Sir my submission to differ on Hindu & Islam. There is no prescription in Hindus books only description r there. In Islam it's all mentioned as prescription in Quran coz, no Muslim can go against book. Plz elaborate on that. U mentioned Ambedkar, he write in his book Islam as a giroh (gang) which try to rule, by guidence from Islamic book. Coz as per Muslim not a single word or full stop can be changed. Ambedkar being a Hindu deny some practice of Hinduism & adopted another branch of Hinduism that is buddhism. Can any Abrahamic religion has branches like Hinduism has Jainism, Buddhism, Sikhism etc. No, bcoz Hinduism is dharma not religion. In Hinduism no one is running after other to make him Muslim or christian, coz its natural not designed. Plz pardon for this. But Sir some time I feel u forget very particular point, that, Description & Prescription r two basic things while analysing Hindu books & Islamic book. Thanks & plz elaborate on this.
@sureshchandramishra5159
2 жыл бұрын
What muslims have done with Dalits in kasmir.even in pakistan
@logicalmind1405
2 жыл бұрын
In my view another thing that should change is celebrating Kurbani, this leaves a very horrific affect on children, I used to live during my childhood in a muslim populous area and saw a goats head floating in drain, a person roaming with a kinife and a Woodlog to facilitate kurbani during bakra eid. I was so terrified to see that as child that I straight to my house and it left a lasting impact on me, I still remember those visuals and feeling I had back then. I wonder what happens to muslim children who see that from their own eyes each year that blood shed etc. This physiological impact must be having lasting Impact on them as well
@rajivdas2937
2 жыл бұрын
Sir , I am your huge fan but I do have two observations: With due respect 1.you should must read the book by Savakar (The indian war of independence 1857), in that book he praised everyone in India & on that time he was considered as a secular figure. But at the later stage politics assassinate his character. 2.Hindu life and daily practice doesn't govern with Manusmriti,even the families doesn't have any copy of Manusmriti. All are moved on if any bad practices happened in the past .
@Billumian47
2 жыл бұрын
I have read him but you must read the huge two volume work by Vikram Sampath. It is a celebration of Savakar but he gives full details of what Savakar wrote and did but then finds justifications for all his actions.
@rajivdas2937
2 жыл бұрын
@@Billumian47 Sure sir ..I will . But I hope Vikram mentioned about the Patit pavan temple 1931 a steer effort by Savakar where untouchable can worship their god as other people would .he was also struggling to vanish the caste system from the Society. Unfortunately his efforts were never appreciated. But I must appreciate your reply,your teaching always leads us to reach at logical conclusions. 🙏🙏🙏
@rajivdas2937
2 жыл бұрын
@@srijandatta287 Dear Srijan . Dear Ishtiaq Ahmed is one the eminent scholar in our subcontinent.. He has written many good books on india Pakistan relation , partition etc . You will also admire him once you will connect him for a long time with his lecture over KZitem. You can raise your concern Infront him in a polite manner .& Definitely he will answer you .. But please don't blame him as a hypocrite... Please Please 🙏
@jayantamajumdar6008
2 жыл бұрын
Professor is ardent admirer of Neheru & Gandhi. He thinks that RSS & BJP are communal. In every Muslim's mind there is a hidden agenda that they will again rule over India like Mugals/ Pathans.
@johnjosephgeorge4136
Жыл бұрын
Great explainations about Shariah and its implications ans implementation . Dr. Sahab your thoughts and inspirations are well founded compairtive with other religions and Sharia .thanks you very much. Sir
@kdear9401
2 жыл бұрын
Sir ji With respect How Sikh Gurus Hindus and Sikhs were most inhumanely treated by muslims ISIS just enforced what historically Islamist did Why Guru Hargobind jee took to the Sword The first Sikh Guru to take up arms Guru Nanak jee declared At sayed pur on the arrival of Babar A devik vipatti a Scourge of the Gods is entering our mother land Rest is history'
@sumitsingh7835
2 жыл бұрын
I get to learn so many things from your videos, usually I cannot easily get access to such information, opinion. For such videos THANK YOU very much Sir.
@niveditamishra7021
2 жыл бұрын
With due respect, why do you have to bring in Hindu angle? Apni baat karo! Classic convert mindset. Denouncing caste system but finding virtues in slavery in Islam is laughable. Thing is both are bad and both degenerated over time. How Pakistanis of all hues and complexion can't do without bringing in Hindu angle into their understanding of their own world!
@syedzain3462
2 жыл бұрын
Doctor Sahab! You are looking weak now a days. Is all ok with your health? I am your regular listener and always pray for for good health
@SanjeevKumar-pl3qq
2 жыл бұрын
Sir, I admire your knowledge. I accept that there were social problems in Hindu society but they have reformed from time to time as a society. Why muslim world as a society is not able to reform. I have doubt that muslim religious scholars Mullahs and Maulanas will ever align with the thought of scholars like you. How reforms can be brought for the betterment of muslims youths and the world. ideology
@harjassingh6786
2 жыл бұрын
Other than your intellectual thoughts ...sir I will you good health, wellness and good energies always... May waheguru keep you blessed....we listen to your every vlog... In the social fabric of life... there are no layers beneath except your inner self....
@hemavaidyanathan6556
2 жыл бұрын
I was disappointed to hear from you that the burning down of the huge library in nalanda was a small crime in comparison to the treatment of the dalits as was practised in those times. Sir, a librarary is not just books . It is the abode of knowledge. And this library was the treasure house of knowledge of philosophers seeking truth, evolving over millenia. After having destroyed such precious manuscripts people like you are saying there is no evidence that the evils of the cast system came on later. When we destroy the books we have destroyed whatever evidence there was of the systems prevailing then. I have great respect for the research you have done and i am currently reading your book jinnah. But i do feel it is unwarranted to comment in areas where your knowledge and understanding is woefully inadequate. It is a fact that western authors did very superficial studies of the sanatan dharma and are primarily the source of information for people who live outside in the west.
@virendraSingh-je3sx
2 жыл бұрын
Some of viewers may not agree with Prof. Ahmed, but you have to be respectful to him while commenting on his views.
@shahidnawaz2115
2 жыл бұрын
Sir, I highly appreciate your thoughts. You describe the things in a very logical way. I am very much against polygamy. I need your comments considering all the logical views in favour & against. People give the post war period as the only reasoning in favor & don't mention its bad effects which grill the females for whole of their life. Are females a commodity. Don't they have the rights to live their own way.
@f-trend2150
2 жыл бұрын
Dear Dr. Ishtiaque Ahmed, on few points of Hindu culture you are not aware so being a scholar and intelligent person I would not accept the sweeping remarks from your side. Do Hindus consider savaraker everything? Does manusmritit is a only book? There are thousands of books from vedas, to upanishad and gita. But in abrahmic religion it is only one book that you follow. The problem that exist on your side is being a Muslim you equate Hinduism similar to Islam and abrahmic way of living life.
@MuhammadAwais-ul7cf
2 жыл бұрын
Excellent conversation.
@sjain9383
2 жыл бұрын
👍👍🙏🙏
@srikanthvenkata5227
2 жыл бұрын
Sir u avoided many controversies in haadis. What is your take onnthat?
@nazlone
2 жыл бұрын
The Qur'an has very few laws...but you require more than that to regulate society. The Ommayeds first used Roman and Persian laws.They initiated new Sharia laws.They were replaced by Abbasids...The different factions do not agree with eachother ..and today it is no different.
@himanshusrivastava2025
2 жыл бұрын
Try and get Mustafa Akyol on the show. His book on reopening Muslim minds is the best articulation of this topic I have read.
@srikanthvenkata5227
2 жыл бұрын
Plz do your homework on islams destruction in india. Younare trying tongive islam a clean chit.
@amarnathjha8319
Жыл бұрын
Manu Smriti's labor economic classification was based on skills and not on birth. Four Barnes (Brahman, Chattriya, Vaishya, Sudra)classification was done 7-8 thousands years back when they started living in groups or clans called Gotra. All villagers of one clan had one Gotra. It was mainly used to avoid in-breeding, unlike that of Muslims. That classification has no values now and modern Hindus do not believe in it. We all call ourselves Sanatan Dharmi.. Hindus have been able to change their laws with the passage of time to bypass old Hindu laws. Muslims cannot do it and hence they are forced to follow outdated rural social customs and laws of 7th century-9th century. Muslims have to show courage to change it. Halala is a nonsense and shameful practice. . Marrying nine years old girls with seniors is another wrong practice. Minority are still ill treated in all Islamic countries. Forced conversion of kidnapped Hindu girls is wrong. There is no freedom of Speech in Islam . A practicing Muslim, even if disagree with the teachings and practices, cannot leave Islam. Because, if a Muslim rejects Islam then it is duty of all Muslims to kill that man. Check videos of Ex Muslim movement, where these ex Muslims do not show their faces. now, you know the reason. They treat non-Muslims as unequal or of lower race. Women cannot even freely go outside and work. Sanatani of modern times have stopped calling themselves as Brahman ,Dalit etc. Kids of even villages are now inter-marrying. Forget about Hindu youth of cities and West.
@PM_Tx
2 жыл бұрын
VERY WELL SAID, SIR.
@PM_Tx
2 жыл бұрын
Very true and logical. Law is made for humans not the other way around.
@harbanstalwar2854
2 жыл бұрын
Very exellent analysis. In a raw language it means the rules framed by primitive societies have no relevance in the 21st century. Many muslims are agitated about so called Islamophobia But keep mum when their fellow brothers go on killing spree They even term them martyrs
@RG-iw4c
2 жыл бұрын
Islam me kon si burai nhi h jo tumhe hinduism me lgti mujhe bta me batata hu Yha logo ko jhoota gyan mt pel. Sorry but tumse baat krne ka yhi trika mujhe smjh aaya jo hunduo me buraiya bta rha jbki tmam burai muslims me h or khi bde str pr even present me bhi.
@MuhammadAwais-ul7cf
2 жыл бұрын
It's Qiyyas not chaos of the English language.
@booksloversonly7413
2 жыл бұрын
Assalam alaikum Sir, I think 🤔 you should read "Reconstruction of Religious thoughts in Islam" which can make the sense more clear Regards
@booksloversonly7413
2 жыл бұрын
Agree with you with the exception of two points 1 monogamy (only one marriage) 2 Islam only give rituals and customs (In fact Islam gives universal principles which are the code of ethics and conduct for whole life) Regards
@RG-iw4c
2 жыл бұрын
Sbse man baat Duniya me koi religion ya law Ya any other jo achchai ke liye janm lete h ek wqt ke baad vikraal roop le lete h. Jruri ye h ki aapko un buraiyo se usi religion me rhkr ldna hota h yhi aapka krtvya h dharam h.
@logicalmind1405
2 жыл бұрын
Super vlog as usual, I wish ppl stop listening to mullahs and listen to ur logical and progressive views 👏
@RG-iw4c
2 жыл бұрын
Mano agr aaj Ukrainian apne des ke liye ldne ki bjay des chhod ke bhag jaye to aap unko kya kahenge. Jbki is najuk daur me Ukraine ko jrurat h apne deswasiyo ki ukrain ki hifajt ke liye. Aaj jo Ukraine chhod ke bhag rhe h vo h muslman or jo Ukraine (hindu religion v Hindustan me rhkr) Me rhkr ld rhe h vo h Hindu. Sare dlit convert nhi hue blki hindu rhkr apne liye lde jiska aap vo profit(reservation) pa rhe jo unka Hrzana ya hk h penelity h jo bramin jyada fees pay kr ke aaj bhugat rhe.
@khetaramsharma1200
2 жыл бұрын
Manu smiriti is much much oldest we give up him a long long ago
@amarnathjha8319
Жыл бұрын
God ne Muhammad Saheb se kaha ki ye prithvi chipti hai. God ne kaha ki Suraj har sham jamin ke andar chhup jata hai aur fir sabere wapas aata hai. God ne sat din men puri sristi-kaynat banaya. Pahle jamin9earth) banaya, fir Asman banaya aur bad men aasmen men tare jar diye jaise koi sonar jebar banata hai.
@navneet8269
2 жыл бұрын
Doctor sahab India Punjab se bol raha hun aapki koi kitab Hindi mein hai agar nahin to aap apni kitab dividation off Punjab aur dividation ke bare mein koi acchi kitab kripya Hindi mein jarur chhapwa hai inke Mishra
Пікірлер: 49