Hayden christiansans delivery is awful as well as the lines. A more charismatic actor might have got away with the sand line. Perhaps alittle wink and a cheeky smile. Would have changed it all.
@ronm931
Ай бұрын
"I hate sand"
@thehdtv7552
2 ай бұрын
more bullshit hate towards George. You fail to remember that the actors say the dialogue won't work but that it did. Harrison Ford will admit it works.
@grathem9789
Ай бұрын
most of the dialogue was improvised by Ford.
@jeremielebrun3637
3 ай бұрын
SHIT! OB1 IS BALD !?!
@4dojo
3 ай бұрын
Even when the prequels were being bashed by everyone I always enjoyed both the prequels and the original trilogy. Now that the sequels have come out I think that more people are starting to appreciate the prequels by comparison.
@brandonelizondo7018
4 ай бұрын
Also, pretty good Harrison Ford/Haan Solo impersonation by Mr. Hamil.
@davidmcfaul7595
4 ай бұрын
6:26 the most profane Alex guiness has ever been
@krkid24
4 ай бұрын
That scene with Hayden and Portman, I remember seeing it and felt soo cringe and forced. I bet they felt the same way. We were all natalie Portman. Even Hayden
@krkid24
4 ай бұрын
Too much lore when the lore wasn't established. But only in George's mind
@Jack-zz7bc
5 ай бұрын
Star Wars exists roughly on a bell curve with George Lucas influence on the x axis and quality on the y axis.
@hyacinthlynch843
6 ай бұрын
George never did get over the clunky dialogue.
@Snagprophet
6 ай бұрын
Alex Guinness got $17 million dollars for the movie which has made $775 million. Not sure how that works for inflation to nowadays but Robert Downey Jr was getting $50 million for his Avengers appearances. Edit: according to an inflation calculator $17 million in 1977 is $64,407,557.76 in 2012.
@Grivian
6 ай бұрын
So many people hate on the dialogue of Star Wars, yet everyone remember all the lines.
@ursidae97
7 ай бұрын
Bro Mark Hamill is just too fucking funny
@GrandFunker
7 ай бұрын
Poor George. The abuse he suffers 😂😂
@cybersecurity7466
7 ай бұрын
George Lucas can't write a greeting card and he can't direct traffic
@pikkyeaterz
8 ай бұрын
this is such a retarded take. "George Lucas wrote all of Star Wars but Mark Hamill asked for one line to be removed, so who's the real genius." I personally feel that the Death Star defense line should've been kept in the movie; it serves as useful exposition and clever foreshadowing.
@shinji136
8 ай бұрын
No one talks like that. The point of dialogue is not just to give information to the audience, if that's all you care about then have a narrator say it. Dialogue is meant to be character expression first and foremost, and unnatural speech detracts from that, while also treating the audience like they're stupid.
@pikkyeaterz
8 ай бұрын
@@shinji136 if you know anything about Star Wars and it's many design philosophies, you'd know that they movies are supposed to work as silent films and that therefore most of the dialogue is redundant. This linear and dogmatic view of dialogue is inherently anti-art and contrary to what all of movie history and cinema as a science tells us.
@shinji136
8 ай бұрын
@@pikkyeaterz Making up stuff doesn't make your nonsense position any more valid. Star Wars is not meant to be or work as a silent film, if that was the case it would have been made as one, and it wasn't. It's not anti-art or anti-cinema to want dialogue to serve its purpose, just how it's not anti-art or anti-cinema to want good acting instead of bad acting. Though the fact you try to flip things over to the contrary only shows how indefensible your position is. Movie history and cinema as a science show that good dialogue, just like good acting, is a benefit if not outright necessary to reaching the proper emotional resonance art is supposed to have at its peak. Bad dialogue does the opposite, no matter how much you want to bend over backward due to your ignorance and anti-intellectualism.
@pikkyeaterz
8 ай бұрын
@@shinji136 kzitem.info/news/bejne/sIN4v3iOm52XZqg "Star Wars movies are basically silent movies and they're designed as silent movies." The issue that I'm trying to point out is that your definition of "good dialogue" adheres mostly to the ideals of KZitem critics who generally don't know anything about cinema (Chris Stuckman types, for example). The idea that realism is at all inherently conducive to quality is absurd and based in zero historical precedent. George Lucas designed his dialogue very intentionally; it's stylistic. You don't have to do the research to find out why exactly he chose to make his movies the way that he made them, but assuming that just because you don't understand Lucas's decision he must have been mistaken is not a very honest way to engage with art. The truth is that almost all art, especially cinema, makes it's impression by being unrealistic in a way that is believable. Every George Lucas movie, from THX to American Graffiti, has this signature eccentricity. It's this eccentricity that makes things like Star Wars so endearing to an open-minded audience. It's part of why the original trilogy did so well and why all of Star Wars engages every demographic.
@grathem9789
Ай бұрын
@@pikkyeaterz george himself admitted his dialogue is a sound effect and is the "king of wooden dialogue"
@theotheraccount
9 ай бұрын
The prequel dialogue feels like a really bad anime dub, with a script so literal it often loses the actual meaning of what's being said, line delivery that's cheesy at best, and overall feels like all the emotion and logic of the script is lost in translation. I don't know how George managed to write a film in native English that sounds like a bad translation from Japanese, but here we are.
@Lanwarder
11 ай бұрын
2:44 George looks like he's about to cry for real. Seriously, I love Lucas' imagination. I can't rank Star Wars on a favorite movies list because its just so unique. I love cinema, and there are countless different genres, but Star Wars is its own thing. My godfather and I always shared a love for music and movies (we both made a living writing music at one point or another....he did it far longer than I did, but I still have time to get back on that horse lol :p) and we mostly love the same kind of movies...but he doesn't get Star Wars at all (I'm still 90% sure that he didn't even gave the entire original trilogy a shot.....he was kind of the 70/80s version of a hipster so the idea of giving blockbusters a shot always seemed to annoy him....too cool for that he probably thought at first lol.) What I've been telling him since at least the age of 10 is that you shouldn't look at Star Wars as a bunch of traditional movies......It's a freaking universe, and when you allow yourself to get sucked into that universe then, and only then, can you truly appreciate that masterpiece for what it is. Unfortunately, in my very personal opinion, Lucas was too much of a big shot when he made the prequels. You watch documentaries and various making of and you hear George come up with obviously terrible ideas (for instance how Jar Jar Binks was the key to make the prequels good....nothing against Ahmed Best, so glad to see him back in SW playing another character) and you just know that people surrounding Lucas have to know how wrong he is.....but he's such a big shot that he's only surrounded by yes men, and the movies suffer because of it. Had someone like Mark Hamill, Marcia Lucas, or Alec Guinness been around to tell Lucas the truth, the prequels would have been better IMHO. I don't know if Spielberg, De Palma, Scorsese watched the first cut of the prequels and had the chance to offer equally brutal but constructive criticisms, but I have a hard time believing it to be the case. I do love Star Wars, I truly do...I don't necessarily am a fan of how they make mistakes or create inconsistencies in the movies and then spend a decade writing books, comic books, video games, cartoon and series to somehow explain what failed to make sense in the movies alone lol, but in a way, it is kinda part of the fun. On a more negative note, I don't know who told Lucas that he was good at writing romance arcs, but between "ohhhh the pain, you are in my very soul", "let's go rodeo picnic" and "let me make apple fly" it seriously took me years not to fall asleep in front of episode 2...and I never fall asleep watching a movie. Incredibly long story short, Lucas has an amazing imagination, but he's at his best when surrounded by people capable of telling him "Hey, this does not work, it just isn't good"....and it's normal. The most talented people have the intelligence of surrounding by people who are better than they are in various specific areas. That's what leadership is all about. To be clear, I don't entirely blame Lucas himself at all for that...I think that he has accomplished so much that way too many people shied away from bringing constructive criticism.....And when you work on a movie of such epic proportion, you probably don't want to risk your paycheck and your name in the credits considering how many doors it will most likely open for your career.
@SusieUndertale
11 ай бұрын
You can tell Mark was SO excited about this being his potentially breakout role, and he put every ounce of his energy into it and it paid off for him
@High_Priest_Jonko
11 ай бұрын
At 0:28 he says he never really thought about it becoming a success or not -- his breakout role -- he just really enjoyed it and was having fun
@Mr.ChrisSchneider101
11 ай бұрын
1:34 Considering what happened to Jake Lloyd, let's just say Mark was absolutely right there.
@charliemoody7168
Жыл бұрын
To be HONEST, *nothing* saved the dialogue in ANY of the Star Wars movies (and I say that as one who saw very film *on* opening day). Lucas is a good filmmaker but he is tone-deaf where dialogue is concerned: he simply has no talent for it. It was part of the corny charm of the original…the sequels (and the fandom) take themselves FAR too seriously
@Jealod24
Жыл бұрын
And then no one stood up to him on the prequels. His wife saved a new hope in the edit and kasdan saved empire in the rewrites and directing, and the actors refused to say his shitty dialogue. Poor sequels
@GamesWithBrainz
Жыл бұрын
marks harrison impression got much better in more recent years lmao
@jordanolson11
Жыл бұрын
rich retards with so much power, throwing it away with stupid trash like starwars, creating a whole generation of de-evolved trog subspecies of human.
@shinji136
8 ай бұрын
You should be thankful for them creating you, then.
@MatiusLenin
Жыл бұрын
9:01 What is the name of that music?
@luskita1197
Жыл бұрын
5:24 That simple decision granted the galaxy with one of the best characters in fiction
@milolowly1744
Жыл бұрын
The fandom didn't ruin Jake Loyds childhood his parents did
@ER1CwC
Жыл бұрын
That line is emblematic of a deeper problem with Lucas: he can’t tell which details are important to the storytelling, and which details are not. JK Rowling has the exact same problem. Both would be better off writing encyclopedias than writing dialogue.
@andrewmorke
Жыл бұрын
Alec Guiness is classy.
@aidanlynn
Жыл бұрын
The thing is, if you were serious about making a science fiction story set in a different world/universe, the dialogue and language would be completely different to what we know.
@shinji136
8 ай бұрын
That would only be the case if realism was the point of fiction, but it isn't. By your pseudo-logic they shouldn't be talking in English or in any known language, and the movie's production should be spent inventing a whole new language that could only develop far away into space. Dogshit take.
@JohnSmith-pn4it
Жыл бұрын
Luke Skywalker is gay now...as Disney has so decided.
@ArdaSReal
Жыл бұрын
The dialogue in the prequels is EXCACTLY what is was supposed to be. it its the most quotable piece of media ever created and sticks in everyones minds, many are blind to its aim but it still actives it
@ImVeryOriginal
9 ай бұрын
It's the most quoteable piece of media ever created right after "The Room".
@jasperfox6821
Жыл бұрын
Heh, George has never been perfect at dialogue, I think the prequals show that, but its really always been about the world building, and the visuals, George has always been on top when it comes to stuff like that, its always cutting edge, the stories of these films, and the world, always drew you in, hell, even the politics of the prequals, mimic our own world. I love all six movies, I grew up will them, and they'll always have a place in my heart. It's why I feel so upset about how Disney did the sequels....yeah it was amazing watching starwars in the cinema again...but they didn't have that same magic the six George Lucus movies did.
@ianrastoski3346
Жыл бұрын
Natalie Portman: excuse me, George, but I have some questions about the dialogue. There's a lot of talk about taxa- Lucas: You are on this council, but we do not grant you the rank of Master.
@countryman032
Жыл бұрын
I don't think any franchise has an actor who has been as good and faithful an ambassador as Mark Hamill has been for Star Wars for the last 40 some years.
@vsavoldi
Жыл бұрын
Nice mix, thx to the editor that put this together.
@davidgodley521
Жыл бұрын
It's just simply amazing how Fat he got since then!
@Kitmaker
Жыл бұрын
Several of the premises in this "the cast changed the dialogue" is completely wrong. Did they change a few lines. Yes. Did the early scripts have awful dialogue? Most definitely. But the later scripts had been redone to basically be the dialogue we hear in the film. Even the scene Mark Hamill is talking about WAS shot with something like that dialogue, but as Lucas said it was left on the cutting room floor.
@TheBusbyBabes
Жыл бұрын
the thing at the very beginning is what the prequels lacked and what made them so bad in the eye of the many when they actually werent
@CloneScavengerVulpin8389
Жыл бұрын
Mark hamill was impressed that the prequels had their own identity.
@super88cloud
Жыл бұрын
4 23
@seanchukwuezi3079
Жыл бұрын
Thank god geroge lucas let the actors improvise their lines it really saved the first movie imagine if empire strikes back and return of the jedi were directed and written by him .
@jzq1740
Жыл бұрын
george looks like hes about to cry every time his dialouge gets brought up, i just wanna hand him a get well soon cake
@mustardsauce5201
Жыл бұрын
ok sure maybe the prequals couldve been a little better but like episode 2 is a gem and we all know it.
@mustardsauce5201
Жыл бұрын
ok but alecs american accent is quite awful
@aguy9893
Жыл бұрын
I love how Lucas looks like "I tried :("
@brennonguilbeau569
Жыл бұрын
Just thank George Lucas that he made you rich for a lifetime!
@DinoJake
Жыл бұрын
Now we know why the dialogue in the Prequel Trilogy sucked so bad. It was because the OG Cast weren't there to proofread the script.
@terrapanda
Жыл бұрын
Fear is their only defense. Fear AND surprise... Their TWO defenses.... are Fear, Surprise ..... and Ruthless Efficiency! Their THREE defenses....
Пікірлер