About the dursleys…. Idk about vernon. But fact ist petunia isn’t scared of magic, she is dying of jealousy and obv doesn’t want her sisters son to have, what neither she nor her son can ever have. Fun fact, in book 5 she mentions Snape.
@rebbeccahoneycutt7941
6 ай бұрын
But nobody realizes it til book 7! I love this one!!
@bitchlasagna1
6 ай бұрын
I think you hit the nail on the head with this one. Petunia was so hurt and resentful by Lily’s powers, that she never wanted Dudley to feel the same way. She would naturally not want Harry to go to a school that Dudley cannot and see her son deal with the same anguish as herself. And when Harry does go, it’s in Petunias best interest to make Dudley look down on Harry and his powers so that he remains feeling superior to Harry and can never be jealous. Vernon just hates anything nonconforming to the stereotypical traditional image of a successful man and family and Harry’s status threatens that
@jelenasavic1294
5 ай бұрын
@@rebbeccahoneycutt7941😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😅😅😊😊😊😊 50:08 😊
@r0xdab0x96xo
5 ай бұрын
I heard a couple years back of the possibility that Petunia actually had a deep caring for Harry as she did for Lily, under all of that jealousy and resentment. That she had coined on or suspected that Harry was just a lamb for the slaughter and wanted to keep him from that fate as the Wizarding World is the reason of her sisters death.
@bitchlasagna1
5 ай бұрын
@@r0xdab0x96xo if one of the most powerful wizards in the wizarding world (Snape) wasn’t able to realize Dumbledore’s plan, I highly doubt a muggle who ignores all things magic would be able to
@fawfulfan
7 ай бұрын
We know for a fact that the Invisibility Cloak doesn't block ALL spells cast at the wearer, because even aside from Dumbledore's spell to immobilize him, Malfoy hit Harry with a Body-Bind Curse while he was wearing the cloak in HBP. I think it's safe to say it wouldn't protect from Avada Kedavra either. I agree that the "protection" aspect of the Cloak is poorly explained. But what I've always interpreted it to mean is, the wearer is immune to any magical attempt to reveal them. So a Summoning Charm for the express purpose of pulling the Cloak off Harry wouldn't work, but if someone already knew where Harry was and cast a curse or hex to immobilize or cause general harm to him, that would still work.
@HarryFernandes15
6 ай бұрын
Ye i assume so aswell. Imagine being in a room with fiend fire but under cloak 😂
@MoxxoM
6 ай бұрын
I mean Moody seems to be able to see him under the cloak. But the eye isn't really explained either. And at least in the movies(I think the books too, but can't say that with confidence) Dumbledore can at least say where Harry is, when he's under the cloak in Hagrids hutt. Maybe that's unique for Dumbledore to be able to do. Or he just casted homeo revelio before entering and thus got the insight that there are more people present than visable and had the deductive skills to tell where to look. It's not like revealing him to others present, but Harry is still revealed to the owner of the eye and Dumbledore, however he managed to do that.
@kirikayuumura5370
6 ай бұрын
To be precise in, not entirely sure but I think its Deathly Hollows, there is a Deatheater who tries to summon Harrys cloak from him and it doesnt work at all. I think it is when they enter Hogsmead
@fawfulfan
6 ай бұрын
@@MoxxoM we all know that the real, literary reason Moody could see Harry under the cloak is that Rowling hadn't decided to give the cloak infinite concealment power yet when she was writing Goblet of Fire. But my personal headcanon to explain this is, Moody actually couldn't see it was Harry under the cloak. For OTHER cloaks he would have seen through them, but with this one he just saw a big hole in his spatial field in the shape of a person, and Snape had already told him one time in the staff room to "Watch out for Potter's unusually powerful cloak, he has a habit of sneaking around at night," so he correctly guessed it was Harry.
@FabricatedPheonix
5 ай бұрын
The cloak itself isn't affected by magic, but people have to remember it's still just a sheet
@Astrovite
6 ай бұрын
4:35 I'm probably not 100% correct on this but I just realized that Harry likely cast the same "love" spell as his Mother when he willingly let Voldemort kill him in The Deathly Hallows. He was basically also given a choice and chose self sacrifice. Thus applying that love protection to the people he cares about in that final battle.
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
Correct!
@kirikayuumura5370
6 ай бұрын
Yes in the Books he even tells Voldemort about it:"I did what my mother did. Dont you see that none of your spells seem to have any binding force?" (Not word for word but the sense remains the same. In the Book Voldemort uses a Binding curse on Neville and he puts the sorting head on Neville's head, igniting it. But Neville can just break the binding curse to pull away the hat and draw the sword of Griffyndor from the hat.
@FabricatedPheonix
5 ай бұрын
That's correct, it's just plainly said and shown in the books
@pontiusthepilot
2 ай бұрын
This also explains why the fetusmolt that is inside him didn't get the same protection- Voldemort is incapable of loving even a sliver of himself once cast out and it didn't choose to sacrifice itself, hence it dies while harry lives. this is a banger take @astrovite
@Astrovite
2 ай бұрын
@@pontiusthepilot Oh yeah! That's a good observation! Thank you!
@evolving_dore
3 ай бұрын
29:10 I think maybe you should re-read Book 1. Harry isn't "finally able to snag and read a letter before being scarted away to a shack", he's unable to get a letter until Hagrid arrives at the shack. Also, to the following point about why the Dursleys don't want Harry going to Hogwarts: they explicitly say that they didn't want him to become a wizard and wanted to stamp it out of him. Hiding the letters from him is them trying to deny him the ability to become a wizard. This is just basic book knowledge honestly.
@x86ed
6 ай бұрын
32:30 Fun fact, when Lucius encounters Harry, and he’s about to cast a spell on him and dobby stops him. The spell that Lucius was going to cast was a Avada Kadavra. When you watch it again you’ll hear him start it. Dude was straight going to off Harry Potter right there at the school 🤣
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
I wonder why he would do that, I feel like voldemort would not have been to happy about that.
@FabricatedPheonix
5 ай бұрын
That's only in the movie. His actor was told to start casting a spell and that was the last one he remembered reading in the books. In the book however luscious didn't even draw his wand he just lunged at Harry
@britishmushroom
4 ай бұрын
Right in front of the headmasters office too 😂
@Jeremy-wp4yh
3 ай бұрын
@@britishmushroomimagine a parent committing a crime at hogwarts trying to kill another student 😂. Major plot hole
@kittykat1102
Ай бұрын
In the movie, Issacs was told to cast a spell, but he didn’t know any. He asked another person in the crew and the only one they knew was Avada Kadavra, so he ended up using that one.
@fawfulfan
7 ай бұрын
Also, with regard to whether all prophecies are fulfilled... remember, in the Hall of Prophecy, some prophecies on the shelves were warm and glowing, others were "as dull and dark within as blown lightbulbs". I've always understood this to mean, the glowing prophecies are the ones that were, or still could be, fulfilled, and the not-glowing prophecies are the ones that did not come true.
@sorenzzz
6 ай бұрын
Despite the Dursley's questionable parenting tactics. They really did do a good job saving Dudley from feeling like he missed out from their heavy demonization of magic.
@SingingSealRiana
Ай бұрын
They neglected him in other ways
@HeatherNickless-vt8zr
6 ай бұрын
The first of two reasons on how Voldemort picked up a cult following, is because he never told anybody his real blood status and so every dark-minded character coming out of Slytherin House probably assumes that he was a pure-blood; It should be common knowledge that most Slytherins with Half-Blood status would naturally want to either keep quiet about what blood status they are within the proximity of Slytherins who are pure-bloods or some like the former known as Delores Jane Umbridge, will just flat out lie about their Blood purity.
@kirikayuumura5370
6 ай бұрын
Priori Incantatem can be used willingly and will probably be used in law enforcement as well. Bellatrix uses it in Deathly Hollows to see that Hermione used a spell to disfigure Harry. Dumbledore mentions in Half Blood Prince that the Ministry of Magic found out that the Riddles were murdered with Morphins wand. The astonishing thing about the Priori Incantatem with Voldemort and Harry is that none of them intended to use it and it just occured after one wand overpowered the other, thus forcing it to relive its last spells.
@timjackson7564
5 ай бұрын
Regarding harry being able to open the snitch to get the resurrection stone, The key is Harry kissing the snitch. It was set to open on the recognition of how it was caught in Harry's first match. Harry caught the snitch by having first contact with his mouth/ lips. When he kisses the snitch this is the memory the snitch holds of it's first contact with Harry causing it to open
@MrPsyJak
3 ай бұрын
Yes, because there's something about Snitches (I don't recall if the birds have the same property) having memory of physical contact. Thus why Seekers wear gloves.
@VonOutlaw
6 ай бұрын
With the resurrection stone, after Harry drops it in the forest if I'm not mistaken he then no longer sees his loved ones around him. He only sees them while he's holding the stone so if him and someone else were both touching the stone at the same time would they be able to see their loved ones at the same time. You got me really thinking so now I'm literally going to be going back rereading all seven books to brush back up.
@shubniggurath3255
5 ай бұрын
42:05 In the first edition of the italian print, Ravenclaw was called "Pecoranera" (Black Sheep). Now THAT was confusing! xD
@VaultLore
5 ай бұрын
Oh woah, that’s crazy haha. Why would they do that?
@shubniggurath3255
5 ай бұрын
@@VaultLore No idea tbh, who knows what the translators were thinking 🤣 It was changed very early though, now we have "Corvonero" (Black Raven/Crow)
@VaultLore
5 ай бұрын
Hahaha oh thank god
@jeremyzmoos7022
8 күн бұрын
@@VaultLore-
@harasen_haras5
Ай бұрын
53:38 When it comes to the movie adaptation's take on the polyjuice potion, my guess is that the kept the voiced unaffected for the sake of reminding viewers that it's a disguise. In the books they characters can be referred to by their names no matter what they look and sound like, but in the movies there's only visuals, dialog, sound effects and music to work with.
@VonOutlaw
6 ай бұрын
I can see your point about the whole Ravenclaw thing, the only thing is though Raven is another word for black and then claw which Eagles have black claws. We're Ravens don't. When it comes to the Hufflepuff Badger I think the reason why my house which is Hufflepuff we have the badger and I'm not 100% certain on this, but Badgers in the actual real world can be quite tamed unless if they are attacked or someone in their group is attacked. At that point they can take down Predators five times their size if I'm not mistaken. As we see in the final book it was mostly Hufflepuff students that stayed behind to help in the final battle. There is a few ravenclaws and a handful of gryffindor's but virtually half the table if I'm not mistaken from Hufflepuff stay to assist and Aid Harry wherever he needed
@eliothutchins501
6 ай бұрын
I heard a theory that Slythern students are sent to the basement so they don’t have to fight with or watch relatives die.
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
Probably true
@tanafritia
6 ай бұрын
I feel that the dursleys reason for not wanting harry going to hogwarts starts with petunia, not vernon. And you kinda mentioned it. She missed out on being a witch. She was jealous of her sister (proven in book 7) i think they were protecting dudley from that same jealousy. They always gave dudley more, more food, more space (2 bedrooms) more fun (outing and stuff) but they couldnt control the magic. That is why i personally believe they didnt want harry to go to hogwarts. They didnt want Dudley to feel how petunia did.
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
Haha I’d be so jealous I don’t blame her
@XeiDaMoKaFE
6 ай бұрын
4:30 I believe Snape is what allowed it in the first place , asking voldy to not kill her and voldy accepting
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
Yeah I think that’s true
@alicediamond387
5 ай бұрын
Around 25:00, could the reference to Harry's scar burning just before his wand turns to block Vodemort be a description of the piece of Voldemort's soul protecting itself? It could be the horcrux using the wand and not a brother wand effect.
@VaultLore
5 ай бұрын
You’re not the only one who had that idea, seems possible!
@moecrazy
7 ай бұрын
To a certain degree I believe that one of the points of this series is that no one is purely good nor evil, but each has potential for good. With Snape, the good he had was his love for Lily. I do agree that this was the primary, if not the only, motivations for the good that he does. That is the good within him. Dumbledore knew this initially and used it. I think Dumbledore assumed that, over time, it would fade and that Snape would fine goodness elsewhere. This is why he is surprised when he sees Snape's patronus. Snape loved one person, but that was enough for him to do what was necessary, even after she was gone.
@moecrazy
5 ай бұрын
@@7gamex Proven? this isn't a math equation. Also, that only demonstrates that he hated James. And James deserved it. Snape demonstrates that it's not simply obsession by continuing to protect Harry even after Dumbledore is gone. However, he also demonstrates his continued hatred for James in his constant bullying of Harry. To me, this actually demonstrates the great flaw of Lily. How could you let yourself fall for your oldest friend's most aggressive bully? It's kind of gross to me.
@moecrazy
5 ай бұрын
@@7gamex Snape was a shitty person. So was James. James was just part of the accepted tribe. Snape calling Lily a bad name doesn't make what she did ok. Her own sister called her a freak (there is no "racial" slur for witches so this is as close as it gets) and Lily still pursued her. Snape at least apologized. James never apologized. Neither James nor Lily ever said thank you or even indicated gratitude for the warning Snape gave to Dumbledore. You could say James was never cruel enough to be a death eater... maybe. And maybe if he were put into Slytherin, we would have. We can't say one way or another. As for the "no one lets themselves fall for someone". That's a childish mentality. To a certain degree, that a big lesson in these stories. You always have a choice. Lily made her choice and it ended up costing her her life. Imagine if she simply told Snape "I forgive you but I can't go with you down that pathway" or if she told James he needed to apologize for his cruelty. There are 2 big lessons for the entirety of the story: 1) there is potential for good (even if just a little bit) in the most unlikable of people. 2) Even those you like most are capable of messing up. People are not simply put in the categories of good and evil. They are a mixed bag. Lily and James made both good and bad choices. So did Snape. Personally, I don't think I would have wanted to be friends with any of them.
@FabricatedPheonix
5 ай бұрын
@@moecrazyI'm sorry but if you're in your 40s still obsessing over your highschool crush then you are sad. What Snape felt wasn't truly love, the things he did was not love. He felt guilty for being the reason Lily died. That was the only reason he even protected Harry at all
@moecrazy
5 ай бұрын
@@FabricatedPheonix It would be sad if it was just a crush. It obviously wasn't. Lily was his oldest (and maybe his only) friend. She was the only thing he ever cared about. This is displayed quite clearly. What is it like for the only person you ever cared about to jump in bed with the person you hate most in the world? Well, it obviously complicates things. This is why Snape is a complex character. He's not good. He's actually pretty nasty. But even nasty characters can care for others. And even nice people (like Lily) can demonstrate that they are terrible friends.
@FabricatedPheonix
5 ай бұрын
@@moecrazy Yeah no that doesn't change things. He was still obsessing over someone from his childhood. It weird, creepy and super sad
@jkent9915
3 ай бұрын
Priori Incantatum in the graveyard is also a product of the horcrux. I always theorized that Voldy’s soul in Harry also made wand allegiance weird. The wand is loyal to the soul and Voldemort’s soul was split so would his wand allegiance.
@moldyvoldy1231
4 ай бұрын
I think in regards to Harry's and Voldemort's wand connection in the graveyard is both unique and not unique. I don't think the victims showing up is unique simply because those were the literal pervious spells that wand had performed. Think about it. Cedric was the most recent. Then, the old man, then Bertha Jorkins, and Harry's parents. The last three were all killed with voldemort's wand by wormtail because Voldemort didn't have a body, but wormtail didn't have a wand. Harrys parents were the last spells performed before Voldemort lost his power. I think if that spell had been used in the field (detective work) it would have shown the same thing, but only if the wands last spell was used to kill. This is where the uniqueness comes in when their wands connect. They werent just connected, they were locked together so it would have continued to regurgitate spells at them as long as they remained connected and it wasnt just the fact that the cores were related it was also that both harry and voldemort had a bit of each other living inside them. Harry with the horcrux and voldemort with Harrys blood. The wands didn't just meet their sibling. They essentially met the same person in both directions. This is why Dumbledore goes on to tell harry in kings cross that his wand was only uniquely powerful against Voldemort but everyone else it was just an ordinary wand. Im sure there were very open and shut murder cases in the ministry using this technique, but just like real life muggle crime, you're not always going to catch your killer that easily.
@jackcreek
Ай бұрын
If slitherin isn't evil, then Percy Weasley would have been in slitherin. He's willing to do everything, except turn evil to get what he wants. He's the posterboy for slitherin ambition, without the evil.
@shmelvampire
5 күн бұрын
He probably just chose it because of his family Maybe he even wanted to protect his younger siblings when they go to Hogwarts at that time Also he probably wanted his parents to be proud of him, their appreciation and attention, esp since in early childhood he felt kind of similarly to Ron. He had two cool older brothers who kind of mocked him/didn't take him seriously It quite slytherin of him honestly, but if the theory about the hat talking to kids helping them decide themselves rather than sorting, it makes sense why Percy would have chosen Gryffindor instead
@moldyvoldy1231
4 ай бұрын
Second comment about the final showdown between Voldy and Harry. I think it was as simple as Voldy's spell rebounding on himself, and I think the reason why is the intentions behind the spells being cast. I dont think the wand Voldemort used would have made a difference, and this is why: Harry had this strong principle of never raising his wand to kill even in defense of his life. You see him and Remus arguing about this after the 7 Potters' because the death eaters realized which harry was the real one when he disarms Stan Shunpike instead of killing him and he says something along the lines of "I wont blast people out of the way just because they're there. That's Voldemort's job." This is a principle he keeps the entire series so when he's finally ready to face Voldemort for the last time he holds true to that principle and basically leaves Voldemort to fall on his own sword. Remember that we've already been shown that there's more to magic than just the spells themselves, and intentions can change everything. Voldemort was pursuing evil, and Harry remained completely pure all through the series. He was never tempted by the dark arts and was never tempted to kill even to save his own skin. Voldemort was so vile that he couldn't possibly win against someone so pure, so the only option was for him to die by his own hand in his arrogance and perversion of magic. Edit: This was a great video. I thoroughly enjoyed it. Thank you!
@VaultLore
4 ай бұрын
I appreciate you watching and all the thoughtful comments!
@denisucuuu
3 ай бұрын
Harry was very much tempted by the Dark Arts, remember how he tortured the Death Eater Muggle Studies teacher using the Cruciatus curse because she insulted McGonagall and spat on her. We also know that he definitely meant it, because it didn't work when he didn't truly mean to torture. Personally, I'm all for it, but Harry is no saint who's never used an Unforgivable Curse.
@jkent9915
3 ай бұрын
I always thought that the same sort of magic that created the horcrux allowed Harry to live. By whatever mechanism, the fact that Voldy’s soul was already split made the magic work when innocents like Lily and Harry were in the crosshairs. As to say the not only did Lily contribute, but Voldemort’s own weakness contributed.
@prasannasundaram8812
6 ай бұрын
At 23:00 My view is that Harry's wand wouldn't have been stronger even until a few mins ago until Voldy takes Harry's protected blood into his own veins ... he just can't kill harry anymore unless he kills himself first ... the protection is within him ... and that's the ancient magic everyone talks about, showing up ...voldy's spell cannot reach harry, with a also version of him inside Harry, which owes its loyalty to Lily's protection in blood.... Its similar to how in the books Pettigrew's claw hand ends up killing him ... certain loyalties are the part of ancient magic rules, laws and everything falls under it.... Same with when the wand raises itself to protect in the 7th book ... Voldy blasts at harry, the horcrux part of him is connected to know something is coming ... the blood protection kicks itself in, and the an involuntary horcrux itself pushes the wand to release its power .. its a short circuit where the same wire is getting re-routed...
@MoxxoM
6 ай бұрын
37:10: Fun fact: Charmeleons don't actually use their colour shifting abilities to cloak themselves. It's more of a display of their emotions and for mating. A cuttlefish or octopus would be far more accurate for a comparison.
@mirzu42
6 ай бұрын
Harrys and voldies wands both had a feather from the same phoenix. What is a phoenixes most known ability? To rise from the ashes, be reborn. I wouldnt say its too far stretched to say the 2 wands acted that way because the animal in question was a phoenix. Maybe dragons or some other animals would have different effects. If i recall correctly phoenixes are quite rare so I guess it would be pretty unlikely that 2 people, whose wands both have a feather from the same phoenix would battle very often
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
Ooooh interesting point. Maybe rare to have two phoenixes, but I’m sure other more common cores could be farmed.
@samuelclayhills3298
7 ай бұрын
Movie Snape is much nicer than book Snape who lets be real was a collosal wanker. He might not have been really evil but he was no saint. While he was mad at being bullied he also defended his own friends when they bullied with borderline dark magic as just some fun. In anger he called Lilly the worst slur imaginable even though she defended him plus his whole love thing was way more of a onesided borderline obsession for him. He joined the death eaters mostley because he had nowhere else to go and only really changed sides to save Lilly. In the books it pretty clear that after everything he still irrationally hates Harry for reminding him of James and the fact that he was cucked. At the end of the day far from even a truly evil person but by no means perfect.
@VaultLore
7 ай бұрын
Yeah, not evil, but I don’t think he’s a “good” guy. Troubled, maybe. 😂
@FabricatedPheonix
5 ай бұрын
A 30+ year old man bullying 11-17 year olds is walking that very thin line though. He's not evil but is most definitely a terrible human being
@pussygangster5976
Ай бұрын
Poor Neville suffered a lot because of Snape. Snape blame him for dead of Lily in kinda sick way i guess (if Voldy decide that prophecy was about Longbottoms, Lily was still alive). Us much i love Alan Rickman in role, i hope in series we see book accurate Snape.
@DaxterSnickers
3 ай бұрын
Setting a bad example may be better than being a normal parenting figure. It definitely will last longer than being loved.
@praharmitra
7 ай бұрын
Another misconception is that Avada Kedavra is an unblockable curse. There are a few instances in the books where the curse is blocked. One that I always remember is during the fight between Dumbledore and Voldemort at the ministry. Dumbledore uses a gold statue to block Voldy's death curse 3 times. In all other examples, where the killing curse hits an inanimate object, the object simply shatters. For golden objects, the curse rebounds. The conjecture is that gold, in general, blocks death somehow. This also explains why Alchemists are interested in transforming elements into gold AND immortality. They look like independent pursuits, but if gold is associated with immortality, it makes sense that the two are pursued together.
@VaultLore
7 ай бұрын
Yeah, that’s a good one!
@hallbjornthefirebreather8376
7 ай бұрын
I believe when Moody / Crouch Jr. Says it's unblockable, he means you can't block it with a shield sharm like pretago or something like that. I originally thought the same thing. "How'd that headstone block the spell if it's unblockable?"
@VaultLore
7 ай бұрын
Yeah I think physically blocking it makes sense, you just can’t defend against it with another spell. Unless it’s love.
@Ediranii
2 ай бұрын
About the smoke and the deatheaters flying. I assume it was a timesaver on the movie part, because in the book we get a slow development of the severity of the situation and the menace the new regime presents. But in the movies we need to focus on the action and black smoke clearly signifies that bad people are approaching, because we skip on a lot of things from the book that paint that picture.
@delex360
2 ай бұрын
The reason i like snape so much is because he does the right things for the wrong reasons. He came from a abusive household, was put into a echo chamber of his own beliefs by being sorted into slytherin, and made a horrible mistake that got someone he cared for killed. Then for the wrong reason he switched over to the good side at great risk, which eventually cost him his life. There is something so real and human about that. When someone does something terrible because of what went wrong in their life, take for example snape bullying students, we all say "well blah blah had a hard life and he turned out good" thats just not how life is. It doesn't always work out like that. Another thing i like about snapes character is that it almost doesnt matter how many times i reread the books i always go back to hating him until the reveal in book 7, love him again, repeat.
@AlienSnowflake
4 ай бұрын
Tbf, the slytherins were not locked up. Their common room is in the dungeons for a start but then again I'm in Slytherin. If they dotn want me battling, be my guest haha.
@VonOutlaw
6 ай бұрын
I could be wrong but I thought I read somewhere on Pottermore, that there was a Half-Blood or a muggle-born that was put into Slytherin, and the portrait there would always be yelling at her because they weren't a pureblood. And a lot of the Slytherin students would mock them. Again I could be wrong
@vasilikitsakiridou7370
5 ай бұрын
As far as I understand, Voldemort wanted indeed to split his soul into 7 pieces. Harry was made by mistake. As Dumbledore said to Harry, he was the hocrux Voldemort never meant to make.
@MoxxoM
6 ай бұрын
15:22: It's easy. The movies chose to let them fly. It's clearly not apparition. And it looks the same when Voldi or Snape do it without brooms. So they changed it for stylistic purposes.
@ADHD_and_Crayons
3 ай бұрын
The books tell about Petunia being supremely jealous of Lily getting her letter.......so much that Petunia writes a letter to Dumbledore begging to be let into Hogwarts!!! I think Petunia harbored that jealousy & it turned to bitterness when she got older. She now "pretends" to despise magical people, but in reality, if she ever got a letter..... she would leave Vernon to go to Hogwarts.
@EndarkenShrine
6 ай бұрын
The reason the dursleys did not want to Harry to go to hogwarts all boils down to control. They wanted to control him, this pattern is classic abusive family routine. They did not want him to be happy , make friends and come to the conclusion he is a normal boy and not a freak of nature, which to their eyes he was like all wizards and witches.
@AlexB-vt5xe
7 ай бұрын
to my understanding raven claw means black claw (raven is a synonym for black, as in raven hair...) for which eagles are known for.
@maciekmiktus
6 ай бұрын
That makes so much more sense!! Thank You 😊
@Sanguivore
2 ай бұрын
I believe a better name in that case would’ve been “Ebonclaw,” seeing as Raven is always gonna be associated in the mind with the bird first-and-foremost.
@emjayee
3 ай бұрын
Petunia knew about Voldemort so they definitely wanted to keep Harry away from Hogwarts to protect themselves
@lanysmith5189
2 ай бұрын
I dont think she did...not completely. She knew James and Lily were murdered and that Harry staying with them would keep him safe..but I do not think she understood how powerful and ruthless Voldemort was. If you look in book 5 order of the phoenix when Vernon wants to kick Harry out after the Dementor attack on Dudly Petunia does not stop Vernon from kicking Harry out until a Howler comes and says the words " REMEMBER MY LAST PETUNIA" which we later find out is Dumbledor. She knew that Lily and James were murdered and that Harry is kept safe with her which is why she let's him stay even against Vernon's wishes. If she knew about Voldemort and how horrible he is. She would not have even entertained Vernon's idea of kicking Harry out. She would of probably gone off at Vernon and called him a idiot as kicking Harry out leaves them vulnerable to be found by Voldemort.
@lanysmith5189
2 ай бұрын
Also she only wanted Harry not to go to Hogwarts because of her Jelousy and not wanting to go through the pain she felt of growing up with a magical sister. She did not want more reminders of her being unspecial which is why she is horrible to Harry.
@TheGabygael
6 ай бұрын
Funnily enough I grew up with the french version and I still struggle with it being an eagle. Had you asked me as a kid what it was I would have said eagle but the image I have in my head is a raven (also eagle's imagery don't really fit with the ravenclaw vibe imo, an owl or the vague idea of a bird would have made more sense to me, I associate eagle's with pride which I link more with Slytherin than ravenclaw. Ravenclaw do value pride I guess but quirkiness, wisdom and learning are more important there to me, idk)
@dcle944
6 ай бұрын
You forgot Luna found Harry unconscious under the cloak. So you may not see a dead body under the cloak but you would see flies and other insects around a dead body.
@lxena8033
6 ай бұрын
So that is just a movie thing, and not cannon. It's actually Tonks that finds him in the books. And she doesn't see him under the cloak, she guesses that he maybe hidding under the cloak, and uses a spell to lift it off of him.
@laurelelliott7021
2 ай бұрын
My theory about flight: It was Lily's talent. Lily taught Severus, and Severus taught Voldemort. Lily is on the swings when Severus's memories begin, and "soars high into the air". I believe she also stays up far too long and lands too softly. Sounds like Lily can fly to me.
@lanysmith5189
2 ай бұрын
I love this theory!!!
@shawngraves3297
6 ай бұрын
The blood protection spell that dumbledore extended to the derslys house didn’t just end when he turned 17, it simply ended when petunia moved out and Harry knew he was leaving for the last time. You got the trace mixed up with the blood protection spell. Which is a very common mix up because they end at the same time in the story.
@AmandaYee-yn9dk
3 ай бұрын
I wonder if the protection still works when he stays at the Weasley’s instead of the Dursley’s because I think he stays there every summer from book 2 and beyond
@dcle944
6 ай бұрын
I think in many cases the part of Voldemort in Harry Potter protected Harry. Think about this. The scar caused Harry so much pain that he shut his eyes, and then the wand acted on its own. Maybe it’s the part of Voldemort that took control of the wand. If somehow it could detect danger and just wanted to protect itself. Think back, I think whenever Harry was in danger, the scar started to hurt.
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
Oh interesting theory, I haven’t heard that about the wand acting on it’s own before!
@lxena8033
6 ай бұрын
@@VaultLoreit's right there in the book. After the flight of the 7 Potters, when they are all at the Burrow. Harry talks about his wand acting on its own, and the others don't believe him, trying to tell Harry that he was the one that performed the magic without realizing it.
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
No I know it acted on its own, but most attribute it to the wands having a mind of their own. Dcle944 is saying that the small portion of voldemorts soul in Harry is what fired the golden fire spell, not the wand being sentient or whatever.
@alshan6336
6 ай бұрын
Occulemcy lessons is what harry goes for with professor Snape is trying to train him so he can not enter his dreams and Control him.
@alshan6336
6 ай бұрын
I'll be honest every person has a different view what's actually happened lol 😆
@Tahanus7
5 ай бұрын
I think slytherin's reputation was destroyed by voldemort. As his house he spent more time around them and with his charisma used it as a recruiting base for his following.
@VaultLore
5 ай бұрын
True!
@HeatherNickless-vt8zr
6 ай бұрын
@fawfulfan; the Smoke effect and the pure light effect for apperating Death Eaters and Order of the Phoenix are supposed to be representations of their auras for either bad or good, that is why the Death Eaters appear to be flying in and out of existence in rocketing streams of smoke.
@richieaerthen24
5 ай бұрын
When the Pottermore sorting quiz first appeared, I took it immediately. I was a child back then and was unhappy to have been sorted into Slytherin, 'the evil house', but did not despair. I quickly googled all possible questions and all possible answers to manually find and input the ones that would have gotten me into Gryffindor like I wanted Thinking back to it now, the quiz wasn't wrong the first time 🤣🤣🤣
@VaultLore
5 ай бұрын
Haha future ruthless ceo
@jkrause365
5 ай бұрын
Dumbledore could cast the body bind curse because the elder wand was one of the three Deathly Hallows, along with Harry's invisibility cloak, and the resurrection stone. There was I think, some sort of symbiosis between the three Deathly Hallows.
@DerPixelRitter
7 ай бұрын
Just found your channel yesterday and watched the other HP iceberg videos and now there's another video :D
@VaultLore
7 ай бұрын
Welcome aboard! Thanks for watching!
@yodhanhunter
Ай бұрын
I am somewhere between Slythering and Griffindor. I did choose Slytherin for Hogwarts Legacy, but part of that is because I preferred the aesthetic of the Common room for them.
@kyleethekelt
10 күн бұрын
Firstly, it is good to hear such sensible and no-nonsense discourse about HP. Correction, though. Albus Dumbledore didn't sacrifice himself; he used his fatal error in putting on the cursed ring in order to further the plan to bring down Voldemort. To me that will have taken enormous courage. Additionally, I've always found the sorting hat's asertion that it has never been mistaken hilarious. The Wizarding World is full of very gifted wizards but all human, or mostly human. Presumably, this included the Founders. If humans are imperfect, the hat was created by an imperfect being and is, therefore, imperfect and capable of error. I, too, get weirded out by people's love for Snape, especially as I have actual experience of abuse by teachers and matrons who, by the very nature of their authority, were free from centure. I applaud your efforts to untangle all the misconceptions and misinterpretations - clearly not aided by movie mud.
@VendettaPSC
10 күн бұрын
Voldemort created Horcruxes uses Ancient Dark magic, Lily created one using Ancient light magic. Two sides of the same coin.
@sunilpermaul7876
6 ай бұрын
Hogwarts doesn't count as "his home". He is generally safe there because Dumbledore and others are there to protect him. Dumbledore literally says Harry needs to return to the Dursley's once a year to continue the charm. It's why he asks the Dursleys to allow Harry to return one more time before his 17th birthday in book 6.
@jameshardman4008
6 ай бұрын
In regards to the visibility flow, preventing spells in the beginning of the half blood prince, Draco paralyzes Harry while he’s under the clock
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
Yep
@erincarter1469
6 ай бұрын
I believe the Hufflepuff badger is best shown in Narnia. Trufflehunter the Badger says they are loyal. In Redwall, badgers are loyal. Since all three are English writers, badgers probably are seen as loyal animals.
@HeatherNickless-vt8zr
6 ай бұрын
@fawfulfan; It is applied to the sacrificial charm, now that I think about it from your explanation about how Harry's blood in Voldemort allowed the dark lord to touch him; but it is deeper than just that, because even though the combined spells used to protect Harry doesn't make the boy immortal, it does give him a few extended years and endurance to live; I think that is why Harry manages to survive the Dragon challenge in his "under-age" status as a Triwizard champion (Before the Little Hangleton Grave Yard event), with or without faculty help. Lilly's Sacrificial charm of protection on Harry was broken when he turned 17 on his birthday in "Deathly Hallows", but the projection of that protection was only reinstated to his allies by his own sacrifice; while the remanence of his friends are protected, Harry no longer has that kind of protection anymore, he is now a normal wizard who left his friends more extraordinary than ever.
@HeatherNickless-vt8zr
6 ай бұрын
Actually, Harry's invisibility cloak is made with the combined weave of demiguise fur with Thestral hair Stitching; Demiguise hair was the main material of the invisibility cloak's make, which is why it was described as being of a silvery color in the book(The Cloak was too blackish in the movies), because it was the material part of the cloak, but what prevented the material from tearing and losing its invisibility effects is due to the Thestral hair thread stitching. I have drawn to the conclusion that the threads that were used to stitch together the other invisibility cloaks were either ordinary thread or thread that was made with the same stuff as the material. This makes me wonder, why Ignotus was the first and only magical human to have ever occurred to use Thestral hair in the construction of his Invisibility cloak? Do not forget that it was the Peveril brothers who have invented the Deathly Hallows themselves; Beedle the bard only followed up with the outlandish factions of how the Hallows were created to immortalize such magical feats the brothers displayed.
@tilltheendoftime-adventure8441
6 ай бұрын
The story itself doesn't rule out Death being an actual figure or entity, however, so it still has merit.
@fawfulfan
6 ай бұрын
The Peverell Brothers invented the Hallows in the 13th Century; Hogwarts itself was only a few hundred years old at that point. I think it's entirely plausible that it took that long for wizards to come up with these inventions. Remember that in the real world, Medieval Europe pretty much forgot how to do running water for a millennium. Personally, my bigger hangup with Harry Potter lore is, how on earth did it take wizards until 1981 to discover that a parent willingly sacrificing themselves for their child grants them Killing Curse immunity?
@HeatherNickless-vt8zr
6 ай бұрын
@@tilltheendoftime-adventure8441 ; It is true that the figure of death thing is still in play, and technically there were more than one figure who embolizes either the appearance or the Aura of death or the meaning of death or the trickery of death through out the entire Wonderous-World-Of-Magic: The Basilisk snake represents the meaning of death; The Dementors Represent the Aura of Death; Voldemort/Tom Marvolo Riddle Represent the Appearance of Death; Albus Dumbledore Represent the trickery of Death. I know that everybody believes that Dumbledore embodies Death as a whole, but I believe he is only the representation of how tricky death can be[the final death is the easy part, but the tricky part is whether you get to choose your soul's path or if your soul will either automatically go to heaven or a place of punishment;_ that is the tricky part].
@Humanoidfrenzzy
6 ай бұрын
@@fawfulfan About the self sacrifice to save your child, I think it's more that if someone’s willing to kill a child, they're willing to kill the parent. The only reason Lily’s sacrifice had that outcome was because Voldemort gave her so many chances to step aside so he could kill Harry, yet she refused to budge. He would have allowed her to live as long as he got to kill Harry. Usually I think they would all just get killed.Why spare a parent if you're already about to kill the child?
@Humanoidfrenzzy
6 ай бұрын
Perhaps the stigma around Thestrals kept wizards and witches away from them? They were often viewed as a bad omen since you could only see one once you've seen death. so rumors and superstitions were probably enough to keep most magic folk far away and avoid them. That would be my guess from the info in the books at least.
@HarryFernandes15
6 ай бұрын
Id have to go read the chapter again but i think ur right on wands conection being similar to priori incatatum but not really. On it must have happened before dumbledore was imeadeatly aware so im guessing it has
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
Yeah confusing topic for sure
@DragonArbock
Ай бұрын
I don't think you get, that pure 'good guys' are boring. Snape is great because he's flawed, and somewhat more relatable.
@robokill387
Ай бұрын
That's not true.
@aon02b
2 ай бұрын
Also, the reason why the symbol of Ravenclaw is an eagle might be because the "raven" part of the name refers to the colour of the claw rather than the bird. So the name would actually mean "black-claw"
@scribblecloud
2 ай бұрын
i know this is the silliest thing ever to be invested in but that one section in level 1 is just the most affirming thing to someone that as a teen used to worry whether i was "worthy" of being in hufflepuff, lmao but like now when putting it like that there is no doubt that i would absolutely be in that house, as it has the traits i value the strongest, and do portray more than i used to give myself credit for i think
@stanleyosburn867
6 ай бұрын
The dersleys wer protected as long as harey was living with them
@TaeaSilimaure
2 ай бұрын
Voices would definitely be affected when consuming polyjuice potion, due to the larynx changing also. So the only thing that would be different is the tone of voice and the way a person speaks. We get the same effects with voice changer apps/programs.
@TZGKIV
7 ай бұрын
Doesnt Draco use petrificus totalus on harry in the train? Harry was spying on him with the cloack too.
@VaultLore
7 ай бұрын
Ahhh shoot yeah you’re right, he does. But still maybe it would stop a killing curse! We’ll never know!
@TZGKIV
7 ай бұрын
@@VaultLore what if it reacts more strongly to stronger and more dangerous spells? Or has to be willed to block a spell in some way?
@VaultLore
7 ай бұрын
Could be, I still like the idea!
@Hyper_Gogeta
2 ай бұрын
31:50 there's a deleted scene of the Slytherins escaping captivity from the dungeons. Unsure if they participated in the battle or not, but they weren't locked up for the entire battle. At least in the movie canon.
@pSiLoCyBeRiOuS
6 ай бұрын
For some reason I always thought the death eaters flying/black smoke was called Flitting, like it borders on the edge of disapperating but it’s not a fully fledged form of it… but I have no idea where I got that from, perhaps mixing up a term from a different book series
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
Hah could be! I’ve never heard that word before but it’s possible!
@pSiLoCyBeRiOuS
6 ай бұрын
@@VaultLore Yeah I figured out where I got flitting from and oof memory unlocked, it’s what the vampires did in the Darren Shan series Cirque du Freak 😂
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
😂 😂
@Loganberry
7 ай бұрын
New to your channel, big HP fan would love if you did more Potter content. Great video.
@aanyagupta681
6 ай бұрын
If Dumbledore had the power to put up the blood charm on harry and 2 of the 3 conditions also worked at hogwarts to protect him then why didn't he do so leaving harry at grimmauld place after lily's death with sirius? After clearing black's name ofc??
@MrPsyJak
3 ай бұрын
To be honest he had all three at Petunia's, which was ideal. At Hogwarts he may have drpped one, but Dumbledore could protect him in other ways at Hogwarts.
@Seabas-r8z
9 күн бұрын
Didn't Malfoy cast a spell on Harry while under the invisibility cloak when he tried spying on the train? The cloak doesn't block spells...
@VonOutlaw
6 ай бұрын
If Voldemort used a different wand like you theorized. Harry would still be protected because Voldemort has his blood inside of him which is still the protection that Lily gave.
@lxena8033
6 ай бұрын
Harry also has a piece of Voldemort's soul in him as well.....
@MrPsyJak
3 ай бұрын
@@lxena8033Depends which duel we're talking about. In the final duel where Voldemort dies, if he had instead used his yew wand, he would've killed Harry, as the Horcrux inside Harry was killed in the forest. I dare say that's why Harry was able to come back - we saw this before with the Resurrection Stone still working after the Horcrux was purged from it.
@SaucyJack88
2 ай бұрын
Everyone seems to forget that Harry Potter was the owner of all 3 deathly hallows during the final battle which according to legends makes him "the master of death".
@JNDReacts
2 ай бұрын
@@SaucyJack88I still say that was a pretty weak plot point. Harry physically wrestled some other wands away from Malfoy, so now the elder wand also belongs to Harry? And we’ve seen duels throughout the series, yet wand ownership/loyalty never changes hands before the final book.
@SaucyJack88
2 ай бұрын
@@JNDReacts not saying it's great writing but in Rowling's defense, the idea that the elder wand changes ownership/loyalty by defeating its current/previous owner was established pretty early on after the introduction of the deathly hallows. Evidently, the elder wand doesn't work the same way as normal wands.
@cato3277
6 ай бұрын
My death eater flying theory - theyre on brooms and are trailing peruvian instant darkness powder behind them to imitate voldemort, out of some admiration for their master and to strike fear in their victims.
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
Ah interesting!
@Batyabelle
7 ай бұрын
53:44 i would love if you made that a video, as a lover of the books and the movies i’ve kinda got them scrambled even if i’ve read the books more. My brain is a mush at this point
@HeatherNickless-vt8zr
6 ай бұрын
Every one should be noted and aught to remember that it was clearly stated in the books, that even though invisibility cloaks are rare objects, Harry Potter's invisibility cloak is not the only one in the wizard world, the cloak was the only cloak shown in the movies, to act more as a foreshadowing for the eventual 7th/8th Deathly Hallows films than a portrayal as being the only invisibility cloak. It is the only Invisibility cloak to be one of the 3 Deathly Hallows but not the only invisibility cloak in the entire wonderous world of Harry Potter.
@VendettaPSC
10 күн бұрын
His is just the best quality one, being made of both Demiguise hair and Thestral hair.
@yellayella.
7 ай бұрын
I thought, in the books, Vernon and petunia mentioned that they didn’t want to continue that magic hubbub and wanted to keep Harry from the wizarding world in general. Obviously they knew very little about how magic actually worked so they may have thought that they could keep him from the school and make him “normal”. They thought wizards were abnormal and obviously they thought it was dangerous considering petunia’s sister lily died so young because a wizard and her involvement in the magical world.
@VaultLore
7 ай бұрын
Hm yeah, I think it’s just strange that they are maybe caring on that level, but then also basically abusive on another.
@yellayella.
7 ай бұрын
Right so true about the abuse. Honestly is so hard to say if they cared from him on a deeper level. Additionally aunt petunia seemed jealous of Lilly (although I can’t remember if that’s in the books or films); which might indicate that she wanted to be magic herself? I’d love to do a case study on the Dursleys and really understand their intentions with Harry. So many layers
@VaultLore
7 ай бұрын
I mean I’d be wicked jealous if my sibling had magical powers 😂
@thesoftersideofsears
6 ай бұрын
They were totally abusive and only took him in because of Petunia’s deeply buried love for her sister. And Petunia was absolutely jealous, she wrote to Dumbledore asking if she could go to Hogwarts!
@Offbeige
Ай бұрын
A question I’ve always had was wouldn’t Voldemort have been stronger/easier to come back if he had had only 1 horcrux, bc wouldn’t the bit of soul that survived in Albania only be 1/8 of the whole rather than 1/2?
@tired_introvert6299
2 күн бұрын
I don't think Voldemort exactly knew Harry was a horcrux, because to kill Harry would be to kill a part of himself, which he obviously doesn't want. And if he had known he might've understood Harry might have lived the killing curse. Idk though, just a thought. That's why I think he made 8 pieces of his soul instead of just 7
@alexmccurter2885
7 ай бұрын
The Elder Wand wasn't the only wand to get through the Invisibility Cloak. Malfoy petrified Harry through it on the train at the beginning of Half Blood Prince.
@letsgetitbigcountry874
2 ай бұрын
So without Snape begging for Lilly life to be spared. There would be no love. Because Lilly wouldn't have been giving chances to leave. Snape.. good guy, bad intentions
@blankahegyi5561
6 ай бұрын
I read all the books many times and for the bond of blood it always sounded like it was part of the love potection from the start and not a second spell because we don't see Dumbledore casting a spell on Harry or anything he just puts him down on the Dursleys doorstep. And a funny thing in the hungarian translation rovena rawenclav is hollóháti hedwig so when I reread the first book and noticed that Harry found the name Hedwig in a history book I tought it was the hogwarts founder whom he got the name from not a random woman named Hedwig.
@Coco-Don
3 күн бұрын
I want an adult HP film so badly. Imagine a Peaky Blinders style show but with magic users.
@ARCtheCartoonMaster
3 ай бұрын
1:53 Patience the milkmaid = Hufflepuff, confirmed
@emjayee
3 ай бұрын
51:00 Voldemort didn't kill Myrtle to make his horcrux from the book, the basilisk did. So professor was a horcrux. He killed him by using his body, which was holding Voldemorts soul.
@MrPsyJak
3 ай бұрын
Quirrell isn't a Horcrux, he is posessed by one. The whole plot is that Voldemort split his soul into seven pieces: diary, Nagini, diadem, ring, locket, the cup and Voldemort himself. The reason his power was weakened was that he broke the charm of 7 when he accidentally made Harry a Horcrux.
@resathe6760
3 ай бұрын
About the theory that Voldemort would've killed Harry at the end if he used his own wand or any other wand than the elder wand. He still had Harry's blood and therefore Lily's protection in himself, ankering Harry to life. As supercarlinbrothers name it lovingly, he is Harry's lovecrux. I don't think Voldemort had any chance of killing Harry himself at this point (he could've let someone else do it, that would've worked just fine).
@Aidith_Diversity
7 ай бұрын
Thank you so much for making this video. Really helped me understand Harry's resurrection on Deathly Hallows Part 2. I would loved if you could also make a video about the Fantastic Beast trilogy and how the Wizarding World connected. These are my questions that i would love to be answered. 1. Did Voldemort killed Grindelwald or not. 2. How Grindelwald is seen of a bigger threat than Voldemort. (I guess Grindelwald is more of a political influence while Tom is like a villain 3. How the wizarding world has a leader like a prime minister that control all wizardkind. 4. Does a qilin randonly born from a female qilin when an election occured. 5. Is being a legilimens (mind reader), seer (predicts/see the future), a vera kind or an alchemist or speak palsetoung is a magical power that can be born with or learned? (As like a Talent or Genetic) 6. How Minerva McGonagall is in Fantastic Beast while that contradicts with her not being born yet. 7. The Black Family and Lestrange Family. 8. How the Caste System/ Pureblood ideologies works? (Pure Blood, Half Blood, Obscurials Vera Blood, Squib, Mud Blood, Maledictus, Goblin, Half Elves, Elfs (House Elfs) .Does it a reflection of Patriarchy of the Muggle World? Does humanoid treated better than uglynoids. 9. How Credence is seperated from Leta and Irma. 10. Does Harry Potter and the Cursed Child cannon?
@nhansen197
6 ай бұрын
Afraid that Lily's sacrifice was not freely chosen. Her choice was taken while under duress. Nor did she chose to sacrifice herself, she chose to protect her son. One other thing, given that the only witnesses were Harry and Voldemort, how does Dumbledore know so much about what happened? Did Dumbledore take Harry's memories shortly after the attack?
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
JKR seems to claim that it was explicitly freely chosen.
@amelianolde6743
4 ай бұрын
In the very beggining of their sixth year, Draco realises Harry is hidden in the cabinet listening to his conversation wearing the cloak, and as soon as he is left alone with him he casts a paralysing spell on him, isn't it? So no, the cloak doesn't prevent the "wearer" of the claok from being enchanted in any way. Let's all remember that Draco's wand was just ar ordinary as anybody's and he was still able to affect Harry. So there's no reason to believe it was the elder wand -being the most powerful one in the world- was why Dumbledore could stop Harry in the Astrology tower. Therefore, the cloak has not the ability to protect its owner from death.
@rhonwenbaker2448
3 ай бұрын
36:52 um, this is not quite true - the Weasley twins not only master the charm, but figure out a way to extend the effect beyond the scope of the object with their headless hats in OotP, later going on the supply the ministry with an assortment of disillusionment wearables. Either they or Hermione also point out that the effect wears off "rather quickly".
@howardhavardramberg333
7 ай бұрын
🙏more harry potter icebergs! 📿
@VaultLore
7 ай бұрын
Always! Thanks for watching!
@Wizworldreview
4 ай бұрын
So actually, in the movies all the deatheaters fly. It’s wrong because only Voldemort and Snape are known to fly. But I’m the movies that black smoke is them flying, I assume they chose it for artistic reasons, or it looked cool
@syddlinden8966
5 ай бұрын
As a practicing pagan, I'm face palming about the idea that no one knew about loving sacrificial magic. It's been a staple of magical practice as long as humans have had it as a part of our culture. Those are exactly the kinds of statements from Jo that make me want to scream "did you even try to research anything?" (The others being the inaccurate tarot, astrology, and rune meanings in the books)
@syddlinden8966
5 ай бұрын
The ONLY reason Harry was offered slytherin at all is BECAUSE he's a horcrux.
@syddlinden8966
5 ай бұрын
The resurrection Stone didn't bring Harry back. He came back because he wasn't killed voldemort's horcrux was killed. The stone was just Dumbledore using Harry as a pawn.
@VaultLore
5 ай бұрын
I don’t think that’s necessarily true. Harry displayed traits that were slytherin-esk on his own without the piece of Voldemort in him. Ambition, wit, cunning, Harry did have some strategizing sides to him.
@VaultLore
5 ай бұрын
Correct, don’t think I said that the stone brought him back? It’s a common misconception.
@lukkusgames5423
4 ай бұрын
Malfoy is able to petrify Harry through the cloak on the train in book 6, so the cloak can't have that strong of an "armour rating", so to speak. Also, Luna can somehow see him through it? Her "Gnargle glasses" must be quite powerful!
@VaultLore
4 ай бұрын
Yeah the more and more I dig, the less powerful and more exceptions the cloak seems to have..
@denisucuuu
3 ай бұрын
@@VaultLoreWhat can you expect from such a powerful object that gets used and is introduced in so many different situations across seven books...
@anastasiabernevik1319
5 ай бұрын
I'm not sure how i feel about this "love charm" and James. I kinda feel like it's unfair to him. They knew it was Voldemort and that he probably came there not to drink some tea and talk it out, you know. I guess he knew he had a bigger chance of death than of survival. And he still protected his family to step before the guy and save them sometime. I love Lily, but I hate it when James and his courage is overlooked as well. Cause most of the time it's just "my mother's sacrifice" and not "my parents'"
@VaultLore
5 ай бұрын
Yeah James got the short end of the stick for sure
@BreadApologist
3 ай бұрын
I suppose in the movie, the death eaters bailing after harry got a respawn, would just be the movie’s interpretation of apparation. Or maybe a type of flight. Like not true free controlled flight. More so like a emergency evacuation type thing. Where it pulls you back to a specified location. Kinda like being a passenger in a plane, you would be “in flight” but not actually “flying” as the pilots would be doing.
@christ.6211
6 ай бұрын
"Over an hour", precisely 2 second over an hour
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
😉
@sofiak4338
6 ай бұрын
Uh, I feel like the effects between Harry and voldemorts wands are pretty well explained in the books, Harry ESPECIALLY asks Dumbledore about the golden flames at „kings cross“. So uh… I mean idk how can you make an argument about that, talk about it for minutes, and then just forget that? Feels on purpose
@erincarter1469
6 ай бұрын
On Priori Incantantum, maybe the effect was also because the core was pheonix feather, and Phoenix are the bird of life and death. Voldemort fears death. Harry is the master of it. (Or will be as the last living relative of the lineage)😊
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
Yeah, but I’m pretty sure they only have matching cores in the graveyard, every other instance Voldemort uses a different wand.
@justdavelewis
6 ай бұрын
RE: the smoke from death eaters and Aurors… i think thats it, Simply a stylistic choice - Movie canon means death eaters and aurors can fly broomless and i think thats ok, but it does take away from Voldemorts power a bit
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
Yeah, it’s supposed to be crazy hard to fly… and now any of them can do it.
@Batyabelle
7 ай бұрын
so happy i stumbled upon these videos :)
@GermanyDodo
6 ай бұрын
Normally i dont comment on yt videos, but i think your content i great and you should have waaaay more subs! i hope this helps for some algorithm magic... keep on doing this cool content!
@VaultLore
6 ай бұрын
So awesome! Thanks for commenting and watching!! I’ve got more in the works!
Пікірлер: 366