You hit the nail on the head. When no one individual had all of the power, policies could change in response to changing conditions. With one leader in complete control, policies can only change when he decides to change his mind, and that would require an admission of error and weaken his power. Such leaders will always prioritize keeping their grip on power ahead of the best interests of the population.
@MultiMenvafan
5 сағат бұрын
Absolutely. Xi Jinping thought and the zero Covid disaster is telling.
@bpd9660
5 сағат бұрын
Definition of a tyrant or despot
@trevorgough2286
4 сағат бұрын
Same as Russia,N.Korea..any more?
@apextroll
3 сағат бұрын
That is very true, but what will be common with the west, is that the least squeaky wheel will get the grease, mean the rich people will come first at the bailout trough.
@aaronmicalowe
3 сағат бұрын
Yup, ego often gets in the way, and we all know this from personal experience.
@occamraiser
4 сағат бұрын
Thanks Tony. Another insightful, level headed analysis.
@kateryan9988
5 сағат бұрын
Nice to see the sheep finally waking up. Let's all further help the Chinese out by reducing any Made-in-China purchases whenever humanly possible.
@MultiMenvafan
5 сағат бұрын
Remember they have mischeviously relabeled it "Made in PRC" to confuse us. Avoid as much as you can.
@1111Here
Сағат бұрын
@@kateryan9988 its almost humanely impossible
@andrewpearson5504
5 сағат бұрын
Lest we forget, there are two teams playing in the 'garbage time of history', one the victor who is tossing up three pointers for fun and the other a team that is dribbling the ball off its foot while hoping for the final whistle to stop the pain. I think we can safely say, China's not the wining team in this scenario. Funny that the garbage time of history is syncing with the garbage time of Chinese football as well (Japan 7 China 0, anyone?). Wasn't one of Xi's directives to improve China's national football team? Another lost dream. Garbage time, garbage time everywhere (in China). Meanwhile in America, we've killed inflation and the stock market will, I predict, make another all-time high today.
@Cedartreetechnologies
5 сағат бұрын
Just like 2008. Our own hard times are just kicking off. I am shedding RE to prep.
@elcastorgrande
3 сағат бұрын
@@Cedartreetechnologies The USA certainly needs a further correction, as we have not burned off the COVID stimulus inflation. But a soft landing is possible. Powell is not Volcker (and fortunately. not Bernanke), but he has been right so far.
@henli-rw5dw
2 сағат бұрын
It's actually win-win. US can rejoice that Chinese stock and property not performing well. China can rejoice that inflation is low and their product is competitive.
@jerryrichardson2799
4 сағат бұрын
The financial system becomes more leveraged, what could possibly go wrong? Minxin Pei: I have one of his books. What I like about Pei is he's willing to tell you what he really thinks and as Tony noted he knows China better than most commentators. I think it's important to note that China's progress has _always_ been considerably overhyped and overstated. When people start buying their own baloney is when the real trouble starts.
@christopherholbert1878
5 сағат бұрын
Liked Pei’s opinion peace.
@antonystringfellow5152
41 минут бұрын
It was excellent!
@tonysu8860
5 сағат бұрын
The actions described by Chinese banks such as lowering interest rates in existing loans is wrong because all it does is ease the pain for homeowners and have a negligible effect on new sales. This is only an attempt to mollify homeowners and a very weak attempt to delay a day of reckoning for the real estate marketplace. This will have absolutely zero effect stimulating consumption because it does nothing to inspire confidence in the economy and any wealth creation will go directly to savings. Critically, no economic reform is implemented that benefits small business formation that would generate quick returns in investment, create jobs and consume resources. The CCP must be the most stupid and uneducated collection of ignorant economists ever.
@Kirkrrr
2 сағат бұрын
According to Peter Zeihan, Xi has been very successful in purging the ranks of anyone with competence who could possibly challenge him one day. First in government (first term), then in business (second term), then academia and more recently the military. The order of the day for the past several years is to lay low and do nothing to attract attention. I think that's part of the reason for the incompetence we're repeatedly seeing now.
@patrickpeake3935
5 сағат бұрын
Thanks Tony
@niko-qi1oi
5 сағат бұрын
In terms of high youth unemployment, there is an old saying "When the economy is bad, family are the first ones hired." This is especially true in China
@I4Icculus
4 сағат бұрын
20% of youth not employed is a problem. Young people with time on hand and a bone to pick with Government is a recipe for disaster. Social unrest is coming in China. Idle hands tend to dig up trouble.
@I4Icculus
4 сағат бұрын
20% of youth not employed is a problem. Young people with time on hand and a bone to pick with Government is a recipe for disaster. Social unrest is coming in China. Idle hands tend to dig up trouble.
@kaitoshinichi
4 сағат бұрын
Family are also the first ones to get betrayed and thrown under the bus. Look at the periods during the great leap forward many parents and teachers were reported to officials for being against the party
@danielmcinnes20
2 сағат бұрын
Excellent video as always. Thanks Tony! Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦!!!
@EricSchafer-b1k
5 сағат бұрын
Even if China stimulates internal stimulus, layoffs are surging globally and the world is entering a globally synchronized depression. We are on the front end of this and layoffs are beginning to surge. Western companies are relocating manufacturing again seeking a cheap manufacturing environment. However, years of aggregate income and benifit drain are crossing a critical threshold. The global demmand colaspe will be breath taking. A lot of society disruptions, homelessnes, and hunger is ahead. Xi along with many other myopic economic and political leaders have contributed to this mess.
@thomaskeating7539
5 сағат бұрын
Fascinating that the 'garbage time' signifies waiting miserable times out, until the clock (Xi's rule) runs out.
@MultiMenvafan
5 сағат бұрын
Both Russians and Chinese seems yo have this passive view as if things will sort themselves out. They won't. The people need to drive the change.
@stantheman9072
4 сағат бұрын
@@MultiMenvafan In these political cultures, the cost of driving this sort of change is paid in blood; a lot of it, I would imagine. These are not the places where you take to the streets unless you’re so desperate that total self-sacrifice is the only option. I don’t see broad scale apathy (browbeaten into them) converting to the level of messianic zeal required to replace tyrannical and highly resourceful authoritarians in either state.
@MultiMenvafan
3 сағат бұрын
@@stantheman9072 sure, but then again things can evolve quickly. Take Tiananmen square for instance. And having a youth unemployment of above 20% means there are a lot of intelligent and frustrated people out there yearning for change.
@deborahcurtis1385
3 сағат бұрын
Yes but Xi is the end of a pattern, but he has gone more into control than the reformers. I've been saying to myself since the outbreak of the commodities boom, that "this cannot last". Well when a vast tree is pushed it falls hard. A reed bends with the wind. This is how the situation is. I feel bad for the needless suffering involved. Today I met a woman from Shanghai who was working in the local supermarket in Melbourne, Australia. She flatly and repeatedly denied there were any problems whatsoever in China. She was astounding repeatedly then stating there were not problems in Shanghai she didn't know about the rest of Chinai. I said "well many are leaving China". Clearly. She didn't deny that bit! The over identification of pride and refusal to admit error is pathological, because it prevents change and learning from mistakes.
@stantheman9072
3 сағат бұрын
@@MultiMenvafan I agree, but am skeptical of any sort of social tipping point coming before Xi is gone from the scene…and I don’t see him being moved out by the CCP as his purges have been very extensive and effective. It just seems to me that something quite unexpected (or disastrously stupid) would have to occur. But you are right, I think, in seeing how “a man alone” as Xi is, will have enormous blind spots. A large tree with shallow roots is very stable, until the wind blows from an unnatural direction. Xi reminds me a bit of Gorbachev, but with a greater desire for personal power and less regard for the people he rules. He’s much more an egotist.
@elcastorgrande
3 сағат бұрын
Commentary from Claremont hits the nail on the head. Put your head down and hold on until the bad times pass.
@davidangeron3365
5 сағат бұрын
RESERVE REQUIREMENT. Do not know what the levels are in China. But, remember Reserves additionally provide Liquidity capacity for the Central Bank to intervene and rescue a sick Financial Institution. It appears that China has a Hospital full of Sick Banks, as they reduce the Central Bank reduces its liquidity capacity!!!
@niko-qi1oi
5 сағат бұрын
China has a tier system for RRR, national, regional and local banks. I believe it is roughly 8/5/3%
@henli-rw5dw
2 сағат бұрын
All banks are state owned, so the ratio is just a way to control lending, there is not much systematic risk.
@helloworld9811
2 сағат бұрын
It was now about 7% in real term after the change announced today, you can consider it as 7%
@RodrigoPalma700
5 сағат бұрын
Thanks for sharing.
@raymondszeto4277
5 сағат бұрын
This stimulus package does nothing to help the poor but more of the same to help the rich and corrupt. Does it create more jobs and raise peoples wages?
@pablosskates7067
4 сағат бұрын
Underwhelming stimulus is like only having enough fuel to get 90% of the way up to space - not enough to break through the atmosphere. You either go big or you go home. Otherwise, you’re just wasting precious resources.
@henli-rw5dw
2 сағат бұрын
It's nothing that stockholders will cheer about.
@chuckley99
5 сағат бұрын
Happy Tuesday!
@eddybiaz5677
5 сағат бұрын
thanks
@JamariusJackson-yg5ui
3 сағат бұрын
Lol they went from a century of humiliation to garbage time.
@RandyBrickley
5 сағат бұрын
It will get much worse
@JamesJohnson-gv7tv
5 сағат бұрын
Yuan vs USD: Yuan 7.03 vs USD$1.00 at this exact moment Eastern Daylight Savings Time, Boston, MA, USA
@jerryrichardson2799
4 сағат бұрын
Thanks so much Tony.
@sonsautomotive
5 сағат бұрын
thank you Tony for being unbiased as much as possible.... i know it must be very difficult to read between the lines and come up with data
@i6power30
5 сағат бұрын
Clearly this channel is based AGAINST China.
@jaydee6268
Сағат бұрын
@@i6power30 Clearly? 🤔
@dcc70
5 сағат бұрын
It's "garbage time". Nobody says "trash time"
@Tewhill357
5 сағат бұрын
Not to be confused with 'trash talk'.
@TomTomicMic
4 сағат бұрын
Rubbish time? It all means the same thing so they can!?!
@beckyconstantinides2546
5 сағат бұрын
Thank you for explaining “ garbage time “. I never followed football so I had no reference for the phrase. When property prices fall , the seniors of the population have their most significant asset decline in value .. This ultimately helps the young because buying their first house becomes possible. The young buying houses stimulates the economy because they then buy furnishing and perhaps have children. The young must wait for their purchase of house until the price becomes highly affordable, or they sign up for high debts for an asset falling in value. Real estate declines usually take 5 or 6 years to hit bottom. By then the houses are as cheap as they will get and the interest rates are very low as the government tries to stimulate the economy. Japan is the exception to the rule as their real estate declined for many more years. I know this not from economic theories and beliefs. I know it from watching the cycle play out three times in my life.
@Andy-P
3 сағат бұрын
How is youth unemployment amongst the party members?
@brian13105
4 сағат бұрын
Thank you Tony .
@ryanreedgibson
5 сағат бұрын
OMG, I'm early! I normally see this after 3 hours of posting. Bad part about being on Moutain Time everyone is up before us. I don't even have my coffee yet, wtf am I doing...
@ChadLuciano
5 сағат бұрын
Tony...you need a pine tree storage facility...the pine trees are massive here...another epic segment...makes the coffee taste better.
@martygillespie5486
4 сағат бұрын
Hi Tony … I continue to enjoy your coverage. Good stuff! Differences I see between China’s past economic recoveries and today’s situation is possibly the systemic decline in net worth of the typical citizen, and definitely the juggernaut of demographics. When the population becomes either too old or unwilling to have children, or both in this case, it’s game over.
@TomTomicMic
4 сағат бұрын
Stock market declining (Mostly always was), Property market declining (Never to return), Infrastructure Development has been non productive since 2008 (It doesn't make any money) Savings soaring and pumped into Exports where they really subsidise foreign buyers ( One wonders what will happen when citizens want to take their savings out when they retire in great numbers in 10 years), most of China's money making is failing and the CCP doesn't know what to do about it!?!
@jhwheuer
5 сағат бұрын
Plug those safety valves and increase the temperature, what could possibly happen?
@thomassimmer5186
5 сағат бұрын
The problem (unfinished houses/bankrupt builders/active mortgages) requires the national government paying to finish the houses. This keeps the banks viable, restores purchasing power of owners, and leverages the value of the work that has already been done. What does lowering the interest rates on these loans accomplish?
@luminyam6145
4 сағат бұрын
Thank you.
@colgategilbert8067
3 сағат бұрын
Thanks Tony. Pei has a lot right. The scale of the new 'stimulus' is too small and conservative vs. the scale of the problems.
@patricknicklaus9536
4 сағат бұрын
as always, truly interesting and informative!! thank you!!
@Cedartreetechnologies
5 сағат бұрын
Ugh. Deglobalization long predicted by M. Pettis is here, and it is hungry.
@Tewhill357
5 сағат бұрын
His name is Tony and he's no doubt still on the speaker circuit, trawling the KL, maybe getting a bit saturated on the host's dime. There are worse fates.
@JohnJaneson
3 сағат бұрын
I wager he helped himself to some Nasi Lemak one plate too many.
@Tewhill357
2 сағат бұрын
@@JohnJaneson 100% (Had to the look up the dish. Now I know more. Thanks.)
@blafonovision4342
3 сағат бұрын
The USA really needs to withdraw from the WTO.
@WarH
Сағат бұрын
You’re the funniest thing about the world trade or organization. Any country can step away from it and they really should. China needs to be taught a lesson bigger isn’t always better. And people who live in glass houses shouldn’t throw stones. What goes up will come down.they have a lot of headwind against them and if they keep playing this game, it’s gonna turn out to be a tornado category five
@theomnisthour6400
5 сағат бұрын
Mastery of driving delivery vehicles in China will soon require a PhD
@JohnJaneson
3 сағат бұрын
Soon, farming will require PhD... although that actually sounds productive if the major is agriculture-related.
@89volvowithlazers
5 сағат бұрын
So basically just printing money right
@theodoremccarthy4438
5 сағат бұрын
I genuinely feel bad for the Chinese people. Times are going to be tough for them for a long while.
@1111Here
5 сағат бұрын
Im no fan of China but they have a combined amount of 50,0000 tons of gold when they go public with BRICS on this next month to back their currency unfortunately we outside of BRICS are all cooked. They are playing everyone who dont know this fact who thinks they are sinking.
@jaydee6268
58 минут бұрын
Thank you, Tony. It almost goes without saying that I have liked and shared with those whom I think are worthy. Until next time, be well!
@LewisPulsipher
4 сағат бұрын
Great ending quotes.
@GARRYJackson-q1h
5 сағат бұрын
It’s only an announcement and will not happen
@Toothnut_Hamsterfolder
6 минут бұрын
Great episode! Thank you Tony!
@user-zz8lb6bd7p
5 сағат бұрын
How long will the bounce last? 1 week, 1 month or 1 quarter? The underlying problems are still there
@gregash7683
Сағат бұрын
Garbage Time ends when there is nothing to flush.
@lonihollenbeck4654
2 сағат бұрын
"Garbage time", the phrase may be applied to mankind's presence here on earth. I've been watching the floods happening around the world and I'm shocked by how so much is turned into garbage and sent out to sea. It will return.
@patgus6528
5 сағат бұрын
excellent comparison of Russia,'s recent restructure and China
@bpd9660
4 сағат бұрын
Yep... both run by despots running their countries into the ground, clinging on to power at all costs
@nwjh1957
Сағат бұрын
Thanks for another great episode, Tony. Keep 'em coming! Pei is insightful and very clear in his discussion. He has delineated the problem with precision, but alas, there's no easy solution without a huge shake-up in government and beyond. With all the other economic indicators trending downwards, some faster than others, it's rather surprising that the CCP hasn't considered changing course, but this mob seem far more attached to ideology, when that tends to lead to any group's downfall. The tighter the attachment, the faster the downfall arrives. The one sign of hope is that the Chinese people, at least the ones who can get noticed, seem to be aware of the problem, but they are hamstrung in trying to do anything. The CCP has implemented such extreme monitoring systems, and added the 'spies are everywhere' scare tactics, that everyone has been terrified into making everything worse by simply following what the CCP wants (or at least expresses that it wants). In a more free and open society, a reasonable group of people would tell the government where to stick their policies and work to make things better, but in the kinds of societies that the CCP has implemented, people's best course of action is to make small contributions to destroy the system by doing what we might call 'work to rule.' And as always in these situations, the elites will hop the hutch with their money, and the everyday people will be left behind to suffer in the resulting cesspool.
@ggusta1
14 минут бұрын
Garbage time usually is when either one or both teams put their scrubs in so their stars don't get injured and or the losing/trailing team scores a bunch of points because the defense of the winning team is resting their stars resulting in a final score that appears close but that's just a mirage for how lopsided the blowout actually was. Garbage time is meaningless because the winner, and in China's case, the loser has already been established.
@michaelhenault1444
5 сағат бұрын
Trying to do a Maoist inspired redistribution of financial wealth is a prayerful endeavor. Make it up as you go along and hope for the best.
@TomTomicMic
4 сағат бұрын
Some would call it economic suicide!?!
@andrewpearson5504
5 сағат бұрын
How was KL, Tony? Honestly, I'm not sure there's a better city for food. The best Indian food I ever had was in KL. Yes, even better than Brick Lane!
@kennethjaggers4108
4 сағат бұрын
The trend is that organizations last around 75 years. Look at the USSR. It’s now 75 years for the PRC.
@richarddobosz6174
28 минут бұрын
Excellent thank you compulsory listening
@ranradd
14 минут бұрын
Great report and thanks for the opinion piece. For the CCP, the clock is definitely running out. It will still take a few years. Lets hope the CCP doesn't decide that war will be the best approach to stay in the game.
@zzbeasley
4 сағат бұрын
Thanks Tony for the extensive commentary by Pei on the Garbage time in China. I wonder if he is talking about the China we come to see. Wasn't the housing bubble inflated by animal spirits taking over the decentralized localities and spurred by shadow banks not regulated by the central banks? The trillions wiped out by the crash were illusory price inflations caused by loose lending. On the surface and from the outside Xi centralization seems necessary. The misallocation of highly educated Chinese away from proper regulation seems to be a problem. Here Pei is on target. If the party insists on controlling this reform then why? how will that make sense?
@maggotman2024
5 сағат бұрын
Central banking buying of stocks not a very good sign. The U.S. federal reserve purchased mortgage bonds in the 2008 financial crisis and bought junk bonds (among many other assets) as markets collapsed in March 2020.
@tonysu8860
4 сағат бұрын
I don't know if that statement was clear whether the banks would actually buy property, if that were the case why would interest be lowered for such purchases? I think it's more likely that banks are lowering interest rates to entice those with discretionary wealth to consider buying property. But under the current conditions I'm not sure any enticement could be strong enough to buy property.
@dliu115
2 сағат бұрын
It really is like a theoretical exercise in the application of strategies to fix a systematic problem
@yyaadude
3 сағат бұрын
Idle youth? A historical type of social environment for unrest. The creation of a subculture wouldn’t be surprising.
@Fish_Ventura
3 сағат бұрын
Thank you Tony
@seanstansbury5585
2 сағат бұрын
Thanks
@binbadende
3 сағат бұрын
Whenever parts of a struggeling system advise that other parts of the system should give up at least part of their priviledges, intellectually funny times have arrived. Unfortunatly this is always on the shoulders of the majority of people who have no say in the development, which for me largely takes away from the fun to watch the downfall.
@markbernier8434
3 сағат бұрын
Not Garbage time but sudden death overtime play. Only one player has to make one decisive move to win.
@goatwatch5375
5 сағат бұрын
Yay
@sofjanmustopoh7232
4 сағат бұрын
So eat bitter doesn’t work . Let’s go back to building more airport , road and fast train 😄
@bjarkih1977
4 сағат бұрын
Maybe they should make a deal with Russia enabling out of work people to go to Russia to work? After all there's a shortage of workers there.
@RoyADane
4 сағат бұрын
The only problem with sending Chinese workers to Russia is that Putin would probably send the "workers" to Kursk or Ukraine....
@gtw4546
2 сағат бұрын
Reducing the reserve requirements might actually work - after all, the less the likelihood of getting your deposits back, the more you might actually spend the money while you have some!
@stephenhall4115
3 сағат бұрын
Thanks.
@ggusta1
22 минут бұрын
You can't just keep throwing money at stuff hoping your problems go away. You actually need to solve the real problems.
@ohadsnir6194
9 минут бұрын
Why headlines must be reversed to positive from now and on before losing leadership!
@Ash-vt5cp
4 сағат бұрын
"Thanks for the pizza Doctor Wang!"
@h4nkx
5 сағат бұрын
When you get a mastrr degree and have to work in an over saturate food delivery job. its means the things are really screwed up. I feel bad for the civiliand they got trap in the commuilnist lies
@anv_bis7287
Сағат бұрын
Funny how China criticized the west for doing this and now they have to do the exact same 😂
@trevorgough2286
3 сағат бұрын
As far as I can see, most commentators are still claiming the Chinese economy is still growing, but at a slower rate of about 4 to 5%. Does anyone agree with me that it's surely shrinking,or am I missing something?
@JohnJaneson
3 сағат бұрын
I predict they will say that they bend the definition of GDP by manicuring the exact composition of the figures. This is doable. We can massively alter GDP by choosing and picking the exact data set.
@EduardQualls
3 сағат бұрын
道 IMHO, Pei was too complementary. He assumes that the moves the CCP made were from informed action, rather than, as it appears now, just situational luck. Marxism is just too inflexible to operate successfully in any post-1890, post-steam age, post-industrial economy. 道 It seems no one in the Party understood the importance of the tutoring industry in its role as soft-landing, talent-supplying reservoir within the CCP economy. It soaked up otherwise unhired, new grads and trickled them out into the wider economy as needed. Now, that trickle is a high flood and (just like with real, storm-flood-disasters) the CCP has no solution for it. 道 With more graduate students than undergrads, on top of insurmountable unemployment at all education levels, Red China appears set on turning itself into a nation of PhD-peasants. The fact is that bachelor's and master's degrees are for general employment; PhD's are only for academia (not general employment), specifically for those teaching bachelor's and master's degree students.
@dm9078
5 сағат бұрын
Thanks Tony. Does anyone know where I can find Professor Pei’s piece?
@recondax
4 сағат бұрын
You may want to check out the description as Tony will post links there.
@ohadsnir6194
5 сағат бұрын
Why another bad headline when HSI skyrockets today? Seriously asking this time
@doltsbane
4 сағат бұрын
Institute Maoist policies, win Maoist prizes.
@kimiyounasarukun
5 сағат бұрын
Engagement for the engagement god, likes for the like throne.
@itrytobeanonymoustoo5289
5 сағат бұрын
First
@DanielVache-nm1kq
5 сағат бұрын
Tony, do you use natural gas for cooking where you live? That could be what is making you sick. You may have poor ventaltion.
@louisgiokas2206
2 сағат бұрын
The comments about the stock market all miss the mark. They show a lack of understanding of how markets work. The large traders, the ones who can actually move markets, are almost all opportunists. I do not say this in a disparaging way. That is the way they make money. Specifically, in this situation, these traders see that there are moves by the government which will draw in fresh money. They don't care about the fundamentals of the economy nor the efficacy of the new policies. They are all about movement. Just watch. Nothing has changed, fundamentally. As soon as people realize this, they will dump the stocks. Frankly, the index shown is still way, way down from its peak. Stock prices are time series. Making any pronouncement from a single measurement is not valid.
@StratificationSmith
2 сағат бұрын
👍
@christopherholbert1878
4 сағат бұрын
Tony is there any credibility to the economist zhu hengpeng story
@justin4fun06
2 сағат бұрын
I love the fact that the CCP’s outlook is gloomy
@michaelgothenburg364
2 сағат бұрын
So do quite a few well educated Chinese I talk to daily. They are unfortunately just resigning and no action, not even talking except with non Chinese. That's how they have been taught and that's the way it will remain for a long time. Not happening soon, it'll be many many years
@patbyrneme007
2 сағат бұрын
Amidst the overwhelmingly negative coverage of China provided by this channel, I guess it was too much to expect that it might have reported the new upward revision in the International Monetary Fund's forecast for China's economy. After visiting China, the IMF's team are now predicting that China's GDP for 2024 will grow by 5%, in line with China's own planning body. Moreover, the IMF's team have increased its GDP forecast for China in 2025 to 4.6%. Meanwhile, it looks increasingly likely that the United States is heading into a severe recession towards the end of this year. If so this will inevitably drag Europe and Japan, both of which are currently stagnating, into negative economic territory. In such circumstances China's 5% growth rate may well appear pretty good. As they say, "everything is in the context". Unfortunately, this channel rarely ever makes comparisons with the West and thus comes across as very one-sided to anyone who isn't committed to regime change in China.
@PeterLynch-x2l
5 сағат бұрын
The zest and motivation to show the bad side of China is superb. 😂
@JohnJaneson
5 сағат бұрын
The zest and motivation to badmouth this channel is superb. This is a NEUTRAL channel, and you keep attacking it. Anti-China channels are the likes of China Uncensored, David Zhang, Lei's real talk, The China Show with laowhy86 and serpentza. Those are anti-China. Not this channel. This channel is neutral. You keep badmouthing this NEUTRAL channel. Do you want this channel to turn and become fully anti-China like the other channels? is that your goal? To add more opposition against China?
@jamesdallas1493
4 сағат бұрын
Peter, tell us the good side.
@jerryrichardson2799
4 сағат бұрын
Yeah start your own channel.
@rainieresguerra6519
5 сағат бұрын
First? 🤯
@jaydee6268
Сағат бұрын
Close, but it seems not.
@PeteKiefer
4 сағат бұрын
Most important analysis yet. At 8:50 you cover “garbage time of history”, a phrase used by the common man in China to describe this chapter of Xi’s leadership. In summary the people on the street see that the CCP’s problems are terminal. The game is over AND THEY KNOW IT. This is big. Thanks. Well done. Pete
@saraseale2364
22 секунд бұрын
Tony, thank you. Best wishes from Ottawa.🦫
@hooplawithbilliesue8143
5 сағат бұрын
Thanks Tony
@danielmcinnes20
2 сағат бұрын
Excellent video as always. Thanks Tony! Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦!!!
@djparn007
3 сағат бұрын
Thank you, Tony 👍
@robertrubin522
2 сағат бұрын
Thanks!
@danielmcinnes20
2 сағат бұрын
Excellent video as always. Thanks Tony! Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦!!!
Пікірлер: 203