What did you think of this latest episode? Let me know below! ⬇⬇⬇
@michaelwallace2487
2 жыл бұрын
Okay. I just rewatched Amok Time. By the way, great episode. Nowhere in this story does it say Spock and T'Pring had not met since childhood. T'Pring does say that she did not want to be married to a legend, but that does not mean they never met. Actually, since Pon Far happens every seven years, and Spock would therefore have the natural biological urge to return to Vulcan, and several times, in seven year increments, it makes more since that they did indeed meet. Therefore, in this area, canon is not violated. So, you are incorrect in your statement.
@treklad
2 жыл бұрын
Perhaps it's not stated explicitly, but Spock is seen looking at a photo of T'Pring as a child, a strong indication that the only recollection he has of her is this moment. Another strong indicator is Spock and T'Pring's greeting "parted from me and never parted", which doesn't seem to account for nice dinner dates. Glad you took the time to watch Amok Time though. It's always a good watch!
@michaelwallace2487
2 жыл бұрын
@@treklad That’s pretty weak. There could be dozens of reasons why Spock pulled up that particular photo, from him being nostalgic to remembering the first time he actually met her to us as viewers seeing him scanning through many photos, and as a viewer catching him looking at that particular photo! Come on man, you were just wrong. It’s okay. No one’s perfect. To me as long as a story doesn’t directly contradict that which has gone before, I don’t judge it as a violation. Why handicap, or judge writers when you don’t have to?
@LoneBrowncoat
2 жыл бұрын
@@michaelwallace2487 .........It is not out of line with many Terran cultures where parents on both sides bargain or form deals within arranged marriages. So T'Pring and Spock could have known each other at ages 7 [the photo on the view screen in TOS] 14, 21, 28 etc. Don't forget in Enterprise, T'Pol was 66 in one season but looked like a human's 20 or 30 something. We knew Sarek's age in "Journey to Babel" and in TNG. While 250 human years is standard, its been mentioned in the past that certain Vulcanoids have lived to 330 human years, much of that attributed to the cold blood metabolism, this includes the Rihannsu, and the Mintakans, and other copper based blood offshoots too. Possibly also the "Preservers" who pretty much are a 'mystery' species.
@mauradlayouni3080
2 жыл бұрын
? "delta scorpii seven"?
@816taylor
2 жыл бұрын
For those who don't know, Ethan Peck is the grandson of the Academy Award winner Gregory Peck.
@williamandrews1683
2 жыл бұрын
I really like his other work like He'll on wheels.
@GPsarakis
2 жыл бұрын
A solid start IMO, and I get the issue with T'Pring probably breaking TOS canon but it's not like Trek throughout the years since TOS hasn't had it's share of little retcons here and there. Pretty sure Voyager had a chunk of them. Anyways, having her on the show should be interesting going forward and probably adds to going from this younger version of Spock to the version we see by TOS. I think many fans forget he was totally different in the cage.
@belovedkingdom
2 жыл бұрын
I don't think the scenes with T'Pring break canon. They could be betrothed from youth but Vulcan rituals still require the woman to initiate nuptials with proposal. For those suggesting Spock should have been paired with another female, that WOULD break canon since he's betrothed to T'Pring. The premiere sets the stage for her to reject him later since his career comes first and she does not wish to become the "consort of a legend."
@stephennewton2777
2 жыл бұрын
As someone who grew up with TOS, I was quite apprehensive about how SNW would be played. Based on this first episode I needn’t have worried, in fact I found watching it quite emotional as they appear to have recaptured the spirit of TOS. I really don’t care about what colour April is, nor Kyle either. Sets had to be updated from the original or would just look archaic by today’s standards, as would 1960’s fashion and hairstyles, so no issues with any of that either. These people, on either side of the cameras, are going to tell us stories and I’m hoping the scripts match the quality of the actors and production staff showcased in this episode. Early days obviously, but I think Gene would be proud.
@rhocat362
2 жыл бұрын
I was going to write a lengthy review, then read yours so didn't have 2.
@jaeepworth7556
2 жыл бұрын
Good review if a bit nitpicky. I think you missed on the warp bomb, and I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt on T'Pring because I enjoyed the interactions of the characters so much. The Chief Kyle thing doesn't bother me at all, and it is hard to reconcile your criticisms with your view on the casting of April. Overall I really enjoyed the episode and am greatly encouraged for the show.
@treklad
2 жыл бұрын
Thanks for watching! I think I made the distinction between Kyle and April clear. One has been featured in multiple Trek productions, while the other has not. In any case I'm looking forward to seeing what they can achieve this season. Optimism!
@LoneBrowncoat
2 жыл бұрын
@@treklad ...... at least Robert April was on a list of names for the Captain in the first "The Making of Star Trek" paperback by Whitfield and Roddenberry 1970-71 and in the original draft script, excerpts of which are in said paperback. Some used copies still obtainable via Amazon.
@CarltonYoung
2 жыл бұрын
I’m impressed by the premiere episode so much I’ve seen it at least three times by now. I have never done that before. 😊 minor canon issues but so what. It’s the spirit of Star Trek that is most important, and what’s been lost for the past decade of Trek.
@stephennewton2777
2 жыл бұрын
Nailed it!
@barkasz6066
2 жыл бұрын
Ah yes, Chief Kyle, my spirit animal and favourite character from TOS. Oh wait nope, I didn't even realize he was a recurring character, even though I literally rewatched all of TOS last year. This is squarely the "don't care" type of thing. Great episode.
@danjsilve
2 жыл бұрын
As a fan of TOS from the '60s, I would give this a 7-7.5 out of 10. A solid strong opener. I did actually give a short round of applause at the end. Talking of Cannon. Uhura was not on the Enterprise in " Where No Man's Gone before" so Kirk was onboard before Uhura unless I am missing something. What is going on with the uniforms, they lack uniformity. Still, this is a huge improvement over Disc and Picard, and this is the Star Trek I recognise. Bring on "Children of the Comet"
@HepCatJack
2 жыл бұрын
Enterprise was re-crewed to deal with an emergency.. Uhura's assignment under Pike may have been temporary, her talents may be needed on another ship at a later time to conform with the original timeline.
@danjsilve
2 жыл бұрын
@@HepCatJack Yeah very plausible. I think it was the Corbinite Maneuver that saw her wearing Yellow. I have very mixed feelings about another actress playing Uhura, as she was the first woman I fell in love with when I was 5, back in 1969 when it first appeared on British TV. I attended my first Star Trek convention in 2018 in Birmingham. I paid for the photo shoots of William Shatner, Walter Koenig and Nichelle Nicholls. Sadly Nichelle fell ill during that conevntion. So I never got to meet her.
@Vyan00
2 жыл бұрын
I'm glad mostly because this show will make the Episodic/Canon whiners shut the frack up for a while. At last, they've got a version of their narrow-minded idea of what Trek is supposed to be - ignoring both DS9 and Enterprise who both had serialized seasons.
@steveday6671
2 жыл бұрын
the Enterprise serialized season was also pretty unpopular tho. hence why they reverted to episodic.
@princeeverlove
2 жыл бұрын
Be Thankful..this, for now, is as Good as we have seen in decades!!!
@AndyCutright
2 жыл бұрын
I love Pike's decision to make themselves known to the new species. The Prime Directive is such a mess. It's simplistic to the point of uselessness.
@benjaminbierley2074
2 жыл бұрын
This, it's a good baseline for sure, but in this case Pike's response to the grey area they found themselves in I felt was valid. The prime directive went out the window the moment they "lit up the sky" and this race saw it and ran with the telemetry they gleaned from it. Enterprise's episode that introduces a moral dilemma that would have been prevented by the prime directive showed why it's needed, but once you've crossed into the grey area the directive doesn't cover you can't abdicate responsability as some think the directive would demand.
@AndyCutright
2 жыл бұрын
@@benjaminbierley2074 Pike has created a situation for the the Federation top brass. The Disco battle is supposed to be top secret, and now he's invited absolutely billions of new beings to join the Federation who witnessed it and reverse-engineered a warp core from the data they gathered. That's not gonna escape the attention of the rest of the federation.
@stephennewton2777
2 жыл бұрын
Always had a problem with the Prime Directive being applied regardless of the situation or outcome. Allowing a planet (for example) to be destroyed and a civilization wiped out by an asteroid because they haven’t achieved an arbitrary level of technology is barbaric. I was soooo pleased when Pike gave GO #1 the finger.
@michaelpapp5518
2 жыл бұрын
I feel like a warp bomb is more like a matter-antimatter explosion. That was my inference, anyway.
@GPsarakis
2 жыл бұрын
That's exactly what it is, so you can't call it a nuke which is actually pretty different. Yeah they both go boom but a nuke can take out a city and the same yield "warp bomb" would be way more powerful.
@whocaresreallly5886
2 жыл бұрын
Indeed it is a matter/antimatter bomb not a warp bomb
@LoneBrowncoat
2 жыл бұрын
@@GPsarakis ......Also could have a gravity component, since a starship needs that to bend time and space. AKA the slingshot effect near massive objects- black holes/G-class stars.
@dataweaver
2 жыл бұрын
I took the “warp bomb” reference as the creation of an unstable warp field. It doesn't necessarily have anything to do with matter/antimatter reactions, any more than the Phoenix was powered by a matter/antimatter reaction.
@LoneBrowncoat
2 жыл бұрын
@@dataweaver ....standing next to a warp field is supposed to fry your guts, hence the pylons. Doesn't explain how the Cardies figured it out, nor the First Federation, who have been abnormally quiet for a milenia .
@teresaravenshaw5477
2 жыл бұрын
Best first episode in Star Trek history. All of it.
@thomashill6347
2 жыл бұрын
Thanks for sharing your thoughts TREKLAD till next week MAY GOOD HEALTH BE YOUR COMPANION
@stainlesssteelfox1
Ай бұрын
I'd say a warp bomb probably uses a warp field in some manner to generate an explosion. Phoenix used a fusion reactor, so I could see them pumping a static warp field up to an energy level that can support warp 1 plus speeds, then accelerating a mass using it, or somehow destructively collapsing the warp field itself, releasing all the energy at once. As for retcons, the Star Trek universe has a flexible relationship with time in-universe. If you can time travels imply by slingshotting around a sun in the space equivalent of a beat up patrol boat, it's entirely possible that small changes in the timeline happen spontaneously, a genuine Mandela effect. The Guardian of Forever is supposedly there to impose some order on things. Or it could be some remnant effect from the temporal cold war, where time had mostly snapped back to it's original shape, but not perfectly, like an overstrecthed piece of elastic..
@Ewok751
2 жыл бұрын
No one is going to call out the SILENT RUNNING reference?
@LoneBrowncoat
2 жыл бұрын
I have several copies of the movie, ½ inch tape, Laserdisc and DVD, but please, jog my memory, obviously I didn't catch it. I'll re-watch Episode One tonight to see if I can spot it.
@ricitizen
2 жыл бұрын
@@LoneBrowncoat I just saw this post and the answer just popped in my head. In Silent Running plant life is becoming extinct. To preserve them, scientist sent greenhouses of forest into space. I think the reference Erik is referring to it the space station that was build around the forest domes put into space.
@LoneBrowncoat
2 жыл бұрын
@@ricitizen .....Yep, re-played SR and SNW E1 episode 1 back to back, listening to the dialogue in both, their explanations were almost identical.
@davidcrummer3775
2 жыл бұрын
I have been a Trek fan since the first series aired. While I enjoyed the "Enterprise" release , this edition blew me away. I think that this may be the best Trek to date. The scripts , and casting are great. I think Anson Mount may be my favorite Captain ever.
@MatthewCaunsfield
2 жыл бұрын
Not a bad first episode. A few "what?" moments like T'Pring and the absurd precision of the transporter, but that's modern Trek I suppose. Definitely keen to see more!
@DaleWinarski
2 жыл бұрын
my personal "what" moment was... how the fuck did they actually make this? wow.
@carlnelsen
2 жыл бұрын
As I watched it I too was tracking the discrepancy's of cannon. But other than those few alterations, this was the truest Star Trek in a long time. It felt like Star Trek. Not Woke Trek.
@recoverinyankee6458
2 жыл бұрын
Following established TOS canon must not be a priority. No federation member had ever seen a Gorn, nor interacted with a Gorn before Captain Kirk. Such was stated in the "Arena" episode.
@thomashill6347
2 жыл бұрын
Loved seeing the Enterprise in the sky
@ebonic211187
2 жыл бұрын
I give it 4 stars. There were some questionable parts, like not going immediately to red alert 🚨 after being hit by plasma torpedos but I’m very happy we are getting back to Star Trek the way it was. This was definitely more like the Trek I enjoy. Improved writing. Not STD or STP. I can’t even watch those. Their terrible. This I can watch. Anson Mount is great as captain Pike.
@rohenthar8449
2 жыл бұрын
I agree with all, except STP SII. Its good, compared to SI which was abomination indeed.
@ebonic211187
2 жыл бұрын
@@rohenthar8449 that’s good to know. I stopped watching near the end of season 1. Just couldn’t continue torturing myself like that! 🤦🏽♂️
@michaelwallace2487
2 жыл бұрын
I'll have to rewatch Amok Time, but I don't think Spock ever said that they had not seen each other since children, only that their marriage was arranged as children. I'll check this episode and see. I haven't seen it in a while.
@whocaresreallly5886
2 жыл бұрын
he said their marriage was arranged when they were 7
@iliumboy
2 жыл бұрын
Every episode, so far, retcons something. In this episode: 1. Spock with emotions 2. Cadets serving on the bridge 3. Beaming medicine into bodies 4. Gorn reference (unknown species in TOS)
@juliusarchibaldiv3880
19 күн бұрын
I am so far enjoying Strange New Worlds and look forward to the next episode like Lower Decks - which I thought I wouldn't like but was hooked. I just hope they don't have a D&D episode or any more musical episodes. But from this episode and perhaps all of "New Trek" including the movies, my top moment is "I've seen my future," moment. In the last 15 years it is the most Trekian of Trek I have seen since the End of DS9 (lost interest in Voyager when the Borg came and didn't have a TV station that ran Enterprise . It explores a potential dark future for the Kileyians while also giving them a potential future without pain and suffering.
@BigNoseDog
2 жыл бұрын
To the folks who created Enterprise, this is how you do a prequel series. SNW successfully captures the spirit of TOS. Yes, they broke some of the continuity and probably annoyed certain folks with casting of non-white actors. But I can look past that because this series does something that neither Discovery nor Picard could do, which is make me actually excited to watch Star Trek again. Also, the producers struck gold with Anson Mount. Not since Patrick Stewart has a Star Trek series gotten the casting so right. I never cared for Avery Brooks, Kate Mulgrew, or Scott Bakula. Discovery found the right actress to play the captain then killed her off. Mount doesn’t remind me of the Pike we saw in The Cage. But he’s so much more likeable and holds your attention in a way that Brooks and Mulgrew never could.
@sociologica4247
4 ай бұрын
Great recap! thanks!!
@amonimac
2 жыл бұрын
I loved it! Just cant wait to see Klingons again and angry fans reactions 😆
@AndyCutright
2 жыл бұрын
All the Klingons look like Peeps now. Yellow, fluffy, sticky, easily packed into an Xmas present box. It's canon.
@starbrand3726
2 жыл бұрын
I'm not sure why they tried to force original series connections instead of just being unique. I still view these new Treks (Discovery, Picard, And Strange) as taking place in an alternate universe. (Yes I know Paramount claims it is the same universe.) But, when they are at warp it looks like Star Wars' hyperspace and not the Next Gen, DS9, or Voyager warp, so how could it be the same universe? It is possible for a civilization to create warp just from a few telescopic readings. Remember, they could have taken sensor readings and not just viewed images. But, regardless, the viewing could have given a genius scientist on their world a new idea. This could have caused the scientist to think or experiment in a new and different direction.
@darththor3982
2 жыл бұрын
good episode and a great start. The one thing I hope is that the character arcs are season long while having an episodic show. that was what always bothered me about early trek,.
@lexxstrum
2 жыл бұрын
Very good episode; I also rewatched it the other night. I think they should have used a different Vulcan character for Spock's love interest; they could have LED us to believe it was T'Pring, and then fake us out with her being someone else (or maybe a Romulan Spy?) I loved Pike's speech to the Kylians, but them moving the Eugenics Wars out of the 20th and into the 21st century grates on me; they could have made up something to go along with the other made up wars they threw in, like "the Resource Wars".
@dsh5564
2 жыл бұрын
I watched it twice I really liked it
@RD9_Designs
26 күн бұрын
Hi, just wanted to point out the correct pronunciation of Mbenga. It's not EMbenga, it's MAbenga. Hope that helps! Great video!
@thomashill6347
2 жыл бұрын
I like the introduction of Sam Kirk ANOTHER character that has a set time of death. Plus it give us more of how her ends up on Deneva colony
@davidcheater4239
2 жыл бұрын
I liked the show. My favourite Star Trek was the original series. This has the same feeling of being daring. My nitpicks about your nitpicks. 1/ Warp bomb. Warp technology is powered by a controlled reaction between matter and anti-matter. It's a lot more powerful than atomic weapons. I completely agree that I don't think this could be figured out through telescopes. 2/ Michael Burnham existing threw out Spock's continuity. I don't think this is anywhere near as disruptive to continuity as the introduction of the Xindi and the Temporal Cold War.
@AndyCutright
2 жыл бұрын
The nuclear missile wasn't armed. It was a flight ready structure and launch pad that could be rebuilt to serve as a launch vehicle to get the warp core into space where it could then be tested.
@yllennocj
2 жыл бұрын
re T'Pring - my understanding from Amok Time was that they were betrothed and his return to Vulcan was to consumate, complete the marriage - the trial by arms was to effectively break the betrothal so she could be with/marry the man of her choosing; as presented here in SNW, it sets up the story line to her developing dissatisfaction with the relationship in his 'galivanting' and the eventual breakdown of her interest in Spock as partner - her proposal could have been her act to secure him in her life and away from Starfleet - his response and potential future scenes where he dissapoints, frustrates her leading to a final showdown my apologies to any who may have mentioned this before me - I have not read through all the comments
@belovedkingdom
2 жыл бұрын
I don't think the scenes with T'Pring break canon. They could be betrothed from youth but Vulcan rituals still require the woman to initiate nuptials with proposal. For those suggesting Spock should have been paired with another female, that WOULD break canon since he's betrothed to T'Pring. The premiere sets the stage for her to reject him later since his career comes first and she does not wish to become the "consort of a legend."
@AndyCutright
2 жыл бұрын
Spock didn't 'marry' T'Pring, and he didn't want to. Unless you're suggesting Spock and T'Pring are going to drift apart somehow later down the road, this breaks canon. Though honestly who cares if it does.
@belovedkingdom
2 жыл бұрын
@@AndyCutrightThe marriage has not been consummated. Canon is not broken. They will part ways later per TOS.
@darrylmars
2 жыл бұрын
nice review. Discovery & Picard also had good premieres before the slide into garbage. "Rickety sets from the 60's" ? You have no idea. When I sat in Kirks chair on the original series I thought it wd break bc it was all so cheap. Live long, etc....
@NuclearFridge1
2 жыл бұрын
"Assigned to be married from birth..." Yeah. Not really. They were age 7 when that happened. The 7-year cycle being a thing for Vulcans.
@tomjares7559
2 жыл бұрын
Fine start to the show. Perfect? No, but few episodes are. Agree with most of your observations and looking forward to episode 2.
@nybsfp7486
2 жыл бұрын
T’Pring had the best leg to ass transition in ST history. Damn. As for the canon…just because she said “marry me” doesn’t mean they weren’t already engaged from birth. It can easily be brushed off as a reaffirmation born out of desire this time rather than requirement The stuff at the end…really pissed me off…at first. Then I put myself in the shoes of the aliens who would have only been seeing that as presented with no knowledge of the agendas we know they were attempting to push and I laughed my ass off. What they presented was a legit and fair warning against the current fascist ruling party.
@PeoplecallmeLucifer
2 жыл бұрын
7:20 reverse engineering isn't that out of place IMO. sometimes just the idea of the thing is enough because no one was in the head space of thinking about things in that way beforehand. Look at the printing press. not long after Gutenberg printed his bible there was a print in the works in Croatia. No one tough of making books Gutenberg style before, but once he'd done it the flood gates opened
@zaprese
2 жыл бұрын
A Star-fleet Captain that needs to be ordered to rescue his own Commander?
@dannyjones1639
2 жыл бұрын
How Vout That VULCAN FOREPLAY ??? Lol
@bneil4059
2 жыл бұрын
Embenga is cool, I wish I could hear him better.
@paweplaczek2191
2 жыл бұрын
Well humanity did made quite few advances by observing stellar events especialy in math and physics. Space battle would be no different.
@thomashill6347
2 жыл бұрын
Good morning TREKLAD, I did enjoy this episode very much. I am surprised that Nurse Chapel is a civilian BUT she has COMMANDER RANK on the cuffs. I liked the scene with chase through the ship, BUT if you bring aliens on board WHERE is the security officer posted at the exits. I would have like to see a younger legacy security officer that is knocked over then the chase.
@jerryjohnson575
2 жыл бұрын
LOVE IT
@rohenthar8449
2 жыл бұрын
Im content. It has a holes true, but still... THIS IS Star Trek.
@ericcohen2108
2 жыл бұрын
I loved it
@rlkinnard
2 жыл бұрын
4.5 stars out of 5, better than any star trek show at the inception including my previous favorite TNG. i liked it much more than you did.
@daveherres3374
2 жыл бұрын
I've been watching since the beginning of TOS. I'd rather have a good story than worry over cannon. They're great characters and I'm fascinated to see how a new generation will interpret them. The old shows aren't going anywhere.
@williamkey4165
2 жыл бұрын
Apparently, they have forgot how to use light, dark it is. Way too dark.
@poseidon5003
2 жыл бұрын
You worry about T'pring but ignore that the planet shot plasma torpedoes and NOT missiles. Dude!
@aleta5873
2 жыл бұрын
Loved it..
@misternobody3481
2 жыл бұрын
It was okay. The canon retcons were annoying. I disagree about Peck. His delivery and the scream with the disguise wearing off were not good. A lot of that can be blamed on the writing, though. Thank you for pointing out the silliness of an alien race creating a matter/antimatter reactor by looking through a telescope when those are INSIDE THE SHIPS. I have issues with a few things, but it seems like a decent attempt to capture classic TOS feel without completely overwhelming us with modern representation messaging. Mostly it felt like a halfway decent fan fiction. I hope it gets better. 2.5/5 stars.
@MsMarlena55
9 ай бұрын
The race of the admiral and of Chief Kyle is not offputtng however in both cases the ages Chief Kyle seems too young and baby faced to be a chief and as you say the admiral seems too young I am not disturbed by having Spock and to bring know each other as adults but later in season 2 it is disturbing that they have to have a engagement dinner similar to Americans two parallel
@thundergodcid960
2 жыл бұрын
TOS canon was thrown out in the first 10 minutes of Discovery season one, and as much as the showrunners like to claim that this is the Prime timeline, it’s definitely an alternate universe. Going in from that perspective, I.e. as an alternate retelling, it’s easily a 9/10 for me. This is the first real Trek I’ve seen since Enterprise ended in 2005. But going in as a nitpicking canon nazi, that naively believes that this is still somehow inline with TOS it’s a 6/10, which is still higher than what I’d give STD or Picard.
@mr.gamenervy7357
2 жыл бұрын
Yep, this is more like Star Trek, I have few complaints. I really enjoyed it! The whole timeline is a bit unknown and a bit of a mess, due to so many things happening in other movies and spin-offs, so we really don't know where we are now, and therefore they can get away with changing pretty much anything they like, but Uhura being there makes no sense to me at all. The new security chief reminds me very much of the security chief on the Orville. Interested to find out more on her back story, as she's a Noonien-Singh. Looking past all the timeline cock-ups, it's proper Trek, it's fun and I loved it!
@LoneBrowncoat
2 жыл бұрын
Singh is a common Sikh surname, but I don't know the origins of Noonien as it's not that common and may be the result of two family lineages merging sometime in the past. However, Khan is simply Hindu, and maybe Mongolian for "Prince", their given names could be quite different and varied.
@bioshock6935
2 жыл бұрын
This is what i don't like about this new show it always ret con the original and changing the actors character's to who they are also from the original. But so far it looks very good along with better acting and feels like star trek so i can let these changes slide as long as going by the first episode its only going to get better because this is the type of trek show i wanted and this is star trek
@thomashill6347
2 жыл бұрын
I would give it a 5/5 Just because it got more right then wrong, THAT being said I agree that our world NOW would say it is not far if they cast a white man to play Transport operator Kyle. As for Robert April I agree not see in any more then one scene in animation NO BIG DEAL. NOW just saying if Dr. M'Benga was cast white that would make most fans mad YET he was only in two episode and Kyle was in many more.
@gerhardrobertbieber4129
2 жыл бұрын
What the Name of the alien race ?
@thomashill6347
2 жыл бұрын
As for how they created the bomb SOME FANS that have a lot more knowledge them me say that telescopes are NOT just seeing but can give many things then sight. WHO KNOW
@Ramonesaehs
Жыл бұрын
I didn't like the set. Especially the bridge.
@whocaresreallly5886
2 жыл бұрын
Zephram Cockram's warp engine was built into a nuclear missile using a matter/antimater power source not nuclear
@HepCatJack
2 жыл бұрын
Which is why it was called a former nuclear missile, without the nuclear warhead it's no longer a nuclear missile.
@sitoudien9816
2 жыл бұрын
It was familiar and didn't break any new ground. They played it safe. Don't get your hopes up. Bait and switch!
@zaprese
2 жыл бұрын
The inclusion of Sam Kirk isn’t as clunky as the inclusion of Noonian Khan!!!!
@tyronealfonso
2 жыл бұрын
I know this is a knitpick, but the most annoying thing about the show is how dark the enterprise looks. It should stand out MUCH more. But hey, at least the show seems watchable.
@steveday6671
2 жыл бұрын
yes i thought that too. looked like something that had been stripped down prior to respraying.
@nel1962
2 жыл бұрын
I think it’s the metallic finish that makes it look dark. Maybe somewhere along the line it will get the brighter federation paint job we are used to.
@jefferywilson456
2 жыл бұрын
I hate to disagree but this is Star Trek 25%. There are three timelines or universes here. There is trek Canaan which is our Star Trek… Trek prime… which is the star trek 25% different Star Trek universe… and the Trek Kelvin timeline which is spun off from prime 25% different trek. This is obviously part of the JJ verse. Look at the sets on the bridge which is strongly from the timeline of Star Trek 2009. This is how I’m able to tolerate a kurtzmen trek. And to be honest I enjoy the Kurtzman trek because it doesn’t screw up my trek cannon. So please be my guest to change as many characters and as many ships as you want! Now that it has been explained to me that my beloved trek cannon sitting off to the side in a little bubble… not being damaged by Kurtzman… I am fine with all of this! For example who cares if Samuel George Kirk is a Science officer on board the good ship enterprise even though he was never in Starfleet ! It’s Kurtzman trek! So let them make as many changes as they want to! 😂 so I say ..boldly go where no Kurtzman trek has gone before! 😂😂😂
@treklad
2 жыл бұрын
The whole 25% doesn't make sense, not now CBS and Paramount have remerged and no license is required.
@jefferywilson456
2 жыл бұрын
@@treklad maybe this will explain everything. kzitem.info/news/bejne/rG5onpWJpJqDe6A&feature=share
@jacknakamori3280
Ай бұрын
Quite hateful that during his 'speech', the challenge to suspected voter fraud was cast as a problem leading to war, and that during the apparent nuking, top of his list of victims were animal species. Perhaps this series should have been called Woke Trek. Needless to say, despite it attracting my attention for a moment, I won't be watching any more.
@MrAeronca100
2 жыл бұрын
In full Woke PC mode...nothing but garbage
@trhansen3244
2 жыл бұрын
What a wasted opportunity. I am even more disappointed in this new series than either Discovery or Picard.
@treklad
2 жыл бұрын
Why?
@whocaresreallly5886
2 жыл бұрын
I enjoyed it for the most part but i do have my issues First they try hard to make Pike a pseudo Kirk the entire begining was too much like Kirk in the nexus second the admiral shouldn't press someone who should be under psychiatric care back into command because it is too risky what if he freezes up at an important time that is why compromised officers can be relieved by the CMO third the Vulcans are too emotional (I'm looking past that they are too redish) and the giant glass room on a very hot planet? Four how did Spock make it back to Earth from Vulcan that quick? And yeah five the beaming from the shuttle was a big dislike if he can't handle a conversation he shouldn't be in command six the Enterprise has an AI after the stuff in disco season 2 seven the Archer has a 3 person crew for a first contact mission eeither that ship is too big or crew too small even if it is supposed to be classified eight warp bomb they call it a warp bomb not an antimatter bomb a warp bomb nine yeah there telecopes not only allowed them to see but analyse break down how to make antimatter and how would that info have arrived at a planet a lightyear away in less than a year ten the advanced genetic manulipation and not haveing to go to the ship stores to find appropriate clothing there are no replicators at this time eleven Spock shouldnt have been able to go on the mission the fact that his transformation was going to be short introduces unnecessary risk as is shown twelve Pike didn't immediately transform Spock didnt immediately transform but the first officer did thirteen the security chief shouldn't suggest introducing a security risk into the mission unless she planned on not returning the people and how is so much known about their genetics without having a sample at the very least the abducted people should have been reatrained fourteen they rushed in and almost crated a worse situation the second they though Spocks treatment would wear off they should have pulled him fifteen why would a species at war not be guarding the aliens questioning them and trying to find out more sisteen Spocks yell seventeen there are better things to have shown the council the bell riots the euginics war what they showed was targeted at Americans and not in allegory like Star Trek eighteen one speach and they get rid of a century of hate and fighting and distrust they are better then us nineteen if not imprisioned he should have atlest been stripped of his command "loophole" or not this Pike is not fit for command
@LoneBrowncoat
2 жыл бұрын
Where's your punctuation? Or are you one of the few that managed to flunk English?
@whocaresreallly5886
2 жыл бұрын
@@LoneBrowncoat I enjoyed it for the most part, but I do have my issues. First: They try hard to make Pike a Pseudo-Kirk. The entire beginning was very much like Kirk in the Nexus from Generations. Second: The admiral shouldn't press someone who should be under psychiatric care back into command because it is too risky. What if he freezes up at an important time? That is why compromised officers can be relieved by the CMO. Third: The Vulcans are too emotional (I'm looking past that they are too reddish) and the giant glass room on a very hot planet? Four: How did Spock make it back to Earth from Vulcan that quick? Five: The beaming from the shuttle was a big dislike. If he can't handle a conversation, he shouldn't be in command. Six: The Enterprise has an AI after the stuff in Disco season 2? Seven: The Archer has a 3-person crew for a first contact mission? Either that ship is too big or crew too small, even if it is supposed to be classified. Eight: Warp bomb. They call it a warp bomb, not an antimatter bomb, a warp bomb. Nine: Their telescopes not only allowed them to see, but analyze and break down how to make antimatter? How would that info arrive at a planet a light-year away in less than a year? Ten: The advanced genetic manipulation and not having to go to the ship stores to find appropriate clothing, there are no replicators at this time. Eleven: Spock shouldn't have been able to go on the mission. The fact that his transformation was going to be short introduced unnecessary risk, as is shown. Twelve: Pike didn't immediately transform, Spock didn't immediately transform, but the first officer did. Thirteen: The security chief shouldn't suggest introducing a security risk into the mission unless she planned on not returning the people and how is so much known about their genetics without having a sample at the very least the abducted people should have been restrained. Fourteen: They rushed in and almost created a worse situation the second they though Spock's treatment would wear off they should have pulled him. Fifteen: Why would a species at war not be guarding the aliens, questioning them and trying to find out more about them? Sixteen: Spock's yell. Seventeen: There are better things to have shown the council, The Bell Riots, The Eugenics War. What they showed was targeted at Americans and not in allegory like Star Trek. Eighteen: One speech and they get rid of a century of hate and fighting and distrust. They are better than we are. Nineteen: If not imprisoned, he should have at least been stripped of his command "loophole" or not. Pike is not fit for command.
@whocaresreallly5886
2 жыл бұрын
@@LoneBrowncoat Here is the corrected puncuation. Where are your refutations?
@LoneBrowncoat
2 жыл бұрын
For one, in "The Cage" Pike was compelled into an illusion that he was on a picnic outside of the city called Mojave, with Vina, named after the once desert that was there and reclaimed after WWIII. There, as in the draft script {source: The Making of Star Trek..Whitfield & Roddenberry 1970-71} Pike was an avid horseman, his favourite was a stallion named 'Tango' {Plus like DeForrest Kelly, Jeffery Hunter was in a plethora of Westerns, Hunter even played Jesus once.}. Like Kirk and the RL Shatner (with his dobermans). Where Kurtzman ever got Montana, I don't know, none of my old books has this. Probably from the Okudas, who have everything WRONG in their books, just like Shane Johnson has all his dates about 60-63 years out of kilter. Yet so many take those writings {Okudas & Johnson} seriously because they simply do not know any better.
@whocaresreallly5886
2 жыл бұрын
@@LoneBrowncoat If it was just the horse i wouldn't have an issue it was the entire scene. A captain of the Enterprise makes breakfast for a lady friend, after suffering a trauma. In a wooded area of the upper North American continent. There is a horse ride. And another captain of the Enterprise asks for help. Which am i talking about?
Пікірлер: 128