Half the research spending for ME in a 10 year period in the UK went on the widely discredited £5M PACE trial [1]. The trial is taught in textbooks [2] and universities [3] as an example of how not to conduct a clinical trial. Over 100 experts and 80 charities want an independent review [4] and 40 MPs want a public inquiry [5].
The authors had a strict plan which had been approved and published, but they decided to change that plan after the trial had started. The changes resulted in the publication of a study that was fundamentally flawed and uninterpretable. The main flaw is that the trial is unblinded and primarily relies on the results of patient questionnaires [6]. Students for best evidence, supported by Cochrane, state" If you are reading a study that is un-blinded, with subjective outcome measures, then you may as well stop reading it" and if a trial is unblinded the measures "must be objective!" [7]. Subjective measures like questionnaires are not reliable especially when the treatment encourages patients to think positively [8]. A freedom of information request of the trial steering committee minutes found that actimeters which objectively measure activity were dropped at the end of the trial because a Dutch study reported negative results [9] [10].
They also lowered their definition of improvement and recovery. Recovery was lowered to a level similar to patients with congestive heart failure [11]. The claim that patients can recover is not justified by the data and is highly misleading to clinicians and patients [12] [13]. Changes meant that 13% of participants were already recovered on a key measure before the trial had even started [14]. Ron Davis stated "I'm shocked that the Lancet published it... I don't understand how it got through any kind of peer review" [15].
PACE TRIAL SERIES: • The PACE trial
TWITTER: / abrokenbattery
GET INVOLVED:
ME Association (UK Charity)
www.meassociat... (Patient Support)
www.meassociat... (Research)
Invest in ME (UK Research Charity)
www.investinme....
Tymes Trust (UK Children Support Charity)
www.tymestrust...
Open Medicine Foundation (USA Research Charity)
www.omf.ngo/
ME Action (Global Grass Roots Action Charity)
www.meaction.net/
Science for ME (ME Science Forum)
www.s4me.info/
CREDITS:
Ask the Prime minister
• Ask The PM - ME
Carol Monaghan - Parliamentary Debate Feb 2018
• PACE Trial Debate at W...
Professor Bruce Levin
• How NOT to Conduct a R...
Professor Brian Hughes
• Hope 4 ME & Fibro N.I....
Dr Fred Friedberg
• Dr Friedberg about the...
John Peters
podcasts.apple...
David Tuller
• David Tuller #CMRC2018
Oxford University Hospital NHS - Graded Exercise Therapy
• Video
REFERENCES:
[1] www.meassociat...
[2] www.amazon.co....
[3] • How NOT to Conduct a R...
[4] www.virology.ws...
[5] www.drmyhill.c...)
[6] journals.sagep...
[7] www.students4b...
[8] www.centreforw...
[9] twitter.com/AB...
[10] www.s4me.info/...
[11] journals.sagep...
[12] www.tandfonlin...
[13] www.meassociat...
[14] journals.sagep...
[15] www.virology.ws...
Негізгі бет The PACE trial - Part 1: Moving the goalposts
Пікірлер: 23