完全知道有很多人替 Rock 不值,當然十分理解,尤其被他深深感動的觀眾。我也有被感動。但始終比賽要分輸贏,否則不分也罷了,因為各自也閃亮了,值得為兩為驕傲!有一點關於Gigi的未必每位都能馬上感受到,所以作為專業評委之一的我要嘗試解釋一下,就是她的natural talent. 這是後天幾乎冇得學的東西,所以她是十年難得一遇的。她處理big band 版愛情陷阱,完全用了她獨有的個人character ,music sense和創意去演繹,是很高曾次的表演,一般觀眾不明白也理解。畢竟這種曲風不是太普及。但我相信聲夢十強裡,暫時只有她一人能真正駕御到這個版本的「愛情陷阱」,又變了一首全新歌咁聽。是商業和藝術的結合。片中忘了提及她的 scat, (ba la be li 嗰段), 處理得很好,也是加分位。懂欣賞的就懂。她的音樂感非常之強。近年少見。所以她再次帶給驚喜給觀眾的時候,我相信因此多數評判還是開了籃燈。我只是想說千萬不要因為這樣便覺得Rock 的成功演出被否定。這只是一個賽果,Rock 除了抵讚便是要讚
Is it just me.... the unique thing I found about Gigi’s performances episode after episode is that I don’t get tired of her voice. I can keep listening to her songs. Her voice is powerful but not overpowering
@kawaicho1
3 жыл бұрын
Yup, completely agree and I can't say that about the other contestants at all. I think like 張老師 said, her variation is fun to watch.... Chantel is just too sweet for me.
@xernawumi458wul3
3 жыл бұрын
@@kawaicho1 "Chantel is just too sweet for me" Cant agree more. Chantell is also so talented. But I love Gigi more . I could keep listening to Gigi's voice in the same song and not getting tired. Gigi is so smart in playing around chestvoice and headvoice all the way through her singing, and her voice is just amazing.
I completely agree Gigi can be a superstar not just singing even in the whole HK entertainment business same as Anita Mui that Gigi can also achieve the best actress with her talents and deep emotional expression who just only 16 years old but deliver the feelings, hurts and experiences like a 40+ aged mature adult naturally
在現場評判的評價,似乎很分化,confusing,難怪Gigi 當場喊爆。當時我覺得Gigi贏,是因為她的觀眾緣。聽了你的分析,才知道Gigi 贏是靠她的實力。 好開心。。Gigi and Rock 的比賽 不是蘋果與蘋果比, 而是蘋果跟柑比。 多謝你的詳盡的分析。very educational。
@user-fj7hv4hq1j
2 жыл бұрын
GiGi的《愛情陷阱》KZitem視頻把趙增熹及Eric Kwok批評「咬字不準」的評語刪去了。其實從來都不會懷疑趙增熹及Eric Kwok兩位作為資深音樂人的能力,但憑他倆在樂檀的經驗及見識,對炎明熹GiGi這首《愛情陷阱》的評語,卻令我非常失望!整首歌中唯一所謂"咬字不準"的便是「…太糊塗」的"太"字,其實他倆是否忽略了她這首歌的曲風是Big Bang + Jazz + swing?另外「太糊塗」前後出現了三次,而每一次GiGi都把「太」唱成「帶」,她真的如此低B連「太」字的正確發音都不懂?還是她在Jazz風中刻意調皮玩音?如果他倆批評玩得過份,乃個人喜惡,無可厚非,但竟然批評是「咬字不準」,甚至如聽似泰文,是否有點令人啼笑皆非! 一向高傲、目中無人的趙增熹有這失誤,還可理解,但連Eric Kwok也察覺不到,真教我莫名其妙!有一點值得安慰的,就是GiGi在演唱會上重唱的版本仍然緊持「玩嘢」,並沒有受到影響。👍👏😝
聽完你講我真係開心晒~ 完全講晒我心入面嘅諗法,由聽到Gigi 唱「守望麥田」「紅玫瑰」開始,我終於見到香港樂壇有希望喇!A Star is Born!!! 咩曲風都唱到,潛能無限,我覺得呢個火星人目前只係開發咗50%,過多兩年真係不得了!就算佢依家開演唱會,全部唱人哋嘅歌,我都已經會比錢睇,因為佢可以將人哋嘅歌唱到變自己隻歌,仲要係勁好聽!
我細過已經跟爸爸媽媽聽張國榮同陳柏强,除了原唱者無懈可擊之外,Rock係於云云重唱者之中最能感動到人跟著同哭同涙,但凡情歌就要攞聽眾共鳴,你失戀你結婚就是情歌,感動人心就係成功,聽到二十幾年後的動人版本,不只在場,連看住電視的也被感動,Rock well done! You deserved to be winner!
so agree with your analysis of Gigi's performance! she is on a whole new level and her talent is consistently mindblowing! the way she sings and emanates so much passion and feeling in her words and movements is amazing! it's not even right to compare her with the other contestants as they are still in the competing mentality while Gigi is already performing like a superstar! truly hope that she will have the opportunities she needs to continue to thrive, grow, and shine as a HK singer!
@chithi8649
3 жыл бұрын
I agree, she is a runaway winner here, there's a distinct difference between their arsenal of weapons available at their disposal. You may got it but you also have to be able to successfully implement it and bring out that wow factor. You can tell when someone does things so effortlessly, at least from the audience POV, and something that comes from within versus someone who just is targeting to simply complete what needs to be done. Some people are just naturals, you gotta be born with it, that's what differentiates singers from superstars.
@leepohkim7200
3 жыл бұрын
Gigi is a girl with alot of personality,i very like gigi .the singing very nice and the voice also.👧
@sauyungwan9004
3 жыл бұрын
gigi表現十分精彩,好正好正好正👍👍👍👍👍,每次好期待gigi既演出🥰
@kityinglikolb
3 жыл бұрын
Broadway... Broadway... Broadway!! Broadway in Hong Kong..... Vision! 音樂老師們,,亜洲百老滙在香港! 好感動的-個演藝比賽!感謝整個團隊的努力!可見娛樂企樂,帶來的影嚮!支持年青人,多嘗試,多参與, ,,!🎉🎉🎉🤩🤩
Clayton, thank-you so much for this review and for the constructive criticism you provide to each of the contestant. Your sir, are a master of music and you contribution to Hong Kong's music industry is truly indispensable, thank-you.
Пікірлер: 892