Someone asked, how do you explain Shu^bah recited different to ^Asim yet had the same teacher. They gave the following example. I didn’t have an answer.
^Asim learned several ways of reciting the Qur'an from the followers of the Companions. He chose from those elements to teach to Hafs, and other elements to Shu^bah.
All the 10 recitors learned the various recitations, some more than others and selected for their (two) narrators (students) different ways of recitations, all of which are mutawatir.
For example, if I taught you some hadiths from al-Bukhariyy and taught your friend the same hadiths from at-Tirmidhiyy where the wording is different but the meaning/subject is the same or complementary.
Негізгі бет WHY DOES HAFS' AND SHUBAH'S RECITATION DIFFER DESPITE THEM LEARNING FROM ASIM? Quranic Recitations.
Пікірлер