Part of me is excited to see the Harry Potter show, especially since I missed out the release schedule wait the books and movies had. Especially if they use the fourth season is the do over and adaption Goblet of Fire deserves. But at the same time, if there is going to be a wizarding world tv series, I would rather have something new or at least something that could open the doors for more stories. I would rather have this new series be an adaption of Hogwarts Mystery, it has a good storyline, it is a prequel (it takes place during the 7 years before Harry, Ron and Hermione went to Hogwarts) and it has a lot of potential on expanding the story and it's characters. These characters should have the same spotlight and recognition as all the others, but many are missing out and Warner Bros are missing out on a chance to make a good show based on this game. Plus it's obvious video game movies are working out and succeeding, look at the Sonic movies, The Super Mario Bros, Friday night at Freddie's and the Last of us for example, they were all based on video games and they were hits in the box office. Why not make Hogwarts Mystery into a tv series?
@sppotterstark8057
Күн бұрын
This show has a higher chance of succeeding then the PercyJackson show which dropped out of nielsens charts barely a month after its first season concluded, never to pop up again in nielsens list. Harrypotter sold 500 million copies by 2018 and still managed to sell 100 million copies throughout covid up to 2022 for a final total of 600 million copies sold worldwide. Combined with the lowest grossing wizard world film making more money then the lowest glossing starwars, mcu and DC films plus High game sales of nearly a billion earned in revenue and a steady park business . Not to mention of the 11 installments, 10 of the films have decent to excellent critical reviews/praise. But yes despite evidence to the contrary, the show will fail because a bunch of Hates, fake fans, disloyal ex fans, conditional fans and DEI snowflakes say it will fail. Haters just want it to fail to justify their social political position and victory over central and right wing politics. Its sickening such people exist in both the wizardingworld harry potter fandom and other fandoms. Almost as sick has having genuine racists apart of a fandom.
@dragus9real
3 күн бұрын
you want it to fail, dont you? XD
@johnord684
4 күн бұрын
I support JK, wokies suck ,it will be a success as this is not Disney Star Wars which sucks. This will be accurate as the producers and directors are announced.
@mechajay3358
4 күн бұрын
I could care less about the Rowling Controversy, I wanna hope this TV series is actually good.
@nicolesudjono
5 күн бұрын
I can't imagine the idea of replacing the great Alan Rickman, Richard Harris, Michael Gambon and everyone else who put their heart and soul in the movies :(
@asruluveira
2 күн бұрын
Meh. I cant imagine somebody replacing Christopher reeves esp after what happen to him. Then harry Cavill happened. Now I can't imagine who can replace him.. It won't be long that we gonna forget the old harry esp those actor is struggling to get a big budget Hollywood movie. When they do HBO reunion. I hope jk won't invite them. She owns potter so i hope they scrap the Internet of old potter and flood them with new ones
@bradleybrown8428
6 күн бұрын
Who are, "the fans?" I'm all for this and I know tonnes of others are too.
@alexhaynes7220
6 күн бұрын
You should be ashamed and no it will not die r you ok
@alexhaynes7220
6 күн бұрын
You all r not Harry Potter fans at all hating on Harry Potter and JK
@alexhaynes7220
6 күн бұрын
Well you r not a Harry Potter fan then
@alexhaynes7220
6 күн бұрын
She is not transphobia at all
@blake343
7 күн бұрын
always wanted a tv shw but i know what they will do to it now with the political activists in charge so pls pls leave it alone
@PaulieLauraXombie1331
7 күн бұрын
The world is so vast wizarding goes back thousands of years there's 11 confirmed wizarding schools they legitimately could have done ANYTHING else but went with a reboot... I would have loved to seen the other schools perspectives on that timeline because every wizard feared Voldemort worldwide.. What did they have planned? Did they know of HP and his connection to Voldemort? Also I'm transgender MtF and I'm still going to love Harry Potter no matter what. I won't let the artists idealisms ruin something that brought me pure joy as a kid, A character I could relate with who felt exactly the same.. Abused/neglected.. Harry Potter means a lot to me.. I turned 11 on Halloween (no lie 10/31) so a bit before the character of Harry Potter in story.. So I legitimately grew up with Harry Potter.
@Kermit46
9 күн бұрын
Real fans stand with jk
@saltymanga6841
9 күн бұрын
I for one think it will be cool, introduce the story to a whole new generation
@henribg1
14 күн бұрын
ha ha ha ha ha
@luneluna307
16 күн бұрын
The show will be a hit even if it’s worse than the movies because the fandom is still alive and it’s not the same like with the LotR show , I’m only 20 and HP is something everyone in my generation knows about, so money won’t be an issue there’ll always be a huge audience
@stephenblack5425
16 күн бұрын
When the DCEU was not working, WB just didn't know what to do and then they just cancelled that universe. The HP tv reboot maybe going on the same path especially with all of the controversies and compitition with the HP movie series.
@gandalfwiz20007
17 күн бұрын
In 2024, everyone is to be Black, Gay and offended by anything. Poison of modern society
@ramonbetzler7786
21 күн бұрын
My solution to this is making it animated
@GlimisGagetry
25 күн бұрын
I think a more accurate to the books reboot with more screen time and more magic will be awesome I had this idea before I heard it was coming true!
@PreacHDefiant
25 күн бұрын
I personally think you missed the boat on this one. You’re letting your personal opinions about an authors outlook on life and politics drive you and it’s pretty pathetic. You don’t have to agree with her at all, but the online people whining are a very loud MINORITY
@maximusdraco2199
26 күн бұрын
I am so happy that I found your channel 🎉
@eglantinepapeau1582
26 күн бұрын
-Rings of power tanked because the writing was mediocre ,and there was no respect for Tolkien in the adaptation . the audience was there ,ready watch the show, they were simply not fooled once they saw the trailer and read interviews. Tolkien is a beloved author whose work will stay beloved and popular through time. same goes for JK , despite the personal beef she developed with a small group of people. -Your personal views of JK Rowlings are not shared by the majority of moviegoers nor the majority of the people worldwide for that matter, it's actually the complete opposite , people side with Rowling on that matter so suggesting that a controversy only shared by a minority of people and a biased media loudening their voices could tank an HP show is a blatantly biased and misguided statement . the only thing that could make it tank is bad writing like rings of power. -You say that despite the supposed global hatred towards JK , Hogwarts Legacy made a fortune in sells , but , in a complete 180 you then say that gen Z could make the HP show tank ? where's the logic in that ? if they weren't responsible for the success of hogwarts legacy then why would their boycott of the show affect its sales ? -I also am not interested in a HP tv show and the reason for that is the same reason most people have : fear of bad writing, bad adaptation , bad acting . That's the realistic reason , not some personal beef a minority of people have with JK Rowling ...
@PotiusSeroQamNumquam
27 күн бұрын
Damn, why can't they simply let it diiiiiie. (Yes, money, I know)
@babbisp1
28 күн бұрын
This series needs an animated show. With every book being as long as it is, it would require several hours of material, but kids age too quickly for that to happen. That's why it needs to be animated. Every book can be a season, the first one being the smallest of course. It being animated would also separate it more from the movies.
@bex2280
29 күн бұрын
Snape Snape Severus Snape Dumbledoreeee
@bex2280
29 күн бұрын
How are they going top the music alone??
@bayarat6106
Ай бұрын
I believe the timing is great for a new adaptation. Kids who grew up watching Harry Potter movies are now in their thirties. Agemates of Rupert or Emma or Daniel will be 37 by 2026. I think that is such an age when people have preteen kids. For the next coming generation to watch and the series to be kept alive, the timing is perfect.
@paulnaylor1924
Ай бұрын
So wrong.i hope you eat your words when this goes off.if they can take their time to tell the stories as per the books it cant fail .just my opinion
@ChelseaChfy-ex1po
27 күн бұрын
This guy is a woke joke
@dmalexander26
Ай бұрын
It’s wild to me that ppl still hate on her and call her a transphobe. To my understanding, she’s only really ever said that that trans women shouldn’t be allowed to compete in women’s sports. I don’t see how that translates to hatred necessarily. All of that aside, I have to agree with your point of the risk of having a ten year plan on a service that bleeds money. Though Netflix has been in the same boat for years and they’re still at it. As far as the comparison to the rings of power, to my understanding, MAX hasn’t casted an overweight, marginalized lesbian to play the role of Harry Potter. If they start Reece and gender swapping, then the comparison would be valid.
@monikasmithsonian2985
Ай бұрын
Honestly even ignoring everything else I’m gonna find the slavery concerning if I rewatch. Like how would you even save that and adapt it for an audience that cares more about injustice
@bradleybrown8428
6 күн бұрын
You don't? Not everything has to fit our world views, plus, it's stated in the books I believe, that HouseElves need magic to live, so they gather the magic and help the wizarding world. Yes some are treated badly but that happens in every culture.
@dineyashworth8578
Ай бұрын
Love the books but hate the author!
@lukestaff6153
Ай бұрын
I don’t understand why just because Rowling stated a pure fact, is now just hated by millions of people as if she is the embodiment of hitler.
@PotterSwiftie
Ай бұрын
Different route… we take all the characters from the Cursed Child (I’m talking about the parents and the kids only, not Delphi) but it would just follow Albus and Scorpius’ life at Hogwarts. Sounds weird but just hear me out on this.
@HighPriestPlays
Ай бұрын
While I also ernjoyed the show there are changes I don't think work, I think kids need at a few more incidents wher they stumbeld into something with little idea whats happening at first. either thempark or the lotus, and I would prefer the lotus. and, I think they just fucked up with the underworld near entirly. The extra pearl was great, but everthing else just didn't work for me.
@Purplebeamer
Ай бұрын
Another person spewing nonsense about jk being a transphobe. it's tired.
@eduardovalseca6019
Ай бұрын
Harry Potter should not be a tv series because of JK Rowling's political posture? Part 1 is not an argument at all man 😆 good content is good content. The Rings of Power suck not because of their horrendous woke shit! It sucks because it is a total mess in terms of narrative and basic writing.
@ChelseaChfy-ex1po
27 күн бұрын
I mostly agree with you but the woke definitely does turn many off as well.
@lieslemmens7762
Ай бұрын
What about an animated series? Is Cheaper, no alterations of the wizarding theme park needed, no problem with main actors quitting (like the witcher). Why not? Would love to see an animated series of Harry Potter in the style of Arcane.
@DrRexie
Ай бұрын
You're completely wrong about that it's not only about the viewership of rings of power while it was terrible it was a pandering schlock fest that got so many characters wrong and then pulled a garbage twist out of its asshole and you say it's failing but it's getting a season 2 so you're completely incorrect about that as well
@danimmmmm
Ай бұрын
Hot take: a show or movie series about another school, but set in the same time frame as Harry's stay at Hogwarts. JK has written these detailed descriptions and lore about every other school in the official Wizarding World webpage, producers and screenwriters have material to take from. This already sets up strong plot lines close to the source material. Because of its origins tied to Scotland, a good candidate could be the American school, Ilvermorny. Plots could be how they tried to get selected, and failed into participating in the Triwizard Tournament, threats from the American Death Eaters and how Voldemort's rise and then war impacted the US and Ilvermorny itself while having their own antagonist, yada yada... The endless potential of this IP seems to be overlooked by everyone that's either in a business-only mindset, or not that big of a fan. Just look at the mess of the Fantastic Beasts movies.
@CzechMirco
Ай бұрын
So basically all three main reasons are your very superficial and subjective issues that have nothing to do with any objective feasibility of a tv series. But as much as I would like a proper tv series that does the original material justice, I agree that it won't probably happen, partially because it is almost impossible. The main characters are kids and with all the nonsense laws about child labor, with not knowing how the kids will turn out once they hit puberty, etc. and with the filming schedule inevitably getting behind their actual real age, this is very hard task for a seven years of commitment, Also with current "diversity" nonsense and other ephemeral politcial rubbish bleeding into every major tv series, the show won't be an accurate depiction of the source in any case. Not to mention the inevitable fact that recreation of Harry Potter world would be extremely costly, including the huge ensemble cast. What if the production company decides after three years that the earnings aren't good enough and cancels the production? Unlike many TV productions, Harry Potter saga is a very internally cohesive story that needs seven years to be completed and finished.
@synkadus
Ай бұрын
haha, Rowling is fucking based
@benwelch6554
Ай бұрын
I hadn’t read the books since 09 but it was my favorite book series so I was excited to see a new show, watched the show and got so bored I didn’t get past episode 6. I wasn’t sure exactly why I didn’t like it, I thought “oh well I’m in my 20s, maybe younger kids absolutely love this still” so I decided to relisten to the audiobooks while at work and I fell in love all over again, I loved and looked forward to my listening yet when trying to go back to the show it didn’t have the timeless magic from the books at all. I felt too disconnected to the characters and the whole plot took all the fun and passion out of the experiences. Mind you to this day I still watch the clone wars and avatar and do not feel like the fun and passion is taken from it. I still enjoy it despite it caters to a much younger audience
@sandiego2380
Ай бұрын
A tv series would make the movies feel less special.
@ChelseaChfy-ex1po
27 күн бұрын
If you compare them to the books they really aren’t that special and have way too many inaccuracies in them
@EliasTheEstory
Ай бұрын
In my opinion if they really want to add to the Harry Potter franchise they should instead make a show/movie series of The cursed child.
@TheFonzieCommunity
Ай бұрын
In my eyes it’s DOA, there is just too much to make it not work. Best for them to make a decision to talk about the muraders and the first war, then pivot to other parts you didn’t talk about enough. I’d rather rewatch the movies or reread the books
@fatbastard51
Ай бұрын
what are you talking about? Hogwarts legacy success proves that people still want harry potter regardless, all this JK Rowling BS is just garbage.
@rdzu834
Ай бұрын
“Remake” “Reboot” Harry Potter is a book series. Even as someone who’s never read the books and loved the films growing up I still feel like people see Harry Potter as a series of films that have novelisations instead of the other way round. So they can’t disentangle Harry from Daniel. It might actually be good. It might be bad. Either way I’m open to a new *adaptation* of the *book series*. Hogwarts Legacy not only let us see nuanced angles to the different houses, Hogwarts looks even better, even with the same exterior and similar interior as the film version. Again I grew up with those films and I’m always going to love them, but the films and the concept of Harry Potter (which the series, like the films is set on adapting) are *not* one and the same.
@Jing737
Ай бұрын
See, the problem I have with this was that Hogwart's Legacy proved that despite the controversy, the property is still popular. Instead of making another show, they could have made a modern take with new characters at Hogwart's in present day. Why not take the kids in the epilogue of the last book and make them the new protagonists?
Пікірлер