For more info on this topic, refer to 1:15:02 - 1:41:40 of this video. • SHOCKING: Disturbing D...
Here are the points in this video:
Allah says tells the muslims to give the disbelievers shelter until they hear the speech of Allah, سمع in Arabic means to hear sounds, so Allah speaks with sound.
There’s a hadith in Bukhari where Allah calls out to Adam with sound, this hadith explicitly describes Allah’s speech as having sound. Also nida is understood by consensus of the Arabs to mean communicating with sound.
Kalam in Arabic is understood to mean sound and words by consensus of those with a sound intellect according to Imam Abu Nasr Al Sijzee.
Zakariya was told that he wasn’t allowed to speak to the people for three days, and that he was only allowed to do hand gestures and signals. This refutes the ashari idea of kalam being inside of you that doesn’t come out of you, as well as it proving that Kalam means communication with sound and words as that’s what Zakariya wasn’t allowed to do. We’re not saying that our speech is like Allah’s speech, this is just to prove the definition of kalam.
Imam Ahmad said that Allah speaks with sound, Imam Al Bukhari also said the same thing in his Khalq Af’aal Al Ibaad.
Abu Nasr Al Sijzee (Died 444H) wrote a book called الرد على من أنكر الحرف والصوت where he refutes those who deny that Allah speaks with sound and words, you can refer there for further information.
Негізгі бет Ashari Makes Huge Blunder When Debating Dawah Man - Does Allah Speak With Sound?
Пікірлер: 57