieve. Hadrosaurs also likely couldn’t kick like horses. Maybe a cow like kick if anything but their forelimbs are far too small for them to do what they do in game.
@freddiewilliams3589
5 ай бұрын
Tbf they do update the models like with lambeo and struthio. And if they're still not updated you can have modded redesigns like with pachy, eotrike and rex. Modding can be a mixed bag but there are still some pretty impressive designs that have come out or are in development.
@JELONGreatMrRed
2 ай бұрын
PoT community servers are becoming a VRChat but with dinosaurs.
@DokuroHeartvore
Ай бұрын
So... Feral Furries? Nice!
@peabrain6872
Ай бұрын
Where are you seeing this
@agustinf1372
2 ай бұрын
The isle struggles with the lack of content (dinos) + a map that is completlely empty, you can run for hours without finding ANYTHING
@peabrain6872
Ай бұрын
Pots preformance is pretty much perfect now, no rubberbanding with 200 players
@MoistW
5 ай бұрын
imo path of titans is better its gotten more updates in a year then the isle could ever have in 14 years
@halfslyced
5 ай бұрын
More doesn't necessarily mean better. Quality > Quantity. And both games suffer from opposite ends of that spectrum.
@SamuRhino2023
5 ай бұрын
I’m assuming you mean the Isle has better quality? 🤨 What kind of Zara r u on and can I have some?
@MoistW
5 ай бұрын
@@SamuRhino2023 isle overall looks better the shi im on lives in africa
@halfslyced
5 ай бұрын
@@SamuRhino2023 the isle has objectively better graphics/lighting/effects. And Path of Titans has a significantly more amount of content. Both games however suffer from their fair share of bugs and connectivity issues. The Isle has horrible optimization and fps... Whereas PoT has incredible desync problems.
@SebastianTuscano
5 ай бұрын
But you can't randomly die to cliffs
@mmmontanhez
5 ай бұрын
One important thing every creator misses about afordability is regionalization. While to (i.e) US players 20 to 30 dollars isn't THAT much of a difference, for third world players using steam the difference is MUCH bigger. In Brazil, The Isle costs 37 reais (Roughly 4,5 dollars) while Path of Titans is 150 reais (30 dollars).
@goldfishmentality
5 ай бұрын
yes, it is quite an issue that POT doesn't have regionalized pricing
@jesustitan-qf9un
Ай бұрын
yap
@rafaela6803
Ай бұрын
Yeah, I'm brazilian and I was very surprised when I discovered the price of The Isle. With such immersive graphics, I expected it to be much more expensive
@zainyfasanyanorris9023
5 ай бұрын
Whos stayed with the isle ever since evrima and enjoys as it slowly gets better bit by bit I need this as reassurance cuz we Are Rare 🗣 🗿
@crabhater9373
5 ай бұрын
🗿🤝🗿 I've been here since the isle was on steam greenlight. It's been forever, but hopefully they roll up their sleeves and make some banger updates for 2024. We could use an update 3.0 sized W
@generalgrievous3729
4 ай бұрын
Only reason i still play isle is because some of my friends invite me to play
@gothic-edgy-rat
4 ай бұрын
Why did you capitalize the “A” in “Are”
@MasterOogway1894
3 ай бұрын
@@gothic-edgy-rat because Are
@theoneandonlyZef
2 ай бұрын
my relationship with the isle is extremely toxic, i run on 20fps, i lag a lot, and the devs often do weird bullshit, but ive stuck with it since the first build of evrima
@MrTickles445
5 ай бұрын
I’d say none of these games are worth buying until more content gets added. If you really feel inclined to buy one of these early access games, then path has more freedom and is more forgiving
@mikehawkhovers9872
5 ай бұрын
I can't say for ISLE but i can say you are missing out in PoT 😉
@thatoneweirdbish6364
Ай бұрын
I know I'm really late to the party but I really dont get the hate between both player bases. The games are so fundamentally different so ofc people will enjoy one experience over the other. I personally play PoT because i enjoy the more casual experience of it and am not a huge fan of intricate survival mechanics and intense atmosphere but I'd never harp on anyone who prefers that, obviously. People need to learn how to get along, this goes for both communities
@yanceymcdonald6017
2 ай бұрын
As a player who owns both games, the only reason path of Titans is more popular is because of accessibility. If you’re looking for realism or even a trace of a survival game, don’t even bother with Path of Titans. That’s not at all what it is. If you wanna run around for hours, searching for collecting pinecones and mushrooms as a dinosaur. Then path of Titans is for you. All of the detractors from evrima complain about the fact that you have to restart when you die. Surprise! that’s what happens when you’re playing a survival game. If I could get my money back for Path of Titans, I would. Oh sidenote, the community in path of Titans isn’t any more welcoming than the Isle. I’ve had way more toxic interactions with other players in path of Titans.
@WhyAmIHereUAsk
20 күн бұрын
theres amazing community server which provides realism and most of them have a time growth officials are hard but the point of questing is to encourage players to get out of the hotspot or to not afk (still has hotspot but less)
@SnuffMumriken
2 ай бұрын
Path is rewarding to play mean while The Isle punishes you
@zelandy1628
Ай бұрын
I mean path is more of a mmo and the isle is a horror survival
@zelandy1628
Ай бұрын
@@Chaos_insurancy it’s just a guy kissing his baby what’s wrong about that? 🤔
@Chaos_insurancy
Ай бұрын
@@zelandy1628 I just realized it right now, I'm so sorry.
@zelandy1628
Ай бұрын
@@Chaos_insurancy you don’t need to be it’s just a joke 😂
@RoyalTheRebel
5 ай бұрын
I mean the isle will be great... in 10 years at current dev time. Don't ever be hyped up for promised features in it and take it for what is in it right now. After you get bored return to it in a couple years and get a a couple new viable dinos to try out. POT with its modding scene and faster dev time lets you experience vastly more content with the drawback that its lower quality and much less immersive. Finally any comparrison would be pointless without mentioning that path has something to do whilst you grow, its repetative and literally collecting rocks flowers etc, but it forces people to not sit in bushes for up to 5 hours taking up afk slots (for a fatal error to occur or constant frame drops to kill you, then repeat) such as what you see in the isle. This causes much more pvp hunts to occur with dinos below full adult stage and makes the game not just a glorified waiting simulator.
@DiamynNotDiamond
5 ай бұрын
I'd personally never play Path Of Titans unless I was gifted it, and even then it wouldn't replace the time I spend in The Isle mostly because of the base game growth being an absurdly long fetch quest. My other reason is community servers since like you said lots of players don't treat it like a survival game and I've dealt with enough rule servers and admin abuse in my legacy Isle days to ever want to touch it again and no rule servers tend to be just as painful if not worse.
@cnaro8073
3 ай бұрын
Isle growth takes waay longer and is way more boring imo
@zelandy1628
Ай бұрын
@@cnaro8073ion wanna do quests and get killed by mixpacks
@frank2510
Күн бұрын
Well, enjoy PoT officials. Come back to us later 😂😂
@alunaticwithashotgun9840
5 ай бұрын
2:02 Eeeeh, launch day Cyberpunk was worse in my opinion, and it was made by a massive tripple-A studio like CD Project Red, they messed up so bad that they completely abandoned some of the very big promises they made, the game turned out pretty good anyway but that's not my point here, with The Isle devs we are yet to see how the game ends up, so far it looks like they are making slow but steady progress towards what they have promised. Also I'd make features category a tie, mostly because it's subjective, for example if I was going off of my own prefferences I'd give The Isle 1 point and then give PoT a -2, not because it's bad but because it's just not what I prefer in what's supposed to be a dinosaur survival game. Edit: Also an important thing that needs to be mentioned is that even if there was a scenario where both games fixed literally all their problems and were completely perfect a lot of people would probably dislike one of them. The Isle will at the end of the day be a hardcore horror survival game, and PoT is... Well I don't really know what PoT is trying to be but it's certainly not THAT. And that's an awesome thing to have, because this way technically everyone should be happy, like if you like one of them and don't like the other it is quite pointless to argue about which one is better, people should just enjoy what they enjoy and STOP BEING AN ASS, and that applies to both PoT's community and The Isle's. Like yea I don't like PoT AND THAT'S WHY I DON'T PLAY IT, IT'S NOT THAT BIG OF A DEAL !
@daffierpython7755
Ай бұрын
Pot is meant to be a mmo rpg, so think kinda like rainbow 6, your supposed to mix certain species together gor the best outcome not what is just the strongest, and pot is meant to be much more team based of course
@StelloTyrannus
5 ай бұрын
This is a very well summed up video, well establishing why people play one game or the other. A point I wanna add is that performance for the isle, at least in my experience, isn’t always bad, but granted I have good specs. It differs per update, but there have been times for me where it ran amazingly. It’s also great seeing that the devs have said and shown that they want to improve performance and eliminate bugs. This is the whole point of the next update that is currently hoardetesting. In the end though, I honestly don’t think there’s much to compare with both games as they are very different experiences from one another. Just play what you like. There is nothing wrong if you dislike the other, OR if someone likes the other and you don’t.
@hellaem6947
4 ай бұрын
I agree with you, there are very different games. Sometimes I feel like POT players that were previously playing The Isle were playing The Isle because there were no games like POT at the time.
@InkGraffiti
Ай бұрын
It's known that Dondi is a jurassic park fanboy. I legit wonder if the beipi being semi aquatic is PURELY because in the JP books it is mentioned they for whatever reason were most often found near river deltas.. the book doesn't talk about them beyond that, just that they were near rivers, so Dondi may have just gone with that concept and gave them a reason to follow rivers haha paleo inaccurate or not.. i love beipi, its a great playable
@Bread-Sliced
5 ай бұрын
In my personal experience I enjoy The Isle far more than PoT (No I’m not saying I support the Dondi or anything like that), it’s just my kind of game. PoT I will admit is in a far better place than The Isle I just find PoT…Bland. It doesn’t feel like an actual survival game. (Yes I know it’s an MMO but everyone calls it a survival game) The Isle and Path of Titans are two completely different beasts and sometimes I feel like it’s rather unnecessary to compare the two.
@joeyvanberkom148
4 ай бұрын
Im sticking with the Isle because, it encapsulates everything I want in a dinosaur. Sure SOME of the developers are assholes but, some of them aren't. Also some people don't understand how hard it is to make pretty in-depth mechanics. What I love about the Isle is that each dino has a unique playstyle and character. I will happily wait a bit longer for dinosaurs when they actually have unique mechanics. Path of Titans feels just really bland for me and I absolutely despise the quest system and the game just feels way less immersive which is what I want in a dinosaur game.
@cr7careca645
5 ай бұрын
Path and the Isle are totally different proposals from each other, the Isle is unfortunately a very good and much superior game, but today Path is a much more enjoyable game because of the mods, the mods help make players more patient, the island unfortunately doesn't have mods and when the update comes, people play for about 4 weeks and stop and go back to the path because of the mods, which makes me upset and the island is still in beta and will continue in 10 years and until then path will continue to grow and the island also I think that with rex arriving I think it will boom
@Bleghspread
5 ай бұрын
Ah, talks about superiority again. None of these games is superior over another. It is all about preferences and, what is more important, about the accessibility. I have friends who told me straightaway that they would like to play TI more, but they simply cannot enjoy the game with such low framerate. The game cannot be even launched due to the Dx12 issue for vast numbers of players. Someone who can either play one or look at desktop icon of the other one is going to make very quick decision and that is pretty much it.
@sporepics
5 ай бұрын
You support Dondi?
@gothic-edgy-rat
4 ай бұрын
The Isle isn’t really better it just has different goals in what your supposed to do
@ccloudleaf
4 ай бұрын
Use more punctuation please!
@KillianJeydel
3 ай бұрын
tbh when it comes to quality between the isle and path I always think that the isle is more realistic looking while path always seemed a bit cartoony to me.
@TTutt92
Ай бұрын
Calling out my procrastination earned a like and I loved it
@MassimoTheVenetian
Ай бұрын
I loved playing The Isle back 6-7 years ago on the Grim Expanse desert map, that felt like such a unique and refreshing experience. I tried reinstalling the game about a year ago and now it just feels like I'm wandering around an empty forest achieving nothing.
@xHugoxN7
4 ай бұрын
I've finally given up on the Isle.
@hugevasectomy5505
2 ай бұрын
11:30 more development time? It's been in development for almost 10 years now, I thinks it's safe to say that the Isle will forever be a broken promise. My guess is that another bigger developer will fill the needs of both POT and The Isle and ultimately make the Isle dead and POT a very niche game. Hopefully we get a triple A dino survival game in the vein of these two but I don't think that will be for a while unfortunately
@flightlesslord2688
5 ай бұрын
Bob feels the most complete imo. But can feel clunkier. POT takes the piss with some of its DLC, but the Isle's dev teams leaves something to be desired. And my laptop cant run it anywhere near as well as BOB or POT. So for me, POT is maybe more fun, but BOB is a better game. But as much as POT can be a walking sim, ive had the most fun with it
@patrox2529
5 ай бұрын
i always wanted to play dinosaur survival game in realistic way, got about 30 hours on the isle, couldnt find any good realism servers, and i disliked some designs. Suprisingly i found many great hard realism servers on PoT and im still enjoying them.
@highlightning6693
Ай бұрын
I bought The Isle and the game launcher kept crashing because of the "Easy anti-cheat isn't installed" error. Tried several possible work arounds to get it to launch and nothing worked. I had 0 interest in spending indefinite hours trying to fix it and got my money back. That error is at least 3 years old and they haven't fixed it.
@crabhater9373
5 ай бұрын
I don't hate Path of Titans but I'll always put the isle first. That's not because I'm an isle stan, but because I don't even consider path of titans to be a creature survival game. It's survival mechanics are mid at best and the questing system is completely pointless. When I play pot it tastes like a big fat nothing burger. There's quite a lot of mechanics but none of them feel satisfying to engage with. From a fundamental level, I think the pot gameplay loop is dull and repetitive. While The Isle tries and fails most of the time to create a creature survival game, Path of Titans doesn't even try. It's essentially a roleplaying game pretending to be a survival game.
@goldfishmentality
5 ай бұрын
It's really just not a survival game, or at least, the community prevents it from being one
@zainyfasanyanorris9023
5 ай бұрын
Fax
@tandava-089
5 ай бұрын
@@goldfishmentality Its design literally cannot handle meaningful combat. Its a dinosaur skinned chat room. Which is fine. But it isnt a survival game at all, and its not like.... a REAL game. Its a game in the way minigames and phone games are games.... Sure.... its technically a game. Sort of. But not really really.
@Louvenoire05
5 ай бұрын
I wish I had a good computer to play the Isle. Path of Titans is not really what I thought it was going to be, I’ve learned to like it. But I would like to try a real Dino survival game, Path of Titans is definitely not that.
@gothic-edgy-rat
4 ай бұрын
They’re actually reworking the Questing system to be better currently and are reworking planning to rework dinosaurs. Also PoT is only around 4 years old, it’s still a new game. PoT is a MMO RBG not technically a straight survival game and the developers update the game frequently, the game actually got a huge update a few days ago.
@trik6979
5 ай бұрын
The Isle is simply not worth it. It demands a expensive rig to run, and even on that, the optimization is actually awful. it takes FOREVER to have updates. the community is super toxic. the devs are super toxic. there's hackers running rampant on the OFFICIAL servers. the actual gameplay is super boring (the only thing to do is eat,drink,fight, nothing more) the game will probably never leave early access, let alone be finished. So, while PoT is not perfect, i genuinely believe is a better investment. It actually gets updates on a regular basis it has mod support. optimization is actually good. while the community is also not perfect, but its nowhere near as toxic as The Isle one. the devs don't antagonize the community or gaslight them. can be played on multiple platforms. while the quest system is not perfect (its gonna get revamped), you actually has stuff to do in-game besides the usual (eat,drink,fight) and they just announced they're working on different gamemodes. so yeah... it kinda saddens me, but i wouldnt recommend The Isle. Talking as someone who played it for 5+ years.
@goldfishmentality
5 ай бұрын
If you want a game, get POT. If you want a ticket to SOON tm, with the potential of having the best dinosaur survival game eventually, get the isle
@trik6979
5 ай бұрын
@@goldfishmentality exactly, PoT is a great game now. The Isle is the Promise of a great game, in the far future.
@Bleghspread
5 ай бұрын
What exactly are those other things one can do in Path?
@tandava-089
5 ай бұрын
@@goldfishmentality Shit, with logic like that, you could just play finished games like solitaire >.>..... about as exciting Some(Many) of the best gameplay experiences Ive had ever has been in the isle. To say its not a functionally finished game is... stirring the pot to be sure... But also blatantly dishonest. Like I said, pot is more done in the same way solitaire or minesweeper is complete.... Still what the isle has already is more total and final than solitaire, minesweeper, or pot. And unfortunately for pot, thats baked into the design. The Isle DESIGNED itself with room to grow. Pot could make an actually engaging gameplay loop(something the isle is doing organically through their hunger system, something that while not flawless now, is actually incredibly well balanced.... The isle in the past 6-12 months has improved in quality by orders of magnitude) But putting that aside, its movement, its animations, and its combat CANT be good enough(to ever be taken seriously by anything but children and people playing games on their phone on the toilet), as a function of how the game itself was built
@BloodPlusPwn
24 күн бұрын
I play em both but honestly PoT is just The Isle waiting room for when it's done. They are slow as molasses but every single update is pretty banging and in a few years it's going to be so far ahead of everything it won't even be a consideration imo
@KaliMontenegro
3 ай бұрын
One thing pot and the isle players can really agree on is that being a baby IS PAIN
@ztk3294
18 күн бұрын
Legacy isle was the best, if all the dinos would of been added..
@TheRikaido
28 күн бұрын
in the last 10 seconds, dude earn my like without ask
@onlyenzoYT
5 ай бұрын
I tried to play officials on Pot and things I noticed is herbis will attack carnis to the death just for fun. And most carnivores r chill. Apex’s love to mix pack and raptors r the only ones who play it like a survival. The hitboxes + the lag could cost u ur life
@ukrainianbloke9676
5 ай бұрын
The isles the better game while POT is the better product.
@christophernelson1334
Ай бұрын
Ok I like the video and it did help me learn the differences before I decide to buy one. The end of the video talking about "watching this and procrastinating whatever you're supposed to be doing right now." Just way to call Me out dude lol.
@truecoulorgecko401
5 ай бұрын
I get 60-100 frames in the isle, I play on max graphics and yet I use a gtx 1070, maybe its because I have really good CPU memory etc. Also the isle is gonna have mods as some point last time I checked. I also personally think that the isle has increased its development by allot recently. Also for the completeness of path of titans I already find the isle to just barely surpass path of titans, that might just be prefference on my end but I do own both games. (btw I love your content:) )
@dextergzslasher4402
5 ай бұрын
I think mods are subjective in the isle, half the dev team hate mods with a passion so it's difficult to say whether or not they would be implemented.
@jakiepoo123
21 күн бұрын
Why do people hate the omni raptor design like it’s the best raptor design in the game media
@DominoDoginater
4 ай бұрын
Man, at least the isle has PASSIVE GROWTH. Man, I wasted my money on P.O.T. PLEASE, if you want to play a good dino game, then play literaly any dino game other than P.O.T Edit:Path of titans could be fun if there weren't care-bearers around every corner, along with the fact that a pouncing dromaesaur can KILL AN ADULT SARCO.
@sillyswan
4 ай бұрын
Played the Isle a couple times, never grew to adult because of the lack of anything the game gives you lol and the night lighting was unbearable, while I understand its realistic I don't wanna play a game that I cant see half the time
@Gamartt
4 ай бұрын
U Can sée with night vision , just dont bé autistic ;)
@the_blue_jay_raptor
4 ай бұрын
PoT is the best and nothing can change my mind.
@MrSucho-vl7ih
5 ай бұрын
The isle should be released for console when it gets finished fr
@thetorocat
5 ай бұрын
it should, but that's highly unlikely will happened
@funkdude505
5 ай бұрын
I like pot better because its devs can handle criticism and listen to feedback from the community. I still can't trust the isle devs to do much of anything after the many years of Dondi and his temper tantrums along with the paradigm shift incident from a while back. im sure im forgetting many more instances of the isle devs many MANY issues but honestly the whole thing could fill out half a bible on it's own and i would rather just forget that the isle even existed
@jacopocastagnino8919
2 ай бұрын
path is for boyz....the isle is for men
@ac_muncher
4 ай бұрын
I want cotylorhynchus in a dino survival game *N* *O* *W*
@hybridsofthorin
Ай бұрын
I would play the Isle if the devs stopped trying to kill their game. They add so many updates that just make the game less and less fun to play
@ADinoNerdXD
5 ай бұрын
summary: if you want a hardcore survival game chose the isle, if you want a less survival more "goofy" game chose PoT. niether game is better they just do differnt things
@dojo45789
2 ай бұрын
Ive always glanced in from the outskirts when it comes to the isle and ended up getting path first last year until enough videos and the summer sale drove me to buy the isle recently. I am glad I did cause I heavily prefer it even through the issues and my pc barely managing to run the game. It just hits that survival itch so much better
@everyonesinsane7689
5 ай бұрын
i started on the isle legacy because i always wanted to play as a dinosaur since like 2017 😭🙏 but overall i like PoT better i like the fact it at least has stego and you can outrun apexes if you need to, the legacy stego has no chance against giga or rex when it comes to fleeing. i know there’s evirma but i don’t even wanna die and restart lmao official PoT makes it feel like you own the dinosaur considering when you die you only lose like half a bar of growth. the isle if good for the views and realism but not the combat fr
@v8hyp
5 ай бұрын
evrima combat is the best out of all 3 games
@everyonesinsane7689
5 ай бұрын
@@v8hyp that’s your opinion, i played all three as well
@craigpaterson4358
2 ай бұрын
I tried so hard to enjoy the isle after having probably 1000’s of hours in pot but I just cannot get into it. I find it odd that they made such a good looking game then turn the lights off 80% of the time so it’s black and white. The start to grow is fill up on food at a hot spot then hide is just boring as hell and even if you decide “right I’m going to go out into the world a bit” instantly killed by a mix pack or a herbi player who just wants to kill everything. Then back to the start. The furthest I ever grew a dino was cera that got to about 80% by getting a perfect diet then hiding and going shopping leaving the game running 😂 it’s just missing the fun part of the game for me.
@scottthesmartape9151
5 ай бұрын
Path of titans is merely just accessible the isle is where I think the fun is at for me
@bizz7612
23 күн бұрын
Thanks for the informative video Goldfish.
@axops4031
5 ай бұрын
For me it just boils down to Path of Titans being infinitely more enjoyable than The Isle. I don't care if it has arguably worse graphics or fewer mechanics, POT is just so much more fun (in my opinion), which is why its popularity has increased so drastically in the last year or so.
@Gamartt
4 ай бұрын
POT IS easier , not fun
@attilamateilonka5579
4 ай бұрын
The main problem with The Isle for me is that the game is veeeery boring 90% of the time. And yes, everybody can joke with the "lol, picking flowers, lol" but at least i CAN do something other than eating and then afk-ing for two hours and eat again, and afk for another two hours, and again, and again.
@megameme3298
4 ай бұрын
The only reason why I enjoy Path of Titans more is because it has a larger variety of dinosaurs that I forgot even exist
@da.mombie
5 ай бұрын
sry mate, but, the 2070 super is a 5 years old mid range GPU. I have the RTX 3080, which is also almost 4 years old and it runs the isle with ease at 60 FPS. not to mention any (2 years old) RTX 40** GPU. in general your argument that a PC is more expensive than a mobile phone and so you give 2 points to PoT is strange to me. with this logic every mobile game gets a 2 points lead to every PC game. you have 60 FPS at star citizen? how many do you have at the beginning of a quantum drive? 2-3 FPS? I guess you know what I am up to ;-) another point I disagree are the features. PoT just looks like they have much more in my opinion. for example, the whole quest system is nothing else than collect 25 flowers, pick 20 branches and so on. the diet system of the isle is pretty much the same. you have many different plants to go for. yes, doing all the quests offers more gameplay than getting your diet. but, the whole quest gameplay is repetitive up to a point where it is nothing but annoying anymore. even more because it is exactly the same for each dino. your feature arguments for PoT were, homebase, growth, complex character optimization, moding, replay features and much more. well, you can put them in comparison to features the isle offers. like the scent feature, a nesting feature, a night vision (yeah, it's a bad one, still a feature), different forms of venom effects (incl. hallucinations), a gore feature, the migration feature and much more ;-) these games offer very different features, but, I don't feel like PoT offers more. feature complete? none of them is any close to it. the isle still has many things to come and PoT also has many features to still complete. like the growth (I guess you mean quests) and the complex character optimization (abilities). both aren't close to be feature complete. didn't PoT also aim for a nesting feature in the past? what happened? XD anyway, even if I disagree at some points, it's a good video and in the end you made the most important point which I couldn't agree more on. the different communities. in my opinion you can't compare these two games at all because of that. like you said very well in the end, it very much depends on what type of game you are looking for. PoT is a fun dino game delivered in a RPG style. the isle is a sandbox survival game with a tendency towards simulation. it really depends on what type of game you prefer. thx for the video, keep it up ♥
@primalboi96
5 ай бұрын
Woah mate! That’s a lot of words
@gothic-edgy-rat
4 ай бұрын
Can you summarize what you said pls?
@POTPachyOTP
3 ай бұрын
Y'all need to learn to read. Anyways, great comment!!
@daffierpython7755
Ай бұрын
The fact you have to dump a couple hundred dollars into a PC just to play the isle, at times being fruitless and it running bad, while pot you can download it it practically anything and at most have to spend maybe a hundred to two hundred bucks to play pot is why it gets the point. Pot is more accessible being on more devices and on average runs about the same, being pretty well, no matter the device you run it on from a shifty mobile phone to a military grade computer The whole quest thing is getting fixed in pot but regardless it gives you a reason to be out and about as opposed to the isle and sitting in a bush until your adult You didn't count pot questing as a positive feature because it's bad but did with the isles night vision, unfair, but gore doesn't really matter its just a meaningless feature to look better, and some of the isles features like different venom are already in or planned to be in pot, mind you planned far before the isle did Yes pot planned on a nesting feature but last I checked it took like what 10 years for the isles nesting as opposed to pot whom is only like... 4 years old? Unfair to compare the two even if pot always delivers on promises while the isle not so much If you want to say the isles better say the isles better, but if you use examples use the right ones and don't be snarky when you use a point like pot not having nesting despite it being planned and literally being worked on as we speak
@NOWAHERRAMAIN
5 ай бұрын
I like both isle and path the isle for realism and path for PvP I like how dondi wanted to keep it 20 I don’t like how path is a dlc paid game at least it’s not as bad a certain game with dragons DOD COUGH COUGH I regret buying dod but I think both have there flaws and things that make the games good I love your vids btw❤ I just don’t like the bugs and devs choices (most of them) of the isle path is fun but I don’t like walking sims lol so I’ve been playing the isle mostly even though I play it on laptop and I play path on ps5 the devs of path make good choices the roster is meh like you said they could just add anky to the roster who cares if the isle already has it on there roster it’s a damm dinosaur
@weewoo8108
29 күн бұрын
I was with you up until Path got 0 Points for roster, when TI takes a year to add in a new playable and then further time to even balance it, while POT has a wider array of dinos as well as more aquatic and flyer options, which are both types TI really struggles with. Then even more if you count modding (some are weird/fantasy creatures, but many other actual dinos are modded in too to expand the normal roster). The sheer amount of updates and actual meaningful content POT has added compared to TI in the same time frame is staggering too, at a certain stage constantly trying to go for hyper realism in your game where there isnt even enough food for its players is just not the thing to be focusing on. Otherwise it was a pretty solid deduction, I would heavily sway in favour of TI being more toxic though, mentioning certain things in discord will get you flamed like no tomorrow, staff are often caught straight lying and making false promises and they ban people for very petty reasons. I once suggested in the suggestions channel of the discord that because the map had a real lack of any diversity between areas/landmarks/POIs/overall poor navigation that a map available in game would be benefitial to the players who want/need one as well as making it much more welcoming to new players, and if players did not want a map they simply...Dont open it? You dont have to use all the tools in a game - especially because devs KNOW people just use third party ones anyway and there is a demand for them. Someone took my suggestion to the global chat, openly mocked me for it and saying I must just be a bad player and encouraged others to hop on the bandwagon because "Its realism gtfo" to stumble around a map being unable to see anything, falling off cliffs and starving to death repeatedly. Its a big yes men crowd.
@NilasJunkyard
5 ай бұрын
I say one can't compare these two, because PoT isn't even finished yet. I've been playing and supporting it since the earliest alpha ( back when there wasn't even a multiplayer yet ). Since then it's been worked on constantly with changes being added every 3-4 months. New game modes will come, nesting, bigger roster, more skins and quest types + rewards and achievements. I do not agree with Anodontosaurus being made an example of, while TI has things like the hyper-mega-ultra-sayan-hybrids. None of the dinosaur designs of TI are natural. They are roaring scifi monsters. I would've understood if you mentioned PoTs Metri, becaue they completely made up the design. (Only a hipbone or a vertibrae was found I think.) Cerato is also not accurate I've been told.
@ThePooPoo-xb2yv
5 ай бұрын
PEACE PLEASE LETS STOP THE WAR! THEIR BALCY THE SAME GAME!!!!
@goldfishmentality
5 ай бұрын
I think you'll find that the video is actually trying to stop the war if you watch the whole thing. Saying they're the same thing just fuels the war imo
@zainyfasanyanorris9023
5 ай бұрын
@@goldfishmentalityur not ur lighting it and baiting tbh
@ThePooPoo-xb2yv
5 ай бұрын
@@goldfishmentality ik just wathed it this was ment for a diff vid XD
@ThePooPoo-xb2yv
5 ай бұрын
@@goldfishmentality love u bro (no homo)
@primalboi96
5 ай бұрын
@@zainyfasanyanorris9023what?
@dr.archaeopteryx5512
5 ай бұрын
It's so funny how Path of Titans is a barely viable minimum product and still the undisputed king of the subgenre. No story, barely any gameplay loop, just enough realism to fit in with modern sciences aesthetics while also ever so often betraying that they either don't actually do any research or will readily slap more group-stereotypical gameplay styles on more unique animals "just because", and a "free trial" mobile game ass monetization structure... All that, and the Isle, which has been in the works for a decade, is being left in the dust. It would just be sad at this point if you couldn't trace every single problem the game has back to hasty, uninformed, headass decisions the developers made. This way it's just aggravating instead.
@daffierpython7755
Ай бұрын
Okay so. No story? Not every game must have a deep story that encompasses every corner of the game. Minecraft doesn't really have a story yet its good, yes it has implied story but the story matters none in the grand scheme. No dinosaur game today has a good game play loop so that can't be used as a reason pot is worse. Its the most scientifically accurate Dino game out today maybe behind BoB and yes, every creature will have group based abilities and purposes due to, ya know, IT BEING A GROUP GAME. The free trial is admirable given thr isle doesn't have it and yet Alderon is profiting solely off pot, and who wouldn't want a taste of something before they buy it?
@bulimah9686
2 ай бұрын
I do want to point out in the isle evrima you can only talk to people of the same dino and you dont meet that much toxic people. But in path of titans theres a global chat with super toxic people and you have huge mixpacks in pot way more than evrima. The most egrigous thing is these huge mixpacks dont get punished even if u fought and slowly win theyll just switch dinos from closest hc and kill you. Then when they do kill you. They go into global chat and be toxic to you and the mixpacking has been getting worse and worse in pot. And pot punishes you for being an adult by giving you a debuff when u first spawn in. Also the hc debuff can kill you when your just trying to get food near a hc then someone who dosent have the debuff comes and kill you. These are just a few problems i have with pot that are not as prevalent or even nonexistent issues in evrima.
@articrabbitfoot3444
18 күн бұрын
Imo as someone that has played both i feel as if path is alot more accessible, not only is it available one everything but its alot less (in comparison to the isle anyways) stressful and cruel to new players or those just trying to grow dinosaurs. We all know the isle is known for having its penalties for death being VERY unforgiving. pathis just iver all the better experience imo, if youre looking for smthn more realistic than obvi the isle is your game but for a general dinosaur gaming experience (even realism can work on certain servers) path is the better option in most regards its not perfect but it feels more full and like u can do way more with it
@R03stedB1Rd
5 ай бұрын
Boh bath of titans and he isle are good, though path of titans is certainly Not a survival game
@R03stedB1Rd
5 ай бұрын
Jesus Christ I butchered that sentence lol- BOTH PATH of titans and The Isle-
@ham_sandvich
5 ай бұрын
honestly i would say that path of titans is better but i still love the isle they are trying to go for quality over quantity but more going for over quality so most can’t play over quantity because the deinonychus mode alone will stutter your fps they can reduce the polygons without making it ugly very easily but over time path of titans puts more updates out with the same level of quality (because the models although ugly the coding they put in out ways the isle) path of titans will succeed over the isle and i’d hate to see that because how much i love both games
@3rwi
15 күн бұрын
In Ukraine Pot is 1200 in our currency while the isle is only 279. I'm sad cus it's so expensive and I have to save for quite a time as a regular poor student😢
@InkGraffiti
Ай бұрын
Path of Titan's refusal to use popular dinosaur and instead use a similar look-alike but they basically just make the popular dinosaur was always funny to me.. like lambeo rather than para, ano rather than anky, pycno rather than carno, the littler rex thing that i can't remember the name of rather than an actual t rex ( until that got added later for some reason ), sarco rather than deino ect ect. If you want dino X in the game just put dino X in the game i dont get itttt
@TheVikingCarnotaur
4 ай бұрын
My guy the reason people don’t complain about path of titans is cause any criticism of the game on their discord gets removed by the moderators Trust me, I know
@jakiepoo123
21 күн бұрын
The isle has more of what I want which is like Jurassic Park theming and I just find path of titans goofy but it is fun to play
@СергійЯремчук-м4р
5 ай бұрын
how can you call the game polished, completed when everything they are doing is just adding basically the same dinos with just different stats with zero uniqueness?
@goldfishmentality
5 ай бұрын
Well that's not really a fault of the game, that's just how it's designed, and the result of having so many options for each dinosaur. If you want more uniqueness, play the isle. That's what the game is made to do. PoT tries to make every dinosaur into a template for people to create their own dinosaur
@СергійЯремчук-м4р
5 ай бұрын
@@goldfishmentality I'm calling it a lazy approach, like it wouldnt take much effort for isle developers to release popular dinos like rex, spino, allo, etc. And make an easy profit from it without putting much effort, but they rather trying to make it as complicated as they possibly can, which is really pushing the genre the most I think and like that approch. I think it's better to wait and eventually get something better rather then get smth quickly which is bad quility. Whatever, from this point I'm just curious what pot will be able to show since they roll out all the major dino and hasn't introduced something unique, they squashed out the lemon as much as they can, while the isle has plenty to offer
@СергійЯремчук-м4р
5 ай бұрын
I was writing a long message ans it didn't sended somehow!? It's a short words what I wanna say that - the pot is just squeezing out the lemon while the isle is keep it for longer and use it in better way
@peabrain6872
Ай бұрын
Which game is this
@СергійЯремчук-м4р
Ай бұрын
@@peabrain6872 path of titans
@TheVikingCarnotaur
4 ай бұрын
Best dinosaur survival game? Beasts of Bermuda Yeah I said it
@Sauropodgaminggaming
5 ай бұрын
Goldfish mentality can you like maybe talk about prior extinction because it is like the best dinosaur survival game on roblox right now.
@rahjah6958
Ай бұрын
Erm I payed £15 for the entire pot....not fucking 90😂
@lookbothways5104
5 ай бұрын
Ive always dreamed about having the isle as a child. Now that I finally played it, I was kinda left disappointed- especially after gateway.
@Lingist081
4 ай бұрын
So you’re still a child
@tycalas2391
5 ай бұрын
For all of the POT kids crying in the comments just letting you know that The Isle isn’t even close to fully developed.
@Gamartt
4 ай бұрын
It Can bé called ' early development" lol
@DokuroHeartvore
Ай бұрын
Well, the Isle Dinos are Genetically Altered Monsters who grow to adulthood is just hours, regenerate super fast, are basically bulletproof and have to eat all the time or they starve to death in less than a day. Lorewise makes sense they don't look 1:1 their real counterpart (it would be nice to have some more updated look tho) Love its unapologetically edgy air.
@СергійЯремчук-м4р
5 ай бұрын
you didnt mentioned that you have to pay extra 20 dollars for every single new dino
@demonicsapphire3773
5 ай бұрын
Beast of Bermuda.
@tahaabdi-rb1uq
5 ай бұрын
the procrastination part relates to me
@CurseOfVanishingI
5 ай бұрын
In path of titans u can lose apex’s to 2-3 latens not to mention the fact this is literally update isle legacy with mods saying its better is a genuine lie
@goldfishmentality
5 ай бұрын
Combat is absolutely not it's strongsuit. The point of this video is to prove that these games are good at entirely different things, and that comparing them isn't all that useful
@Vanny1980
5 ай бұрын
I thought everyone in the isle loved legacy? Why do you all of a sudden wanna clown on pot cause of that lol?
@CrystalKingOverlord
4 ай бұрын
I like both games i like the isle for the true survival experience and i play it more often but i play pot time to time
@BlackMage_BlackMage
Ай бұрын
I hate the isle. I have so many hours in it and play it every other night just solo Herrera for hours. I hate it but I have had so much fun playing it I struggle through being punished. it's not perfect, but I don't want to collect flowers in an rpg style dino game. the survival aspect of the isle keeps me coming back
@Some1-2
5 ай бұрын
1:33 i was in that herd in updeit 3
@SternaRegnixTube
2 ай бұрын
Isle has graphics path of titans everything else
@jurassicjuice2479
Ай бұрын
Fr
@jurassicjuice2479
Ай бұрын
Except for growth system
@WaveDaSeaWing
5 ай бұрын
Can everyone agree that both games are good 🍷🗿
@Loading12327
4 ай бұрын
guys, guys this is all wrong. we all know the best dinosaur game is beasts of bermuda. tut tut tut!
@goldfishmentality
4 ай бұрын
💀
@Adaptibility
5 ай бұрын
I think you should reupload this I didn't see it in my subscriptions it might be bugged
@goldfishmentality
5 ай бұрын
I actually did that intentionally to try and reach pot players. Its just weird algorithm experimentation basically. I hope subscribers see it from the community post.
@joannakedzior8882
2 ай бұрын
path of titans has much relaxed players and nice dinosaurs sound like nice dinosaurs and has mods too, dinosaurs have maaany attacks and buffs but it can be sometimes laggy becausd when you play on computer and you try to catch a laggy nintendo player or something, has not the best grafics and weather like the grow and questsystem and the jump, swim and runningspeed are not really too goos like a deinonychus cant jump over a sarco or something bigger bc the hitbox is too big and the jumphigh is nah and the dlcs cost too much the isle has very nice grafict with very nice abilities like the ability by all the dinos and every dinosaur has his own ability and strength like the weather is nice, looks nice and is much more realistic, costs less than path of titans and has legacy and evrima so you dknt need to buy all the dlcs, in legacy are soooo many dinosaurs and there are mods too and hypos, quetz, developer, unoffizial servers like offizial, very good growsystem and even nesting and the scent thing and you can even buy dinosaurs on some discord servers but has very toxic players, on evrima there are not so much dinos like on legacy, has slow development, too many players on some server sometimes, no globalchqt on offizial evrimaservers now i hope if someone read this he will be able to buy the best game for him of these 2
@fortunemichael5097
5 ай бұрын
You cant mention path and not mention how the Dino’s move, I love that game but Jesus the movement is honesty disgusting and is pretty much legacy but even worse at times
@goldfishmentality
5 ай бұрын
How so? The precise movement is really nice. I prefer evrimas momentum based movement, but I don't think POT's is even remotely as limiting as legacy
@Marcin9200
5 ай бұрын
Prior extinction exists and it is free, just sayin.
@TheAaronsGamers
2 ай бұрын
so aka i think you were bias to the isle
@mikaeelrasul1688
5 ай бұрын
Path of titians has reached their peak making them better than the isle atm but the isle still has a higher peak potential
@Hunting-Raptor
5 ай бұрын
Dinosaur world mobile
@martindominguez5324
Ай бұрын
Ark has left the chat jurassic world the game has the the chat jurasic world evolution 1 and 2 has left the chat
@BuIIy_Maguire
5 ай бұрын
Both. Both is good
@Traxgam3s
5 ай бұрын
tbh i agree with everything he says but the reason The Isle promises so many things and to only 2 of em a year is cuz The Isle doesnt have that many Dev Teams so thats why updates thake soo long and i dont say that cuz i think the isle is better im just saing this so its said
Пікірлер: 339