This video is further proof that no matter what I say about a game, people will still find a way to be mad about it. #1 THIS IS NOT A GAME REVIEW. It's a first impressions video. All of my game reviews are titled as such with a (Game Review) in the title. If you took this as a comprehensive game review, it means you clearly do not follow my channel, so I cannot totally blame you, but if you DO follow my channel and thought this was an in depth review.... well, shame on you #2 Whether or not the "Line Infantry" class is good does not take away any of the points that I made in this video. There's a bunch of troglodytes in the comments rn flaming the entire video and calling it worthless because I didn't know about some niche mechanics that are never told to you. #3 I LIKED THE GAME. Are you all blind and deaf or something? I said it was good. I said people should try it. Why are so many treating me like the anti Christ for missing a few mechanics that will ABSOLUTELY NOT sway anyone's, or even my opinion of the game Thanks for coming to my TED talk, so you all in DDOS in 2 months I guess
@channelege8325
Ай бұрын
you're cooked 💀 At least you got a bunch of material for DDOS.
@skele9762
Ай бұрын
this doesnt look like bowl mass hysteria to me.
@mbxyjm1471
Ай бұрын
You are the devil
@mbxyjm1471
Ай бұрын
You suck
@palehead
Ай бұрын
I seriously don't know what happened. Normally your fans pretty generally have your back but this is the first time I have seen the TOP COMMENT with tons of likes be a stupid and overly harsh criticism that doesn't even actually say anything, and in this case literally reveals another flaw on a video trying to say that said game is GOOD. You scroll through here and there's so much support for the idea of "this guy didn't play the game because he's hating on stuff he doesn't understand." If these are really such important features, shouldn't there be something in place the lets you understand them without having to gain experience you could just not even achieve in the first place? Other people are saying this isn't a good review because it doesn't cover every single aspect (because apparently you can't just share you experience with something unless it's a full-blown journalist review). To top it all off, probably the stupidest thing in here is people saying "oh Eclipse, the game got updated Eclipse! Bad review because wrong version of the game!!" Because of course, you're an omniscient being. You were supposed to know that this update was coming to this game you haven't played before, and wait to make a video on it because that makes so much sense. I swear, all of this is so stupid.
@Fezezen
Ай бұрын
I am the creator of Guts and Blackpowder. The game I made before Guts & Blackpowder was Left 2 Die, some copy of Left 4 Dead. Guts & Blackpowder started as a joke between the developers of that game as a "What if zombies but against muskets" thing, since it's an absurd idea that hasn't really been done before, and at first glance it seems like such an idea would never work. We cancelled Left 2 Die because G&B became much more promising, and also because just copying Left 4 Dead into Roblox was not at all fun or interesting to us. The melee weapons having multiple attack directions was a holdover from games like Blood and Iron, the type of Napoleonic Simulator you discussed at the start. This does have a bit of a purpose though, mostly just on the sabre though and not really any other melee weapon. You can thrust your sabre to gain extra range, but sacrifice the sweeping action. It is useful when trying to run away from zombies. I do see your point in how it's pretty much useless in every other way though. Mostly it's just there to give the melee weapons a bit of variety, and if you don't care for that, version 0.10.0 allows you to lock the swing direction you want so you don't have to put up with it. I don't think the Line Infantry class is useless at all. The musket is the most accurate weapon in the game, and has the highest penetration in the game. It is very useful for sniping, particularly taking out special zombies like the bomber and the runner. The line infantry class also has the most useful charge ability with their bayonet that practically instantly kills zombies. The bayonet is also a very useful melee on its own without the charge because of its high damage and range. The Blunderbuss is also by far the most useful firearm in the game. Its spread and damage means it can take out a group of zombies very well. These people are very useful for a team because they create space for their team. In endless mode the seaman class player will usually get the most amount of kills, and therefore be actively helping their team by getting those kills. The Officer's pistol, by design, is borderline useless. It has high spread, meaning you are unlikely to hit a target that is far away. This is on purpose because the officer isn't a damage class, it is a support class. It just seems to me like you missed the entire point of these classes in favor of your own personal play style. Only one of the classes is locked behind a badge, which is the priest class. Arguably the most useless class. It's locked behind a badge just because we didn't want inexperienced players to play it, die because he has a very weak melee, and is very support oriented, and then get frustrated. Also an inexperienced priest would annoy their team because they wouldn't play their purpose right. Which is to help infected players. All classes other than that are playable without any achievement necessary. A lot of regiments are locked behind game passes. They don't provide anything mechanically new or different, they are purely cosmetic, and this is how the game makes money. It's entirely just to distinguish yourself and not because they actually serve a mechanical purpose. Some nations do lack a surgeon regiment to choose from, and this is something we're addressing. Endless mode was the first mode in the game, and naturally it was pretty uninspired because I was working completely alone at the time, and just wanted to see if something with the concept would work. Objective mode is the meat of the game, where I think the concept is at its best. Endless mode is something we've been eyeing to change some time soon because pretty much all of the developers agree it is boring. It's become a cemented part of the game now, and some people really like it and hate objective mode for some reason. You are correct in saying that the lack of items is from the time period. It's very restrictive, and doesn't lend itself well enough to a game with many items to buy and try out. We still have many ideas to work out for it, but the game will likely never have anything near the variety in terms of items as a game like Team Fortress 2.
@chicken_kiev9929
Ай бұрын
endless mode is goated 🐐
@axelthorpe7708
Ай бұрын
I read all of that and I’m proud of myself. I also wanna tell you about my zombie idea. Lurking in the shadows, inside of the town, there lies, something that will turn your face, into a bloody frown. This is the zayonet charger, they look like any infantry that the map is based around, they wield a musket and apron spotting someone, they will let out a load scream for about 2-3 seconds attracting any nearby zombie. After their long wind up, they will run at you with their bayonet and faster then a runner. (I’d say about 2x faster or maybe slightly lower.) When they catch someone, they will thrust their bayonet into their targets body and deplete their health rather fast. When their victim is almost at 0 hp they will take the bayonet out of the poor players body and prepare an attack very similar too the upwards bayonet attack. When they thrust it down, it lands on the victims face sending them to the ground, dead. They can tank 4 sabre side slashes and 2 axe attacks, but they get one shot by every firearm in the game. When they have attacked someone, you either waste a lot of time by meleeing them, or you could just shot them so your teammate doesn’t lose too much health. When you kill the zayonet charger while he already got to someone, their musket will be left in the victims body and has to be pulled out by another person, but without the pressure applied by the zayonet charger it will deal a lot less damage over time. If you find this is too simple for your game, you could make it actually shoot people with its musket, but only once before using its bayonet to charge at people. I hope you like this concept of mine!
@samueldismukes1265
Ай бұрын
cool
@_sansvisage
Ай бұрын
You guys are the goats, keep brainstorming you guys have one of the most promising games on this platform
@Lester11223
Ай бұрын
i aint reading allat
@celsiusnebula
Ай бұрын
If you're a true connoisseur of bowls, you'll know that zombies are also similar to bowls. In fact, everything in this world is a bowl. The point of the matter is, zombies want to hold brains in their stomachs, like how a good bowl will hold any food you put into it. Zombies also work together as a team, like how you can put multiple bowls into each other and still have it work.
@gator7774
Ай бұрын
irreversible bowl-rot
@celsiusnebula
Ай бұрын
@@gator7774 check the top comments on the previous 2 videos :)
@gator7774
Ай бұрын
@@celsiusnebula hahaha very nice
@PhuongNguyen-ho8ce
Ай бұрын
what is bro yapping about?
@Arabicat.
Ай бұрын
@@celsiusnebula I see what you did there * points finger guns at you*
@Nullworks.
Ай бұрын
The direction swing has a use. -Swinging right or left sweeps -Swinging up allows for headshots -Swinging down has higher swing rate The different directions also have different ranges Also the game was inspired from another game called blood and iron
@solar_pan-el
Ай бұрын
doesn't matter when you're spamming left click against a horde of zombies imo
@Nullworks.
Ай бұрын
@@solar_pan-el well not all the time it does matter especially because of runners and defending hordes by yourself
@pavlo5551
Ай бұрын
@@solar_pan-elyou won't survive even 5 seconds against a horde after getting separated or being one of the last survivors
@ahmetergul4131
Ай бұрын
@@pavlo5551I smell skill issue. There is literally an achievement called "Alone, at the end of the world" where you literally need to kill horde by yourself and I am not even talking about solo runs that is viable to casual players.
@NurtyBN
Ай бұрын
Direction doesnt matter too much like he said 90% I just spam click until my finger hurts, btw upper swing doesnt even hit head most times lmaoo,. There is advanced tech with lower swing to hit head thats it
@certifiedgoofba1l
Ай бұрын
1:42 the creator behind G&B (Fezezen) was working on a game before G&B, called Left 2 Die, which was pretty much Roblox L4D.
@haihahoi
Ай бұрын
yeah bro
@skriblz3047
Ай бұрын
apparently he got the idea to make gb after seeing the musket which was a joke/meme weapon at the time (I think it was on ready 2 die) and I guess he thought of the concept of cool napoleonic zombie game and decided to run with that instead of r2d I either found out about this by a comment from someone else on yt, when I was digging through Fezezen's KZitem, or somewhere on the official gb discord.
@flop69419
Ай бұрын
you can melee the barrel guy for the best results
@Ilikeducksbroski
Ай бұрын
Stake is the best weapon to do it
@Falchion420
Ай бұрын
funny thing is that in the video he actually does this
@Premierofpotatoes
Ай бұрын
XD
@sim51m
Ай бұрын
Eclipse is the type of guy that would melee the barrel zombie and be confused on why it exploded
@moistisprobdead
Ай бұрын
He actually did melee the barrel once.
@feral-laptop6839
Ай бұрын
exactly 💀
@istoleyourtv7823
27 күн бұрын
😂 or stab it with the bayonet from far away.
@2fore2splace50
Ай бұрын
I wish this guy actually played the game [A BIT MORE]. The line infantry gets special buffs during charge, specifically 10x the melee damage and the ability to instantly kill anything you touch without having to swing your bayonet. The blunderbuss IS good for crowd control, though the randomness of the spread can mess you up pretty good. Some regiments are locked behind a paywall… yeah. It’s a way to support the developers and they’re purely cosmetic. Also the new update is out, which overhauled the UI and added a few new maps and weapons (no, people don't expect him to know when the update would come out. it's just that the version of the game he's playing on is 5 days out of date.)
@dormitory650
Ай бұрын
literally it's so obvious he played for maybe an hour or two at most 😭 he brings up some good points yeah, but saying line infantry and seaman are useless is actually fucking insane
@notsand3533
Ай бұрын
🎉
@randomincguylol3647
Ай бұрын
2fore2 my beloved.
@tutterthemouse152
Ай бұрын
it was just a tryout i suppose. he's trying to branch to a lot of different games on roblox through recommendations and give his thoughts on it. he doesn't spend a long time on the games but he generally has enough understanding on why you should try it out
@Bloxxer0908
Ай бұрын
Real
@thunderspark1536
Ай бұрын
Damn surprised you're covering this! Now I wait for decaying winter, my other favorite game on the platform! The similarity you mentioned to pvp, it's because the game takes it's combat from blood and iron, a fellow Napoleonic game. The specific advantages of Linemen and blunderbuss is their improved ability to handle special zombies, linemen for pierce and blunderbuss for hitting multiple special zombies. Often time zombies can hide behind other zombies/be grouped up and be difficult to hit with the low-pierce pistol.
@sureusebuddy
Ай бұрын
Oh, yeah! I forgot about DW. Great game, not sure if Eclipse would enjoy it, but I'd love to see a review on it.
@thunderspark1536
Ай бұрын
@@sureusebuddy If he did this one I don't see why not. He may not enjoy it due to lack of tutorial but it's not that complex of a game either.
@sureusebuddy
Ай бұрын
@@thunderspark1536 Oh, yeah. Didn't think about that, although the strategies are quite difficult, especially while soloing. Unless you use the hive mind cheese.
@ToppHaat
Ай бұрын
I'm suffering from trying to do showdown :(
@lobzoy
Ай бұрын
"Now I wait for decaying winter" god help your poor soul because i can tell hes going to *despise* it
@rock6998
Ай бұрын
4:05 "the default rifle man class is awful, it just sucks, there is 0 reason to use this class" has the gun with the highest possible accuracy and range to snipe bombers (musket) has the best single target damage melee in the game (bayonet) has the ability to one shot every enemy in the game when combined with an officer charge (bayonet again) has the best possible penetration for a gun in the entire game (musket can kill up to 11 zombies in a single shot if lined up correctly) please play the game for more than a couple of hours and figure out these mechanics before saying shit like this man come on
@sethivaltas619
Ай бұрын
on god man
@iwillslapyou4982
Ай бұрын
"best single target damage melee in the game" is debatable, especially considering sapper's ridiculous headshot multiplier. However, your point still stands, line infantry is a good class.
@rock6998
Ай бұрын
@@iwillslapyou4982 i consider the bayonet to more viable in more situations, axe headshot multiplier is great but bayonet headshot also one shots regular zombies and has a longer range if you're trying to kill runners, also factoring in how slow axe is compared to bayonet, axe is better for multi target hits.
@solar_pan-el
Ай бұрын
who gives a fuck about the bayonet's single target damage when you have a sabre that can kill in the same hits, and has better crowd control? line infantry's penetration also doesnt really matter when everyone is using melees and straight lines of zombies are rare the only good thing about line infantry is the accuracy...... which is only used to kill stalkers and bombers. other than that, youre a meat shield that presses left click and R every 6 seconds or so, unless you're using sabre
@engineerfour3071
Ай бұрын
@@solar_pan-el I saw a video San Sebastian and most part of the time are using Bayonets, don't say Sabre is best. (In the video 1 Line Infantry and 1 Sapper)
@PizzaSMelt
Ай бұрын
Just a heads up before bringing any counter argument to the front. This whole video is merely first impressions just how anyone else would have, and as first impressions the things Eclipse addressed still matter, because at the very least the game should better explain its mechanics so certain classes/gimmicks don't seem useless to first time players.
@skeleman4235
Ай бұрын
why would he make a critical video on the game if he's on his 'first impressions'
@averylongnameforabsolutely566
Ай бұрын
@@skeleman4235 You are braindead. Google the concept of first impressions please and never comment again until you get past 5th grade.
@g_anjer
Ай бұрын
@@skeleman4235 this video is not a review, it's 'first impressions' for a reason, he LIKES the game still.
@sethivaltas619
Ай бұрын
Yeah, I guess the issue becomes that it largely feels like a review, and some of his own fans even seem to have thought that it was a review until he clarified that it wasn’t. Pretty unfortunate turn of events all in all
@hoangphongnguyen4044
Ай бұрын
It's about the game too, the first impression doesn't mean you have to know everything/tips/stuffs in this game.The exploration can be around gameplay, Like how people use other class, how you choose class by reading and press ? Some points are right but some points are bad for comparison/judging too soon( How he didn't know about bayonet when the game literally showed that)
@user-sx9qs2hr1q
Ай бұрын
As someone who had a similar experience at first i don't blame your first impressions and hope you continue to play it specially now after the update that just got out
@Qrcrap
Ай бұрын
Blunderbuss is a key part of clearing, and surprisingly requires skill 💀 cause its not a full blown shotgun at times, I have seen someone who just spammed blunderbuss in 1 leipzig round and got 230+ kill, ofc with sappers and musicians. +Spamming them in endless with a competent squad with just 2 sappers wave 37 is plausible
@moistisprobdead
Ай бұрын
I would know I did something similar.
@Premierofpotatoes
Ай бұрын
Fr
@nooby5697
Ай бұрын
The devs were working on another zombie game before, which was just a copy of Left 4 Dead. The game was really unfun and unoriginal, so they decided to take Blood and Iron and make it into a zombie game, this being the source of some problems that you mentioned (sword system, choosing classes). Now, no class in this game is usseles and every single one is essential to winning the game. The line infantry has the muskeet, the gun with the biggest accuracy in the game, thus making it a good gun for picking off bombers before they get the chance to blow up your defense. The muskets bayonet also becomes really strong during an officer charge. Also, the seamen is good for crowd control, its the best option you got other than blowing up bombers, albeit the spread can make it incosistent sometimes.
@FridgePinkman
28 күн бұрын
I like how this man's first impressions and takes on this game is so objectively wrong that the entire community and the game creator collectively slam dunked his ass
@CorruptTypes
Ай бұрын
ur finally covering this game, been following it for a year now and im glad to see its grown this much
@goodboi1725
Ай бұрын
Nice to see you checking this simulator out, though I do wish you put more time into it before putting out a review. It’s probably not your thing, but there are just some things you leave out because you haven’t played the game enough. Basically, yes, the line infantry and seaman class is just as invaluable because they provide more firepower.
@bruh_moment2833
Ай бұрын
thank you eclipse for reviewing this game. I’ve been waiting for a while and seeing this video pop up in my recommended really made my day. I’ll make sure to watch it later after school
@skriblz3047
Ай бұрын
his review could be better ngl
@bruh_moment2833
Ай бұрын
Although I do wish you played AFTER the most recent update
@elsenorepico8090
Ай бұрын
the review is just yapping because he have skill issue
@NurtyBN
Ай бұрын
@@elsenorepico8090 you're just malding over first impression, which does not hold any solid criticism just personal experience
@sethivaltas619
Ай бұрын
@@skriblz3047it’s not a review though apparently
@therealbaco7968
Ай бұрын
If a game on roblox has somewhat low players, it's most likely a good thing, roblox players can't play good games.
@soursalt698
Ай бұрын
so many good and interesting games go unnoticed because people would rather play the most boring, unoriginal, micro transaction stuffed games to ever exist (and roblox algorithm just kinda sucks)
@tantank
Ай бұрын
Because majority of the games are brain dead, the same as their target market
@pavlo5551
Ай бұрын
@@soursalt698roblox is for kids, kids love wasting their free time on brainrot instead of doing homework. That's what I used to do, and that's just how our brain works
@bzynga2533
Ай бұрын
@@pavlo5551 I think he knows… he just saying that there are games that are more deserving of players
@nicoa1711
Ай бұрын
What about that crazy adventure
@flarethefox9836
Ай бұрын
Love that you covered this.
@domidoo1753
Ай бұрын
Guts & Blackpowder is a game ive been playing since release, and I currently have racked up over 600 hours in it. Not much replayability but I still love the premise of the game. On regards to "some classes are useless", let me make one thing clear. No Class is inheritly useless, they all have a purpose, some are better than others, yes, but they all do something better than others through the use of their main weapons or ones you can buy in the shop with a little playtime. Line Infantry: Has musket for long range, most accurate gun, decent damage and the bayonet is great for dealing with single enemies, it can have a carbine that can shove its enemies and reload faster for a little less damage, or a pike to kill enemies in melee from a long distance, but loosing its gun Seaman: The Blunderbuss class that you called useless, the Blunderbuss is, by far, the most overpowered thing in the game, and has been for a long time. Aim for the head and you can easily kill a group of 10+ zombies in a single shot, if your close enough even 20+ per shot, the Nock gun on the other hand, despite what many people think, is the worst gun in the game. With too long of a reload time to be of much help, and too accurate to deal with any amount of crowed. Ive heard every argument for this weapon and I have a rebuttal for every single one. Officer: Close range pistol for quick reloading, dosent do much damage but is good for dealing with bombers quickly, its main focus is using its saber to kill enemies, build up its charge bar then pop a charge at a good time for your team to cut through the enemies, or if theyre using a musket (with a bayonet) or a pike, they can just walk through them Musician: mm music Sapper: Heavy melee damage and builds stuff to slow the enemies advance, the general best melee class, but still needs support from its team to hold any ground due to slow attacks speeds with the axe, or low cleave with the pickaxe. Doctor: mm healing Preist: Cures infection (only useful on hardcore), low attack damage and range, but can also use its crucifix to push enemies back and stun them for a limited amount of time (all enemies excluding bombers)
@pancakeman0proplayz911
Ай бұрын
great explain fellow g&b comrade
@TheGoatKianne
Ай бұрын
im gonna have to disagree with the nock gun its really good it claps zombies easily i don't mind the reload its really op once you master it
@lefishe286
Ай бұрын
It's not that classes are useless, I agree that why use that if you can actually help your team? Honestly for most of not all maps all you need are sappers...and 2 medics. That's it. You can win anything with just sappers and medics. There's no reason other than endless for you to pick live infantry, officer or blunderbuss.
@sethivaltas619
Ай бұрын
Pretty sure it has a good bit of replayability if you've managed to rack up >600hrs in it
@littlebadassgaming
Ай бұрын
Old Guard here. Never played hardcore.. How bad is the infection mechanic in it?
@pancakeman0proplayz911
Ай бұрын
I didn't expect you to make a video about g&b. I personally enjoy the game since it's very different from the zombie games that I have played on roblox. And some of your point are valid in my opinion but some aren't that much like the musket is not worst that the pistol it has a longer range better penetration and can do a bayonet charge while being buffed by the officer (charge ability) and you forgot to mention the subclass like the lancer for the line infantry. And I do get that this is your first time playing g&b but there's still alot of thing you are not aware of. It's ok if the game doesn't fit your taste.
@candace758
Ай бұрын
ive never thought there would come a day that you cover this game, but im happy that you did
@ollirock_221
Ай бұрын
I have been playing this game for around 9 or 7 months now, and i REALLY enjoy it, ive almost gotten ALL badges and i always play this game when im bored, I try to get the very last badge i have to obtain. This is a good game and should be more popular!
@tdguy1532
Ай бұрын
When the lastest update came out the last week the players count reached the 15,000, even the devs were celebrating such succes.
@quiltzgamingyt237
Ай бұрын
Let me guess, the last badge is the Old Guard Badge?
@ollirock_221
Ай бұрын
@@quiltzgamingyt237 Nope its the “Evening redness in the west” Badge
@sureusebuddy
Ай бұрын
You finally played G&B! I loved the game, and I'm glad you liked it too. you're my favorite Roblox youtuber on the platform. Thank you, Eclipse.
@hanakaze3960
Ай бұрын
The different factions thing is more for customization, but I do agree that it's a bit confusing
@even_cooler_name_w_israel
3 күн бұрын
its not the hitbox changes to where you swing up is more damage and more chance for critical hit down is faster attacks but no critical hits and smaller hitbox
@invis_potion
Ай бұрын
I love playing this game, and I can understand why people would want to correct you on stuff they're passionate about. I played this game WAYYY back when it had 0 content, 0 replayability and essentially was a watered down version of your first impressions (Endless Map) and trust me, the menu and class selection was so much worse. I actually find this video really helpful, because it gives the devs an insight on how an actual complete new player would feel playing this game and improve their game so that you don't have to go on whole search journeys to become a medic lol. I'd say just keep making these type of videos on smaller games, because you give it attention to a wider audience, as well as give the devs some feedback to improve.
@Yuh_zhimmy
Ай бұрын
Yeah. The ui was hella confusing in 2022 when the only objective map was vardos lmao
@killerspino8087
Ай бұрын
The reason directional melees exists is to give more flexibility for melees like downward strikes are really easy to hit headshots with but have less range, stabs have more range, side strikes have an easier time hitting more enemies at once and have average range.
@freekshowgaming859
Ай бұрын
cool bug facts about the default rifle, if u go into first person, u can aim for headshots with the bayonet against zombies, which usually 1 taps a zombie, something i have found helpful in campaign and holdout mode
@pavlo5551
Ай бұрын
Or you can just look up with your bayonet, and press t
@mbxyjm1471
Ай бұрын
It does work in the early rounds but in the later rounds it becomes redundant due to igniters and bombers. It’s still a good tool to use once paired with the Officer.
@bioeyuko1266
Ай бұрын
Actually the directional combat can change some small things, like hitting the head, since hits have headshot modifiers
@Kiorka
Ай бұрын
Thanks for the entertaining video as per always Eclipse. Cheers ❤
@CaltRBX
Ай бұрын
Nice video, although there’s many issues with your criticism that I’ll assume is rooted in a lack of experience on your behalf (as you had stated, this is a first impressions video). If you plan to return to G&B, I’d suggest finding some experienced players and trying out the game with them, learning some tips and tricks, and returning to review again once you’ve gotten a bit more experience. Maybe take a look at the wiki and learn some new things you hadn’t known before! (Check out the bayonet on the Line Infantry’s musket, if there’s anything that may redeem the Infantry in your eyes, it’s gonna be the bayonet). I’d love to see a follow up to G&B, as I believe there’s a lot of things you seemingly haven’t gotten the chance to explore!
@Ruinatior
17 күн бұрын
Having to use a wiki is stupid, people have gotten so desensitized to using a wiki and don’t care anymore. What guts and black powder is really lacking at the moment is a tutorial. He played for 3 hours wich should be plenty of time to understand what the classes roles are. I hope that they add a tutorial before finishing the game.
@thelegosarge
Ай бұрын
Holy, i am so glad that you are checking out this game. 2 words: Delicious Leg
@nursestoyland
Ай бұрын
another 2 words: best melee
@srijemanin7924
Ай бұрын
What most people will get here is that you, actually havent played the game for more than an hour at most. lol
@srijemanin7924
Ай бұрын
@@Richcraftttttt It would have been alright if he gave some critique that was based on something valid. But its clear he has no clue what hes talking about
@coldfacemoji132
Ай бұрын
the fact that he shit on seaman and line infantry tho......
@averylongnameforabsolutely566
Ай бұрын
WARNING!! WARNING!! 😲😲😲😲YOUR COMMENT 💬HAS BEEN ANALYZED 🔍WITH IT BEING DETERMINED 🤔THAT IT CONTAINS APPROXIMATELY 75% BRAIN FAILURE!🧠🪦 DELETE YOUR COMMENT NOW❗❗BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE AND YOU END UP IN: *DDOS* 😭THIS IS YOUR FINAL WARNING! SOON, YOUR COMMENT MIGHT BE SCREENSHOTTED BY THE MAN HIMSELF☹AND BE USED LATER!! PLEASE EDIT✏📝OR OUTRIGHT REMOVE YOUR COMMENT!🔫YOU ONLY HAVE A FEW DAYS LEFT!🤯😰YOU MAY HAVE TO SAY GOODBYE TO THE REPLIES IF THEY PILE UP TOO MUCH😡😡AND YOU GET CALLED OUT FOR BEING *DEFICIENT IN THE MIND* ⚡⚡I FOR ONE WILL LIKE THE COMMENT SO THAT ECLIPSE MAY SEE IT SOONER!👍📌
@averylongnameforabsolutely566
Ай бұрын
Warning! Warning! 😲This comment has been analyzed and peer-reviewed🔍, and has been determined to contain *75% DOWNGRADED MENTAL CAPABILITIES* . 🧠🪦Please delete this comment before it is too late! Or else you may risk ending up in, *DDOS* ! ‼Do not fret, as long as you edit the comment to be different before it gains popularity✏, you'll be safe! I encourage you to read the pinned comment 📌while you rethink, reassess, and replan your own! Act quickly! 💯Else you may be dogpiled on by, shockingly⚡💡, reasonable people, possibly even Eclipse himself! 🌕🐺I for one with like your comment, in hope Eclipse sees it sooner! 🚩👍 I hope I spoke good lesser English, anything better might have been flagged as spam.
@averylongnameforabsolutely566
Ай бұрын
Warning! Warning! This message has been analyzed, peer-reviewed, and has been broadcasted directly to you! This reply has been determined to contain *75% DOWNGRADED MENTAL CAPABILITIES* . Please delete this comment before it is too late! Or else you may risk ending up in, *DDOS*! Do not worry yourself however, as long as you edit the comment to be different before it gains popularity, you'll be safe! I encourage you to read the pinned comment while you rethink, reassess, and reevaluate your own! Act quickly! Else you may be dogpiled on by, shockingly, reasonable people, possibly even Eclipse himself! I for one with like your comment, in hope Eclipse sees it sooner. I hope I spoke good lesser English, anything better like including emojis might have been flagged as spam.
@omegablaze135
Ай бұрын
Alright yeah I'm stupid but I'm keeping this up anyway since it's mainly my thoughts about the game + tips and tricks and stuff. Hope you enjoy playing the game nonetheless. I'm glad you decided to make a video on Guts & Blackpowder as it's one of my current favourite games on Roblox, although I do feel like you misunderstood a few things about the game. 1. The different directions that you can swing are useful in gameplay because all of them have different hitboxes and swingrates - a sideways swing reaches a medium distance and hits a wide area, an 'up' swing has you jab which has the longest hitbox but a low swingrate, and a down swing has the lowest range but the highest swingrate. 2. The Line Infantry (the class with the muskets) are not actually useless - first off the majority of combat is still uses melee, and so having a bad gun isn't too detrimental if there aren't any far away dangerous zombies to shoot (e.g. bomber zombies which carry a powder keg that explodes when it is shot, or igniters which throw a lantern that is basically a napalm grenade) although these are some of the most dangerous zombies in the game and so it it invaluble to have people who can pick them off from a distance before they can do anything to you. Second off, when using the musket did you look at the two buttons on your screen that appeared? 'Cancel Aiming F' and *'Toggle Bayonet X'*. Toggle Bayonet allows you to affix a bayonet and charge the last terrified rapscallion; it has a very long melee range (the average range of the sabre is 4 studs, for the bayonet it's 6.5 studs) and a high enough melee damage to oneshot the base zombie variants that sabres have to two shot. The bayonets also are buffed significantly buffed with an Officer's Charge as it allows them to deal almost triple damage (enough to one shot all zombies in the game) and auto attack any zombies in range. Also the musket has a high penetration stat of 11 (how many zombies it can shoot through) compared to the pistol's penetration stat of 5. The seaman is better for crowd control than you think, although if the horde isn't massive enough there's no real point in using the blunderbuss (it can kill up it 60 zombies in a single shot, which is overkill for smaller groups). It also has the funny Nock Gun which can deal 250 damage per pellet and you can load *seven* of them (you won't finish reloading until basically the end of the horde if you decide to load all the bullets though). 3. The alternate factions are purely for cosmetic purposes and are basically just for people who want the drip, want to support the devs, or care about historical accuracy. I do agree though that they should probably be filtered out into a separate 'Skins' or 'Cosmetics' tab though. One of the classes, The Priest, is locked behind an achievement that is basically "Hey do *everything*" although this is the only class in the game like that. Also yeah like no one plays Surgeon ;-;. 4. Yeah endless is boring. It's required for the 'Soldier's Grace achievement though (which is what unlocks the priest class) and is the main reason why people choose the game mode (there are also people who just like the gamemode, so eh) 5. I do feel like the shop prices feel very daunting for someone new to the game and that some of them should be reduced in price slightly. The lack of items in the shop is a problem, although not really something that can be fixed immediately because as you said the game is still in development and more items will be added to the shop in future updates.
@doctorenvy9650
Ай бұрын
Look man Im glad you found the game and decided to give it a try and heck- Even like it, but please play for a few more hours or understanding things better, Like, the nations/regiment mechanic is just there for cosmetic purposes or to make it more "accurate" considering how the maps are actually historical locations within the Napoleonic Wars, its not that deep or anything. But I'm still glad you found this game, and Im still glad you liked it.
@d3viltwelve679
Ай бұрын
Infantry isn't really useless just because most people don't know how to use it, bayonet is extremely good at poking zombies at medium range with low cd and oneshot via headshot. For range, musket's shot has better penetration and accuracy then pistol, and do i even need to mention bayonet's insane synergy with officer's charge?
@Marx8679
Ай бұрын
Plus the way he was using the musket wasn’t really intended. It’s more of a line up zombies to shoot since it was high pierce.
@moistisprobdead
Ай бұрын
It's also a sniper!
@systemstress9932
Ай бұрын
eclipse finding a games name relatable
@playeryoshi252
Ай бұрын
Holy smokes, least expected video from Eclipse. Nice!
@littlebadassgaming
Ай бұрын
1. The Musket class is actually very good for direct damage. As the bayonet to the face instakills all zombies but the axe-wielding ones. 2. No class is locked behind a gamepass. The Priest is the only unlockable one, and thats for balancing reasons as its meant for more experienced players.
@vicentescangarelli2361
Ай бұрын
4:28 the rifle is actually better then the pistol because it can shot through zombies, albeit its not that useful most of the time unless the zombies are coming at you in a straight line, and the blunderbuss is VERY good at dealing with hordes so idk why you think its bad dealing with them to be honest
@garbajae
Ай бұрын
طز فيك
@somebigboyletters702
Ай бұрын
Because you have a sword that deals with crowds easily, especially when you’re with a team, from the perspective of a player, yes it’s not bad for dealing with hordes, but even then it’s not the hardest with just a saber, and this is made worse from a team perspective, as why would you waste time shooting and reloading when your team will just clear out that same horde just as faster, as for the rifle, same issue in terms of penetrating zombies, and it really is just a stronger pistol with a longer reload. And realistically, when are you gonna actually be using your gun? To deal with bombers, and pretty much nothing else. Why use a rifle or blunderbuss when you can use a pistol that does all of those but faster? The only scenario I can imagine the other weapons actually being better is within the Catacombs and Kaub. Catacombs when it comes to deal with the last stand waves to shoot down bombs and more crowds, and in Kaub at the end in the basement segment. But these upsides are also just a matter of making it easier to shoot zombies, so if you know how to aim, pistols are still objectively better.
@sharuryavig
Ай бұрын
lets not forget the bayonet on the musket the second longest weapon in the game and officers charge as well
@somebigboyletters702
Ай бұрын
@@sharuryavig When you have a sabre, the bayonet really doesn’t mean all that much, made even more pointless with the hand axe, while it’s usage in an officer’s charge is extremely prominent and the most useful part about it, you realistically wouldn’t and shouldn’t be using it without a charge active as you’ll just be doing extra damage to one zombie, that you could kill the same way with two strikes with a sabre, as well likely killing more with it. Also something extremely niche, it lowers your movement speed, which honestly isn’t that apparent or that big of a downside, but something I personally dislike.
@dx_pair_gaming7853
Ай бұрын
It's simply because you wouldn't want to mele the dangerous zombies like the barrel or the sapper since theyre so clumped together that you can barely even see them, the problem is made worse when you're on a dark part of the map like the rooms In Kaub, the guns are more of a backliner type of thing since you will always need a Mele to stall until you're done reloading and then when the meles are low they could go to the back and let the medics heal them and the gunners would create some kind of distance between the horde and the team if we're not talking about efficiency and more about overall team support the guns would be still pretty important
@memehivefive9852
Ай бұрын
The game IS in version 0.10.10. So like, very very unfinished. But I do like how it keeps the old style of the original game, blood and iron, which the game is heavily based on (since you couldn't find the game, blood and iron is basically just a napoleanic war-based game where you have to fight other places, and that's basically it, so I think guts and blackpowder is a lot better). So, here's some things I think you got wrong. You probably won't read all of this or maybe not even any of this but these things are just my opinions. 1. The Line Infantry is not actually so useless. Maybe I should rephrase this, it IS bad but only if you have the default weapons. And even though the default Line Infantry is worse than the Officer, his gun has more pierce and range, along with more damage (which is useful later on in an endless or objective match where the enemies will get 3 hit by the pistol). There is also a shop where you can buy new weapons for different classes. The Line Infantry can use the the Carbine and Pike, along with a hand axe available for a secondary, which deals more damage than the Sabre. And you did check out the shop, but I just wanted to point this out since it doesn't seem like you bought any weapons. Oh, one more thing. During a charge, the officers ability, the line infantry just one hits everything it touches. Also 10x melee damage. 2. More of a smaller detail, but at 6:18 when you said you spawned in as a Line Infantry is just a simple glitch. Though I don't really blame you for being mad at it since it is annoying and can throw a game, it will probably be fixed, because again, the game is very unfinished as you also acknowledged. 3. Again, a smaller detail, and probably won't change your opinion which is fine, but at least the endless mode DOES have more unique enemies, with Bombers and Runners coming at wave 7 and Igniters coming at wave 20 which have a unique fire mechanic that can be dealt with using a bucket of water. But again, it probably won't change your opinion since objective modes are still better. Now since this was a first impressions video rather than a review, maybe you'll change your opinions, maybe you won't, either way, this is just what I think about it
@amusician644
Ай бұрын
Its technically a spin off of blood and iron since the weapon system are all similar and if you turn on friendly fire it becomes blood and iron in a way.
@BagpipeWeasel6
Ай бұрын
YAY!!!! I RECCOMENDED U PLAY THIS YIPPIE :D
@astraljava8500
Ай бұрын
Day 7 of suggesting eclipse to play [COMBAT INITATION] Combat initation is a ultrakill based game which would be a really good compromise to playing the actual ultrakill, its also REALLY REALLY fun and good
@randomguyonyt1183
Ай бұрын
He'd probably not know how to ricoshot
@astraljava8500
Ай бұрын
@@randomguyonyt1183tommorow il list off some tech
@astraljava8500
Ай бұрын
By tommorow I mean next vid
@daryncollins7640
Ай бұрын
by watching the entry point video(s) i can already tell you how this is going to go down he tries it and just says to play ultrakill as it is going to be better than the roblox game
@astraljava8500
Ай бұрын
@@daryncollins7640 probably, but would i still continue it? Ye
@flycatcher219
Ай бұрын
“Someone who is yet to master his craft blames his tools.” You mentioned the line infantry having no special abilities and the blunderbuss not being able to clear hoards. Both of which aren’t true. Thanks for making a video on the game just try play a bit more of the game before you criticise it. Thank you.
@RenReii.
Ай бұрын
i dont think you understand. the point that he made is that theres other classes that can already do the same thing except better
@flycatcher219
Ай бұрын
@@RenReii. The line infantry class is used for accuracy and amazing hits on singles Targets The Officer has the charge ability which is a huge buff to teammates. The Seaman has an amazing crowd control weapon. The fifer is a support class much like the medic and priest that have their own uses. And the Sapper of course builds barricades and is vital for nearly all gameplay. Each class has very unique traits and while i agree this traits are hard to find after only playing for 1-2hrs but G&B is not a beginner friendly game. It is designed to be hard and that's what makes it so great imo. Sorry for ranting. Stay safe!
@tameflames
Ай бұрын
@flycatcher219 single target classes in any horde game are the weakest compared to other classes unless there's bosses, but even then they're still pretty niche
@a-guy_i_think
Ай бұрын
@@flycatcher219 oermmmmm achtually its a musician, and thers a surgeon and chaplain aslwell
@flycatcher219
Ай бұрын
@@tameflames I guess this is an argument though line infantry has other abilities like a parry and the ability to one shot under a charge effect and has the highest buff under fifer. The accuracy is needed for taking out the bomber zombie as well though which is vital to avoid losing.
@calabasher
Ай бұрын
only thing i'd say you got wrong is the regiments part, wich it IS confusing, but they do not lock any classes and just change your character's outfit, the one and only class locked behind an achievement is the chaplain wich, within 1-3 hours (i wont say its not a lot for a casual player) you can get also all "infantry" categories have the same 5 classes while the specialist section is only for the surgeon and chaplain
@wander7812
Ай бұрын
Semi-Unrelated, but bro Imagine a Survival, Open World, Zombie game, that has a focus on Independent Community-Building, Faction Systems, and interactive surviving with Players, instead of the usual "run around and loot people." It would go so hard, and actually tap into the True Survival Aspect of a Survival series, but for Survival games.
@altezer8710
Ай бұрын
So turns out this time people are gonna use the “oH eCliPse dIdnT pLay tHe gAme FoR tHat lONg” to defend him now. “First impression” my ass, this video seems more like a review to me with the fully confident criticism in the video. I know this is not a review video, but a first impression one, yet the way you portrayed it is misunderstanding. That’s why people are targeting you for your lack of experience and understanding of the game. You’re not wrong and couldn’t be right either, but is the way how your video turns out to be for others. Next time, try making a proper statement and might as well give a good context on what your video is to be.
@Yuh_zhimmy
Ай бұрын
Yeah. Eclipse takes a little bit more of a cynical approach to newer games that he reviews. A good amount of them are just straight up bad, but imo for a game like this he definitely could’ve played it a little more.
@kalebvaitkevicius8494
26 күн бұрын
I mean... he critisized it well but i think he really just didnt learn the mechanics and was wrong at some points, line infantry is good for some maps with barrelers, blunderbuss is incredible against low hp targets overruning the team(also good for that one runner area in i think leipzig) and medics arent actually that good if your team isn't an icompetent mess (still need atleast 1)
@haroldbloc
Ай бұрын
The problem I have with those videos is that when you actually played the game, you can see that he didn't play more than an hour... PVP? The devs created Blood & Iron before which is PVP, of course you aren't going to to find under the Guts & Blackpowder group because, group name, nothing to say about it :/ Locked regiments? Purely cosmetic, here to support the developpers. The only class that is locked behind an achievement is the priest which is hard to play and requires you to know the game enough to play it, and random newbie cannot use priest since it can't fight and only serve a support purpose. That's why you have to "prove" that you're skilled enough to play it, and still, the requirement are quite easy. Endless? The difficulty rises (obviously) and it's there to test out your survival capabilities, reaching wave 35 in one life alongside other requirements that are easy if you play the game (which you probably didn't) rewards you which a new regiment (which is still cosmetic only). It's a team base game, and seeing your team go far is really rewarding. Things to buy? All of them are just there to change the gameplay but aren't required. For exemple, the pike removes the long range ability for a permanent bayonet which is already on the base rifle of the class, the pickaxe is just there to switch to a more fast "single target" type of attack instead of the slow crouwn. If this comment ends up in a daily does of stupid thingy, please, stop doing bad reviews of game after just playing so little. And don't say "it takes too much time" because G&B is an easy game to understand and the skill cap isn't high so you can pretty much have fun fast (unlike another roblox anime game with fruit in its name)
@mynameisyourname4684
Ай бұрын
But it wasn't a review. . .
@FineUndDandy
Ай бұрын
Oh yeah this game is great, I never thought you would give it a try though so it's very nice to see! Hope you enjoy it! Haven't finished the full video but I would disagree with your assessment on the rifleman, in wave defence especially sappers are a huge boon but can easily be undermined by the bomber type zombies, making riflemen useful to snipe these from afar to avoid defences being destroyed. I've also found myself being able to rack up huge kill counts with the blunderbuss to help thin through the waves more efficiently than teammates with swords who put themselves at risk via melee, from what I've seen a team with all the classes would outcompete a team that just spams sappers, surgeons, priests and officers granted the players know what they're doing. I think the game is a lot more balanced in this regard of requiring a cohesive team which can work with or against it and in my opinion creates more unique scenarios!
@nicknick_nick
Ай бұрын
It's such a trend for good Roblox games to have low but dedicated player counts, those games will have consistent numbers even years after no big updates.
@Jame88888
Ай бұрын
There's a priest class also that can bless people to make infected uninfected so if people doesn't have priest in a endless round and they're infected they'll just have to accept death ig
@mbxyjm1471
Ай бұрын
It’s barely used in normal mode. Hardcore is where it’s highly needed.
@realsupergonks
Ай бұрын
i can't wait for your review on blox fruit to talk about how unique of a game it is too!! great video as always eclipse ❤
@jeffboy4231
Ай бұрын
@@Hm-nc2of if anything you'd be on DDos
@Biggest_Con
Ай бұрын
Its satire ❤@@Hm-nc2of
@Zenniiiiiii
Ай бұрын
@@Hm-nc2of this exactly is why I am subscribed to Eclipse.
@szymonslusarczyk2299
Ай бұрын
bait used to be believeable
@daryncollins7640
Ай бұрын
@@Hm-nc2of r/woooosh
@fjfhu7690
Ай бұрын
Game is really fun if you play for more than 2-3 hours, once you understand how it works it's easy. Regiments and cosmetics like blemishes are purely cosmetic, they don't do anything to gameplay except you looking cooler and are the only thing in this game locked behind a paywall that you need to spend robux on (Not every regiment, after recent update 2 regiments in French Empire are obtained by a badge), and only that is locked behind a badge is chaplain. Infantry class is not useless, but it probably looks like that at first sight, a musket can be switched to other weapons like carbine or a pike, carbine being faster than a normal musket and pike being a long range melee weapon. Also, when you choose a class in another regiment in another country, and the next map you'll be playing DOES NOT have this country to choose from, you'll end up as a line infantry because you can't play as that regiment and country on this map. cosmetics
@Blue-ex9sm
Ай бұрын
Directional slashing is pretty helpful since swinging left with sapper can blend
@heyitsdavid-1213
Ай бұрын
I think bro didn t even play 4 matches and called it quits. The game punishes you for working alone and being selfish .
@moistisprobdead
Ай бұрын
He probably did play very little and probably expected it to play without heavy reliance on teamwork, hence why he gravitates to officer which is pretty good solo.
@mbxyjm1471
Ай бұрын
Only thing he’s right is endless mode.
@TheGlassMan
Ай бұрын
I think bro didn't even scroll 4 lines on the channel and learned that his game reviews have (Game review) on the title, this video is merely a first impression. You'd usually miss a lot on your first go around in games usually, you don't just suddenly get implanted with awareness of X mechanic or tech.
@moistisprobdead
Ай бұрын
I mean the blunderbuss take was just straight up wrong.
@TomXndr
Ай бұрын
4:10 you're right, but have you ever tried using the bayonet
@BreadMan1000
Ай бұрын
Also Waves is a good mode for getting a shop currency called "Francs" which you use to buy items for other classes. also old guard requires you to survive 35 waves so there's that too.
@ult-qj2wy
Ай бұрын
eclipse oiled up gyatt naked in the woods
@oliplayz3312
Ай бұрын
Wut da heelll.
@peylol1781
Ай бұрын
What does that sentence even mean?
@kle018d8
Ай бұрын
@@oliplayz3312normal g&b player
@sethivaltas619
Ай бұрын
Repent to God
@oliplayz3312
Ай бұрын
@@kle018d8 You mean, least suspicious?
@matpatlover
Ай бұрын
No views in 1 second? Bro really fell off 💀 (Edit: I'm just a troll thank you for wasting your time on yapping)
@ixorium4303
Ай бұрын
its getting old and overused 💀
@Sky_darts
Ай бұрын
This is the new "stopping kids from saying first" trend and I hate it.
@Itsmecamden
Ай бұрын
hahahahahaha sooo funny
@OneN4me
Ай бұрын
You are NOT making the whole squad laugh. Stop trying.
I think this was made with a lot of assets/inspiration from blood and iron, which is where directional melee comes from. Also, the blunderbuss is REALLY good. Also, the slight disconnect between the classes and the actual objective is one of the unique points of the game. Much like the soldiers themselves, you aren’t really SUPPOSED to be fighting zombies. It’s a really interesting spin on the napoleonic war genre, but I will say it’s probably meant for people that frequent those games. The experience of a new player is probably not as good. I played this game a while ago when it was just a last stand type zombie game. God, it really has evolved.
@Bloxxer0908
Ай бұрын
About the "factions", they are actually called regiments and do not offer any advantage other than flexxing perks
@Cupcakesfilledwithwhipcream
Ай бұрын
moosic
@SigmaBananaProGamer45
Ай бұрын
the directional attacking does have some use because the up swing does more damage but takes longer and the down swing is faster but does less damage which makes it better to kill runners with
@TrebleMaker1
Ай бұрын
Hi eclipse! Love your vids
@THENACHOUNEDITED
Ай бұрын
regiments are just customization, just like most badges (some of them giving cosmetics or regiments), only badge required class is chaplain being the most useful class in the game. line infantries bayonet is useful with an officer's charge, being able to oneshot every zombie type. sea men are more for far defense, as the blunderbuss has high accuracy from far away. all gamepasses are purely cosmetic gamepasses, no buffs. the game punishes you by playing alone, teamwork is outright required to play well. edit: technically gamepasses that give cavalry are different by being able to play lancer. but that still dosent change the fact that its just line infantry.
@galaxynoob6297
Ай бұрын
i find it funny that he started playing this the moment it got updated at some point, so the reason why the shop was short was cause they just added it
@x_zao8150
Ай бұрын
never expected eclipse to make a video about this game but here we are
@Sleepy_Kyra
Ай бұрын
Rifleman can target specific enemies easier than officer, rifleman has several options of rifles. Officer has only one pistol. Seaman has incredible crowd control potential
@Kebablover495
Ай бұрын
For the part he says the directional attacking is useless, I just want to say that for the most part it is but it does help occasionally when a zombie is below or above you on a elevated platform like a staircase which is particularly helpful on maps with said staircases such as kaub’s ending and San Sebastian
@noplusky
Ай бұрын
I remember playing this game like 1 year ago we were 4 builders and we just screamed "THE WALLLLLL!" the all time
@godzillamanz8139
Ай бұрын
This is just britian during a zombie apocalypse
@hellohennessy3462
Ай бұрын
The Line Infantry is used as Bomber sniper thanks to its relatively fast reload and being accurate. The Officer could do such a job but the pistol is innacurate and you often miss your shot. The bayonet is also very powerful in general especially with your directional attack facing upwards. The Blunderbuss is probably the most useful class in G&B. I play it often. I don't know why you said that it is bad at crowd control but on higher waves and maps like Catacombs, the long range and spread helps detonate bombers. The regiments locked behind gamepasses are just cosmetic. Your weapons don't change only your costume does. I agree that the UI is very confusing now.
@alphaprime8005
Ай бұрын
"Rifleman" or infantry has a use, and a big one is the synergy with Officer, if an officer uses it's charge, it can one shot any zombie, the game really relies of synergy of other classes and they need to work together.
@astralvoid5523
Ай бұрын
Love that you played the game, dis-liked the first impressions, glad you enjoyed it though.
@Caragoner
Ай бұрын
Glad you liked the game, but, while ill give you seaman is bad due to the blunderbuss being RNG and will rarely hit more than 3, the rifleman actually gets some advantages. Particularly its bayonet which lets you keep fighting without putting away your gun and is great during charges due to its length. The UI needs a clean up though you're correct
@slime8721
Ай бұрын
I enjoyed this review
@uhhhidk1096
19 күн бұрын
Linemen are meant to be snipers that pierce through multiple enemies or aim for barrels, so they don't insta kill everyone. The officer pistol is way worse than the musket even if it couldn't pierce just due to the accuracy and damage of the musket.
@Looman69420
Ай бұрын
the pet sim 99 jump scare got me shaking in my boots.
@ilikesnakes4695
Ай бұрын
Played this very periodically since it had first started getting going, introduced from a napoleonic war game (Campaigns/Waterloo/Napoleonic Wars) whatever you know it as, it's really well made. Also one thing about riflemen, the rifle is a bit better than a pistol and the bayonet is a good middle of the road melee weapon, but it becomes obsolete later with other melees that can be unlocked and in any case the blunderbuss for the seaman is better than the rifle, so yeah it could definitely' use a rework, I think it's ok for people starting out though.
@Premierofpotatoes
Ай бұрын
1, rifleman are mainly used for its subclasses, 2, blunderbuss has spread that scales with distance, 3, some classes needs you to unlock certain badges to use, 4, the nation/unit selection is purely for cosmetic purposes. 5, you forgot about the chaplain class,(it has an ability to push zombies away) 6, the reason ppl play endless mode is to get currency to unlock subclasses and the 'old guard' cosmetic for flexing. 7, it's fun once you get your friends together to play.
@NESOGaming-ec5ln
Ай бұрын
The funny part is that the line infantry is the best class, having the most range for both guns and melee weapons
@Unita_8869
Ай бұрын
I never expected this guy to actually review this game.
@xx_bobybless_xx1493
Ай бұрын
Hey eclipse, talking about zombie games , i got one for you. Rise of the dead is an incredible zombie game and the fact that there is still people playing it after all these years proves it. There is enough content for you to make multiple videos on it and the game is also so fun to play with friends. You should check it out.
@KuyaKloris
Ай бұрын
Eclipse is the type of person to start the horde when the sappers are building and wonders why the team and him got obliterated
@billy685
Ай бұрын
I hate when new players dont know how to play games and they make mistakes
@HenriqueMuit
Ай бұрын
The Regiment system is confusing at first but i don't think there's really any better way to quickly choose your regiment than this, so it's complicated to get used to but it's still organized and quick And for the classes they actually have some very neat stuff to make everyone of them strong! The Line infantrie's musket has an bayonet to meelee in long range and an better damage upgrade when the Officer's charge And the game just updated and it's really improving on having more weapons and all that
@vitor-fc6nt
Ай бұрын
The fact that i talked about guts and blackpowder in your balanced games and afterwards you go ahead and post video about it was so awesome asdksaldja Though i have A LOT of critics about this video, most of them come from the fact taht you made this video BEFORE the new update they just released, which pretty much broke most of the critics hahaha, also since it is your first impression as well, so first starting off with: Regiments, you said that the regiments and classes choosing is confusing, which i honestly agree, i first found the game in 2023, i joined, got confused, quit, but rejoined on 2024 after some reconsideiration, and LOVED it, Which honestly, that is a issue with the game of not having a tutorial honestly, even with the new update, at least the weapons are more explained bc of the shop rework, but the classes and regiment? yeah not so much, which i honestly think they should add a tutorial to explain that, since i think thats one of the main reasons why the game player count is not that much Though i would like to say that, the a lot of divisions for regiments is a absolute need and is not useless, they are not only for skin purposes (since some regiments you unlock through achivements) but also for story purposes, since not only that but, Guts and blackpowder have a very goated story as well, being very story acurrate with the actual napoleonic wars, with the maps, countries in it, the designs of each regiment and more! (though there are some innacurate history stuff but they know about it and most of them are for gameplay purposes) so yeah, the regiments are not useless, since it adds a cool variety of clothes bc ya know, skins, and improves the world building of the game alongside the lore it have within it Now the other critic: Classes, well you said the line infantry is a useless class and it would be better use the officer rather then it, well considering this is a first impression and again it was BEFORE the shop update, then i understand this POV of you so much, but correcting it... no... in fact... *LINE INFATRY IS ABSOLUTE MUST!* well you see, there are some type of zombies who uses bombs as their weapons, which if you don't shoot at the bomb, they will come at you and go boom, now, that zombie is VERY deadly, as it can destroy the barriers of sappers and kill a lot of players, now the best class to kill those is in fact, the line infatry with it musket, because of it range and penetration which allows you to shoot better at teh bomb and also kill a few zombies on it's line, different from the pistol which have less range and... a very bad penetration, like really, it sucks as a penetration, officer pistol is more for killing iginiters and waves where there aren't many that bombs, because well, you said you only did 1 endless right? so i'll assume you didn't pass many waves but... after like wave 20, there is a lot of bombers and A LOT of zombies, even a lot of igniters! and with that, you can't really relay on being that close to some giant wave of zombies and shoot with the officer on the bombs and iginiters, so thats when the musket shoot is relied, oh and you also forgot THE BEST THING ABOUT THE MUSKET... which is.... THE GODLY BAYONET! well that thing of bomber you could just use the other weapon line infantry have which is the carbine, which not only it realoads faster, but also have better range and etc, aka overall stats for bomber and iginiters situations, but the musket have the bayonet, which is a very op melee, since it can kill zombies at a good mid-range and it most op part is that, when the officer ability is used, the musket bayonet becomes RIDICIOUSLY FAST AND INSTA KILLS, which the game even tries to encourage that by creating the badge "GIVE EM STEEL" which is killing 10 zombies with a bayonet charge, and a officer change with a bunch of line infatry with a bayonet doing that, it clears A LOT of zombies, and the same logic for the blunderbuss, it actually is good for crowd control, in long wave of endless or Kaub (which have a lot of zombies in the end of it) it is also a need since you won't have 500 of officers using the charbe ability for line infantry (not to mention also risky since it is am elee) and thats when bluderbuss come, not to mention that it is also a good bomb killer, so yeah, i think you got the ideia of the classes wrong and pretty much all of them have it utility, which i don't judge you since before the shop rework, stuff such as penetration and range were mentioned and you just figure it out by playing the game a lot, but i am very open to debate about it And the last of all: The Replability and Melee directions: Well i think you got the melee directions ideia wrong bc i don't think you have saw this thing, which is: headshoot damage with melees, in this game you can deal headshoot damage with melees, which is why the existence of melee directions, bc, if you aim above, it is way easier to headshoot with the sabre, but at the cost of landing on less zombies bc of it being vertical and not horizontal, and the reverse if you aim sides, which adds a strategic way of how you can aim your melee and when to, which though a critic would be: how annoying it is to do that, but then: BOOM! the new update also fixed taht by addiction direction lock, where you can lock your direction that your melee is using and it won't change, and you can unlock it also whenever you want, oh and a show of that strategy is that: with Sabre you mostly would want to do side ways bc sabre is mainly to kill low amount of crowds, but for Priest with his Stake, it is better to lock it up since it only will use it melee to kill enemis at him, making it better to go for a headshoot, also bc of it low dmg as well. and about the replability, the weapons shops is very balanced on it ways as you don't absolute need to buy the items there and you can get even Old Guard with just the basic classes, but the weapons not only offers different styles of fighting, but also can indirectly help the player, the pike weapon makes line infantry be a TOTALLY different class as it no longer have a musket or a bayonet but a fixed lance, and the nock gun for the blunderbuss make it be a last resource killer for only emergecny cases like very long wave of endless, and honestly, one thing i do thought was bad, was how little the replability is even with those weapons is, since you pretty much only had the 2 modes, some few badges which some of them reward you with actual stuff, like the priest badge which you gives the priest class, and the old guard with rewards you the old guard division on french empire, and also the shop items, but that's not all really, which guess what? Also was improved in the new update! Where they added a new mode (finally), new weapons (even to sapper who i didn't even know that could be possible but they managed to do that and do it good), and new badges (even secret badges which you need to do chalenging stuff to get cool rewards), improving the replability! So summing up, i think most of my arguments counters some bad things you mentioned about the game and i also think most of the these bad things were improved and no longer that bad after the new update that just released, though i'm open to debate to anyone in the comment section and also on the purple social media site which have servers in it (Which i won't mention else this comment can get deleted so just ask me in the comments)
@dbusterYT
Ай бұрын
There's actualy a sort of block, some melee weapons like the sapper's axe that can shove, blocking enemies (there's also the carbine shove)
@saadgoumri3200
Ай бұрын
Yoooo w game glad you tried
@EnclaveSoldier2201
Ай бұрын
I think thw reason it feels like a simulator is because the combat system is mainly based on the combat system of Blood and Iron (a napoleonic war simulator game).
@lim9933
Ай бұрын
Finally some recognition for the most unique zombie game in roblox rn
@JamesFR2007
Ай бұрын
Can't wait for this game's game review and new DDOS episode
@PapaPonoupo
Ай бұрын
You're right on the shop thing, it takes litterally hours to buy anything at all from the shop
@altezer8710
Ай бұрын
The shop is pretty much a bonus thing for people who play the game a lot so new players aren’t to expected to buy stuff from the shop.
@asriel4046
Ай бұрын
Alright Eclipse, I know probably a lot of people told you this a long time ago, but... Allow me to explain. Factions are depending on the map you play, Russian factions are present on maps with Russian historic value, and so does the others, gamepass factions, like any other. Are an optional purchase that is only cosmetically changes your classes, like their uniform and hats. Specialist classes are special classes that can truly turn the tides of certain battles, medic: More teammates = more men to fight of the horde. And badge + mission unlockable class, with is Chaplin, that posses the crucifix that stuns the horde with holy power, and is able to "get rid of evil in persons body" (Cure infection that you can get from zombie, if you get grabbed. More zombies grab you = higher the chance of getting infected.) But is also possess the weakest melee weapon, with forces him to hide behind his teammates. And about riflemen, they have a bayonet, with is a very powerful ranged melee weapon, as well as that rifle is a very powerful single shot weapon that deals a very good damage to zombies, with high accuracy.
@Vextiion
Ай бұрын
Line infantry is just the officer but without a charge and the charge gets replaced by a sword on the gun (bayonet) and longer range Seamen is a long ranged crowd control (just line infantry with only the range and damage is the good part) Officer is a NEEDED class since the buff shred zombies in seconds Musician is just a support with reload speed (you can buy other instruments to, the drum: faster swing speed the fife is reloading speed and the trumpet is a long cooldown instrument that does both reload and swing speed Sapper is useful for keeping zombies away with barricades, spikes and caltrops Medic is the heal support class Priest (which needs a badge to unlock) acts like a way better barricade
@dedisaputra723
Ай бұрын
it took me about 3 hours to get the most expensive shop item in the game ( according to the footage ) the pike, very easily. you just have to play long enough
@jackshadow1234
29 күн бұрын
The game is genuinely good once you have played it enough and understood everything there is to it, I have 100% the game and without a doubt, one of the best roblox games on the platform even though it's content compared to others is low. The team working on it is really good at what they do and are always on top of bugs and updates.
@mimice9496
Ай бұрын
Eclipse, you should try Traversal, it's a short but difficult stealth game that doesn't take more than an hour or 2 to complete, and it's pretty polished.
@ijustdostuff5553
Ай бұрын
Yea this game is very good, the only thing i dont like is that some of the servers will be pretty empty because theres like 200 people but out of everything the game is very good
Пікірлер: 926