You're telling me soyeon leader of (g)i-dle with the most strict company gets to release music she likes and wants and write them too? But blackpink with yg can't? 💀💀
@carl859
Жыл бұрын
Bcz Their company Cube doesn't have producer but yge wants teddy - bekuh to produce songs.... And you never know what's behind the scenes bcz the way g-idle hate cube they should have leave the company till now....their contract is ending soon ,so let's see if they will leave the company or renew with them
@makimawho
Жыл бұрын
@@carl859 yeah tru but when it comes to releasing a song it's not just about production yk The whole company is involved she has told us about the whole company not liking the concept of nxde but she still made them release it
@9xprincess
Жыл бұрын
CUBE is one of the least strict companies and honestly has always valued musicality and creativity. In terms of Gidle since Soyeon and the members almost single handedly launched themselves during their debut era CUBE has had to let them led the group’s direction. Surely at least after DUx3 era BP were pop stars and could have evolved artistically if they wanted too.
@oogaboogass
Жыл бұрын
Fr omg their lyrics are just .. 💀 yeah G-idle will always be superior ✨💅🏻
@user-yf9nj7eb6z
Жыл бұрын
@@oogaboogass "i dont wanan play this pingpong id rather film a tiktok" yeah sure 💀💀💀
@blackatblu
Жыл бұрын
if yg wants blackpink to renew their contract, yg better let them release music not just every 2 years and for the members to have creative freedom. to be honest, i think this is what sounds like the most ideal situation to me... too bad it won't ever happen. don't mind me, i'm just gonna cry my heart out for my favourite girlgroup!
@AB-yk2pq
Жыл бұрын
Members do have creative freedom? They're allowed to participate in making songs and giving suggestions (said by themselves multiple times). They also chose what songs to do on this tour.
@kpop_united
Жыл бұрын
@@AB-yk2pq They doesn't choose their is a seperate person who makes tracklist
@carl859
Жыл бұрын
@@AB-yk2pq Not really! Jennie-rosé make songs with a foreign producer but yge rejected it ,rosé make a remix with bella which yge rejected then it got leaked... it's still on internet you can find it.
@AB-yk2pq
Жыл бұрын
@@carl859 If it's rejected it's rejected for reasons. Remix with Bella probably wouldn't even be released. Jennie and Jisoo co-wrote Lovesick Girls, Rosé co-wrote both her solo songs, Jisoo and Rosé co-wrote Yeah Yeah Yeah and Jennie and Lisa added their verses for The Show.
@AB-yk2pq
Жыл бұрын
@@kpop_united They've literally said in their American interview that they had a lot of meetings with the company and that each member had a say for this tour.
@zhisu2665
Жыл бұрын
almost 7 years but most rookies have been more active within their first year💀
@dearsputnik9870
Жыл бұрын
it just genuinely saddens me to see how a girl group that has the potential to make a huge impact lost the passion to continue. obviously us kpop fans are sad seeing our idols fall out of love with their job, but it is what it is. if the girls are presenting us with sloppy performances, modelling, being ambassadors, acting and pushing the brand of blackpink instead of developing their music style and doing the bare minimum, we have the right to want them to disband. girl groups such as gidle, new jeans etc, are talking about topics that NEED to be talked about, and speaking to us through music and their performances. gidle talk about the rejecting gender expectations in tomboy, as seen in lyrics such as "neither man nor woman", cleverly integrating messages into their music. they constantly deliver 150% into their performances and are innovative and have the drive to keep going. new jeans talk about parasocial relationships in the idol industry. their songs omg and ditto are a commentary on kpop fans and their fantasising about idols and hyperfixation on them. a lot of the members in these groups have solo activities, their own music, acting roles etc. however, they never forget what they owe to their fans: passion for their music, consistent releases, and they're revolutionising the kpop industry. how on earth are blackpink, a seven year old group, regressing in every single way possible way. their lyrics and songs arent a reflection of themselves. like lisa got scammed by her manager, and jennie is a relationship gal (I'm not blaming either of them for this). but then they present this cool bad bitch that doesn't gaf image and its like ??? where is your own story? its either they change, or us as fans are not in the wrong for asking them to disband.
@hauwamahmudmudi1867
11 ай бұрын
What topic are new jeans talking about 😂 jeez
@dearsputnik9870
11 ай бұрын
@@hauwamahmudmudi1867 do ur research ditto is about idol and fan parasocial relationships, omg's mv literally expands on this through addressing mental health. not only that but they're literally reshaping the idol industry.
@dearsputnik9870
11 ай бұрын
@@hauwamahmudmudi1867 if u cant be bothered to actually read the comment, don't respond to it, its a bad look.
@Lilo_06
8 ай бұрын
I agree with this. If they are falling out of love with their jobs then they should disband. If they continue they will soon lose popularity as a lot of people think they should disband.
@officiallyshivani5024
7 ай бұрын
@@dearsputnik9870I still remember in February or something I fell in love with ditto for its meaning and omg for its catchy lyrics and meaning. And I don't I need to mention about gidle bcuz I liked them since tomboy for their meaningful songs and I'm new to kpop I don't know bout their past songs but I listened to few of them and they're good.
@laylamia
Жыл бұрын
"I loveeee Blackpink but they need to disband" finally found someone with the same feeling as me oh god,i love the girls and their few songs but i just have a feeling they need to disband
@Imsochloe
Жыл бұрын
Obviously don't love them then
@Entis.c.v
Жыл бұрын
@@Imsochloe whatt 💀
@Totally_not_an_armie
Жыл бұрын
Omg same
@Imsochloe
Жыл бұрын
@@Entis.c.v she obviously doesn't love them then ??
@Entis.c.v
Жыл бұрын
@@Imsochloe just because u think a girlgroup should disband because their company isnt managing them well doesnt mean u dont love them????????
@soomi
Жыл бұрын
As long as people massively keep hyping that one two mediocre comebacks then yeah, we keep getting the same thing over and over. This is not just about BLACKPINK btw. People keep hyping things loyally every time, but sometimes as fans you need to STOP buying if something isn't amazing. Otherwise the companies won't try to do better or to give us more. I loved BP once too. This is not coming from an anti or a hater. I wish the best for them.
@Totally_not_an_armie
Жыл бұрын
Same
@elanan9411
Жыл бұрын
You realize taste is subjective right? Or do I need to introduce that to you? You personally may not like the content. If so you should stop tuning in. But you cannot dictate the feelings of millions of people according to your own opinions. That's weird asf.
@LLissa
Жыл бұрын
@@elanan9411 it's not about that. It's about the fans that complain about waiting too long and disliking Blackpink's music, yet continue to Hype every release. The only reason YGE does the bare minimum is because fans will still support Blackpink.
@jiminomega
Жыл бұрын
I think the reason why everyone gets hyped is not because the music is good, it's because the fans miss them so much, that they would take anything that is given to them, hoping that this time they won't disappear like they always do, but it's the same...
@LLissa
Жыл бұрын
@@jiminomega for real, I honestly feel bad for blackpink. They deserve better than yg
@goldenhourss
Жыл бұрын
i feel like the girls haven't shown yet all they got: rosie vocally, jennie in terms of rap exc. their debut videoclips show how much talent they have, alongside potential as an artist and i really feel like it's kind of a pity...
@gyal7892
Жыл бұрын
every time i wake up and remind myself that bp potential was fucking wasted by yg, them, or smn else
@luvyjun
Жыл бұрын
@@gyal7892 ikr its so sad, they could have been so much more...
@kittykatxoxo
Жыл бұрын
Absolutely unfair to Rosé Jennie the are not able to show High notes ability and fast fire rap ability the reason I hate. cause ppl ALWAYS rank them so low in vocal ral category even with younger artist but ppl don't know it's because of YG bruh they have so much POTENTIAL but because of YG not able to showcase it n ppl think they are not much skilled
@goldenhourss
Жыл бұрын
@@kittykatxoxo also i think they trained quite a lot and could show it but they barely get songs to sing
@gyal7892
Жыл бұрын
@@kittykatxoxo i don’t quite understand all of your comment, but i really wish jennie would song more vocal based song. i love her tone and found it quite unique, i always go back to their sure thing cover because they just sound so good, also some of their pre debut performances clip. blackpink had the potential to be big, they had the creativity, passion, and resources. but they didn’t, or at least too late to remove the “model” tag. everyone shamed them for it, but want to put it under the rug now that every group and their mother has brand deals by saying at least the newer groups actually releases music. it makes me want to scream, it’s just the frustration
@got7ish788
Жыл бұрын
The most painful thing about an artist is seeing them fall out of love with what they do, that's exactly my case with BP.
@hater-des-ploucs
Жыл бұрын
No but bro don't ever stop uploading videos, I LOVE your channel so much, you talk abt kpop in the best way ever : it isn't boring to watch, the topics are so interesting. you're so respectful of the groups yet you have what some people would call '' problematic '' opinions and man i love it so much
@yjahesh3173
Жыл бұрын
I know right
@seokjinluvie
Жыл бұрын
ikr
@himaririku9254
Жыл бұрын
G DRAGON KING .-.
@Luviesoozu
Жыл бұрын
Yesss
@hashcrap
Жыл бұрын
i genuinely like how he expresses his opinion without being rude or offensive like other channels
@ozmer
Жыл бұрын
I just want more Rose solowork. I'm addicted to her voice.
@zaynes5094
Жыл бұрын
I want her to cover Creep by Radiohead. Trying not to flood her inbox but I really do want to see her do that 'cause I think she'd kill.
@deluxis4991
Жыл бұрын
I think there are 3 main reasons why BP is where it is right now, that means a group of models and influencers rather than artists. First is the girls them selfs. You can see that every year the girls are more and more burned out but not because they have so much to do. It's the opposite. Constant waiting for YG to give them a comeback and trying to do other things can be as tiring as doing content all the time but as you said it in the video it's YG that needs BP so why they don't force YG to giving the regular comebacks? Because they don't really care anymore. YG won't listen to them anyways. So yes YG is the second problem. The label basicly took for granted that whatever they will sell with Blackpink name on it it will sell out in millions. YG will always give Teddy the role of the main producer, composer and songwriter. Why? Who knows what's going on behind the scenes with YG and Teddy. That's why even when the girls wanted to release their own songs when somewhere in their first years in kpop YG always said "No" because Teddy wouldn't be the main again. As we seen it in 2022 YG probally didn't wanted to release the new album but was forced by fans who started to boycote the new BP merch. And with this we come to the third problem that are fans themselfs. Yes the fans. They basicly don't know what they want from Blackpink as a group and as a soloists. Every comeback was a mixed opinions between "this is cool", "this doesn't sound like BP" and "this sounds too much like BP". When the group was releasing songs like Playing with fire or Stay or even Lovesick girls it was seen that those songs even if objectively are the best songs of BP didn't do as good as their normal Teddy edm copy paste songs like Kill this love or HYLT etc. So when some part of Blinks say we want something new they are really saying "we want new albums with the same Teddy music we got all this time". Those 3 points are from my own none-blinks subjective obsevation so no hate. I have friends that are Blinks and they are awsome but they keep their objective and critical thinking and aren't blindfolded fans.
@gyal7892
Жыл бұрын
i agree! i just know that bp could have been so much more, not even in the music department but visual arts jennie told how she’d have many chanel/fashion magazine and i’m sure it cultivated her creativity, same with rose who’s more into music i wish they would use jisoo’s acting in their mv to create more depth and mayb lisa’s dancing to do a silent movie or smth their talent were just wasted
@KpopUnniesUwU
Жыл бұрын
So trueee, rumored Jennie and Bekah and Rosie have a fight over lyrics.
@lizdior8148
Жыл бұрын
As someone who has followed Blackpink and their music for a considerable length of time, I agree with your sentiments. They are one of the few girl groups that I still listen to, although I do occasionally check out newer groups such as Ive or listen to some of Itzy's songs. It is clear that Blackpink is incredibly famous and has already achieved a lot. Rose has shown that she has the potential to be a great solo artist, Jisoo has demonstrated her acting skills, Lisa could continue to excel in her dancing career, and Jennie is a renowned fashion icon who attends various fashion events. Although it would be heartbreaking to see them disband, I believe it would be the best decision for them if they were to go their separate ways. Of course, I would love to see Jisoo finally have her own solo project, but I don't want to keep fellow blinks waiting for something that may not happen. While I do wish they would come out with more comebacks, I understand that they may not have the freedom to do so. Blackpink has been around for a while, and they played a significant role in introducing me to K-pop. Even if it saddens us, I think it's time for them to disband and move on to new chapters in their lives.
@jay_jade94
Жыл бұрын
The first sentence is actually what I see, group of beautiful powerful girl that achieved a lot in they're career but now I actually see them more as brand's models and that kinda of stuff, on stage they're good 1 time and the others are just them tired, making mistakes, being annoyed, lazy dancing.
@Lilo_06
8 ай бұрын
I agree. As much as I love them,they are getting tired of waiting and if YG doesn't give them a comeback soon then they won't be resigning the contracts. We all know they would still be very successful even if they disband and I remember watching one video of Rosé and Jisoo (I think). They were in the kitchen and I think Rosè said how much she wants to be a mom. If she really wants that then theirs a possibility she might completely quit K-Pop and find a new career.
@savsybunny7955
Жыл бұрын
i'm not even tryna be biased but i feel like rose is the only member who isn't necessarily doing it JUST "for the money" and actually enjoys the music aspect. the others ehhh...
@annarane8874
Жыл бұрын
Agree
@ayapalerme5870
11 ай бұрын
Look at BP performances and tell me that Lisa doesn’t enjoy being an idol.
@ajlee2168
11 ай бұрын
@@ayapalerme5870 she definitely does enjoy being an idol/ performer, but thats still different from being interested in the music itself. lisa is great on stage, but i see her passion lies in dancing, not making music. rose seems to be the only one actually interested in creating music, not just performing.
@Snowflaxe7065
5 ай бұрын
@@ajlee2168 exactly her songs are meaningful too in the whole bp i found her still rooted with music
@cocainekate420
Жыл бұрын
Honestly you're one of my favorite kpop youtubers, your videos are so chill and layed back but not in a boring way. I really enjoy the way u explain and talk about things!
@hihi615
Жыл бұрын
Yes! Him and Mera are literally my favorites (I lowkey wait for comebacks JUST for them to make videos on it lol)
@Tarikkb
Жыл бұрын
If they’re gonna renew they better change directions of their music , have a creative direction for an album , work with different producers and be involved with the music , experiment styles , they literally have the connections to the top people in the western and Korean music industry they’re in the same label as oscar winning producer finneas , if they’re gonna keep doing the chorus build up and anti chorus , with bunch of cool beats smashed together , they should disband there is no point to destroy the golden statue they build , they have accomplished almost everything in the materialistic sense , awards , money , tours……but they have not made substance yet , ever since 2016 we have seen nothing but the brand of blackpink in their music , it was like a product , if they’re planning on changing that that’s the only reason they should resign otherwise it’s not going to matter
@gyal7892
Жыл бұрын
i want the girls to show up especially in the visual art department like i’m ready if they grow up in any department from the moment it correlates w their way as music artist
@Tarikkb
Жыл бұрын
@@gyal7892 IKR !!! Like yes what we see is cool and expensive but I don’t see growth , intention and cohesiveness , it’s really rare
@gyal7892
Жыл бұрын
@@Tarikkb yes, thats what bp miss the most
@gyal7892
Жыл бұрын
@@Tarikkb mayb a stretch but bp could've iconic and welld one *concepts* if they had the creative freedom (ppl says they dont have it other says they have it so 😶)
@kittykatxoxo
Жыл бұрын
YG only focuses on Rap swag n showing they are freaking cool they should also make vocal songs n change concept like twice. Tbh now I just wanted Rosé Jennie to showcase their talent POTENTIAL they both amazing girls have. I'm tired of ppl ranking them so low in vocal rap categories with other artists just because YG don't let the show their Talent n even they have ability to write produce song like, Channie did but YG rejected it always teddy n bekuh boom she even disrespected Blackpink.I'm so done seriously 7 years with no high notes of Rosé , 7 years with no self written songs for comeback,7 years with no self written rap of Jennie being selected for song, reason ppl to call them low skilled bruh
@AB-yk2pq
Жыл бұрын
Kpop stans stop blaming YGE challenge: They take 1+ year of hiatus and yet they as group rarely write, compose, make choreographies or anything really. Despite 3/4 of them having private KZitem channels they've barely released any content during their hiatus. Even if they didn't have KZitem, they'd still have Weverse but they probably forgot their passwords as this point. They haven't improved their skills and if anything they've regressed since The Album since there are still videos of them not singing or forgetting choreographies. Yes, YGE is to blame because they don't give them comebacks but so are the members. Believe it or not, I used to be hardcore Blink but I simply don't want to blame just the company after their latest comeback.
@nicole-kl1io
Жыл бұрын
I agree I used to be a hardcore blink but the girls are to blame for as well I hope people know that blackpink are most definitely NOT rookies anymore, they have a lot of experience in the industry I’m pretty sure they can make their owns songs and more?
@elanan9411
Жыл бұрын
You seem very updated about a group you dislike and think the worst of. This is referred to as obsession.
@AB-yk2pq
Жыл бұрын
@@elanan9411 I don't think the worst of Blackpink. They're all still mostly nice girls that have talents. And of course I'd know a lot of about them when I was their fan for years? I do not longer follow them but I wish them the best in life. Tell me you're sensitive Blink without telling me that.
@elanan9411
Жыл бұрын
@@AB-yk2pq if you "do not follow them anymore" why does your behavior say anything but? Aside from that, if you want to express an opinion online, you can't expect people to not express opinions in return. Labeling people as "sensitive" because they responded to you will get you nowhere in life.
@AB-yk2pq
Жыл бұрын
@@elanan9411 You're the one who said I have "obsession" over expressing my opinion. Make it make sense. All of things I've talked were present in 2021 as well as majority of years I was following Blackpink. That just shows that Blackpink's situation is nearly always the same, not that people who talks about Blackpink are obsessed (unless they're just insulting girls as people and so on). I've listened Born Pink once or twice, liked 2 songs. I've seen first few shows of their tour and that's it. I didn't even watch their newest content and to be honest I didn't even know Jisoo comfired her solo until someone didn't say that in comments.
@CAETT0
Жыл бұрын
In the beginning BP was so refreshing and strong, they had banger and the best stage presence ever. Their vocals are unique and easily recognizable and I liked them for that. But with the years I stopped listening to them because of many reasons: 1. all their songs are the same. Same structure, same concept, same attitude, same rap verses, same lyrics. I mean, never change a running system, right? They still were the best selling gg, you cannot deny and with every comeback, they got new fans, new KPOP stans and that's fine. But as fast as they got new fans, they also lost old fans because of that, which brings me to 2. no development at all. Since 2016, they didn't develop at all. They had the same sound for 7 fcking years, but still kept the same level of vocals and rap. Jennie is a great rapper, but I couldn't hear any develpment in her skills, same with Rosé's and Jisoo's vocal skills. No decent high notes, no unique time to shine for them, and same concept, same everything. But the saddest thing about that is their regression in stage presence. Even rookie groups outshines them at this point. Just look at Le Sserafim's stage presence. They are WAY BETTER than Blackpink in 2022. Which brings me to 3. They OBVIOUSLY don't want to this sht anymore. You can see that clearly if you just open your fcking eyes, seriously. Since their last comeback 2022 and first live performances since hiatus, you can see that they neither knew their OWN CHOREOS, nor had any stage presence at all anymore. Rosé didn't execute moves properly, their synchronization is worse than trainees and they didn't even tried, Jennies attitude on stage fcks me up, because it's not her first time being lazy on stage. Lisa is the only one I trust, when she'd say, she wans to continue as idol, at least with this kind of concept. Which brings me to 4. Even if they don't want to continue as group, I would believe, Lisa is still interested in dancing and rapping, because she is now the trainer for YG's new gg and she puts some effort in their latest performances. I also could imagine Rosé continuing as soloist, because she did covers and wrote own songs. Since she barely had her time to shine in BlackPink as vocalist, she'd better be a soloist at this point. YG never used her (and Jisoos) vocals properly which always fcked me up tbh. I would also be tired of this. 5. They are no idols anymore. Like you said, YG lost control over Blackpink and I totally agree. Since they had several cooperations with luxery brands, they decided to be influencers. Which worked for them perfectly and if they like that (and get more money with it), then it's fine. They don't need to be Blackpink anymore, maybe that's why they went to hiatus. As group, they didn't grew, but as individuals they did. I loved Boombayah back in the days and As If it's your last is still in my favourite songs-playlist, but they really need to disband at this point. YG played smart: gives them a last comeback, forces them to tour around the globe and let them disband after that. Maximum money with minimum effort. And on tour you see underwhelming 'performances' from bored out influencers for wayyyyy too much money. I'm so sorry for blinks.
@moody_town10
Жыл бұрын
Blackpink have been away for to long they don't feel like a group. They got me into K-pop they made me fall in love with the genre. Some songs i truly like but tbh if they are going to come with music every decade then it should be different like doing different concepts but they already built too much of a solid image as a girl crush group. If they disband it wouldn't matter because the other side they keep talking about the exaggeration about their songs and tour honestly made me forget they were a big group. If Blackpink are going to stay as a group i hope they start to get more songs. Other than that idrc. Also YG is gonna debut a new group and there is no way Blackpink will be getting the same treatment after that. By that i mean YG probs will forget that they even exist
@Meeuuuuw
Жыл бұрын
Bruh YG ain't dumb abt forgetting BP, they are the biggest GG for now, but if they keep doing that 1 year hiatus thing, just to play hard to get, I guarantee they will lose all of their popularity, that means their gonna flop, and will probably make that new GG their new BP
@eveek
Жыл бұрын
@@Meeuuuuw for now? Y’all been saying that for years and yet they get more looks than old big K-pop groups
@candyland9471
Жыл бұрын
@@Meeuuuuw i get the feeling yg does not care about them being the biggest girl group considering they threw bp in the dungeon for two years unprovoked still gave no clear reason for that except it takes time to make high quality songs but when i actually looked into bornpink tally and happiest girl were demos from other artist,and ready for love is a leak from 2018. they barely put any effort into bornpink with no other gg to handle now a new group is on the scene ready to debuet i do expect blackpink to get pushed to the back considering teddy will have to make songs for baemon too and it takes him two years for just blackpink alone. yg should not disband bp right beheind baemons debuet or it will cause a lot of trouble for baemon who just wanted to debuet like any other normal trannie . i also have a theory yg will disband bp but the four members will resign to yg and continue as models or actress in jisoos case because yg does have a modeling and acting sub label i think. i dont see the girls passion for being idols anymore but i can tell they girls still love fashion a lot that ties into why they pink their own outfits,/hair styles but are not really involved in their musical process and also why most of their solos activites is in fashion events .
@kurikei1999x
Жыл бұрын
@@Meeuuuuw YG actually did that with 2NE1 when BP debuted
@himaririku9254
Жыл бұрын
G DRAGON KING -
@datmelonblob
Жыл бұрын
i do agree blackpink (as a group) is very hard to get casual kpop fans to stan the group. like for me, i mainly listen to kpop for the music, not for the visuals/idol events. when i first started listening to blackpink, i absolutely loved their songs, but after listening to it 30 times over i got kinda bored. i checked their yt channel, seeing if they released any new music, but they didn't so i moved on. i mean there are 10 million groups out there i cant wait 2 years just to get some music.
@user-bz5mr7kb1i
Жыл бұрын
Thank god Blackpink Don't Have Casual Listeners. Like Itzy,Twice.
@Liyah2004
Жыл бұрын
This video was my exact thoughts on Blackpink since 2020. And when you mentioned their concert videos, I had that same feeling as well that it just wasn't up to par with their other concerts and that they really weren't feeling it. It's so weird how this girl group that got me into Kpop went so downhill its sad
@leosan2025
Жыл бұрын
well this was 4 months ago, I think this video is outdated now lol
@narutodivergent
11 ай бұрын
@@leosan2025 fr even more after what they did on coachella
@Lilo_06
8 ай бұрын
This was a while ago.
@hihi615
Жыл бұрын
I kinda think Lisa wants to still do this whole "Blackpink thing". Or at least, she still wants to perform, whether it be as a soloist or group I'm not sure (I think if the group had more comebacks, and she got lots of solo opportunities, she'd like it). But I think the rest are kinda over it. Which is normal, you want one thing when you're young, but as you get older and experience more you just want something different. I think Rose would still release music every once in a while... but I think she'd be akin to Adele in terms of how often she releases it (once very few years-) I think Jennie is more into being an influencer and socialite. I think it comes natural to her. Her personality and style seems to naturally gravitate that way too. And if I'm being completely honest, I think she's kinda not into the 'k-industry' as a whole (she's into that 'sterotypical LA girl lifestyle', and her Instagram and sightings practically prove it - I think she'd been akin to Kylie Jenner, Lily Rose Depp (or even Zendaya since it seems she might be getting into acting) in terms of what she wants to do with her career). I think she was into being a kpop idol at first, but after not so many comebacks (I think at first YG really was holding Blackpink back... but i think after a whole they got used to it and adapted it), and the fact that she was completely dragged by kpop fans and media (most of it unfair, some fair criticism but blown way out of proportion), I think changed her attitude towards the industry and her attitude in general. I don't think she's too eager to still be in the kpop industry. As many have suspected, I think her and the other members of Blackpink are just waiting for the contract to be up. I think they actually might dip afterwards (although I think the other members might stay in YG, but as casual soloists, actors and performers, not as a group, at which point we will likely see less of all them except in magazines and brands and on social media... except Lisa, I think she'll continue this 'trainee mentor reality show' thingy she's got going on) Jisoo... I'm not so sure. I think if Blackpink were to disband, she'd probably act a lot more. But I don't think she'd nessesarily be a 'full time' actress)
@skyhideaway
Жыл бұрын
let's be real. the only reason blackpink is the biggest girl group is because they're popular. and the only reason they're popular is because they're from YGE and they were branded as the "new 2ne1". there are so many girl groups in the industry who deliver more, who are passionate about music, who experiments with songs and performs energetically. mamamoo, idle, twice, dreamcatcher, purple kiss, etc. they deserve to be more popular than blackpink because they actually care about their career. they care about music and about their fans. blackpink really doesn't seem to. blackpink doesn't feel like a 3rd gen group at all, they still seem like rookies, and really inexperienced, untrained rookies at that. they're kind of awkward with their interactions with fans and they seem bored and languid on stage. and every time one of the members perform badly on stage, blinks are always trying to defend them, saying "they're just tired" or "they weren't feeling well". girl, tired of what? they come back every 5 years, they get so much rest. there are so many groups who have multiple comebacks a year and still perform energetically on stage. let's just face facts - blackpink are models at this point, not idols. the only member who seems even slightly interested in music is rosé and she isn't utilized enough as the main vocalist. and about writing or producing songs, I've seen blinks claim that jennie wrote stay, or jenlisa wrote a specific rap. but there's no proof, there's no credits, we only have their word for it. that's not enough. the only one with credits is lovesick girls, which was co-written by jennie and jisoo. blinks love to baby blackpink and act as if the members aren't grown women with agency. it's so funny because on one hand, blinks praise blackpink for being "boss bitches" and "independent queens", but when it comes to their involvement in their career, suddenly it's "oh they're being controlled by yg", "yg doesn't allow them to do such and such", "it's not their fault, they have no freedom". i refuse to believe that after becoming so popular, those girls are still "controlled" if they ever were. they're not. they just don't care about their career because at the end of the day, they're popular and anything they release goes viral simply because they are blackpink. not because it's a good song / album, not because they perform well, but because they're popular. and they receive their paycheck regularly and are filthy rich at this point, so why should they care? this isn't hate to the girls, but it is criticism. like you said, they either need to perform better or they need to disband.
@crazyabout1327
Жыл бұрын
Preach!
@bkbhkbbk
Жыл бұрын
No matter what u say tho, they’ll still be the gg that overshadows everyone (nj is kind of an exception rn but alot of ppl still don’t know the girls themselves so I don’t know if that’s even a win?)
@skyhideaway
Жыл бұрын
@@bkbhkbbk yeah obviously. my thoughts on this matter, or anyone else's, isn't going to change their popularity. i guess if they do disband, their popularity might start fading
@crazyabout1327
Жыл бұрын
@@bkbhkbbk I don't see that happening. BP are popular because they are still (kinda) active. The moment they disband, their popularity as a group will fade away. Yeah, the girls probably will get acting gigs, ofc modelling gigs, but 2-3 years after disbandment nobody will remember their music. They have no legacy music-wise (their songs are good for dancing/clubbing, but they will not stand the test of time, believe me) and new and new groups will come with better songs. Heck, I'm sure that when Baby Monster debuts, BP will be left in the YG dungeon for good. Because that's what he always does. The reason why they overshadow the other groups now is because they have a massive fanbase that streams like crazy. But views means nothing in terms of longevity. The only people that will remember them are their fans and maybe even they will forget about them sometime in the future if the girls stop doing music after leaving YG.
@uglycow6204
Жыл бұрын
I half agree with you.. rosé is very very passionate about music, she co wrote two of her solos.. (when she plays instruments u can see how happy she is, and she cries when she sees fans..)
@lety_nosequemasponerd4134
Жыл бұрын
"Yeah it's sad but true, we gotta kill this love before it kills you too"
@blg_wy
11 ай бұрын
I've been a fan of Blackpink since their debut, and in all those years, I haven't even been a fan of any other K-pop group except them. They are my only source of happiness whenever I have no school, whenever I'm sad, and in everything. Just this year, I found myself getting interested in New Jeans and leaving Blackpink behind. For almost 7 years, I was only stanning Blackpink, and it's only now that I've found interest in another K-pop group. As much as I don't want to admit it, I'm losing interest in them, and that's probably why it made me stan Newjeans. But just the thought of them disbanding makes me emotional, it's like those things that you're used to seeing everyday and all of the sudden you woke up and there's nothing and all that's left are the memories. I may sound dramatic but this is how I'm really feeling that I didn't want to believe and admit months ago. All that being said, I'll still support them no matter what❤️
@yoon1365
Жыл бұрын
There's also this. So far fans have always blamed yg for everything blackpink "doesn't have" Less songs they're controlled blah blah But say if they do resign with the company Then they'll be CHOOSING that company Let's face it they could they have the job everyone wants they do smthn for a small while and then take extended vacations Why would anyone wanna loose that job On the other hand say it really is true they're controlled or whatever and they really do wanna continue n release more songs as a grp Then they could pull a got7 Idk I just believe if they resign their contract AND nothing Changes then they'll run out of excuses
@HailToTheMeep
Жыл бұрын
Personally. I don’t think they have the group cohesion to pull a GOT7. Plus: YG isn’t JYP. The latter at least “allows” artist to set themselves free, even if not by design and almost by accident (GOT7 and Stray Kids). YG will DESTROY the girls before they set them free.
@lovelymill
Жыл бұрын
yge destroyed 2ne1 and then pulled out blackpink. yge will destroy BP soon and then debut their new girl group. i bet
@Joy.W.
Жыл бұрын
@@Itwastoodumb You act like it’s an easy thing to do
@natisnotes
Жыл бұрын
I quit listening to BP because they mostly feel like models for brands who make music as a second job :/ while other groups are giving new fresh vibes!
@9xprincess
Жыл бұрын
Honestly you spoke the truth. However I think contractually YG still holds a lot of power in terms of revenue, ownership and management. But yes BlackPink could take more control over their creativity and overall artistic direction. The Born Pink era could have been their artistic emancipation, but the Pinks themselves are in on the formula because it gives the most money with the less amount of work and creative energy. I think their harsh training days and initial control by YGE burnt them out.
@sleepyfriendstm
Жыл бұрын
This gotta be clickbait...lol Edit: It wasn't and valid points were made.
@luciddreamqueen812
Жыл бұрын
It’s so sad seeing them fade away like they are. I was a huge fan of 2ne1 and I thought the worst case would be BP getting put through things similar to 2ne1, but this is a different kind of awful. At least with 2ne1 fans knew most of them would keep trying to perform in the future, but with BP it looks like they’re just so tired that it’s a decent chance most of the members won’t perform anymore. And it’s just so sad seeing art and passion die. I really really hope BP doesn’t sign a new contract and disappear for a bit to recover then come back in their own ways. Regardless of whether they do more in music or they leave entirely, I hope they do what they actually care about because they seemingly don’t care right now. Just discovered your channel and I really like your ways of presenting info and opinions :)))
@Sneha2929lol
Жыл бұрын
In my opinion, I think you're clearly right. That the fact is blackpink can do many things they can write their songs , change their sounds or concept but they are not willing to. Not in a sense of hate but there must be a reason, I personally think there are 2 reasons : 1. That they are not passionate about it now as they were before. Being a really really really big fucking gg it is really hard to fulfill the expectations of the shitty fans and like he said THEY'RE DONE NOW, THEY'VE DONE IT ALL , THEY'RE DONE WITH THIS LIFE , THIS GROUP, THIS FANDOM , THIS INDUSTRY. After the COVID we can see a hike in kpop fans which has grown in a big percentage. And I think not only blackpink but other groups too (specially 3rd gen) are now fed up. 2. This one might be disrespectful but I am saying in no sense of hate that I think they're not changing anything is because they want MONEY. The music that was a big fuckin hit before 4-6 years back , blackpink is uploading similar music with same fukin concept because young kpop fans just don't care , they are just toxic and that's what is a big strategy of companies to print their money. These music which were a big hit before 5 years are still the same and still being a big hit why? Yes. You guessed it right. Correct me if I am wrong and I really want you're options. If you wanna hate on me , please do it's your right but just accept the reality that at the end of the day, they will disappoint you and leave you alone on the same stage you were before kpop and om the same stage that got you into kpop. Thank you.
@nonamenosurname6127
Жыл бұрын
Man, you have a point. They need to change their sound if they want to renew their contract. Otherwise it is better for them to go as soloists or actresses.
@rainbowshit
Жыл бұрын
AS A BLINK,I TOTALLY AGREE WITH EACH AND EVERYTHING HERE
@sweetmarmaladera1573
Жыл бұрын
I want them to disband. They need creative freedom. Id love to hear Rosé sing her own songs. Jisoo originally wanted to be an actress and Id love to see more of her acting side.
@Idkaina
11 ай бұрын
I agree with this statement.
@hiloo917
Жыл бұрын
“same fucking sounds same fucking concepts” is real as fuck. someone has finally said it. i love blackpink but it’s just nothing new anymore
@y2klove581
Жыл бұрын
It’s sad cause you could see the hunger they had from debut and I think after 2019 they lost their drive since they done it all like rosé said in a literal song that she realised everything she needed was on the ground in her song on the ground maybe that’s why she still has some of that passion for music I just want them to be happy whatever they do in life
@Gojo0442
Жыл бұрын
blackpink is a good kpop group, but they are so overrated. 1st off all of their songs are so similar, like so many of their have ratatatatata or the same beat. they also have meaningless lyrics and they create a new song ever year. and ngl what i notice in a lot of their songs is that jennie has the most lines and rose has the least line (i know it is the company fault because jennie is the company favorite but its still unfair) also they barley even create songs all they do is do fashion most of the time. they basically arent kpop idols if mostly what they do is fashion. i agree they should disband, they seem like they loved their career when they first started now they seem like they dont wanna do this career anymore they look like they wanna do a different career. like jennie should be like a model or an influencer, rose being solo and doing her own music, lisa a dancer or a dance teacher, and jisoo an actress. edit: i am happy the way you explained how everything isnt yg fault its blackpink
@orsolya986
Жыл бұрын
I don't know how I feel about Blackpink I love their songs and the members but Im scared of blinks and their concept isn't really my thing!
@user-fg9of7vh6u
Жыл бұрын
my my i m so tired of these fans protecting them, if yg had control would they let jennie be in the idol, would they?? think , if u can
@vibeyclare5066
Жыл бұрын
The problem is that YG doesn't want to disband BlackPink. And the reason for that is BlackPink is YG's BIGGEST group and i mean BIGGEST group BlackPink is the only reason why YG is such a popular company. And that is why YG needs BlackPink.
@gyal7892
Жыл бұрын
they’re not the only reason tho, they’re one of them yg was already popular like they were part of the big 3 bp just propelled them even more
@zaynes5094
Жыл бұрын
He doesn't really ever disband groups. Just breaks their contracts and lets them go do whatever they want with whoever they want.
@idk.bruhhhh
Жыл бұрын
dude I keep coming back to your vids like I just love the way that you form your opinions in a logical way and say things out there that people usually don’t have the guts to so like seriously don’t stop and keep up the good work :)))
@tiredofshadows
Жыл бұрын
Y’all weird to me. Don’t you guys think the reason they are popular is because of the same shit they do. Same songs, girl crush, and come back every now and then. I’m positive if they did what y’all wanted and changed their song sounds and themes and etc they wouldn’t be the be biggest girl group. So many kpop fans on KZitem and Reddit say they want change or unique groups. Those weird unique and quirky groups always flop. Simple matter of the fact is the genera public like BlackPink just the way they are. I believe majority of youtube and Reddit kpop fans live in their own bubble which just doesn’t reflect the general public’s opinion.
@tiredofshadows
Жыл бұрын
Blinks don’t want sound change and general public doesn’t care. They are bigger than ever in the numbers even with hardcore kpop fans complaining nonstop. Change is the opposite of what fans want it literally shown through the money and following. Companies ain’t stupid they would have change themes or song types if that would make them more money.
@jajjnki
Жыл бұрын
@@tiredofshadows literally 50% of blinks want sound change. Plus they would probably gain more attraction with the extreme change. Girl crush sux since it’s so used.
@chinoncv1634
Жыл бұрын
About the concerts, i went to one of their shows here in Europe back in December and i must say that the clips online does not represent the show well at all. They never once looked bored or uninterested and there was nothing "lazy" about their performances either so when it comes to performing on stage it felt to me like they loved it just like in the past, if not more.
@karinasnooodles_
Жыл бұрын
Did you go to the earlier concerts
@MariaHernandez-mm9tf
Жыл бұрын
I went to one here in Chicago with my daughter and for me is boring to death but is maybe because I am not a blink lol
@aurora-cc6hk
Жыл бұрын
@꧁༒☬𝕸𝖔𝖔𝖓 𝕷𝖎𝖌𝖍𝖙☬༒꧂ SAME
@cateila
6 ай бұрын
The one in asia sucks
@matmic0326
Жыл бұрын
TRUE!!! If BP wanted release more songs and content for Blinks, they would do it. But they want to do photoshoot for luxurious brands, fly to Paris fashion weeks etc. They aren't rookie girl group who debuted a year ago and are under control of YG. They are the biggest gg in the world, they can have control on themselves. Even TWICE, who are 7 years afer debut, can do what they want - they write their own songs, do melody projects for fans, do lots of content like TTT, and the have time for Once.
@user-bz5mr7kb1i
Жыл бұрын
But still twice Flop..unsold Concerts even in their home country.
@gogogogig
Жыл бұрын
@@user-bz5mr7kb1iyou’re just using numbers and trying to change the subject….no matter what twice cares about their fans more than bp ever will accept it
@sayenka6093
7 ай бұрын
Well, the worst is happening.
@ningfication_
3 ай бұрын
lmao he really predicted everything
@heavenbound9157
Жыл бұрын
DISCLAIMER: While I am aware that the criticism I share in this comment might be considered harsh, I want to make clear that it is not coming from a place of hate, but rather just frustration. I started out as a fan of BP and was really rooting for them at the beginning of their career, but I'm also a fan of music and k-pop and I don't think it's fair to blindly support mediocrity at the expense of groups/artists that are more deserving. BP are the perfect example of how far one can get in the industry when one is beautiful, because honestly, that is all they have going for them (please note that I am talking about the group and not the individuals. I think Lisa is an incredible performer and Rose is a great vocalist). They give me NOTHING and have been giving me NOTHING for years. I started out as a fan, but I can't say I've enjoyed anything they've released since 뚜두뚜두, which came out 5 years ago. As a k-pop fan of over 15 years I find it incredibly offensive when an agency treats fans as these brainless zombies that will just support everything and keep buying everything no matter the quality of the output. Why is it that a group with only 2 studio albums has 4 live albums? Make it make sense. And the dumb thing is that fans keep buying and supporting this nonsense. The songs they have released since 2018 have been the same song over and over and over, and yet people keep supporting it. Meanwhile, there are so many incredibly talented and hardworking idols that are much more deserving of BP's fame but get completely overlooked because they are from smaller companies (or maybe not as physically attractive as the BP girls are). Even their seniors, 2NE1, a far more talented group in my humble opinion, were disbanded for no fucking reason other than that YG wanted to bet everything on BP (in my opinion because they are conventionally more attractive girls. It is no secret that YG thought the 2NE1 girls were ugly and even said it to their face multiple times). I understand that this has always been the case in the industry, but I think that as k-pop becomes more global we need to start thinking about whether we want beauty to be the new standard, and whether we want these ridiculous beauty standards that have been upheld in the k-pop industry for so long to transfer to other markets. We need to stop rewarding beauty without substance. And we need to demand agencies give us quality MUSIC, because k-pop is about music, ultimately. Nothing wrong with having good visuals, but if there's no real talent to back it up then you are just taking up space for nothing. Disband BP, let's see which one of these girls can hold up in the industry on their own.
@chaaruvijay9419
Жыл бұрын
@Mila Odu Yeah, I mean I'm just some kid and even I seem to be singing more than them... not to mention(trying to) write songs.... (and all 5 people who watched that torture on Insta liked it 😆)Don't get me wrong, I love style and makeup and modelling which are all awesome, but you gotta have some interest in making and performing music, which only Rose seems to care for. I don't think we should treat them so harshly, but I agree, if BP's disbanded, let's see which one of these girls can hold up in the industry on their own.....
@charumag9814
Жыл бұрын
blackpink brought me into K-Pop and its good to know that someone who has been there fans feels the same about how dragging it has been ( for me personally ) as i have always look up to there change and growth its always the same no matter how bias i have been with dis group 😶
@kpopme7327
Жыл бұрын
but I don't understand why kpop fans are so stupid that they don't understand that BP is successful because of this kind of music and what yg does
@lillischmidt1445
Жыл бұрын
Exactly!!!
@youarebeautiful9876
Жыл бұрын
You told what I had in mind. I am new to kpop and this group was the reason i got invested in k-pop even though I was never really a blink.I am a Midzy now btw!
@Ah1My-Spinach-Puffs1
Жыл бұрын
Someone said it perfectly they are just a bunch of models/ influencers/ kdrama actors who walk into a studio every couple of years. After their Dallas show which was a waste of money it’s clear that music is their SIDE hustle.
@what-a-marvelous-tune
Жыл бұрын
i do feel like one of the big factors for them losing their passion can be related to the amount of, let us not kid ourselves, unnecessary hate they received. hell, the internet was on a jennie witch haunt for her entire solo promo. can you blame her for starting to dislike going on stage?
@Lion-cu1hl
11 ай бұрын
YG will drop them because they're not charting with their songs. Whereas the producers and owners of the company take the most income. What they have now is just temporarily. The fame, the money they get from the sponsors from showing to the shows, and the concerts while toping songs from the charts is a lifetime income. That's why YG wanted to debut the new girl group and make sure to release a hit song. That's why they recruited talented ones over looks.
@YJL186
Жыл бұрын
I just want them to be happy and do what they enjoy doing. They have released some of my favorite music in the genre and in my opinion, are some of the most talented people in the industry. I will be sad if they disband but I also understand your point. If disbanding is what the girls want, then I would support that decision. I just hope they do what is best for themselves at the end of the day. Blackpink will always be one of my favorite groups in the genre of K-pop.
@bogklarkaszabo9656
Жыл бұрын
It's really such a shame that we aren't face to face to talk right now. You seem like such a thoughtful person who is good to have conversations with. I really feel like it's sad how throughout their whole carreer as you've mentioned they've pretty much done it all. They broke multiple records and achieved to have a huge worldwide audience and fanbase and their influence speads like wildfire. However the most important thing when being an artist imo is having passion for what youre creating. I miss that and i don't see that. And that's really upsetting. This is also why i'm really conflicted about the whole kpop industry. I'm aware it's not only about the music but it has started to shift its focus on visuals and money and marketing so much which i can see in blackpink's case that it just leaves me feeling empty about it all. I agree with you though.
@jmd0605
Жыл бұрын
Counterpoint: What about the worst scenario if they do disband? It's so easy to say their legacy as the biggest girl group in K-pop would be preserved, but what about who they are as artists, afterward? Because let's face it, once they disband, they will not have the same kind of clout or attention they do once they disown the brand of BLACKPINK. They will not have the same opportunities, especially since we've seen what kind of projects they've extended to. Lisa has only had two collabs, but why are they branded under "LISA of BLACKPINK"? Jisoo and Jennie has had acting experiences in two big shows. Snowdrop wasn't the best, and The Idol hasn't come out yet, but what the two of them have in common is their scandals are pretty big fucking deals. Their acting debuts are already tainted by Don't Worry Darling-levels of drama. And while Rose hasn't had anything to worry about yet, that's because she hasn't ventured outside of anything solo music-related. Most of them are just covers or guest appearances on musical Korean shows. Sure, all eyes are on them during these, and I'm not saying they won't still be famous; they just won't have the same attention or clout they currently receive. They probably won't be banking in on the same kind of money. And while that doesn't seem to be a problem for a lot of people, because they're "artistically free" or whatever...I just think that it's a logically bad move. Of course not everyone can stay in the spotlight forever, but how to do we know that this August of 2023 is their end? Side tangent: let's talk about 2NE1. They disbanded in 2017 and have made 2 significant impacts since; Park Bom's comeback, and their Coachella reunion in 2022. CL and Minzy, despite their best efforts, have not made much noise. CL's album wasn't a flop, but it's certainly not the gamechanging debut we would expect from the Baddest Female. And Dara...well let's be honest, she's moved on to variety and (sometimes) acting, even under YG she definitely never planned on going to music all the time. Park Bom isn't the most famous soloist, but Spring made a lot of noise, especially since it was a collab...with Dara, a 2NE1 member. See the trend? The name 2NE1 is what connects them, it's what empowers them. I'm not trying to discredit or downplay whatever success they have or will have on their own merit, but it will never be the same as the kind of noise they make under the name, the brand, the legend, 2NE1. And the same goes for BLACKPINK. In my opinion, I think they should renew, but not for the same amount of time, and they should definitely start showing up, start showing more passion. Maybe 2-3 years, and then more legitimate projects because at that point, they don't have any excuses anymore. BLACKPINK is a brand, they're not the same kind of artists BTS, TWICE, Red Velvet are. They're not the same kind of artists BIGBANG and 2NE1 are. They're influencers, models, socialites, celebrities who do music on the side. And if that's selling out, then I'm sorry, they've already sold out a long time ago. Renewing their contract is just a matter of how long their current fame lasts, and how they're going to maintain it.
@mary4963
Жыл бұрын
The same way Jimin's features where branded 'Jimin of BTS' or JK's. 'Jungkook of BTS'. I don't understand the logic with that point because you seem to be nitpicking at something that is industry standard atp. She is a member of BP, as JK & Jimin are members of BTS. If you had no issue with them using their band then having an issue with this just feels like mindless hate.
@ohmygod4031
Жыл бұрын
That's right
@ajlee2168
Жыл бұрын
i dont know if this is a hot take or common sense, but after blackpink disbands, there's nothing really they leave behind. no real impact has been made thus far (depending on how to define impact you might disagree ig), there's no meaningful legacy to look back on. if they split up they'll keep some hype to their names but it'll fade rather quickly imo. i think they're just okay with ygs strategy and dont even want to change it, so once they disband and cant follow that same formula anymore, i dont see any of them staying at the level they're at right now. staying in blackpink is safe, going solo to actually evolve as an artist would be a risk; yg, teddy and bp have never taken risks like that. its not gonna happen any time soon.
@jmd0605
Жыл бұрын
@@mary4963 my only issue with that is if they disband, their names won't hold much weight compared to if they bring in their band name. I'm not an ARMY, I can't speak for Jungkook and Jimin, but I think they could hold on their own without the name BTS attached to them because the possibility of disbandment isn't a big deal in the fandom (yet). Same cannot be said for BLACKPINK. If they were to go on their own, without their names attached, they wouldn't make the same noise. Maybe for the first few years, but if the name BLACKPINK is no longer relevant, neither will they.
@jmd0605
Жыл бұрын
@@ajlee2168 no you're right. I guess if we were to look at it differently, however, BLACKPINK did make 1 big impact on the industry, however negative it may seem, and that's sparse comebacks and treating 8 songs as a full album. Okay, they did not INVENT the concept of an 8 song album, but they sure as hell normalized it. Chungha, (G)I-DLE, and I'm pretty sure even other artists have started to do so. Not that 10+ song albums will go away, but it seems likely that it would become an industry standard soon, especially if they renew and continue with, as you said, the formula.
@towardsuniverse
Жыл бұрын
Yeah...they are the group that got me into K-pop too.. They got me bcuz they were popular They were beautiful. They had catchy beats. But after this much years I realized they are just average , in every term . "THEY ARE NOT THE BEST , "...BUT ofc for marketing strategy they are the best. If they want they could be better especially rose as a singer. Jennie , Lisa could be models and jisoo a actor. I'm not a blink anymore but watching about their disbandment makes me teary , and nostalgic. They gave me memories ❤️❤️❤️😭...#blackpink #kpo
@AgussxVenus
Жыл бұрын
i want to change something you said ''they have done it all'' i WISH they had done it all there's so many concepts we haven't seen from them a straight up Sexy concept (we know for sure Lisa can do that) a cute but edgy concept (kinda like ice cream, and yes i know most people don't like it) the problem is not only YG but Teddy as a producer only makes the exact same thing for Blackpink Pink Venom is literally a copy of How You Like That i think if they used songs like ''Tally'' WITHOUT changing the original lyrics the group would sound better but we keep getting the exact same thing ever since DDU-DU-DDU-DU came out and this is not a ''Blackpink only'' thing to me this happened with Twice as well it began with Alcohol Free and it went downhill turning the group into the ''cute concept only'' when their best eras were ''Feel Special'', ''Fancy'' and ''More & More'' a group that is a VERY good example of doing everything right is Red Velvet they don't stay in one concept, they keep trying new things i just really hope blackpink ends on a good note when it has to wouldn't want it to be this soon but if they don't change their style i don't see it going any other way
@juliana_melo
Жыл бұрын
I agree with a lot of things you've said in this video, but with two especific topics I have to disagree. First: Blackpink is not the biggest/best girl group ever, and I don't care about any blink's opinion on this. Yes, they do get the biggest numbers and whatever, but the quality of their music and performances are way below when we compare to other gg in the industry. Rookies are doing a better job than them, so hmm, nope. And second: all the stuff you've said it may happen if they renew their contract has already happened. One of the reasons I can't agree on calling BP the biggest gg is that they're almost not idols anymore. Releasing five songs a year (at best), keeping the same concept/formula for every cb, doing shitty performances in concerts (except for Lisa, maybe), etc. They should just disband and go modelling or something.
@5arahbelle
Жыл бұрын
the biggest does not equal the best. are they the best? that’s subjective. but they are most definitely the biggest. you ask the average not kpop fan to name a koop gg, they will not know any of the rookies because they haven’t even put a dent in the western market. are they getting more popular?? yeah and the quality of performances might subjectively be better but OBJECTIVELY blackpink is the most well known gg. they are literally headlining coachella this year. not just attending again, they are the top THREE performers at coachella. in the WEST. a rookie group cannot compare to that
@judas7585
Жыл бұрын
Girl bp are globally recognized and no other kpop gg is really that relevant outside korea
@helenhill9983
Жыл бұрын
I'm glad someone said this. Personally, with how low quality and unchanging BP's songs are, I have been feeling more and more that they're just overrated. If others disagree, that's fine. It's just my opinion. 🤷♀️
@athensuye6105
Жыл бұрын
I love your channel so much .. And your voice is very laid back and chill..please continue this type of videos. 😊😊💕
@staycsprinkles3777
Жыл бұрын
4:15 They sold out a long time ago and that shit already does happen. If they don't disband it will be the status quo and kpop stans wont care bc they will keep streaming their content
@stu4635
Жыл бұрын
The members would be acutely aware that the lifestyle they now lead is an expensive one. There is a reason some Spice Girls ended up with F1 team bosses and world renowned footballers. If they disband it could all dry up very quickly and then what? The fashion industry machine keeps churning. Ofc YG need BP more but the members may need BP more than they realise. Their schtick has long been 'we're bad ass women, girl power 2020s style', yet they have lyrics with Chanel and Lambos, they sold out long ago. AIIYL and Whistle are the tracks that got me into them, and nothing has grabbed me like those two songs since.
@candyland9471
Жыл бұрын
the thing that gets me is most of their songs are written by a man saying they don't need a man
@yasavinggrace
Жыл бұрын
and honestly like one comment said I feel like now since both recent and 4th gen ggs (like newjeans, ive, le sserafim, and even 50/50 now w/ cupid) are becoming more popular and viral now that yg will probably disband bp (and I think the girls would too for more opportunities) especially since they have a new gg coming they would focus all their attention on them.. like look how long it takes bp to release music and there’s no way yg could handle 2 ggs unfortunately :(( and I’ve seen that they even wanna make some of the members of the new gg the new Jennie and Lisa like 😭 I really think blackpink are going to disband honestly it’s sad
@sandwich834
Жыл бұрын
some of the people in this comment section are so delusional omg 😭 did you actually even watch the video??
@bt-eg8xu
Жыл бұрын
i don't see how staying in the group would benefit them at all in the short and long run. their solo fans are honestly wayyyyy more dedicated than the group stans, they're absolutely thriving without one another, and honestly their relationship in my opinion is like those friends who see each other at school and maybe once in a while outside of there. not like four best friends who have grown up and had all this fun side by side and are meant to be together forever. so it makes more sense to me for them to cut the lazy gg bullshit they've been pulling recently and go their separate ways
@RockstarCho38
11 ай бұрын
this is so true, they have the power to do whatever they want but they don't (I love the girls but come on now, 7 years! And they have about 40 songs. while other groups haven't even been here for half their time and are having comebacks left and right) but I do agree, for their own good, they *need* to disband and if they renew that contract and continue to do the same concept and shit I don't think I'm going to be able to support them anymore. and like you said, they've done it all. What more can they do? so I hate to say this, but I feel their time is up. this is my opinion (and I'm also agreeing with the video) so if you have a problem don't waste your time hating on me- I'm just stating what I belive
@yesterdaypizza9725
Жыл бұрын
"Biggest kpop girl group" honestly new fans of kpop are just ..... if that's what we are basing biggest kpop girl group on, I remember when the old kpop groups worked hard to prove themseleves but now all you have to do is be pretty and everyone will be fan and then you get the title of biggest kpop group. Yeah pretty easy
@elanan9411
Жыл бұрын
No. Biggest kpop girlgroup is an objective fact 😵💫 and that is backed up by Forbes, the Grammys, rolling stone and many more, and most of all, statistics and numbers.
@soraya131
Жыл бұрын
biggest kpop group is just a brand. there a difference between being the biggest group because your a global influence or being the biggest group because of your impact to music as a whole or even being the biggest group, because your name is the most known. i feel like there’s so many groups who can be called the biggest K-pop group based on certai categories bc not one group has all three😩
@JkLina13
Жыл бұрын
@@soraya131 BtS got all without GG ofc they just biggest kpop of every criteria u mentioned and even more !
@winisning
Жыл бұрын
I love your channel so much, I was actually waiting for you to upload this topic
@zaynes5094
Жыл бұрын
It's true. They were the first group I started following some 3 months ago when I got into K-pop (not for the music really, I'm a rock and metalhead first, although I do like some Red Velvet, Mamamoo and Apink stuff). Now I'm really into Red Velvet, Twice, Mamamoo, and Apink more musically than I was at first, but I still don't like K-pop or the industry itself. It limits these girls and guys and demands a strict code that they have to follow at all times. When you're a teenager you want to hang out with friends, you want to have fun while you can, and maybe have a girlfriend/boyfriend/both (maybe not at the same time though), but this industry doesn't even let them have a girlfriend or boyfriend. It doesn't even allow for them to understand or explore their sexualities, and even in my small-town HS we had girls and guys we heard about getting caught at parties making out with other girls or guys. BUT THEY CAN'T EVEN DATE. Rose could go do some solo albums, signed with Cube or HYBE, and she'd have that freedom to do stuff I think she'd have the creative freedom to do whatever she wants. She's said she's an artist first, and I believe that, but if she really wanted to have some more artistic license and freedom to do what she wants she would get THE F OUT.
@SYLV_IN
Жыл бұрын
If they disband at least Rosé could be a solo singer like taeyeon, Jisoo could be an actress i think that's what she wanted to do, Jennie could model and be an international star (jet setting) as for Lisa she could be a solo Rapper like CL , a Choreographer for amazing shows, or even work on her singing which is something she wasn't able to do being the rapper of the group
@sparsh_jaiswal
Жыл бұрын
Just wanted to say that just give it a thought YG needs blackpink or blackpink needs YG??maybe in their rookie era they really needed YG but now blackpink is strong enough that they can do what they want,in the sense they can produce,compose their own songs,write their raps and etc. You know till 2019 their music sounded very fresh and LSG and HYLT was still tolerable but BORNPINK?no...I say that blackpink have one of the most iconic songs in the industry and one of the deserving groups but just accept that they are very overhyped,i won't say overrated because their songs till 2019 deserve that rate but now I don't think there is something fresh and new it's just their recycled music.....but you can't deny that girl crush is one the most common concept but blackpink owns this concept,they pulled off this concept the best.there are more talented groups other than bp but bp had ICONIC songs so their songs covered it all. Now they are just models that sometimes makes music.....Now they are in a situation where "either die as a hero or live long enough to see yourself as a villian".Now they had enough of there career.
@Alexanderstewart_734
Жыл бұрын
I wanna say Jennie might be a soloist Jisoo is going to be an actress Lisa is going to be a model and Rose might be a model
@zoepadilla5797
10 ай бұрын
jennie is probably gonna become an influencer since she honestly seems the most tired of idol life out of the four jisoo may continue singing or she may start acting or both lisa is probably gonna become a dancer or dance teacher since she still seems pretty passionate abt dancing/performing and rosé is most likely gonna become a soloist since she seems the most passionate abt singing and songwriting
@lianahit2614
6 ай бұрын
the way your worst scenerio happened lmao
@seoce
Жыл бұрын
BLACKPINK is stuck in the Pink Venom of BLACKPINK they need to disband, they have been already in the industry for more than 7 years and they need to go to other paths. BLINKS Know they're so popular and they don't want BLACKPINK to disband but they need to know they could be WAY more famous in the GLOBAL industry ROSE: Needs to be a soloist (Could still be in YG, or her nationality can do something, she's BORN to be a soloist, she's BORN PINK, could be the same popularity) JISOO: Needs to be an actress (She already had her peak, she's getting weaker and we know her actress talent is A LOT, and she can be the MOST popular member in the global world like Hollywood) JENNIE: Model (could be a lot of things more, which is why, she would be a FAMOUS ICON in the global industry, work with a lot of luxury brands, we already got her in MET GALA, and she can be WAY more popular with BLINKS support) LISA: Too many options.. but she could still be in the MUSIC Industry, (she still has something to give, but BLACKPINK could be slow downing the possibilities, as i said. Maybe soloist or in a group) Also, she could also serve as a model. YG: Can invest for BLACKPINK the BABYMONSTER new group, and also he can have ROSE. THIS IS NOT The End. This opens paths, for everyone, including BABYMONSTER. With BLINKS POWER, they can shine everyway. Thanks!
@user-bz5mr7kb1i
Жыл бұрын
Jennie and Blinks support?? What did blinks did for Her. Always trolling Her for Line distribution,calls Her favoritism,boycotting Her solo debut??
@ajlee2168
11 ай бұрын
this comment feels like its baiting blinks lmao sorry no offense
@adjass
Жыл бұрын
Why cant blackpink not disband but now focus more on there solo projects like snsd does. Does there own thing for a time. Mabye members wanna go to a other company but are still a part of BP. 🤷♀️
@arespyre
Жыл бұрын
True
@kpopstan4ever641
11 ай бұрын
Mad respect for you. You've got one of the best, if not, THE BEST kpop channel on YT. Your opinions are so well explained and you're not even offensive! Great work man. Love your effort and explanation.
@innomuichiro0
Жыл бұрын
keep posting such videos man, I love your videos so much
@honor__
Жыл бұрын
Tbh, with the amount of money that they make, I don’t think YG will disband them anytime soon. However, I think they will most likely disband on the girls’ accord (this year?) because they already have so much going for them outside blackpink
@zolytienda
Жыл бұрын
The first kpop group that caught my attention was 2ne1, but for obvious reasons the second was blackpink and as a fan we are loyals even if we listen other kpop groups we have one favorite and mine was Blackpink I only listen to them, but I started get boring for the periods of inactivity and started to listen more other groups like bts, stray kids, twice and many others… I think if Blackpink only wants money they’re gonna continue that way, but if they really listen to blinks they have the power to do something about it… but it seems that they only want to be models now and not singers if they release an album every for years that is so annoying as a fan… when there are more new groups over there… and recently announced the new group BABY MONSTER and the rumor that Blackpink is going with THE BLACK LEVEL with Teddy I hope they make a good decision I don’t wanna lie their songs are fire but the fans are loyal and deserve better
@liu5461
Жыл бұрын
i'm sure they'll renew the contract, all their brand deals and influencer thing comes from the name of 'blackpink', they probably don't want to lose that, but they're definitely neglecting music, their fans should except even less songs and comebacks from them in the future.
@spookbowl
10 ай бұрын
Y'all if they disband the only thing u fans are losing is their songs (& overpriced concerts..) which nobody really gaf about if they all sound the same right? They're not gone forever and i'm sure they'll be good friends still 🤷♀️ and the things the fans aren't talking about is that the money blackpink wants. they always think about how they're gonna miss blackpink but miss girl ofc they won't disband they still want money!!!
@jisuskitty
Жыл бұрын
well jisoo is finally getting a solo so who knows what their group will hold in the future and a new yg girl group is coming so we don’t know how often bp will comeback after that new gg debuts
@masteroffear5762
Жыл бұрын
After looking at those North American encore dates and how they did in Coachella, nah it seems like i don't think they will 🤔
@taylorcullen2659
Жыл бұрын
Jisoo debuting in March, the girls headlining Coachella and now some large stadium venues for their encore concert coming up kinda feel like a set up for Blackpink to go out with a bang, if not through disbandment, then through a loooong hiatus after the tour, and I mean long. If they do renew, I think they're gonna focus on solo activities (music, acting, fashion) while YG puts all their effort into Baby Monster's debut and we won't see another OT4 song until at least late 2024 but probably 2025 if the girls are busy with solo activities.
@pledisafterschool
Жыл бұрын
YGNGG will debut in 2023 so I’m excited how they will follow Blackpink’s success
@ambred.b8284
Жыл бұрын
I think bp can be very successful as soloists (if they disband). I bet there’s hundreds of recording companies that would love to sign them (and I’m pretty sure that some companies are already waiting for when they have to renew their contract!)!
@userdreamcatcher
Жыл бұрын
I to as a blink agree even more now. Like if they did not stop when they got more famous with duddududdu and would of comeback more and experimented with their musik they would of for sure be more passionate about being a kpop idol. But they didn't and i even now am not excited anymore when they come back. It's just if they want blinks to stay and they go their own way (what they should have done before) they should disband
@crazycarrollcrew
Жыл бұрын
I would prefer if they would all disband and maybe take a break for a while and then maybe come back with other groups so that we can see them in another group/concept but they are getting old it is rare you will see a 36+ age kpop I-dol like very rare.
@ashm003
Жыл бұрын
Tbh, im still waiting for jisoo's solo debut. I hope she'll get one before they disband (which i can see happening). It would be cool if they could disband and then comeback together under a different label, name, and concept, but they probably won't.
@floresl.1974
Жыл бұрын
Oh my god YG is gonna see this and copy the emotional video script. Why am i so sure it's going to be exactly the same
@chaerryoung_
10 ай бұрын
I LOVE BP and all, but man, come on pls disband already it’s been like 7 years.
@pe4rl__
Жыл бұрын
Blink here, I really believe YG is wasting their talent. From what I’ve heard about their Born Pink concert tour….. eesh.. 😬…
@Velvet62211
Жыл бұрын
YG literally rushed the whole tour and even though the girls should’ve practiced more, YG is their boss. He should’ve made sure they were prepared for a world tour but he just saw this world tour as a chance to profit so he just sent them off immediately. Now the result of being unprepared? A bunch of hate
@pe4rl__
Жыл бұрын
@@Velvet62211 and with BabyMonster coming soon in ‘23 (now delayed debut as of now)
@lucycarlay8547
Жыл бұрын
Honestly I think some dude woke up in sweat at 3 am in the summer and remembered that he forgot that he also manages a girl group.
@Velvet62211
Жыл бұрын
@@lucycarlay8547 deadass 💀
@HailToTheMeep
Жыл бұрын
Their popularity is undisputed. But what impact? Getting people into kpop? This is a serious question I am not being sarcastic or toxic.
@user-yf9nj7eb6z
Жыл бұрын
yeah in 3rd gen everyone is doing a cute concept but after blackpink arrived, the girl crush concept but in a pretty way was popularized. Nobody cared about music video views until they saw blackpink pulling numbers. They broke into the west so effortlessly. Their way of releasing music is exactly what 4th gen are doing. Ive is doing the 2 song per comeback thing. Each member is a global ambassador for luxury brands and notice how idols these days have model gigs too. They had companies wanting to replicate their success (aespa is a carbon copy, wonyoung follows jennies style etc.) Im not hating on these idols, but it will be dumb not to admit that agencies uses blackpink as a vision board for their girlgroups. are basically the blueprint but sadly kpop stans doesn't acknowledge this. They hate blackpink but secretly wants their faves to be like them.
@karinasnooodles_
Жыл бұрын
@@user-yf9nj7eb6z aespa is nowhere similar to BP be serious stop disrespectful my girls like that
@user-bz5mr7kb1i
Жыл бұрын
@@karinasnooodles_SM tried too hard to compete Against Blackpink. Like Even their Coachella outfit carbon copy of Blackpink. Aespa has Broke Blackpink record of album sales but still SM used Ads..why they Don't trust Their million Seller could pull those number?? Funny How MV has 80m views but not even 1m likes..lol Also spicy not even reach 5m in spotify.😂
@annarane8874
Жыл бұрын
The main reason I want them to disband: I want Rose to go solo
@aeshirin
11 ай бұрын
bro i love your channel. plz keep making videos
@wandeesthoughts
Жыл бұрын
I came in here being defensive but you’re not wrong it’s time the girls work more on their solo careers
@lonilocoesque
Жыл бұрын
this is true though 😂 i have same thoughts i think it’s ridiculous that we blame everything to YG because they can do it if they want
@losiloso8178
Жыл бұрын
I am still in denial maybe but I am waiting for what comes after shut down. The MV clearly stated the badaboom era is over so if I am not getting any high quality movie esque MV with actual script and different sound then my journey with them is finally over. Because I really do think not YG but the share holders had a lot to say on their releases up until now. Kpop in essence is a business model, lets be real. And like you said, YG needs BP so with the new contract they can have more freedom. And if they dont do nothing with their freedom then yeah, thats it.
@bpnimri
11 ай бұрын
As a blink who was in total denial this video opened my eyes. I LOVE blackpink, in fact pink venom is the song that got me into blackpink and kpop, but I totaly understand AND AGREE with older blinks. I feel like blackpink could absolutely kill new concepts, like there are MANY amazing concepts in kpop, and I would love to see them explore more. I´M SO SICK OF THE YG SYLE LIKE IT´S NOT 3RD GEN ANYMOREEEE blackpink needs to put out something more fresh or newwwwww Even so, I absolutely love their music, but I want, NEED to see something different from them, I love the girls, they have a lot of talent, they are the biggest gg in the world, and they totally deserve it, but for god´s sake I seriously need them to do something a little different, AND LIKE even tho I fell in love with blackpink bc of pink venom, their early discography is just the absolute best, BLINKS DON´T WANT KILL THIS LOVE 4.0 WE WANT SOMETHING NEWWWW 😟😟😟😟😟 I´m thankful for pink venom and shut down, it´s a blessing to my ears and an unskipable song for me but if you put it next to the rest of their discography, it´s still good, but we all want something a bit new, something that feels refreshing and like yeah, yg isn´t at total fault but honestly I´m so done with yg, I wish they treated blackpink as artists and you know THE BIGGEST GG IN HISTORY instead of money machines, and a name they can slap wherever they want just bc they know that that product will sell out. anyways stan blackpink y´all
@clarysage1298
Жыл бұрын
their title tracks have been on a major decline since ktl imo. judging by how successful their solo work has been, the best way for them to grow now is to grow apart. they've performed at coachella twice, broken records, and thats great, but the only way left for them as a group now is down.
@cherryblossom719
Жыл бұрын
I think it'll be something like what it is with bigbang right now
@seulgislove
Жыл бұрын
3:21 lmfao bro this is literally something close to what jisoo said in the shut down behind the scenes 😭😭
@breakfast_
11 ай бұрын
I love Blackpink but I would also prefer the disband ://
Пікірлер: 893