So I don't have to spend more energy on this than is necessary, I've summarised the main reasons I reject Hadith in one place so I can concentrate on more interesting subjects.
00:24 Hadith, a large body of hearsay.
00:39 Hadith, written down 100-200 years after the revelation of the Qur’an.
00:41 Hadith, part of the faith of Sunni Islam.
00:51 Qur’an claims to be complete and perfect.
01:00 Sunni Islam claims the need for something else or, instead of.
01:10 The religion of Islam is based entirely on Hadith.
01:26 The corpus of Sunni Islam rests on 5 so called pillars.
01:35 Nowhere does the Qur’an mention any pillar as related to a religion.
01:42 It (pillars) comes from Hadith.
01:49 The initiation (or declaration) known as the shahada is found nowhere in the Qur’an.
02:18 The basis for this religion called Islam, is the Hadith literature.
02:36 They pore over it (Qur’an), but not to understand it.
02:55 They believe it (Qur’an) could only be understood by referencing the Hadith literature.
03:15 Why I don’t believe in this ‘library of stuff’.
1) the Qur’an itself claims to be from God,
2) the Qur’an claims to be complete.
- if true, no good reason to follow anything else.
- if not true, no good reason to follow Qur’an.
03:39 Not interested in a cultural narrative called Islam.
04:00 Only interested in the truth (in this life, and the life to come).
04:11 Read the Qur’an and realized that it is perfect, it is true, and it is from God.
04:15 Only rejected the religion called Islam, after thorough investigation.
04:30 Why? Because It is nonsense.
05:21 The compilers of Hadiths were all Persian.
06:00 They regarded the Arabs as inferior.
06:27 They had mastered the art of real politic.
06:52 What changed? A revelation from God (Qur’an) had disciplined the Arabs.
07:02 How do you attack that? Corrupt the text if you can, not possible.
07:28 What they did was co-opt (divert), like what Paul did with Christianity.
07:46 Own it and you lead it where you want it to go, using leverage.
08:14 Not accepting the Hadiths, is equated with disregard of prophet Muhammad (the intended leverage).
8:34 I have done my homework.
08:46 By definition it’s hearsay (Hadith), to them it’s acceptable.
09:48 We’re expected to entrust our eternal souls to this literature, I won’t do it.
10:00 The Jews made the same mistake.
11:17 If it is not the evidence, we reject it.
11:43 The different bodies of Hadiths (Shi’a and Sunni).
12:24 Character of Muhammad in Qur’an vs. Hadith (completely different).
12:39 In the Hadiths, Muhammad has (all) the answers.
12:55 In the Qur’an, it’s a completely different narrative.
13:12 If you want people to become passive you need a saviour. Nowhere in the Qur’an is there mention of a Mahdi.
13:40 Limited number of laws in the Qur’an.
13:55 Wrong to make haram (illegal), what God does not make haram (illegal).
14:55 Example where the Qur’an is at complete odds with the Hadiths.
- Qur’an written down by faithful scribes on pure pages (paper), a book protected.
- Hadith allows doubt (burning books, verses questioned).
15:48 Brand Islam requires you to have both (Hadith and Qur’an).
16:21 You’re forced into cognitive dissonance (accepting conflicting narratives).
16:43 Commonalities between Islam and Western democracy (doublethink).
17:40 Muslims who cites small parts of the Qur’an completely out of context. (Eg. what the messenger gives you take, what he forbids you, leave.)
18:39 In the Qur’an, it’s God who guides, and the Qur’an (God’s word) is guidance.
18:59 You should warn with this Qur’an.
19:33 He (Muhammad) would say on the Day of Judgment, they have abandoned it.
19:56 When was the last time you tried (understanding the Qur’an on its own merits)?
20:20 They are following in their father’s footsteps.
21:10 What has the Religion of Islam achieved in the last 1000 years?
21:33 There are decent people who believe all kinds of things, it doesn’t mean what they believe in is correct.
22:05 The Qur’an does not describe a religion called Islam.
22:46 Don’t care if I’m the only person in the world that doesn’t accept it.
22:50 It’s foolishness, and obvious foolishness, because it detracts from the book of God.
23:16 It’s a tragedy.
[Thanks to Azim Zahur for time codes]
SAM GERRANS: quranite.com/a...
THE QUR'AN: A COMPLETE REVELATION: quranite.com/t...
THE GOD PROTOCOL: quranite.com/t...
QUR'AN TRANSLATION AUDIO: quranite.com/a...
ONLINE QUR'AN READER: reader.quranit...
KZitem AS PODCASTS: itunes.apple.c...
PODCAST SERVER: www.quranitecas...
PAPER BOOKS FOR 10% LESS THAN ON AMAZON: www.quranite.c...
HELP ME TO KEEP DOING THIS: www.quranite.c...
FIND OTHER QUR'AN-ALONE MUSLIMS: www.meetqurani...
WORK IN SUMMARY: • Sam Gerrans And The Go...
quranite.com | warningtotheelite.org
Негізгі бет Why I Reject Hadith
Пікірлер