What do you think - psychological condition? Let me know below, and hit that like!
@goa9034
4 ай бұрын
2 comments erased!!! In less than 3 minutes I didnt mention even the word this video has as a title Pathetic
@VesnaVK
4 ай бұрын
Thanks for being brave and bringing us these voices, Andrew!
@gzoechi
4 ай бұрын
More like an indoctrination
@andrewgoldheretics
4 ай бұрын
@@goa9034 i hate that!
@Bullcutter
4 ай бұрын
@@goa9034That would be the YT boys enforcing their company's policy!
@dgh5760
4 ай бұрын
“No one tells kids that transitioning is like getting on a boat on one shore of a fast moving river to reach the other side, but you’ll never get to the other side and you’ll be in that boat for the rest of your life.” August 25, 2023, Dr. Julia Mason, Doctor of Pediatric Medicine
@HiAdrian
4 ай бұрын
That's an incredible quote! The weight of it, the horror…
@Juan_Stabone
3 ай бұрын
Unfortunately for many of them, that boat ride ends up fairly short.
@TomJones-op9nj
3 ай бұрын
So now we know why so many “drown” on their Journey….a Journey apparently being sold to them by the very people that are supposed to protect them….I seem to recall something like….DO NO HARM
@stephenmcdonagh2795
3 ай бұрын
Or climbing an infinitely extendable ladder placed six feet away from an infinitely high building, each time you extend the ladder the closer you'll get to 90 degrees, but you'll never get to 90 degrees as there are an infinite amount of fractions in-between. Actually I'm just using this as an excuse to write this conundrum I've had in my head for years. Two sexes, period... for one of them.
@Rayblondie
3 ай бұрын
Why do they have to put all this on us continually? The government are culpable in this for allowing it to go so far as are the doctors who fitted in with the deception. I believe God made them male and female full stop.
@MrNigelTBean
4 ай бұрын
At 62 I now feel that I am existing amongst the Midwich cuckoo's. At work many of the young are frequently off work for mental health issues. I see a lot of insecurity, desperate longing for a group to belong to. I see a lot of mal adjustment and straight addiction. I work in a clean room so phones are not allowed. At break there is almost a stampede to get to the lockers and get the phone out . There is little to no conversation, just incessant tapping and scrolling and a desperate longing for "followers" and "friends". No one seems to know anything, no one has hobbies, no one can string a sentence together. No one knows or cares about history, current affairs etc. There is no logic, no critical thought. Knowledge is knowing the names of all the Kardashians. You can't have a discussion because it's all about feelings not empirical data or scientifically established fact. People become upset about nothing and especially if you have a different view. There is little determination, grit, strength, endurance. No commitment. We have destroyed our youth or at least sat back and allowed others to and we blame the young for it. At this point I see it getting much worse and very quickly, just as with all previous societies. The only future I see is eventual collapse unless there is a great actual pandemic of black death proportions or a bloody great war to preempt it. Western civilisation is monumentally screwed.
@ninjawizard3865
4 ай бұрын
Western civilization is destroying itself the only way it can, from the inside out.
@colinsneller6274
4 ай бұрын
So right!
@alicejwho
4 ай бұрын
You articulated so well all I'm seeing (at 58). I agree: we're completely screwed.
@ninjawizard3865
4 ай бұрын
Well done 👏
@ninjawizard3865
4 ай бұрын
Western civilization doomed itself at the end of WW2.
@paulgeoffrey725
4 ай бұрын
At last someone has the guts to say it as it is.
@strykerpass600
4 ай бұрын
You must be deaf….. it’s been said millions of times over and over. In fact there are over 300 pieces of legislation in US courts saying similar stuff. Matt Walsh made a movie about it. There are KZitem channels that are dedicated to this topic …. Careers and fortunes have been built on being anti-trans. 30 trans people were murdered in the US in the last 6 months of 2023- so people aren’t just talking they’re acting. Should be ashamed of yourselves- where are people’s humanity.
@VesnaVK
4 ай бұрын
She's not the only one, I'm happy to say. Julie Bindel, Helen Joyce, JK Rowling, etc.
@slimal1
4 ай бұрын
@@strykerpass600 I'm sure you know not all 'anti-trans' folks want trans ppl to be physically harmed. Violence against ppl who just want to live their lives and love their partners is just unacceptable.
@FiredUpFeminist
4 ай бұрын
@@VesnaVK And Kathleen Stock!
@Jump-n-smash
4 ай бұрын
In the freedom-loving USA, you mean?
@MjollTheLioness-o4y
4 ай бұрын
The people who call lesbians transphobic for refusing to date transwomen give off the same vibe as the guys who say that they can turn a gay woman straight in one night.
@honeychurchgipsy6
4 ай бұрын
@LadyAmmalthea0615 - yes, I agree, I have had a definite misogyny vibe from these transwomen for a long time.
@DaVinci368
4 ай бұрын
I agree with your statement but would respectfully suggest that you stop using the fabricated word, “transwoman”. That is a word manufactured by gender ideologies. The intention of the word is specifically to obfuscate and confuse the general public as it implies that a man can “be” some version of a woman. They cannot. And using their term only aids in the confusion so much of the general public retains around the plague od gender ideology. Research show that a significant proportion of the general public mistakenly think that the term “transwoman” applies to a biological woman who has gender dysphoria. Because of this, they take no notice when laws are created that allow “transwomen” into the showers and locker rooms and rape shelters where only women are allowed to be. So please, consider using terms such as tranvestite or gender dysphoric man, or transsexual man, instead of the ideologies “newspeak”.
@electraruby
4 ай бұрын
@@DaVinci368 Well pointed out!
@intermidable
4 ай бұрын
@@DaVinci368 Show me the research, cuz I ain't buying it.
@SuperLibertarianMan
4 ай бұрын
As a man, of 41 years I have not once heard another man say they could turn a lesbian straight. But I've heard women say it a number of times.
@davidr9876
3 ай бұрын
The difference between the Trans movement and religion is that you're allowed to disagree with religion.
@Captain_Nemo1961
3 ай бұрын
Yes but it does resemble a cult more than a religion. All the stages of recruiting are there as well as the scorning and death threats if you try to leave the coven .
@FIatts
3 ай бұрын
Sure but both are just as stupid to believe are valid
@conillet
3 ай бұрын
Unless the religion is Islam, of course.
@miradamevska5887
3 ай бұрын
It certainly does have the cult traits in the trans movement, it is that a cult movement.
@austinjt4264
2 ай бұрын
You haven't heard of Muslim Religion yet... I think.
@lovedaybebe5881
4 ай бұрын
I worked in a residential mental health facility, and one patient was Trans , had every operation possible as they had money. Cheek implants Adam’s apple shaved , jaw line basically everything and yet was desperately unwell in terms of mental health. I did some research so that I might be better equipped to offer support , and the stats very much suggested that they are not happier , it doesn’t get better ! The person in question was very clever and looking back I realised , likely on the autistic spectrum. Such a travesty that this ideology is being pushed ! I’m glad you are shining a bright light on the problem 🙏🏻
@gzoechi
4 ай бұрын
Autistic people are a main target because they stand out as to not perfectly fit traditional gender roles. The others are homosexuals. The trans ideology is nothing else than pure hate against people who are different. It's like under the Nazis with Eugenics to breed out "degenerates".
@terrorists-are-among-us
4 ай бұрын
Guys that thinks women are spoiled bimbos and life isn't fair are not going to be happy explaining to the guys they seduce that it's not a real vagina, but it always seems good enough at the time 🤡
@mikewade777
4 ай бұрын
Gender disphoria does not leave post op. It's lifelong..
@gzoechi
4 ай бұрын
@@mikewade777 It's only as long s you believe you suffer from it. That doesn't have to be the whole life. Getting rid of people that have a bad influence on you might already fix it. Also if it doesn't leave post-op means, the op is pointless anyway. I guess that's an explanation of the doctors who don't want to be held responsible.
@mikewade777
4 ай бұрын
@@gzoechi What external influence, How do you get rid of An external influence if you don't know what it is. Is there any evidence of an external influence?. And no, I'm not talking about this woke nonsense..
@TheLongestConfidence
4 ай бұрын
Remember when "I'm a male lesbian" was just a cringe joke we'd make when we were idiot 15yo boys? This is the dumbest timeline.
@Astuga
4 ай бұрын
Monty Pythons, Life of Brian - transgender scene Back then it was just a crazy joke.
@SYLTales
4 ай бұрын
I used to joke with an attractive lesbian friend that I was a lesbian trapped in a man's body, so I was perfect for her. We had a good laugh because we were both Gen-X, and so totally uncaring about a few words. Besides, at the time, it was funny.
@lizadeeza
4 ай бұрын
@@SYLTales I know you were joking. But Lesbians get this joke so many times it becomes sexual harassment. The TIM are now doing this non-stop plus bullying and shaming Lesbians for being attracted to ONLY women.😢
@Astuga
4 ай бұрын
@thenunt I doubt it.
@debbylamont8441
4 ай бұрын
😂
@savannalilly6547
4 ай бұрын
When my daughter was 10 years old, she had one friend from her close friend group of 6 girls come out as trans. I was really shocked, as it was the first time I had ever heard of this happening. The parents let us know how to handle it, and we just went with what they said. About a year later, a second girl from this group said she was non-binary (another thing I'd never heard of), changed her name, and started dressing like and cutting her hair like a boy, and we had to call her "they." At that point, I had the same reaction as Mia, in that it would be ridiculously statistically unlikely for my daughter to know 2 people with gender identity issues, and I became really unsettled and started getting skeptical. When she was in 8th grade (when they went back to school after covid), a third girl from this group came out as a trans boy as well. And I was like, that's bull shit. There is no way that is even possible that three girls from the same friend group are trans! I started going down the rabbit hole on what's going on here, and it's all so obviously a social contagion. My daughter is 16 now, and the first two girls returned to their girl identity at about the start of high school, and (as far as I know) never had any medical treatment, but the one that came out in 8th grade has had testosterone for over a year now. It's been a crazy thing to witness, especially since my older daughter (by 3 years) never had a single trans kid in her entire grade level, let alone multiple kids in a small friend group.
@krissyk9767
4 ай бұрын
Crazy. Its normal for kids/teens to go through phases of confusion and insecurity with their bodies. But somehow today kids are being brainwashed into thinking their confusion and insecurity means they are trans.
@atheistbushman
4 ай бұрын
I have seen reports of mothers with up to 3 trans children!
@RKingis
4 ай бұрын
ROGD
@nickbarber2080
4 ай бұрын
@@atheistbushman Munchausen's by proxy.
@Merriwether-w8k
4 ай бұрын
a social contagion - all of it? Really? because of your anecedotal experience? Think like a scientist - please
@rickoshea8138
3 ай бұрын
Mia, is spot on, on every point. Clear, articulate, humane, helpful and fearless. I love what she is doing.
@autumnb7135
4 ай бұрын
I just had my comments removed by KZitem & I was warned that if I make another similar comment that I may have my account removed. This is dystopian.
@doer-knower
4 ай бұрын
Beware of complaining: any mention of your stance might put you onto the outcast list. Seriously!
@doid4354
4 ай бұрын
Yup, I have seen legitimate violence from the so-called “accepting lgbt community” and their comments stay. But when I state a literal fact of life it counts as hate speech.
@autumnb7135
4 ай бұрын
@@doer-knower what’s the outcast list?
@iwo612
3 ай бұрын
I agree. I had an Insta account and constantly shared reels spreading awareness against the trans cult. It was removed with no warning and I was blocked from accessing it.
@HiAdrian
3 ай бұрын
lol, I had made a reply about how this hasn't happened to me, but now realized that reply got 👻'ed.
@janillingsworth7478
4 ай бұрын
I was recently shocked to discover that 10 year olds in my country's Intermediate schools are being taught that body disphoria and transexual gender identities are natural , normal biological accurrances . The children are taught to be kind, ( nothing wrong with that until I discovered that this kindness was to believe and support the lies ), but also to use trans language as a matter of respect as if it was expressing biological truths. It seems that many pubescent girls find this idea very exciting, novel and fashionable. As a loving grandmother I spoke out against this to find my grandchildren a little surprised that, in their assessment, I could be so old fashioned, and potentially transphobic. Our children are being brainwashed into believing lies and are not being given the truth about hormone and surgical "interventions" that will permanently disfigure and sterilize their friends.
@chilltarts
4 ай бұрын
Nailed it. Our children are being brainwashed.
@RKingis
4 ай бұрын
And usually they use Intersex conditions as some kind of proof for their beliefs.
@unitysprings3631
4 ай бұрын
My body dysmorphia isn't normal! I think it's the result of CSA.
@januaryoctober8618
4 ай бұрын
Canada?
@Merriwether-w8k
4 ай бұрын
@@RKingis Intersex is real - as is trans - science supports this
@SheridanM-dc1nk
4 ай бұрын
She’s absolutely right, straight off the bat. Absolutely no such thing as gender identity.
@evangriffith4394
4 ай бұрын
There’s... not?
@VesnaVK
4 ай бұрын
@@evangriffith4394 "gender" is a grammatical term for noun categories, borrowed from linguistics by John Money and others a few decades ago, applied to a brand new concept that never existed before, the idea that a person can be a different sex from the sex they were born as. That doesn't make sense that to say, so Money borrowed the word gender so that he could talk about this Idea in a way that sounded reasonable. English has three genders. Many European languages have two. Some languages have several.
@Merriwether-w8k
4 ай бұрын
No, she's wrong - science can be chanllenged and science wriiten solely by straight cis males can definitely be challenged -
@SheridanM-dc1nk
4 ай бұрын
@@VesnaVK exactly. “Gender identity” is illogical and nonsensical on all levels. It is essentially, the feeling you’re the opposite sex. Which is impossible, sex isn’t a feeling. They’ll always tell us it’s not a feeling, and it’s not stereotypes, and it’s not a costume- when it’s actually all 3. Then add onto that, the fact that in their doctrine “gender doesn’t equal sex, they’re completely different, your sex doesn’t define your gender, they’re unrelated” but “gender affirming care” requires hormones and procedures to emulate the opposite sex.
@tehbakedpotato
4 ай бұрын
We need to bring back the term transsexual for anyone undergoing hormone treatments or surgeries in an attempt to become the opposite sex.
@annikabjornson998
4 ай бұрын
If it’s not a mental illness why is suicide such a constant threat? The mentally well don’t kill themselves due to simply not being affirmed by strangers.
@Anne_Onymous
4 ай бұрын
Only like 10 years ago, people said "We can't let men call themselves women... Then what's next, they'll be using their bathrooms?" And the community/allies would respond "No, of course not! Gender and sex are completely different!" Well now look where we're at.
@monicanavarro2906
4 ай бұрын
Yep. I remember people gaslighting me when I worried about the "slippery slope", but it isn't always a fallacy-just the logical chain reaction of accepting an idea. Ex. If we start to validate that some people identify as animals (and some already do!), then what would stop us from treating them as such? Or treating animals as people too, and blurry that line? It's not absurd to assume that those would be the ultimate consequences, since it's baked into the initial "tolerance" stage. If it's OK for you to be an animal, then why would it be wrong for you to marry one, for example? All sorts of lunacy will naturally start happening. I also was told that sex differences were always going to be respected... until they weren't. *The truth is that we don't accept mere self-identification for anything that others are forced to believe and affirm.*
@bricaaron3978
4 ай бұрын
@@monicanavarro2906 *"...when I worried about the "slippery slope", but it isn't always a fallacy..."* It's not _ever_ a fallacy. It's the "Slippery Slope Fallacy" that is a fallacy (The Slippery Slope Fallacy Fallacy). The Leftist pretends that the Slippery Slope is a universal law --- once 'A', there _must_ be a progression to 'B', and then 'C', etc.) --- and from that straw man identifies it as illegitimate. But the Slippery Slope is, as you indicate, a _general_ truth. The fact that, in general, once 'A', it easier to progress to 'B', and once 'B' it is easier to progress to 'C', etc. (See the No True Scotsman Fallacy Fallacy, which rests upon an incorrect definition of the word 'true')
@frances5954
4 ай бұрын
@@monicanavarro2906well,caligula appointed his horse incitatus a senator of Rome, and married him to the mare penelope. Don't be a bigot.
@TheAlexa6
4 ай бұрын
I have five children ages 10-27. Parents have no clue how widespread this evil mind virus has become. My 27-year-old daughter who is on the Autism Spectrum recently told me that when she was a teen she started reading up on trans issues and became confused about her own identity. She is straight but was an athlete and a tomboy. I had NO idea she was absorbing this crap and we have always been an open and close family. Now she speaks out against this stuff having realized she’s simply a female who is a little socially awkward and enjoys traditionally ‘male’ hobbies. She wants a husband and a family and tells me she thanks God she never got fully sucked into this. Our kids on the spectrum struggle socially as it is and can be easy prey for those with a nefarious agenda. A decade later it’s even more prevalent amongst teens. My youngest daughter has known handfuls of ‘trans’ kids throughout high school and they are always struggling with co-morbid psychological and/or family trauma problems. I worry very much for these children and the future of our society.
@JohnStevens79
3 ай бұрын
A LOT of those who now call themselves "transgender" have ASD (some studies place the percentage as high as 40%). The failure of "gender clinics" to do a proper psychological assessment of their clients is setting the stage for some truly massive malpractice suits.
@laurenhowell7691
3 ай бұрын
I'm 29 years old and I think I would definitely be in the same boat as your daughter! I'm also on the spectrum and didn't get diagnosed until 25. I would be into typically male things aswell eg being obsessed with sci-fi and dressing like a fourth member of blink 182 and a teenager 😂. You're dead right when it comes to even younger kids on the autism spectrum being so vulnerable to this bs. I've absolutely nothing whatsoever against genuine transgender people. Nothing but love and empathy for those struggling.. but the way this movement and community is gone.. it leaves me very distrustful and to be honest, angry. And that's coming from the B in LGBT...
@sigsauer7929
3 ай бұрын
I have four kids 12-29 and I feel the same way, also I think the spectrum is made up garbage as well.
@infamouse9149
4 ай бұрын
My ex is a psychologist... she counsels people into this b.s.... one young man (was a mutual friend, but she brainwashed him into staying clear of me) thought he was gay, but was trying to be straight... she councelled him into going trans - dressing, acting, etc., the part. He didn't get to the point of any surgery. He committed suicide within a year of this 'acting' routing. I realize I'm no university grad in this field, but from what I saw, the poor guy merely needed some social skills and confidence - I could pretty much guarantee he'd be straight and 'normal'. My ex told me that my way is promoting 'rape culture' and this guy needed her way of treatment. Sadly, she's still doing this job and destroying countless other lives.
@lindawitt9063
4 ай бұрын
That’s a very sad story. It’s frightening to think that ‘professionals’ have the power to destroy lives because they buy into the bs and have highly inflated egos.
@TheFractusman
4 ай бұрын
Sounds like your ex dropped you for a good reason
@ninjawizard3865
4 ай бұрын
@@TheFractusmanWhat the what?!
@winstonsmith9424
4 ай бұрын
"from what I saw, the poor guy merely needed some social skills and confidence" - i think that is so true and so important for so many people. Myself too at certain points in my life. Thank you.
@lookingatdaisies9901
4 ай бұрын
@@TheFractusmanshe counselled a man battling with sexual identity into becoming trans and then he ------- himself. Were you being a troll?
@minhearg8331
4 ай бұрын
As a child, I was convinced I was Superman. Fortunately, my parents chose not to confirm my delusion and didn't encourage me to jump off tall buildings.
@shlack
4 ай бұрын
Actually, the real outcome would have been your parent have you surgically enhanced to become a super hero.
@Hyzenthlay70
4 ай бұрын
I thought I was Dorothy and wanted to chase tornadoes
@VesnaVK
4 ай бұрын
I thought I was a boy. Later on, I thought I was a cat. My best friend thought she was a horse.
@frankarouet
4 ай бұрын
Yep. You can believe that "gender" identity or, say, gravity is a "social construct" until you try throwing yourself off a skyscraper.
@kaija-liisalaakso8266
4 ай бұрын
My son thought he was a car.
@AProudDad
4 ай бұрын
This epidemic literally destroyed my sister, and ruined my family... Each and every one of us. My parents were the sweetest most open-minded people, and their treatment during this led to extreme trauma and death. I'm not trying to be overdramtic, this is a reality and I'm gearing up to write about it; I think it's a story at least some should hear, and it may help some others. -Felt compelled to write this straight in the middle of this epsiode. I applaud the bravery of this woman. I plan to email Hertitics, but Andrew if you happen to see this, a response would be amazing. Irregardless. Take care, everyone. Thanks for reading.
@lloyannehurd
4 ай бұрын
Write it!!! It’s a true and painful story. I would buy the book with extra copies to drop off at schools and libraries. (But please it’s regardless not ever irregardless). Best wishes.
@lizadeeza
4 ай бұрын
I would suggest contacting Buck Angel - who is easily contacted via Twitter and Instagram. Buck has a very popular KZitem channel and has done tons of interviews with detransitioners, and other folks who have been harmed by transgender ideology. Buck's audience is different - as Buck is a 60 yr-old TransID Female who is very open about having female biology but transitioned 30 years ago w/ diagnosis of being Gender Dysphoric. She ( looks very much like a he) has been on the forefront of fighting against transition of children and removing the safeguards of protocol. People in Buck's audience are more likely to have folks in their life who are considering transition or considering detransition - so your cautionary tale could really be helpful there.
People will look back at this in a hundred years time the same way we look back at the Salem witch trials
@MsZelda2012
3 ай бұрын
There won’t be people in a hundred years. The machines will have taken over… Terminator Judgement Day.
@uncleskipsprairiejustice9367
3 ай бұрын
Interesting choice of analogy. You are probably aware that socially contagious "possession" behavior and accusations of "witchcraft and demonic possession" originating among teen girls was at the heart of what happened in Salem. So, yeah. Bullseye.
@alexpetrov8871
26 күн бұрын
Perhaps modern witch trials have not yet begun. I'd say that from a historical perspective, trans ideology is a good candidate for witchcraft.
@windsongshf
4 ай бұрын
"Dress however you please. Call yourself whatever you like. Sleep with any consenting adult who’ll have you. Live your best life in peace and security. But force women out of their jobs for stating that sex is real?" - JK Rowling
@jasperhorace7147
4 ай бұрын
And stop expecting us to indulge YOUR fantasies.
@Beachwavessun
4 ай бұрын
Queen 👸🏻
@DutchIsraeli
4 ай бұрын
Not transphobic in any way, shape in form. Very respectful, I would say.
@LucyOLastic
4 ай бұрын
"Sleep with any consenting adult who'll have you..." That's so sweet. I'm almost moved to tears by her boundless compassion.
@alvinsmith3894
4 ай бұрын
@@LucyOLastic That part alone is proof that she's not a homophobe. Good gay people acknowledge and love JKR because of this and is calling out the TQ+ bs. To be quite honest, lesbians has been trying to warn people about the TQ+ since the 70s. It's just that no one listened. And here we are now.
@Erick_Bloodaxe
4 ай бұрын
More people need to get educated on this issue and speak the F up about it. Frankly this nonsense is everyone's fault. Everyone who just sheepishly sits by and lets them push this on children is criminally negligent. Every doctor carving up patients just to take their money, KNOWING it won't help the patient BTW, is a criminal.
@ReverendDr.Thomas
4 ай бұрын
It's DEFINITELY NOT my fault. I'm the arch-enemy of leftists.
@janesmith8050
4 ай бұрын
No, it is NOT “everyone’s” fault. Radical Feminists and lesbians have been on the front lines of warning society about the dangers of gender ideology for decades now. I myself have been raising the alarm about this issue for 17 YEARS now. It’s not our fault that you refused to listen.
@Skitdora2010
4 ай бұрын
99% of my youtube strikes are from speaking out on youtube about it. I was trained on it in college in graduate level psychology classes by a practicing clinical psychologist who had such patients in her career and I worked as an RN. I also got a strike for making a comment about Ron Perlman's skeletal structure.
@0hffs
4 ай бұрын
But how do we combat the commentary from Trans people, allies, and all the mess that it’s caused between the letters. I’m Gay, I’m Atheist, Anti-LGB Alliance associated, but am currently just alone as an LGB, not because I’m hateful towards Trans people but because I REALLY CARE ENOUGH TO SAVE LIVES through mental health FIRST. I’m being ignored, being called Transphobic, a bigot. We are just too far down the rabbit hole and my hope is that LAWMAKERS from ALL SIDES block whatever the Trans agenda wants. The agenda refuses to take into account EVERY VOICE, even detransitioners. I cannot, in good faith, have my name attached to the possible suffering of Trans lives unless they are guaranteed a prosperous life at the end, but that doesn’t mean they have to desperately augment their bodies 😢
@kennorthunder2428
4 ай бұрын
How does a judge manage to say: Her beleif that sex is real is not worthy of respect in a democratic society? By assuming truth and goodness is whatever "we" say it is. This is simply not the case. There is a fabric of reality that we must align ourselves with. In EVERY sphere of life.
@VesnaVK
4 ай бұрын
Please interview Bob Jensen! He is a longtime lefty college prof who got cancelled when he explained that trans ideology makes no sense from a leftist POV. Great interview with him on Spectator by Julie Bindel, "Why trans activists are intellectually incoherent." He makes points I've not heard anywhere before.
@memoryhero
4 ай бұрын
Thanks for the tip - will deffo check him out.
@TheLongestConfidence
4 ай бұрын
100 percent. There's nothing "leftist" about denying material reality and demanding that others do as well. This ideology couldn't be more antithetical to anything historically recognizable as "left".
@KarinStrong-k4j
4 ай бұрын
I saw that interview. It is excellent.
@Wendyj55
4 ай бұрын
Me too. Thanks
@gzoechi
4 ай бұрын
The trans ideology just used the empathy of the left to push their ideology. Especially women are susceptible to this kind of manipulation.
@jeffswingdancer8302
4 ай бұрын
Medical studies on animals are not permitted to be so loose, with no solid scientific evidence, analysis & documentation of outcomes, etc. The scientists would never get funding or permission of a research institution. If discovered, they would be shut down. But our society is celebrating doing this to our children. We're watching one of the greatest medical scandals of all time unfold.
@harryhill8543
4 ай бұрын
thats the main point of cass, this is an area which has existed outside of the normal safe guards of medicine.
@Geeronimo99
4 ай бұрын
Animal experiments are wrong. They are very crude and misleading.
@winstonsmith9424
4 ай бұрын
very good point but i wonder if there may be a quiet looseness in those areas too
@winstonsmith9424
4 ай бұрын
@@Geeronimo99 and not particularly helpful
@joannlarson6386
4 ай бұрын
Then to have a case where a man chose to be castrated in prison because he is a dangerous rapist and he had a hard time getting authority to do so.
@thereselarfield7177
4 ай бұрын
I have a family member transitioning … she has cut her family off… it’s got nothing to do with her transitioning it’s the fact that she is seriously mentally unwell… diagnosed with anxiety, depression and borderline… it’s angers me that nobody in our health industry looked into her mental health it was bam … let’s put her on hormones… is she any happier…. A big fat No…. We are always there for her… but she’s hard work!!!!
@amaryllisequistra
4 ай бұрын
Remember that any mental health practitioner who looked into her mental health could lose their license for practicing’ conversion therapy’ instead of affirming her identity. This is how far the trans activists have got changing laws and clinical practice guidelines in a short space of time with no evidence to back up their assertions. It just doesn’t add up…
@bovineavenger734
3 ай бұрын
The entire cult preys on those near the abbysm and desperate for greener pastures. Terribly sorry about your loss.
@jeseljams9956
Ай бұрын
I’m sorry your family is going through this. I’m in a similar boat.
@annabel6038
4 ай бұрын
Realising that there is no evidence for the existence of gender identity is when everything clicks. This is the best interview on the issue that I've heard. I know Mia has written the WPATH files already, but if she wrote a book that crystallises this central truth, im sure it would be a valuable contribution to the fight against this pervasive and damaging ideology.
@jezdavis1865
4 ай бұрын
This young woman is fantastic. Well done Andrew for shutting up and not cracking stupid jokes.
@Snikit
3 ай бұрын
Agreed! He is looking a bit slouchy though. Maybe the camera?
@trishs4503
4 ай бұрын
Aligning with reality is a major component of good mental health. A woman cannot “feel like a man” because she has no knowledge of that. Your body isn’t a mistake. Align with the truth; it sets people free!
@beachlife4346
4 ай бұрын
@@timgreenglassClassic response because its the only answer given in the woke handbook. It's also not what we are talking about here.
@helenrandle6868
4 ай бұрын
A very, very small percentage of people are born with indeterminate indicators of biological sex. It is a medical condition and is not what is being discussed here. It is incorrect to conflate (or use in justification of trans ideology) intersex with gender dysphoria - but some do.
@almathwasmywowusername9529
4 ай бұрын
@@timgreenglassIntersex people don’t automatically believe in an ‘gendered soul’ that you feel inside yourself manifesting as distress with entirely healthy body parts. In that case the body is unhealthy and you’d be entirely normal to feel distressed. Like someone with MS or any other life altering disease.
@Gorgina010
4 ай бұрын
@@timgreenglass Sex organs can be deformed and/or hormones out of wack, but gen tests don't lie. Who has Y-chromosome (usually one, in rare cases more than one) is a male, and who doesn't have it is a female. Intersex doesn't exist, what exists are incompetent doctors, who don't order a gen test when there are irregularities.
@arcticfox-yt1ok
4 ай бұрын
How does a woman feel that makes her a woman? I am woman but I don't know. However, I know I am a woman when I look at my gen1talia and have my period. That is specific to women.
@Morbazan125
4 ай бұрын
People have totally confused personality with gender
@juneelle370
4 ай бұрын
Absolutely ~ & that’s the whole point! Transhumanism needs to eliminate biology (words like sex replaced with gender) and ultimately the rights of personhood. “Gender” goes far beyond the biological strengths and vulnerabilities of both sexes and puts both sexes in personality boxes, with no way to even get along. Humanity is a Venn diagram of personality and studies have shown the more a woman has of so-called “feminine” personality characteristics, the more anxious and depressed she is because of lack of autonomy. Further, studies show that most men and women identify with both sets of traits so we are ALL “non-binary”. I was taught gender in college before they were teaching transgender ideology-and I called it out as the same sexism I was taught in religion! Religion teaches traditional gender ideology whether they call it that or not! It’s outrageous that it’s so regressive but framed as progressive. The two dividing words of gender are “masculine” and “feminine” and both tie WAYS OF BEING to sex-aka sexist stereotypes. The only things that could be accurately characterized as “masculine” and “feminine” is *appearance* because humanity has always had to clock sex for SAFETY reasons. Traditional gender ideology is just as regressive and untrue as transgender ideology ~ because if not , it never would’ve had to have been so pushed, coerced, enforced! Both traditional gender ideology and transgender ideology try to attach PERSONALITY (ways of being) to sex/sex appearance! We need to bring back the word PERSONALITY with a quickness!!! Edit: spelling/clarity
@SheridanM-dc1nk
4 ай бұрын
They’ve also reinforced the exact stereotypes they claim to be going against. To them, woman isn’t female- it’s skirts and makeup and sugar & spice and all things nice, twirling around, crying at sad films.
@juneelle370
4 ай бұрын
@@SheridanM-dc1nktransgender ideology was built upon traditional gender ideology. I was taught gender ideology in college before transgender gender ideology was introduced, and I raised my hand saying this was the same sexism I was taught in religion! I still believe in Creator but religion, whether they call it gender ideology or not, teaches exactly this. They’ve replaced the word personality with gender as it attaches personality/roles to sex (traditional gender ideology) and now sex appearance (transgender gender ideology.) It’s regressive, limiting and divisive to both sexes and to their relationships as well!
@Merriwether-w8k
4 ай бұрын
@@SheridanM-dc1nk No - that's not it - sex is much more complicated than just xx or xy - also, you cannot decouple nutrure from nature - envrronment affects gene expression - they used to think homosexuality was a mental illness - now you can find humpback whales having anal sex on youtube - same will happen with trans because it's medicine
@winstonsmith9424
4 ай бұрын
not even peronsonality i think. Personality and circumstances and life experiences and feelings may draw you to one or more of a limited number of youth culture tribes available at any given time in the sphere of your personal possibilities. Goth Punk Mod Rocker Soul Girl etc. Young gay Person also - Ok this one maybe more of a personality or I think more of a sexuality - if you lived in or near a big city. Not that many youngsters upped sticks at a very early age to travel to follow their tribal instincts or asserted their individuality at home in hicksville (ok personality + again I guess) but some brave hearts did. This is a top down ready made (er by whom?) selection box culture for less brave (no derogation intended) outsiders including not a few oldies
@pavsmonkeytube
4 ай бұрын
Ah! She addressed the one element I've been truly confused by: what happened to the guardrails? I studied psych at UT-Austin in the '90s. As undergrads, we were taught that transgender people existed and they were fully accepted as a reality of the quirkiness of human genetics, but that a bare minimum of one full year of ongoing psychotherapy was critical, to ensure that transitioning was the answer for a given person. And that was adults! No way would any psychologist, they said, ever go near this with children; so no one under about 25. But they've taken the psychologists right out of the equation, haven't they? That is just idiotic, if not inhumane, to me. Are we even allowed, anymore, to discuss the simple reality that the human brain is not fully grown until the mid-20s? That there is a difference between adult and childhood functioning in the brain itself? Children are not good at thinking for themselves. Duh!
@dwwolf4636
4 ай бұрын
Repeat after me. Ideology. It's another Critical wedge to destroy normal society by the Critical Theorists. I.e. marxists v6.0
@jennteal5265
4 ай бұрын
They haven't removed the psychologists, the psychologists are quite on board with all of it.
@bricaaron3978
4 ай бұрын
@@jennteal5265 *"They haven't removed the psychologists, the psychologists are quite on board with all of it."* Well then, they have removed the _psychology._
@luizmonad777
4 ай бұрын
Its clearly a social epidemic when something which used to only affect 0.001% of the population now affects almost 1/4 or even more of it.
@luizmonad777
4 ай бұрын
@@bricaaron3978 why don't I get affirmative care for my bipolarity ? I want affirmative care, just let me be the King of the World when I'm in my mania phase, that will fix my problem, that's for sure. I can have surgery to become a King, they can pump blue blood into my veins.
@natasharostova5186
4 ай бұрын
i love her unpopular stance that adults cant be anything they want. Mia, you're a brave heart.
@elchevita8717
3 ай бұрын
They can only be the woman or the man they were born
@AngusKart
4 ай бұрын
It definitely makes their life a whole lot worse. A lifetime of medication and surgeries. Loss of sexual function, sterilization, lifelong chronic pain, the list goes on.
@FiredUpFeminist
4 ай бұрын
A huge study released last month found that the risk of suicide and self harm among people who had undergone transition surgery was 12X higher than the average population. Sex reassignment surgeries make lives worse. www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC11063965/
@KT-gi9do
4 ай бұрын
And have you any idea what psychiatric treatment can do? You have already made list. Here it is: kzitem.info/news/bejne/tYSi1WRqq6aLaqQsi=DB_vmFC2oknm2xCA I don't understand why nobody protests against this?
@HeiressEllie
4 ай бұрын
it sounds like you came to this conclustion by yourself. like clearly trans people are doing great when given access to the care they require. i cant belive the echo chamber youve made for yourself. like do you know trans people or do you just take whatever you see curated for you on tik tok at face value?
@unitysprings3631
4 ай бұрын
Would you affirm an anorexic if they said they were obese? I ask, because that's who I was and I see no difference between me and the trans folks @@HeiressEllie
@benjaminthomas228
4 ай бұрын
"Cry Me a River" is a popular American torch song, written by Arthur Hamilton, first published in 1953 and made famous in 1955 with the version by Julie London.
@samsonlovesyou
4 ай бұрын
How can you possibly accuse a 52 year old man who looks in the mirror and sees a sexy 18 year old girl "mentally unwell"?? It's the pinnacle of mental wellness!
@Lilly-xg5xw
4 ай бұрын
😂😂😂
@SheridanM-dc1nk
4 ай бұрын
They ALWAYS call themselves “girls”, too. Plenty of them on this platform, men in their 50s, 60s, 70s calling themselves trans girls.
@hughtube5154
4 ай бұрын
@@DaddyBiscuits"Oh boy."
@TokyoXtreme
4 ай бұрын
@@hughtube5154"I'm retarded?"
@nikobellic570
4 ай бұрын
How did we allow this fetish to take over our laws, governments, schools and institutions?
@janenoble6889
4 ай бұрын
I can't thank this woman enough for stating the blimmin obvious and talking so plainly and not using their language. I feel just like her about the utter madness of it all and how it has managed to get so far, mind boggling. Great interview. How about getting Jennifer Bilek on your show.
@jm162
4 ай бұрын
Extremely interesting. This has actually clarified to me my disquiet about transgender and I am now more comfortable discussing it. Several of my 25-30 year old offspring have friends who have caught the contagion and I've struggled to articulate my disquiet - not any more!! Cheers Mia and Andrew!
@Mithras444
4 ай бұрын
I know a girl who is in transition and now she realizes that she is in menopause and is freaking out! I dont think there is anything good about putting a YOUNG lady into menopause!😮
@anitasingam4831
4 ай бұрын
There is currently a worldwide shortage of Hormone Replacement Drugs which is seriously impacting real females going through menopause. Menopause can be debilitating with symptoms affecting the mind, body and organs. Could the enabling of gender dysphoria be contributing to this shortage? It seems in the end it isn’t helping and is wasting a life changing drug which doesn’t make it to the people who really desperately need it…just a thought.
@pollyparrot9447
4 ай бұрын
@@anitasingam4831 I question whether this shortage of HRT drugs is really true. Normally if a company detects a new market it just increases supply.
@Mithras444
4 ай бұрын
@@anitasingam4831 I have been through menopause and it is horrible that young women are ruining their bodies. I am NOT for this transgender movement! But I do not take hormones either because I think it caused my mother's cancer. Also I feel fine, actually better without hormones. I don't understand why women are taking them. I never felt better.
@ApacheMagic
4 ай бұрын
@@Mithras444lucky you. I’ll tell you why I take hormones. 14 hot sweats on average during 8 hour work day. Every day. Five years. Soaked through. 14 times a day. Soaking wet bedclothes multiple times every night. No more than 2 hours sleep at a time, at all. Average 3-4 hours a night in total with awake periods between. Zero deep dreamless sleep and the resulting exhaustion, inability to function, and eventually falling asleep at the wheel at 2pm in the afternoon, writing off my car and somehow miraculously did not harm anyone, including myself. 15kg added overnight. Muscle loss and weakness. I could barely stand up unassisted out of a chair. And I have been a fit and active outdoors type my entire life. Depression Wild mood swings. Every joint aching. All this has gone with estradiol. So lucky you, but don’t you dare judge other women because we suffered from it more than you did.
@anitasingam4831
4 ай бұрын
@@Mithras444 I sweat from my scalp to between my toes like running water every 20minutes from the hot flashes. I need to shower 3 to 4 times a day from being drenched in sweat and it smells if I don’t. I can not leave the house if I am like that. Also I am glad you don’t suffer but the lack of hormone balance is what could cause cancer and organ issues for me and many others which is backed by the latest research regarding a drop in hormone balance and menopause. Brain fog, aching joints and muscle pain etc. You are very lucky but others do suffer to the point of debilitation and it can effect a woman to the point that she is unable to function. Think about all the older women who work, run businesses and are CEO’s…it can get bad. But truly I am so glad you don’t have issues with menopause, I wouldn’t wish it on anyone…blessings upon you darling heart ❤️
@rayanaasmar3659
4 ай бұрын
I am trans and still living as trans . I terribly regret and cannot go back .feeling alone with all this disaster. I am 31 years old , transitioned when I was 17 .feeling stuck
@valbonney2575
4 ай бұрын
I'm so sorry to hear this, that must be hard to live with. I hope you have freed yourself from any connection with the radical activists, as I don't believe they will help you. But there are people who will help you, at least to come to terms with things and discuss your options. Reach out, maybe to your doctor or a kind relative, just don't try to deal with it alone. Wishing you all the very best 🧡
@joyfromillinois1099
4 ай бұрын
Yes, wishing you all the best abd praying for you. Think about reaching out to other detransitioners and other groups like genspect to see about help with counseling etc. Sorry this has happened. You only made decisions based on what you knew at the time. Now you know more abd your decisions woukd be different. Please seek good support. We are with you and wish you the very best.
@emilyemily444
4 ай бұрын
Thank you for sharing that with us (and I don't mean it sarcastically either). I'm sorry for the unimaginable hell you've been through. Please know that you are worthy, and I genuinely wish you the best for your future🙂✌️
@0hffs
4 ай бұрын
But how do we combat the commentary from Trans people, allies, and all the mess that it’s caused between the letters. I’m Gay, I’m Atheist, Anti-LGB Alliance associated, but am currently just alone as an LGB, not because I’m hateful towards Trans people but because I REALLY CARE ENOUGH TO SAVE LIVES through mental health FIRST. I’m being ignored, being called Transphobic, a bigot. We are just too far down the rabbit hole and my hope is that LAWMAKERS from ALL SIDES block whatever the Trans agenda wants. The agenda refuses to take into account EVERY VOICE, even detransitioners. I cannot, in good faith, have my name attached to the possible suffering of Trans lives unless they are guaranteed a prosperous life at the end, but that doesn’t mean they have to desperately augment their bodies 😢
@atheistbushman
4 ай бұрын
Did you consult with psychologists or psychiatrists? Was the pros & cons and physical long term risks explained to you?
@benaiahwright937
4 ай бұрын
I'll never understand how lying is kind
@minuishaq631
4 ай бұрын
The left think unless we lie trans people will kill themselves. We all have to keep their delusions going.
@JessHarris-d8v
4 ай бұрын
All the long term data on detransioners rarely include older detransitioners such as myself... elder detransitioners have valuable input. The conversations are centered on youth and their experience which is short-lived.
@littleboots9800
4 ай бұрын
I follow a guy in his 50s, I am Sam. He is recently detransitioned after living more of his life without testicles and penis as he did with. He has recently had his breast implants removed. The last 4 years has been a raw period of finally facing who he is and the trauma of his childhood. He's very brave. Lived decades as a transwoman, many surgeries, all the hormones etc. Finally he is living authentically as a man and healing. I hope you have found a new way of living that you find fulfilling. It may not be the same as the life you would've had without transitioning but it can still be a good one that is fulfilling, happy and gives you the peace of living authentically. All the best!
@0hffs
4 ай бұрын
But how do we combat the commentary from Trans people, allies, and all the mess that it’s caused between the letters. I’m Gay, I’m Atheist, Anti-LGB Alliance associated, but am currently just alone as an LGB, not because I’m hateful towards Trans people but because I REALLY CARE ENOUGH TO SAVE LIVES through mental health FIRST. I’m being ignored, being called Transphobic, a bigot. We are just too far down the rabbit hole and my hope is that LAWMAKERS from ALL SIDES block whatever the Trans agenda wants. The agenda refuses to take into account EVERY VOICE, even detransitioners. I cannot, in good faith, have my name attached to the possible suffering of Trans lives unless they are guaranteed a prosperous life at the end, but that doesn’t mean they have to desperately augment their bodies 😢
@monicanavarro2906
4 ай бұрын
Truth can be painful but it's also the path to healing. I wish you the best and I'm glad that you're learning to accept and love yourself as you truly are.
@robertmarshall2502
3 ай бұрын
I'd be interested to know what input you feel you could add to the conversation
@JessHarris-d8v
3 ай бұрын
@robertmarshall2502 I began living in transition 3 decades ago and detransitioned in 2015. Many physical and mental long-term effects from testosterone will be with me permanently.
@ChollieD
4 ай бұрын
"Male Lesbian" heh, in high school (class of '87) we joked about being Lesbian trapped in boys' bodies. Never thought I'd see people trying to pass this off as a real part of the world.
@yvonnelas2969
4 ай бұрын
And actual lesbians being scorned because they don’t want sex with a penis!
@LisaBeta-42
4 ай бұрын
Well - why not - being a gay female myself: just stealing words, like all the groups do! So you are eighter male or female - that is what sex stands for. Then you might be hetero~ or homo~ sexual, meaning attracted to the opposite sex or people of the same "appearence" as yourself - in Latin HOMO just means human, but that is a totally other issue! And lastly you define, what you are attracted to - if you are not quite sure, what you should call yourself after changing sex or gender several times (ok, you can't change your chromosomes yet, so missing Y-chromosomes makes you female by definition, even if puberty might never come aroud, if you own only one of the important X-chromosomes) Attracted to females makes you a Lesbian (men of Lesbos would like THAT) and being attracted to men ist just gay (hurray & colourful, because the word had been stolen before). Who does not LOVE men, real men, great men, strong men - old school and decent! Don't run off with anyone of them, but appreciate them for the struggles of life they have to face each and every day. Gets an even distribution of "questionable" words to ALL people, so they might loose their potential to be used as a slur against a small, specific group of people...
@JohnnyKnackertache.
3 ай бұрын
In a camp accent: 'Look, I'm not gay. I just act this way to get in with the birds.' 😐 Sorry for the old fashioned joke. Was born in the 1970s. Reminds me of some absurd situation from Benny Hill or Porkys revenge. If a man loves a man or A woman loves a woman... Well, Live your life. This is the western world. Its none of my business.
@RandomGuyyy
3 ай бұрын
Eddie Izzard used to say that stuff but realised he would get maximum benefit if he unironically identified as trans.
@brady3474
3 ай бұрын
I’ve known I was a lesbian trapped in a man’s body for decades! Even at my advanced age, about all I think about is women. And if I was a woman, I wouldn’t get anything done because I would just sit in my house playing with my breast all day!
@annukkakiviranta4356
4 ай бұрын
She nailed it. When I was teenager I said that I dont want kids, because I like dogs😂 I still have dogs,.4 kids and husband Best life - you can have both. I was so silly when I was fourteen. Thank god I am almost 50 years old.
@ToreDL87
4 ай бұрын
Can't do recreational drugs but say you identify as a... 2x4" or something and they immediately put you on the table and absolutely shred you to their liking without legal ramifications.
@cindyduncan7049
4 ай бұрын
Recreational?? You can't even get prescription pain meds most of the time.
@brady3474
3 ай бұрын
Pure evil
@TrebleSum
4 ай бұрын
Wasn't "gender dysphoria" classed (in the DSM5) as a mental disorder until very recently? I'm beyond shocked that this was changed. It seems so obvious to so many of us. I'll definitely be watching, thank you in advance to all those involved!
@mysticladytarot7777
4 ай бұрын
Did you delete my reply?
@gzoechi
4 ай бұрын
The gender cult has gotten hold of the WHO a while ago
@joen4642
4 ай бұрын
KZitem does that a lot these days. Sometimes it's visible under Newest @@mysticladytarot7777
@MissSpookyMooky
4 ай бұрын
The DSM was infiltrated by a t "woman" who managed to convince his peers to remove it, they evidently were too nervous to say no to him. He's on one of those Jubilee debates boasting about it.
@TrebleSum
4 ай бұрын
@@mysticladytarot7777 KZitem delete comments all the time & there doesn't seem to be any rhyme or reason for it. Also, this channel could have deleted it, but I highly doubt it unless your language was out of line.
@carentipler419
4 ай бұрын
Always remember without doctors and councillors this couldnt happen. I use these terms loosely
@wilpri
6 күн бұрын
*counselors
@mattgiant8836
4 ай бұрын
First of all: I'm Dutch and I'm sorry. Second: I was in a mental institution in the early 90s as a teen and genderdysforia was already a thing between the youth then (but still treated as a mental illness). To me this society now, is like the world upside down. Thirdly: This must be the best looking podcast ever, Andrew because you look smashing in that white Tee and blue blazer and ms Hughes just said she is older than thirty and has had three children and I though she looked 22! ;) Anyway,another great interview again, I love this series so much. Love from The Netherlands.
@Cocytus127
4 ай бұрын
It blows my mind that people will still call trans marginalized when they’re the most affirmed, coddled, and celebrated demographic in the western world.
@brady3474
3 ай бұрын
Except by the sane.
@lgw3721
4 ай бұрын
This conversation is needed in American public schools. I am astonished at my colleagues who embrace gender ideology without doing any personal research on the issue.
@luizmonad777
4 ай бұрын
Do they embrace or they're being forced to accept it out of fear ?
@joce11
4 ай бұрын
@@luizmonad777I'd argue it's fear and also cowardice. We all know the truth but people lack the courage needed to speak the truth due to fear. This is changing that's for sure, thank goodness.
@lgw3721
4 ай бұрын
@@luizmonad777 That’s a great question. I think some of both. Some have fully embraced it, some are likely fearful for their jobs.
@PanicBeach
4 ай бұрын
I listened to the audio podcast last night. It's an excellent interview. Mia is a truth teller and a voice of reason in an insane world!
@VesnaVK
4 ай бұрын
Wait, is there a heretics audio podcast that's available before the video?? 🤯
@TrevorDodd-ev1sx
4 ай бұрын
When I was a kid in the 70's and growing up in the 80's I never met one single person who was a trans gender. Of course there were one or two friends who were gay, but nothing in the scale of today.
@GordieGii
4 ай бұрын
Not only is there no follow-up, I have heard dozens of detransitioners say that when they called their gender clinic to say that they think they might have made a mistake, the clinic immediately stopped returning their calls.
@jkkjeldsen8249
4 ай бұрын
"It's verging on insanity"--Richard Dawkins on transgenderism
@dmoonmaster1653
3 ай бұрын
Other social contagions that effected the youth include: • tourettes style tics that teens adopted after it was fashionable or trendy on social media; • and romanticised displays of having 'alters,' 'head mates,' or 'being plural' which again was/is a 'trendy' fad on social media and lapped up by youths. Both, like transgender messaging, effect teens who are uniquely vulnerable to the struggle of 'finding their place in the world' or are trying to 'explore the exciting edge where society is developing new ideas' as a way to stand out or distinguish themselves from the boring older generations. So yes it does matter when influencial people romanticise and 'sell' gender identity online, like Ellen Page and Dylan Mulvaney airing their mental health issues to seek public validation. There will be a broken generation of people who have to pick up the pieces of their life after they've been sterilised and mutilated. Or they'll continue to be victimised and fetishised by the trans movement even if it ever loses credibility.
@norbarellis
4 ай бұрын
Its like affirming the 'weight gender' of an anorexic.
@crow4936
3 ай бұрын
Or saying an insane person who believes they are king of the world is actually the king of the world..
@celesteklose4903
4 ай бұрын
I can’t help but think about the Salem Witch Trials. That started from a social contagion with young girls.
@adam8892
4 ай бұрын
We need more people like Mia. It is nice to hear someone talking common sense for a change.
@martinda7446
4 ай бұрын
Love this woman. She is wonderful.
@Guyjharrison
4 ай бұрын
social engineering is not by accident
@philjudd3473
4 ай бұрын
It is about sterilization.
@ninjawizard3865
4 ай бұрын
You don't have to reduce the population if the populace sterilized themselves willingly.
@winstonsmith9424
4 ай бұрын
Social Engineering is imho the worst aspect of it all
@doid4354
4 ай бұрын
@@philjudd3473why would the government want us to be sterilized when they need us to make babies, aka future employees
@philjudd3473
4 ай бұрын
@@winstonsmith9424 100%
@streamscounselling9501
4 ай бұрын
Thank you Mia for bravely speaking out about these atrocities. I am Canadian and am appalled at the evil doing of my government. God must intervene this mess.
@pollyparrot9447
4 ай бұрын
I wonder if Canadian taxpayers are being informed that they have to pay for people to have frankensteinish modifications made to their bodies? It is the sort of thing that the Australian mainstream media would completely ignore.
@joemadden4160
4 ай бұрын
In Ontario recently a MAN won his courtcase to have the taxpayers pay for his special surgery (he wants to keep his _____ but wants a pseudo vag made from his colon🤮). The only place to have it done is Texas so Canadians will be footing the bill. He identifies as a woman...but wants his pe is... 😑 We're paying for FRANKENSTEINING (as one poster mentioned).
@glensylw4802
3 ай бұрын
He will intervene soon.
@purpledoor2959
19 күн бұрын
I am a Canadian as well. While listening to this conversation, I was wondering to myself if I might be able to claim to identify as a trans man and explain how some dental work would help me to be more comfortable in my body. If they can add dental work to the package perhaps I can wear pants and a checkered shirt with a belt for a year to have the government pay for some of my needed dental work. ??? Then detransition back to feeling pretty in a dress???
@shakespearewilliam8423
3 ай бұрын
When you claim to believe in nothing, you'll end up believing in anything.
@hanthejan
4 ай бұрын
This is such a fantastic interview. Mia’s clarity of thought and boldness in expressing it so needed. Thanks to both of you.
@juliejoy4887
4 ай бұрын
Parents are prohibited from punishing their own children, now they are friends. Friends don't have responsibility.
@honeychurchgipsy6
4 ай бұрын
@juliejoy4887 - you can discipline your child - which means holding them accountable for their behaviour - you just can't beat the f out of them. By the way, hitting kids doesn't work to discipline them - we don't even do that to dogs now - we use positive reinforcement techniques and they work. However, I agree with you that being a kid's friend is not good, but I think it has been imported from American culture - films and sit coms in particular - that promote the idea that parents should not/cannot discipline their kids.
@e_i_e_i_bro
4 ай бұрын
Prohibited from punishing children? Huh? And how is that a bad thing?
@liberality
4 ай бұрын
@@e_i_e_i_broBecause children need to be told when they're wrong.
@lucieirl
4 ай бұрын
Even with that statement I’d disagree, if my friends watched and let me do this to myself ..they’re no friend :/ it’s a shame parents are manipulated and guilt tripped into thinking they’re bigots who’s child will k*ll themselves if they don’t affirm
@e_i_e_i_bro
4 ай бұрын
@@liberality that's not punishment. That's parenting.
@urban_rambler
4 ай бұрын
Thank you Mia, for your measured, clear, factual explanation. I have watched two young girls suffer because of this; they had pre-existing conditions, but were not able to access counselling help, due to the shortage of available community mental health services and long waiting lists to gain access to psychiatric or psychology services here in Australia. Social media filled the gap at a critical stage and now both are on the path to testosterone, hormones, binders and surgery.
@sjxt1556
4 ай бұрын
Andrew, your reaction to the non-binary surgery was priceless. Mia was a Wonderful guest btw, very well spoken. Enjoyed this interview.
@Andrea-zm1nl
4 ай бұрын
The part about this trans stuff that perplexes me the most is the glaringly obvious reality of how sexual attraction works. You see, a heterosexual human is sexually attracted to a person of the opposite sex and to the natural genitalia of the opposite sex, a homosexual person is attracted to a human of the same sex who has the natural genitalia that they were born with. In other words no one is wired to be sexually attracted to mutilated genitals of either sex. So, who do all of these surgically altered humans think they are going to settle down with? I just don't get it.
@yvonnelas2969
4 ай бұрын
Maybe another trans person? I agree that it would be hard for them to find a partner. Even if the created genitals look realistic it seems the males with neo vaginas have discomfort and pain when having sex. I can’t imagine the surgically created penises would have normal sensation either. Then there is the infertility which could be off putting for a partner.
@rosabscura
4 ай бұрын
This though..
@Andrea-zm1nl
4 ай бұрын
@@rosabscura I mean seriously though. Have you ever looked up a picture of a sex change? They exist, and the results are quite a bit less than normal or natural looking. Not only that but the newly constructed genitalia are non functional, generally speaking. Biology is what it is, and it perplexes me that anyone would mutilate their body in this way, ruin their sex life forever, and drastically reduce or completely eliminate their own dating pool, just to look a little bit more like the sex they wish they were.
@993Redveg
3 ай бұрын
The sad reality is that vanishingly few people of either sex or any sexuality are attracted to mutilated bodies. So their only recourse is to defame the rest of us as transphobic. The truth is just too painful to contemplate.
@bovineavenger734
3 ай бұрын
@@Andrea-zm1nl The pictures aren't bad enough, imagine the smell
@BeaCuffe
4 ай бұрын
As a child, I was desperately envious of boys as they could run round with their shirts open or off when it was hot. I was never a girly girl and did an apprenticeship in the motor trade. Thank god this was not a thing then as I am sure if I was that age today I would have been pushed down that road.
@anitasingam4831
4 ай бұрын
It seems to me the whole movement is actually reinforcing traditional gender role stereotypes. It’s a step backward really.
@ninjawizard3865
4 ай бұрын
Just curious, if it was made legal for woman to walk around top less, how many would?
@VesnaVK
4 ай бұрын
@@ninjawizard3865 it's cultural. People in many places in the world have accepted this for a long time. Consider the topless beaches in Europe. It's not a big deal.
@ninjawizard3865
4 ай бұрын
@VesnaVK Topless beaches are not the same as walking around in public topless on a daily basis, which I doubt many woman would do.
@VesnaVK
4 ай бұрын
@@ninjawizard3865 I mentioned the topless beaches because the standard for toplessness is the same there for men and women. Men can't acceptably walk around everywhere without a shirt on. But there are situations where it's acceptable for one sex but not the other. Obviously this is what the commenter had in mind. She only mentioned e situation of children at play, anyway. You're the one one who brought up the (fantasy?) situation of grown women.
@yurilandman1
4 ай бұрын
It’s literally the Flight of Icarus. Wings provided by hospitals.
@ragged_claws_scuttling
4 ай бұрын
Kind of, but I’d suggest the sun is beautiful.
@Christopher-iv6sn
4 ай бұрын
@@ragged_claws_scuttling freedom of expression is beautiful though. The point is that they flew too high up their own asses that they can’t see anything else as beautiful anymore, and will thus fall from grace. This can be evidenced by the idea pushed that naturally feminine women who seek a life of homesteading are disgraceful, or that macho/masculine men are horrible by virtue of their nature. They can no longer see the beauty in anything but ultimate fluidity and a life with no barriers whatsoever. It’s truly sad how unfettered delusions lead to self-destruction. The greater issue is that they are trying to convince others to join them on that journey to the sun.
@Geeronimo99
4 ай бұрын
And emporer.s new clothes
@yurilandman1
4 ай бұрын
@@cougarcartel4658yes, metaphorically, an allegory. I’m pretty convinced this is exactly why that story is what it is. Important message to protect the youth. We forgot this tale.
@doer-knower
4 ай бұрын
Those who saw the truth, in "The Emporer's New Clothes" didn't speak up because they would probably lose their job (position, situation, standing, status, etc). That's what the story says! If we ask an AI to combine that detail together with the story of Icarus, what might that story be?
@kingclover1395
4 ай бұрын
What baffles me the most is why the old established view of transgender in the psychiatric and medical community was so easily overthrown. It used to be well understood that it was a rare thing and not the mass phenomenon that it's considered today. It was very difficult to get the surgery approved and a long process. And for the very good reason that they wanted to do no harm. And very few people even wanted it. When I asked a few older trans people why they never wanted the surgery, they told me that they didn't want to chop their genitals off. It wasn't considered necessary like it is today. I'm a gay person in my 50s, and a few decades ago even the people I know who lived as transsexual didn't believe that they were really women. They knew who and what they were. And they still feel this way. That's because it wasn't an ideology back then. It wasn't until the trans ideology was introduced that there was all this confusion about what is male and female. Hopefully it won't last forever.
@VesnaVK
4 ай бұрын
Look up the Spectator interview of Bob Jensen by Julie Bindel. Title intellectually incoherent. He actually makes sense of it all.
@minuishaq631
4 ай бұрын
Once gay marriage became a reality all these NGO'S Charities Lobby groups and activists needed a new cause and trans was it.
@monicanavarro2906
4 ай бұрын
I knew two guys who lived as women, but didn't actually believe they were women. This was in the early 2000s... It feels like forever ago with the way things have changed.
@izoedyourbabydaddy7628
4 ай бұрын
I think people are confused 🤔 The definition clearly states "woman identified as male at birth". Woman gender/ $ex male =🏳️⚧️ woman
@johnbones261
3 ай бұрын
Give the children who transition the right to take a lawsuit against the surgeons, psychologists, who treated them later on if they feel they were pressured or misled. No statute of limitations. All this would go away.
@Techadopter
3 ай бұрын
What a fantastic speaker of sense Mia Hughes is. She says many of the things I have thought and am sure most others also, but does it in such a calm and considered manner. I always get worked up over these issues and am completely useless in having the conversation as a result. All power to her.
@JTV1965
4 ай бұрын
Thanks for the excellent interview! I have noticed over the decades that some children are also sexually abused at a very young age and these people (victims) have their own broken personality, they are often broken after a traumatic experience and even have difficulty determining their own gender later. There are a lot of these broken childhoods...girls and boys.
@JTV1965
4 ай бұрын
I know very well a girl who was raped by my neighbor's boys when she was 7 years old. The incident was later covered up by the teacher and the neighborhood. The girl told the 1st grade teacher about the incident, who did not tell the parents. It was followed by bullying, threats (these boys), abuse, frequent absences from school, and mental disorders and states of fear. 5 years of therapy and questioning her own gender..a girl. Therapists recommended changing the girl's name to a boy's name at the age of 12-13 and hormones, maybe later sex surgeries, but these therapists and doctors hid the girl's rape from the parents. Those who knew the cause of the trauma, how satanic this was. For parents, the cause of all problems was defined as the child's gender identity problem, i.e. a boy in a girl's body. When the thing was finally pulled out, this girl turned back into a girl. But there is still a lot of work left for self-esteem and school success. The girl won them all. At that point the parents were shocked, tired and relieved...no more rainbow tickets!.. later She told her parents, luckily you didn't agree to the name change, hormones or surgery... I was totally confused, confused and scared.. I don't want to remember this time anymore. It was a mess for 10 years. Today this girl..young woman is doing well. School is going well, as are hobbies, such as gym and ballet. The girl's friendships have also returned to new good friends..they all disappeared for years to online friends and unknown rainbow children and their agendas...therapist agendas!
@rvastrik
4 ай бұрын
a mentally healthy mature person can accept himself and the surrounding reality as it is
@setsuzuya1751
4 ай бұрын
actually no - pure acceptance of what's around you, specifically without questioning it, is a trauma response. Being okay and content with the status quo, in and of itself, is not a measure of mentall well being, but it is imo an indicator of it. for example; If someone born into slavery thought "yep, that's how it should be, I accept being a slave bcoz that's reality", we now would consider this brainwashing, wouldn't we? thinking things along the lines of "How could anyone be okay with being a slave? are you insane!?" I
@mirianakovachevic748
4 ай бұрын
@@setsuzuya1751He meant to say : What if a slave thinks he is not a slave but a free person ?
@doid4354
4 ай бұрын
@@setsuzuya1751accepting that you were born with certain body parts and chromosomes is not a harsh truth of the world.
@bovineavenger734
3 ай бұрын
@@setsuzuya1751 Yeah because being born a certain color or gender is a harsh reality we should try to change, even though IT IS ABSOLUTELY IMPOSSIBLE because it is written in every single cell of our body, forever bound to our existence. Genius thought there.
@setsuzuya1751
3 ай бұрын
@@bovineavenger734 when you say "every cell in your body" I assume you mean chromosomes in regards to gender and melamin for race. 1) melamin determines what color your skin is, but you can very much increase it's levels by extended exposure to the sun. would that change your race? No, it would not. Why? Because race in context of humans is a made-up concept. If two entities can breed and create a fertile offspring - they are the same race. 2) Basic biology says that chromosomes dictate your gender. Advanced biology states that they don't, they determine what hormone should be dominant, and those hormones determine internal and external markers of gender, so no, it's not in every cell of your body, just the hormones... and then lastly - My original comment says absolutely nothing about any of that - I merely stated that accepting reality as it is does not mean someone is mentally well, as well as that being mentally unwell and accept reality as is is also very much possible
@deborahbaxter9250
4 ай бұрын
This was fantastic!! Loved this guest! I am in agreement! Thank you!⭐️
@conillet
3 ай бұрын
Sane woman calling out insanity. Mia Hughes makes some important points I haven't heard before with such clarity.
@bobbresnahan8397
3 ай бұрын
I've read 3 books on this topic, all good, nut none put the problem as clearly and as concisely as Mia does in this interview.
@JaneyDoe-gx2vb
4 ай бұрын
I’m so glad I’m not a young person now. I absolutely would have taken puberty blockers and had a mastectomy in the mid 90s. I never doubted that I was female, but I was a shy early bloomer. So I think many young girls today are on the trans bandwagon for the same reason.
@ooosh1
3 ай бұрын
me too
@sallywillis1448
4 ай бұрын
Mia Hughes is exceptionally clever and wise.
@sallywillis1448
4 ай бұрын
J.K.Rowling is a genius and ethically sound. Mia and J.K are my heroes!.
@ElleNoir.
4 ай бұрын
The gender reassignment surgery market is a billion-dollar market and growing. Confusing young minds that can be easily influenced is a huge business. Once they catch the hook, they become patients for life.
@johnlone141
4 ай бұрын
Your right, it kind of sits next to disaster capitalism, along with big pharma. We are in decline and many people are neurotically searching for answers.
@redreuben5260
3 ай бұрын
It’s just a re-run of The Emperor’s New Clothes
@flowermeerkat6827
4 ай бұрын
Andrew, great interview! I applaud not only the knowledge of your guest but your sensitivity and insight.
@criticalPhase
4 ай бұрын
A fantastic episode! Thank you very much for this video!
One thing i'm always struck by, is how the trans activists seem to almost always completely gloss over how incredibly bad for your health it is to have cross-sex hormones in your body at levels required to 'transition'. None of them ever seem to want to address it, yet it frequently leads to osteoporosis and a host of other demonstrably life-shortening health conditions. Then again, I suppose when the whole thing is predicated on committing yourself utterly to a form of roleplay, it's not all that surprising.
@s3any1977
4 ай бұрын
Very eloquent, informed and eductional.
@Charlieee23
4 ай бұрын
I wish Andrew had asked Mia a bit more about her career and background before getting into the WPATH/trans conversation as it sounded a bit like Mia was your average Twitter user inspired to find out more about this issue after reading JK Rowling’s tweet, not that she was able to do that because of her researcher/journalist background (I’m guessing). I’ve not heard of Mia besides her involvement with the WPATH files, so it just would have been helpful to know. Other than that I’m really enjoying this interview 😊
@juneelle370
4 ай бұрын
This is how we got into this problem in the first place. bell hooks talks about how academia co-opted feminism for elitist purposes in the 1970’s and work hard to keep non-“expert” voices OUT of the mainstream discourse. Did Socrates have a degree? There is wisdom to be found in ALL walks of life, and yet you need to hear a title before you can even listen to her and address her arguments? You’ve been well “educated” to listen to only “select” people.
@Charlieee23
4 ай бұрын
@@juneelle370 it wasn’t that I would only listen to her if she was considered an “expert”, it was more that I was wanting to find out how she was able to publish an article around such lucrative and secretive material and get it accredited and discussed around the world. You would have had to have skills, experience and network connections to be able to do that surely? You probably couldn’t have just been an admin assistant for a small business or a checkout clerk then a social media investigator in your spare time, to have been highly involved in a project like that
@Atomb
4 ай бұрын
She was a normie, a mother. No expert background. Just curious and an intelligent woman. Listen to her interview with Benjamin Boyce for more background.
@Simple_Jackass
4 ай бұрын
We in society need to continue being open and honest about REALITY every time we're confronted with this subject, regardless of where we are or who we're talking to. Keep it respectful, but we've got to stop biting our tongues, it will only get worse....
@jonbob9872
4 ай бұрын
I know two trans people, both were abused. One was massively physically and psychologically abused as a child. Same happened to his sister but less. He has done a lot of internal work and has deteriorated, and realised that part of the picture was wanting to be like the sister who was treated (somewhat) better. The other was psychologically abused and the favouritism given to his sister was just unbelievable, to the point he (representing as she) was in tears when recounting some of it. I'm not sure if he had the insight this might have created the wish at a young age to be a girl and I didn't brooch it - not my place to.
@judy7276
4 ай бұрын
Hi, I work in mental health and came across the same scenario
@alistair-01
2 ай бұрын
This should be required viewing for everyone. Mia is brilliant and eloquent and your interview style is perfect.
@Snikit
3 ай бұрын
Get this woman on as many podcasts as possible, please! ✨💎✨
@megancarey2121
4 ай бұрын
I showered with the light off when I went for a gastric surgery that went wrong. I lost 230lb in 1 year and 3 months because I could keep anything down even water and had to have an IV with fluids multiple times. The skin made me feel so disgusting I couldn't bear to touch it to wash it even if I had the lights off.. mental health intervention saved my life. ❤
@cindyduncan7049
4 ай бұрын
Was excess skin not an option after gastric bypass?
@cindyduncan7049
4 ай бұрын
Removal*
@ryanwardcomedy
4 ай бұрын
I feel for u meghan...I lost about 9stone in a year because I couldn't eat...it was absolutely horrific. I had my surgery in Prague and back to the UK just had to get on. Ended up in a psychiatric ward after a year. Complete mwntal disorder I thot surgery and weight loss would cure. I really feel for u meghan. No1 understands what it's actually like to live with these surgeries
@TheMoxin
4 ай бұрын
I’m so sorry to hear that. I’ve had the same surgery for gastric cancer but I had a brilliant surgeon. Keep focusing on the fact that without that scar you’d most likely not be here. Be thankful for your marks. I have it too.. Our War wounds. You’ve EARNED your stripes, Captain! ❤ be proud.
@megancarey2121
4 ай бұрын
I love these replies ❤️ I really needed to hear them. Thank you.
@elishevak.8637
4 ай бұрын
I'm a mother and I've been an educator in middle school for decades. Nowadays girls see that motherhood is not celebrated at all, therefore the physical changes of adolescence are despised. When a girl starts getting her period, she must cope with a new (sometimes painful) reality. When motherhood was celebrated, girls could see the point of going along with nature's path.... Now girls are educated to be competitive and to strive for a prestigious career and see it as the sole core of their being. I do see the contribution of feminism in letting women express their talents but here is the down side of it. Girls wish not to be girls... Little girls used to say " When I grow up I want to be a Mommy" Nowadays when a little girl says it's considered a failure in her upbringing...
@Weissguys6
4 ай бұрын
Thank you! Truth.
@rensha8635
4 ай бұрын
It’s the debasement of women in the sex riles caused by the harm of pornography that has caused women to run from womanhood, not the opportunity of careers.
@davidcox3076
3 ай бұрын
Very eye-opening. Why be female and suffer through menstruation when you won't be giving birth? Having a career is the be-all end-all of life, after all. The damage from feminism continues.
@LoveYourself-my9nz
3 ай бұрын
It has nothing to do with motherhood! And celebrating being a parent is different from telling young girls that their whole life goal is to be a mother. Because of this mentality lots of women got treated like a child producing machine to a worthless piece when they were not able to bear a child. I think this obsession of being a mother is what pushes these young girls to be this trans ideology because only this way they can skip this pressure. It's so weird how west has such an extreme and regressive conservative mindset and because of that now it's suffering. I never wanted to have biological children and never ever felt even a little interest toward this trans ideology, and the reason was simple I never thought that I had to impress random people by becoming a mother, it's a personal choice and if you want it then only you can celebrate it. I don't become a bad person just because I don't want children and people around me also don't think that I'm a bad woman because of that choice even if they understand/ agree with or not. But in the West there's so much hate, pressure or identity of being a woman and whole life goal to be a mommy. It's a part of someone's life, an important one but not everything.
@LoveYourself-my9nz
3 ай бұрын
It has nothing to do with that! It is an important part of someone's life but not everything. You can only celebrate something when you yourself want it not when someone puts pressure on you for doing it and your value depends on it. Sorry to say but in old times women celebrated motherhood because that's their whole value, people still celebrate it the only difference is that we don't put our whole value in it. Which is a really good thing.
@cosmoseinfeld1
4 ай бұрын
Andrew, with your channel, you are doing extremely important work. As is this guest. I hope more people discover these conversations and the public becomes more vocal on this topic. We need to revert course quickly.
@abletobeconfused
4 ай бұрын
“I can only be my true self through hyper invasive surgery and a lifelong reliance on exogenous medications”
@ashleighmckenzie9557
4 ай бұрын
So good to hear a sane person on this subject.
@justsome-guy7596
4 ай бұрын
What a wonderfully clear, articulate and compelling discussion. Thank you Mia and Andrew for a job very well done indeed.
@adamofyorkshire
4 ай бұрын
This is a fantastic podcast on issue. Best I've heard
@vinceporter228
3 ай бұрын
I not anti trans, anti socialist, anti capitalist... I am anti-ideology regardless of what. I cannot give up my rational faculties simply because one may be offended by what reason produces.
@Tight--LiNeZ
2 ай бұрын
When you tell people that they're insane, they cry and moan. People feel bad for them and scold those who made them cry. That makes them unpopular. That's all that happening, on a huge stage.
@DianInHerOrb
4 ай бұрын
Brave to use that title. Good on you Andrew.
@andrewgoldheretics
4 ай бұрын
Thanks so much!!
@DianInHerOrb
4 ай бұрын
How much is a pint these days? Have one on me 🍺
@paulcasini4759
4 ай бұрын
The day JK Told the truth
@kennethblakeley6536
2 ай бұрын
Superb analysis of the current madness...the harm is incalculable 😢
Пікірлер: 2,6 М.