Beyond what is discussed in the video: Thābit is a kalām term. In the original Muʿtazilī argument for thubūt al-maʿdūmāt, al-Tamāyuz yastalzimu al-thubūt (kull maʿdūm mutamāyiz, wa kull mutamāyiz thābit, fa-kull maʿdūm thābit), and tamāyuz necessarily presupposes immutability (if the intelligibility of a thing is not stable and unchanging, the thing cannot be mutamāyiz). People should look into the argumentative structure of kalām more carefully before they decide a translation is "wrong".
Негізгі бет What are al-Aʿyān al-Thābita ? / The Immutable Archetypes? | Hasan Spiker
No video
Пікірлер: 6